csec commissioner's report 2011-2012

8/13/2019 CSEC Commissioner's Report 2011-2012

1/56

Communications

Security

Establishment

Commissioner

2011-2012

AnnualReport


2/56

O$$'!# $ C**+'!a'+/ S#!'

E/a)'/&*#+ C**'//'+#

P.O. B 1984, Sa'+ B

Oaa, O+a'

K1P 5R5

T#).: 613-992-3044

Fa: 613-992-4096

W#/'#: .!/#!-!!/.%!.!a

M'+'/# $ P)'! W(/ a+"

G#+*#+ S#'!#/ Ca+a"a 2012

Ca. N. D95-2012

ISSN 1206 - 7490

C# &/: Ma)a(


3/56

J= 2012

!= > ">= D=

!G= G.&. B=, 13 F>>

101 C>>= B D, "> >

#, #=>

K1A 0K2

D ':

= > >= 273.63(3) > Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac, I < > > >= > >

A 1, 2011, > ! 31, 2012, > > = > =,

P.O. Box/C.P. 1984, Station B/Succursale B

Ottawa, Canada

K1P 5R5

(613) 992-3044 Fax: (613) 992-4096

CANADA

Communications Security

Establishment Commissioner

The Honourable Robert Dcary, Q.C.

Commissaire du Centre de la

scurit des tlcommunications

Lhonorable Robert Dcary, c.r.


4/56


5/56

ANNUAL REPORT 20112012

TABLE OF CONTENTS

B> > H>=> &> D, %.C. /2

C> C>= = > > = > >

>= = == =

==>= = /26

4. A== > C'EC >= = == >= /28

5. A== > > > C== = =>= >

G>= C= = > = 2011 /30

6. = 7. A== > == = C'EC = 2010 = ==

> == = C'EC = 2011 >

>= > > C== =


6/56

ANNUAL REPORT 20112012

C> C'ECR A /34

D = Sec+# I'+&a#' Ac /34

A > C> = O & = + = == /37

>< Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac= Sec+# I'+&a#' Ac& > != > C> != > C>< O > !> /50


7/56


8/56

ANNUAL REPORT2

BIOGRAPHY OF THE HONOURABLEROBERT DCARY, Q.C.

H>=> &> D, %.C., >= C>

C> H>=> ! '

(= C=R ' > ' > E= A) (1970N1973),

C>-D> > & >= F> >= C== =,

=-&> C>= D= C>=, = = G=, , = T"e L'! a'd "e S"+ H#+ "e

Rea+#a#') (1983).

H > A >< 1990 > 2009. I=

2009, >= > > C> > A>= > '>

= ==, = = 2010


9/56

20112012 3

COMMISSIONERS MESSAGE

> > > =>< != > ">=

D= > I >= =>

>>= > C> = =

= > I > = = = =. I

> > > I = >=,

> > > = > > =

== =.

>- > >

=> , = >==,

> > =>, > >

C=R > == = =, >=@=, > >

> >. >= > =>=.

= > > == >=>= =

= = @ = > =>= > >

=. > ->= >=, >=

= => > >

>. I= =>=, >, > >= =>

> => > , >

>= > = >= =, =

> > < >


10/56

ANNUAL REPORT4

>, I > > = > > C'EC =

C'I'. I = > @= >.

+= = >= >= =, C'EC > => , =

== >=, > =>= = C= > = C==

> C=. H>, C'EC > = =

> >=>= C'I', = @, > =

=> >= >= C== >. I= >=

=, C'EC > >== >=>=

> = =-

, I > =

= C'EC >= @ > C'I'.

F, = C'EC >= > > =>=-C==

> C=, = =>= > >=

C== ===>= =>. >,

C'EC >===>= > C== >, => >

=, > >= != >

">= D=. >=, >, > =>

= > = @; > > C== >, > .


