damming the irrawaddy - burmese
TRANSCRIPT
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 1/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 2/90
uGsefawmfwdk h ucsifvlr_zHG h+zdK;a&;uGef,uftzJG haejzifh TtpD&ifcHpm xGufay:vmzdk�
twGuftpjyL;ulnDaxmufyH hay;cJ haom tvl&Sifrsm;jzpf=uaom DCMF ESif h GGF wd k �ud k
txl;aus;Zl;oif&Sdygonf?
xk denf;wl TtpD&ifcHpmtwGuf enf;pepfrsm;jzif h yH hyd k;I taumif;qH k;jzpfatmif 0d kif;0ef;
ulnD=uaom BRC, E-desk ESifh ERI okd hudkvnf; txl;aus;Zl;wifygonf? xdk�twl
TtpD&ifcHpmuk d tprStqH k;wd kif owif;tcsuftvuf aumufcHpkaqmif;jcif;ud k wm0ef
,laqmif&GufcJ haom ucsifobm0ywf0ef;usifqd kif&mtzJ G�ESif h yg0ifulnDay;aom ucsif
ausmif;om;vli,frsm;tzJ G�ESif h enf;pepfrsm;/ t}uHn%fjzif h0d kif;0ef; ulnD=uaom tjcm;obm0ywf0ef;usifqdkif&m tzJG�rsm;tm;vHk;udk vnf;txl;aus;Zl;oif&Sdygonf?
Kachin Development Networking Group
ucsifvlr_zH Gh+zdK;a&;uGef,uftzJ G�
KDNG onf 2004 ckESpfwGif pwifwnfaxmifaom ucsifjynfe,ftwGif;ESif h jynfyEd kifiH
rsm;&S d ucsifjynfe,f zH G�òz;a&;qd kif&mtzJ G�rsm;ESif h vlxktajcjyKvlr_tzJ G�tpnf;. uGef,uf
wpfckjzpfygonf? KDNG . OD;wnfcsufrSm a&&SnfzH G�òz;wd k;wufa&;twGuf ucsifjynfe,f
twGif;&Sda'ocHtzJG�tpnf;rsm;ESifh twlvufwGJ+yD; xda&mufpGm taumiftxnfazmf
aqmif&GufEd kif&efjzpfygonf? tzJ G�tpnf;.&nf&G,fcsufrSm jrefrmEd kifiHwGif vlr_a&;ESif hEd kifiH
a&;wdk;wufajymif;vJ jzpfay:ap&eftwGuf wdkufyJG0ifae=uaom a'ocHjynfolrsm;t
wGuf wef;wlnDr#r_ESifh w&m;r#wr_tay: tajccHonfh vlr_tzJG�tpnf;wpf&yfudk xl
axmifjrif hwifay;&efjzpfonf? ucsifobm0 ywf0ef;usifqd kif&m tzJ G�onf ucsifvlr_zH G�òz;
a&;uGef,uftzJ G�wGif tzG J�0ifjzpf+yD; TtpD&ifcHpmjzpf ajrmufzd k�twGuftptqH k; wm0ef
,lpDpOfa&;om;onf htzJ G hjzpfonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 3/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 4/90
tpD&ifcHpm tusOf;csKyf 1
tcef; (1)? aemufcHord kif;a-umif; 5
ppfwyf}uD;pdk;r_ESifh ucsifjynfe,ftwGif; jzpfay: ajymif;vJr_rsm; 6jrefrmEdkifiH&Sd a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief; 8jrpf}uD;{&m0wD 10
{&m0wDjrpf0Srf; 11jrpfqHka'oESifhucsifwdk @twGuf ,Ofaus;r_t&ta&;ygr_ 14
tydkif; (2) {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf aqmufvkyfa&;pDrHcsuf 1 6
qnfudk rnfodk @toHk;csrnfenf; 17
v#yfppf"gwftm;a&mif;csr_rS &&Sdrnfh cef@rSef;ajcwefbdk; 18b¾maiG rnfr#ukefusrnfenf;? 18tifrdkifc (arc) jrpfudkqnfzd k @jcif; 19tcsdefumv owfrSwfcsufrsm; 20qnfaqmufvkyfrnf hae&mY vwfwavm jzpfay:wd k;wufr_rsm; 23tusKd;pD;yGm;t& yg0ifywfoufae=uolrsm; 25
tydkif; (3)? {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnfa-umif h jzpfvmEd kifaom 3 3
&dkufcwfr+ qdk;usKd;rsm;
{&m0wD jrpfqH kqnf pDrHcsufa=umif h a&v$rf;cH&rnf hae&mrsm; 33vlrsm; ae&yf&if;pGef @cGg ajymif;a&$ @&jcif;ESif h �if;.aemufqufwG Jjy\emrsm; 34
jrefrmEd kifiHwGif qnfwnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm;a=umifh a&$@ajymif;=u&r_rsm; 35,Ofaus;r_qd kif&m ysufpD;qHk;&_H;apr_rsm; 41toufarG;0rf;ausmif;r_b0rsm; ysufpD;=u&jcif;? 43jrpfatmufyd kif;&S d ajrEkEH k;wif pd kufcif;rsm; ysufpD;apjcif;? 44vH kðcHa&;twGuf ylyef&r_rsm; 47obm0ywf0ef;usif ysufpD;qHk;&_ H;r_rsm; usef;rma&;qdkif&m tE W&m,frsm; 60
rmwdum
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 5/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 6/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 7/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 1
tpD&ifcHpm tusOf;csKyf
jrefrmEdkifiH. tcsuftcsma'orsm;udk jzwfoef;pD;qif;aeaom/ tm&Swdkuf. t"dujrpf}uD;woG,fjzpfonf h {&m0wDjrpfud k qnfzd k @=uayawmhrnf? jrefrmEd kifiH. ppftpd k;&onf{&m0wDjrpfud kydwfI (152) rDwm tjrif h&S daom {&mrqnf}uD;wckud k wnfaqmuf+yD;/v#yfppf"gwftm;ud k w&kwfjynfod k @yd k @v$wf a&mif;cs&ef w&kwfukr%Drsm;tm; &if;ES D;jr�KyfES HcGif hðycJ honf? jrefrmppftpd k;&tzd k @ 0ifaiG0ifvrf;topfrsm;&&Sdrnfjzpfaomfvnf; rnfonfhta&;qd kydkifcGif hr# r&S daom jrefrmEdkifiHjynfolrsm;tzdk @rl TpDrHcsuftwGuf xdcdkufepfemr_rsm;jzif h wefbd k;ay;qyf=u&rnfjzpfonf?
(2007) ckESpfwGif jrefrmEdkifiHY qnfopfrsm;aqmufvkyfa&;ESif h ywfoufaom pDrHudef;tajrmuftrsm;ud k xkwfjyefa=ujimcJ h+yD;/ �wd k @txJwGif tdrfeD;csif;wd kif;jynfrsm;od k @ v#yfppf"gwftm;wifyd k @ a&mif;csEd kif rnf h a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief;rsm;vnf; yg0ifaecJ honf?v#yfppfpGrf;tifqmavmif rufarmae=uaom tdrfeD;csif;wd kif;jynfrsm;tzd k @ jrefrmEd kifiHt
wGif;wGif qnfrsm;aqmufvkyfjcif;onf v#yfppf"gwftm;udk aps;csdKcsdKESifh &apEdkifonfhtwGufa=umif h tusKd;tjrwfjzpfapaomfvnf;/ Tqnfrsm;wnfaqmufjcif;a=umif hjzpfay:vmaprnf h pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;ESif h ywf0ef;usifqd kif&m xdcd kufepfem&r_rsm;ud k jrefrmEd kifiHbufjcrf;&Sd vlxkrsm;odk @ yH kcswGef;yd k@xm;Edkifygonf?
jrefrmjynfajrmufydkif;tpGefqHk;jzpfaom ucsifjynfe,f&Sd {&m0wDjrpf tpðy&mjrpfqHkY
qnfaqmufvkyfa&; pDrHcsufzGif hyG Jtcef;tem;wckud k (2007) ckESpf/ arvwGif usif;ycJ hygonf? TqnfrSaeI a&tm; v#yfppf"gwftm; rD*g0yf 3�600 (MW) ud k xkwfv$wfay;Ed kifrnfjzpf+yD;/ trsm;pkud k w&kwfEd kifiHod k @ yd k @v$wfa&mif;csaprnf jzpfonf? Tqnfwnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm;onf w&kwfEd kifiH A[d ktpd k;&. �taemufrS ta&S @od k @ pGrf;tifyd k @v$wfapa&; rl0g'� (West to East Power Transmission Policy) t& aqmif&Gufjcif;
jzpfygonf? Tv#yfppf"gwftm; a&mif;csr_wefzd k;onf wESpfv#if tar&duefa':vmoef;(500) cef@&Sdvdrfhrnf[k cef@rSef;&onf? {&m0wD jrpfqHkqnfonf Tjrpfa=umif;wav#muf w&kwfwdk@u wnfaqmufrnfh qnf}uD; (7) ckteuf yxrOD;qHk;qnfvnf;jzpfonf?
qnfa=umifh jzpfay:vmp&m&S daom qd k;usKd;rsm;ESifhywfoufI pdk;&drfylyefrdaoma=umif hucsifjynfe,f wv$m;&Sd &yf&Gmvl}uD;rsm;ESifh &Gmol&Gmom;rsm;u AdkvfcsKyfrSL;}uD;oef;a&$ESif h ajrmufyd kif;wd kif;ppfXmecsKyf wd kif;rSL;xH Tqnfaqmufvkyfa&; pDrHcsufud k &yfqd kif;ay;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 8/90
2 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
&ef uef @uGufpmrsm; ay;yd k @cJ h=uonf? od k @aomfvnf; Tuef @uGufr_rsm;ud k vspfvsLðyxm;=uqJyifjzpfonf?
ZD0owW pHkvifaxGjym;r_ESifhywfoufI urBm@ �tausmf=um;qHk;ae&m� ae&m (8) ckteuf Ta'oud k wcktygt0iftjzpf owfrSwfxm;=u+yD;/ qnfwnfaqmuf+yD;pD;yguTa'owGif;&S d cef @rSef;ajc&Gmaygif; (47) &Gm a&ðryfoGm;ayawmhrnf? vlOD;a& cef @rSef;ajctm;jzif h (10000) onfvnf; td k;tdrftajcysuf a&$ @ajymif;=u&rnfjzpfum tvkyftud kifqHk;&_ H;&jcif;/ tvkyfvufrJhjy\emud k yd krd kqd k;&Gm;vmapjcif;/ rl;,pfaq;pGJr_ jy\emrsm;wd k;yGm;vmapjcif;ESif h ud k,fcHtm;usa&m*g (tdyfcsftd kifAG D-attd kif'Dtufpf) ul;pyfysH @yGm;r_
yd krd kqd k;&Gm;vmzG,f &S daeayonf? a&v$rf;r_a=umif h a0;vHacgifoDonf h a'orsm;ESif h òr@}uD;rsm;ud k qufoG,fxm;aom vrf;rsm;vnf; jywfawmufum vrf;yef;qufoG,fa&;ESifhukefoG,fa&; xdcd kufepfem=u&ayawmhrnf?
r=umao;rDumv/ (2006) ckESpf twGif;uvnf; teD;tem;&Sdjrpfay:Y wnfaqmuf
xm;aom qnfusKd;aygufjcif;a=umifh aetdrfrsm;ESifh wHwm;rsm; arsmyg qHk;&_H;=u&+yD;/vlrsm;toufqHk;&_H;&jcif;/ v#yfppf"gwf tm;ay;puf&HkESifh qnftaqmuftODrsm; jyefjyifIr&awmhavmufatmif ysufpD;jcif;rsm; jzpfay:cJ h&ygonf? jrefrmEd kifiH ajrmufyd kif;onfajrivsif'%f r=umc% cH&wwfaomae&mjzpf+yD;/ {&m0wDjrpfqH k qnfae&monf t"duppfud kif;ajrivsifa=umESif h uDvd krDwm (100)yif rjynf hwwfaom tuGmta0;wGif wnf&S daeygonf? qnfatmufbuf uDvd krDwm (40) r# tuGmta0;wGif&S dae=uaom ucsif
jynfe,f. òr@awmf jzpfonf h jrpf}uD;em;òr@aevlxkrsm;tzd k @ qnfusKd;aygufjcif;/ od k @r[kwfobm0t& r[kwfaom &kwfw&uf a&v#Hwufr_ESif hvnf; ñuH&Ed kifygao;onf?
xd k @tjyif qnf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmufr_a=umif h jzpf&aom qdk;usKd;rsm;rSm ig;zrf;vkyfief;/EH k;wifajrEkvGifjyifrsm;wGif ,mpd kufysKd;=uolrsm;ESif h jrpf&d k;wav#muf jrpfurf;yg;rsm;ay:wGif
pd kufysKd;rS Dcd kae=uolrsm;wd k@tay: aocsmayguf usa&muf&ayawmhrnf? tjcm;qnf}uD;rsm; aqmufvkyfa&;vkyfief;rsm;rS Todk@qdk;usKd;rsm; ñuH=u&yHkudk aocsmrSwfwrf;wifxm;cJ h=u+yD; jzpfonf? Tod k @jzpfvmrnf h qd k;usKd;'%foif hr_rsm;ud k {&m0wDjrpfud k rS Dwif;aexdkif=uonf h vloef;aygif;rsm;pGmwd k @ cHpm;=u&ayawmhrnf? xdk @tjyif iSufzsm;a&m*gysH @ES H @ul;pufvmEd kifouJ hod k @/ a&avSmifwmwrHrsm;rS xGufvmaom rDod kif;rmusL&D jy'g;qdyfoif hr_ ponf h usef;rma&;jy\emrsm;ud kvnf; jrefrmjynfolwd k @ cHpm;=u&vdrf hrnf jzpfyg
onf? Ttajctae jzpfay:vmygu urBmay:wGif usef;rma&;apmif ha&Smufr_pepf tnH hzsif;qHk; EdkifiHwcktjzpf owfrSwfcHxm;&aom jrefrmEdkifiH. usef;rma&;pepftwGuf
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 9/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 3
ydkI0efxkyf0efydk; jzpfvmapawmhrnf? {&m0wDjrpf.trnfESifhtwl ,SOfwGJausmf=um;vSonfh &Sm;yg;rsKd;wkef;awmhrnfjzpfaom {&m0wDvif;ydkifig;}uD;rsm;onfvnf; TjrpftwGif;rS t+yD;wd kif aysmufuG,foGm;Ed kifygonf?
ppftpd k;&onf wnfaqmufa&;pDrHcsuf}uD;rsm;. vH kðcHa&;twGufqd kum ppftiftm;wd k;csJ @csxm;jcif;ESifh xdka'owGif ajrjr�Kyfrdkif;rsm; cif;vmzG,f &Sdaeygao;onf? ppftpdk;&.tus,ftjyef @vl @tcGif hta&; csKd;azmufr_rsm;twGuf tpD&ifcHpm tapmifapmifu rSwfwrf;wifazmfjycJh=u+yD;/ twif;tusyf vkyftm;apcdkif;jcif;/ ajrodrf;jcif;ESifh vltrsm;.touftE W&,f+cdrf;ajcmufjcif; ponfh vl @tcGifhta&;csKd;azmuf zdESdyfr_rsm;onfvnf;
Tqnfwnfaqmufa&; pDrHudef;rsm;ESif htwl vd kufygvmEd kifygonf? {&m0wD jrpf qH kqnfae&mwGif aexd kifae=uaom vlxkrsm;onfvnf; c|if;csufrjzpfEd kifyg? tvm;wltusKd;qufrsm; ud k cHpm;&&ef ta=umif;&S daeygonf? txl;ojzif h trsKd;orD;rsm;tzd k @ ppfwyf.vdifr_qd kif&mt& t=urf; zufr_rsm;ud k cH&Ed kifp&m ta=umif;&S daeygonf? TuJ hod k @aomab;tEW&m,frsm; omru/ qnfaqmufvkyfrnf hae&mud k owfrSwft+yD;/ ajymif;a&$ @=u&
onf htcg toufarG;0rf;ausmif; vkyfief;rsm;vnf; qH k;&_ H;xdcd kuf=urnfjzpf+yD;/ b0tajcysuf=u&aoma=umif h trsKd;orD;rsm; taejzif h/ vdifazsmfajza&; vkyfief;rsm;ESif h vlarSmifcd kukeful;r_rsm;xJod k@ usa&mufoGm;apEd kifonfh tE W&m,fvnf; &S dEdkifygonf?
&mpkESpfrsm;ESif hcsDI jrpfqH ka'oonf ucsifwdk @. *k%f,lzG,f tarGtESpfomru jrefrmEd kifiHolEd kifiHom;tm;vH k;. tarGtESpfvnf;jzpfaom aw;oDcsif;rsm;/ uAsmrsm;ESif h '¾m
&DyH kjyifrsm;. blrdeufoefvnf; jzpfcJ hygonf? tu,fI Tqnfud kom qufIaqmufoGm;rnfqd kygu trsKd;om; ,Ofaus;r_ txdrf;trSwfae&mwckvnf; tem*wfrsKd;qufrsm;twGuf tpOfxm0& qHk;&_ H;oGm;&ayawmhrnf?
ucsifzG H @òzd;wk d;wufa&;uGef&uftzG J @ (KDNG) u {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf wnfaqmufa&;pDrH
csuf &yfwef;u &yfypfa&;twGuf twdtvif; zGifh[awmif;qdkvmcJholrsm;ESif htwlwom;wnf; &yfwnfygonf? vuf&S d ppftpd k;&onf �. ppftm%mwnfjrJa&;twGufom óu;yrf;aev#uf&S d+yD;/ �wdk @ tjrwftpGef;rsm;aprnfh {&mrwnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;}uD;rsm;ud k wd k;jr�if hvkyfaqmifv#uf &S dygonf? Twnf aqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm;. tusKd;qufaumif;usKd;csrf;omudk jynfolvlxkrsm; cHpm;cGifh&Sd=urnf r[kwfbJ/ xdcdkufepfem&rnf h ay;qyfr_rsm;ESif h tE W&m,frSefor#ud kom tm%mrJ hjynfolrsm;tay: usa&mufap
ygvdrf hrnf? Tod k @ {&mrpDrHcsuf}uD;rsm;tpm; a'oae jynfolvlxkrsm;. tcGif hta&;rsm;udk todtrSwfðyay;+yD;/ obm0t&if;tjrpfrsm;udk pDrHcef@cG J&mY olwdk@ud k,fwdkif yg0if
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 10/90
4 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
aqmif&GufpDrHcGif hay;&ef vd ktyfygonf? xd k @tjyif tjcm;a&G;cs,fp&menf;vrf;rsm;ud kvnf;&Sm=uHaqmif&Guf&ef vd ktyfygonf? w&kwfEd kifiHonf tdrfeD;csif; tiftm;}uD; Ed kifiHwckjzpf+yD;/ a'otwGif; Ed kifiHrsm;twGufrsm;pGmaom aumif;usKd;rsm; aqmifusOf;ay;Ed kifygonf?ucsifzG H @òzd;wk d;wufa&;uGef&uftzG J @ (KDNG) taejzif h w&kwfEd kifiHtay:awmif;qd kvd konfrSm jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; w&kwfEd kifiHu aqmif&Gufaeonf h pDrHcsufrsm;wGifvnf; w&kwfEd kifiHwGif; csrSwfxm;onf h usif h0wfpHowfrSwfcsufrsm;twd kif; av;pm;vd kufem aqmif&Gufyg&efESifh TpDrHcsufrsm;. qdk;usKd; tusKd;quf'%fudk cHpm;=u&rnfh jynfolvlxkrsm;.toHud k tav;teufðyyg&ef awmif;qd kygonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 11/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 12/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 13/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 7
=uygonf? xdk@tjyif pnf;urf;rJh opfckwfr_a=umifh ucsifjynfe,f. ºu,f0vSaomobm0opfawm&d kif;rsm;ESif h axGjym;vS onf h ZD0owWrsKd;uG Jrsm; wnf&S daer_vnf; ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;cJ h&ygonf? owWKwl;az:a&;vkyfief;rsm;a=umif h jrpfacsmif;rsm; npfnrf;=u&ygonf?xd k @tjyif rl;,pfaq;pG Jolrsm;/ ud k,fcHtm; usa&m*g (tdyftd kifAD G-attd kif'Dtufpf) ul;pufr_rsm;ESifh vlarSmifcdk ukeful;a&mif;csr_rsm;vnf; ydkrdkysH@ESH @jzpfyGm;vmaoma=umif h vlr_tzGJ @tpnf;wckvHk;twGuf ydI xdcdkufepfemzG,fta=umif; jzpfapcJhygonf? xdkr#omruud k,fcHtm; usa&m*g jzpfyGm;r_ESif h rl;,pfaq; 0g;jy\emonf tdrfeD;csif; w&kwfEd kifiHod k @yife,fpyfjzwfausmf ul;pufoufa&mufae+yDjzpfygonf?
