convergent innovation - food packaging forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · we are building the food...

41
CONVERGENT INNOVATION Modular Platforms for Scaling up What Packaging can Contribute to Business Competitiveness and Healthy Diets from Sustainable Food systems Laurette Dube with Technical insights from Claire Sand, Packaging Solutions Inc. & Strategic Business Insights from Enderson Guimaraes, Refresco Group October 24 2019, Zurich Food Packaging Forum

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

CONVERGENT INNOVATION

Modular Platforms for Scaling up What Packaging can Contribute to Business Competitiveness and Healthy Diets

from Sustainable Food systems

Laurette Dube with Technical insights from Claire Sand, Packaging Solutions Inc. &

Strategic Business Insights from Enderson Guimaraes, Refresco Group

October 24 2019, Zurich

Food Packaging Forum

Page 2: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Agenda

• Convergent Innovation in the agri-food sector (product formulation, branding and ecosystem)

• Translational science foundations

• Use Case: Building supply and demand for food packaging solutions to endocrine disruption effects of BPA on child brain development for lifelong wellness

2

Page 3: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Food Convergent Innovation(FCI)

Transformational discovery & innovation platforms converging across disciplines and sectors, fostering the production, promotion and consumption of foods & beverages that sustain the health of the economy through the health of people and the health of the planet.

Laurette Dube et al, September 11 2019

Page 4: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

FCI is a behaviorally informed and AI-powered innovation approach that fosters a virtuous cycle centered on food ad the convergence sweet spot

• Utilizing AI and other digital technologies facilitates, expands, and accelerates innovation for new products and new diets that hit the Food Convergent Innovation (FCI) sweet spot.

• This leads to a virtuous cycle of innovation / impact / insight.

…Ingredients, Taste, and Sensory Technology, with… …Packaging,

Transportation, Retail, Service,

and Consumption, with…

…are willing and able to pay for

…want

…are able and willing to produce

…and the planet can sustain

…and society need

Food thatPeople… …Pipelines

In Digital Technologies, Media, and Advanced

Analytics, with…

…Farmand Food

Processing, with…

…Nutrition,Health, and

Disease, with…

…Animal and Plant

Breeding, with…

FCI Sweet Spot Brings Together…

Insight drivingInnovation

Innovation drivingInsight

Page 5: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Driving Convergent Innovation Through Modular Projects for Lasting Supply and Demand for Real World Solutions

Integrated Digital Backbone Supports each Discipline

ConvergentInnovation

(CI)

Dri

ves

CI

Targeted OutcomesSerendipitous Outcomes

Supply

ChainNutritionBiotech

GenomicsPharma Consumers

Medicine

Bio

Pharma

Public

HealthHealth

EconomicsSustainability

Management

Commerce/ Commercial

Macro/Micro Economics

Culture/ Anthropology

Decision Neuroscience

Behavioral Economics

Page 6: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Public

Health

Case Study FCI-Quebec: Inventory of natural ingredients allowing a clean label with improved shelf-life and food quality.

Integrated Digital Backbone Supports each Discipline

Dri

ves

CI

Shared information across food industry sectors (dairy, bakery, meat, ingredients, fruits and vegetables, etc.) mapped needs to available and novel natural ingredient and process solutions, enabling extended shelf-life for clean label foods.

Biotech

Pharma Consumers

Medicine

Bio

Pharma

Health

EconomicsSustainability

ManagementMacro/Micro

Economics

Decision Neuroscience

Behavioral Economics

Supply

ChainNutrition

Genomics

Culture/ Anthropology Commerce/

Commercial

Highlights critical elements Convergent

Innovation(CI)

Page 7: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Case Study: Chewpod delivery system with natural ingredients lead to product innovation in functional chewable category

Integrated Digital Backbone Supports each Discipline

Dri

ves

CI

Consumers

Medicine Public

HealthHealth

EconomicsSustainability

ManagementMacro/Micro

Economics

Decision Neuroscience

Behavioral Economics

Culture/ Anthropology

Commerce/ Commercial

Biotech

Pharma

Supply

ChainNutrition

Genomics Bio

Pharma

Using Chewpod patented delivery systems and partnering with other food/ingredient companies, developed new Food/Natural health products delivering bioactives for oral absorption for targeted consumer benefits (anti-stress, blood glucose modulation, etc.)

