crossfire comments · • 25mm english civil war • 2smm napoleonic ware infantry, dm41ry,...
TRANSCRIPT
CrossFire Comments • Challenges Garners Preconseptions.
• Superb. • Original.
• Rulers Not Needed. • Plays Quickly
• Reality Based. • Recommended.
• Merchanisms Do Not Get in the
Way of Tactics
• No Rebasing.
• Company Packs A Good Idea
• You Can Smell The Smoke and
Taste the Dirt.
• Play This Game.
· If you play WWII this is for you!
WWI 20MM • Brits • Scots • Gennans • French • Anzacs • Equip.
Ne-w
DBR Rules
1. 1 $14.99
STRATEGOS #2
WWII 20MM • Buildings • Eastern Front • Western Front • The Pacific • The Desert
SEND $3 FOR CATALOGUE TO WARGAMES OR FREE WITH ORDER OR FREE BULK MAIL
SAY WHAT YOU WANT
Artie Conliff e ($19.95)
HOVELS Ltd. • La Hay Saint Fann Set (25) • Stone Tower (25) • ACW/Wild West (25) • Samurai Vi llage (25) • Fann Accesories (25) • 238 Row of 3 Shops with Detachable
Roofs (15/20) • Ditch & Bank ( 15) • Roman Marching Camp. (15)
$18.95
New From Essex & Dixon (V OTED #1 IN Q UALIT Y)
25MM • Multi Head Vikings • Multi Saxons • British Napoleonics • French Napoleonics • ACW lO 366 • Old West to 69 • Wild West Mexicans • Multi Normans • Ancient Persians
15MM Ancient/Biblical • Hurri-Mitanian (Biblical) • Dacian • Etruscan E. Roman Etc. • Sassanids • Carthaginian
15MM Medieval/Renaissance • English • Spanish • Persian • Reiters • Byzantine (1250-1450)
15MM Napoleonic • Bavarian • Dead & Wounded
15 MM Franco Prussians (Coming Shortly, Samples Here Now)
VENE VIDI VINCI (Medieval & Shield Decals)
METAL BASES
($3.99)
BOOK.S AC1 Shako Napol. Rules $19.95 AC2 Spearhead WWII $24.95 AC3 Advanced Armati $19.95 AC4 Spearhead E. Seen. $18.95 AC5 Spear Desert Seen. Sl8.95 G4 Tactica Medieval $19.99 G66 Guerilla Rules $13.99 G37 Fire & Fury ACW $24.95 G62 Fire & Fury Seen (E) $19.95 G65 DBR List Ill $13.99 G68 DBR ECW Scenarios $13.99
IWARGAMES. BOX 278, ROUTE 40 EAST TRIADELPHIA, WV 26059-0278 (304) 547-0000 e.mail [email protected]
Sam
ple
file
SOME OF WHAT'S NEW FROM GHQ Leclerc MBT N116
( )
1:285 Scale
M2 "Long Tom" w/ Mack NO US68
Archer UK53 CA Good Hope GWB20
40mm Bofors w/ Morris 4x6 UK54
French
Colonel
British Line Grenadier
NAPOLEONIC REBEIJIJION
These IOmm (N scale) Waterloo Era figures are the most precise, detailed Napoleonics ever
produced for gaming and dioramas.
British Line Flank Company
Bugler
Made of I 00% Britannia Pewter
French Foot Artillery Officer
French Legere Bugler
French Sapeur
British Royal Artillery officer
British
Colonel
British Royal Artillery man
FOR MORE INFORMAT I ON, SEE OUR W EBSITE, OR SEND $3.00 FO R GHQ's CURRENT CATALOG
GHQ, 28100 WOODSID E RD. SHOREWOOD MN 55331 (612) 374-2693 fax (61 2) 470-4428
www.~hqmodcls.com
Sam
ple
file
***VISIT OUR NEW WEB SITE - http://users.aol.com/Brookhobby
FoUNDRY Now available at your local hobby shop, or directly from Brookburst Hobbies!
zti'EZIV- LO'\VBR PRICES! Yes, we're now able to offer you lower prices on most of the Wargames Formdry litre! The new s ugges ted retaiJ prices on 25 mm figures are as follows:
*25mm Foot/Mounted Figures: *2Smm Horse Figures:
$1.20 each, or $11.50 for a Pack of 10 $1.70 each, or $15.00 for a Pack of 10 $1.20 for a Pack of 10 *2Smm Shields/Spears/Standards:
1t Prices currently remain as before for: 25mm Equipment, Vignette, and SSG Series; 15mm Burgundian Series: 20mm WW2 Series; 1/72 Arab-Israeli War Series; 40mm American Civil War Series However, further changes are planned for the future, and all prices subject to change without notice .