typftcwf&yfpJa&; aemufyd kif;umv/ vlrsKd;pkrsm; ,cifu xdef;csKyfxm;&m e,fpyfa'orsm;xJod k @wd kifatmif jrefrmppfwyfrsm; wd k;csJ @csxm;vm+yD;/ e,fpyfa'ozG H @òz;a&; tpDtpOfrsm;uvnf; ,SOfwG Jvd kufvmcJ hygonf? Ttajctaersm;a=umif h Ed kifiH. obm0t&if;tjrpfrsm;ud k vkyfief;&Sif}uD;rsm;xH a&mif;pm;Ed kifcJ h=uygonf? jrefrmEd kifiH. obm0"gwfaiG @/ausmufjruf&wemrsm;ESif h u|ef;opfwd k @ud k vd kcsifwyfrufae=uonf h tdrfeD;csif;EdkifiHrsm;
onf/ jrefrmppftpd k;&u vl @tcGif hta&; csKd;azmufr_rsm;a=umif h emrnfysufI t}uD;tus,f&_wfcscHae&onf hwd kif ppftpd k;&ESif h tay;t,lðy qufqHcJ h=uygonf? ppftpd k;&onfucsifjynfe,fY awm&dkif;wd&p>mefrsm; cdkv_Husufpm;cGifhay;xm;&m ab;rJhawmrsm;ESifhjrpfa=umif;rsm;wGif ukr%Drsm;ud k pD;yGm;jzpf a&$xkwfcGif hðycJ h+yD; tjrwftpGef;rsm;pGm xkwf,l
Ed kifcJ h=uygonf?1 (trsm;pkud k w&kwfEd kifiHod k @ ukef;vrf;rS wd kuf&d kufwifyd k @onf h) u|ef;opfESif h
tjcm;opfrmrsm; ajymifwvif;cgatmif ckwf,l a&mif;csonfhudpPrsm;ESifh ywfoufI
Ed kifiHwum jypfwifa0zefr_rsm;ay: xGufvm+yD; aemufyd kif;wGif/ ppftpd k;&onf Ed kifiHjcm;od k @opfwifyd k@onfhvkyfief;rsm;ud k &efukefrSaeIom wqifhvkyfudkif&rnf[k trdef@xkwfjyefcJ hygonf? Tenf;tm;jzif h opfvkyfief;rS aocsmayguf wd kuf&d kuf tjrwfxkwfEd kif&ef ppftpdk;&u xyfrHpDpOfcJ hygonf?
ppftpd k;&onf xdkif;Ed kifiH/ w&kwfEd kifiHwd k @ESif h obm0"gwfaiG @a&mif;csa&; ESpf&SnfoabmwlnDr_rsm;vnf; ðyxm;onfhtjyif/ tdENd,EdkifiHESifhvnf; aphpyfaqG;aEG;v#uf&Sdygonf?ToabmwlnDr_rsm;wGif obm0"gwfaiG @yd kufvd kif; wnfaqmufa&;twGuf t}uD;pm;Ed kifiHjcm;&if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_rsm;vnf; yg0ifygonf? tdrfeD;csif;Ed kifiH od k @r[kwf Ed kifiHjcm;ukr%Drsm;onf/ �wd k @. y%mr&if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_twGuf tjrwftpGef; tvH ktavmuf jyefvnf&,lEd kifa&;twGuf TpmcsKyfrsm;ud k ESpfaygif; (25) ESpfrS (30) ESpf pDrHxm;avh&S dygonf? Tod k @&if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hxm;aomae&mrsm;Y &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Holtzd k @ �wd k @oabmwlvufrSwfxd k;xm;aomtpdk;&. wnf+idrfr_/ od k@r[kwf wnfwH hr_wGif tavmif;tpm;vkyfxm;&onfvnf;jzpf
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 14/90
8 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
&m/ ppftpdk;&u T �obm0pGrf;tifa&mif;csr_�rSaeI EdkifiHa&;t&omru/ b¾ma&;t&yg tusKd;tjrwfrsm; xkwf,l&&S dEd kifonf h �t&if;tjrpfoHwrefa&;� upm;uGufvnf; jzpfaeygonf?
jrefrmEd kifiH&S d a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief;(2006) ckESpf pufwifbmvtxd/ w&m;0ifudef;*%ef;rsm;t& jrefrmEd kifiHwGif &S d+yD;om;
v#yfppf"gwf tm;xkwfv$wfr_ pGrf;tm;onf pkpkaygif; (1�775) rD*g0yf jzpfygonf?2 a&
tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfr_rSm t=urf;zsif;tm;jzif h Tpkpkaygif; yrm%. (30)rS (35) &mcd kifE_ef;&S donf[k cef @rSef;&ygonf? aemufxyf a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfEd kifrnf h puf&H krsm;ud kvnf; wnfaqmufaeqJ jzpfonf[k a=ujimcJ hygonf?
jrefrmEdkifiHwGif a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfrnf[k cef @rSef;wGufcsufxm;onfh yrm%onf(38� 000) rD*g0yf jzpf&m/ �onf ta&S @awmiftm&Sukef;ajr&S d Ed kifiHrsm;xuf ausmfvGef
rsm;jym;aeonf h yrm%yif jzpfonf?3 (etz) ppftpd k;&onf Ttvm;tvmtwd kif;
taumiftxnfaz:Edkifa&;twGuf tvGefpdwfxufoefaeonfjzpf&m/ owfrSwfxm;
Ad kvfcsKyfrSL;}uD;armifat;u aygif;avmif;qnfzGif hyG J wGif rdef @cGef;ajym=um;aepOf/ w&kwfEd kifiHrS &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Holrsm;vnf; wufa&mufcJ honf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 15/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 9
aom tvm;tvm&S donf h ae&mrsm;Y &if;ES D; jr�KyfES Holrsm;ESif h em;vnfr_ pmc|efv$mrsm;trsm;tjym;ud k tvsifpvd k a&;xd k;csKyfqd k v#uf&S dygonf?
a&tm;v#yfppf xkwfvkyfr_ESif h qnfrsm; (Hydropower and Dams) trnf&S d pufr_vkyfief;r*~Zif;wGif r=umao;rDu azmfjycJhaom aqmif;yg;wapmift& �avmavmq,fjrefrmEdkifiHwGif taumiftxnfaz:&ef pDrHcsufa&;qG JaeqJjzpfaom pDrHcsuf (29) ckudkpm&if;ðypk az: jycJ hygonf? Tpm&if;xJwGif ucsifjynfe,f&S d qnfwnfaqmufa&;pDrHcsuf(5) ckta=umif; rygcJ hacs? ta=umif;rSm aqmif;yg; yH kES dyfaz: jy+yD; aemufyd kif;rSom xkwf
jyef=ujimcJ haoma=umif hjzpfonf?4 vuf&S d a=ujimxm;onfrsm; omru tpOfwd k;vmae
v#uf&S daom pDrHcsufrsm;u az:nGef;jyaeonfrSm ppftpd k;&taejzif h tvm;tvm&S daeonfh a&tm;v#yfppf"gwftm;ay;puf&Hkrsm; tjreftaumiftxnfaz:a&;ESifh xd kpuf&H krsm; rSaeI EdkifiHjcm;aiGa':vmrsm; tirf;r&&&Sdvdkaeaom taetxm;yifjzpfonf?tpd k;&onf v#yfppf"gwftm;ay; vkyfief;rsm;wGif t"duavmifpmtjzpf obm0"gwfaiG @ud k tm;xm;ae&mrS (2030) ckESpf ta&mufwGif a&tm;pGrf;tifbufod k @ ajymif;vJtm;
xm;awmhrnf[k v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;XmerS t&m&S dwOD;u jrefrmEd kifiHwGif; xkwfa0aeaom owif;pmwapmifud k ajymjycJ hygonf?5 od k @aomfvnf; Ta&tm;v#yf ppfpDrHcsuf
rsm;rS &&S dvmrnf h v#yfppf"gwftm; rnfr# jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; usef&S dtoH k;ðyEd kifrnf qd konfud k &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif; rod&ao;acs?
jrefrmEd kifiH. tdrfeD;csif;Ed kifiHrsm; jzpf=uonf h xd kif;Ed kifiH/ tdEN d,/ b*Fvm;a'h&S f/ w&kwfEd kifiHrsm;u v#yfppf avmifpmud k tirf;r& vd kcsifae=uygonf? jrefrmEd kifiHbuf tjcrf;wGifwnfaqmufrnf h xd kqnfrsm; a=umif h v#yfppf"gwftm; aps;aygaygESif h &Ed kif=urnfjzpf+yD;/Tqnfrsm; wnfaqmufjcif;a=umifh tusKd; qufjzpfvmrnfh pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;ESifhobm0ywf0ef;usifqd kif&m qd k;usKd;rsm;udkrl jrefrmEd kifiHbuf tjcrf;rSmom c|if;csefxm;&pfvd k=uygonf? xd kif;Ed kifiHESif h tdEN d,Ed kifiHwd k @wGif &S daeonf h qnf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmufr_
qef @usifa&;v_yf&Sm;r_rsm;u tiftm;aumif;aeaoma=umif/h jrefrmEd kifiHwGif a&G;+yD; qnfwnfaqmufvd kae=uygonf? Ttcsufonfvnf; TEd kifiHrsm;twGuf txl;qG Jaqmifr_w&yfjzpfaeygonf?
(1998) ckESpfwGif urBmhb%fESifh urBmhobm00ef;usif xdef;odrf;a&;or*~ (World
Conservation Union)
wd k @u {&mrqnf}uD;rsm;. xda&mufr_ud k pDppf=unf h&efESif h qnf}uD;rsm;aqmufvkyfa&;ESif h ywfoufI pHxm;csufrsm; csrSwfEd kif&ef urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&maumfr&Sif (World Commision on Dams--WCD) ud k zG J @pnf;xm;cJ hygonf? Taumfr&Sif
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 16/90
10 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
u (2)ESpfausmf=um avhvmcJ h+yD;aemuf awG @&S dcJ h&onfrSm �ae&mtawmfrsm;rsm;Y qnf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmufjcif;a=umif h&vmrnf h tusKd;tjrwfrsm;twGuf/ vufcHEd kifzG,f&mr&S daom/ &Hzef&Hcg rvd kvm;tyfaom xdcd kufepfemr_ wefbd k;rsm; ay;cJ h=u&onf�[k azmfjycJ h
ygonf?6 urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&m aumfr&Sif. tpD&ifcHpmxGuf+yD; aemufyd kif;wGif {&mr
a&tm; v#yfppfqnf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmuf&mY xdcd kufepfem&r_ ukefusp&dwfrsm;ud k av#mhayghwGufqjcif;ESif h &vmrnf h tusKd;tjrwfrsm;ud k tvGeftu|H yd kwGufrSef;qxm;jcif;rsm;
ta=umif;udk urBmwv$m;rS ydkrdkod&Sdvm=u+yD;/7 qnf}uD;rsm; tawmfrsm;rsm;udkvnf;
zsufodrf;ypfae=uygonf? od k @jzpfonf hwd kif w&kwfEd kifiHonf/ jynfwGif;rSma&m jynfyrSmyg{&mrqnf}uD;rsm;ud k tpOfwd k;I wnfaqmufaev#uf &S donf htjyif/ jrefrmEd kifiH&S d a&tm;
v#yfppfxkwfvkyfa&; vkyfief;tpDtpOfrsm; txajrmufvmapa&;wGif OD;aqmifOD;&Gufðyaeol jzpfvmygonf?
w&kwfEdkifiHta&S@yd kif;&S d zG H@òz;}uD;xGm;vmaeaom òr@}uD;rsm;qDodk@ v#yfppf"gwftm;axmufyH hay;Ed kif&ef wd k;Iwd k;I vd ktyfvmae&m/ w&kwfEd kifiH A[d ktpd k;&u �taemufrS
ta&S @od k @v#yfppf"gwftm;yd k @v$wfay;a&;rl0g'�ud k tylwjyif; taumiftxnfaz:&ef jzpfvm&ygonf? w&kwfEd kifiH taemufyd kif;ESifh tdrfeD;csif; jrefrmEd kifiHwGif aqmufvkyfrnfha&tm;v#yfppfxkwf a&umwmrsm;onf Trl0g'ESif h tHud kufjzpfapygonf? jrefrmEd kifiH.a&tm;v#yfppfu¾wGif w&kwfEd kifiH. &if;ES D;jrSKyfES Hr_onfvnf; ESpfEd kifiHt=um; pD;yGm;a&;ESif h Ed kifiHa&;t& yd krd k&if;ES D; yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufvmapa&;twGuf u¾wck jzpfvmaeonf?pGrf;tifvkyfief;ESif h ywfoufaom r*~Zif;wapmifu azmfjy&mwGif �taemufEd kifiHrsm;ujrefrmEd kifiHud k �. qd k;&Gm;nHhzsif;vSaom vl @tcGifhta&;rSwfwrf;rsm;a=umif h[kqdkum0d kif;y,fxm;csdefwGif w&kwfEdkifiH tpd k;&u xd kEd kifiHxJod k @ aiGrsm;qufvuf yH katmoGefcs
v#uf&S daeonf?�[k r=umao;rDu az: jya&;om;cJ hygonf?8
jrpf}uD;{&m0wD
ukvor*~ obm0 ywf0ef;usiftpDtpOf (UN Environment Programme). urBmhywf0ef;usif xdef;odrf;r_ apmif h=unf ha&; Xme (World Conservation Monitoring Centre)
u {&m0wDjrpfud k �. ZD0owW0g pH kvifaxGjym;jcif;ESif h tem*wfumvwGif zdpD;+cdrf;ajcmufr_cH&zG,f ta=umif;rsm;a=umifh urBmay:wGif OD;pm;ay;xdef;odrf;&rnfh jrpf0Srf;
(30)wGif pm&if; xnf hoGif;xm;cJ hygonf?9 od&S dxm;aom tcsufrsm;t& {&m0wDjrpfwGif
ig;rsKd;pdwfaygif; (79) rsKd; cd kv_ H&maexd kif=uonf htjyif/10 (2002) ckESpf txdavhvmcsufrsm;t& {&m0wDjrpf0Srf;Y vltrsm; todtrSwfðyxm;aom iSufpm;usufe,fajr (4)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 17/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 18/90
12 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
The Myitsone
Song of praise for the Kachin confluence
Memorable ever pleasant Kachin homeland
Mali hka and Nmai hka flow there with beautiful and colorful surroundings
Local residents enjoy their lives
This is the lovely natural homeland of the Kachin people
Dear loving brothers and sisters
Will you forget it due to long loss of contact?
Will you be looking forward to my return?
On the river banks of Mali hka and Nmai hka
The singer�s song spreads
The fascinating environment of Kachin homeland
Impressed my heart and nostalgia is felt
I will keep the music of my soul in my heart for you brothers and sisters
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 19/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 13
{&m0wDjrpfonf ucsifjynfe,f&Sd rvdcESifh tifrdkifc (arc) jrpfrsm;aygif;qHk&mrSaeIpwifpD;qif;onf? Tjrpfzsm;c&m jrpfESpfpif;vH k;onf [dr0EWmawmifwef;. ta&S @awmifyd kif;a'orS jrpfzsm;cHvmjcif; jzpfonf? tifrd kifcjrpfonf ylwmtd kajrmufbuf&S d vifa*Gvma&cJawmifxGÉf (Languela Glacier) rSm pwifay:xGef;onf? jrpfqH konf ucsifjynfe,fòr@awmf jrpf}uD;em;òr@. ajrmufbuf (28) rdkif tuGmwGif wnf&S donf? jrpfonfjrefrmEd kifiH. A[d kcsufra'orsm;ESif h wd kif;jynf. 'kwd,t}uD;qH k; òr@jzpfaom rE Wav;òr@ud kjzwfoef;pD;qif;oGm;onf?
jrpfatmufyd kif;jzpfaom {&m0wDjrpf0u|ef;ay:a'oonf us,f0ef;I ajrqDajrESpfjynf h0
aom ajrjyef @ vGifjyifwckjzpf+yD;/ tvsm; (290) uDvd krDwmESif h teH (240) uDvd krDwm&S donf? jrpf0u|ef;ay:a'o atmufyd kif;onf vrk&$ H @!G HawmESif h 'Da&a&muf jrpf0a'ojzpf
+yD;/ xdcdkufvG,faom El;nHhodrfarG@aom a*[pepfwckvnf;jzpfonf?14 jrpf0u|ef;ay:
a'oonf vlOD;a& (3) oef;ausmfrS Dwif;aexd kif&mjzpf+yD;/ jrefrmEd kifiH qefpyg;txGuf.(60) &mcd kifE_ef;eD;yg;ud k Ta'ouxkwfvkyf jznf hqnf;ay;aeonf? od k @jzpfapumrl jrpf0
u|ef;ay:a'oae jynfolwd k@onf ppftpd k;&. tcGeftwkwfzdpD;r_ESifh ajr,myd kifqd kifcGif hrJhaer_wd k @a=umif h qd k;&Gm;jyif;xefaom qif;&JrG Jawr_'%fud k cHpm;ae=u&ygonf?15 yk*~vduyd kif
ykZGefarG;vkyfief;rsm; pnf;urf;rJ hvkyfud kifae=ur_ESif h opfawmðyef;wD;r_rsm;a=umif h obm0ywf0ef;usifrsm; ysufpD; qH k;&_ H;ae=u&+yD;/ urBm@awm&d kif;wd&p>mefrsm; &efyH kaiGtzG J @ (World
Wildlife Fund) u {&m0wD a&csKd&$ H @!G Hawmrsm;&S d a*[pepftwGif; aexd kifae=uaomawm&d kif;wd&p>mefrsm;tzd k @ tem*wf&SifoefEd kifa&;onf �txl;pd k;&drfzG,f tajctaeqd k;
&Gm;aea=umif;� azmfjycJ hygonf?16
�urBmOD ; wnfpuwnf;u usaemfwdk@&J@ obm0tarGjzpfcJhwJhae&m wcsd K@&S d ygw,f ? jref rmEd kif iHrSmqd k&if tJ'D tarGawGxJrSm ykyg;awmif / ZG Ju yif awmif eJ @ rvd c/ tif rd kif cjrpf qH kawG ygwmaygh? 'D &wemawG zsuf qD ; cHvd kuf &+yDqd k&if tm;vH k;zsuf qD;cHvdkuf &ovd k jzpf oGm;rSmaygh?� (ucsifjynfe,frS oif;tkyfq&mwOD;ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;csuf/ awG @qH kar;jref;cef; trSwf-30)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 20/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 21/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 15
avh&S d =uonf? Tae&monf {&m0wD. csufjr� Ky fZmwdae&mjzpfaoma=umif hucsi fvlrs K d ;wd ki f ;u Tae&mtwGuf * k%f ,l =uonf? * Dwpmqd kE Si f huAsmq&mtawmfrsm;rsm;u jrpfqHkta=umif;a&;zGJ@cJh=u+yD;/ TjrpfqHkajrta=umif;ESifhywfoufI txl;a&;zGJ @xm;aom aw;oDcsif;trsm;tjym; &Sdaeonf?
wefz&Jaus;&Gmonf rvdcESif h tifrd kifcjrpfqH kwGif wnf&S d+yD;/ Tvrf;qH kvrf;cGY avSqdyfvnf;&S donf? jrpf}uD;em;rS jrpfnmyd kif;&S d yd ka0;vHaom ae&mrsm;od k @oGm;vd kygu Tae&mwGif avSajymif;pD;=u&onf? ucsifjynfe,f&S d ord kif;0if omoemðytzG J @}uD;wzG J @jzpfaom±d krefuufovpfausmif;awmf A[dkXmeonf wefz&Jaus;&GmwGif wnfxm;ouJ hod k@/ t
jcm;ordkif;0ifbk&m;&Sdcdk;ausmif;rsm;vnf; T&GmY wnf&Sdae=uonf?
ucsifwdk@. '¾m&Dwyk'fu Todk@qdkygonf? urBmapmifhewf}uD;u vufwzufpDwGifa&$cGufwcGufpDud kifv#uf a&rsm;oGef;csvd kufonf? vuf,mbufrSaeI pD;qif;aomrvdc({&m0wD) jrpfonf jrpftzd k jzpf+yD;/ yd kIus,fonf? a&wdrfonf? a&pD;oefonf? vuf0J
bufvufrSaeI oGef;csvdkufaom tifrdkifcjrpfonf ol. ESpfrjzpfonf? olronfjrif hrm;aomawmifacsmuf urf;yg;rsm;/ opfyifjrif h}uD;rsm; xlxyf&mawmrsm;tkyfrd k;xm;v#uf jzwfoef;pD;qif;cJ h&+yD; vlrjrifomaom a&eufyd kif;rsm;&S donf? xd k @twGufa=umif holronf wdwfqdwfonf? tod&cufonf? tE W&m,fðywwfonf[k ,lq=uonf?TonfrSmvnf; jrpfESpfoG,f. ,ae@yx0Dtaetxm; twd kif;yifjzpfonf? a&$cGufrSaeIaygufzGm;vmojzifh/ jrpfESpfoG,fpvHk;wGif a&$tr_efrsm;/ twH k;tcJrsm; yg0ifpD;qif;
vm=uonf? a&$usifolrsm;onf ESpfaygif;rsm;pGmuwnf;uyif jrpfurf;oJjyifrsm;ay:wGifyd kifeufowfrSwfI ,m,DwJrsm;aqmufvkyf tdyfpuf=u+yD;/ aygaygv_ difv_ dif &S daeaomig;rsm;ESif h awmxJrS opfOopfzkESif h toD;t&Gufrsm;ud k csufðywfpm;aomuf=uv#uf/ Tjrpf
rsm;xJY a&$&SmcJ h=uonf?17
jrpfqH ka'oonf '¾m&Dvm rdbrJ h nDaemifjzpfol c±d kif*rf; (Hkrai Gam) ESif h c±d kifaemf(Hkrai Naw) wdk@ aexdkifvmcJh&m Zmwdt&yfa'otjzpfvnf; vltrsm;od=uonf?'¾m&DyH kjyifu qd k&mwGif nDjzpfol c±d kifaemfonf raumif;qd k;&Gm; odrf;iSuf}uD;waumifud k ol.av;r#m;ESif h &J&ifhpGmcGif;+yD;aemuf ucsifjynfolwdk @udk u,fwifcJholtjzpfvnf;trsm;. ,H k=unfud k;pm;jcif; cHcJ h&onf? ol @ud k ,ae@umvwd kif ewftjzpf ylaZmfyoae=uqJjzpfonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 22/90
16 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
tyd kif; (2) {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf aqmufvkyfa&;pDrHcsuf
qnfESif hywfoufaom tao;pdwftcsuftvufrsm;
(etz) ppftpd k;&onf w&kwfEd kifiHrS yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufrnfholrsm;ESif h yl;aygif;I (yxrOD;pGm) {&m0wD jrpfr}uD;ay:wGif qnf}uD;wckwnf aqmufEd kif&eftwGuf pDrHudef;jyifqifa&;qGJv#uf&Sdaeygonf? odk@jzpfygu T}uD;rm;aomqnfa=umifh jrpf. obm0a&a=umif;ud k rkcsajymif;vJ oGm;aprnfjzpfonf? od k @aomfvnf; ppftpd k;&u Tqnfaqmufa&; pDrHcsufaqmif &Gufrnf h a'owGif aexd kif=uaom jynfolvlxkrsm;ud k today;jcif;rðybJ/ qnfwnfaqmufa&;ESif h ywfoufonf h tao;pdwf tcsuftvufrsm;ud kvnf;
vlod&Sif =um; xkwfjyefjcif; rðyao;yg? uHtm;avsmfpGm ucsifzG H @òzd;wk d;wufa&;uGef&uftzG J @ (KDNG) u TpDrHcsufESif h ywfoufonf h pm&Gufpmwrf;tcsKd @ud k &&S dEd kifcJ h+yD;/ aqmufvkyfrnf h qnf. oabmobm0ESif h twd kif;tqud k od&S dEd kifcJ hygonf? jrefrm v#yfppf"gwftm; ay;vkyfief;ESifh/ pdkufysKd;a&;ESif h qnfajrmif;0ef}uD;Xmewdk @u a&;om;ðypkxm;aom(2002) ckESpf/ azaz:0g&Dv &ufpG Jazmfjyxm;onf h �{&m0wDjrpfqk Hqnf bufpHka&tm;
pGrf;tif toH k;csa&; pDrHcsuf� (Irrawaddy Myitsone Dam Multipurpose Water UtilizingProject) trnf&S d Ttaxmuftxm; pmwrf;Y pDrHcsuf. tao;pdwftcsuftvufrsm;ud k az: jyxm;onf? (atmufwGif azmfjyxm;ygonf?) TpDrHcsufwGif yg0ifywfoufae=uaom w&kwfEd kifiHrS ukr%DtcsdK@. qd kif&mtcsuftvufrsm;ud kvnf; vwfwavmowif;rD'D,mESifh pmapmifpmwrf;rsm;wGif azmfjycsufrsm;udk pkpnf;I az: jyay;xm;ygonf?