ConvergentInnovation

(CI)

Highlights critical elements

Page 8: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Pulses as Test-bed Agricultural Commodity for Global and National FCI Platforms

PIP-India Launch in Presence of the Honourable Lawrence MacAulay, Canada’s Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food

From the detailed note to AAFC press release on March 2017 India visit:

Pulse Innovation Platform-India is designed to bridge gaps and build synergy

between pulse production, its processing, and its contribution to human and

environmental health

- Honourable Lawrence MacAulay, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food

Page 9: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Pepsico: Reduction of Share of Legacy Brands to 10% of Global Business with Award-Winning Sustainability Strategy

(Mehmood Khan, 2019, former Pepsico Vice Chairman)

9

Page 10: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

The Time May be Ripe for Bridging Investments and Innovationon Both Sides of the Social/Commercial to Build Supply and Demand

for Healthy Foods and Diets Around the World

10

Food people are willing and able

to pay for

Food people want

Food the farmer and value chain are willing and

able to produce

Food the planet can sustain

Food people need

Convergent Innovation“Sweet Spot”

Page 11: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Mother Food International: A Global Enterprise of Local Businesses for Economically Viable Solution to

Mother and Child Nutrition

11

2016

Strategy:

Nutrition:

Data:

Product

Development:

Flavors:

Page 12: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Canada Food Policy: Innovating, Branding and Commercializing Agri-Food Products, Processes and

Systems at the FCI Sweet Spot on Domestic and International Markets

FCI SWEET SPOT BRAND CANADA

It is about understanding & leveraging the claims behind “the brand”

Canada food brand project

TrustedQualitySafeSustainableReliable

Clean

…are willing and able to pay for

…want

…are able and willing to produce

…and the planet can sustain

…and society need

Food thatPeople…

Page 13: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

A 21ST CENTURY PREMIUM ECOSYSTEM BRANDFOR INDIA AND THE REST OF THE WORLD

13

“I trust”“I can eat”“ I can and will afford”“I believe it is healthy”“It is tasty , appealing“It is s convenient

Category-based Nutrient Threshold“High protein”“High fiber”“Low GI”“Some minerals”“Low in fat, salt & sugar”

“Increase sales and financial return”“Corporate image”“CSR”“Consumer & market insights”

“More value for my crop”“Quality”“Pride”“Confidence”“Cool” – younger generation

Research, policy and regulatory aspects for enabling environment

“Sustainability”- environment, economic, & food/nutrition security“Impact”“Mobilizes other resources”“Scale & integrate with gov’t programs”“Multi-sectoral collaborations”

“Innovation”“Impact”“Returns”“Sustainability”“Visibility” “Mobilizes untapped resources”

FCI CANADA INVENTING THE 21ST CENTURY PREMIUM ECOSYSTEM BRAND

Investors

Government

Research and Policy EnablerS

Farmer

Business

Health / Nutrition Enabler

Eater

PatientCitizenConsumer

Page 14: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with a variety of partners in a connected world.

FCI India

FCI Ghana

FCI Montreal

FCI Quebec

FCI Canada

FCI GlobalIntegrative Digital Backbone(Connect People, Organizations,

Knowledge, and Data)

Behavior-Context-Market-Industry Insights and Trends, Research (S&T) Support (Precision

Retailing)

Industry, technical and strategic advice & support to action (FCI Grand Support Accelerator)

Dig

ital

& D

ata

Part

ner

s

Aca

dem

ic P

artn

ers

Act

ion

Par

tne

rs

Capabilities Partners Geographies

• There are a number of ongoing initiatives, cross-leveraging learnings from each.

Page 15: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Translational Science Foundations

15

Page 16: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Breaking the 1st Industrial Revolution Codes for Economic and Social Value Creation and Breaking Complexity in 4th Industrial

Revolution Bite-Size Action

16

Page 17: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Convergent Innovation (CI)

17

• CI framework bridges science, policy, and actionthrough digital innovation, human agency, andsocial capital to alleviate the constraints andaccelerate real world solutions to grand challengesthrough convergence:

• between natural, life, social and engineering sciencesthat historically have had each of these spheres asrespective domains;

• between health, social, and economic systems thatstill divide modern society in structuring how scienceis translated into products, services, programs orother innovations to support individual and society;

• between public, private and civil society actors ineach of these systems;

• between the various scales at which mechanisms,actors, and institutions are operating.

Page 18: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Bringing Systems Sciences to Embrace Some of the BtSComplexity of Real World Behavior

Page 19: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Complexity and Systems Science Framework for Food Choice, Eating Behavior and their Environmental,

Health and Economic Outcomes

Page 20: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Convergent Innovation: Keeping Individuals at the Center of MultiScale Social

and Economic Innovation, Operation and Policy Systems that Individually amd

Collectively Target Convergent Outcomes

• The complexity is clear.

• The solution is not to solve for

all variables at once but rather

to converge on those areas

where we have clear strength,

experience, current capability

and a right to win, allowing time

for development of the requisite

knowledge in those areas where

these are lacking.