.r Note that at these new lower prices, quantity discounts are no longer available.
NewRang~ - LATEST NEW RELEASES! NewStriu -•25mm North European
Bronze Age 1200-900 BC Warriors
•25mm Blbllca1 Ware Mtd. Messengers/Scouts Egyptian Civilians Vignettes
•25mm Napoleonic Wars Scots Greys" Dragoons British Heavy Cavalry Horses
• 25mm American Civil War1861-1865
Infan try in Kepi and Sack Coat, Grea t Coat Civilians
• 40mm American Civil War Union and ~ftlt:rate lrrfontry, Owolry, Artilltry
• 25mm American Civil War U.S.Infontrv full dress, Union & Cc11[t:tfervte 'Smnce Dress, 1861
• 1n2 SI!Qle Arab-Israeli Wars lsntdi PaiTIS, Antbs
• lSmm Barons' Ware, 1200-1300A.O.
Mounkd and Foot • 2Smm Biblical Wars
Egyptums, Nu/Mns, Hillites, Cilhlulnite, St11 Ptople
• 25mm Boer War BrilisJ! •11!1 Botr lrifrmtry, Cllw/ry
• 1Smm Burgundlanlltallan, Ware Of The Roses
Owolry, Footmen, Artilltry • 25mm Chlna 1839-1900
Orin~ ll'lfJ'malist, Taiping Infantry, /:;VtT Victorious lfnrty
• 2Smm Crimean War British, Fn:nch, Tur*$, IUlSSions
• 2Smm Early A mer. Indians Soulhtr11 and Norlhtnr Tribt:s
• 25mm Elizabethans Infantry, Qroalry, Artilluy
• 25mm English Civil War • 2Smm Napoleonic Ware Infantry, Dm41ry, Artilltry Fn:nch 1807-151 Austrians
• 2Smm franco-Prusslan War 1805-15,8/zvQru~riS 1811-15, Polish frtneh and PrussfAn ltrfontry, and Dutch UtnCD'S, British Ol!Jil}ry, Artilluy 1809-15, Vigmttt sns
• 2Smm french Revolution • 25mm N. Amer. War o/1812 1789-1802 Arrltrialn and Britishft=anadian
Fn:nch ~ulttrs, Ciuiliatl$ and Sans lnfontry, Artilluy Culolles, Pruss;Q,15, AustriarJS • 25mm North West Frontier (of
• 25mm General Purpose Indla), 1880-1900 p.,ck and Dntfl Animals, Shap ami British, Sikh~ Guides, Bengal Acassorits, Ct~~tes, Barrds, <tc. lAncers, Cu tlS, Afghans
• 2Smm Great War,1914 -1918 • 2Smm Perelan & Peloppone-British & Ccmmonwtallh, French, sian Ware 490 B.C. - 390 B.C.
Cmtutns; Infantry, Artilluy, Tanlcs Grtdls & SpaTial! Hqplitts, Gr«* Lt. • 2Smm Hundred Yeare War l!rfontry & Owolry,lmmcn1als,
Persian lnfanlry 11nd Qroalry Mmmkd and Foot Knighls, • 25mm Pirates •- »uccanee-Bowrntn, lrrfontry "" D ·~
• 2Smm Indian Mutiny 1670-1700 British 1111d Loyal Sikhs, Mutinerrs, 12/righly indiuidUill jigun:s! Nghan Tribtsittm; lnfrmtry, • 25mm Polish Army Late 16th CA!XIIry, Al'lilltry, Utplumts to mid 17th century
• 2Smm Marlburlan Wars Infantry, Olwlry, Wing..S HuSSIIrs lnjrmrry, _CIIviJlry, Artt11try, Swttles • 2Smm Annie& & Enemies of aiul RllSSIIlns Roman Republic: 250-150 BC
• 25mm Maxlmllllan Romans, Cilts, Spanish, Adventure 1861-1867 Olrthaginians
Fn:nch and J>1ttican lnfarotry, • 25mm Early Imperial Romans Owolry, Art1lltry Legicnurries, Aur1l iarie, CAvalry
*** Trade and Dealer lfUJuiries are Welcome! ***
• 25mm Late Roman Empire Romans, Saxons, Picts, Fn~nks, Arthurinn Trrfontry and Ol!Jil}ry
• 25mm Samurai: 16th Century Samut~~i, AshigtUU, Ninjll, HtrOt:S
• 2Smm Sikh Wars British and Sikh Offrcmt. lnftmtry, Artillery, Owolry, and tsmgol l.Jtncn-s
• 25mm Swalu Gun and Equipment Range
Mon: than /0 arlillety pituS, MLriiDXlllhrough WW I
