coverage of westgate report 25 march 2014

68

Upload: media-council-of-kenya

Post on 11-Mar-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

The Media Council of Kenya carried out an extensive media monitoring exercise on how the media covered the Westgate shopping mall terror attack that occurred on 21st September 2013, especially in observing the professional obligation as required by Code of Conduct for the Practice of Journalism in Kenya and social responsibility in commenting on public issues while at the same time respecting the limitation to freedom of expression on national security grounds.

TRANSCRIPT

  • The

    Wes

    tgat

    e Sh

    oppi

    ng M

    all i

    n N

    airo

    bi, K

    enya

    .

  • Terrorism has become a constant threat in communities everywhere. In their heinous operations, terrorists seek the most attention and publicity as these are to have a multiplier effect on the impact of the cowardly acts. They commit violent crimes in order to cause fear and terror as they disrupt normal life, in the hope of gaining attention for a cause.

    Charged with the responsibility of providing information about events in society, media access to information is a critical need, particularly when the safety, security and survival of the members of the public are threatened.

    Considering the fact that the aim of terrorists is to seek attention and free publicity in order to create fear and dread, the medias role in reporting acts of terrorism becomes a delicate act because while the media are obligated to provide news and information, they could be manipulated or otherwise roped into the terrorists' nefarious schemes.

    Perhaps the most important question that emerges from media coverage of terrorists' acts is whether detailed gaffer to gaffer coverage of terrorists acts encourages further violence or promotes the terrorists agenda. There is also the question of whether the media can fall victims of terrorists machinations and become accomplices as terrorists seek cheap publicity. Do the media in their reporting magnify and emphasize the threats and fear instead, thus further emboldening terrorists?

    Terrorists, governments, and the media see the functions, roles and responsibilities of the media when covering terrorists events from differing and often competing perspectives. Such perspectives drive behaviour during terrorists incidents often resulting in both tactical and strategic gains to the terrorists operation and the overall terrorists cause.

  • Jour

    nalis

    ts a

    nd s

    ecur

    ity

    offi

    cers

    tak

    e co

    ver

    at t

    he W

    estg

    ate

    Shop

    ping

    Mal

    l.

  • Loca

    l and

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    l jou

    rnal

    ists

    cam

    ping

    at

    the

    wes

    taga

    te s

    hopp

    ing

    mal

    l fol

    low

    ing

    the

    terr

    or a

    ttac

    k.

  • Decency and human respect prescribe that the authorities must first notify the families about their loss before mentioning the victims' names on the airwaves, never mind showing their pictures. A qualified senior editor, with experience in covering such bloody scenes, should monitor the photos prior to their broadcast

    (Almagor, 2005)

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • A jo

    urna

    list

    repo

    rtin

    g liv

    e fr

    om t

    he W

    estg

    ate

    Shop

    ping

    Mal

    l.

  • Photo Colour

    Valid ColouredBlack & WhiteTotal

    38353436

    87.812.2100.0

    87.812.2100.0

    Frequency Percent Valid Percent

    APPRAISAL REPORT

  • Frequency Percent Valid Percent

    Valid Yes

    NO

    N/A

    Total

    1

    75

    360

    436

    .2

    17.2

    82.6

    100.0

    .2

    17.2

    82.6

    100.0

    Warning over photos used

    Main Subject

    Rescue personnelInjured personsCrowd/publicGovernment Officialsmedia personnelOther scenes

    Total

    791431225201561436

    18.132.82.85.74.635.8.2100.0

    18.132.82.85.74.635.8.2100.0

    Frequency Percent Valid Percent

    APPRAISAL REPORT

  • Frequency Percent Valid Percent

    Yes

    NO

    Total

    229

    207

    436

    52.5

    47.5

    100.0

    52.5

    47.5

    100.0

    Does the Photo have a caption

    Accurate96%

    Inaccurate 4%

    Frequency Percent Valid PercentYesNOTotal

    4432436

    999.1100.0

    999.1100.0

    APPRAISAL REPORT

  • 91%

    9%

    Treatment of subjects in the photoDignified treatmentUndignified treatment

    Accurate and ComprehensiveTreatment

    YesNo

    5%

    95%

    Frequency Percent Valid Percent

    YesNOTotal

    2434436

    .599.5100.0

    .599.5100.0

    APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • 27

    APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • Keny

    a D

    efen

    ce F

    orce

    s so

    ldie

    rs p

    atro

    l the

    Wes

    tgat

    e Sh

    oppi

    ng M

    all v

    icin

    ity.

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

    Aiding terrorists in media coverage

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • Gen

    eral

    Ser

    vice

    Uni

    t pe

    rson

    nel t

    ake

    posi

    tion

    s at

    the

    Wes

    tgat

    e Sh

    oppi

    ng M

    all.

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • Adh

    eren

    ce t

    o et

    hics

    : The

    Med

    ia C

    ounc

    il of

    Ken

    ya m

    embe

    rs a

    ddre

    ssin

    g th

    e pr

    ess

    at t

    he W

    estg

    ate

    Shop

    ping

    Mal

    l.

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

  • APPRAISAL REPORT

    Page 1Page 2Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9Page 10Page 11Page 12Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21Page 22Page 23Page 24Page 25Page 26Page 27Page 28Page 29Page 30Page 31Page 32Page 33Page 34Page 35Page 36Page 37Page 38Page 39Page 40Page 41Page 42Page 43Page 44Page 45Page 46Page 47Page 48Page 49Page 50Page 51Page 52Page 53Page 54Page 55Page 56Page 57Page 58Page 59Page 60Page 61Page 62Page 63Page 64Page 65Page 66Page 67Page 68