csta webinar series - may 7, 2020 impacts and...
TRANSCRIPT
CSTA WEBINAR SERIES - May 7, 2020
Impacts and lessons learned from the cancellation and postponement of
Major Sporting Events
A conversation with Benoit Girardin, LBB Strategies and 3 Canadian sport leaders :
Debra Amrstrong, Skate Canada, Ahmed El-Awadi, Swimming Canada, Eugène Lapierre, Tennis
Canada/Rogers Cup
Debra Amrstrong
Chief Executive Officier
Skate Canada
www.skatecanada.com
Ahmed El Awadi
Chief Executive Officer
Swimming Natation Canada
www.swimming.ca
Eugène Lapierre
Vice-Président de Tennis Canada
Directeur de la Coupe Rogers
www.couperogers.com
Benoit Girardin
Président
LBB Stratégies - LBB Sport
www.lbbsport.com
Prof. Sports Law, McGill, HEC, UOttawa
General Manager (now former)
ISU World Figure Skating Championships
Sport Consultancy Agency Montréal-Ottawa-Annecy
WHAT WE DO
Sporting events (bid and host)
Sports business and management
Sport and event facilities
Sports Law & risk enterprise
Revenue generation
WHO WE WORK WITH
Sports Organizations
Professional sports
Event organizers & promotors
Public partners & Sponsors
Destinations & cities
www.lbbsport.com
LBB’s Event experience
8 Olympic, Paralympic & PanAm Games
ISU World Figure Skating Championships
FIFA 2026 World Cup
Tennis Canada Rogers Cup
CFL Grey Cup
World Artístic Gymnastics
FINA Worlds aquatics
5 Jeux du Québec Finals, Canada Games
World Equestrian Games and World Cups
Panam Championships in combat sports
Swimming Canada Events
FIS Events (Alpine and Snowboard)
USports Vanier Cup
Sport tourism and hosting strategy for
multiple NSOs, IFs, sport cities and Events
companies
“TOGETHER FACING
THE STORM”
“WE ARE ALL IN THE
SAME BOAT”
“Something never
before seen in history:
a complete shutdown of
the sporting industry” JetLaw, Abigal Wood, March 21, 2020
Play Ball during the Spanish Flu
Sport has always
resisted and stayed
alive in times of crisis
EVENTS CANCELLED or POSTPONED IN CANADA
World women's hockey championship in Halifax
World figure skating championships in Montréal
World Cup cross-country skiing in Canmore + Quebec
World women’s curling championship in Prince George
Long-track speedskating events in Calgary
Arctic Winter Games March in Whitehorse
North American Indigenous Games
2020 Finales des Jeux du Québec in Laval (to 2021)
Alpine ski NorAm finals at Panorama Mountain
Tennis Canada Rogers Cup in Montreal, Toronto TBC
ITU World Series Triathlon in Montreal (fall 2020)
Montreal FI race (fall 2020
IBA men’s Olympic qualification tournament in Victoria
Olympic and Paralympic trials postponed to 2021
The RBC Canadian Open, St. George’s in Toronto
Volleyball Canada Men’s Nations League
UCI Mountain Bike World Cup in Quebec City
And many more…
EVENTS CANCELLED or POSTPONED IN CANADA
NHL suspends 2019-20 season
Major League Soccer, CONCACAF
Champions League suspended
NBA suspends season
MLB cancels the spring training and
suspends the regular season
NLL suspends 2020 season
CFL activities suspended
Toronto Defiant esports team
Overwatch League event cancelled
Spruce Meadows (Calgary) cancelled
And around the World (as of May 7)
Tokyo OPG 2020 rescheduled to 2021 Tour de France rescheduled to August 29th
Badminton Worlds rescheduled to November 2020çEuro 2020Rolland Garros pushed to September 20th
Wimbledon cancelled (1st time since WWII)World Athletics and Para Athletics rescheduled to 2022Tennis Laver Cup 2020 (Boston) postponed to 2021FINA Worlds Aquatics postponed to May 2021World Beach Games postponed to 2023IIHF Men's Worlds Ice Hockey cancelled F1 races cancelled And many more to come...