(1) wnfae&m tifrd kifc/ rvdcjrpfqH k. atmufbuf(3)rd kif (jrpf}uD;em;òr@rS 25rd kiftuGm)
(2) ajryH ktn$ef; 1 vufrv#if 1 rd kifpau;/92G 10 24 2860
(3) qnfe,fajrtus,f 18� 000 pwk&ef;rd kif(4) txufa&avSmifuef}uD;. a&tjrif h 980- ay (299-rD wm)(5) qnftjrif h 500-ay (152-rD wm)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 23/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 17
(6) a&avSmifuef}uD; tjrif hqH k;xdef;Ed kifaoma&tjrif h 950-ay (290-rD wm)(7) a&avSifuef}uD; trsm;qH k;xdef;xm;Ed kifaoma&xk 34- {uay oef;(8) yifrqnf.tvsm; 500-ay (152-rDwm)(9) txufqnf (awmifa=um) trSwf (1) tvsm; 4�200-ay (1,280-rDwm)
(10) txufqnf (awmifa=um) trSwf(2) tvsm; 4�300-ay (1,311-rDwm)(11) txufqnf (awmifa=um) trSwf (3) tvsm; 1�850-ay (564-rDwm)(12) qnftrsKd;tpm; ausmufpDuGefu&pfud kif (a&jznf hqnf)(13) owfrSwfxm;aom v#yfppf"gwftm; 3�200 rD*g0yf(14) trmcH v#yfppf"gwftm; 1� 100 rD*g0yf
(15) ESpfpOfxkwfvkyfr_ 16�634 uDvd k0yf em&Doef;aygif;
qnfud k rnfod k @toH k;csrnfenf;pDrHcsufwGif t"du yg0ifvkyfaqmifrnf hol wOD;jzpfaom w&kwfEdkifiH v#yfppf"gwftm; &if;ESD;jr�KyfESHr_aumfyd ka&;&Sif; (CPI) . tqd kt&/ ,leefv#yfppf
"gwftm;uGef&ufukr%D (Yunnan Power GridCompany) u jrefrmEd kifiHrS xkwfv$wfay;rnf h v#yfppf"gwftm;rsm;udk ,leefv#yfppf"gwftm; uGef
&ufjzif h w&kwfEd kifiHod k @ yd k @v$wfay;rnfjzpfonf?18
w&kwfEdkifiHonf �. �taemufrS ta&S@odk@
v#yfppf"gwftm; yd k @v$wfay;a&;tpDtpOf� enf;wlyif/ r[mrJacgifa'o v#yfppf"gwftm;uGef
&uf19 xJod k @ v#yfppf"gwftm;rsm; yd k @v$wfEd kifa&;
twGuf tjyif;txefavmaqmf aqmif&Gufaeonf? xd k @tjyifTqnfrsm;rS xkwfv$wf rnfh a&tm;v#yfppf &&Sda&;onf/ w&kwfEd kifiH. �taemufydkif;a'orsm;wGif zGH@òz;r_jzpfay:vmapa&;�r[mAsL[m. ta&;}uD; tpdwftydkif;wckjzpf+yD;/ w&kwfEd kifiH taemufyd kif;rS aps;csdKoufompGm xkwfv$wfvd kufaom v#yfppf"gwftm;ud k pGrf;tifvd ktyfaev#uf&S daom ta&S @yd kif;jynfe,f urf;&d k;wef;a'orsm;od k @ yd k @v$wf
ay;&ef &nf&G,fcsufvnf; &S daeonf?20
ucsifjynfe,f&Sd qnfrsm;ESifh &Srf;jynfe,f&Sd a&$vDqnfwdk @ ta=umif;ajymqdk&mY bef
aumuftajcpd kuf pGrf;tifqd kif&m yd kif;jcm;oH k;oyfolwOD;u �jrefrmEd kifiHrSmu 'Davmufrsm;wJ h v#yfppf"gwftm;ud k yd k @v$wfay;Ed kifwJ h jzef @a0ay;a&; aumif;uif*&pf óu;uGef&uf
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 24/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 25/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 19
tifrd kifc (arc) jrpfud kqnfzdk @jcif;ppftpd k;onf {&m0wDjrpfay:&S d yifrqnf}uD;tjyif/ jrpfqH kajrmufbuf&S d tifrd kifcjrpfay:Yvnf; aemufxyf qnf (7)ck wnfaqmuf&ef vsmxm;aom pDrHudef;rsm;&S daeygao;onf? (2007) ckESpf/ arv tpdk;&xkwf jrefrmhtvif;owif;pmyg aqmif;yg;wyk'fYatmufygtwdkif;az: jyxm;ygonf?
trSwf (1) v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;Xme vufatmuf&Sd/ a&tm;v#yfppf taumiftxnfaz:a&;XmeESifh w&kwfEdkifiH v#yfppf"gwftm; &if;ESD;jr�KyfESHr_aumfydka&;&Sif; (China
Power Investment Corporation--CPI) wd k @onf a&tm;v#yfppfvkyfief; pDrHcsuf (7)
ck ({&m0wDjrpfqHkY 3�600- rD*g0yf pDrHcsuf/ csDaAGY 2�000-rD*g0yf pDrHcsuf/ yg&SD;Y 1�600-rD*g0yf pDrHcsuf/ vmuifY 1�400-rD*g0yf pDrHcsuf/zDaZmY 1�500-rD*g0yf pDrHcsuf/ acgif*vefzlY 1�700-
rD*g0yf pDr Hcsuf/ vd ki fZmY1�560-rD *g0yfpDrHcsuf) udkucsifjynfe,ftwGif;Y wnfaqmufoGm;rnfjzpfonf?qnftm;vH k; wnfaqmuf+yD;pD;oGm;yg u pkpkaygif; rD*g0yf
(13�36 0)udk xkwfv$wfay;Ed kifrnf[k ar#mfvif hxm;ygonf? TpDrHcsufonf jrefrmEd kifiHY t}uD;qH k;a&tm; v#yfppfvkyfief; jzpf+yD; wd kif;jynf.
t}uD;qH k; a&tm;v#yfppfvkyfief; pDrHcsufjzpfaom &Srf;jynfe,f&Sd (7�100) rD*g0yfxkwfay;Ed kifonfh wmqef;qnf. tiftm;xufom
vGefaeygonf?22
Laiza
MyitsoneChibwe
Lakin
PhizawKhaunglanphu
Pashe
jrefrmhtvif;owif;pmyg tcsuftvufrsm;t&qnfwnfaqmufrnf h ae&mrsm;
rvdcESifh tifrd kifcjrpfay:&S d qnfwnfaqmuf&eftqd kjyKxm;aom ae&mrsm;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 26/90
20 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
tifrd kifcjrpfay:wGif wnfaqmuf&efvsmxm;aom {&mrqnf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmufrnf hpDrHudef;onf oef f @pifaomTjrpf. a*[pepfud k aocsmayguf xdcd kufysufpD;aprnfjzpfygonf? xd kr#omru/ {&m0wD jrpftay:wGifvnf; rvG JraoGtusKd;oufa&mufr_rsm;jzpfay:apygvdrf hrnf? TtpD&ifcHpmwGif az: jyxm;aom {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf. xdcd kuf&d kufcwfEd kifr_ qd k;usKd;rsm;twd kif;yif/ tifrd kifcqnfrsm; tm;vH k;. &d kufcwfr_ qd k;usKd;rsm;onfvnf; tvm;wlyif jzpfygvdrf hrnf? Tqnfrsm;wnfaqmufrnf htwGufa=umif h vltrsm;tdk;tdrftajcysuf&r_ taetxm;ud k rod&SdEd kifao;yg?
tcsdefumv owfrSwfcsufrsm;2002 {&m0wDjrpfqk Hqnfa&bufpH ktoH k;csa&;pDrHcsuf trnfay;xm;aom
avhvmwdkif;xGmr_ w&yfudk jrefrmv#yfppf"gwftm;ay;vkyfief;ESifh
pd kufysKd;a&;ESif h qnfajrmif; 0ef}uD;Xmewdk @u a&;om;ðypkcJhonf?uefqd kif; v#yfppf"gwftm; ukr%D(Kansai Electric Power
Company)u jrpfqH k&S d wefz&J&GmwGif tao;pm; rd k;av0\XmewckwnfaqmufcJhonf?
2003 qnfaqmufrnf hae&mod k @ KEPCO .wd kif;wma&;tzG J @wzG J @ 2-}udrf
a&mufvmcJ h onf?2004/ azaz:0g&D wefz&J&Gmom;rsm;u ajrmufyd kif;wd kif; ppfXmecsKyf wd kif;rSL; Ad kvfcsKyfarmifarmifa&$ xHod k @ uef @uGufpm ay;yd k @cJ honf?
2005/atmufwdkbmv w&kwfEd kifiH&S d ,leef puf,E W,m; oGif;ukef/ xkwfukef ukr%D
(Yunnan Machinery Export & Import Company)ESif h ulrif;
a&tm;v#yfppf 'DZd kif; Xme (Kunming Hydropower Institute of
Design) wd k @u qnfaqmufrnf h ae&mud k wd kif;wm=uonf?
w&kwfEdkifiH v#yfppf"gwftm; &if;ES D;jr�KyfESHr_ aumfydka&;&Sif;CPI)
ESifh jrefrmEdkifiH pGrf;tif0ef}uD;Xmewdk@ em;vnfr_pmc|efv$mvufrSwfa&;xdk;yGJ tcrf;tem;
qnfwnfaqmufrnfhae&mod k@ oGm;rnf hvrf;azmufvkyfxm;yHk
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 27/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 21
2005/ Ed k0ifbmv (YMEC) ESif h jrefrm v#yfppfpGrf;tif 0ef}uD;Xmewd k @ tifrd kifcjrpf0Srf;zG H @òz;r_ yl;aygif; aqmif&Gufa&;twGuf em;vnfr_pmc|efv$mw&yfud kulrif;òr@wGif vufrSwfa&;xd k; cJ honf?
2006/ =o*kwf-pufwifbmv ajryHka&;qGJjcif;vkyfief;ud k txl;ðyvkyfud kifaom jrefrmEdkifiHrS pef;
wufenf;ynm ukr%DvDrdwuf (Suntac Technologies Co. Ltd)
u wefz&J&Gm&S d bkef;}uD;ausmif; wausmif;wGif &H k;pd kufv#uf qnfaqmufrnf hae&mud k wd kif;wmcJ honf? wd kif;wma&;vkyfief;rSm toH k;ðyrnf hpuf,E W,m;rsm;ud k w&kwfjynfrS o,f,la&;udpP tqifajy
atmif aqmif&Gufa&;twGuf 0ga&Smif&GmwGifvnf; ,m,Dpcef;pd kufonf? pef;wufukr%Donf w&kwfukr%D (YMEC)ESif h yl;wG Jvkyfud kifonf?
2006/atmufwdkbmv qnfaqmufrnf hae&m (jrpfqH krS atmufbuf 3-rd kiftuGm) Y jref
rmEd kifiHrS at&Sa0gvfukr%Du pDrHcsufaqmif&Gufa&; pcef;wckwnfaqmufcJ honf? pcef;aqmufvkyf+yD;pD;onfESif h wòyifeuf w&kwfvlrsKd;ajrae&mppfaq;a&;ynm&Sifrsm;onf pcef;wGif 5-v=umr# aexd kifv#uf ajr ae&m ppfaq;onf?
2006/ 'DZifbmv v#yfppfpGrf;tm; trSwf(1)0ef}uD;XmeESifh w&kyfEdkifiH. t}uD;qHk;v#yfppf"gwftm; xkwfvkyfa&; tzG J @jzpfaom w&kyfEd kifiH v#yfppf"gwf
tm; &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_ aumfyd ka&;&Sif;(CPI)wd k @onf �arc-rvdc a&t&if;tjrpfzG H @òz;a&;qd kif&m {&m0wDjrpfqH k a&tm;v#yfppf pDrHcsuf�twGuf em;vnfr_pm c|efv$mw&yfud k vufrSwfa&;xd k;cJ honf? ToabmwlnDr_wGif jrpfqH kwGif 3�600 rD*g0yf pDrHcsufESif h tifrd kifcjrpfay:&S d csDaAGwGif 2�000 rD*g0yf pDrHcsufwd k @yg0ifonf? TvufrSwfa&;
xd k;onf h tcrf;tem;od k @ at&Sa0gvfukr%Dvnf; wufa&mufonf? ("gwfyH k&_)2007/ Zefe0g&DrSar w&kwfEd kifiHrS csef*sif;'DZd kif;Xme (Changjing Design Institute of
China)u vGefpufjzif h ajrwl;azmufjcif;/ a&avSmifuef ppfaq;jcif;ESif h ZvaA'wd kif;wmjcif;rsm; aqmif&Guf&eftwGuf 'DZd kif;a&;qG Ja&;tkyfpkrsm;apv$wfcJhonf?
2007/ {+yDv qnf (7) ckwnfaqmuf&mY v#yfppf"gwftm;ay;rnf h 65-rD*g0yf"gwftm;ay; puf&H kw&H kud k csDaAGacsmif;teD;wGif wnfaqmufa&;t
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 28/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 29/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 30/90
24 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
vuf0JzufrSaeI tpOftwd kif;? ? jrpfqH kteD; wd kif;xGm rSwfwrf;wifaeolwOD;? qifa*smifbGrf ESif h*a&mifbGrf t=um;/ qnfwnfaqmufrnf hae&mY qef;wuf wd kif;xGma&;ukr`%D. uGif;qif;refae*smwOD;u tvHpd kufaeyH k? 0g'lbGrf&S d wd kif;xGmrSwfwrf; jyKxm;aom tvHwck? vrf;ab;wGif &SdaeaomausmufrD;aoG; erlemrsm;?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 31/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 25
tusKd;pD;yG m;t& yg0ifywfoufae-uolrsm;
(etz) ppftpd k;&. tzGJ@tpnf;rsm;v#yf ppf pGrf ;tm; 0ef }uD ;Xme (MOEP)
v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;Xmeudk 0ef}uD;Xme (2) ck cGJI zGJ @pnf;xm;ygonf? trSwf (1) v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;Xmeonf v#yfppf"gwftm; xkwfvkyfa&;twGuf wm0ef&Sd+yD;/trSwf(2)v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;Xmeu v#yfppf"gwftm;jzef @jzL;ay;a&;twGuf wm0ef,l&ygonf? xd k @tjyif T0ef
}uD;Xmeonf (2002) ckESpf/ azaz:0g&DvwGif a&tm;v#yfppfOD;pD;Xme ( Department of Hydroelecric Power--
DOHP) ud k zG J @pnf;cJ hygonf? TXmeonf tem*wfv#yfppf"gwftm; vdktyfcsufudk jznf hqnf;ay;Edkifa&; twGufa&tm;v#yfppfxkwf vkyfief;rsm; pDrHcsufa&;qG J&efESif h taumiftxnfaz:&ef
wm0ef&S donf?24
T0ef}uD;Xmevufatmuf &S d Ed kifiHyd kif pD;yGm;a&;vkyfief; Xmersm;onfv#yfppf"gwftm; xkwfvkyfjcif;/ yd k @v$wfay;jcif; ESif h jzef @jzL;ay;jcif;wd k @ud k wm0ef,laqmif&Guf&onf htjyif Tvkyfief;rsm;twGuf Ed kifiH jcm;&if;ES D;jr�KyfES Holrsm;ESif h zufpyfvkyfief;rsm;wnfaxmifEd kifygonf? tifrd kifcESif h rvdcjrpfrsm;ay:&S d wnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm;twGufem;vnfr_pmc|efv$mrsm; vufrSwfa&;xd k;cJ holrSm trSwf(1) v#yfppfpGrf;tm; 0ef}uD;Xmejzpfonf? Ad kvfrSL;}uD;aZmfrif;onf (2006) ckESpf/ arvwGif trSwf (1) v#yfppf pGrf;tm;0ef}uD;Xme. 0ef}uD;jzpfvmcJhonf?
