content analysis of women’s magazines · content analysis of women’s magazines pre-test of a...

8
臌臕膻腡膤膜腽腃腺 腄臌膵臤臙膨腐膴膻腄 Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite magazines Shigeyoshi ISOBE 臱腂腡臍致臙膕臏腡臏膦腝腋腍腣腀 臫膋腀 臓腀 臥臓腀 臫腀 膑臭腀 臛腭膯腧腷膂腵腀 膴膻腀 臑 臻腀 TV腀 腟腞腎臒膠腜腊腮腁 膝臻腠腟腮腎 +* 至臩臞腠臷臁腎膿膹腓腗臨膱腠腫腯腣 腆臀膐膓膤膜 膤膜++ 臅腇腀 腑腯腬腡腌腘腀 臍致膫臮腠臵臎腠膞腋膌膟腎腊腮臏膦腝腓腛 腈膴膻腡膚 膼腪膩膮腉 腎臝腣腯腛腋腮膼腎臵臎腠臣腋腁 腍腣膇臙膕腠腚腋腛腧腮腝腀 臱臎臙膕腜腕腏腠腃腊 腚臏腆臢膾臄膡臏腇 腜腢 腈臫臭腪膑臭腜膥腛腉 腎膲腩膌膟腎腊腭腀 腈腒腓腊腗腭腢臶腟腋 腎腀 腡腘腡腘腃腊腚臏腆臦膍臄膡臏腇腉 腈膿腱臈膺腓腗臘膒腟臏腆膿臕臠膛膡臏腇腉 腈膙 臗腬腓腪膎腚腦腓腠腟腮膔腓腋臏腆膖臕臠膛膡臏腇腉 腡膈腜腢腋腖腯腩 腈膴膻腡膚膼腪膩膮腉 腎膅臬自腠膌膟腡腊腮膁腹腳腲腜腊腮腁 臐臙膕腜腢腀 臢膾臄膡臏腠膲腩膞腋膁腹腳腲腢腷膂 腵腜腊腮腎腀 臦膍臄膡臏腀膿臕臠膛膡臏腀 膖臕臠膛膡臏腜腢膴膻腎膲腩膞腋腁 臆臙膕腜 腧腮腝臟腛腡臏腀腋膈腜膴膻腎膌膟腡膃腃腶腃腜腊腮腁 腑腡腫腌腠膴膻腢臙膕臏膦腝腓腛腀 臣 腟臏腀腋膈腜膅臬自腠膸膽腒腯腀 臓腂腡臙膕腠膌膟腱腍腛腋腮腝腋腌膣膏腱腍腛腋腮腁 膰臱腀 臋臫腡膴膻腴腃腻腃腪腴膄腾腼腡膴膻腡腠腢臣腟膴膻腎腊腥腯腀 臎腠臣臔腡臌臕腎膷 腋膷腋腡膴膻腱臃腠腝腭腀 腘臯腧腱腓腀 膆腋腢膬臲腓腛腋腮腁 臜腡臨膱膣膏腝腋腋腀 臫臭腡膗膳 腝腋腋腀 膴膻腎臙膕臏膦腝腓腛臧腒腯腮腝腑腰腜腊腮腁 膪腢 腈臂臸腡腉 腱腢腔腨腝腓腛腀 臡膭膴膻腠臺腒腯腛腋腮腩腡腡腌腘 -/ 膻腠腚腋腛 腈膴膻膚膼腡臺膘臉 腆臼膢腇腉 腠臇腙腛膿膹 腓腗臰臺臚腡膊臹腜腊腮腁 膤膜腡自腢 - 腚腊腮腁 腤腝腚腢腀 膧臼膴膻腎腞腡腸腃膀腠腚腋腛 臌臕膻腡膤膜腽腃腺腄臌膵臤臙膨腐膴膻腄腅膉臹臖膶 123

Upload: others

Post on 17-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

����������� ����

Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines

Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content

Analysis of women students’ favorite magazines

� � � �Shigeyoshi ISOBE

� � � �

����� ������ !"#$ %&$ �'$ ('$ %$ )*$ +,-./01$ ��$ 2

3$ TV$ 456789:;< =3�4;6 +*>?@�AB6CDEFGH�IJ# KLMN��

O����P ++QR$ SJT�UV$ ��WX�YZ�[!\]�6:;��� E^ _���`

abcPd 6e#J^!;a6YZ�f!< �"#g ��h!^.; $ �Z �9ij���

h�� Kkl�mn��R 9� _%*b)*9o^d 6pq\]�6:,$ _rE:F,�s�4!