• The long term vision is a multi-

level ecosystem system for

convergent innovation

20

Page 21: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Dopaminergic Gene and Brain Systems as Regulators of Behavioral Responses to Internal and External Environment

https://medlibes.com/entry/dopamine-pathways

https://www.everydayhealth.com/dopamine/

Page 22: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Food Choice and Eating as Neurobehavior:Characterizing and Improving Real World Environment

× →

Page 23: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Building Supply and Demand for Real-World Solutions to

Endocrine Disruption Effect on Child Brain Development

23

Page 24: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Endocrine Disruptors

Schug et alMol Endocrinol, August 2016, 30(8):833–847 doi: 10.1210/me.2016-1096

Thaddeus T. Schug, Anne F. Johnson, Linda S. Birnbaum, Theo Colborn, Louis J. Guillette, Jr., David P. Crews, Terry Collins, Ana M. Soto, Frederick S. vom Saal, John A. McLachlan, Carlos Sonnenschein, and Jerrold J. Heindel

Page 25: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Endocrine Disruptors: Past Lessons and Future Directions

Schug et alMol Endocrinol, August 2016, 30(8):833–847 doi: 10.1210/me.2016-1096

Page 26: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Endocrine Disruptors: Past Lessons and Future Directions

Schug et alMol Endocrinol, August 2016, 30(8):833–847 doi: 10.1210/me.2016-1096

Page 27: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Estradiol and the Developing Brain

27M. M. McCarthy Physiol Rev. 2008 January ; 88(1): 91–124. doi:10.1152/physrev.00010.2007.

Margaret M. McCarthy

Page 28: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Estradiol and the Developing Brain

28M. M. McCarthy Physiol Rev. 2008 January ; 88(1): 91–124. doi:10.1152/physrev.00010.2007.

Page 29: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Moving toward technological solution: EstrogenicityAssessment of a New Food-Contact Coating and the

Bisphenol Used in Its Synthesis

Soto et alDOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b04704 Environ. Sci. Technol. 2017, 51, 1718−1726

Ana M. Soto, Cheryl Schaeberle, Mark S. Maier, Carlos Sonnenschein, and Maricel V. Maffini

Page 30: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

From Technological to System-Level Innovation and

CI Ecosystem Building

Meaningful increases in sustainable

packaging and decreases in food

waste and endocrine disruption are

attainable by reconsidering the

value chain processes that define

how food goes from farm to fork

Food Forum Claire Sand, PTR 3

0

Page 31: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Packaging Innovation Within Agri-Food Supply Chains: Illustration Intelligent Packaging

Yam, K. L. (2012)In Emerging Food Packaging Technologies(pp. 137-152). Woodhead Publishing.

Page 32: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Traceability in Packaging to enhance food safety and quality

Yam, K. L. (2012)In Emerging Food Packaging Technologies(pp. 137-152). Woodhead Publishing.

Page 33: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Packaging to enhance food safety and quality

Yam, K. L. (2012)In Emerging Food Packaging Technologies(pp. 137-152). Woodhead Publishing.

Page 34: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Intelligent packaging to enhance food safety and quality

Yam, K. L. (2012)In Emerging Food Packaging Technologies(pp. 137-152). Woodhead Publishing.

Page 35: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Intelligent packaging to enhance food safety and quality

Yam, K. L. (2012)In Emerging Food Packaging Technologies(pp. 137-152). Woodhead Publishing.

Page 36: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Bridging Networks and network resources in CI Ecosystem Building for Supply and Demand

J. Musiolik et al.Technological Forecasting & Social Change 79 (2012) 1032–1048

Page 37: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Creating CI Ecosystem: How resource constellations affect the strategies of system builders

Musiolik, Jörg, et al.Technological Forecasting and Social Change(2018).

Page 38: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Informal institutions matter: Professional culture in Agriculture, Food, Material and Health/Medicine

Wirth, Steffen, et al.Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 8 (2013): 20-41.

Page 39: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

SummaryFCI ecosystem: Engage Many players, many hands.

Focused goals, targeted outcomes.

Universities

• Education and training• Fundamental and

strategic research

Research institutes• Strategic and applied

research• Pre-competitive &

confidential projects

Spin-offs / SMEs• End-to-End Lean and

Agile Innovation. Entrepreneurship

International & national companies• R&D departments• Shared facilities• Joint activities

• Bringing together the key players essential for success: universities, companies with global reach, companies closely linked to their communities, research institutes, entrepreneurial startups.

• Imagine what can be achieved.

Page 40: CONVERGENT INNOVATION - Food Packaging Forum€¦ · 24/10/2019  · We are building the food convergent innovation ecosystem from a robust base - initially 3 core capabilities with

Brain-to-Society/Convergent Innovation Team at MCCHE

Peer reviewed research

40

Key Team Members

Laurette Dubé Patricia P. Silveira Robert D. Levitan James L. Kennedy Spencer Moore Yu Ma

Michael Meaney Andre Portella Jian Yun Nie Lesley Fellows Shawn BrownAlain Dagher

Nathan Spreng Nathan Yang Daiva Nielsen Susan Carnell Baerbel Knauper Alan EvansCatherine Paquet