contractor evaluation abc

Upload: isaac-mohanadasan

Post on 04-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    1/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    2/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    3/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    4/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    5/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    6/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    7/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    8/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    9/30

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    10/30

    Security deposit/Performance bond

    Law, regualation and requirements

    Site inspection and site survey

    Access and egress

    Progress PhotographsProgress report

    Site meetings

    Site office and temporary building

    Site office and temporary building (contd)

    Site management and supervision

    Site agent

    Contractors site staff

    Plant and equipment

    Materials test

    Form of contract (cont'd clause 5)

    Form of contract (cont'd clause 19,20,21)Temporary access roads

    Temporary Drains

    Temporary crossings

    Existing roads

    Temporary electricity supply

    Water for works

    Temporary lighting (contd)

    Telephone

    Mosquitoes prevention

    Pumping

    Pollution

    Signboard

    Sheds etc

    Safety,health and welfare of work people

    Sanitary accommodation

    Safety measures for the consurction of buildings

    Site security

    General scaffolding and staging

    Shop drawings

    As built drawings and opperating and maintainace instructions

    Keeping site dry

    Removal of rubbish

    Clearing the works and handing overTemporary hoarding

    Stamping of contract document

    Calculated Preliminaries

    Page 1/6 (performance bond)

    Page 1/7

    page 1/10

    page 1/12

    page 1/13

    Description

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    11/30

    Page 1/14

    page 1/15

    page 1/16

    page 1/18

    page 1/21

    Page 1/25

    page 1/29

    page 1/33Page 1/49

    page 1/50

    page 1/52

    page 1/53

    page 1/54

    page 1/56

    page 1/57

    page 1/58

    page 1/59

    page 1/60

    page 1/64page 1/66

    page 1/68

    page 1/69

    page 1/71

    page 1/72

    page 1/75

    page 1/79

    Electrical services

    Electrical services

    Electrical services

    Telephone and CCTV system

    Telephone and CCTV system

    Telephone and CCTV system

    Cold water and sanitary plumbing services

    Cold water and sanitary plumbing services

    Cold water and sanitary plumbing services

    Fire fighting services

    Fire fighting services

    Fire fighting services

    Airconditioning services

    Airconditioning services

    Airconditioning services

    Lift installationLift installation

    Lift installation

    Landscaping works

    Landscaping works

    Landscaping works

    Glass canopy roof

    Glass canopy roof

    Glass canopy roof

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    12/30

    Glass railing to main staircase first & second floor terrance and void area

    Glass railing to main staircase first & second floor terrance and void area

    Glass railing to main staircase first & second floor terrance and void area

    Timber pergola with transparent polycarbonate sheet

    Compact TNB sub-station

    Rainwater harvesting retention tank

    Entrance culvert slab

    Fencing wallMild steel entrance gate

    Contingencies sum

    Calculated Prime cost and provisional sums

    Page 2/2

    Page 2/3

    Page 2/4

    To provide design and shop drawings

    setting out pile points

    Grout test

    Piling equipment

    Piling equipmentPiling records

    Piling records

    Piling records

    Piling records

    Piling records

    Piling records

    Load test

    Load test

    Page 3/1

    Page 3/2

    Page 3/6

    Piling equipment

    Piling equipment

    Piling equipment

    Setting out and as-built drawings

    Setting out and as-built drawings

    supply,deliver,unload,handle,transport, pitching within the site

    supply,deliver,unload,handle,transport, pitching within the site

    supply,deliver,unload,handle,transport, pitching within the site

    drive only with jacked-in method; complete with standard x-point shoe

    extension joint

    cutting off pile heads

    pile pluggingLoad test

    Load test

    Calculated Piling works

    Page 3/9

    Page 3/10

    Page 3/11

    Micro Piling works

    Pretensioned spun concrete piles

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    13/30

    Excavator: Below lowest floor level

    Excavator: Below lowest floor level

    Excavator: Below lowest floor level

    Excavator: Below lowest floor level

    Excavator: Below lowest floor level

    Concretor: Below lowest floor level

    Concretor: Below lowest floor level

    Concretor: Below lowest floor levelConcretor: Below lowest floor level

    Concretor: pile caps, column stumps, ground beams lift pit walls

    Concretor: ground slab BRC A7

    Concretor (sawn formwork): pile caps, column stumps, ground beams lift pit walls

    Sundries: underneath ground slab

    Sundries: underneath ground slab and beams

    Sundries: lift pit walls

    Page 4/1

    Page 4/2

    Page 4/3

    Concretor: suspendend floor beamsConcretor: columns

    Concretor: lift core walls

    Concretor: mild steel and high tensile bar reinforcement; links, stirrups or binders

