crowdcity the first online platform for receivables trading
TRANSCRIPT
Agenda
CrowdCity
How it works
Business strategy
Investor information
Market analysisI.
II.
V.
III.
IV.
3
Invoice Trading allows SMEs to assign their receivables directly to investors through an online Marketplace that
efficiently manages all flows of the transaction.
Invoice Trading: the Italian market vs the UK Benchmark
In the U.K. invoice trading volume achieved the £ 1Bln milestone in the summer 2016. In Italy, the market, with € 21Mln
of traded volume, is at an early stage of a promising growth path.
3,9
13,516,3
18,221,0
0
5
10
15
20
25
0,5 3,3 18,7 35,9 52,5103,4
195,5
314,0
434,8
618,4
796,3
0
200
400
600
800
1.000
8,1% Ann. yield
Italy
20 Investors
40Businesses financed
~ 220Sold invoices
36K Avg. invoice
value70 gg.
Avg. maturity
€ 21M Invested
United Kingdom
97,8%
Settled transactions Annualised yield
Market size (£, Mln)
Write downs: 0,3%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
Yield Bad debts (right scale)
Market size (€, Mln)
I. Market analysis Source: MarketInvoice, Politecnico di Milano, data elaboration CrowdCity. Data refers to major players in their respective geographical area and represent almost the entire market
4
The Italian market for trade receivables is currently worth € 570Mld
Trade receivables market data (2015)
Trade receivables 2015 € 570Bln
Yearly growth (YoY) 3,0%
Businesses insolvency (YoY) -6,0%
Average loss on trade receivables 3,0%
Average payment days 95 days
Highlights
Business lending B2B average payment terms
55
27
38
17 18
56
80
35
51
1621
69
0
20
40
60
80
100
Contractual payment extension Effective payment extension
FOCUS: Factoring in Italy (2015)
Receivables advanced 9,8%
Yearly growth 3,0%
Average advance 80%
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
Prestiti fino ad 1 anno a società non finanziarie residenti in ItaliaValore nominale dei crediti acquistati pro soluto da intermediari finanziari ex 106 TUB
305 Bln
281Bln19 Bln
11Bln
68%
32%
56 Bln
Nonrecourse
Recourse
Source: Banca d’Italia, Politecnico di Milano, Euler Hermes, Intrum Justitia, data elaboration CrowdcityI. Market analysis
Loans up to 1 year to Italian non-financial sector
Face value of receivables acquired by financial intermediaries ex 106 TUB
570 Bln
570 Bln
56 Bln10%90 Bln
16%
5 Bln1%
421 Bln73%
Factoring
Invoicediscounting
Other
Unservedmarket79 Bln
14%22 Bln4%
35 Bln6%
436 Bln76%
P.A.
B2C
Export
B2B
Invoices Collection
Potential market
Outstanding invoices and collection solutions (2015)
(re
ba
se
d 1
00
)
5
The Invoice Platform - Competitive Advantages Innovation Efficiency
Price Settlement
The trade is settled within 5 days from assignment
In a single payment, equal to 100% of the sale price
Via wire transfer directly between seller and buyer
Service features
The subscription process is entirely digital and requires 10 minutes
The discount rate is negotiated directly between parties
Maximum flexibility in terms of frequency of use (i.e. no lock in period, minimum
commitments, etc.)
“Mediatore Creditizio" (i.e. authorized financial intermediary)
He assesses the obligor’s rating and the credit quality of every single transaction
According to his market’s knowledge and the analysis provided by the external
Rating Agency, he suggests the appropriate discount rate for each transaction
He identifies businesses that can benefit from the platform’s service
Online Contracts Management
The platform manages all communications between the parties
Contracts are underwritten with digital signature
Contracts are delivered with legally certified emails (PEC)
II. CrowdCity
CrowdCity innovates and simplifies the receivables assignment process
6
Seller
Seller
Businesses issue invoices to their customers in
connection to the delivery of goods or provision
of services.
The Company in need for cash can find on our
marketplace specialized Investors willing to
anticipate the liquidity in exchange for a
discount on the invoices’ face value.
The Platform approves as eligible only
receivables which are verified, legally
transferable and not overdue, only if related to
B2B invoices of € 25,000 or more, regularly
registered in the seller’s accounting books and
issued in compliance with the Italian law.
The receivables, sold with no recourse (i.e. “pro
soluto”), are rated according to their credit
worthiness which provides an indication of the
appropriate discount rate.
The sale price is transferred in a single payment to the bank account of the seller, within 5 days from the signing of the Sale
Agreement
III. How it works
The Seller cashes in the selling price within 5 days
Obligor
Investor
Seller
Seller
7
The Mediatore suggests the
appropriate discount rate, which is
equivalent to the current market
price of the receivables
The Mediatore Creditizio,
duly authorized by the
Regulator, analyses all the
information in his
possession to express an
indication of the appropriate
discount rate.
In his analysis the Mediatore
relies on his experience,
current market conditions
and his estimate of the
investors’ risk appetite.
Mediatore Creditizio
To assign a rating, Cerved
evaluates the company
financials, any prejudicial
event, the industry trends
as well as all information
gathered by reliable and
official data sources.
Cerved rating relies on
“Payline Decision”, the
innovative information
service that monitors in real
time payment habits of
Italian SMEs and their
Directors.
Cerved Rating Agency
Cerved uses a scale of 13
notches, 8 of which are
considered “Investment Grade”
CrowdCity’s analyses
independently the following
Company’s information:
Balance sheet strength analysis
Income statement profitability analysis
Cash flow balance analysis
Industry trends
The result is then published
on the Platform in a specific
Credit Report.