Morning Consult, found that only 48% of sports fans feel
comfortable returning to live sporting events in 2020
Seton Hall found that 72% of Americans will not return to
a sporting event until there is a coronavirus vaccine
When will they be back?
Sport Business Journal (April) asked When will fans feel
comfortable attending live events?
3% Not until 2022
46% Spring of 2021
51% In 2020 as restrictions lift
According to a report by Journal of Science, social
distancing may be required until 2022.
“FACING THE
STORM”
THE BUSINESS OF SPORT NEEDS TO RESTART
The Impacts
Financial PeopleSportLegal
1. Event expenses incurred
and nonrefundable deposits
2. Lost of event net revenues
(ticketing, merchandizing,
concessions, TV revenues,
VIK, charity, sponsorships, ancillary activities)
Financial impacts
3. Loss of Jobs-contractors4. Revenue loss for suppliers, hotels5. Loss of financial legacies and revenues for the sports federations (provincial, national, international)6. Loss of economic ROI for the destination/public partners/sponsors7. Loss of revenues for media partners and TV
Financial impacts
Human impacts
PEOPLE
Athletes + teamFans + PublicStaff +VolunteersSuppliers SponsorsMediaPublic partnersAmbassadors
Legal dimensions
Cancellation, reduction of contractual obligations because of Force Majeure (a civil law concept) or contract frustration (common law)
Force Majeure derives from civil law and refers to an unforeseeable and irresistible event which prevents or makes impossible for a party from performing or fulfilling his or her contract obligations.
Frustration implies that you need to establish that an event (COVID-19) was unforeseen by the parties, that it makes them incapable of fulfilling their obligations they agreed to, and that that event is not their fault.
Other few legal considerations
SO will require FM insurance coverage
Which insurance applies? the IF, NSF, event organizer, suppliers (hotels)
Are governments going to require enhanced health protection measures
moving forward? Events/facilities
Termination of sponsorship or funding contracts partially executed
Termination of employment respecting employment laws even if FM
Oganization/host city contracts with the IF
Need to mitigate liability exposure through renegotiated contracts and risks
transfer
Development of an event risk management strategy moving forward
WHAT’ NEXT
RESTARTING THE EVENT INDUSTRY
SCENARIO PLOTTING
1st GO FOR DOMESTIC & REGIONAL
EVENTS WITH COVID-19
2nd INTERNATIONAL EVENTS
WITH COVID-19 (travel ban lifted)
3rd COVID-19 ACCEPTED + VACCINE
REGULAR NATIONAL & INTERNATIONAL EVENTS (IN NEW NORMALITY)
KEY CONDITIONS TO RESTART
PUBLIC CONFIDENCE & ACCEPTABILITY OF COVID-19
INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL & MOBILITY
FINANCIAL VIABILITY – REDUCED REVENUES VS EXPENSES (COVID-19)
ADAPTED FACILITIES
WHO AND IOC/IF GUIDELINES ON MASS GATHERINGS
WHO AND IOC/IF GUIDELINES ON MASS GATHERINGS
Decision making factors
1. Is your sport a lower or higher risk?
2. What is the size of event?
3. Indoor vs outdoor locations
4. What is the level of risk associated with your demographics?
5. Have you or will you be ready to deploy a Risk communication strategy?
Source WHO. Considerations for sports federations/sports event organizers when
planning mass gatherings in the context of COVID-19-April 14, 2020
Hygiene/cleaning measures
Physical distancing, venue adaption
In and out rule for competitors
On site testing
New formats or competitions
No or limited fans, crowd flow
No cash payments, Touchless self serve
Virtual queuing and text messaging
Enhanced virtual experience
Masks available
Medical team on site
Isolation room, evacuation procedure
Austrian ski teamreturns to the slopes
Testing at arrival & departureSmall groupsPhysical distancing Hygiene measuresEvacuation protocolMedical team on site
“no spectators, no line judges, no ball kids and no post-match handshake at the net”
“a rare instance of live, televised sports with unmanned TV cameras stand in fixed positions”
Return to Competitions
Play Ball ! Korean Baseball
Let’s be optimistic but realisticLet’s get back to work together and restart, step by
step our event industry
How can we help you?