    Concretor: swan formwork; sides, vertical, soffit

    Prestressed concrete floor beams: second floor beams

    Prestressed concrete floor beams: third floor beams

    Frame: structural steel; Sundries

    page 4/5

    page 4/6

    page 4/7

    Concretor: suspendend floor slab

    Concretor: suspendend cornice slab

    Concretor: mild steel and high tensile bar reinforcement; links, stirrups or binders

    Concretor: suspendend floor slab

    waterproofing membrane

    pavior

    Concretor: suspendend roof beams

    Concretor: suspendend roof slab

    Concretor: suspendend roof slab

    Concretor: mild steel and high tensile bar reinforcement; links, stirrups or binders

    Concretor: mild steel and high tensile bar reinforcement; links, stirrups or binders

    concretor: sawn formwork; sides and soffit suspended roof beams

    concretor: sawn formwork; soffit; horizontal suspended roof slabProprietary steel roof truss: pitched roof; 30 degrees

    Proprietary steel roof truss: pitched roof; 10 degrees

    Roofer: pitched roof; 30 degrees

    Roofer: extra over for ridge capping

    Roofer: pitched roof; 10 degrees

    Roofer: pitched roof; 30 degrees (1 layer of bison woven 2 double sided aluminum foil)

    Roofer: pitched roof; 10 degrees (1 layer of bison woven 2 double sided aluminum foil)

    Roofer: pitched roof; 30 degrees (1 layer of roxul 50mm thich x 40kg/m3)

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    14/30

    Roofer: pitched roof; 10 degrees (1 layer of roxul 50mm thich x 40kg/m3)

    Rainwater goods: 100mm diameter

    Rainwater goods: extra over for bends

    Rainwater goods: extra over for forming outlets

    Rainwater goods: extra over for 150mm diameter dome grating

    Rainwater goods: Embedded ground slabs (100mm diameter)

    Sundries

    SundriesWaterproofing membrane

    pavior

    page 4/10

    page 4/11

    page 4/12

    page 4/13

    Concretor: to staircase

    Concretor: to landing slab; 175mm thick

    Concretor: to landing beam

    Concretor: to staircase and landing slab

    Concretor: to landing beamsConcretor: undercut risers; exceeding 100mm but not exceeding 200mm high

    Concretor: open string including cutting to profile of threads and risers

    Concretor: landing slab, staircase, landing beams

    Plasterer: sides of open string; extreme 300mm wide

    Plasterer: slopping soffit of staircase, soffit of landing slab, sides and soffit of landing beam

    Pavior: to thread 200mm-300mm wide

    Pavior: to riser; 100mm - 200mm high

    Pavior: to landing slab

    Pavior: skirting; 100mm high

    Pavior: extra over for nosing tiles

    Painter: sides of open string; extreme wide

    Painter: slopping soffit of staircase, soffit of landing slab, sides and soffit of landing beam

    Works associated in mild steel: work to staircase 100mm high

    page 4/15

    page 4/16

    page 4/17

    Brick layer: to external walls

    Brick layer: to external walls

    Brick layer: to internal walls

    Concretor: Windows

    Aluminium worker: top hung windows

    Aluminium worker: Casement windows

    Aluminium worker: Casement windowsAluminium worker: Casement windows with fixed glass panel

    Aluminium worker: fixed glass window 1200mm x 3500mm (w7)

    Aluminium worker: fixed glass window 900mm x 3000mm (gridline 4/D-C)

    Aluminium worker: fixed glass window 7665mm x 2000mm (roof level)

    Aluminium worker: fixed glass window 7665mm x 1000mm (roof level)

    Aluminium worker: fixed glass window 2200mm x 2000mm (roof level)