ajrmufydkif;wdkif; ppfXmecsKyfajrmufyd kif;wd kif;ppfXmecsKyf wd kif;rSL;onf ucsifjynfe,fESif h ppfud kif;wd kif; wpdwfwyd kif;wGif ppfqifa&; wm0ef,l&ygonf? jrefrmEd kifiHwGif
vuf&S d ppfXmecsKyf (13) ck&S dI wd kif;rSL; (13) OD; &S dygonf? olwd k @onfEd kifiHawmf +idrf;csrf;a&;ESif h zG H @ òz;a&;aumifpD tzGJ@0ifrsm;vnf;jzpfygonf? �olwd k @&J @ =oZmt&S deftm%m uawmh &efukefrSm &S dwJ hzG J @pnf;yH kuvG J&if/ wEd kifiHvH k;qd kif&m rl0g' csrSwfwJ h udpPawGud k ausmfvGef =oZmra&mufEd kif=ubl;? 'gayr,f h olwd k @xd kif&wJ h ppfwd kif;awGrSm
awmhææ wd kif;rSL;awGu =oZmt&S dqH k;yJ? pD;yGm;a&;vkyfief; uefx&d kufpmcsKyfudpPawG/ t&if;tjrpf xkwf,la&;vkyfief;awG/ td k;tdrfjcHajrwnf aqmufa&;vkyfief;awG/ ausmif;/ aps;eJ@ vrf;-wHwm; wnfaqmufa&; vkyfief;awG tm;vHk;rSm
0ef}uD; Ad kvfrSL;}uD;aZmfrif;
ajrmufyd kif;wd kif;ppfXmecsKyfwd kif;rSL;Ad kvfcsKyf tkef;jrif h
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 32/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 33/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 27
w&kwfEd kifiH awmifyd kif; v#yfppf"gwftm;uGef&uf (China Southern Power Grid)
(2007) ckESpf/ arv(21)&ufae@wGif (CPI)onf �tifrd kifc/ rvdcESif h {&m0wDjrpf0Srf;rsm;&S da&tm;v#yfppf pDrHcsufrsm; yl;wG Jtaumiftxnfaz:a&;ESif h ywfoufI yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufa&; oabmwlnDcsuf w&yfudk w&kwfEdkifiH awmifydkif;v#yfppf"gwftm;uGef&ufaumfyd ka&;&Sif; (China Southern Power Grid Corporation)ESif h vufrSwfa&;xd k;cJ hygonf?Tod k @jzif h TpDrHcsufrsm;wGif �ukr%DESpfckonf r[mAsL[majrmuf vkyfief;vkyfzufrsm;
jzpfvmcJha=umif; tcsufjyvdkufjcif;yif jzpfygonf?28
w&kwfEd kifiH awmifyd kif;v#yfppf"gwftm;uGef&uf (CSG) onf/ w&kwfjynf. awmifyd kif;
jynfe,f (5) ckrS aumfyd ka&;&Sif;rsm;ud k aygif;pkv#uf (2000)ckESpf/ 'DZifbmvwGif wnfaxmifcJ haom tpd k;&yd kifukr%Dwckjzpfygonf? vuf&S dtm;jzif h Tukr%Donf urBmt}uD;qH k;vkyfief;}uD; (500) pm&if; (Fortune 500 Global List) wGif (266) tqif h &S daeygonf?(CSG)onf w&kwfEd kifiH. awmifyd kif; v#yfppf"gwftm; uGef&ufESif h ywfoufaom &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_/ wnfaqmufr_ESif h pDrHtkyfcsKyfr_wd k @ud komru v#yfppf"gwftm; yd k @v$wfjcif;/ jzef @a0
jcif;rsm;ud kyg wm0ef,l&onf? �onf r[mrJacgifa'o v#yfppf"gwftm; aumfyd ka&;&Sif;wGif Ed kifiHawmfaumifpDu cef @tyfwm0efay;xm;onf h tvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0ifvnf;jzpfonf htjyif r[mrJacgifa'o v#yfppf"gwftm;aumfyd ka&;&Sif;. vkyfief;ud k wufwuf
ºuºu wGef;aqmfay;v#uf&S donf?29
&if;ESD;jr�KyfESHolrsm;w&kwfEdkifiH v#yfppf"gwftm; &if;ESD;jr�KyfESHr_aumfyd ka&;&Sif; (CPI)onf �. Ed kifiH&yfjcm;&if;ESD;jr�KyfESHr_wGif b¾maiGaxmufyHhjcif;/ñuH&Ed kifaom ar#mfvif hrxm;onf h tE W&m,fqHk;&_H;r_rsm;udk pDrHtkyfcsKyfjcif;wdk@ESifh ywf
oufI b%f}uD;rsm;ESifh aumfydka&;&Sif;trsm;udk oGm;a&mufawG@qHk+yD; t}uHOm%frsm;awmif;cHcJ hygonf? Tod k @aom aqG;aEG;wdkifyifcH tzGJ@tpnf;rsm;wGif w&kwfEdkifiH
yd k @ukef-oGif;ukef b%f (China Exim Bank)/ w&kwfEd kifiH yd k @ukef tmrcH aumfyd ka&;&Sif;(China Export Credit Insurance Corporation)
/ w&kwfEd kifiH pufr_ESif h ul;oef;a&mif;0,fa&;b%f (Industrial and Commercial Bank of China)/ w&kwfEd kifiH aqmufvkyfa&;b%f (The Construction Bank of China)/ umvf,Gef aumfyd ka&;&Sif;ESif h &if;ES D;jr�yfES Hr_
P h ot o: CP I
ub l i c a t i on
w&kwfEd kifiH v#yfppf"gwftm; &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_ aumfyd ka&;&Sif; (CPI) u 2007 ckESpf/ rwfvwGif usif;yaomjynfy&Sd a&tm;v#yfppfpDrHcsufrsm;Y &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_zdwfac:a&;aqG;aEG;yGJwck
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 34/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 35/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 36/90
30 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
avmavmq,fY avmfppf[efonf ukr%D. OuUXjzpfonf? ol.om; jzpfol xGef;jrif hEd kif(ac:) pwDAifavmonf refae*sif;'g&dkufwmjzpfonf? pwDAifavmonf bdef;ukeful;&mrSmyg0ifywfoufonf[k ouFmruif; jzpfcH&r_a=umif h/ (1996) ckESpfwGif tar&duefjynfaxmifpkod k @ oGm;a&muf&ef ADZmydwfyifcHcJ h&onf? Tod k @emrnfysufr_a=umif h at&Sa0gvfukr`%Dtaejzifh jrefrmEdkifiHtwGif; aqmif&Gufaeaom pD;yGm;a&;vkyfief;rsm;xdcd kufepfemr_r&S donf htjyif/ vuf&Sd tm%m&Sif tpd k;&atmufwGif rñuHpzl;atmifjrifr_rsm;&aeonf?
(1995) ckESpfwGif pwDAifavmu/ vkyfaz:ud kifzufwOD; jzpfol puFmylEd kifiHol pDpDvD,m
iuf (Cecilia Ng)ESif h vufxyfcJ honf? jrefrmEd kifiH&S d puFmyl &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hr_rsm;. w0ufausmfausmfonf at&Sa0gvf. tpkpyfyg0ifr_jzif h 0ifa&mufcJ honf[k cef @rSef;&onf? pwDAifavmonf puFmylvkyfief;&Sifrsm; tod kif;t0d kif;xJwGif v_yf&Sm;aeqJ&S dae+yD;/ ol @zcif.yifv,f&yfjcm;&S d vkyfief;rsm;ud k at&Sa0gvf. yifv,f&yfjcm;&S d ukr%DcG Jrsm;jzif h pDrHtkyfcsKyf
ay;v#uf&S donf? 34
jrpfqH kpDrHcsufwGif at&Sa0gvf ukr%D. wdusaom tcef;u¾udkxkwfaz:a=ujimxm;cJhjcif;r&Sdacs?od k @&mwGif olwd k @. vkyfaqmifcsufrsm;wGif jrefrmAdkvfcsKyfrsm;ESif hw
&kwf ukr`%Dwdk@t=um;tquftoG,fvkyfay;jcif;/ vrf;azgufvkyfjcif;ESif hypPnf;u&d,mrsm;axmufyHhjcif;wd k@yg0ifvdrfhrnf[k ucsifzG H@òzd;wk d;wufa&;uGef&uftzG J @(KD NG)u
,lqonf? at&Sa0gvfonf a& avSmifuef}uD; a&rjznf hrD umvwGifyif opfuJ hod k @aomt&if;tjrpfrsm;xkwf,l jci f ; r SaeI tusK d ;tjrwf&Ed ki fz G,f& S daeygonf?a&rv$rf;rDwGifowWKESif h tjcm;ausmuf jruf&wemrsm; wl;az:&eftwGuf a&avSmifuefwnfaqmufrnfh ae&mrsm;wGif prf;oyf ppfaq;r_rsm; vkyfaeonf[k ,lq&a=umif;a'ocH&Gmom;rsm;u ajymjycJ hygonf? at&S a0gvfonf opfvkyfief; cGif h ðycsuftrsm;tjym; &xm;+yD;jzpf&m/ a&rv$rf;rDwGifyif a& avSmifuef wnfaqmufrnf hae&mod k @0ifa&mufopfckwfEdkifzG,f&Sdaeygonf?
P h
qnfwnfaqmufrnfhae&m&Sd at&Sa0gvf ukr`%Dtajcpdkufpcef;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 37/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 38/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 39/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 33
tyd kif; (3)? {&m0wDjrpfqH kqnfa-umif h jzpfvmEd kifaom &d kufcwfr+ qd k;usKd;rsm;
qnftxufyd kif; ? ? a&zH k;v$rf;jcif;ESif h t"rRa&$ @ajymif;&r_rsm;qnf wnfaqmuf+yD;onfESif h a&avSmifueftwGif;od k@ a&jznf hoGif;onfESif h wòyifeufa&avSmifuef}uD;. tjrif hqH k; a&csdefrSwfxuf edrf haomae&mrsm;rS vlxkrSefor#wd k @ ajymif ;a&$ @ay;=u&ayawmhrnf? olwd k @. td k;tdrfrsm;/ pd kufysKd;ajr,mrsm;/ bd k;bGm;yd kif ajrae&mrsm;ESif h txGÉftjrwfxm;&m ae&mrsm;vnf; a&atmufod k @ a&muf&S d jrKyfuG,foGm;ayawmhrnf? olwd k @. toufarG;0rf;ausmif; vkyfief;rsm;ESif h olwd k @. b0"avhvkyf&d k;vkyfpOfrsm;vnf; qHk;±H_;=u&ayawmhrnf? jrpfqHkw0dkufwGif aexkdif=uolrsm;. jrpfurf;yg;
wav#muf O,smOf pdkufysKd;=uaom vkyfief;rsm;/ v,f,m/ opfr[kwfaom tjcm;opfawmxGufypPnf;rsm; &SmazGa&mif;csjcif;/ ti,fpm; a&$wl;azmfjcif;/ ponf hvkyfief;rsm;vnf; ysufpD; qH k;&_ H;=u&awmhrnf jzpfonf? tpOftvmtm;jzif h &SdcJ haom urBmvSnf hc&D;oGm; vkyfief;rsm;uJ hod k @aom a'oqd kif&m toufarG;0rf;ausmif; vkyfief;rsm; tm;vH k;vnf; qH k;&_ H;&ayawmhrnfjzpfonf?
{&m0wD jrpf qk Hqnf a&pGrf ;tm; buf pH ktoH k;csa&;pDrHcsuf (Irrawaddy
Myitsone Dam Multipurpose
Water Utilizing Project) t& a&avSmifuef}uD;. tjrifhqHk;a&csdeft
rSwfonf (290)rDwm &S dvdrf hrnfonf?emqm§tJef*sDatat jzwfoef;oGm;onf h ò*[fwkrS &d kuful;aom "gwfyH kt& ( NASA/ NGAA Suttle Radar
Topography) 90rDwm 'pf*spfw,fyH k
wGufqr_ yH kp H(90 meter Digital
Elevation Model) tcsuftvufrsm;. uGefwdkrsOf;rsm;udk tajccHv#uf ucsifzGH@òzd;wkd;wufa&;uGef&uftzGJ@ (KDNG) uajrjyifnDrsOf; (290) rDwmatmuf edrfhaeaom a&v$rf;ZHkajryHk wckudk wGufcsufazmfxkwfEdkifcJhygonf?
TpDrHcsuf. a&v$rf;cH&rnf h a'otus,ft0ef;rSm 766 pwk&ef; uDvd krDwm&S d+yD;/ t=urf;zsif;tm;jzif h? aus;&Gmaygif; 47 &Gmud k vH k;0a&zH k;v$rf;oGm;rnfjzpf+yD;/ vlOD;a&cef @rSef;acstm;jzif h 10�000 r# td k;tdrfrJ hjzpfum a&$ @ajymif;=u&rnfjzpfygonf? (Z,m;ud k=unf hyg?)
�uef qd kif ;ukr%D &J @rSwf wrf ;t&qd k&if {&m0wD jrpf qH kqnf aqmuf vd kuf wmeJ @ wef z&J&Gmawmha&ðryf oGm;rSmyJ? usaemf wd k @&Gm aysmuf oGm;rSmud kusaemf wd k @awmf awmf pd wf raumif ; jzpf =uw,f ? pd k;vnf ; pd k;&d rf w,f ? bma=umif hvJqd kawmh 'D ae &m[m usaemfwdk@&J@ordkif;qdkvnf;[kwfw,f? vrf;yef ;quf oG,f a&;vnf ;[kwf w,f ? wefzd k; xm;p&m obm0t&if;tjrpfqdkvnf; [kwf w,f ? tvGef ta&;}uD ;wJ h ae&myg? � (awG @qH kar;jref;jcif;/ trSwf- 15)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 40/90
34 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
vHk;0a&v$rf;cH&rnfh aus;&Gmrsm;tjyif tjcm;aus;&Gmtrsm;onfvnf; v,f,mjcHajrrsm; qHk;&_ H;&Edkifjcif;/ opfawmrsm; qH k;&_ H;&jcif;/ ul;oef;oGm;vma&;vrf;a=umif;rsm;a&jrKyfoGm;jcif;/ a&v$rf;cH&jcif;a=umif h ajymif;a&$@vmonfhvlxkrsm;0ifa&mufvmjcif;/ponfh tusKd;qufrsm;udkvnf; cHpm;=u&ygvdrfhrnf? txl;ojzifh jrpf}uD;em;rS qGrfy&mbGrf/ ylwm td ka'orsm;od k @oGm;aom um;vrf;r}uD; jywfawmufa&jrKyf oGm;rnfjzpf+yD;jrpf}uD;em;rS acsaAGod k @oGm;aom um;vrf;vnf; jywfawmufoGm;rnfjzpfonf? a&v$rf;cH&aomvrf;rsm;udk tpm;xdk;jyefvnfazmufvkyf rnfhtwGufa=umifhvnf; ZD0owWoabmt& axGjym;aom opfawmrsm;wGif xyfrHxdcd kuf& Ed kifaom tusKd;qufud kvnf;cHpm;=u&ygvdrfhrnf?
vlrsm; ae&yf&if;pGef@cGg ajymif;a&$@&jcif;ESifh �if;.aemufqufwG Jjy\emrsm;urBmh qnfrsm;aumfr&Sif (World Commission on Dams). cef @rSef;csuft& urBmw0Srf;vH k;wGif qnfrsm; aqmufvkyfr_a=umif h vlOD;a& oef;(40)rS (80) txd ae&yf&if;pGef@cG g ajymif;a&$@cJh=u&a=umif; azmfjyxm;ygonf? Todk@ajymif;a&$ @=u&r_a=umifh trsKd;
orD;rsm;ESif h Xmaewdkif;&if;om;vlrsKd;rsm;rSm txl;epfem cHpm;cJ h=u&ygonf? aumfr&Sif.azmfjycsuft& &kyfyd kif;qd kif&mt& ajymif;a&$ @tajccs=u&r_ESif h oufarG;0rf;ausmif;? aexdkifr_b0rsm; ajymif;a&$@=u&aoma=umifh �ajr,mrJhrsm; jzpf&jcif;/ tvkyfvufrJhrsm;jzpf&jcif;/ tdrfajc,mrJhrsm; jzpf&jcif;/ cGJjcm;zdESdyfcH&jcif;/ pm;a&&duQm rzlvHkjzpf&jcif;/aoE_ef;jrifhrsm;jcif;ESifh vltrsm;ydkif &if;jrpfrsm; qH k;&_H;&jcif;/ vlr_a&;ESifh ,Ofaus;r_t&jyefvnfxlaxmif Ed kifaomowW drsm; qH k;&_ H;&jcif;� wd k @ud kvnf; jzpfyGm;apygonf? zG J @pnf;
wnfaqmufxm;aom vlaer_ pepfòyuG J&jcif;ESif htwl pD;yGm;a&;t&pGrf;tm;rsm; ysufpD;qHk;&_H;&jcif;wdk@a=umifh �rsm;aomtm;jzifh jyefvnf ðyjyifI r&Edkifawmhavmufatmifvlaer_tqifhtwef; edrf hus&jcif;rsm;� udkvnf;jzpfapygonf?
{&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf wnfaqmufr_a=umif h ajymif;a&$ @vm&zG,f&S daom vlxkrsm;onf jrpf
}uD;em;òr@odk@ ajymif;a&$@tajccsvm=uzG,f&Sd+yD;/ tvkyftudkif&&Sda&;wGifvnf;aumif;/vlr_0efaqmifr_vkyfief;rsm; yH hyd k;ay;&mYvnf;aumif;/ zdpD;r_rsm; yd krd koufa&mufvmaprnfjzpfonf? tcsKd@aomolrsm;rSm awmeufrsm;xJY v,fajropfrsm; wDxGif=uzG,f&SdIobm0ywf0ef;usiftay:wGifvnf; zdpD;r_rsm; jzpfay:apygvdrf hrnf? tcsKd @aomolrsm;rSmtvkyftud kif&SmazG&ef a&$ wGif;a'orsm;od k @ ajymif;a&$ @tajccszG,f&S d+yD;/ xd ka'orsm;wGifvlr_a&;jy\emrsm;jzpfaom rl;,pfaq;0g;oHk;pGJr_/ udk,fcHtm;usa&m*g (tdyfcsftdkifADG)
yd k;ul;pufr_ESif h avmif;upm;r_rsm;ud k yd kqd k;apygvdrf hrnf? aemufqH k; ucsifjynfe,fwGif;rSjrpfqHkqnf wnfaqmufa&;pDrHcsufa=umifh a&$@ajymif;xGufcGgvm=urnfholrsm;onf
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 41/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 42/90
36 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
&d k;&m,H k=unfrIt& wd kif;&if;aq; opfOopfzkrsm;ud k oif hav#mfonf htcsdefwGif &SmazGpkaqmif;=u&onf? �yH krSef tm;jzif h usaemfwd k @u aq;jrpfawGud k Zefe0g&Dvuae {+yDvtwGif;rSm&Sm=uw,f? 'D&moDu aq;jrpfawGpkvd k @ taumif;qH k;&moDyJ? 'DtcsdefrSm awmxJ
u ewfaumif;ewfjrwfawGu aumif;csD;ay;=uvdk@ aq;aygif;cwJhtcsdefvd k@ ,lqw,f?usaemfwd k @u tud kif;tcufawGyJ ,lw,f/ opfyif yifpnfu tayG;ud k r,lbl;? usaemfwd k @u 'Daq;yif awGud k aemifrsKd;quftxd qufoH k;Ed kifzd k @ xdef;odrf;xm;=uw,f?� (awG @qH kar;jref;jcif;/ trSwf-10)
wdkif;&if;aq;0g;rsm;tjyif/ tcsK@daomtrsKd;orD;rsm;uvnf; opfr[kwfaom awmxGufypPnf;rsm;tay: rSDcd kI touf&Sifoef&yfwnfae=u&onf? rd_rsm;/ [if;&GufrsKd;pHk/awmxGuf opfoD;rsKd;pH kud k olwd k @u a&mif;csum 0ifaiG&Sm Ed kif=uonf? TypPnf;rsm;ud ka'oaps;/ òr@aps;rsm;wGif a&mif;csI olwd k @twGuf ta&;ygonf h qD? qm;ESif h rD;zd kacsmifoHk;ypPnf;rsm;udk jyef0,fEdkif=uonf? Tenf;tm;jzifh awmrsm;u aus;vufaevlxkrsm;twGuf b%fwckozG,f wefzdk;&S dvSonf? tu,fI jrpfqH kqnfwnfaqmufvd kufonf htcsdefwGif/ Tawmrsm;rSm a&atmufa&mufoGm;awmh rnfjzpf+yD;/ xH k;wrf;pOfvm
&Sifoefaexd kifEdkifonf h b0rsm;vnf; ysufpD;òyuG J=u&awmhrnf jzpfonf?
a*:eefaus;&Gm&S d &d k;&mwdkif;&if;aq;xkwfvkyfaeyH k? opfawmrsm;wGif ta&;ygvSonfh wd kif;&if;aq;tyif/ EG,fjrpfrsm;ºu,f0vS+yD; jrpfqHkqnfom wnfaqmufcJhygu Topfawmrsm;vnf; a&v$rf;cH=u&awmhrnf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 43/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 37
jrpfqH ka'o. obm0tvStyESif h ucsifvlrsKd;rsm;. ºu,f0vSaom ,Ofaus;r_a=umif h/xd ka'oodk @ vlrsm;pGmvma&mufvnfywfavh&S dygonf? od k@twGufa=umifh c&D;oGm;vkyfief;rSaeI a'ocHrsm; aiG0ifvrf;ajzmif h=uygonf? a'ocH tpm;taomufrsm;ESif h &d k;&m
vufr_ypPnf; a&mif;csolrsm;rSmvnf; jrpf}uD;em;ESif h txufbufa'orsm;od k @ tvnfvma&muf =uolrsm;xHrS ae@pOf0ifaiGud k rS Dcd kI &Sifoefaexd kif=u&ygonf? �aps;onftrsm;pkrSm trsKd;orD;rsm; jzpf=uygonf? tjcm;olrsm;rSmvnf; c&D;oGm;rsm;ud k avSjzif hvSnfhvnf =unfh&_&ef ydk@aqmifay;onfhtwGuf 0ifaiG&=uygonf? Todk@ c&D;onfydk@ay;olwOD;u jrpfqH k.tvSud k csD;rGrf;cef; zGif hygonf? �c&D;oGm;awG 'Dae&mud k trsm;}uD;
vm=uw,f/ olwd k @u taysmfc&D;twGuf avSpD;+yD; =unf hcsif=uw,f? usaemfu avSeJ @yd k @&&if rdepf (30)ud k usyfwpfaomif;,lw,f? =unf hprf;ygOD;-'DjrpfqH k ae&mu b,favmufvSovJqd kwm/ olwd k @bma=umif h vmcsif=uw,fqd kwm cifAsm;jrifomwmyJ?� (awG @qH kar;jref;jcif;/ trSwf-13)
jrpfqHk&Sd tvnftywfavSpD;&efESifh aps;a&mif;ae=uaomqdkifrsm;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 44/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 45/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 39
qnfwnfaqmufvd kufr_a=umif h jrpfnma'owGif ig;rsm;a&$ @ajymif; tajccsom;aygufr_ud kydwfyifvd kuf ouJ hod k @ jzpfoGm;aprnf jzpfonf? od k @twGufa=umif h a&umwmtwGif;ESif hjrpfatmufyd kif;a'orsm;wGif ig;ta&twGuf usqif;vmEd kifouJ hod k @/ ig;rsKd;pdwfrsm;vnf;av#mhenf;vmEd kifonf? �if;wd k @rSm jrpfqH kteD;awG @&aom ig;rsKd;rsm;jzpf+yD; aysmufuG,foGm;&ef ta=umif;&S daeayonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 46/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 47/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 41
,Ofaus;r_qdkif&m ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;apr_rsm;tu,fI qnfwnfaqmufygutcsKd @aom ,Ofaus;r_qd kif&mt& ta&;ygonfhae&mrsm;onf a&jrKyfqHk;&_ H;&awmhrnfjzpfonf? �ae&mrsm;wGif ord kif;0ifbk&m; ykxd k;rsm;ESif h c&pf,mefcsyfausmif;rsm;yg0if+yD;/ jrpfqHkae&m&S d wefcd k;}uD; a&$anmifyifonfvnf; a&jrKyfoGm;vdrfhrnfjzpfonf?
tcsKd @aomolrsm;u TanmifyifwGifewfaeonf[k,Hk=unf=u+yD;/ aumif;rItwGuf yoylaZmf=u&mae&mvnf;jzpfonf?qnfaqmufjcif;jzif h vlrsm;ud k &kyfyd kif; qd kif&mt& ae&majymif;a&$ @jcif; jzpfap&H kr#omru/�wd k@. ,Ofaus;r_rsm; qufvufxdef; odrf;wnfwH hEd kifa&;twGufvnf; xdcd kufapEdkifonf? TjrpfqHkae&monf ucsifvlrsKd;rsm;twGuf 0daooxl;ae&mwckjzpfouJhodk@/
ord kif;0ifae&mvnf; jzpfonf? tu,fI Tae&mom a&jrKyfoGm;ygu vltrsm;*k%f,lcJ h=u&aom/ yG Jvrf; rsm;aqmif&GufcJ h=u&aomae&monfvnf; aemifrsKd;qufrsm;pGmwd kifqHk;&_H;oGm;apawmhrnfjzpfonf?
