critical essay 4 - sword at sunset

Upload: maeve-murray

Post on 05-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/31/2019 Critical Essay 4 - Sword at Sunset

    1/5

    Igo~o Iuxxgz 7

    Agxclt _ej~oxqj}z I%N%G% je Axog}j~o Txj}jed

    Vxga}jaui Qoioq}ox 7# Igz 4# 8678

    Kgeo Alcoige# Ioe}lx

    Axj}jagc Oqqgz != Qtlxm g} Queqo}hz Xlqoigxz Qu}acjnn

    Moqaxjv}jleq gem Movja}jleq; ]bo Dllm gem ]bo Hgm

    _vle axga`jed lvoe Qtlxm g} Queqo}hz Xlqoigxz Qu}acjnn# J tgq uequxo tbg} ghlu} j} vu}

    io le omdo% ]jdb} hcla`q ln }or} dcgxom hga` nxli }bo vgdo# qagxaocz hxl`oe uv hz mjgclduo gem

    }bja` tj}b xjab mo}gjc% J} mjme} }g`o cled }l njduxo lu} tbg} tgq aguqjed }bo vuqb gem vucc ln g

    cl~o)bg}o xocg}jleqbjv }l hujcm uv jeqjmo io j} tgq }bo q}zco% Qu}acjnn abgeeocq g txj}jed q}zco }bg}

    to qoo je igez lcm acgqqjaq0 qbo jq }blxludbcz moqaxjv}j~o "g} }jioq }l g nguc}* gem egxxg}oq tj}b g

    mxz njxq})voxqle ~ljao% Gc}bludb }bo tlxcm qbo axog}oq jq ~j~jm gem ngqajeg}jed# j} jq gcql g} }jioq

    }ll iuab nlx g cojquxocz xogm% G wul}o le }bo hga` al~ox hz }bo Cjhxgxz Kluxegc bgm j} alxxoa}# }bg}

    }bjq jq# G hll` nlx }bo gvvxoajg}j~o# ig}uxo xogmox%

    ]bo hll` hodjeq gem oemq g} }bo qgio vcgao; gq Gx}lq# Qu}acjnnq @jed Gx}bux njduxo# cjoq

    mzjed gn}ox ge je}oeqo hg}}co% Ilq} ln }bo hll` jq }boxonlxo je ncgqbhga`# gem }bo moajqjle }l ml }bjq

    tj}b g njxq})voxqle vlje} ln ~jot gccltom nlx uq }l do} Gx}lq bjemqjdb} hjgq }bxludblu} }bo q}lxz#

    bocvjed uq gcled }bxludb }bo moeqo alijedq gem dljedq ln }bo vcl}% ]bjq abljao tgq g eoaoqqgxz

    leo# nlx jn el} nlx Gx}lq gjm je vuqbjed }bo q}lxz nlxtgxm# j}q aleaoj~ghco }bg} leo ijdb} do} clq}

    giledq} }bo qog ln uengijcjgx egioq gem hg}}co }ga}jaq% ]bo bjemqjdb} mloq qlio}bjed ocqo nlx uq

    gq tocc0 j} gccltq uq }l do} }l `elt Gx}lq je }tl mjnnoxoe} q}gdoq ln bjq cjno g} leo }jio% To cogxe

    ghlu} bji }bxludb bjq ga}jleq je }bo vgq}# hu} to gcql hoalio gawugje}om tj}b }bo lcm ige tbl

  • 7/31/2019 Critical Essay 4 - Sword at Sunset

    2/5

    Igo~o Iuxxgz 8

    aliioe}q le blt bo ga}om tboe bo tgq zluedox% Je }bg} qoeqo# to dxlt aclqox }l bjq abgxga}ox

    tj}b xocg}j~ocz cj}}co or}xg onnlx}%

    Leo ln }bo ilxo lh~jluq q}zcjq}ja abljaoq jq Qu}acjnnq mxz ~ljao% Xodgxmcoqq ln tbg}o~ox

    oraj}oioe} lx je}xjduo jq bgvvoejed g} }bo }jio# Gx}lq dj~oq }bo gaalue} gq leo ijdb} dj~o g q}ov)

    hz)q}ov bjq}lxjagc xovlx}% J} noocq jivoxqlegc gem mjq}ge}# o~oe }bludb j} jq txj}}oe je njxq} voxqle%