    Aluminium worker: aluminium fixed louvred window

    Aluminium worker: aluminium fixed louvred window

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    15/30

    Aluminium worker: aluminium fixed louvred window

    Aluminium worker: aluminium fixed louvred window

    Page 4/21

    Page 4/22

    conretor: lintol (doors)

    concretor: To suit door openings

    concretor: To suit door openings

    concretor: To suit door openingsconcretor: To suit door openings

    Joiner: wrought pressure treated grade B timber

    Joiner: wrought pressure treated grade B timber

    Joiner: wrought pressure treated grade B timber

    Joiner: wrought pressure treated grade B timber

    Joiner: one hour fire rated

    Joiner: one hour fire rated

    Work associated in mild steel: mild steel grille

    Painter: work to metal surface

    Painter: work to door leaf

    Ironmongery: fixing to timber doorsSundries: fixing cramps (doors)

    Page 4/24

    Page 4/25

    Page 4/26

    Page 4/27

    Plasterer: walls and columns

    Plasterer: walls and columns

    Painter: walls and columns

    Painter: walls and columns

    Wall Tiler: to walls

    Page 4/29

    Page 4/30

    Pavior: to floors

    Pavior: to floors; levelled

    Pavior: to floors; levelled

    Pavior: to skirting

    Waterproofing membrane: floors (toilet area)

    Waterproofing membrane: extra over 1:3 cement and sand angle fillet

    Waterproofing membrane: extra over for 300mm high upstand skirting

    Page 4/32

    Page 4/33

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishesPlasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Plasterer: Ceiling finishes

    Suspended Ceiling

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    16/30

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Painter: Ceiling finishes

    Page 4/35Page 4/36

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: Luton

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: Andermatt

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: windsor

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: yale

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: toilet paper holder

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: malvern

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: Shower rose

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: bib tap

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: bowl, sink, tap etc

    Sanitary fittings and accessories: floor trapPage 4/38

    Page 4/39

    Demolition works: Existing prayer hall

    Concrete vanity top

    Concrete vanity top

    Calculated Building works

    Work below lowest floor level

    Frame

    Upper floor

    Roof

    Staircase

    External Walls

    Internal walls

    Windows

    Doors

    Wall finishes

    Floor Finishes

    Ceiling Finishes

    Sanitary appliances

    Miscellanrous works

    Earthworks: Site clearance

    Earthworks: excavator

    Earthworks: excavatorEarthworks: Backfilling with imported earth

    Earthworks: temporary earth drain

    Earthworks: Wash trough

    Earthworks: Sediment Basin

    Earthworks: Temporary access road

    Earthworks: Temporary access road

    Earthworks: Temporary pipe culvert

    Earthworks: Removal of temporary works

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    17/30

    Earthworks: Removal of temporary works

    Earthworks: Removal of temporary works

    Earthworks: Removal of temporary works

    Earthworks: Removal of temporary works

    Earthworks: Demolition of existing retaining wall

    Earthworks: Relocation of existing pipe culvert

    Page 5/1

    Page 5/2Page 5/3

    Page 5/4

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Excavator

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: ConcretorReinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Concretor

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Drainage works

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Drainage works (sundries)

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls: Drainage works (sundries)

    Page 5/6

    Page 5/7

    Page 5/8

    Road works: Concrete drive way

    Road works: Road

    Road works: high road kerb

    Road works: high outlet road kerbs

    Road works: closed turfing (ground)