�ucsifvlrsKd ;awG[m 'D pD rHcsufjyef&kyfod rf;ay;zd k @ (etz) ppftpd k;&eJ @ w&kwfukr%D awG/ jrefrmukr%D awGud k tcGif hta&; qd koif hw,f? 'D vd kawmif;qd kzd k @ wm0efvnf;&S d w,f? 'D vd krvkyfEd kif =uzl;qd kv#if jzif h {&mrord kif;aºu;wifawmhrSm aocsmw,f? bmjzpfvd k @vJqd kawmh
jrpfqH ka'oqd kwm ucsifvlrsKd ;awG&J @ ord kif;a=umif;/ *k%fod uQmeJ @ qufpyfaevd k @yJ jzpfw,f?� (awG @qH kar;jref;jcif;/ trSwf 30)
a&v$rf;cH&rnf h wefzJaus;&GmrS uufovpf bk&m;&S dcd k;ausmif;wck
a&jrKyfoGm;rnf h wefzJaus;&Gm&S d &d k;&m,Ofaus;r_ taqmuftODwck
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 48/90
42 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
ig;zrf;ol wHigtrsm;pku yd kufcsjcif;ud k 2 rsKd; toH k;jyKavh&S donf? avSay:rS yd kufar#mjcif;ESif h tjcm;wenf;rSm yd kufud k tao 24 em&D wae@vH k; axmifxm;+yD; wae@v#if 2-3 }udrf ppfaq;jcif;rsKd; jzpfonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 49/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 50/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 51/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 52/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 53/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 47
vH kðcHa&;twGuf ylyef&r_rsm;ucsifjynfe,f&S d vlxkrsm;onf qnfusKd;I 'kuQa&muf=u&yH kud k ud k,fawG @ tawG @tñuH&Sdxm;cJh=u+yD; jzpfygonf? jrpf}uD;em;òr@. ajrmufbuf 10 rdkif tuGmwGif&S daom}udrfc&rfa&umwmrSm (2006) ckESpf/ Zlvd kifvwGif &ufrsm;pGm rd k;onf;xefpGm &GmoGef;+yD;aemuf qnfusKd;aygufcJ hygonf? a&umwmusKd;aygufr_a=umif h }udrfc&rfaus;&Gmud k a&v$rf;cJ h+yD;/ vl 5-OD; aoqH k;cJh&ygonf? 0ga&Smifqnfonfvnf; 2006 ckESpf/ arvwGifusKd;aygufysufpD;cJ hygonf? od k @aomfvnf; Tqnf usKd;aygufonf h owif;rsm;ud k owif;rD'D,mrsm;wGif azmfjyjcif;r&S dbJ/ ppftpd k;&u owif;rxkwfjyef&ef wif;usyfpGmwm;jrpfxm;cJ hygonf? urBm. tqd k;&Gm;qH k; qnfusKd;aygufr_rSm w&kwfEd kifiH tv,fyd kif;&S d [Deef
c&d kifwGif 1975 ckESpfu jzpfyGm;cJ hygonf? T uyfab;'kuQ jzpfyGm;r_ESpfaygif; (20)ausmfausmfvGefvmaomtcgrS owif;tao;pdwfrsm; xGufay:vmcJ h&m/ vlaygif; (230�000)r# Tjzpf&yfa=umif h toufqH k;&_ H;cJ h&ygonf? 41
ajriv#ifrsm; tEW&m,f
xdk@tjyif iv#if}uD;rsm;. jyif;tm;/wnfae&mESif h xl;jcm;csufrsm;udkvdkufI iv#ifrsm;a=umif h qnfrsm;Ytufa=umif;rsm;udk jzpfay:apEdkif+yD;/wpfcgw&Hqnfòyus usKd;aygufonftxdjzpfapEdkifygonf? urBmvHk;qdkif
&m iv#ifa=umif hjzpfaom tE W&m,frsm; avhvmtuJjzwfa&; tpDtpOf(Global Seismic Hazard Assess-
ment Program). tcsuftvufrsm;t& jrefrmEd ki fi Honf iv#if
tE W&m,f jrifhaomtajctaerS tvGefw&mjrifhrm;pGm wnf&Sdaeaoma'otwGif;wGif usa&mufae+yD;/ajrmufyd kif; ucsifjynfe,fESif h ppfud kif;wdkif;twGif;wGif worwfwnf; jrif hrm;pGm &S daecJ hygonf?43 {&m0wD jrpfqH k
qnfonf jrefrmEdkifiHudk jzwfoGm;aom ,la&;&Sm;ajrjywfv$mESif h tdEN d,
ta&;ay: tajctaersm; [Deef uyfab;'kuQtjyif/ 1993 ckESpfwGif jzpfyGm;aomusif[dkifc&d kif (Qinghai province) &S d a*gif[l;qnf(Gouhou dam) usKd;aygufr_wGifvnf; vlaygif; (1�200)cef @ toufqH k;&_ H;cJ h&ygao;onf? xd ktcsdefrSpI w&kwfEd kifiH. a&t&if;tjrpfqd kif&m 0ef}uD;Xmeonf qnfrsm;vH kðcHr_qd kif&m vrf;!$efcsufrsm;ESif h pnf;rsOf;Oya'rsm; csrSwfvmcJ hygonf? txl;ojzif h 1998 ckESpfwGif jyXmef;aom a&}uD;r_xdef;csKyfjcif;qd kif&m Oya't& uef @owfxm;aom twd kif;twmwck. txuf&S donf h qnfwckcsif;pDtwGuf ta&;ay: jyifqifr_rsm; pDrHxm;&S d&efvd ktyfygonf? TtpDtpOfwGif ta&;ay:tajctaejzpf
ygu qufoG,f&rnfholrsm;pm&if;ESifh ta&;ay: pDrHaqmif&Guf&rnf h vkyfief;rsm;yg0ifygonf?42 jrpfqH k qnfpDrHcsuftwGuf tvm;wl ta&;ay: pDrHxm;csuf rsKd;ud kvlod&Sif=um; xkwfjyefa=ujimxm;jcif; r&Sdao;yg?od k @aomfvnf; jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; vkyfief;rsm;aqmif&Gufae=uaom w&kwfEdkifiHyd kif ukr`%Drsm;taejzifhvnf;/
w&kwfEd kifiH Oya'rsm;twd kif; vd kufemaqmif&Guf&ef jyXmef;xm;jcif; r&S dyg?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 54/90
48 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
ajrjywfv$mawG @qH k&m iv#iftuf a=umif;rS uDvd krDwm 100 atmuf av#mhenf;aoma'otwGif; usa&mufaeygonf? ppfa=umif; ajrv$mjywfa=umif;wGif wdkif;wmr_t&jyif;tm;tqif h (M 7.0- 8.0) tqifh&Sdaom iv#ifrsm;udkvnf; awG@ñuHcJh&zl;ygonf?xd k @tjyif qnf}uD;rsm;wnfaqmufr_a=umif hvnf; iv#ifrsm;jzpfyGm;ap&ef yd krd kwGef;tm;ay;ouJ hod k @ jzpfapEd kifygao;onf? qnfrsm;a=umif h iv#ifjzpfay:&r_rsm; (Reservoir-induced
Seismicity or RIS) ud kvnf; awG @&S dcJ h=u&+yD;/ tyd kwd k;vmaom a&zdtm;rsm;a=umif hqnfatmufajc&Sd ajrtufa=umif; i,frsm;wGif zdtm;ydkwdk;vmap jcif;jzpfay:&jcif;jzpfygonf?44
qnfwnfaqmufrnf h a'owGif aexd kif=uonf h vlxkrsm;twGuf vH kðcHa&;pDrHaqmif&Gufay;Ed kifr_ tpDtpOfrsm;rSm yGif h vif;jrifomr_ r&S donf h tm;av#mfpGm/ pd k;&drfylyefzG,f tajctaersm; jzpfvmapygonf? a'ocHjynfolwOD;u ajymonfrSm- �tu,f I w&kwf awGom qnf vmaqmuf r,f qdk&if awmh usaemf awmh vH k ðcHtE W&m,fuif ;vd rf hr,fvd k@rxif bl;? usaemf awmh jrpf }uD ;em;òr@rSm td rf 0,f zd k @ jyif xm;+yD ;+yD ? 'gayr,f h tckawmh rajymif ;
ao;bl;? bmjzpf rSef ; od wmr[kwf bl;?� (awG @qH kar;jref;cef; trSwf-29)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 55/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 56/90
50 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
�tJ'D rSmoGm;+yD ; tvkyf vkyf ay;=u&wJ holawGu/ olwd k @rd om;pk v,f awG jcHawGud krvkyf Ed kif =ubl;? tJonf awmh rd om;pkwckvH k;xd cd kuf &w,f ? usyf wnf ;=u&w,f ? vkyf tm;ay;oGm;=u&wJ h olwd kif ;uvnf ; ud k,f h&d uQm ud k,f yd kif ,loGm;=u&w,f ? tvum;vkyf tm;ay;=u&wJ htjyif ud k,f hypP nf ;u&d ,mawGvnf ; ud k,f ,loGm;=u &w,f ? tu,f I rd om;pkawGu vkyf tm;ay;r,f hol rv$wf Ed kif zl;qd k&if tJonf tpm; usyf (3�000) ay;=u&w,f ? tJonf tcsd ef u (3�000) usyf qd kwm od yf wef zd k;&S d w,f ? qef aps;eJ @ qD aq;u tckavmuf aps;r}uD ;=uao;bl;? a,muf sm; om;r&S dwJ h rkqd k;rtdrfawG/ td rf axmif pkawGu ud k,fwd kif tvkyf oGm;vkyf&if vkyf / r[kwf &if vnf ; yd kufqHtpm;ay;=u&w,f ?
ppfwyfu &GmtkyfpkwckrSm aumfrDwDwckzGJ@cdkif;+yD;awmh qnfwnfaqmufa&;t wGuf qd k +yD ;/ rd om;pkwckqD uae yd kuf qH (300) usyf aumuf cd kif ;w,f ? tJonf t csd ef u usaemf vnf ; 'D aumf rD wD xJrSm tzG J @0if tjzpf ygao;w,f ? usaemf u ppf wyf p cef ;xJrSm a'ocH jynf olawGud k b,f vd kpnf ;&H k;&r,f qd kwJ h oif wef ;awG/ rd om;pkawG
qDu yd kufqHaumufcHzdk@ twGuf oif wef;awGwuf&ao;w,f? wcsKd@vlawGu usaemhud k od yf a'goxGuf =uw,f ? a'ocHvlxkawGu qnf wnf aqmuf +yD ;wJ htcg v#yf ppf rD ;&r,f vd k @ xif xm;=uw,f ? wu,f awmh jzpf rvmbl;? wcg qnf usKd ; oGm;&jyef w,f ? qnf wnf aqmuf a&;eJ @ ywf ouf vd k @ a'ocHvlxkawGu tawmf pdwf ysuf =uw,f qd kwm usaemf ,Hk =unf w,f ?� (awG @qH kar;jref ;cef ; trSwf -25)
a'ocH c&pf,mefoif;tkyfq&mwOD;. tqd kt& qnfwnfaqmufa&;twGuf ajr&Sif;
vif;&mwGif opfyif}uD;rsm; ckwfvS J=u&mY &Gmom; 2-OD; aoqH k;cJ h&+yD;/ qnfwnfaqmufrnfhae&monf awmxlaoma=umifh &Gmom; 7-OD; iSufzsm;a&m*gjzifh toufqHk;&_H;&onf[k od&S d&ygonf? qnfwnfaqmufa&;umvwGif ta&twGuf rodEd kifaom aus;&Gmvlxkrsm;rSm zsm;emjcif;/ '%f&m&jcif;rsm; ñuHawG@cJh=u&ygonf? tvkyform;rsm;.usef;rma&;twGuf apmif ha&Smufay;r_ r&S donf htjyif ppftpd k;&xHrSvnf; zsm;em'%f&m&
ygu usef;rma&;apmif ha&Smufr_ r&&SdcJ h=uyg?
uwd ysuf jcif;? �}udrfc&rfqnfaqmufwkef;u usaemfwdk@ jyif;jyif;xefxefvkyftm;ay;cJh=u& w,f ? +yD ;vmawmh v#yf ppf rD ;vnf ;r&bl;? yxryd kif ;rSm tpd k;&u a'ocH jynf olawGud k pnf ;&Hk;wkef ;u qnf wnf aqmuf+yD ;wJ htcg &vmwJ hv#yf ppf ud k ausmif ;
awGtwGuf oH k;r,f ? +yD ;rS ppf wyf twGuf / +yD ;awmh csyf ausmif ; bk&m;&S d cd k;ausmif ; awGtwGuf oH k;r,f / pwkw�taeeJ @rS tpd k;&&H k;awGtwGuf eJ @ &yf &GmvlxkawGt
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 57/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 51
wGuf oH k;r,f / ajymcJ h =uw,f ? +yD ;awmh vrf ;rD ;awGvnf ; vif ;vmr,f ajymw,f ? aemuf qH k;awmh olwd k @ajymwJ htwd kif ; wckrS jzpf rvm=ubl;?� (awG @qH kar;jref;cef;trSwf-26)
qnfwnfaqmufr_ +yD;pD;aomtcg v#yfppfrD;ud k tvSnf huspepfjzif h axmufyH hay;ygonf?aus;&Gmrsm;rSm av;&ufrS w}udrfrD;&ygonf? od k @aomfvnf; (etz) ppftpd k;&. ppfwyfrsm;ESif h &H k;rsm;rSm tcsdefjynf hrD;&+yD;/ tcrJhv#yfppfrD;oH k; pG J&jcif;jzpfygonf? aus;&Gmom;wOD;u ajymjyonfrSm &Gmrsm;onf rdk;umvwGif v#yfppfrD;&aomfvnf;/ aEGtcgwGifv#yfppfrD; r&&S d[kqd kygonf? tjcm;&Gmom;wOD;u ajym&mwGif �aEG&moD a&muf vmwd kif ;
ausmif ;om;awGu qnf rSm tca=u;aiGr&bJ vkyf tm;ay;=u&w,f ? aemuf qH k; v#yf ppf rD ;&vmwJ htcgvnf ;usa&m/ olwd k @ bmtusKd ;tjrwf rS rcHpm;=u&bl;? ausmif ;pmzwf zd k @/ td rf pmvkyf zd k @ za,mif ;wd kif rD ;ud kyJquf tm;ud k;ae=u&w,f ?� (awG @qH kar;jref;cef; trSwf-27)
qnfusKd ;aygufjcif;? (2006) ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv eHeuf (2;00)em&DtcsdefwGif &ufowWywf 5 ywf=um rd k;onf;xefpGm &GmoGef;vm+yD;aemuf qnfusKd;aygufygawmhonf?t&S deft[kefjyif;pGmjzif h xd k;qif;vmaom a&vH k;u teD;&S d a&tm;v#yfppf puf&H kwckvH k;ud kwd kufpm;xd k;csoGm;cJ honf? TtwGufa=umif h vl 5-OD; toufqH k;&_ H;cJ h&onf? }udrfc&rfc aus;&GmESif h jrpf}uD;em;òr@udk qufoG,faomt"du wHwm;rSmvnf; a&pD;jzif h
arsmygoGm;cJ honf? od k @aomfvnf; xl;qef;pGmyif aus;&Gmaevlxkrsm;teufrS rnfolwOD;wa,mufr# toufqHk;&_H;jcif; r&SdcJhyg? a&tm;a=umifh awmifESpfvHk;=um;wGif&Sdaomae&mwckvHk;udk a&wdkufpm;xdk;cs oGm;aoma=umifh a&tm;v#yfppfpuf&Hkudk jzpfap/qnfud kjzpfap jyefvnfðyjyif wnfaqmufEd kifjcif; r&S dawmhyg? 45
a'ocHjynfolwOD;. ajymjycsuft& a&wd kufpm;r_wGif tdrf 5 vH k;arsmygoGm;cJ hygonf?tjcm;tdrfrsm;rSmvnf; txl;qd k;&Gm;pGm ysufpD;cJ h&+yD; jyefvnfwnfaqmuf=u&ygonf?tdrfyd kif&Sifrsm;u olwk d @tdrfrsm;ud k jyefvnfðyjyif&ef rwwfEd kifaoma=umif h usef&Gmom;rsm;u 0dkif;0ef;ulnD=u&ygonf? �&dkrefuufovpf bk&m;ausmif;/ ucsif bufywpfbk&m;ausmif;/ &yf&Gm tzG J @awGeJ@ woD;yk*~v pD;yGm;a&;vkyfief;&SifawGu usaemfwdk @ud kvmul=uw,f? t&ifu wcgrS 'Dvd krsKd; a&}uD;wm rñuHcJ h&zl;bl;? 'Dwcg ñuH&wm usaemf
wdk@twGuf odyfcufcJygw,f?�[k &Gmom;wOD;u ajymjyygonf? (awG@qHkar;jref;cef;trSwf- 22)
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 58/90
52 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
aemufxyfysufpD;qHk;&_H ;&aom zGH @òz;a&;pD rHcsufwcka'oqd kif&m zG H @òz;a&;vkyfief;rsm;rSm rnfr#atmifjrifa=umif; (etz) ppftpd k;&u tjrJwrf;0g'jzef@ ºum;0gavh&Sdygonf? od k@aomfvnf; vufawG@wGif a'ocHjynfolvlxkrsm;twGuf tusKd;jzpfxGef;apr_ r&Sd=uyg? }udrfc&rfqnfonf �zGH@òz;a&; pDrHcsufrsm; ratmifjrif&yHk. Oyrmaumif;wck jzpfygonf? jynfolvlxkrsm;rSm [email protected];ESifhtcsdefud k tv[\qH k;&_ H;cJ h=u&+yD;/ olwd k @. b0ud kvnf; aemufqH k;wGif xdcd kufepfemapcJ hygonf? xdk@tjyif TpDrHcsufrsm;rS xGufay:vmaom v#yfppfrD;udkvnf; cHpm;EdkifcGifhr&S dcJ h=uyg?
a&v$rf;rdk;r_'%fñuHI epfem&zG,f&Sdjcif;? urBmay:&S d qnf}uD;rsm;. tusKd;tjypf oufa&mufEd kifr_ twd kif;twmud k us,fus,fjyef @jyef @avhvmcJ h=u+yD;aemuf urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&maumfr&Sifu qnfrsm;a=umif h jynfolvlxkrsm;wGif a&v$rf;rd k;r_'%f yd kIñuH&zG,f&S donfud k awG@&S dcJ h=uygonf? a&wmwrHrsm;onf a&v$rf;rd k;r_'%f ti,fpm;tcsKd @ud k umuG,fay;Ed kifaomfvnf;/ a&v$rf;rd k;r_ }uD;rm;
pGmjzpfay:vmygu qnfrsm;a=umif h ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;&r_ yd kI}uD;rm;apEd kifygonf? a&v$rf;rd k;r_}uD;rm;pGm jzpfay:vmygu qnfrsm;u xd ka&vH k;rsm;ud k xdef;odrf;xm;Ed kifpGrf; r&S d=uawmhyg? a&v#H+yD;aemuf yd kIqd k;&Gm;jyif;xefaom a&v$rf;rd k;r_rsm;jzpfay:apygonf? jrpfqH kqnfwnfaqmuf&mwGifvnf; TudpPonf pdk;&drfzG,ftcsufjzpfygonf? ta=umif;rSm Tae&monf jrpf}uD;em;òr@txufzuf uDvd krDwm (40) cef @ tuGmta0;wGifom wnf&S daeaoma=umifhjzpfygonf? r=umao;rDESpfrsm;twGif; xdka'ow0dkufwGif a&v$rf;rdk;r_
tE W&m,fu wESpfwjcm; yd kIqd k;&Gm;jyif;xefvmaecJ hygonf? ta=umif;rSm Ta'ow0d kufwGif a&$wl;azmfae=uaoma=umif h jrpfurf;yg;rsm;ud k ysufpD;ap+yD;/ a&a=umif; ajymif;vJaponf htjyif/ a&}uD;r_ud k obm0t& wm;qD;Ed kifaom opfawmrsm;vnf; ðyef;wD;vmaeaoma=umif h jzpfygonf? (2004) ckESpf/ Zlvd kifvwGif jrpf}uD;em;òr@a&v$rf;cJ h+yD;/ vlaygif;(19�000) ausmf a&v$rf;r_'%fcHcJ h=u&ygonf? a'o&S d &yf&GmtzG J @tpnf;rsm;ESif h bk&m;&S dcd k;
ausmif;rsm;/ bmoma&;toif;rsm;u zsm;emolrsm;ESif h tdk;tdrfrJh jzpf&olrsm;ud k ulnDu,fq,fay;a&;twGuf &kef;uefóu;yrf;cJ h=u&ygonf?46
&kwfw&ufa&wufvmonfESif h ñuH &Ed kif jcif;? a&umwmrS a&v#Husonfjzpfap/ qnfusKd;aygufonfjzpfap &kwfw&ufa&v$rf;r_jzpfapEdkifygonf? xdkodk@ r[kwfygbJ vnf; a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfaom puf&Hkrsm;wGif
cs defcgr[kwfbJ &kwfw&uf wmwrHrS a&pGef@xkwfonfh tjzpfrsK d;&S dEd ki fyg onf?jrpftxufyd kif;&S d qnfud k pDrHtkyfcsKyfaeolu v#yfppf"gwftm;ay;puf vd ktyfr_a&yrm%
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 59/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 53
tajctaeud kvd kufI a&pGe f @xkwf&ef qH k ; jzwfcsufcsygonf? (Tod k @a&pGef @xkwf&efqH k;jzwfcsufcsolrsm;rSm jrpftxufyd kif; w&kwfEd kifiH&S d tm%myd kifrsm;vnf;jzpfEd kifygonf?) a&pGef @xkwfvd kufonf htcg a&tjrif h csufcsif;wufvm+yD;/ jrpfta=uyd kif;&S dvlxk rsm;rSm óuwifowday;r_ r&SdbJ a&tE W&m,fESif h ñuH&Edkifygonf? vltrsm;tzdk@�wd k @.avSrsm;/ ig;zrf;u&d,m rsm; qH k;&_ H;=u&+yD;/ &kwfw&uf a&jrif hwufvmr_a=umif htcsKd @rSm a&epfaoqH k;=u&ygonf?47
rSwfom;zG,f&m qnfrsm;a=umifhjzpfaom a&v$rf;rd k;r_rsm;tDwvD/ 1963 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbmv? ? urBmhtjrif hqH k;qnf}uD;wckjzpfonf h
Ad kiftGef @a&avSmifwrH (Vaiont Dam) onf wnfaqmuf+yD;pD;I a&pwifjznf honfESif h wòyifeuf iv#ifrsm;v_yfvmapygonf? ajrwkefv_yfr_a=umif h a&avSmifwrHtwGif;odk@ ajrom;òyusr_rsm; jzpfay:vmap+yD;/ ajròyr_a=umifh vd _if;vHk;}uD;rsm;jzpfay:vm+yD; qnfwrH tay: rDwm 200 ausmfjrif haom vd _if;vH k;rsm; v$rf;rd k;cJ honf? ESpfrdcef @t=umwGif avmif*g&H k;òr@ (Longarone) vnf; wòr@vH k; a&v$rf;rd k;cH
&+yD; vlaygif; 2�000 ausmfr# toufqH k;&_ H;cJ h&onf?