Comment pouvons-nous vous aidez?
Benoit Girardin
LBB Stratégies - LBB Sport
Mobile (514) 795-9536
Office (514) 389-8282
www.lbbsport.com
Webinar #5: Official Launch: Sport Tourism Event Evaluation Report (STEER)
Presenter: Iain Edmondson, Director, Legacy Delivery Ltd.
Thursday, May 14, 2020 @ 1:00 pm Eastern
As public authorities start to consider how events can be part of the COVID-19
recovery plan, it has never been more important to articulate the wider impacts of
sport events. This webinar launches the latest CSTA tool to assess the wider
tourism, social and environmental impacts of events
STEER (Sport Tourism Event Evaluation Report). STEER and STEER Pro will
enable CSTA members to report on, plan for, and quantify wider impacts,
complementing the direct economic data available from steam2.0 and steam pro2.0.
Key considerations Comments Risk factors and mitigation
Are there sports that
could be considered a
lower or higher risk?
Lower risk sports where physical
distancing is possible, e.g.
archery, shooting and some
athletics events. These will be
less of a risk if physical
distancing advice for athletes,
coaches and spectators is
followed.
Higher risk sports include contact
sports. Physical and close
contacts among players increases
risk of transmission of COVID-19.
Consider:• daily health check of
competitors• Physical (at least 1 meter)
separating of competitors,
officials, spectators and
support staff
• thorough disinfection
and cleaning
after/between
bouts/competitions
• sharing of equipment should
be prohibited, in particular
ensuring that water bottles
and cups are not shared
• consider safe utilization of
the closed containers for all
disposable and reusable
hygiene materials (e.g.
tissue, towels, etc.).
Source WHO. Considerations for sports federations/sports event organizers when planning mass gatherings in the context of COVID-19-April 14, 2020
Size of event The size of the sporting event
affects the risk.
Physical distancing of
spectators must be
maintained if spectators and
support staff are to be
present during the event.
Other factors must also be
considered across the
different target groups:
• participants (includes
officials)
• Spectators
• host country (international
events)
• other participating countries
(international events).
Conducting sporting events
with designated seats in
arenas with widely spaced
spectators for at least 1-metre
physical distancing, numbered
seats for contact tracing,
temperature monitoring at
entrances and provision of
visual reminders such as
stickers or wrist stamps may
reduce the possibility of
incidental contact.
Source WHO. Considerations for sports federations/sports event organizers when planning mass gatherings in the context of COVID-19-April 14, 2020
Indoor or outdoor locations Outdoor events will be better
ventilated than indoor events.Venue facilities Requires liaison with the venue
owners to ensure the facilities do or
can comply with WHO and national
recommendations during the COVID-
19 pandemic.
Source WHO. Considerations for sports federations/sports event organizers when planning mass gatherings in the context of COVID-19-April 14, 2020
Demographics (age and health)
Competitors of sporting events tend to
be younger and healthier than
spectators. However, some
competitors, coaches and support
staff may have underlying health
conditions.
The age and health of spectators and
other staff will vary.
Pre-travel and pre-event health
checks are highly
encouraged/mandatory to ensure
exclusion of those with potential
additional risks (co- morbidities,
medications, allergies)
Riskcommunication
Ensure public health advice is
available before and during the
event to all participants, staff, and
personnel of all relevant stakeholders
Display signs to inform spectators
and support staff about ways in
which they can prevent themselves
from getting infected with COVID-19
and passing the virus to others.
Source WHO. Considerations for sports federations/sports event organizers when planning mass gatherings in the context of COVID-19-April 14, 2020