cottingham stadium · 11/6/2019 · spaces throughout cottingham stadium have been redesigned in...
TRANSCRIPT
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
COTTINGHAM STADIUMRedesign Presentation | November 6, 2019
1DESIGN CONCEPT
The design concept for Cottingham Stadium is built around Easton Area High School’s alma mater. The space is community-focused and a celebration of great traditions of the district, the city and the surrounding community.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
2REDESIGN GOALS
The redesign has three goals: lower the costs of construction, increase the return on investment and optimize the variety of uses. Spaces throughout Cottingham Stadium have been redesigned in order to achieve an estimated savings of $3.1 million to $3.6 million. The investment return is increased by the flexibility of spaces allowing for a variety of athletes and community members to use the improved venue.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
3COTTINGHAM STADIUM SITE PLAN
Major areas impacted by the redesign are the home and visitors stands, entrance gate, 12th Street, locker rooms and general site work. The following slides break down each area with an explanation of the redesign and an estimated cost savings.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
UPD
ATED
10/22
/19
Item
Descriptio
nLow Ran
geHigh Ra
nge
Alternate ?
1Provide alum
inum
bleache
rs with
pre‐fa
bricated
pressbo
x instead of precast con
crete
1,20
0,00
0$
1,30
0,00
0$
Yes, con
crete (add
)2
12th Street (existing eastern sid
ewalks/curb remain, no "bum
p ou
t", m
ill asphalt instead of re
place)
100,00
0$
130,00
0$
No
3Elim
inate curb widen
ing on
12th Street fo
r Paxinosa drop
off
60,000
$
70,000
$
No
4Co
mbine
12th Street ticket boo
ths &
arch into com
mon
smaller structure
100,00
0$
150,00
0$
No
5De
lete custom press box and
vom
itoriu
m wall at H
ome bleachers
400,00
0$
450,00
0$
No
6De
lete th
e constructio
n of 3 new
con
cession stands
600,00
0$
690,00
0$
No
7Elim
inate wall closure from
12 ft. height to un
derside of bleache
rs70
,000
$
80,000
$
No
8De
lete custom canop
y over Visitor p
ress platform
110,00
0$
130,00
0$
No
9Re
move resilient and
polish
ed con
crete flo
ors a
nd provide
sealer
40,000
$
50,000
$
No
10Re
duce air cond
ition
ing eq
uipm
ent in Field Ho
use (keep 10
mini split AC
units)
320,00
0$
350,00
0$
No
11Simplify
screen
walls for e
xterior m
echanical enclosure at field hou
se30
,000
$
40,000
$
No
12Re
duce pub
lic re
stroom
plumbing
fixtures by 50
%11
5,00
0$
140,00
0$
No (See
Note 1)
13Re
move hard ceilings from
toilet roo
ms
30,000
$
40,000
$
No
14Re
duce signage scop
e includ
ing bron
ze letters in sid
ewalk and othe
r signage/le
ttering
40,000
$
50,000
$
No
15Re
duce Locker S
cope
in field ho
use
50,000
$
60,000
$
No
16Re
duce Electric
Scope
for U
ndergrou
nd exten
sion to outbu
ildings (o
verhead services to
remain)
60,000
$
75,000
$
No
17Re
duce hard wire
d data con
nections, utilize
wifi
30,000
$
35,000
$
No
18Elim
inate additio
nal TV station cabling infrastructure fo
r rem
ote parking locatio
n40
,000
$
50,000
$
No
19Ba
sic sc
ore bo
ard in lieu
of LED
video
board
75,000
$
100,00
0$
TBD
20Re
duce con
crete sla
b scop
e to ston
e in storage room
s und
er bleache
rs25
,000
$
35,000
$
No (See
Note 1)
21Re
duction in new
retaining wall scope
(include
s prio
r VE ite
m to
remove brick vene
er)
200,00
0$
250,00
0$
No
22Re
duce sc
ope of HVA
C for p
ublic re
stroom
s ben
eath bleache
rs50
,000
$
60,000
$
No (See
Note 1)
23Install chain Link Fence in lieu
of C
MU walls @ storage areas
160,00
0$
190,00
0$
No (See
Note 1)
24De
lete Ticket/Bo
oster B
uilding on
11th Street
80,000
$
100,00
0$
No
Estim
ated
Total Savings
3,98
5,00
0$
4,62
5,00
0$
Estim
ated
Alte
rnate for S
ynthetic Turf field
850,00
0$
1,00
0,00
0$
Estim
ated
Net Savings
3,13
5,00
0$
3,62
5,00
0$
Notes 1
Hard Cost B
id Results
17,346
,742
$
17,346
,742
$
Adjusted
Hard Co
st Incorporating Estim
ated
Savings (N
atural Grass Field)
13,436
,742
$
12,821
,742
$
Adjusted
Hard Co
st Incorporating Estim
ated
Savings (Synthetic Turf Field)
14,286
,742
$
13,821
,742
$
Soft Costs on Bid Da
y (In
clud
ing $5
00,000
project con
tingency)
2,66
7,94
0$
2,66
7,94
0$
Adjusted
Soft C
osts to
Delete Utility
Relocation ($70
,000
) and
Provide
Basic Scorebo
ard (Item
19 above)
2,52
2,94
0$
2,49
7,94
0$
Bid Day Total Project Cost
20,014
,682
$
20,014
,682
$
Adjusted
Total Project Cost (Natural Grass Field)
15,959
,682
$
15,319
,682
$
Adjusted
Total Project Cost (Synthe
tic Turf Field)
16,809
,682
$
16,319
,682
$
Assumption made that fixture varia
nce will be approved
. Costs based
in who
le or in part on sm
aller toilet roo
m, larger storage ro
om
COTTINGHAM
STA
DIUM PRE
LIMINAR
Y ESTIMAT
ED SAV
INGS
Item
num
bers
re
fere
nced
th
roug
hout
pr
esen
tatio
n.