11/56

I= >>>= = C'EC = C'I' = = @

= >>>= = >=>= >=, >== >

> => >>= = =

>. , I = >= >= == > C'EC = C'I' . 273.63(6) >

Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac> G>=> = C>= > > = = = . A 54 > Ca'ad#a' Sec+#

I'e%%#!e'ce Se+#ce Ac> != > ' =E @ >< 'I&C P >

>=== = > =

=>=Q. I < > >=>= = 'I&C >,

> >>=, > >= >= > >= > C'EC = C'I'.

> > @ = = >==>, = >= > >

C' I'*#+ #' "e Ac#' Ca'ad#a' O#c#a% #' Re%a#' Ma"e+ A+a+, >= < > = = ==>=>= = C=.

== > > => > =

= = > ,

>= '=> A> > C>= # =

'>=-C F> > %=R = '>> > >'. I < = >>= > >

> > > = C'EC. , >

>, = = = = =>= =

> = >=>= = . =, =,

> > > >=>= > =

=- = >. >


12/56

J>= F>, >= => =,

C'EC >= J= 30, 2012. I = >>=

= I = = < > >. I < >==

> >= = . ! = = == =>= >= > = C =

> > = < > > > I >

=

D= > = = == = > ">= '

A> > >>= = >. #=

, C'EC => > = ">= D=

!=R >>> D H = > > !=.

I > => = > > = =

>= = = C'EC. H>, I < >

@ > > ">= ' A> >

> >== =>=

> > C'EC >>= = >, = I

C'ECR = >=>

>= = >=> .

ANNUAL REPORT6


13/56

MANDATE OF THE COMMUNICATIONS SECURITYESTABLISHMENT COMMISSIONER

! = > =>=:

1. $e(ie)ig CSEC ac&i(i&ie% > = > ">= D= =

A>= G= > C= > = C'EC I

= > =>= >< >= > = > = = > >>= =>=

> C'EC. > , => > C>


14/56

Reviewing CSEC activities > > = C'EC = >= , = , > > != >">= D=;

M > = C'EC > > > != > ">=

D= = > A>= G= > C=;

M > = C'EC > => >= = ==

= =>= =>> (I) C==;

=

M > = C'EC > = >

> > C== =

=.

Conducting investigations! = I < = =

>= > = > = = =>= C'EC. I = O = >, = O = C'EC

> >=== > ">= D= = C > C'EC

> > >=. I I

C'EC > > >

!= = > A>= G= > C=.

ANNUAL REPORT8


15/56


16/56

Ae* A 2>=08=B 7 G > 7 A;0= B28>=B > 7Na-#('a% Dee'ce Ac-

0=3 7 Sec.+#-1 ( I'(+&a-#(' Ac-A;08=6 > ; 0=3 > >= =>=

= =>= = > = >

G>= C=; =

() > C'EC > > = = >>=

= > =>= = == > = > =R >= >.

ANNUAL REPORT10

Protection of CanadiansCSEC is prohibited by law from directing its foreign signals intelligence

collection and IT security activities at Canadians wherever they might be in

the world or at any person in Canada.


17/56

LIMITATIONS IMPOSED BY LAW ON CSEC

Parts (a) and (b) of CSECs mandateC'ECR > >>= > >= = ==

= > >>= > >= =>= = =>=

= > = > G>= C= >

= = C==R :

1. C'EC > >< = >= =

== >>= = I C==,

> >>= = = >, > =

>= = C=, > =>=;

2. I= >== , C'EC =

= >= > => >= >= >

, P >= '% = >

==>= , = > , > > =,> > = < > G>= C= >; =

3. > > > ===>=

=>= > >==

>= = == >>= > I ,

Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac@ >>=

!= > ">= D=. =>= >=. != >= > >=>= > > = A

= >

===>= =>= > >

= > .

20112012 11


18/56


19/56

Conditions for ministerial authorizations> >= > >= = ==

>>=, != = >= = > >> C=;

M =>= > => >= >= > =>= > ; =

M > > >

C== = >= >

= = = > ==>= , = > .

> >= > > > > G>= C=, != = =;

M =>= > => >= >= > == > >= > > >= >=;

M > = >= =>=

= > =, > > = < > G>=

C= > > =; =

M > > >

C== = = =>= > =>=.