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnitures

    Road marking and furnituresRoad marking and furnitures

    Page 5/10

    Page 5/11

    Drainage works: Brickwall Drain

    Drainage works: precast concrete drain cover slab

    Drainage works: reinforced concrete catch pit

    Sump: Brick wall sump

    Sump: Brick wall sump

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    18/30

    Sump: discharge control pit

    Pipe culvert: 600mm diameter

    Pipe culvert: 900mm diameter

    Pipe culvert: 1200mm diameter

    Earthworks

    Reinforced concrete retaining walls

    Road works

    Drainage worksSump

    Pipe culvert

    Calculated external works

    Preliminaries

    Prime costs and provisional sums

    Piling works

    Building works

    External works

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    19/30

    A B C

    A,B 9,000 Waved ------------- N/A included in report but no

    F N/A 11,800 ------------- Missing in contractors re

    A,B,C,D N/A N/A 5,000

    E,F,G N/A 11,800 N/A

    B 1,000 2,124 1,500C,D 1,000 N/A 3,000

    C,D 1,000

    E 8,000 15,340 10,000

    A,B,C,D,E,F 12,000

    D,E 36,000 ------------- 24,000

    B,C,D 54,000

    C,D,E,F,G 18,000 169,920 -------------

    B,C,D,E,F N/A 141,600 25,000

    E,F,G 3,000 5,900 N/A

    A 3,500 11,800 -------------

    A,B,C 7,000 18,880 35,000E 3,000 ------------- 5,000

    A N/A ------------- 3,000

    B N/A ------------- 3,000

    C,D,E,F 3,000 ------------- 5,000

    A,B,C,D,E 8,000 27,140 -------------

    A 4,000 37,760 20,000

    A 1,000

    B 1,000 10,620 -------------

    A,B,C N/A 3,186 5,000

    D N/A N/A 8,000

    E,F N/A N/A 5,000

    B 2,400 3,540 1,500

    C,D N/A N/A 5,000

    E N/A N/A 5,000

    A,B 2,400 ------------- 5,000

    A,B,C,D,E,F,G 1,800 N/A N/A

    C 18,000 25,488 27,000

    C,D,E ------------- ------------- 35,000

    C,D,E,F,G N/A 3,540 -------------

    A,B,C 1,800

    B,C,D N/A ------------- 5,000

    D N/A 16,520 N/A

    F 6,000 5,900 5,000A,B 6,000 30,444 10,000

    F N/A 9,440 7,500

    211,900 562,742 263,500

    9,000 waved N/A

    N/A 11,800 N/A

    N/A 11,800 5,000

    2,000 2,124 4,500

    9,000 15,340 10,000

    Contractor (amounts RM)item

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    20/30

    12,000

    36,000 N/A 24,000

    54,000

    18,000 169,920 N/A

    N/A 141,600 25,000

    3,000 5,900

    3,500 11,800

    7,000 18,880 35,0003,000 ------------- 5,000

    3,000 ------------- 11,000

    8,000 27,140 20,000

    4,000 37,760 20,000

    2,000 10,620

    N/A 3,186 18,000

    2,400 3,540 11,500

    2,400 ------------- 5,000

    1,800

    18,000 25,488 27,000

    N/A ------------- 35,000N/A ------------- 5,000

    N/A 3,540 -------------

    1,800 5,900 -------------

    N/A 22,420 5,000

    6,000

    6,000 30,444 10,000

    N/A 9,440 7,500

    A 400,000 400,000 400,000

    B 8,000 8,000

    C 4,000 8,000

    D 100,000 100,000 100,000

    E 2,000 2,000

    F 1,000 2,000

    G 140,000 140,000 140,000

    H 2800 2,800

    I 1400 2,800

    J 300,000 300,000 300,000

    K 6,000 6,000

    L 3,000 6,000

    J 600,000 600,000 600,000

    K 12,000 12,000

    L 6,000 12,000

    A 240,000 240,000 240,000B 2400 4,800

    C 2400 4,800

    D 100,000 100,000 100,000

    E 1,000 2,000

    F 1,000 2,000

    G 150,000 150,000 150,000

    H 3,000 3,000

    I 1,500 3,000

    10,000

    2,500

    3,750

    3,500

    7,500

    15,000