ygupPwef/ 1992 ckESpf/ pufwifbmv? ? ref*vmqnf (Mangla Dam) .a&xdef;armif;ESifolrsm;u óuwifowday;jcif; r&SdbJ a&v$JwHcg;aygufrsm;udkzGif hcscJ honf? rsufjrifoufaorsm;. tajymt& a&tjrif heH&H 7 rDwmr# jrif haoma&eH&H}uD;u &GmESifhqnfteD;&Sd ppfwyfpcef;qDod k@òyqif;vmcJ h+yD;/ vl 500ausmf
toufqHk;&_H;apcJhonf?
uae'g/ 1996 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv? ? uG D;bufa'o/ qef*lae;jrpf0Srf;vGifjyifwGifa&v$rf;rd k;r_a=umif h vl 7 OD; toufqH k;&_ H;cJ h&+yD;/ vlaygif; (16�000) cef @ud k u,fq,fae&mcsxm;&aom tajctae jzpfay:apcJ honf? uae'g a':vm (1 '\r
5) bDvD,Hr# ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;cJ h&aom a&v$rf;rd k;r_onf uae'gEd kifiH ord kif;wGift}uD;us,fqH k;aom jzpf&yfjzpfonf? tpd k;&u zG J @pnf;ay;onf h aumfr&Sif. avhvmawG @&Sdcsuft& ravsmfuefaom pDpOfaqmif&Gufcsufrsm;ESifh qnfwmwrHrsm; usKd;aygufcJ hr_a=umif h a&v$rf;rd k;r_ud k yd krd kqd k;&Gm;apcJ honf[k azmfjycJ honf?
Ed kuf*sD;&D;,m;/ 1999 ckESpf/ pufwifbm§atmufwd kbmv? ? udef*sD/*sufbm/ &Sd&d&d kqnfrsm;. a&xdef;pDrHcef @cGJolrsm;u a&wHcg;rsm;udk zGifhvd kuf=uaoma=umif h Ed kif*gESif h um'kemjrpf0Srf;a'orsm;wGif qd k;&Gm;jyif;xefonf h a&v$rf;rd k;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 60/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 61/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 55
ck ({&m0wD/ rJacgif/ oHvGif/ausmufz&mESifh jrpfeDjrpfrsm;)wGi fwpif;tygt0if jzp fygonf? us,fjyef@vSaoma&pD;qif;&mvrf;a=umif; wav#muf&Sd obm0a*[aA'pepfudk xdef;odrf;xm;&efonfta&;}uD;vS+yD;/ jrpfa=umif;twGif;&S d xl;jcm;wefzd k;&S donf h a&
nd �a&arSm frsm;ESi f h taumifi,frsm;ESif h Tjrpfa=umif;ud k rS Dcdk&Sifoefae=u&aom jynfolvlxkrsm;twGufvnf; toufaoG;a=umozG,fyifjzpfyg
onf?
50
qnf}uD;rsm;wnfaqmufvdkufjcif;jzif h Ttajctaeud k qef @usifI qd k;usKd;rsm; jzpfay:apygonf? jrpfa=umif;&S d obm0a*[pepf wnfwH haer_ud k rxdef;odrf;Ed kifawmhyJ/ jrpfa=umif;. a*[pepfud k òyuG Japygonf? qnfujcm;xm;vd kufaom jrpf.txufESif hatmuf ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm;ud k oD;oef @yd kif;
jcm;onfhES,f&Sdap+yD;/ rsKd;&dk;ADZ xdef;odrf; &Sifoefr_pepfudk jzpfapaom ZD0owW0grsm;a&$ @ajymif;oGm;vmr_ud k yd kif;jcm;jzwf awmufonf hES,f jzpfapygonf? xd k @tjyif ,cifua&v$rf;EH k;wifaomvGifjyifrsm;ESif h jrpf a&ud kvnf; xdawG @r_uif;rJ hvmapygonf? qnfrSpGef @xkwfvd kufaoma&rsmwGif te,f tESpfyg0ifr_enf;+yD;/ "gwkoabmt&vnf;ajymif;vJr_rsm;jrpfa&wGifjzpfvmapygonf?51
ucsifjynfe,fonf ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm; axGjym;pGmwnf&S daeaom ae&m 2-ckjzpfonf h tdEN d,-jrefrma'oESif h awmif w&kwf tv,fyd kif;a'o=um; txl;tav;xm;&rnf hae&mwGifwnf&Sdae+yD;/ urBmay:wGif tav;xm;xdef;odrf;&rnf h obm0a*[pepft& ta&;ygaom a'owck jzpfygonf? Ta'oESpfckwGif toD;oD;Y &Sm;yg;aom ZD0owW rsKd;uG Jaygif;tenf;qH k; (1�500) cef@pD&S dae=u+yD;/ �a'owGif aexd kifcJ haom rlvrsKd;uG Jaygif;(70)µ
r# qHk;&_H;aysmuf uG,fcJh&+yD jzpfygonf?52 tdENd,-jrefrm ZD0owWpepft& ta&;}uD;
�qnfrsm;onf ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm; axGjym;wnf&S dr_tay: wpH kw&mtusKd;oufa&mufr_&S dapEd kifaom tajccHtaqmuftODwnfaqmufr_vkyfief;rsKd;jzpfygonf? qnfrsm;wnfaqmufr_a=umif h jrpftxufyd kif;&S d jrpfa=umif;wav#mufa'orsm;ud k a&v$rf;rd k;Ed kif+yD;/ &moDtvd kuf a&pD;qif;aer_/jrpfatmufyd kif;&S d te,fusr_jzpfpOfud kvnf; ajymif;vJapEd kifygonf? xd k @tjyif qnfrsm;wnfaqmufr_a=umif h ig;rsm;a&$ @ajymif;aexd kifr_ vrf;a=umif;rsm;ud k [ef @wm;r_jzpfap+yD;/om;ayguf&ma'orsm;od k @ a&$ @ajymif;r_ud k xdcd kufapygonf?æqnfwnfaqmufr_onf ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm; axGjym;pGmwnf&S daexd kifr_ud kvnf; wd kuf&d kuftusKd;oufa&mufr_ &S dapygonf?Oyrmtm;jzif h vlrsm;ajymif;a&$ @r_ jzpfap+yD;/ xd kod k @ajymif;a&$ @tajccs&jcif;a=umif h obm0t&if;tjrpfrsm;tay:xyfIzdpD;r_rsm; jzpfay:apygonf?�48
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 62/90
56 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
a'orSm ta&;}uD;a'o (8) ckteuf/ wcktjzpf owfrSwfxm;cJh+yD; ZD0&kuQ rsKd;EG,f(7�000) ausmf wnf&S daeaom a'ojzpfygonf?
Tod k @ urBm}uD;. a*[aA'pepft& ta&;ygaoma'orsm;tjzpf owfrSwfcHxm;&onf htjyif/ rvdcESifh tifrdkifcjrpf a&wHcGefwdk@ awG@qHk&m jrpfqHka'oonf rDZdk&rf-r%dyl-ucsifrkwfokefopfawma'otwGif;Yvnf; usa&mufaeygonf? Tae&monf obm0twGuf urBmhom;&d kif;wd&p>mefrsm; xdef;odrf;apmif ha&Smufa&; &efyH kaiGtzG J @}uD; (World
Wild Wide Fund for Nature--WWF) . apmif ha&Smufxdef;odrf;&ef todtrSwfðyxm;aom a*[pepft& ta&;ygaom a'o (200) teufrS wcktygt0ifvnf; jzpfygonf?
xl;jcm;axGjym;aom ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm;wnf&S daer_ a=umif h ,ckuJ hod k @ owfrSwfxm;jcif;vnf;jzpfygonf?53 Ta*[pepft& ta&;ygaom yx0Da'owGif/ a'orsm; pkqHk=uonfhvrf;qH kozG,fjzpf+yD;/ tdEN d,/ tif'd k-rmvm,ef/ tif'd k-w&kwfa'orsm;wGif awG @&S d&aom&kuQowWZD0 rsKd;pH kud k awG @Ed kif+yD; ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm; txl;ºu,f0aoma'ovnf; jzpfygonf?awmifwef;rsm;ESif h awmifukef;rsm;a=umif h a&aiG @rsm;xdef;odrf;xm;onf h us,fjyef @vSaom
vGifjyifud k zefwD;ay;xm;ygonf? Ta'owGif; aygrsm;vSaom om;&J wd&p>mefjzpfonf husm;rsm;uvnf; Ta'o. xl;jcm;r_ud k jznf hqD;wefzd k;jrifhapygonf?
jrefrmEd kifiHwGif tenf;qH k;iSufrsKd;uG J (1�027)wnf&S dae+yD;/ ta&S @awmiftm&Sa'o&S d Ed kifiHrsm;wGif tjcm;Ed kifiHrsm;xuf yd krd kºu,f0pGmxdef;odrf;xm;Ed kifaom Ed kifiHjzpfygonf?54 a'oaygufiSufrsKd;uGJrsm;onf {&m0wDjrpfa=umif;wav#mufwGif usufpm;=u+yD;/ (2002)
ckESpf pm&if;t& {&m0wDjrpf0Srf;a'owGif iSufrsm;usufpm;aexd kif&m ae&m (4) ck&S daeygonf?55 {&m0wDjrpf tv,fyd kif;a'oonf wdbufESif h [dr0EWmajrmufyd kif; tjcm;a'orsm;rS a&$ @ajymif;aexd kif=uaom a&aysmfiSufrsm;twGuf aqmif;cd k&mtwGuf/ em;cd ktajccs&mae&mjzpfygonf? a&. t&nftaoG;ajymif;vJ oGm;jcif;/ ig;rsm;wnf&S dr_ ta&twGufajymif;vJoGm;jcif;twGuf iSufrsm;tajccsr_wGifvnf; xdcd kufajymif;vJr_rsm; jzpfay:
vmapvdrfhrnf jzpfygonf? xdk @tjyif urBm.tjcm;aom a'orsm;wGif&SmazrawG @Edkifonf h iSufrsKd;rsm;aysmuf uG,fqdwfokOf;&rnfh tajctaevnf; jzpfapEd kifygonf?
Tod k @ om;aumifrsm;aysmufuG,foGm;&jcif;onf a&$ @ajymif;tajccsr_ yH kpHysuf,Gif;oGm;apjcif;/ a&. t&nftaoG; usqif;oGm;jcif;/ a&. jrpfa=umif; pD;qif;r_ obm0ajymif;vJoGm;jcif;wd k @a=umif h jzpfay:Ed kifygonf? {&m0wD jrpfqH kqnf wnfaqmufa&;ESif h tifrd kifc
jrpfay:wGif wnfaqmufrnf h tqd kðyxm;aom tjcm;aomqnfrsm;a=umif h ,ck umvuwnf;u rsKd;wkef;vkeD;yg;jzpfaeaom/ txl;&Sm;yg;ae+yDjzpfonfh {&m0wDvif;ydkifrsm;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 63/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 57
(Irrawaddy dolphins) ud kvnf; tE W&m,f&S dapEd kifygonf? jrpftxufyd kif;wGif qnfwnfaqmufr_a=umif h jzpfay:vmEd kifaom jy'g;"gwfrsm; ZD0owWrsm;wGif pkyH kodyfonf;vmjcif;a=umifhvnf; ydkIqdk;&Gm;apEd kifygonf? (jy'g;tenfrsm;pkyH kaeaom a&avSmifwrHrsm;ææ tcef ;ud k =unf hhyg?) jy'g;qdyfoifhr_ jy\emrSm jzpfvmEd kifzG,f&Sdonf h }uD;av;aomjy\emwck jzpfygonf? urBmhobm00ef;usif xdef;odrf;a&;or*~ (World Conservation
Union). tqd kt& a&arSmfyifrsm; ydwfqd k @xlxJvmjcif;/ tajccsaexd kifaom ZD0owWrsm;av#mhenf;oGm;jcif;/ rmusL&D jy'g;"gwfrsm; pkyHkvmjcif;wdk@a=umifh-
�jrpfae vif;yd kifig;}uD;rsm;twGuf txl;tE W&m,f&S dvmap+yD;/ Tta=umif;rSm a&t
wGif; taqmuftOD}uD;rsm; txl;ojzif hqnfrsm; aqmufvkyfjcif;a=umif h/ a&umwmrsm;ESif h a&wHwd kif;rsm; aqmufvkyfjcif;a=umif hjzpfapygonf? a&wGif; aqmufvkyfr_vkyfief;rsm;a=umif h obm0ywf0ef;usif xdcd kufysufpD;apr_rSm ododomomjzpf+yD;/ twd kif;tqt&tvGef}uD;rm;vSygonf? Twnfaqmufr_rsm;a=umif h ZD0rsKd;uG Jrsm;OD;a&ud k uG Jjym;wnf&S dap+yD;/ jrpfa&jzif h &Sifoefa&;twGuf rS Dcd kae=u&aom ZD0 owW0grsm;/ tyifrsm;aysmuf
uG,fum/ obm0ywf0ef;usif axGjym;wnf&Sdr_vnf; qkwf,kwfusqif;vmapEdkifygonf? od k @aomfvnf; TudpPrsm;tay: od&S dem;vnfr_ odyf r&S d=ubJESif h/ qd k;usKd;rsm;tay: tav;xm;r_ r&S d=ubJESif h/ jrpfae vif;yd kifuJ hod k @aom Ed k @wd kufowW0grsm;tay: oufa&mufapr_ESifh ywfoufI xnf hoGif;tav;xm; pOf;pm;r_r&S d=ubJESif h/ a&wGif;wnfaqmufr_rsm;ud k quf vufaqmif&Gufae=uygonf?�56
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 64/90
58 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
w&kwfEd kifiH. obm0ywf0ef;usif umuG,fxdef;odrf;apmif ha&Smufa&; Oya'rsm;t&qnfwnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm; twGuf obm0ywf0ef;usif xdcd kufapr_tuJjzwfcsuf (Environmental Impact Assessment) ESif h vlr_a&;t& xdcd kufapr_tuJjzwfcsuf (Social Impact Assessment) vkyfaqmif&ef vdktyfygonf?Oya't&ud k pDrHcsuf. jyefvnf ppfaq;oH k;oyfr_ESif h oif hav#mf-roif hav#mf qH k;jzwfcsufcsEd kif&eftwGuf aqmif&Guf=u&ygonf? pDrHcsufjyifqif a&;qG JaepOfumvrSmyifTuJ hod k @ ywf0ef;usifESif h vlr_a&; xdcd kufr_qd kif&m tuJjzwfcsufrsm;ud k aqmif&Guf=u&+yD;/ T&v'frsm;udk pDrHcsuf jyifqifa&;qGJ&mY xnfhoGif; pOf;pm;toHk;cs=u&yg
onf? 57
jrefrmEd kifiH&S d wnfqJOya'rsm;t& Tod k@ ywf0ef;usifESifh vlr_a&; xdcd kufr_qd kif&mtuJjzwfcsufrsm;udk aqmif&Guf&ef xnfhoGif; jyXmef;xm;onfudk rawG@&Sd&yg?(2006) ckESpf/ atmufwdkbmvwGif (etz) ppftpdk;&u a&t&if;tjrpfESif h
jrpfacsmif;rsm; xdef;odrf;r_Oya'ud k jyXmef;cJhaomfvnf; txufazmfjyygtcsufrsm;ryg0i fyg? TOya'wGi f p Dr Hc sufrsm; twGuf tu,fI jrp fa=umif;rsm;ajymif;vJapjcif;/ a& t&nftaoG;usqif;apjcif;ESifh a,bk,stm;jzifh obm0ywf0ef;usif xdck dufysufpD;r_ &S dapEd kifygu/ o,f,lyd k @aqmifa&;0ef}uD;Xme.cGifhðycsuf&,l&ef vdktyfonf[kazmfjyaom tcsKd@tydk'frsm; &Sdygonf? jrefrmEdkifiHa&t&if;tjrpfESifh jrpfacsmif;rsm; xdef;odrf;a&; !$ef=um;r_OD;pD;Xmeuvnf; jrpf
acsmi f ;rsm;. ywf0ef ;usi f rysufp D ;apa&;twGuf =unf h& _ =uwfrwf&efwm0ef& S dy gonf? od k @aomfvnf; TOya't& cGi f h ðycsuf&,l&eftwGufaqmif&Guf&rnf h oif hav#mfaom vkyfief;pOftqif hrsm;ud k tao;pdwfazmfjyxm;jcif;rawG@& bJ/ qdk;usKd;rsm; jzpfay:vmapEdkifaomudpP&yfrsm; wm;qD;umuG,fa&;ESifhywfoufI wdusaom Oya'pnf;rsOf;rsm;/ vkyfief;pOfrsm; jyXmef;xkwfjyefxm;jcif;
rawG@&yg? xdk @tjyif jrefrmEd kifiHwGif v$rf;ðcHjyXmef;r_&S daom obm0ywf0ef;usifxdef;odrf;r_qd kif&m Oya' r&S dao;yg? 58
,ae@txd {&m0wDjrp fqH kqnf wnfaqmufrnf hudp PE Si f h ywfoufIjzpfay:vmEd kifonf h obm0ywf0ef;usifqd kif&m &d kufcwfr_rsm;tay: tuJjzwfcsufud kvltrsm;od&S dEd kifatmif xkwfjyefay;jcif; r&S dao;yg? Tod k @ tuJjzwfppfaq;r_ rsm;
aqmif&Gufxm;&S djcif; vH k;0r&S d[kyif oHo,yGm;p&m tajctae &S daeygonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 65/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 59
{&m0wDvif;ydkifig;}uD;rsm;urBmay:wGif jrpfwGif;ae vif;yd kifrsKd;pdwf (4) rsKd;cef @om &S donf hteuf/ {&m0wDvif;yd kifig; }uD;rsm;(Orcaella brevirostris) onf wrsKd;tygt0ifjzpfonf? �wd k @onf
urBm@jrpf}uD; (3)pif; jzpfonf h tif'd keD;&Sm;Ed kifiHrS r[mcrfjrpf/ avmEd kifiHawmifyd kif;/uarBm'D;,m;/ AD,uferfEd kifiHwd k @ud k jzwfoef;pD;qif;oGm;aom rJacgifjrpfESif h/ jrefrmEd kifiH. {&m0wDjrpfwd k @wGifom &Sm;&Sm;yg;yg; awG @=u&onf? vif;yd kifig;}uD;rsm;onf(2) rDwmrS (2²75)rDwmtxd &Snfv#m;+yD;/ tjym&if hrS rD;cd k;arSmifta&mifrsm;&S d=uonf?