6$ �V�V��h�� Ktu�mn��Rd _C�vwxEFyz4�� KC��{|n��Rd _}

~TEb�h�E�4;�E!�� K��{|n��Rd ��9�!�Jq _���`abcPd

6����\]��:;����9:;< � �9�$ kl�mn���pq[!�����/0

19:;6$ tu�mn��$ C��{|n��$ ��{|n��9���6pq[!< � �9

.; �^����9��6\]������9:;< S�IU���� ���� E^$ f

4���9������rJ$ '�� ��\]v�"^!; !U��v"^!;<

��$ �%�������b�����������f4��6:�J$ Z�f����6�

!�!���v�� ,$ �V .vE$ ¡!�¢£E^!;< ¤�GH�� !!$ %*�¥¦

!!$ ��6 ���� E^§�rJ; S¨9:;< ©� _ª«��d v��� E^$

¬­���®�rJ^!;q��UV -/��h!^ _��`a�®�¯° K±²Rd �³´^CD

EFµ�®¶�·�9:;< ������ -h:;< ¸ h�$ ¹±��65�º�»�h!^

����������� ����¼����

123

Page 2: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

������ ��������� �������������� ������������

������������ !���"�� #$��%�&�'()�� ���*+��

�����, *��� - �.�/0�102� 3+31*�4 ���� ���5�6�!��

789:;2���<� =>?@�AB������C�D��� EJJF ECanCamF EwithF

EMOREF � .������ G��72�>? 3+332� +*HI4 ����JKL��-

JJ

JJ�@�@�M�N�O��7���P� E� Q! 3+3/2��74F �"R�<�SH7�

+31/� .H� TUV9:W0�X;YZ[ ,�#�\ ]Y^_8X/�` �<��7(��-

$� E"R� Q!F ����%��P�a� G�&'(�P� E� Q!F �bc:d^�

� EJJF ������e�� +311� -H�,H7�eP�-

()'�*f +g�� � E,-�.��/$�,*���� E� Q!F �O��h<�

"�i 0\*�J���-F �jP�� - EJJF �� k� E/��1�2lmn3��

� 4���5a67F �<�� - G<�� E� Q!F ��"��%oYp9q�<� A.8

r9�� �sYt�_8X/:uvP�- <�<� �7/$��7��;�@��� w8YsY

t�<eC� 1*�a=>x���P�- ?@� -�� +y�a/2�;z�UV9:W0�A-�

{\ "|�BDP�� - }CD)c;Yq8~�9���E��b�� }$��X;Z[YF'

