criteria for abundance monitoring accuracy accuracy precision precision representation...

11

Click here to load reader

Upload: alexander-lopez

Post on 26-Mar-2015

221 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Criteria for abundance monitoringCriteria for abundance monitoring

AccuracyAccuracy

PrecisionPrecision

RepresentationRepresentation

Page 2: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Quality LevelsQuality Levels

AA ExcellentExcellent BB Very GoodVery Good CC GoodGood DD FairFair FF PoorPoor

Page 3: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Major RegionsMajor Regions

Upper Columbia River (above Priest Upper Columbia River (above Priest Rapids)Rapids)

Snake RiverSnake River Mid-Columbia River (above Bonneville)Mid-Columbia River (above Bonneville) Lower Columbia RiverLower Columbia River

Page 4: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Accuracy and Precision specific: Accuracy and Precision specific:

Region; Species and race Region; Species and race

Chinook: sp/su, fallChinook: sp/su, fall

Steelhead: su/wiSteelhead: su/wi

CohoCoho

ChumChum

SockeyeSockeye

Bull Trout (D max?; C?; all Bull Trout (D max?; C?; all F’s?)F’s?)

Representation: By Monitoring projectRepresentation: By Monitoring project

Page 5: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Interception MethodsInterception Methods Fixed structures, complete blocks (Dams/Hatcheries)Fixed structures, complete blocks (Dams/Hatcheries)

1) complete or near complete count (i.e., 24/7)1) complete or near complete count (i.e., 24/7)2) incomplete count (i.e., >=2/3 time extrapolated)2) incomplete count (i.e., >=2/3 time extrapolated)3) incomplete count (i.e., <2/3 time extrapolated)3) incomplete count (i.e., <2/3 time extrapolated)

Un-fixed structures or incomplete blocks Un-fixed structures or incomplete blocks (Traps/Weirs)(Traps/Weirs)1) complete or near complete count1) complete or near complete count2) incomplete count (w/ mark-recapture)2) incomplete count (w/ mark-recapture)3) incomplete count (w/o mark-recapture)3) incomplete count (w/o mark-recapture)

Page 6: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Spawner Surveys: Spatial Spawner Surveys: Spatial CoverageCoverage

Index: How much coverage?Index: How much coverage?

1) <50% of habitat1) <50% of habitat2) 50-85% of habitat2) 50-85% of habitat3) >85% of habitat3) >85% of habitat

EMAP or probabilistic: What level?EMAP or probabilistic: What level?

1) ESU1) ESU2) MPG2) MPG3) Population3) Population

Page 7: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Spawner Surveys: Temporal Spawner Surveys: Temporal CoverageCoverage

1-2 Pass at peak 1-2 Pass at peak

Multi-Pass around peak (>=3)Multi-Pass around peak (>=3)

Census or Area-under-curveCensus or Area-under-curve

Page 8: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Spawner Surveys: TypeSpawner Surveys: Type

ReddsRedds

Live and CarcassesLive and Carcasses

Page 9: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Snake-Dam/HatcherySnake-Dam/Hatchery Accuracy: Accuracy:

DH1: A: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH1: A: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd

DH2: B: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH2: B: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd

DH3: D: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH3: D: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd Precision: Precision:

DH1: A: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH1: A: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd

DH2: B: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH2: B: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd

DH3: F: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthdDH3: F: sp/su chin, fall chin, sock, su sthd

Page 10: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Snake-Trap/WeirSnake-Trap/Weir Accuracy: Accuracy:

TW1: A: sp/su chin, sock; n/a: su sthdTW1: A: sp/su chin, sock; n/a: su sthd

TW2: B: sp/su chin, sock, su sthdTW2: B: sp/su chin, sock, su sthd

TW3: D: sp/su chin, sock, su sthdTW3: D: sp/su chin, sock, su sthd Precision: Precision:

TW1: A: sp/su chin, sock; n/a: su sthdTW1: A: sp/su chin, sock; n/a: su sthd

TW2: B: sp/su chin, sock; C: su sthdTW2: B: sp/su chin, sock; C: su sthd

TW3: D: sp/su chin, sock; F: su sthdTW3: D: sp/su chin, sock; F: su sthd

Page 11: Criteria for abundance monitoring Accuracy Accuracy Precision Precision Representation Representation

Snake-Spawner SurveysSnake-Spawner Surveys<50%<50% 50-85%50-85% >85%>85%

IndexIndex1/2-pass sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=D, P=F sp/su chin: A=C, 1/2-pass sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=D, P=F sp/su chin: A=C,

P=DP=D

su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A=D, P=Fsu sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A=D, P=F

Multi/ sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=C, P=D sp/su chin: A, P=BMulti/ sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=C, P=D sp/su chin: A, P=B

Census su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A,P=F su sthd : A,P=DCensus su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A,P=F su sthd : A,P=D

ProbabilisticProbabilistic LoLo MedMed HighHigh1/2-pass sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A,P=D sp/su chin: A,P=C1/2-pass sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A,P=D sp/su chin: A,P=C

su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A=D, P=Fsu sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A=D, P=F

Multi/ sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=C, P=D sp/su chin: A=B, Multi/ sp/su chin: A,P=F sp/su chin: A=C, P=D sp/su chin: A=B, P=CP=C

Census su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A,P=DCensus su sthd: A,P=F su sthd : A, P=F su sthd : A,P=D