    6,000

    2,500

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    21/30

    J 100,000 100,000 100,000

    K 2,000 2,000

    L 1,000 2,000

    A 55,000 55,000 55,000

    B 120,000 120,000 120,000

    C 30,000 30,000 30,000

    D 5,000 5,000 5,000

    E 50,000 50,000 50,000F 6,000 6,000 6,000

    G 200,000 200,000 200,000

    2,656,500 2,681,200 2,649,250

    1,586,200 1,601,600 1,578,500

    604,300 613,600 604,750

    466,000 466,000 466,000

    6,500 1,180 -------------

    4,000 1,770 -------------

    3,000 ------------- -------------

    A 35,000 33,040 45,000

    B 25,000 11,800 15,000C 1,000 1,770 2,000

    D 62,496 75,501.12 133,920

    E 22,400 29,734 49,000

    F 178,560 245,817.60 200,880

    G 66,250 61,289.20 79,500

    H 12,090 13,900.40 18,600

    I 20,000 33,040 22,000

    J 4,000 6,608 5,000

    10,500 2,950 N/A

    3,000 N/A N/A

    426,796 512,502.30 570,900

    A 35,000 48,380 25,000

    B 8,000 3,540 10,000

    C 1,000 1,770 2,000

    D 4,000 1,180 2,500

    E 2,000 1,180 2,500

    A 61,100 56,846.50 65,800

    B 56,400 56,846.50 65,800

    C rate only rate only rate only

    D 34,968 50,579.50 39,480

    E 2,115 3,050.30 2,820

    F 2,585 5,546 5,640

    G 4,935 5,546 21,150A 20,000 22,650 22,000

    B 6,000 7,788 7,500

    678,399 780,353 843,090

    50,000 56,050 42,000

    162,103 178,414.82 200,690

    26,000 30,444 29,500

    A 426,796 518,452.32 570,900

    B 238,103 264,908.82 272,190

    2,500

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    22/30

    A 9440 13,924 10,195.20

    B 2,500 2,950 2,160

    C 1020 1,404.20 765

    D 1,830 1,799.50 1,317.60

    E 21,320 15,094.56 12,792

    F,G,H 26168 19,159.10 18112

    A,B,C 37800 36,957.60 -------------

    D 51,168 49,249.20 ------------- MISSING PAGEE 3,869 3,754.52 ------------- c

    F,G,H,I 72439.2 77,872.14 -------------

    J 24,264 22,673.36 -------------

    A,B,C,D 26272 35,844.86 32617.2

    E 4044 7,157.88 14,558.40

    F 4044 7,953.20 8,088

    G 1855 1,563.50 1,908

    62278 54,331.36 45,341.80

    189,540.20 190,506.82 197,559.40

    36,215 52,519.44 50,169.60

    A 87360 84,078.54 79,142.70B 36800 35,417.70 33,338.50

    C 16,060 15,584.80 15,400

    D,E,F 341254.8 366,848.91 350734.1

    G,H,I,J 92860 132,377.12 94598.4

    A 156,520 42,621.60 137,600

    B 403,040 113,492.40 366,400

    A,B,C,D 25,000 N/A N/A

    574,334.80 634,307.07 UNCLEAR DESIGNATION

    559,560 156,114 573,213.70 c

    25,000 N/A 504,000

    A 113,200 108,955 102,446

    B 2592 2,494.80 2,349

    C 117,241.20 126,034.29 120,497.90

    D 92288 125,915.44 89,980.80

    E 13,871 21,936.20 10,296

    F 12,012 17,634.76 9,895.60

    A 25920 24,946.38 23,481.90

    B 13248 12,751.20 12,006

    C 7040 6,776 6,380

    D 57988.8 62,337.96 59,599.60

    E 20541.6 22,082.22 21,112.20

    F 24192 29,339.82 20,966.40

    G 12352 16,852.76 12,043.20A 21675 12,036 24,225

    B 30515 16,944.80 34,105

    C 19890 13,540 21,675

    D 1380 1,085.60 2,760

    E 28002 19,062.90 30,515

    A 2040 1,504.50 2,550

    B 2872 2,118.10 3,590

    C 3570 5,265.75 9,690

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    23/30

    D 5026 7,413.35 13,642

    E 3560 4,200.80 4191.9

    F 300 424.80 2577.6

    G 150 212.40 1288.8

    H 150 212.40 1189.2

    I 750 708.00 706.5

    A 2520 3,221.40 1,008

    B 3780 3,221.40 4,284C 18,721 29,606.20 13,896

    D 16,212 23,800.76 13,355.60

    161,282.40 175,086.04 155,589.30