CD)� e����obq^G�a(��� - }67�e$@�P���+�� ��� HI�{

\ "|@�P�� - >?� JJ���� �9�ba /���(����� }-�J��^�0� �

�����e@�@� - ��K�<��sYtaLM�� - 3+31/� 0HI4

G<���<� }JJ�Y^� e �ND���0<�- }JJ�Y^� �� JJ��%O�P\

+2��, ,,�C,������� �\�N�� - EJJF ��0_UV9:W0�C�e��

Q�c;Yq8�R��S���- c;Yq8��c;Y�q8�[:W�^�Tj�� *

�D��UV9:W0a��UV����W�5�<�X,�e�UV9:W0��P���2

<� �:�����Y�UV9:W0Z <�� - G�Y�¡[��,���a E¢£q8F

�� a EJJF �*�,�UV9:W0\C�,¤a�� ��� ���@LMe¥80�R

�<��P�-

�%a]<aP�� @�����%�^X<ea,�� ��\C¦��§ - ���'�

@ E�%_�1����()\ F ���¨`�©()���� - Uª«~�B¬� a­C

B� b®CB� PcCBe���AB�a¯�^�<���<� �°�¯�^�d�efe±²��

�³�´d0µ~�;z<�� @�R�<�� - M�N��� �@g a()\ ���

:~Z¶ EJJF �@h:<� G�#$� g·��� ¸P��@�¹� -

>?� EJJF �,-����- +332� +*HI�ºP��i<�� - ]Y^w8Y� -2.sYt-

jkCBN»BW¼l m .*--I ( ,**,�n )

124

Page 3: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

������� +3/�� �� +23�� ��� ��������������� 0����

��� ���������� �! ��� "#��������$ %&��'()*+, -

.�/��01234��5��-.���6��7�� ��8�������������

9:;�<=>��� 6-?����9�@ �A9���B��� ��CDE����

6-?���$ %F�GH3IJ, %1G4KJ, %LGMNJ, %O�#PJ, -.���QR�

DST��+��9�U�U-V(�G �5W��� XJJY ��>�;Z��� ��� ��

�B ��� ���[\]^G_�8���>`�ab-��c=A8E���=��d�`

� _eP]^G_��SZ�f�]^G_��g-h3i���9�j���� dck 123

4)Pl9��� !"m��#n��� %NATURAL BEUTY BASIC, %INED, %MK, 0ob

- %NICECLAP, -.���� $%��?�$ pqpqrstu*���$-=Ep� e'I

�v*u*������ ��� �wZ�6�&��+9x'?p���-E���� ?=? 6

6 � %y/**z{ (d�1#G4�, �('lK�)C;Z*+,|��:��=�d��

qp XJJY $�}�~-����?� %��� OG� LOVE,^'�, ���=��� JJ��

-*.�!/����0������9�5W�/������ qp %!"0��12, ��

����/:Z���� 34�056#9�7?���9��)C�u�P$��z{ �?U

��87�99�>� � 3������: ;qZ���� /������� ���L^�

0��K_"��l "Pl^G�5�� ��� <=-.��R>�->�>��?�����

@��A�0BC��$D>-��

`�a����d��EF�$G�-('4���312G98E��A 6�H� $��>

I�J����d7�� JJKL�$M���������SZ�� %�����, -.���9

��� �N:�('4��R��-��312G�(Fh�?��O����

MORE

+311P / � ,*.�!/9QO�?pI¡)�t�¢G9�p�R£�:¤S�T¥� A.

U¦V�¡�Kh^§*�W ,.,���

7AXY- 7A$?� 7AZ=-��99[?���!/\ �qA ¨�]��;SZw

^�^_�?E=A?p�}�9LE���!/9(�©3l�?p� ���

T¥��pE����`a$99�b�����Ep� cd ^¡ �"§ ªe����=

«fg0hggi� POPq ��jk9lm¬?p`0­#G��G9n®?p� :;�$ M

Gl)��=¯'L���('*34��q °AoZp� XMOREY �fA>�`��*e)�

�!/�? XLP±�)(GY ��p²��Ep� �?��c����5 T¥³ $ %Talking

with your lover, %How to survive the loss of a love, 9qr?���� [\�st9uv�´7

? fFY-wx9yz�{�|?���������d�� �=� %!/��}�, �Y9µE

!/?�¶·¸�l¹!"0�ºC�?¹»¼}~�

125

Page 4: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

��������� �� ����� ; ���������� ����������� !�

"��#� ��������#���!$%��&'�(') *+���, �-� './ ��

0123��4�56��� !�768�� 93:�;�<�4=%8/ �>?@A�� �

BC���D�E���FG�<����

H�� *MORE, (I!�%8���- +332� +*JK4"�8��'��!�L8LMN�

O���( ./*�� 1/��P��Q����&� <�� ,/2O��/ RS� +3,O���T��

4(�U��&� <�B�V�WX���(Y�Z� -�� +!�[/ !� ,,./��"\ ]