20112012 13

Ministerial authorization: authorization provided in writing by the Ministerof National Defence to CSEC so that CSEC is not in contravention of the

Criminal Codeif in the conduct of foreign signals intelligence collection or IT

security activities it should unintentionally intercept a private communication.

An authorization can be in effect for no longer than one year. In 20112012,

there were six foreign signals intelligence collection and two IT security

ministerial authorizations in effect.


20/56

ANNUAL REPORT14

E , I > C'ECR >= O

> > => >= = >= O > =

> = > >=>= >

>>= > != > ">= D= >=

C'EC > > = > => O = >>= > = O > >=

. C'EC = > = = = = >

= >. I= >=, >= > =>

> .

MINISTERIAL REQUIREMENTS AND POLICIES TOPROTECT THE PRIVACY OF CANADIANS

C'ECR >= = == = I

> = > = = Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac, > > C== = = =>= >

= =>=.

B> C'ECR >= = == = I ><

>= >= > ->- >. > >= = >== > C'ECR= , = I = = == = I

= ===>= =


21/56

>= =>= > >,

>= =:

M >= > >= == = =

Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac = = >= G>= C= == >;

M = > > > > = > =

=>=;

M >== =>= >= >

> C=; >

M = > =, > > = < > G>=

C= >.

+= >= , C > C'EC > != > ">= D= =>= >=

>= =. > = O >=

, @ , = > ==>=

, = > , > = > =, > > =

< > G>= C= >.

> = = = >=

== > > >< == ><

> !=, => =

>= =, = >

C'EC = > > >= CR = C'ECR . J= 2001

!= D >= C&&'#ca#' Sec+# Eab%#"&e'Acc'ab#%# F+a&e+$ > >=

C'EC, == @ C'EC > > == > != > ">= D= >= C'ECR > = =

20112012 15


22/56

, > = >= I > C'ECR .

> =>< > =.

#= =P+#ac Ca'ad#a', => @=. I @ C'EC> > = >

>= C'EC .

C'ECR >>= >,P+ec#'! "e P+#ac Ca'ad#a' a'dE'+#'! Le!a% C&%#a'ce #' "e C'dc CSEC Ac###e, > =>= >== = C'EC >, == C'EC

= ==. I >==

> > C== =

= =>= > = =>=. != > > =

> >== @ =>= >=

C'EC = >= > . I

C'ECR > = >.

ANNUAL REPORT16

Information about Canadians: any personal information (as described in thePrivacy Act) about a Canadian, including a Canadian corporation.


23/56

Canadian identity informationC'ECR > == C== = =>=,

=>= == >. H>,

= > = = C== > > > >

=>=, C'EC = > =

>>= >= > >== C== = =>=.

#= = C==.

International collaborationC'EC = > ==>= = O = 'R

">= ' A=, = K=>=R = => >

>= =>R =R > >< >==. ! < > = = >

@ = > = = >>= >

> C==. E = C'EC = >=>=== >, < > = =>= >=

= > @ . F>

= >>= , C'ECR @ >

= = >= @ > >==

= . D= == C'EC

> === > @== > = >= > Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac= > > = C'EC (. 47).

20112012 17


24/56

COMMISSIONERS OFFICE ANDREVIEW PROCESS

I < > = > , > =

-=, @. I= 2011N2012, R = $1,942,429, =

> = > >

= , > >= .

Ae* D> 2011N2012 ' E= >

# > C>= > C==. I I

> = = == I C'EC > =>< != > ">= D=

= A>= G= > C=.

Selection of activities for reviewI - = = > > =, . I >= > > =. ! = I

= >< C'EC >= = = >= = > =

> C'EC. I > > > C > C'ECR == > >

!= > ">= D= >= C'ECR > = = , > = > = > C'EC >=

> >= =>=-> > > C==.

ANNUAL REPORT18


25/56

& >==, = > >:

M >=> C'EC >= > = > => > =>= > C==;

M =, = ==, >

= > = =- ;

M = == = > > >

=>> = > ;

M C> @ >>-; =

M = = >== , =

> = >< J C=. !