• 25mm Vikings, Nomans & Saxons
Infantry, Bowmen, Owolry • 25mm War of the Ro.u
Mount..S and Foot Knights, lnfontry, A.rlilluy
• 2Smm Zulu Ware 1879 British lnfimry and Qroalry, Natal Natiw Cimtingmt, Zulus
• 20mm Second World War Britislt and Ccmmonwttlllh1 Amtriaans, Fn:nch, Polish t939, Russians, Ctr11wns, ltalians, Japantu, £11ropt11n Resislaf!C4 Tank Cm.vs
~~~~ ... ~~~~~ SHIPPING- ln U.S.A., SS.OO flat fee for any order sent via regular UPS or
' IMPORTED HOBBY PRODUCTS FROM AROUND THE ~RLD'
12188 Broolchurst Street, Garden Grove, CA 92840, U.SA Phone (714) 636-3580 or use our 24 hour fax: (714) 636-9150 E-Mail - [email protected] Web Site- http:/ / users.aoLcom/ Brookhobby Store Hours: Mon.-Thur. 10:30 AM to 8 PM; Fri . 10:30 AM to 8:30 PM;Sat. lO AM to 7 PM;Sun.ll AM toS PM, US. Pacific time.
Post Office; for 2nd Day or Next Day Air, billed at actual cost. To Canada, $8.50 flat fee. For rest of world, allow 40% of merchandise total fo.r Surface Mail, 80% for Air Mail (excess will be credited). FOR U STJNGS: - In U.SA., indicate which Lists are desired, and include $1.00 handling total. Warpmes Foundey Listing (non-illus.) is $3.00. Sample figures available for most lines, Sl .00 per line requested. Reat of world - p lease send self-addressed envelope with two IRCs for Listings.
We also accept c:hecks for domestic orders and inlemational money ordct"S (in U.S. dollars S) for aU Others.
Sam
ple
file
lNFANTRY SQUARES 5
COWNIAL RULES 17
THE REPUBLICAN ROMAN ARMY 25
• e ouner
ARTICLES
INFANTRY SQUARES IN THE NAPOLEONIC WARS BRENT NOSWORTHY presents a Chapter that missed publication in his recent book .... ......................................................... 5
WITH MACDUFF TO THE FRONTIER ROSS MACFARLANE with colonial rules of the same name as last issue's French & Indian mles 1940 .............................. 17
THE REPUBLICAN ROMAN ARMY & ANCIENT RULES BILL HAGGART investigates the shortcomings of various Ancient Rule Sets in properly presenting the Republican Army capabilities .............................................................................. 25
EBANEMAEL PETE PANZERI presents a scenario based on the fan1ous battle ............................................................................... 45
FOR GOD, WEALTH & HONOR TERRY GORE with a philosophy of mles for Dark Ages and Medeival gaming .......................................... 49
DEPARTMENTS
THE REVIEWING STAND Figw-es, Books, Rules and Accessories .................................................................... 35
INDEX TO ISSUES #67-70 Tom Desmond does his annual thing ........................................................................ 53
THE COURIER DISPATCH News of the hobby ...... .................. . 55
DISPATCHES FROM THE FIELD Letters to(or at) the editor ......... 63
VOLLEY FIRE Your opinions of The Courier. ............................. 64
Cove.· Plwto: Napoleonic Square - mostly Front Rank with some Redoubt and Elite. Napoleon & Staff- Wargames Fdry; Old Guard - Essex. Painted by Pattick Slupccki Photo by Otv Banasik.