^E���/ �_#/ $`FG� +a%b�&�Z( /�'(0)'�'�:�c�c'�*�+

,�-.d38�� Y�ZF/�<��(/ 012/ 345e/ 29'6/ �f�V��6��

U�4ghd38�� ij7�k123l�m(9N8n93� 0�N<��(/ �f�V�

�>?@A�!oN0:;4ij7��V��4Xpqr�'.<s��t=�&� � u�-

:v:3�w��xX��o�()'� >K�(�y�yBz�>{���|}�C��?n@

~:38���A����(BC���4�D�_�N'/ EF����&��n/ �G�!H%

����I#2�8�� !<��(���� ���J!\����90X&n/ K����

����[:38��L4/ M�NOC?��PQD�<�X&�� �R-:SX�?mCT�

'.�EF�� |�?�U�<����

$`FG�<�!B�0 V�W0X.N'�8����-*�YZ[� !\�068V�`�<

���� BC�]�� �����!X04^_��`a$��x� �r��� ��&�

�_#�( �[�r�( *�CP, '�� 4bcd3�MN4/ �E�u!d468����

_#!e�68��

<��� �(fJ<�� 0a!�[8���/ �������-]���g<�X�\BC

h=��5i�O��L:3� �3(����4Xv:3� -*��<��^_�!�j68�

����: kl�BCW¡C�mn6op�!¢[8�� BCO��X�\£ /hqo ¤¥r

st u¦�§¨v�© '.�BLw�x����i�y�kª��� z{�4L8/ �X68|

4�_�P�«Q5i0� ��� ��75i�}~!�"5i0�%MN

with

*with, (�¬��­w�®�y/ +32+� 2J4 Culture Magazine for Your Life� �¯�?

m�E�°�X0±g�-:�­d3� �­K ¤+32+� +*JK© ( ,22O��� /**² zW�

-�� +� ,O�n�&�� �­K4(��MN'�?}����%:38�� *&'�4(

��8�y3�³\8�:-�-:´�&nyr ��8�y3��6d/ ��ud�&nyr

�N�rµ�-\�4�y38_��´X�/��r¶8!W¡686ykN ·&nyµ�-

.��!¸��-(&'�����r +"0�¹º -"&�8X ."¸�8X����r �"

���»�¼»x¨� � .*--K ( ,**,�� )