{&m0wDvif;yd kifwd k@onf vlwd k @ESif hyl;aygif;I ig;&Smwwf=uaom rwljcm;em;onf hxl;jcm;csuf&S donf? jrefrmEd kifiHY wHigwd k @onf avSeHud k avSmfwufjzif hacgufI vif;ydkifrsm;udkac:avh&Sdonf? vif;ydkifwdk@u ig;rsm;udktkyfzGJ@+yD; ydkufxJodk@armif;ydk@ay;wwf=uonf? &vmaomig;ud k vif;yd kifwd k @tm;vnf; wHigwd k @u r#a0ay;=u&onf?Trwl xl;jcm;aom taygif;taz:zG J @r_a=umif h ody Hynm&Sifwd k @tzd k @ vlESif hwd&p>mefwd k @. qufqHa&;ud k avhvm&ef xl;xl;jcm;jcm; tcGif htvrf;w&yf &&S daponf?
od k @&mwGif urBmhobm0xdef;odrf;apmif ha&Smufa&;tzG J @ (The World Conservation
Union)u {&m0wD vif;yd kifrsm;ud k tvGef&Sm;yg; xdef;odrf;apmif ha&SmuftyfaomowW0gtjzpf (2004) ckESpfwGif xnf hoGif; a=ujimowfrSwfcJ honf? vGefcJ haom&mpk
ESpftwGif; {&m0wDjrpfxJ&S d vif;yd kifta&twGufrSm (60) &mcd kifE_ef;eD;yg;av#mhusqif;oGm;cJ h&onf? avmavmq,f taocsmqH k;cef @rSef;awG @&S d&aom ta&twGuf
rSm (59) aumifomjzpfonf?59 jrefrmEdkifiH&Sd ppftpdk;&onf ausmufajrmif;ESifh
rif;uGef;t=um; (qnfwnfaqmufrnf h ae&mrS uDvd krDwm 330 cef @om uGma0;onf hae&m)wGif (72) uDvd krDwm us,f0ef;aom vif;yd kifrsm; umuG,fapmif ha&Smuf
a&;ZH ke,fajrwckud k owfrSwfay;xm;cJ honf? od k @aomfvnf; vif;yd kifrsm; umuG,fapmif ha&Smufa&;ZH kESif h ywfoufI trsm;jynfolod&S dEd kifatmif rnfr#twd kif;twmtxd a=ujimvkyfaqmifay;aea=umif; aumif;pGmrod&S d&acs?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 66/90
60 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
usef;rma&;qd kif&m tEW&m,frsm;
rpD;bJ +idrfaeaoma&wGif a&m*go,f aqmif Ed kif onf h tif ;quf rsm; yd krd kayguf zGm; Edkifjcif ;? vGwfvyfpGm pD;qif;aeaom {&m0wDjrpfudkqnfjzifhwm;vdkufaoma=umifh/ a&+idrfaeaom uefozG,f jzpfvmayrnf? xd ktcg tif;qufrsm;/ yufusdrsm;ESifh tjcm;
aomw&dp>mefrsm;vnf; ydkrd kwd k;yGm;vmEd kif+yD;/ a&m*gydk;o,faqmifEdkifaom uyfyg;rsm;/ ydk;r$m;rsm;vnf; ydkrd kaygufzGm;vmapEdkifonfh tE W&m,f&Sdygonf? uyfyg;oHaumifrsm;a=umif h jzpfonfh (schisto-
somiasis)[kac:aom aoG;xJwGif oefaumifwG,faoma&m*gud k qnfwnf
aqmufonfh ae&mrsm;wGif ydkrdk wdk;wufjzpfay:vmonfudk awG@&Sd&ygonf? Toefaumifrsm;onf a&m*grsKd;pH kud kjzpfapEd kif+yD;/ rv_yf&Sm;Ed kifjcif;/ ºuufom;rsm;tm;aysmhoGm;jcif;/ ud k,fcE<m csdeJ @oGm;jcif;/ ta&jym;a&m*grsm;/ tonf;ysufjcif;rSonf 0uf&l;jyefa&m*g/ ausmufuyf tvkyfrvkyfEd kifawmhonftxd ysufoGm;jcif;/ uifqma&m*grsm;txd
jzpfapEd kifygonf? &Spfpwd k qdkrDa,;ppf (schistosomiasis) a&m*gpG JuyfcH&olrsm;onftjcm;a&m*grsm;vnf; xyfrHul;pufcH&ap&ef vG,fulygonf?60 Ta&m*gtjyif urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&m aumfr&Sif. rSwfwrf;ðyxm;csufrsm;t& �a&avSmifwrHrsm;ESif h a&ay;a&;pDrHcsufrsm;onf iSufzsm;a&m*gzl;ajymaom a'orsm;wGif aqmif&Gufavh&Sdaoma=umif h/ iSufzsm;a&m*g jzpfyGm;r_ESif h ul;pufysH @yGm;rI yd krsm;vmaponf�[kvnf; azmfjy
xm;ygonf?
jy'g; tenfrsm;pkyHkaeaom a&avSmif wrHrsm;a=umif h jrpfatmufydkif;a'oaevlxkrsm; xHodk @ tqd yf oifhapEd kif onf ? a&rsm;onf a&avSmifwrHxJwGif +idrfaeonfESif htr# ykwfod k;vmaom ZD0&kyfºuif;rsm;ud kpm;oH k;&Sifoefae=uaom bufwD;&D;,m;rsm;u a&xJwGif&S daeaom jy'g;"gwf (rmusL&D)rsm;ud k rDod kif;vf rmusL&D"gwf (methylmercury) tjzpfod k @ ajymif;vJypfygonf? T"gwfrSm vlwd k@. A[dktm&Hka=umpepfudk tqdyftawmufjzpfapaom "gwfwrsKd;jzpfygonf?
ucsifjynfe,f&Sd uav;rsm;onf urBmay:wGif tqd k;&Gm;tnHhzsif;qHk;aom usef;rma&; apmifha&Smufr_pepfatmufwGif aexdkifae=u&onf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 67/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 61
TrDod kif;vf rmusL&D"gwfrsm;ud k tpm;taomufuGif;qufrsm;rSwqif h v$ Jajymif;a&muf&S dI vlwd k @xH a&mufvm=u+yD;/ vlwd k @wGif pkyH kvmapEd kifygonf?61 taru rDod kif;vfrmusL&D"gwfygaom ig;rsm;/ tcG Hygaom c&k/ ykpGef/ *%ef;rsm; pm;rdygu om;tdrfwGif rDod kif;vfrmusL&D"gwfxdawG @Ed kif+yD;/ uav;. OD;a%SmufESif h tm&H ka=umpepfzG H @òz;r_ud k xdcd kufapEd kifygonf? uav;. odpdwfqifjcifr_ (cognitive thinking)/ rSwfOm%fpl;pd kufr_ (memory
attention)/ bmompum; ajymqd kr_/ tEkpdwfvkyfief;rsm;ESifh tjriftm&H k (fine motor
and visual spatial skills) wd k @ud k xdcd kufapygonf?62 ody Hynm&Sifrsm;u a&avSmifwrHrsm;twGif;&Sd ig;rsm;wGifvnf;aumif;/ qnfwnfaqmuf&ma'o jrpfatmufydkif;aevlxkrsm;. aoG;a=umrsm;twGif; jy'g;pkyH kvmr_ taetxm;ud kvnf; txl;owdxm;vm=uyg
onf?63
tm&S yHk&dyf (Images Asia) ESifh ucsifvlrsKd;w&yfvHk; zGH@òz;r_qdkif&m vlr_tzGJ@tpnf;(Pan Kachin Development Society) rS xkwfa0cJ haom �rnfonf hwefzd k; ay;&-ay;&(At What Price)�[laom tpD&ifcHpmwGif azmfjyxm;csuft& {&m0wDjrpfzsm;ydkif;
jzpfaom/ rvdcESifh tifrdkifcjrpfrsm;onf 1999 ckESpfrSpwifI ucsifjynfe,ftwGif;t"dua&$wl;azmf&SmazG=u&m ae&mrsm; jzpfae=uygonf?64 Ta&$wl;azmfxkwfvkyf&mae&mrsm;onf qnfwnf aqmufrnf hae&m. jrpfnmyd kif;jzpf+yD;/ a&wGifjy'g;"gwfyg0ifr_E_ef;jrif hae+yD; jzpfae+yD[k ,lqEd kifzG,f&S dygonf? 2003 ckESpfwGif ppfaq;prf;oyfcsuft&{&m0wDjrpfa=umif;wav#muftwGif; aexd kifaom ig;trsKd; (22)rsKd;wGif jy'g;"gwfyg0ifr_E_ef; trSefyif jrif hrm;aea=umif;awG @&S d&ygonf?65 Ta'otwGif; jrif hrm;pGmyg0ifaeaom
jy'g;"gwfrsm;onf wmwrH. aemufausmwGif pkyH kae=urnfjzpf+yD;/ azmfjycJ honf htwd kif;aemufyd kif;wGif rDod kif;vf rmusL&Dtjzpf ajymif;vJoGm;rnf jzpfygonf? qnfrS a&xkwfv$wfonfhtcg jrpfatmufydkif;wGif aexdkif=uolrsm;onf jy'g;qdyfoifhaeaom a&ESifhig;rsm;udk xdawG@=u&awmhrnf jzpfonf? Tqdk;usKd;udk jrpf}uD;em;òr@atmufbuf 28rd kiftwGif; aexd kif=uaom vlOD;a&aygif; (140000) ud k xdcd kufzG,f &S daeygonf? xd kr#ru
{&m0wDjrpfa=umwav#muf aexdkif=uaom oef;aygif;rsm;pGm jrefrmEdkifiHom;rsm;&S dae=uygao;onf? xd k @tjyif ig;rsm;ud k zrf;pm;=uonf h iSufrsm;ESif h tjcm;Ed k @wd kufowW0grsm;onfvnf; tvm;wl tqdyfoif hcH&zG,f&Sdaeygonf?
qnfwnfaqmufrnfhae&mwGif usef;rma&;xdcdkufcHpm;&Edkifonfh tajctaeESifh a&$@ajymif;vlxkrsm;t=um; jzpfvmEdkifaom usef;rma&;tusKd ;qufrsm;
qnfwnfaqmufrnf hae&mESif h eD;pyf&m aus;&Gm/ vlaer_ tod kuft0ef;rsm;wGif usef;rma&;jy\emrsm; rsm;vmEd kif+yD;/ txl;ojzif h tdyfcsftd kifADG§attd kif'Dtufpfa&m*gul;puf
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 68/90
62 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
ysH@yGm;vmr_ jzpfay:vmEdkifaomqdk;usKd;rSm urBmw0Srf;vHk;&Sd qnfrsm;wGif ñuHawG@ae&aom jy\emyifjzpfygonf?66 a&$@ajymif;tajccs&jcif;a=umifh vltrsm;&kwfcsnf; b0ysuf=u&+yD;/ usef;rma&;t&vnf; yd kIxdcd kufepfemzG,f tajctaeud kñuHapygonf? urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&maumfr&Sif. rSwfwrf;ðycsufrsm;t& �jyefvnftajccsaexd kif&ef ajymif;a&$@cH&aomvlxkrsm;xJwGif aomufoHk;a&&&Sdr_jy\em/ usef;rma&;apmifha&Smufay;r_/&kyfywf0ef;usiftopf/ vlr_tod kif;t0d kif;todpdwfESif h tom;usap&eftwGuf &kef;uef&aomjy\emrsm;ñuHawG @=u&+yD;/ usef;rma&;tajctaetay:oufa&mufr_&S dapygonf?�
jrefrmEd kifiH. òyuG Jaeaom usef ;rma&;apmif ha&Smuf ay;r_ pepf
urBmhusef;rma&;tzGJ@ (WHO)u jrefrmEd kifiH. usef;rma&;apmifha&Smufr_pepfudkurBmay:wGif tcsKd @wJhtqd k;&Gm;qH k; EdkifiHwcktjzpf owfrSwfazmfjycJ hygonf? ukvor*~uav;rsm;qdkif&m &efyH kaiGtzG J @ (UNICEF) u azmfjycJ h&mwGif jrefrmtpdk;&uEdkifiHom;wpfOD;csif;twGuf usef;rma&;apmifha&Smufr_vkyfief;rsm;wGif toHk;p&dwfrSmtar&duef a':vm 0 ² 40 om&Sd+yD;/ xdkif;Ed kifiHwGif (61) a':vm &Sdaeygonf?
ud k,fcHtm;usa&m*g(HIV/AIDS)
wd kufzsufa&; udpPwGif vl 52 oef;twGuf wESpfv#ifrjzpfpavmuf tar&duefa':vm (137000)om&&Sdygonf?67 jrefrmEdkifiH. csKd@wJhòyuG Jaeaom usef;rma&;apmif ha&Smufr_pepfud k =unf hygu/ qnfwnfaqmufrnf htwGuf yd krd kjzpfay:vmrnf h a&m*gb,rsm;a=umif h vlr_tzG J @tpnf;wckvH k;. usef;rma&;ud k xdcd kufapawmhrnfrSm aocsmonfhtcsufyif jzpfaeygonf?
rvdcjrpfESif h tifrd kifcjrpfurf;yg;rsm;wGif a&$wG if;wl;ae=u&mrS xGufvmaom tqdyfoif hypPnf;rsm;onf a&umwmtwGif; pkyH kvm&ef ta=umif;&S daeonf? a&umwmrS xyfrHpGef @xkwfaom a&rsm;a=umif h jrpfatmufajc&Sdvlxkrsm; xdcdkufepfem&ayrnf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 69/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 70/90
64 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
tajcrJ h ajymif;a&$ @=u&jcif;ESif h vdifuG Jjym;r_tay: tusKd;oufa&mufapr_tajcrJ h a&$ @ajymif;r_a=umif h jzpf&aom/ vlr_tzG J@tpnf;ud k taxGaxGtm;jzifhqif;&Jusyfwnf;apjcif;/ vlr_a&;t& upif huvsm;jzpf&jcif;/ ud k,fpdwf'kuQrsm;ESif h usef;rma&;qd kif&m qd k;usKd;oufa&mufr_rsm;onf txl;ojzif h trsKd;orD;rsm;tay: yd kIqd k;&Gm;pGm xdcd kufr_ &S dapygonf? (urBmhqnfrsm;qd kif&m aumfr&Sif?pm-115)
qnfpDrHcsufrsm;a=umif h ae&majymif;a&$ @&r_ESif h jyefvnftajccs=u&r_wd k @a=umif hjzpf&aom qd k;usKd;rsm;oufa&muf&mwGif trsKd;om;rsm;ESif h trsKd;orD;rsm;tay: xdcdkufapyHkjcif; rwl=uyg? ae&majymif;a&$@=u&jcif;a=umifh &Sdaeaom vlr_tzG J @tpnf;ESif h rdom;pkrsm;. aqGrsKd; tod kuftðrHud k òyuG Japygonf? trsKd;orD;
rsm;onf obm0t& trsKd;om;rsm;xuf a&G @vsm;oGm;vmaexd kifr_ enf;yg;jcif;a=umifhvnf;aumif;/ rdom;pkrsm;/ aus;&Gmrsm;/ vlr_todkuftðrHrsm; òyuGJ=u&jcif;a=umif hvnf;aumif;/ trsKd;orD;rsm;wGif yd kIxdcdkufepfemr_ jzpf=u&ygonf? tu,fI jyefvnftajccsaexd kif &yguvnf;/ a,muf sm;rsm;rSm yd kIv_yf&Sm;oGm;vmwwfonf h obm0&S djcif;a=umif h òr@rsm;wGif 0ifaiGaumif;aom tvkyf&&ef/ od k @r[kwf tpm;xd k;tvkyf&&ef yd kI vG,fulygonf? Ed _if;,SOfcsuft&trsKd;orD;rsm;twGuf tvkyf&&ef ydkIcufcJygonf? 71
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 71/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 72/90
66 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
azmfjyxm;=u+yD;jzpfygonf?69 jrefrm ppfwyfzG J @0iftrsm;u usL;vGefaom rk'drf;r_rsm;rSmpHkprf;ppfaq;jcif;r&Sdovdk/ jypfr_usL;vGefolud kvnf; wpHkw&m tjypfay;jcif; r&S dyg? Ttvm;wl jzpf&yfrsm;rSm u&ifeDjynfe,fwGif avmyDwa&tm;v#yfppfpuf&H k vH kðcHa&;twGuf apmif h=uyf&aom ppfom;rsm;wGifvnf; jzpfay:usL;vGefcJh=uygonf?
(2007) ckESpf/ azaz:0g&DvwGif touf(14 rS 16) ESpftwGif;&S d ausmif;ol (4) OD;udkucsifjynfe,fajrmufyd kif;/ ylwmtd k&S d ppfwyft&m&S d (3) OD;ESif h ppfom; (4)OD;wd k @u tkyfpkjzif h rk'drf;ðyusif hcJ h=uygonf? Trdefuav;rsm;ud k jynf hwefqmvkyfr_ESif h zrf;qD;xm;cJ h+yD;/Ed kifiHwumu &_ H @csjypfwifr_rsm; jzpfay:vmonf htcgrSom jyefv$wfay;cJ hygonf?70 Trk
'drf;r_usL;vGefolrsm;tay: ta&;,ltjypfay;cJ hjcif; &S d-r&S dud k tao;pdwf rod&S d&yg? Tod k @aom tjypf&S donf h w&m;cHrsm;ud k ta&;,ltjypfray;bJxm;onf h tajctaeESif h tpd k;&udk,fYu trsKd;orD;rsm;tay: t=urf;zufr_rsm; cGif hðyusL;vGefapaom tajctaewGif{&m0wDjrpfqH kqnf wnfaqmufa&;pDrHcsufae&mwGif/ ppfwyfrsm; yd kIwd k;csJ @csxm;rnf/ppfom;rsm; yd kIwd k;rsm;vmaprnf h taetxm;a=umif h yd kItxl;pd k;&drfzG,f jzpfapygonf?
vdifazsmfajza&;vkyf ief ; }uD;xGm;vmapEd kifjcif ;? ucsifzG H @òzd;wk d;wufa&;uGef&uftzG J @ (KDNG) u tao;pdwf rSwfwrf;ðycJ haom [l;aumif;csKdif h0Srf;a'o&S d a&$rd kif;wl;azmf=uonf h a&$wGif;rsm;wGif ,m,Dtajccsvmonf h vkyfom;rsm; rsm;jym;vmjcif;/ xd kvkyfom;rsm;onfvnf; jzpfovdktaetxm;wGif aexdkif=u&jcif;tjyif/ trsKd;orD;rsm;taejzif h vkyfcvpmenf;onf htjyif/ tvkyftcGif htvrf;vnf;
&Sm;yg;onfhtwGufa=umifh Ta'orsm;Y vdifazsmfajza&;vkyfief; }uD;xGm;vmaeyHkudkazmfjycJ hygonf? jrpfqH kqnf wnfaqmufa&;uJ hod k @aom pDrHcsuf}uD;rsm; wnfaqmuf=urnf hae&mwGifvnf;/ Tod k @tajctae rqd k; v#ifaomfrS tvm;wl vlr_a&;tajctaersm;jzpfay:vmEd kifygonf? vdifazsmfajza&;vkyfief;rsm;wGif tvkyfvkyfae=u&aom rdef;rysKdrsm;/t"rRjynfhwefqmtjzpf cd kif;apcH=u&olrsm;rSm t=urf;zufr_rsm;ESif h a&m*gul;pufr_rsm;
vnf; cH=u&zG,f&S daeygonf? xd k @tjyif Tod k @aom trsKd;orD;rsm;ud k vlr_tod kif;rS z,fusOfcH=u&aoma=umifh pdwfydkif;qdkif&m cHpm;epfem&r_rsm;vnf;&Sdygonf? ? pDrHcsuftaumiftxnfazmfrnfhae&mwGif udk,fcHtm;usa&m*g (tdyfcsftdkifADG§attdkif'Dtufpf)vnf; yd krd kul;pufysH @yGm;vmzG,f &S daeygonf? vlxktrsm;twGuf usef;rma&;apmif ha&Smufr_pepf txl;edrf husaeaomtaetxm;wGif tjcm;vl @tzG J @tpnf; w&yfvH k;od k @ yd krd kul;pufysH@yGm;EdkifonfhtE W&m,ftwGufvnf; pdk;&drfzG,fjzpfygonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 73/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 67
Our Homeland (Kachin Song)
The most pleasant and glorious homeland of ours,
The site where Mali hka and Nmai hka join together
It is surrounded by snow mountainous and green forest hills,
The mist and the cloud encompass this location
Here, beautiful flowers are blossoming
Rivers and streams flow eternally
Birds and cuckoos fly around,
Cool and pleasant is our homeland
Welcome every one, just for a visit
Unforgettable Kachin culture which can never be satisfied to observe,
Awesome scenic views and natural sights , precious jade and wildlife abound
All kinds of fruits and crops are abundant
As long as the Irrawaddy (Mali hka) river flows
The love of the ethnic Kachin will never cease
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 74/90
68 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
ti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppf xkwfvkyfief;rsm; (Small hydro power--SHP)
onf yd krd kaumif;rGefaom tjcm; a&G;cs,fp&m enf;vrf; jzpfonf?
ti,fpm; a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief;rsm;ud k acsmif;i,frsm;/ tvwfpm;ESif h t}uD;pm;jrpfrsm;rS a&ud kuJ h,lI aqmif&GufEd kifygonf? Tenf;onfobm0ywf0ef;usif rysufpD;apaom pGrf;tifxkwf,lEdkifonfh enf;yif
jzpfygonf? ti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief;rsm; (Small
hydro power--SHP)
[kqd k&mY rsm;aomtm;jzif h pGrf;tif (10)r D*g0y f xufenf;Ixkwfay; Ed kifaom pepf
rsKd;jzpfygonf? qd k;usKd;tenf;i,fr#om jzpfap+yD;/ a0;vHacgifoD
aom a'orsm;wGif pGrf;tif axmufyH hay;&eftwGuf toH k;ðyEd kifygonf?Tti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppfxkwf vkyfief;rsm;wGif a&ud k ajrmif; od k @r[kwfydkufjzifhoG,f,lI wmbdkiftwGif;odk@ ay;ydk@jcif; jzpfonf? xdktcg pufarmif;wH&Sd a&cGufud k &dkufap+yD;/ wmbdkifpufud k vnfapygonf? Tod k @vnfaeaomarmif;wHud k rD;tm;xkwfay;rnf h *sifea&wmESif h qufoG,fxm;ay;jcif;tm;jzifh a&G@&Sm;r_rS v#yfppfpGrf;tiftjzpfodk@ ajymif;,ljcif;jzpfygonf?76 Tvkyfief;rsm;wGif qnf}uD;rsm;/ a&umwm}uD;rsm; rvd ktyfonf htwGufa=umif h/ vltrsm;ajymif;a&$ @&ap&ef/ opfawmrsm; a&jrKyf
ysufpD;ap&ef tajctaevnf;r&S dapyg?