@ = = =>= > , =

C'EC >> = =

= > > >= >. ! =>=

>= = >== > >

C'ECR == > = > =>< .

E = = C'ECR =

= > , >, >== >

@.

Legal $e#'i$eme&%: I C'EC > >= =

>= Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac, P+#ac Ac, C+#'a% Cde, Ca'ad#a' C"a+e+ R#!" a'd F+eed&= = > = >=, = = >=

J C= .

20112012 19


26/56

Mii%&e$ial $e#'i$eme&%: I C'EC > >=

= >= =, >>=

@ = >= > .

P!licie% ad "$!ced'$e%: I C'EC > >

> = > = > = >

> = >= >= = = > >

C==. I > => > =

> = >. I > C'EC >

= >

.

= > >== > >= = = >

=>= = > >>= >

> C==.

! > >=

. I => > C'EC

>= > = ==. A , I =>

> >>- = = .

> > > C'ECR

= > > = > >= >>. #=

= = >

>>= O , > > C'EC

>= == = , , >, = >

> > = =>= > >

> > . > > >

ANNUAL REPORT20


27/56

> . ! > > >

> C==.

> !> = Ae* E> > > >

>< (. 50).

Recommendations'= 1997, = I != >

">= D= 68 >. I= >, >

>== 133 > -

>= = > > = >=

. , C'EC > = >= > >= >= 15 >


28/56

OVERVIEW OF 20112012 FINDINGS

D= 2011N2012 >= , I >

!= > ">= D= >= C'EC .

>= = > > =

> O > = >= 273.65(8) >

Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac.

The resultsE I > = =

> C'ECR = =. #, I < > >

> C'EC , I =

> = > = >= > I

=>=.

I= > = = >

> > > C>


29/56

20112012 23

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE SEVEN REVIEWS SUBMITTEDTO THE MINISTER IN 20112012

1. CSECs retention and disposal of interceptedor copied communications

Background -== = > >= =>= = = =

> =>== > = > C'EC = = (>) = > (>=) > =>=

@. C'ECR >= = == = I > = =

=>= = > > @ > Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac @ C'EC > > > C==. I =

= = > > ===>= = >=.

A G>= C= =>=, C'EC >

@ = >. Acce I'+&a#' Ac=P+#ac Ac> >= = , = >=>=, > >=. F =>=,

C'EC, > = >= =>= > =>= >C'EC > =

>= > =>= >=. => >= >

> > = = = > >=@=, = = > = > = I => C'ECR =>=

= > > >=

>


30/56

> = >= = == >>= = I

>> => >

>= = >. I @

=> > = >- = =>>-

> > C'EC =>= = > > =>= = > > @

> = >= > C'EC

= = >>= > > C==.

=>= = > > > = C'EC >

>=. H>, C'ECR =>== > = > =

>= = == = I > >== =

> . I => C'EC > > >.

I > >= C'EC >= .

ConclusionI >= C'EC >= =>= = >

= > = = >= = .

ANNUAL REPORT24


31/56

2. CSECs operations centre and particularforeign signals intelligence collectionactivities conducted in 2010

BackgroundC'ECR >>= = = >

C'EC = G>= C= =, ==>=

= = > == C'EC >= = ==

> = . D= >, = >

= >>=>=. A > >= , =

>>= = > >>= > C > C'EC

= > > =>= > = = = > = > = > >= = 2010 = C'ECR

>= = == >>= = = >

=> >

>= > > > = >= > .

I > =>= > C'ECR >= > @ >= C= = > > C== =

=>= = >= = == > >

=. C'EC >= >.

I= => > == = >>=

=, I >= C'ECR > > =

> = >= >.!> >, C'EC

= > = >. C'EC = =>

= > = >.

H>, C'ECR >>= =>= > >

>= = > = > >>= =.

C'EC >= = >= = >>= =>=

> > =R . I =>

>>=.

20112012 25


32/56

ConclusionI >= C'EC >= =

= = =.