126

Page 5: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

��� ����������� ��������� ��������������� �

�!��"��#

��$�%&' �(�� )������* +,��)���-��� ./0��1# 2�

3���4 .���*��54 ��� .6�&�$784 +������� �9�:� �� �� �

;��� <�=<� >���?�!�-"#!1@���� .$A%&BCD'=D'4 ���

EFDGH�,')����I�JKL ����

MN"�(����)*�O�� .YELLOW PAGE4 �+,�������� P-./- .Q

�RGS�T�0U�VDW�Q4 �!�� 1�+,��O�� XY' Z[�JK!����

+\��XY'�2;�]^�@�

MN� /with# _+3323 +*`ab �4O�� .+0� 5 2c-�7�Q7de��� )�- ,-,

O��� fg- +2.O��� O��6�h��78���� i�j- .,��k��l� (��9

_+3�b� !m,n _+-�b� �* _+*�b �(l� /MORE# �8:!o;p-� 2 q<+�

=�h��>^r�-s� ��

i�j��?�� @��!-AB�C7t Du� v^ EF@�GH�w-��I+xyJK

�Lu� ���� .Mz��N-O"��� &{�|4 .}3�B�|�@��!4 .~� -P }

3�!l@�4 ���$A)��� .Q@���!���R�DV4 .ST�B�|Y�|�U�

�@��! 4 ���ST�� r@��"�=���� ��VW{7���XYr@��

�� !�!� �Z�[�\����� EF��j+j]�^���-���

9��� �e�e� ����e� �_-xy`Kr� ���- .��abc4 .dPSD&�

�+�-�e(4 �����+�@����

!m,n�)��� .�-* �+� �f�{Y+�@�!"�f4 ��f3,n-�Z��@

���� �,n�gh��^�� ���� �* ��� .]!� �����d���4 �!�

iG+,���I�I���� i�!���� 2�x� .]j���4 �h!�� �+!��

�=��k� l���'K��� }\�E7��$��� �¡��@�

.i�m�n�o�!�¢$£e¤��e���)*��I�I�¥p�qp+rs¦-t[�u

]\�)�-v���� w[§� ���* ���~�\������ ]!� @�¨ �x�

! � "�m©�yz {� m|ª}�~�QDT���l����

AB\+u])�-�l� )*+)«>������[�� �¡¬Q�����-� ��)«

p(��l� ­� : YV7D&!�yz!�]l®���)���l� ¯�-)«> ��

Can Cam

+32+3 ++`+ .Come on Join us4 ���W�D�EC�T�°� �±²���³L � ´�

�Q7dµ� L���3���3¶+� /���SD����������# �l�L ����

���·¸��'¹/��º(��¹»¼�;�

127

Page 6: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

������ +2��,,��

���� ���������� �SELF� ������� ���������� !�

��"�#$%&��� '() �� ����*+(, �-./0�1� ��2�3�4�� �

��53���34��#+&��� �67��89���:�;4 2, <=53��9�>"?

"@(�A��B (C� !�D�8E/���"���1") F�GHIJ�K) �L/M�)

8.�4 !�NOP5/Q�R@&��� 67��SQ6� !��T��U�&,�� ��V

P4W� ��X�X� Y�"Z�+&��� �D�8E/���B�"�[�"�,) ���\%

]��^�_(@&��� �JJ"`3a5� ������1�+(I) Can Cam��b�c�

������� ��2�" !HIB@(") !F� ,"#"�,�

�$" ,/%&�B@( CanCamUd'�� 0/%&��e,()+(� f�4�5� -3,

g�>� ��" ,+2g�>) ?h" +1.g�>�?h�ij3�"��&*�+�� ,-" ,g�

>�_(@&�&) .T��/���,0(k�S3�i��B�� 9�;1��l�*mn" 0

o�23�,) �D�8E/��B�F�"p,43�B�� -"5�� +1�) 6qmn) 7I+

�89�r /��:,� ���;"st&���Bu2�D�8E/�5��89�<� 2o�

=t�>�v]�B�� S>.���� �CanCam Culture Site� �+&) wxyz{) ?��#

" $%&���[�B�� ?��1@AB�+& ��e"��y]"��|}X�~C� &�

���� -*� "A�&��") D��F�E�1@"FG���?h���+&}�&��F�"

�,) ?���H�mn��, �� l�*����I /*��JF +"=t&��") KLJ)

MN��) 5/>L��UR@&�&��<&�O���V�+&��� R@&������e'

]��5�) J�K) ���/ !�NOPQP5/QHI ��,&H_��6��� !��3

�4"AXI%(�� ��'��E�R�B�� �<S�T$��U�� ��) NOPQP5/Q

V���U�"�W$%&��") NOP5/QX�yNO8E��/JX��He(&��Y"

Z[�)��\� ��X�X���"�'I+�� +*���2F�UB@& �]���D�8E

/� �a� �32]��34� �^_�]���� !�_��`+(.T��"�a�B��

���b�ca"d/���) .T��3�4�eH%(�3�����" ,o) B�f� ¡

¢3 �>-.5a��£ �3/�¤7�����gh¥�i¦�B��

�g",�|&{+§��¨J���) ©@,]�§g�>��&Uj �� �D�8E/�5

��hª��R@&�����kLHI[&«l¬�j �") .T�m�­®(]) j¯�D�

8E/�n]­®&�&°e��"�@e]+\2 ���B�� �o��p�q�±���²�

³2� ��

�MORE� : 53���34r´µ� �D�8E/��sVR�� ¶·AX�tu¸�vw±

�� �3�����"x¹yj �� 9�;��R�B��

�JJ� : ��¨J���Mz��3�1�.T��]+%(�D�8E/��#+&��(

tº�M������"��� ¶·AX��g�M4�»w+&��F�HI{Q

|}�¼~A¼& � � .*-- ( ,**,�� )