jrefrmEd kifiHESif h ucsifjynfe,f&S d vlxkrsm;onf olwd k @vd ktyf=uaom v#yfppfpGrf;tif&&S dap&eftwGuf/ ti,fpm;a&tm; v#yfppf xkwf,la&;vkyfief;rsm;udk oifhav#mf&menf;vrf;rsm;jzifh aqmif&Gufae=u+yD; jzpfygonf?trSefqdk&v#if w&kwf EdkifiHonf ti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppfxkwfvkyfief;(Small hydro power--SHP)wGif OD;aqmifaeonf hae&mu &S donf[kqd kEd kif+yD;/ (2006) ckESpf pm&if;rsm;t& ti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppfxkwf puf&H k
Inversin, A. R. Micro-Hydropower Sourcebook
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 75/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 69
tcef; (4)? tod&S d&S djzif h oabmwlI tepfemcH-u&jcif;/ od k �r[kwf tjcm;a&G;cs,fp&m
enf;vrf;rsm; !$efjya&G;cs,fapjcif;r&S dbJ vltrsm;u xdcd kufepfem-u&jcif;?
wefz&Jaus; &GmrS &Gmom;wOD;u ajymjy&mwGif �tpd k;&uawmh usaemf wd k@udkw&m;0if tod ay;wmawG r&S d ao;ygbl;? at&Sm;a0g (ukr%D ) uvmawmh &Gmvl
}uD ;ud k 'D ae&mrSm olwd k @tvkyf vkyf r,f qd kwm tod ay;ygw,f ? 'gayr,f h &Gmom; awGud k bmud pPvkyf r,f / b,f twGuf a=umif h vkyf r,f qd kwm &Sif ;jywm r&S d ygbl;?�
[k ajymygonf ? (awG @qH kar;jref ;cef ; trSwf -14)
ppftpd k;&onf Tqnfwnfaqmufa&;ESifh ywfoufI a'ocH jynfolvlxkrsm;xHodk @w&m;0if ta=umif;=um;jcif; r&S dao;yg? od k @aomfvnf; aus;&Gmvlxkrsm;onf uGif;qif;wd kif;xGma&;tzG J @rsm; oGm;vmaeonfud k jrifawG @ae=u&+yD; qnfwnfaqmufawmhrnfud k
odae=uygonf? *syefavhvmwd kif;xGma&;tzG J @wcku pm&Gufpmwrf;rsm; usefcJ h+yD;/ �wd k @rSwqifh wefz&Jaus;&GmteD; wnfaqmufrnfh qnfESifh tjcm;tcsuftvufrsm;udkod&S d=u&ygonf?
a&v$rf;rnf ha'orsm; azmfjyxm;onf h ajryH ktygt0ifjzpfaom taxmuftxm;rsm;ud k=unfhI wefz&Jaus;&Gmom;rsm;u ucsifvlrsKd;rsm;. OD;aqmiftzGJ@tpnf;wckxHodk@�Tqnf aqmufvkyfa&; udpPtay: wm;qD;Ed kif&eftwGuf vd ktyfaom ta&;,laqmif&Gufr_rsm; ðyay;yg&efESif h oufqd kif&m tm%myd kifrsm;xH qufvufwifjyay;&ef� (2004)
aygif; (43� 027) ck &Sdaeygonf?77 �rdrdbmom wnfaqmufEdkifaom/rdrdbmom xdef;odrf;pDrHEd kifaom/ rdrdbmom toH k;ðyEd kifaom� ti,fpm;a&tm;v#yfppf puf&H krsm;wnfaqmuf&ef w&kwfEd kifiHu 1960 ckESpfrsm;uyif rl0g'csrSwfcJ hygonf? Tod k @ A[d k OD;pD;csKyfud kifr_ rxm;bJ jzef @cG Jxm;aom pDrHcef @cG Jr_pepfESif h a'ocHjynfolrsm;ud k �wd k @bmom pDrHxdef;odrf;Ed kifaom a&tm;v#yfppfxkwf vkyfief;rsm;wGif &if;ES D;jr�KyfES Hapjcif;ESif h toH k;ðyapjcif;ud k yd krd kjr�if hwifaqmif&Gufoif hvSygonf? od k @aomfvnf; jrefrmEd kifiH&S dppftpd k;&u qnf}uD;rsm;wnfaqmufa&;Yom tm;oefaeum/ w&kwfEd kif
iHrS ukr%Drsm;u Tod k @aqmufvkyfa&;twGuf ulnDyh Hyd k;ay;ae=uygonf?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 76/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 77/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 78/90
72 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
15 "Irrawaddy�s bounty is its people�s curse,� in The Nation, January 24, 1997.16 http://www. Worldwildlife.org/wildworld/profiles/terrestrial/im/im0116_full.html17 T'¾&Dajymqd k=u&mwGif uG JvG Jr_ tcsKd @&S dygonf? ewfrif;}uD;u vufwzufrSaeI a&$cGufjzif havmif;+yD;/ tjcm;vufwzufrS
aiGcGufud kifI avmif;csonf[kvnf; qd k=uygonf? xd k @tjyif jrpfrsm;ESif h ywfoufonf h xl;jcm;csufta=umif;rsm;wGifvnf;uG JvGJajymqdkr_ tcsKd@&Sdygonf? Please see The Kachins: Religion and Custom, A. Gilhodes,
1996 and http;//www.pandaw1947.com/irrawaddy_river.htm18 Myanmar Hydroproject, Report, China Power Investment Corporation Myanmar
Hydro Division, April 2007.19 aemufxyfowif;tcsuftvufrsm;ud k China Southern Power Grid. website pmrsufESm www.csg.cn
wGif =unfhEdkifonf//20 �West-to-east Power Transmission Program Well Underway in SW China,� People�s
Daily Online, January 10, 2003.21 �China to Build Dams in Northern Burma,� The Irrawaddy Business News, February
2007.22 China eyes second dam on Thanlwin , The Myanmar Times, Volume 19, No.336, May
14-20, 2007, �China firm to build Myanmar hydro-power plants,� AFP , May5, 2007.23 China eyes second dam on Thanlwin , The Myanmar Times, Volume 19, No.336, May
14-20, 2007.24 �Hydropower plays a leading role in Myanmar�s power development plans,� Inter-
national Journal of Hydropower and Dams, Issue Two, 2005.25 �Who rules the Ground?� The power of Myanmar�s area commanders,� at http://
www,asiaweek.com/asiaweek/magazine/99/0903/nat_myanmar.html26 http://eng.cpicorp.com.cn/channel.do?cmd=show&id=527 Myanmar Hydroproject Report , China Power Investment Corporation Myanmar
Hydro Division, April 2007.28 http://eng.cpicorp.com.cn/channel.do?cmd=show&id=529 http://finance.mapsofworld.com/company/c/china-southern-power-grid.html ESifh
www.csg.cn tifwmeuf pmrsufESmrsm;rS owif;tcsuftvufrsm; &,lygonf?30
http://www.ymec.com.cn/en/about.htm31 www.yndaily.com/html/20051201/news_88_714449.html32 http://www,cjw.com.cn/index/civilization/detail/20070530/88736.asp33 at&Sa0gvfukr%Donf ysOf;rem; òr@awmfopf (aejynfawmf) . twGif;ESif htjyif taqmuftOD;rsm; aqmufvkyfa&; twGuf
tpd k;&ESif h uefx±d kufpmcsKyf csKyfqd kxm;aom t"duukr%D}uD;wckvnf; jzpfonf//34 at&Sa0gvfESif h ywfoufaom tcsuftvufrsm;ud k {&m0wDr*~Zif;rS cGefqrf (Hkun Sam) u okawoeðyonf?
�Hanging drug couriers but investing with their suppliers,� in The Nation, October
20, 1997.35 http://www.suntactechnologies.com/36 htpp://www.japancorp.net/company_show.asp?compid=45337 Dammed by Burma�s Generals: The Karenni Experience with Hydropower Development
from Lawpita to the Salween, The Karenni Development Research Group, 2006.38 (WCD p. 112)39 Down River, The consequences of Vietnam�s Se San River Dams on Life in Cambodia
and their meaning in international law,The NGO Forum on Cambodia40
�The Mekong�s Changing Currency,� Montree Chantawong, in Watershed , Vol. 11,No. 2, November 2005-January 2006.
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 79/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 73
41 Silenced Rivers, the Ecology and Politics of Large Dams , Patrick McCully, 2001,
p. 117.42 w&kwfjynfol@orwEdkifiH/ a&ESifh pGrf;tif t&if;tjrpfrsm;tawG@tñuHwGif qnfrsm;ESifhywfoufaom udpPrsm;udk
urBmhqnfrsm;qkdif&m aumfr&Sifodk @ wifjy&ef Professor R. Fuggle and W.T. Smith, 2000. ðypkaomw&kwfEd kifiHta=umif; wifjycsufpmwrf;rS &,lygonf?
43
http://asc-india.org/maps/hazard/haz-myanmar.htm, last accessed June 22, 2007.44 Silenced Rivers, the Ecology and Politics of Large Dams , Patrick McCully, 2001, p.
113-114.45 vH kðcHa&;0efxrf;rsm;ESif h tif*sifeD,mwOD;rSm a&epfaoqH k;cJ h&ygonf? 'Drd ku&ufwpf jrefrmhtoH xkwfv$if hcsuf? (2006 ckESpf/
Zlvd kif 12) Dam burst kills five in northern Burma�s Kachin State.46 jrpf}uD;em;a&}uD;r_owif;udk http://www.kachinstate.com/reporton_myitkyina_flood.html
tifwmeufpmrsufESmwGif zwf&_Ed kifygonf?47 Down River, The consequences of Vietnam�s Se San River Dams on Life in Cambodia
and their meaning in international law, The NGO Forum on Cambodia, 2005, �Deathtoll rises in Indian dam tragedy,� 12 April 2005, www.waterpowermagazine.com
48 From Myanmar: Investment opportunities in biodiversity conservation , Birdlife
international, 2005, citing �Large-scale hydrological changes in tropical Asia:
prospects for riverine biodiversity,� Bioscience 50 (9): 793-806, 2000, and �The
ecology of tropical Asian rivers and streams in relations to biodiversity
conservation,� Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 31: 239-263, 2000.49 �Large-scale hydrological changes in tropical Asia: prospects for riverine
biodiversity,� David Dudgeon, in Bioscience , September 2000.50 Greater Mekong Subregion Atlas of the Environment , Asian Development Bank, 2004,
p. 37.51 Silenced Rivers, the Ecology and Politics of Large Dams , Patrick McCully, 200152 Tta&;ygaom a'orsm;ta=umif;ud k a'gufwm aemfref ar,m (Dr. Norman Meyers) u yxrOD;qH k;avhvmcJ h+yD;/
1988 ckESpfwGif yHkESdyfazmfjycJ h+yD jzpfygonf? Tavhvmr_udk ESpfpOfxyfrHjznf hpGufcJ h+yD; aemufqHk;pmtkyfrSm Hotspots
Revisited: Earth�s Biologically Richest and Most Endangered Terrestrial Ecoregions.
[k trnf&ygonf/ �udk atmufygtifwmeufpmrsufESmwGif zwf&_Edkifygonf? http://multimedia.conservation.org/cabs/online_pubs/hotspots2/cover.html
53 http://www.worldwildlife.org/wildworld/profiles/terrestrial/im/im0131_full.html54 Myanmar: Investment opportunities in biodiversity conservation , Birdlife
international, 200555 Irrawaddy Watershed, EarthTrends/World Resources Institute, 2002.56 Occasional Paper No. 23 Biology and Conservation of Asian River Cetaceans,
accessed at http://www.iucn.org/themes/ssc/publications/rivercetacean.htm57 w&kwfjynfol@orwEdkifiH/ a&ESifh pGrf;tif t&if;tjrpfrsm;tawG@tñuHwGif qnfrsm;ESifhywfoufaom udpPrsm;udk
urBmhqnfrsm;qkdif&m aumfr&Sifodk @ wifjy&ef Professor R. Fuggle and W.T. Smith, 2000. ðypkaomw&kwfEd kifiHta=umif; wifjycsufpmwrf;rS &,lygonf?
58 �Legal aspects of hydropower projects in Myanmar,� in Hydropower and Dams ,
Issue One, 2007.59 �Smith, B.D. & Beasely, I. 2004.Orcaella brevirostris (Malampaya Sound
subpopulation). In: IUCN 2006. 2006 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species .
<www.iucnredlist>.org. Downloaded on 21 June 2007.60 &Spfpwd kqd krDa,;ppfa&m*gESif h ywfoufaom tcsuftvufrsm;ud k Silenced Rivers, the Ecology and Politics
of Large Dams, Patrick McCully, 2001. pmtkyfrS &,lygonf?61 WCD, p. 118.
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 80/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 81/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 82/90
76 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
aemufqufwG J 1? awG @qH kar;jref;cJ holrsm; pm&if;
pOf &ufpG usm;§r touf tvkyftudif
1 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 35 bk&m;ausmif;vl}uD;
2 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 24 ul;wd k @avSorm;3 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 38 wHig4 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 60 rkqd k;5 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 30 wHig6 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 58 v,form;7 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv r 64 v,form;
8 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv r 27 usyrf;aps;a&mif;ol9 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv r 46 ti,fpm; rd kif;wGif;wl;orm;10 2006 ckESpf/ rwfv r 39 wd kif;&if;aq;q&m11 2006 ckESpf/ pufwifbmv usm; 28 0g;a&mif;ol 12 2006 ckESpf/ pufwifbmv usm; 24 wHig13 2006 ckESpf/ pufwifbmv usm; 26 ul;wd k @avSorm;14 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 24 ae@pm;tvkyform;15 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 40 bk&m;ausmif;vl}uD;16 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 27 wHigESif h ul;wd k @avSydk @ol 17 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 60 v,form;ESif h wHig18 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 55 v,form;ESif h ti,fpm; rd kif;wGif;wl;ol
19 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 60 v,form;20 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm r 65 v,form;21 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 44 aus;&Gmvl}uD;22 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 40 oif;tkyfq&m23 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 43 t"rRvkyftm;cd kif;apcH&ol 24 2006 ckESpf/ atmufwd kbm usm; 56 oif;tkyfq&m
25 2007 ckESpf/ rwfv usm; 58 oif;tkyfq&m26 2007 ckESpf/ rwfv r 29 v,form;27 2007 ckESpf/ rwfv r 26 v,form;28 2007 ckESpf/ {+yDv usm; 40 oif;tkyfq&m29 2007 ckESpf/ {+yDv usm; 29 oif;tkyfq&m30 2007 ckESpf/ ZGefv usm; 63 oif;tkyfq&m
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 83/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 77
aemufqufwG J 2? qnfa=umif h epfemr_ qd k;usKd;rsm; cHpm;&rnf h&yf&Gmjynfolrsm;rS wifjyaom qnf wnfaqmufa&; uef @uGufonf hpm/
2004 ckESpf/ Zefe0g&Dv?
od k@OuUX/ twGif;a&;rSL;ucsifjynfol @ twd kifyifcHaumifpD &SmwmjzL/ jrpf}uD;em;ucsifjynfe,f?
ta=umif;t&m? ? arvdc-tifrd kifcjrpfqH kwGif qnfwnfaqmufrnf hudpP?
vl}uD;rif;cifAsm;?
txufazmfjyyg ta=umif;udpPESif h ywfoufI wefz&Jaus;&Gmae rdrdwd k @ jynfolrsm;rS rdrdwd k @ vlrsKd;pk w&yfvH k; xdcd kufepfemapEd kifaomudpPESif h ywfoufI arwWm&yfcH wifjytyfygonf?
ay (500) tjrif h&S donf h uGefu&pfjzif h rHI/ ausmufom;jznf h a&avSmifqnfwckud k *syefEd kifiHrS uefqd kif;ukr%Du wefz&Jaus;&Gmawmifbuf 3- rd kiftuGmta0;/ rvdc-tifrd kifcjrpfqH kae&mwGif r=umrDwnf aqmuf&ef &S daeygonf? TudpPonf ucsiftrsKd;om;w&yfvH k;ud k tEW&m,fusa&mufapEd kifaomudpP jzpfygonf?
qnfwnfaqmufvd kufjcif;a=umifh rdrdwd k @jynfolrsm;tay: atmufazmfjyyg qd k;usKd;oufa&mufr_rsm; jzpf
ay:vmEd kifonf[k xifjrifrdygonf?1? aus;&Gmaygif; (20) ausmf/ vlOD;a& (3000) ausmfESif h rdom;pk (500) wd k @. aexdkif&maus;&Gmrsm;a&v$rf;cH&Ed kifjcif;?2? a&v$rf;cH&r_a=umif h pd kufajrv,f,mrsm; (18˜ 000) pwk&ef;rd kifcef@ ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;oGm;Ed kifjcif;/3? a'ocHjynfolrsm;taejzifh toufarG;0rf;ausmif;vkyfief;rsm; qH k;&_ H;&um/ b0rvH kðcH jzpfvmEd kifjcif;?4? ucsifjynfolrsm;. vSyom,maom obm00ef;usifrsm; ysufpD;qH k;&_ H;&rnf jzpfjcif;/5? &mESif hcsDaom wd&dp> mefom;aumifrsm;/ opfrmefyef;rmef trsKd;rsm; qH k;&_ H;&Ed kifjcif;?6? rvdESif h tifrd kif 0gvGef;/ rvd-c&ef 0gvGef;ESif h qGrfy&mbGrf }wd*Ha'o&S d vrf;yef;qufoG,fa&;rsm;a&v$rf;cH&r_a=umif h jywfawmufoGm;Ed kifjcif;?7? c&d kifaemfESif h c&d kif*rfwd k @. ucsif&mZ0ifvm Zmwdajra'orsm; ajryH kay:rS aysmufuG,foGm;&zG,f &S daejcif;?8? ucsifjynfe,fajrmufyd kif;a'o&S d c&pf,mefomoemjyKtoif; XmecsKyfvnf; ae&maysmufuG,f&zG,f &S daejcif;?9? ucsifvlrsKd;rsm;twGuf ord kif;0if/ tav;tjrwfxm;&mae&mrsm; ysufpD;aysmufuG,foGm;&zG,f &S daejcif; ponfwd k@ ñuH&Edkifygonf?
odk @jzpfygI TpmESif htwl taxmuftxm;rSwfwrf; 2-ckud k qnfwnfaqmufa&;vkyfief;rsm; &yfqd kif;ap&eftwGuf vdktyfovdk qufvufaqmif&GufEd kifyg&efESif h oufqd kif&mtm%myd kifrsm;xH qufvuf wifjyEd kif&eftwGuf yl;wG Jwifjytyfygonf?
av;pm;pGmjzifh-
wefz&Jaus;&Gmom;rsm;tm;vH k; pkaygif;vufrSwfa&;xd k;ygonf?rdwWLud k-1? autdkiftd k (KIO)qufqHa&;&H k;/ jrpf}uD;em;òr@?2? tJef'Datau (NDAK) tzG J @ qufqHa&;&H k;/ jrpf}uD;em;òr@?3? ucsiftrsKd;om; ,Ofaus;r_Xme/ jrpf}uD;em;òr@?4? ucsif bufywpftoif;awmf XmecsKyf/ jrpf}uD;em;òr@?
5? jrpf}uD;em;òr@ uufovpftoif;awmf XmecsKyf?6? ucsifjynfe,f usrf;pmoifausmif; aumvdyf/ aemifeef;/ jrpf}uD;em;òr@?7? wefz&Jaus;&Gm aumifpD/ vufcHzd kif?
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 84/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 85/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 79
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 86/90
80 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 87/90
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 88/90
82 {&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif;
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 89/90
{&m0wDjrpfud k ydwfqd k � a&umwmwnfaqmufjcif; 83
Villages in the food zone of Irrawaddy Myitsone Dam
8/6/2019 Damming the Irrawaddy - Burmese
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/damming-the-irrawaddy-burmese 90/90
a&v$rf;cH&rnf h aus;&Gmrsm;rS vlOD;a&pm&if;
Village name
an�mfarSmfavm0f*rfZefaemif;*s0g,efa':rm,ef*geef,eftif'kef;ZGyftlavmif,efatmf&m,efZGyf&m,efcgefb,f,ef
rZGyftifa':,efcsDazGvarmfZGyf (emarmfZGyf)r*&rf,ef&Sefaigc0rf,efrmefa'gif
'GrfbefZGyfqeDcl;ref0def;qd kifavmfvd _ifqD;qa*gh0lrefwefz&Ja*Gaxmifa0&S DzppfZGyfaumhocgremZGyfqueftifqGyfZGyftif*spf&SDawG,efw,ef
No .
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1 0
1 1
1 2
1 3
1 4
1 5
1 6
1 7
1 8
1 9
2 0
2 1
2 2
2 3
2 4
2 5
2 6
2 7
2 8
2 9
3 0
3 1
3 2
3 3
3 4
3 5
Household
21
13
72
18
10
14
15
32
42
8
6
54
11
218
17
29
65
69
165
31
18
189
263
5
6
173
22
4
10
5
7
10
18
18
40
Population
113
58
386
87
57
73
77
179
401
60
51
292
109
1097
65
138
334
354
847
163
107
897
1294
25
30
1406
106
15
57
20
28
30
180
160
150