3. Update on an ongoing review of CSECsforeign signals intelligence sharing withinternational partners

BackgroundI > C= = > ==.

C'ECR > >= = == >>= = I

= = =

>= >= >=. C'ECR >=-== >= > O = 'R ">= ' A=,

= K=>=== > = C'EC, =, =

=, G>= C=. >> = = = > = > ==

>> =.

> = > >< @ = ==

= > >> = =>= >= =>.

G>= C=R >= > &> > '==

C>= :

= > =>= >= = =@= O >, = >>= O


33/56

>= -- = >= > C=R =>=

=>= =@, > = >= = =

= > = >== = >

=>= = >= = = C=R =>=

= == = =>= = . H>, =>= C= = > C==. A>

>> =R =, >= =

= = > >= =>= ><

=>=

=.

C> C'ECR

>= = == >>= >>>= = =

==>= =. , > > , I

> != = >= =>= >

.

Findings , I >= C'EC > >

> C== = ==>= =. F>

= = >> >=-==

>=>= > C'ECR >=

= == =>= =?

I >


34/56

4. Annual combined review of CSEC foreignsignals intelligence ministerial authorizations

Background'>= 273.65(8) > Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac@ C'EC > = >= P> =

> = > == > != > ">=

D= >= Q. A= == > >=

= == >>= >= >= I

> > > . > > ==

> >= = == >>=

>= >:

1. = = == = > >= > C'ECR

= >>=;

2. = >= >=>=->= > , =, ,

= = @= >>- ; =

3. = > = =

>= = C'EC

= >= > = >=.

Findings+= >, I C'ECR >= =

== >>= >

> C==. I >= > C'EC

= >= >. I >

>. I >= C'EC = >= >

> ==>= , = > , @ 273.65(2)(d) > Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac.

ANNUAL REPORT28


35/56

20112012 29

F> > >= = == >>= , I

= = > =>= = >

> C==, > = > = >

= = == = > = > = = == >>= >= => >== = == = >< >

= C'EC => =>>

> . C'EC , >, = ==

> >>= >, == >= = >

>>= > > C==.

I= >=, > > >=

= O = = == >= = >< > R

>>=. -

= = = =>= = > >

C==. I= >=, = =>= >= =

>= C'ECR ==>= = =>

. I =>= >

C'ECR >= = == =>=-=

=.

I = >.

A > = > 2011N2012 >= >, I < =

>= >< != > ">= D= > > = > >, I = !=


36/56

=>= = I == C'EC => =

>= =

== . C= > > >>= > >

= > >= > > C'ECR

== >. " , I = > C'ECR

= > >< C'EC

> >>=.

ConclusionA >< == >= > = 2010 = == >

> > C== = =>= > G>= C=

= >=, > C'EC >== > > C==.

C== = =>= = >>=

>= > >== C== = =>=. #= =


37/56

FindingsI

= @ > = > = .

> G>= C=

= = > = . ! > = >= >

>== C== = =>=; > C'EC >=

= == >; = > > C==

= =>=.

I >= C'ECR > > C== =

=>= > G>= C= = >= =

>= > = > =

= > = >= > C'EC =

>>= > > C== = C'EC

=> >, = = >= , > =

>.

I > =>= > > = < >

> = => =

>== > =>

> >

> > C==.

Conclusion! => = = >, > = > => = >>= >

20112012 31


38/56

> C== = > > >, I C'EC >

> > > == = C'EC.

A>= > C'EC, > = = = ==

> C== = = > >

=> > > = >>= >. C'EC > @ C'EC

>= = == = I > > =

> > = > =

== = > = . > >

== >: @ => > == = >

> >=; = =>< > =,

> >>= > > C== >

ANNUAL REPORT32


39/56

> >>- . > ==

= C'EC > = = = = = > > 2010

== = C'ECR = , => > . I = = == = I

== = @= >= = C'EC >

> ==, >= >= > == => > >

>= > = ==.

2010 conclusion! > == = 2010 => = =

>, = = >==, = >=== >=

>=@= >= >< ==, = =

= = > >= = =.