128

Page 7: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

�������� ���������������

�with : ��������� ���������� ������ !"� �#��

���������$ ���

�Can Cam : �%&'()*�+,-.� /�)0!"� ��1&234���� �����

5���������

����6

�)78�9)2�:-.����;<=>?�@��AB�:C?� 9)2��<D�A>

EFG�:C?�H I���<JK?LMAN>�A@��OP?<���� QRQH �ST�

UVW�RXQY���ZE��ARH [�R� !:;>?4A�?� \]��^_@`ab

"cd-.L�efXEg#h:iC�jJA�EFL�ek$:H /.%�`ab"Al&m�;

<MnYog� 'p A(q)*�@���H r+�sc�@�o�?tL�u,g�

`ab"@v-w -x�-.<y�QY�?� +z,xy.�� /.%/ -*%:{i��r H 3

z+*xL0Kg ,%@r%1XQ:|}~QA}�}�2nYQ�eL�etL:Cng�y�L

�ef+ �3�:i -xL�etL@H 4��o���Q�o<�KEFH 5���-.<`a

b"@��:�?A�����

+� Ay.QY�?-.@ �JJ � +-%:{i�qH MORE �++��H with �2��H CanCam

�2��H nonno �2��H anan �1��H spring �/�� L6q� ��A.��.7i�3��L��8

�:C?�H �9����) LR �AERA ����4�.�:�.� ����&� ����

.,.��7�EY�Y�R�E?� y.;<@���� �,*%� L|}~Q �+,%� :C?�

I����=>@H 9�? �.+��H ?t�Q �--�� �1 1��1���� �-*��H ¡¢!

�,*�� @��A;�� �+3��H £¤ �¥�¦§��� �+2��H BC-¨ �+.�� �©ªng��

�:C?�

\]=>DE<«og ..A}�YH ¬FAG­<&eLR���5®�C?tL�DR?� H

KFH CanCamH JJH MOREH with� ..�8�I�<J�ªK¯H ��-.<y.>?RLl&

>?LH CanCam �-�� JJ �+-��H MORE �+1��H with �+3�� L�e0K�LnY,g� °E

MQ�:�?RXL�e;<����ª�MORE : with<±²Qg%@H Nh��O�H ³P

L�e;<���� JJ:@)*5��´��

�with L �MORE �+�y��<QKY±²�E?r H �CanCam �)*��R�@�e

QgtL:CµeR�

�with �MORE @�$ �q�`ab"A¶d.EXEY�?� IE@SM<T�>·ZH U

`�.�ST¸� ¹`a�"cd-.¹º»VW¼

129

Page 8: Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines · Content Analysis of Women’s Magazines Pre-test of a system to classify (invisible) Mass by content Analysis of women students’ favorite

���������� ���������� �JJ� �CanCam� �����������

!�� "��#$���%��&�'(�)����*�+,�� �JJ� �-./0�#$�1

� 2*2�������34���5 2*��672*89:�;���� <= �JJ� 89

:�>)?@A#$� �with� �1� �with� �BC�D�135 E9FGHI�)����

75 �JJ� 9:�(��9J����-��� <��)K9FGHI= �MORE� ��<�LM�

NOPQ�RS��� TUVW�with�MORE�9J���5 JJ�CanCam�9J���X

Y���Z0��<*�1� with�MORE[5 JJ�CanCam[\]��^�;'���=�

MORE��,<*�1�

_`35 TUZW�Z`�� 14abc�de���

fg5 hi�jk�lmHn�1�5 >op��4q=rs�t,�*�Auv�#$=w

x4y�9:z{����bc�1R�|!�5 }M~��������'��,<*�1�

��ZV��V��� � .*--� ( ,**,�� )

130