    To qoo vgqqgdoq cj`o# Qlio ln }bo gxxltq bgm ncgijed qvjxj})qlg`om xgdq }jom }l }boi# gem }bojx

    gxab qbltom cj`o qbll}jed q}gxq le g tje}oxq ejdb}% G not oeoiz gxxltq geqtoxom# hu} elt

    igez0 }bo monoemoxq toxo }ll je}oe} le }bo dg}o j}qocn }l bg~o iuab }jio nlx qbll}jed# "7?=*% Je

    }bjq vgqqgdo# toxo dj~oe }bo nga}q hcue}cz gem tj}blu} }bo `jem ln voxqlegc aleeoa}jle leo orvoa}q

    nxli g njxq})voxqle gaalue}%

    Gc}bludb Qu}acjnn qooiq }l ho nlem ln uqjed qjijco }l hunn box moqaxjv}jleq uv g el}ab# }bjq

    xogmoxq mloqe} hocjo~o j}q oeludb }l oq}ghcjqb je}jigaz tj}b }bo quxxluemjedq% ]bo qjijcoq ml

    gaalivcjqb l}box }bjedq# nlx orgivco# cgzjed lu} }bo qo}}jed% Qu}acjnnq tlxm abljaoq je box qjijcoq

    dl g cled tgz }l hxjedjed xogmoxq hga` je }jio# tj}b alivgxjqleq cj`o# qblucmoxjed je cj`o lroe

    lu} ln }bo to}# tbj}o gq g qtge# dleo gq qtjn}cz gq g hjxm mgx}q gaxlqq g quecj} acogxjed# gem

    mgvvcom cj`o g auxcotq hxogq}# "8?# ::# 7=1# 1>8*% ]boqo gxo el} }bjedq g voxqle je g ilmoxe oxg

    tlucm }bje` }l qgz# gem ql xogmoxq gxo `ov} je }bo vxlvox }jio voxjlm gem }xgje ln }bludb}# g nucc

    tlxcm quhioxqom je }bo auc}uxo }bg} cjoq ho}tooe }bo cjeoq%

    Tbjco aox}gje tlxm abljaoq ig`o }bo el~oc tlx`# l}box hj}q ln jenlxig}jle igz aguqo

    qlio xogmoxq }l hoalio nxuq}xg}om tj}b }bo hll`q vgajed lx clqo je}oxoq} gc}ldo}box% ]bo njxq}

    buemxom "dj~o lx }g`o* gxo momjag}om }l }bo mo}gjcjed ln huzjed# qoccjed# xgjqjed# gem }xgjejed

    tgxblxqoq% J} jq je}oxoq}jed }l el}o Gx}lq vxlaoqq# nlx quxo# hu} J bg~o mluh}q ghlu} blt eoaoqqgxz

  • 7/31/2019 Critical Essay 4 - Sword at Sunset

    3/5

    Igo~o Iuxxgz 1

    }bo coed}bq ln quab moqaxjv}jleq gxo# oqvoajgccz nlx g agqugc xogmox% ]boxo gxo }jioq je }bo el~oc

    tboxo Qu}acjnn moqaxjhoq ge oealue}ox lx hg}}co vcge nlx vgdoq gem vgdoq# gem l}box }jioq tboxo qbo

    dcgeaoq l~ox o~oe}q }bg} to igz aleqjmox ilxo jivlx}ge}% Nlx orgivco# je }bo hodjeejed ln }bo

    hll`# Qu}acjnn }g oq }toe}z)nlux vgdoq }l do} Gx}lq il~jed le bjq }gq` }l dg}box ioe gem blxqoq#

    hu} lecz qo~oe mo}gjcjed bjq oealue}ox tj}b Zdoxeg# tbjab oemq uv hojed ~oxz jivlx}ge} hz }bo oem

    ln }bo q}lxz% ]boxo gxo qjr}ooe vgdoq }occjed ln blt Gx}lq qvog`q }l g eue ghlu} cog~jed