2011 findingsI= 2012, I = = == = I

== > C'EC = = 2011, =

@= >= = C'EC > > ==.

I = = = C'EC = >

> ==. #= => C'EC =

= > > = > C'EC = >=>= >=== C== = =>=.

20112012 33


40/56

= = >= > =>= . F> > >

== = > = I , I < > >

=> C'EC = > == = =>= =

> >=. I => C'ECR > >

>>->= .

2011 conclusionI < C'EC >> > > >= = >=

> == > = 2011. ! >

== = 2011 => =

@ >>- . I => = =.

COMPLAINTS ABOUT CSECS ACTIVITIES

I= 2011N2012, I => > C'EC

= =>=. => = C'EC

>= = > > C=.

F> >= >, C'E C>-..).

DUTY UNDER THE SECURITY OF INFORMATION ACT

I = Sec+# I'+&a#' Ac> =>= >< >= > = > =

> = > >>= =>= O

= =>= = > C'ECR O >= >=

= =.

"> >


41/56

ACTIVITIES OF THE COMMISSIONERS OFFICE

Review Agencies Forum & A= F>< > >< ,

' = I== & C>

@ >= 5 > Pb%#c Se+a' D#c%+e P+ec#' Ac.I < >== >

C>R > == >

C> = >= > =.

Other activitiesI= ' > > = I== = ' ' > C>= =.

>R > >= >= =


42/56

I= #>, R E D>, D> > #>= =

>= >= A=

> JR >==, Te+++#&, La a'd De&c+ac: 10 ea+ ae+9/11. = >= =>= , = >

> > = > C== > ><

= > =

. > > >= = = K=>< = > 'I&C, I

= = >= > = >= = =-> === >

= == = = C== = ==>=

>=.

A> = #>, > >< = >== >=

=>= > => =>>, Ve+ 'e#'5!+a#' d d+# 4 %a #e +#5e e de ec"'%!#e de 5c+#5. >== >= Ce'+e de +ec"e+c"e e' d+# b%#c > = > !>=. ! E D> =

= = > >= =>= = =>=

= = =>= > =>> =

>>= = =>= . >== > > >= > =

=, , =>=

= .

I= ">== > C== A>>= > ' = I==

' (CA'I') = #. F> 10 , > CA'I' >== = > =

= ==. = R


43/56

> C'I' > 'I&C. > > C'EC

> C'I', > =

>=

> C'EC O >< =

=>= > C'I'. , I = >= C =

= >= >> > = > >>>= =

>= > > =>= > C'EC = C'I'. A I

=> = >=, >>=, = = >,

> >>>= = 'I&C = , > ==

= > , = > >

> =@ H>=> J D== #RC>==>.

I= >= > >> > ==

>>>= > > >= C'EC-C'I' .

C'EC = >=>=, = >

=>> = = C'ECR

. F> >=, C'EC = > =

= == > > = = > > > != > ">= D= = > =: C'ECR >= = ==

= ==>= =; = > C'I' = C'ECR

> > > =>= 12 = 21 > CSIS Ac; = C'EC I

>= = > > G>= C= = C+#'a% Cde = F#'a'c#a% Ad'#+a#' Ac.

20112012 37


44/56

# == > 2012N2013, > =

, = >: C'ECR # > C>=->< =

= =>= C'I'; = ==

>>= >= = >=; I

>= = >=; = C'ECR

= >= .

I= >=, I >== == > >= =

== >=, C'EC > > C==

= =>= > >=

=.

I= ! 2012, C= > 8 I==>= I== &

A= C>== = #. >= = == >==, = 1997. , =

> = > > >< 10 >=.

C>== >= =@ >>= > > >

> = > = > = >< =

>=. += > , => = .

'>= > > >

=== > >= >. C=

>>= > > >= = = > C>== = 1999. > > =

> = > >R

= >>R.

>>= > > C>==>, I> = !> >=

> >=>= > == = > >=. + >=>=

ANNUAL REPORT38


45/56

>=? O > = >= ? O > -

>=>= ? + > > ,

=? @>= > > I >> > > >==.