Hom
e &
Vis
itor S
tand
s
Entra
nce
Gate
12th
Stre
et Im
prov
emen
ts
Lock
er R
oom
s
Othe
r Site
Wor
k
4HOME & VISITOR STANDS
Aluminum bleachers and a pre-fabricated press box are replacing the custom press box and vomitorium wall. The custom canopy over the visitor press platform is also removed. The storage areas beneath the bleachers have gravel floors and chain link fencing.
1 $1,200,000 $1,300,000 5 $400,000 $450,0007 $70,000 $80,0008 $110,000 $130,00020 $25,000 $35,00023 $160,000 $190,000
Total $2 million $2.2 million
Item Low Range High Range
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
5HOME STANDS
With a variance, the public restroom fixtures will be reduced by 50 percent and the hard ceiling is removed. HVAC in public restrooms is reduced.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
12 $115,000 $140,00013 $30,000 $40,00022 $50,000 $60,000
Total $195,000 $240,000
Item Low Range High Range
6VISITOR STANDS
With a variance, the public restroom fixtures will be reduced by 50 percent and the hard ceiling is removed. HVAC in public restrooms is reduced.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
7HOME STANDS RENDERING
As a cost-saving measure in the redesign, several customized pieces are replaced by pre-fabricated buildings, as is the case in this rendering. The view shown is a pre-fabricated press box on the home stand side.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
8HOME STANDS RENDERING
This rending looks north east toward the home stands from the North 12th Street end of the stadium. Mobile food vendors are shown to the left and the entrance to public bathrooms can be seen beneath the stands just right of center.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
9HOME STANDS RENDERING
The rendering shows the area behind the home stands. To the left is the storage area and bathrooms, and to the right beyond the fence is the parking lot. The storage areas are locked and the surrounding fence is covered in vinyl signage for added privacy.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
10ENTRANCE GATE
The entrance remains near the corner of North 12th and Church streets with no change to the existing retaining wall. The arch and ticket booths are combined into one, smaller structure. Bronze letters have been removed from the sidewalk and overall signage is reduced. A basic scoreboard on the field replaces the LED video board on the arch.
4 $100,000 $150,00014 $40,000 $50,00019 $75,000 $100,000
Total $215,000 $300,000
Item Low Range High Range
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
11ENTRANCE GATE
The mural remains and a portion of the existing gate will be reused. Pavers at the main entrance will be available for donor sponsorship. A new ramp makes the stadium ADA accessible from this entrance.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
1212TH STREET IMPROVEMENTS
12th Street remains largely as it is today with the existing retaining wall and mural. Plans for curb widening, bump outs and asphalt milling are removed. Electric service to stadium outbuildings remains overhead.
2 $100,000 $130,0003 $60,000 $70,00016 $60,000 $75,00021* $200,000 $250,000
Total $420,000 $525,000
*Savings include work on entrance gate
Item Low Range High Range
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
ENTRANCE GATE & 12TH STREET IMPROVEMENTS RENDERING
This rendering shows the main entrance to the stadium near the corner of 12th and Church streets. The tower has been reduced in size and ticket booths included into one structure. This view also shows 12th Street largely unchanged from how it exists today.
13
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
14LOCKER ROOMS
The overall scope of the field house is reduced. Ten mini split AC units will remain, and exterior equipment will be protected by fencing instead of screen walls. Lockers are simplified and locker rooms will use a sealed concrete floor.
9 $40,000 $50,00010 $320,000 $350,00011 $30,000 $40,00015 $50,000 $60,000
Total $440,000 $500,000
Item Low Range High Range
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
15OTHER SITE WORK
Additional site works includes the removal of planned new concession stands and the new ticket/booster building. Hard wired data connections and additional TV station cabling is removed.
6 $600,000 $690,00017 $30,000 $35,00018 $40,000 $50,00024 $80,000 $100,000
Total $750,000 $875,000
Item Low Range High Range
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
16TURF FIELD
Installation of a synthetic turf field is designed to increase Cottingham Stadium’s return on investment. Turf is a more durable surface that requires less maintenance. The new field allows for a wider variety of uses, including soccer, field hockey, lacrosse and general recreation. This redesign positions Cottingham as a valuable public asset.
Cost $850,000 $1,000,000
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
17REDESIGN GOALS
The redesign has two goals: lower the costs of construction and increase the return on investment. Spaces throughout Cottingham Stadium have been redesigned in order to achieve an estimated savings of $3.1 million to $3.6 million. The investment return is increased by the flexibility of spaces allowing for a variety of athletes and community members to use the improved venue.
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19
18COTTINGHAM STADIUM DRAFT MILESTONE SCHEDULE
COTTINGHAM STADIUM REDESIGN PRESENTATION 11/6/19