    Duoebuigxg je box agxo nlx leo quiiox# zo} lecz nlux vgdoq momjag}om }l Gx}lq mjqal~oxjed }bo

    gnngjx ho}tooe Homtzx gem bjq tjno voxbgvq }bo qjedco tlxq} }bjed }bg} bgvvoeq }l Gx}lq% Qjijcgx

    vg}}oxeq qblt uv }bxludblu} }bo hll` tboe leo alivgxoq vgqqgdoq ghlu} }xg~ocjed }bo alue}xzqjmo

    }l vgqqgdoq tboxo hg}}coq gxo }g`jed vcgao% Jivlx}ge} gem je}oxoq}jed vjoaoq ln }bo q}lxz nooc

    uemoxijeom# tbjco }bo coqq je}xjdujed eoaoqqgxz vgx}q gxo mxgte lu} cledox }bge igz ho xowujxom%

    Cj`otjqo# to gcql qoo }bjq vg}}oxe qbltjed uv tboe to alivgxo }bo ~gq} moqaxjv}jleq ln

    vcgao gem qo}}jed }l }bo not moqaxjv}jleq xodgxmjed abgxga}oxq% Tbjco }bo qo}}jedq je }bo hll` }g o

    le g cjno ln }bojx lte# }bo abgxga}oxq xoigje xocg}j~ocz leo mjioeqjlegc% Nlx orgivco# tboe Gx}lq

    ioo}q Zdoxeg# }bo vgq}uxoq gem bjccqjmoq quxxluemjed box blio gxo }blxludbcz movja}om# uqjed quab

    vgqqgdoq gq }bjq;

    Vxoqoe}cz# gq J nlccltom }bo tg}ox mlte# }bo q}oov ngcc ln }bo ~gccoz qliotbg}# gem

    }bo dxluem uemoxnll} abgedom nxli illx dxgqq }l g moeqo gxlig}ja agxvo} ln hld

    izx}co je}oxcgaom tj}b bog}box0 gem J hodge }l nooc }bo njxieoqq tj}b o~oxz q}ov

    gem }bo q}xogi vcuedom gn}ox j} je g cled qcjmo ln hcga` tg}ox qill}b gq vlcjqbom

    dcgqq uemox }bo }gedco ln bgt}blxe }xooq# gem xludb vgq}uxo agio uv }l ioo} io

    gcled }bo bjccqjmo "86*%

  • 7/31/2019 Critical Essay 4 - Sword at Sunset

    4/5

    Igo~o Iuxxgz =

    ]bo ghl~o mo}gjcq g vjoao ln cgem Gx}lq tgc`q gaxlqq honlxo bo o~oe alioq }l Zdoxegq ngxiq}ogm%

    L}box quxxluemjedq gxo kuq} gq mo}gjcom% ]bo lu}qjmo tlxcm vlvq lu} g} xogmoxq# hoalijed g }bjed

    gcc ln j}q lte% Zo} tboe to ioo} Zdoxeg# to `elt ~oxz cj}}co ghlu} box abgxga}ox% Tbjco Gx}lq

    mloq moqaxjho box gvvogxgeao tbg} qbo tgq togxjed# tbg} alclx box bgjx jq# o}a% to ml el} cogxe

    iuab hozlem }bjq% Gcc to elt jq }bg} qbo jq bjq bgcn)qjq}ox# gem }bg} qbo jq nucc ln bg}o% Hu} tbg}

    `jem ln voxqle jq qbo< Jq qbo }xucz gq }oxxjhco gq toxo com }l hocjo~o# lx jq qbo g ijqcom qluc tbl

    bgm el l}box tgz }l orvxoqq boxqocn< To qjivcz mle} `elt% Zdoxeg jq g txoeab }bxlte je}l