I = = = = >>= >

Na#'a% Dee'ce Ac, >>. I >= >>= = >

>=. B I >= > = >= = >=>.

F=, I = =, C>

C>= >= = > >= >

>= = = , I < = ===.

I =>= =>= >.

20112012 39


46/56


47/56

ANNEX A: EXCERPTS FROM THE NATIONAL DEFENCE ACTAND THE SECURITY OF INFORMATION ACTRELATED TO THEMANDATE OF THE COMMUNICATIONS SECURITY

ESTABLISHMENT COMMISSIONERNational Defence Act+ Pa$& V.1

A>= C>=> = C>= = =

> > > C> C>


48/56

> > =>=

(4) I= = > > , C> >

> I=@ A.

E >=, >, .

(5) C>=, =

= = C>= = >

> > > =, > >

B>, =

(6) C> = =>= =

> C> = > A > = = > = G>=> = C>=.

=>=

(7) C> C>>= = >= > =

> = > == > != >= .

ANNUAL REPORT42


49/56

Security of Information Act

= =

15. (1) "> >= > = >= = >= 13 > 14 >=

> = =. ...

> > > > =

(5) A > >

> = = =>=-> >= >= >>=: ...

(b) >= , > => >= >< > D A>= G= > C=, = > >== >, = > =

=>= = >=R >>= >, ...

() C> >=R =

=>= > >, > >= >, C>


50/56


51/56

45ANNUAL REPORT 20112012

ANNEX B: HISTORY OF THE OFFICE OF THECOMMUNICATIONS SECURITY ESTABLISHMENTCOMMISSIONER

# > C> C= = 2003, >= C>>=

= = J 2009. H>=> C. C>, C.C., C.D., > > ' > C=, C>< D ! 31, 2010. #= J= 18, 2010, H>=> &> D, %.C., > F C> > A, >= C> (>< J= 1996 > D

= > > # = C>= = > II >

I'*#+#e Ac. D= >, C>= >>: > > C>

=> C=; = > > C'ECR .

>= > > C'EC =

>=. >= > >== C>

= I'*#+#e Ac.

>= > => Sec+# I'+&a#' Ac, O#c#a% Sec+e Ac. >= C>=, > > > = > , > =

> =>= > C'EC >= >= = =.

+ C>== > > != > ">= D=

>, C> > >, D

">= D=.


52/56


53/56


ANNEX C: EXCERPTS FROM THE NATIONAL DEFENCE ACTRELATED TO THE MANDATE OF THE COMMUNICATIONSSECURITY ESTABLISHMENT

C>=

>> =, >= G>= C= > : >=

= ==, = =>= =>> . C'EC > > =

= >>= = > => >= == = G>= C=R == >.

C'ECR =>= =>> > = = >== =>= .

C'EC > >= = >= > G>= C=

= > >


54/56


55/56


ANNEX D: 20112012 STATEMENT OF EXPENDITURES

Standard Object Summary ($)

' = B= 1,022,064

=>>= = >= 11,652

>>= = ' ' 386,906

&= 168,110

& = !=== 235

! = ' 12,164

!= = E@


56/56

ANNEX E: COMMISSIONERS OFFICE REVIEW PROGRAM LOGIC MODEL

Plan, conduct and report on reviews

and studies of CSECs activities

Reports to Minister of

National Defence and

CSEC- assurance

- information

- findings

- recommendations

CSEC accepts and

implements advice and

recommendations

Government and public confidence in the

Notifications to Minister

of National Defence and

Attorney General of anyCSEC activity that may

not be in compliance with

the law

Annual Reports to

Minister of National

Defence for tablingin Parliament:

- assurance

- information

Support for Minister

of National Defence in

his/her accountability

for CSEC

CSEC activities based

on sound policies,

procedures and

practices

Low CSEC susceptibility to, andincidence of, lack of compliance

with the law; high level of

safeguarding privacy

ACTIVITIES

OUTPUTS

OUTCOMES

(Immediate)

(Intermediate)

al)

csec commissioner's report 2011-2012

Documents