cosmological 1
TRANSCRIPT
Proving that ‘god’ (or something) existseasier than it soundsmaybe
Sleepless productions
first of all...• does it even matter?
• should you even care?
• would it change who you were if you knew God was there?
• one minute super quick answer in pairs
Sleepless productions
Let’s start with science...• you see a crater, what does that mean has happened?
• if you see a new table in cdt, what has happened?
• there’s a burnt out car in the school car park?
• someone’s holding a ice pack to their head?Sleepless productions
Let’s start with science...• if you see a bullet fly past you, what does that mean has happened?
• if you see one of your mates with a black eye, what has happened?
• or someone comes into school looking a lot browner than usual?
• someone’s eyes are all black because their mascara has run?Sleepless productions
science?• well almost...
• everything has a cause doesn’t it?
• or does it?
• pairs
• 3minutes
Sleepless productions
dominoes• if everything has a cause
• then every cause must have a cause (as every cause is a separate thing)
• so your mates girlfriend/boyfriend dumped her because she’d been with someone else at the weekend.
• and that would be caused by something else as well...
Sleepless productions
reactions test game• silence is the key
• if you move before i do, you lose a point
• anyone looks round, you lose a point
Sleepless productions
simple versionyou are going to learn eventually that there is not only one cosmological argument
in fact you’re going to learn about loads
some that work better than others
so cosmological argumentsbut for starters, this is an easy version.
We’ll call this the causal version of the c.a.Sleepless productions
the argumentP1 Everything has a cause.
P2 Nothing is its own cause
P3 A chain of causes cannot be infinite
P4 there must be a ‘first cause’
C this is GODSleepless productions
so in the game..who was god?
Sleepless productions
so in the game..
who was the big bang?
Sleepless productions
so in the game..
and all the rest of you were all of history...
Sleepless productions
an infinite chain
‘hanging’ in the sky...
goes on for ever it seems like...
Sleepless productions
you are all expert critical
thinkers...do you find each of these
premises acceptable
make a couple of sentences on each one, reasons.
and conclusion, does it follow?
TITLE: The Cosmological Argument; GUT REACTIONS
Sleepless productions
the argumentP1 Everything has a cause.
P2 Nothing is its own cause
P3 A chain of causes cannot be infinite
P4 there must be a ‘first cause’
C this is GODSleepless productions
Cosmological Argument -
Week 2Introduction to metaphysics
Discussion of argument as conceived last week -
potential problems, fallacies & the like.
Introduce the Kalam cosmological argument
Sleepless productions
gut feelings...
god exists, yeah?
Sleepless productions
premise 1
• a priori/a posteriori?
• any exceptions?
• in fact it’s pretty well established physics...
• laws of thermodynamics
• things only change when something causes them to...
Everything has a cause.
Sleepless productions
premise 2
• a priori/a posteriori?
• cause they happen at different times
• any exceptions?
• Kant’s cushion?
Nothing is its own cause
Sleepless productions
premise 3
• a priori/a posteriori?
• this is a really big deal this time...
• how could you prove this?
A chain of causes cannot be infinite
Sleepless productions
premise 4
• a priori/a posteriori?
• think about it a bit more
• no first cause = no second cause = no third cause = nothing.
• does it follow if we accept the other premises?
• what about if everything has a cause?
there must be a ‘first cause’
Sleepless productions
“then what caused god?”
aka the schoolboy objection
but does it work?
Sleepless productions
conclusion
• a priori/a posteriori?
•why would you think it was GOD?
•what can you tell about this ‘GOD’?
this is GOD!
Sleepless productions
the Kalam argumentMetaphysics - The Cosmological Arguments
Sleepless productions
QuickTime™ and aH.264 decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
“evidence” videoSleepless productions
who is the main proponent of a cosmological argument alive
today?
what does ex nihilo mean?
write out his argument in a premise/conclusion form.
how does he validate his second premise?
questions
Sleepless productions
QuickTime™ and aH.264 decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
video Kalam IntroductionSleepless productions
why did people stop believing the universe was eternal?
what did hubble discover about other galaxies? why does it matter?
what did it mean for those who believed the universe was eternal?
what is singularity? what began here?
what does background radiation suggest?
questions
Sleepless productions
the kalam argumentP1 Everything that begins to
exist has a cause.
P2 The universe began to exist.
P3 The Universe must have a cause.
C sounds like GODSleepless productions
stephen hawking
It really does look like the universe did have a start point (and so is finite).
[well maybe]Sleepless productions
HW: what evidence is there for the big bang?
questions
Sleepless productions
standard higher notes
Sleepless productions
st thomas aquinas
‘i can prove to you that god exists’
Sleepless productions
the argumentP1 Everything has a cause.
P2 Nothing is its own cause
P3 A chain of causes cannot be infinite
P4 there must be a ‘first cause’
C this is GODSleepless productions
uncaused causer
“sounds like a pretty good description of God.”
hmmm... hmmm... sounds sounds
familiar... familiar...
it must be something it must be something eternal... something eternal... something
really powerful... really powerful... something outside of something outside of time...and most of all, time...and most of all,
something totally something totally NECESSARYNECESSARY
Sleepless productions
uncaused causer
“sounds like a pretty good description of God.”
everything everything with a cause, i with a cause, i
will call will call contingent... contingent...
...and this first ...and this first cause I will call cause I will call
NECESSARY, NECESSARY, because it doesn’t because it doesn’t
depend on depend on anything else for anything else for
its existence.its existence.Sleepless productions
a problem?‘but don’t premise 1 & 4 contradict each other?’
hold on a hold on a second...second...
let’s think let’s think about it about it
carefully....carefully....
the first three premises are like a problem4 is presented as an alternative to premise 1if 1 &4 are okay then, the argument goes, we
must accept 4
Sleepless productions
but what about?
“if god created the universe, who created
god?”
ah haaa...ah haaa...but...but...
that is that is another another
BAD BAD objection...objection...
the whole point is that Aquinas says God is Necessaryif something created God, then God is NOT NecessaryGod is only contingent, and we still have the problem!
Sleepless productions
a proper objection...
is there a fallacy of composition to be found
here?
ah haaa...ah haaa...but... but...
there is a there is a bit of a bit of a
problem...problem...
can you remember what that means?something to do with parts and the whole
Celtic football Club has legs...
there is a there is a bit of a bit of a
problem...problem...
Sleepless productions
a fallacy of composition.
..all of the part of an object (O) have a given property
(P)
this doesn’t this doesn’t mean that O mean that O
has has property Pproperty P
can you remember what that means?something to do with parts and the wholeCeltic football Club has legs...Human body is
invisible?
we could we could also use the also use the
word word EQUIVOCATIEQUIVOCATI
ONON
Sleepless productions
how does that fit with what we have been talking about?
let’s find out...
questions Sleepless productions
QuickTime™ and aH.264 decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Equivocation what’s it all about? - KalamSleepless productions
big bang isn’t a causebecause nothing can be
its own cause
Sleepless productions
and this cause...well it’s ‘god’...
Sleepless productions
you are all expert critical
thinkers...for homework, you need to
have a shot at the basic argument...
give it the NAB treatment...
is it valid? what about its form?
Sleepless productions
conclusionwhy is there something
rather than nothing?
Sleepless productions
if this is truly
inconclusiveand i have another reason
for believing that god might exist, that might just tilt the balance that
way...
Sleepless productions