    101,462 62,669.80 113,280

    18,418 22,060.10 39,426

    41,233 59,849.76 32,543.60

    A 12,800 12,319.20 11,596

    B 2,640 2,371.60 2230.8

    C 2,240 2,155.86 2029.3

    D 21,675.20 22,074.48 21,104.80

    E 3,607.20 3,877.74 3707.4F 2,975 3,710.25 2635

    G 2,350 3,078.50 2820

    H,I,J 8986 11,395.26 8143.2

    A 2,115 2,079.75 1,551

    B,C,D 6898 7,699.50 5715.9

    E 42,500 22,418.75 13,515

    F 51,000 14,943.00 9,010

    G 4400 3,868.04 4,659.60

    H 3260 3,582.74 1,727.80

    I 8500 10,030 1,270

    A 705 270.25 1,692.00

    B,C,D 1827 1,002.24 1879.2

    E 122,200 12,390 47,000

    57,273.40 60,982.89 54,266.50

    118,673 64,621.78 48,929.30

    124,732 13,662.49 50,571.20

    A 55,330 50,511.26 44,968.20

    B 114,660 84,591.78 27,136.20

    A 72,710 66,377.62 59,093.40

    A 6960 2,737.60 5336

    B 1,820 1,321.60 1960

    C 8,050 6,277.60 9800

    D 14,400 11,479.04 17,920E 6,400 4,493.44 7840

    A 3,500 1,519.84 3,360

    B 13,800 5,947.20 12,600

    C 19,200 8,673.20 25,200

    D 6,600 2,891 16,800

    E 2,000 867.30 1764

    F 700 377.60 560

    G 1,800 991.20 1470

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    24/30

    H 3,600 1,982.40 2893

    I 700 377.60 560

    37,630 26,309.28 42,856

    51,900 23,627.14 65,207

    A 7020 2,761.20 5,382

    B 600 223.62 324

    C 6150 3,193.08 5,280.80

    D 2560 1,255.52 2,060.80E 400 177.00 313.2

    F 6720 2,360 4,051.20

    A 17,220 6,773.20 10,381.20

    B 2160 1,298 732

    C 4800 2,006 9,732

    D 18,000 16,820 23,520

    E 19,800 14,868 17,280

    A 9200 8,260 4,746

    B 1830 863 671

    C 4680 2,208.96 1,684.80

    D 2440 5,038.60 3,660A 862 1,017.16 2,586

    23,450 9,969.82 17,412

    61,980 41,465.20 61,645.20

    18,150 16,370.71 10,761.80

    862 1,017.16 2,586

    A 16,940 18,561.40 13,068.00

    B 66,482 75,431.50 55,231.20

    C 7,260 6,068.15 8,712

    D 20,456 9,818.88 36,820.80

    A 62,100 60,657.90 58,650

    111,138 109,879.93 113,832

    62,100 60,657.90 58,650

    A 10,215 10,714.40 27,240

    B 12,150 11,867.85 11,475

    C 359,000 366,431.30 305,150

    D 12,980 13,246.09 6879.4

    A 4725 3,982.50 4860

    B 875 2,065 2100

    C 1750 3,097.50 2100

    394,345 402,259.64 350,744.40

    7350 9,145 9,060

    A 14,736 10,867.80 11,052

    B 5584 8,236.40 4,606.80C 7310 12,938.70 5,263.20

    D 3680 8,684.80 3,091.20

    E 15,262 15,931.18 11,974.80

    F 5994 7,334.88 4,528.80

    G 7456 9,073.02 4,753.20

    H 3776 5,291.12 2,407.20

    I rate only rate only rate only

    A 14,736 7,073.28 13,262.40

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    25/30

    B 5,584 3,092.14 5,444.40

    C 6,579 4,100.91 6,140.40

    D 3,312 2,932.96 3,459.40

    E 4,696 2,254.08 4,226.40

    F 1,776 983.46 1,731.60

    G 2,097 1,307.13 1,957.20

    H 1,062 940.46 1,109.20

    63,798 78,357.90 47,677.2039,842 22,684.42 37,330.80

    A 720 1,298 1,920

    B 9,300 14,632 14,508

    C 2,800 4,130 5,880

    D 6,300 11,770.50 10,080

    E 1,386 1,168.20 3,960

    F 2,160 15,930 5,400

    A 2,100 2,478 3,360

    B 3,100 1,829 780

    C 400 177 600

    D 1,200 1,180 2,88022,666 48,928.70 41,748

    6,800 5,664 7,620

    A 18,000 29,500 25,000

    B 6,000 2,336.40 6,000

    C 10,800 4,460.40 7,500

    3,600,717 3,044,097 3,035,147

    A 288,033.20 297,357.62 293,030.80

    B 1,158,894.80 790,421.07 1,077,213.70

    C 351,204.20 402,970.49 335,465.30