CrowdCity
The report is the reference tool
to analyse the risks of the
transaction
Obligors undergo 3 levels of credit analysis
III. How it works
8
The Sale Agreement: 100% online Management & Direct Settlement
The investor
downloads the
receivables Sale
Agreement and
underwrites it
with its digital
signature.
The seller is then
notified of the
investor’s
purchase and in
his turn he signs
the contract with
his personal
e-signature.
E-SIGNATUREPURCHASE
The receivables
are uploaded,
rated and
published on the
Marketplace.
The Investor sets
his eligibility
criteria and start
the selection
process.
The final portfolio
of Receivables to
be bought may be
identified either
through manual
selection or
automatically
thanks to the
AutoBid tool.
The contract is
finally sealed and
declared as not
amendable only
once CrowdCity’s
verifications are
successfully
completed.
CrowdCity then
notifies the Obligor
of the assignment
of the receivables,
via legally certified
emails, and
provides indication
of the bank account
details of the new
legal Entity to be
paid (i.e. the
Buyer).
NOTIFICATION
The investor
settles the sale
price via wire
transfer.
At the maturity
date of the
receivable, the
Obligor pays,
again via wire
transfer, the
invoice face
value directly to
the Investor (no
flows of
payments are
handled by the
Platform).
SETTLEMENT
CrowdCity verifies
that the Sale
Agreement is
properly defined
and completed,
and certifies the
official date of
both e-
signature’s.
Seller and buyer
can always access
for their perusal,
within the
Personal Area
section of the
website, the
contracts signed
by their
counterparty.
VERIFICATION
III. How it works
9
Beyond the Invoice Trading - Supply Chain Financing
IV. Business strategy
Strategy
Potential Sellers may be identified directly by the
Obligors, which are usually either multinational
corporations or players with a national footprint
with high credit standing.
Crowdcity analyses the Obligor’s supply chain to
identify businesses with solid fundamentals,
potentially interested in optimizing their working
capital.
The Obligor introduces CrowdCity to its interested
suppliers, facilitating the On-Boarding process.
Strengths
The relationship with the Obligor allows us to collect
privileged information about the potential seller.
The Obligor can confirm the quality of its business
relationship with the supplier.
The Obligor can thus rely on suppliers with a properly
managed cash flow cycle, and eventually may even
negotiate more favourable payment terms.
Supply chain
creditworthiness
Obligor
Large multinational company benefiting of a proven reputation and credit standing
AAABB -
10
23%
10%
67%
Discount rate
CrowdCity
Mediatore
Investor
Return distribution
REVENUES BREAKDOWN
Obligor
Mediatore
Investor
Face Value
1/3 of return
70% of commission
Alignment of interests between our Network and the Investors
Registered at the Albo dei Mediatori, they identify and
source different financing solutions for their clients. As
independent legal entities, they provide useful insights
and opportunities on the SMEs landscape. As sponsors,
they introduce and promote CrowdCity’ service to
businesses with liquidity issues/constraints.
Mediatori Creditizi
Professionals within the business consultancy sector,
they recommend CrowdCity as solution provider for
supply chain optimization. They seek out companies
that, even though fundamentally solid, still need to
optimize their liquidity management without
compromising the quality of their products/services
Financial Consultants
With regards to short term financing, CrowdCity allows
banks to offer a more effective service to their clients.
Where traditional banking fails to meet expectations (e.
insufficient credit lines, heavy capital constraints, etc.)
CrowdCity can complement their offering by providing a
fresh and efficient alternative solution.
Banks
Cash flow sequence
IV. Business strategy
11
Invoices as an asset class
Financial instrument: trade debt
Repayment: self-liquidating, zero-coupon
Duration: 30 – 180 days
Ticket size: from 25.000 € to 1.000.000 €
Risk-reward: credit risk + cash urgency
premium
0,0% 0,1% 0,2% 0,7%
3,7%
9,4%
15,8%
18,7%
22,1%
11,6%10,5%
3,9% 3,4%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
A1.1 A1.2 A1.3 A2.1 A2.2 A3.1 B1.1 B1.2 B2.1 B2.2 C1.1 C1.2 C2.1
Cerved rating’s distribution
(avg. 2008 - 2014)
Sellers
Obligors
1-Y P(d) 0,00% 0,00% 0,00% 0,00% 0,01% 0,11% 0,27% 0,73% 1,60% 3,58% 7,08% 16,33% 52,78%
Investment Grade Speculative Grade
Risk metrics and investor’s risk management toolbox
2,0%
2,5%
3,0%
3,5%
4,0%
4,5%
5,0%
5,5%
6,0%
Average default rates -
subjects surveyed by Cerved
Risk Management tools
CrowdCity’s company report
Cerved credit rating report (ECA approved by ESMA,
in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009)
Payline, the receivables’ settlement monitor
Diversification
Systemic risk: low correlation with financial markets
V. Investor information Source: Cerved, data elaboration CrowdCity
The Risk management process consists of a thorough credit analysis and the selection of properly diversified portfolios.
CrowdCity analyses the worthiness of every obligor and approves as eligible only the ones rated at investment grade level.
Contacts
Piazzale Luigi Cadorna, 13 Milano
Tel: + 39 02 89095407
Fax: +39 02 89092583
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.crowdcity.it
Disclaimer
The data and information contained in this
document do not in any way constitute
solicitation to the public savings.
The content of the document is of exclusive
property of CrowdCity, is protected under
copyright law and may not be reproduced
without prior authorization from its owners.
This material is intended for the sole personal
use of the recipients that are authorized for
strictly personal purposes, to save, record and
print the data and information it contains.
In no case may the recipient to publish,
retransmit, redistribute or reproduce in any
way any information in any form to third
parties.
It is also forbidden to use the content for
public purposes or in the context of economic
or commercial activity.
All rights reserved