    Gx}lq cjno0 qbo qox~oq g vgx}jaucgx vuxvlqo# gem hozlem }bg} qbo bgq el mjq}jedujqbjed

    abgxga}oxjq}jaq% Tbg}q ilxo# qboq el} }bo lecz abgxga}ox bgemcom }bjq tgz%

    Aoj# Dtgcabigj# Aoxmja# gem Iomxgu} gcql ngcc je}l }bjq ag}odlxz% Aoxmja gem Iomxgu}#

    iuab cj`o Zdoxeg# gxo abgxga}oxq nuocom hz bg}o tblqo lecz vuxvlqo je }bo q}lxz jq }l aguqo Gx}lq

    mltengcc% To mle} `elt gez}bjed ocqo ghlu} oj}box abgxga}ox% Aoj gem Dtgcabigj gxo cogmoxq

    giled }bo Alivgejleq# gem ogab bgq lecz leo mjq}jedujqbjed abgxga}oxjq}ja Aoj jq g cjdb})bogx}om

    cgmzq ige# gem Dtgcabigj jq g tgx quxdole tj}b g cjiv% To mle} `elt iuab# jn gez}bjed#

    ghlu} }bojx voxqlegcj}joq% Gx}lq qgzq leao }bg} Aoj mloqe} `elt }bo }xz iogejed ln bg}o# hu}

    el}bjed nux}box jq o~ox ioe}jleom ln j}%

    ]bo lecz }tl abgxga}oxq }bg} do} ilxo mo~oclvioe} gxo Duoebuigxg gem Homtzx# hu} }bjq

    xogmox tjqboq nlx ilxo% Duoebuigxgq abgxga}ox tgq oil}jlegc g} box hgqo# hu} qbo agxxjom g alcm

    cldja ghlu} box gq tocc# vgx}jaucgxcz tboe qbo }lcm Gx}lq }bg} bo qblucm igxxz box% Qbo }oq}om blt

    ngx qbo alucm vuqb Gx}lq gcilq} aleq}ge}cz# qo}}jed box tjcc gdgjeq} bjq tboeo~ox qbo mjme} do} box

    tgz% Qu}acjnn vlx}xgzq box gq g q}xled tlige je }bg} qoeqo# hu} tj}b box gnngjx# to alio }l qoo box

    ~oxz mjnnoxoe}cz% Je }bg}# qbo jq g tog` tlige tbl quaauihom }l cleocjeoqq# blto~ox

    uemoxq}gemghco }bo ajxauiq}geao igz ho% Cj`otjqo# Homtzx jq gctgzq movja}om gq wuoq}jlejed# lx

  • 7/31/2019 Critical Essay 4 - Sword at Sunset

    5/5

    Igo~o Iuxxgz ?

    g} cogq} aliioe}jed le Gx}lq aliigem# }bo tgz g nxjoem ijdb} je lxmox }l oequxo }bo hoq} aluxqo

    ln ga}jle jq }g`oe% To do} }bo qoeqo }bg} Homtzx mloq doeujeocz agxo nlx Gx}lq gem bjq quaaoqq%

    Bjq ilioe} ln tog`eoqq tj}b Duoebuigxg jq }buq ilxo vgjenuc nlx xogmoxq }bge o~oe }bo mog}b ln

    g abgxga}ox cj`o Dtgcabigj%

    Qu}acjnn jq jemoom g qvocchjemox gq }boEot Zlx` ]jioq Hll` Xo~jot acgjiq le }bo nxle}

    al~ox ln }bo hll`% Qbo qogicoqqcz tog~oq mo}gjcq }ldo}box }l dj~o xogmoxq g alivco}o vja}uxo ln

    box }jio gem qo}}jed# gem }bo xoquc} jq hxog}b)}g`jed% ]bjq xogmox lecz tjqboq }bg} ilxo ln }bo cj`o

    tlucm bg~o hooe uqom le qlio ln }bo el~ocq abgxga}oxq Zdoxeg# Iomxgu}# Aoj# Dtgcabigj# gem

    Aoxmja }l ncoqb }boi lu} gem dj~o }boi ilxo }bge leo mjioeqjle%