0
Sam
ple
file
I
The Courier \OK/II I \lt:R/l'\'HO/lt:\10\T \I/\1\Tl RUt.\ \1/\(, \1\li \11\t:
i\ IANAGI G EOITOR: R1ch:lfd L. Br)ant
BUSINF,SS :\ lA AGER:Lco Cronin
ART OIREC J'OR: Jo>CI~h Miceli
AD\'ERTISING i\IANAGER: Tom DcMnond
CONTRIULITIN(; EDITORS Jim Arnold: 1-..en Bunga: R<>bcn Bcuttoe: Jim Bird'<!yc:
John Boehm: BaiT) Fox: Terry Gore: Bill Greenwald: Ja) Hadley: Scott Holder, Paul Koch: Boh Marshall: Greg Rice: Bill Rutherford:
Dan Sdtorr
STAFF CARTOONISTS Brian Lum Jose Nicrn
STAFF PHOTOGRAPHERS On Bana'i~ I Pal Cnndrn)
TilE COURIER DISPATCH. Greg Rice
STM' F ILLUSTRATORS Alan Archambault. P:11rick Cru~iau. AI KarJ,a.
Joe Mauhew,, Lam Schuman. TeiT) Manton. Greg Rice. John Thull. ;\l ike T)>tlll.
PRINT! 'G: Quantum Printing
THE COURIER PUBLIS ~IING CO;\IPA 'Y. 1, C. Richard L Bl') am. Prcstdcm
nrRECTORS Richard L. Bryant. Leo Cronin. Jo,cph Miceli
TilE COURIER!ISSN 1062-1)371 ) is puhli,hcd quancrl) tappro.ximalc-1} Dccemhcr. i\larch. June. September) at W. Bridgewater i\IA 02:179.
SUBSCRIPTIONS USA Sl9 !one Ycan.S34t2 Ycar•l S-15(3 Year;J:S. AMERICA. Surface Rate $18 for -1 "'uc>. CANAOA: write toT. D. lmpon,, 70()-IR 5th A, c. SF.. C~gaf'). Albcnu T2H2G3 ENGLAND & EUROPE: Write 10 Panizan Pre>-\. 26 Cliff"'a GrO\'C. Lcigh-on-Sc:o. c-.c,, Engl:md. SS9 INQ. AUSTRALIA: Write to: E.\scx i\hniatures Pt\ .. Lid .. 22 Sydney Road. Horn'h) He1gh1>. NSW 2077. Tel: !02)9-177 66%.
BACK ISSUES Cum:mlssuerumil next i>'uc "out) is ~.SO USA: Back is;.ucs are SS.OO ca. USA: Canada & S. Amcril'a add S2 en .. Forcogn Aorn1aol add S-1 ca. Back h>ucs arc avwlablc for 6 months after publication onl) Monic' in US funtb drawn on US bank.' or International Postal Monc) Order.
No rcspon>ibilit} is a\\umetl for >l:tlcmcnls of fact or opinion mad~ h) the autho~. No rc~p<•n,ibilil) i~ U'->Umcd for un,olicited m:mul>Cripl\, hut all 'ubmi,,ion' arc wckome. no <IUCr) necc:l!>al'). All 'ubmi,~iun' should contain a !>elf-addrc>scd STAMPED en,clope larJ!C enough 10 return the ~ubmis;ion. Plca.\e write for I he AUTHOR'S GUIDELINES.
This Magazine and other publication' <Jf The Courier Puhli>hing Compan) are sold wi~11he undcr.tanding ~1a1 c\cry rcaM>nabk ;Utcmpt 1\ made to dcli\Cr them ,:tfcl) through the mail>. TI1e Courier Publishing Compan) ' ' not respon,ible for otcm~ I0\1 m the m:u ls. Replacement>\\ ill he provided u1 their uMotll cosl.
l 'TERNET hnpl/www.magwcb.com ADDRESS CHANGES
60 days noucc of address change 1s rcquorcd. The U S Post omcc DOES KOT FORWARD THIRD CLASS MAIL. You w1 ll he ch:trgcd for replacement issues mi>scd due 10 untimely noucc 01 address change. If issue is returned you will be ch:lJ}!cd our co;t for returning il to the correct address.
ALL DOMESTIC DEALER INQUIRIES. ADVERTISING COPY. AND INQUlRIES, SUBSCRIPTIONS (except •~~ 111Cntioned :1hove1 AND ARTICLES 10 THE COURJER. PO Box 1878. Broc~ton. MA 02-103.
0. 73: F:nlirl' Cunrent.s 1997 Ill The Courier Puhlbhing CompMy. ·Inc.
11tis cditoJial opens with a sad note - the passing of Fred Vietmeyer. Fred wrote the Column. Line & Square rules that so many of we ''Old Guard' ' bit our wargaming teeth on. His passing marks l.he passing of an era in Miniature Wru-gruning and he wi ll be sadly missed. See the obituary on page 43.