    D 322,395.40 319,665.70 340,838.90

    E 300,678.40 139,267.16 153,764 c

    F 169,990 135,103.04 72,104.40

    G 72,710 66,377.62 59,093.40

    H 89,530 49,936.42 108,063

    I 104,442 68,822.89 92,405

    J 173,238 170,537.83 172,482

    K 401,695 411,404.64 359,804.40

    L 103,640 101,042.32 85,008

    M 29,466 54,592.70 49,368

    N 34,800 36,296.80 38,500

    A 5,000 11,800 10,000

    B 5,000 7,375 5,000

    C rate only rate only rate onlyA 78,000 38,350 62,400

    B 1,660 4,897 3,320

    C 13,000 41,300 12,000

    D 4,600 9,440 12,000

    A 30,800 15,446.20 13,860

    B 3,000 7,080 2,000

    C 2,400 2,124 3,600

    A 1,660 3,917.60 1,992

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    26/30

    B 3,000 2,360 2,400

    C 1,000 1,180 2,400

    D 9,240 2,725.80 7,700

    E 600 354 7,200

    F 8,000 11,800 30,000

    G 1,800 3,540 12,000

    10,000 19,175 15,000

    97,260 93,987 89,72036,200 24,650.20 19,460

    25,300 25,877.40 63,692

    A 6,425 7,581.50 5551.2

    B 7,710 9,097.80 6476.4

    C 7,210 8,507.80 6180

    D 10,620 10,443 5097.6

    E 12,500 14,750 13,500

    F 3,420 2,421.36 2,052

    A 2,565 2,315.34 2188.8

    B 16,416 15,798.69 14,877

    C 16,640 16,016 15,080D 17,809.20 20,271.06 19,380.60

    E 30,974 35,255.70 33,707

    F 1,344 1,467.20 1052.8

    G 13,312 20,616.96 12,979.80

    A 22,400 9,912 26,880

    B 1,120 2,312.80 672

    C 2,240 4,956 3360

    47,885 52,801.46 38,857.20

    99,060.20 111,740.95 99,265.40

    25,760 17,180.80 30,912

    A 120,510 82,039.50 100,116

    B 59,840 40,120 29,376

    C 23,700 4,661 3318

    D 5,200 920.40 1248

    E 5,140 3,032.60 3084

    A 8040 1,976.50 3886

    B 90 26.55 19.8

    C 120 236.00 240

    D 120 354.00 288

    E 120 354.00 360

    F 120 354.00 480

    G 790 1,398.30 711

    H 600 1,654 1200I 13,200 6,490 7260

    214,390 130,773.50 137,142

    23,200 12,841.35 14,444.80

    A 22,400 26,432 36960

    B 2820 3,882.20 11,280

    C 3,000 3,835 3900

    A 12,600 15,900.50 12,600

    B 12,000 12,626 12,000

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    27/30

    C 3,000 3,156.50 4,800

    A 350 354 720

    B 34,200 31,388 36,480

    C 26,600 21,299 28,500

    A 168,760 163,689.60 187,872

    B 172,705.20 181,723.21 169,034.60

    C 237,590 143,614.85 151,586.80

    D 28,220 34,149.20 52,140E 27,600 31,683 29,400

    F 61,150 53,041 65,700

    696,025 607,903 655,734

    211,900 568,642 283,500

    2,656,500 2,681,200 2,649,250

    664,899 780,361.14 843,090

    3,600,717 3,043,796.30 3,237,243.90

    696,025.20 607,900.86 655,733.40

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    28/30

    t applicable

    port

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    29/30

    A B C A B

    Preliminaries 211,900 568,642 283,500 211,900 562,742

    Prime costs and provisional sums 2,656,500 2,681,200 2,649,250 2,656,500 2,681,200

    Piling works 664,899 780,361.14 843,090 678,399 780,353

    Building works 3,600,717 3,043,796.30 3,237,243.90 3,600,717 3,044,097External works 696,025.20 607,900.86 655,733.40 696,025 607,903

    Total 7,830,041 7,681,900 7,668,817 7,843,541 7,676,295

    CalculatedGiven data

  • 7/29/2019 Contractor Evaluation ABC

    30/30

    Difference

    C A B C

    263,500 0 5,900 20,000 Error in contractor reports

    2,649,250 0 0 0

    843,090 13,500 8 0

    3,035,147 0 301 202,097 Error in my calculation655,734 0.00 2.00 0.60

    7,446,721 13,500 6,211 222,098