PHIL BARKER By the time you sec this Historicon will. have taken place and you will be aware of l.he award of The Scruby Award to Phil Barker. The Scruby Award is named for the father of Historical miniature Wargaming in l.he US and is given every ol.her year to ·'that person whose contribution to l.he hobby is on such a level l.hat the hobby would not be the same without him. There were several very
deseiVing candidates who, no doubt, will be awarded in subsequent award years. But who can
not realize that Phil. almost single-handed (though he will deny it) brought Ancient Gaming to the level it is
today. His seminal rules and reference works led to the tournament play we see at just about every convention -the
hobby is mush richer because of his effort. Congratulations, Phil SAPPER'S REPORTS
There has been a dearth of Sapper's Report articles lately. lt is very popular with l.he readers ru1d l would like to have one in every issue. Many have promised such but have not been forthcoming. 1 know many of you have ideas. on new approaches to terrain, builclings, gaming items. etc. send it in on disk with a hard copy and photos and illustrations.
OTHER ARTICLES Quite a few readers have written in to ask why we don't have more of ·such-andsuch articles· . We can only print what we get- there is no staff of writers. You the readers provide all our articles. Send a Stamped - Self Addressed envelope for our Aul.hors Guide. We have plenty of ruticles on hand by they tend to be about only a few periods and we Like more diversity. We need DBM and DBR oriented articles. good scenarios in just about any period. We would Like to see some Fire & Fury scenarios and battle reports as well as some based on Empire rules and Piquet. Of cow-se we will entertain articles on any Historical Miniature Wargaming subjecL
Duke Seifried's Pathan games at Historicon - Photo by Pat Condray
Sam
ple
file
~~------~(~_T __ H_E __ C_O_V_R_I_E~R~)~--------~
INFANTRY SQUARES In The NAPOLEONIC WARS
C 1997, Brent Nasworthy
is article \l'lH originally wrillen as a chapter in Mr. Nosll'orthy:v recent book WITH MUSKET AND SWORD. BAITLE TACTICS OF NAPOLEON AND HIS ENEMIES
(see The Cmtrier #71, PI: 44 ). The chapter did not find its way imo the book and I feel that it is as important to Historical Miniature Gamers as the rest of the book so 11•e have reprillfed it here with Mr. No.l'll'orthy:v kind permission. The book is available from Sarpedon Publishers, 166 Fifth Ave .. , NY, NY, 10010 (JSBN 1-885119-27-5) am/ is tl MUST read for all Napoleonic Period gamer.\·. - ED.
Although the square was not completely unknown during the seventeenth century, it was by necesl.ity an ad hoc formation which required more time to form than was available during actual battlefield conditions. With the adoption of cadence by the Prussian infantry during the 1730s and other armies between 17~8 and 1752. it became much more feasible to form square in the heat of an action.
When compared to the Napoleonic Wars. however. the use of squares during the Seven Years' War remained relatively rMe. The rea<>on for this lay not in the inability of the infantry to form square quickly - at thi~ point all the armies in western Europe were quickly adopting cadenced marching and the new manoeuvres - but rather in the grand tactical implications that resulted once one or more squares were formed. The practice of forming long continuous bailie was simply inimical to the use of squares. If one or more ballalions along a lengthy line were to form square. the adjoining battalions would now have a t1an.k exposed
0
and could be easily rolled up by the enemy cavalry. So. either all the baualions along the line h.ad to form square. or those that remained in line somehow had to protect any exposed flanks either by throwing back part of the line en potence (pan of the line was run perpendicularly backward) or en crochet (part of the line was thrown hack at an angle) or anchoring it behind some natural form of protection such as a morass. gully, etc. This might prove to difficult or impossible to do heat of the baule. however.
Once the French started to employ the French school or impulse system of grand tactics, these restrictions were immediately eliminated. ln thts grand tactical system battalions were usually maintained in column of ll'aiting. Those lines that were formed were much smaller. i.e .. that is they were generally battalion. regimental or brigade-sized lines. And. a brigade commander could anchor these '>rnaller lines simply by placing a battalion in closed column at an exposed end rather than relying on terrain. All of this meant that a battalion or regiment commander was much more free to fonn square when threatened by cavalry than his counterparts had been in earlier wars. The result was a proliferation of squares during the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars.
AILJ10ugh the word "square" conjures up battalion-sized formations. t11ere were in fact many different types of squares. ranging from small rallying squares which might only have 15-20 men to army-sized squares. What follows is a description of the largest of these down to the smallest.D ivisional Squares
Sam
ple
file