contaminants in san francisco bay sport fish · 2016-10-14 · contaminants in san francisco bay...

25
Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary Institute Vince Palace, University of Manitoba Robin Stewart, USGS Menlo Park Monitoring to Protect Human Health and Inform Regulatory Action

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish

Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary InstituteVince Palace, University of Manitoba

Robin Stewart, USGS Menlo Park

Monitoring to Protect Human Health and Inform Regulatory Action

Page 2: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Protect Public Health Inform ManagementStatus and Trends

Page 3: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Status &Trends

HgPCBsDioxinsPBDEsPFOSSe

Page 4: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Mercury

Page 5: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Mercury Exceeds Thresholds

Page 6: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Mercury in Striped Bass – no long-term trend

Page 7: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PCBs

Page 8: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PCBs Exceed Thresholds

Page 9: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PCBs may be declining in shiner surfperch

Page 10: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PBDEs

Page 11: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PBDEs continue to decline

Page 12: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PBDEs are elevated in wastewater-influenced fish

Page 13: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

PFCs are elevated in wastewater-influenced fish

Page 14: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Selenium

Page 15: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Selenium is elevated in Suisun Bay sturgeon

Page 16: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Selenium in sturgeon – no long-term trend

Page 17: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Muscle Plugs

• 5 mm diameter biopsyplug

• 2-3 plugs per fish

• Non-lethal samplingmethod

• Monitor attainment of regulatory thresholds

Page 18: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Muscle plugs & fillets are well correlated

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
PRELIMINARY DATA DO NOT CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION
Page 19: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Muscle Plug Study

Sturgeon Derby Study

Test muscle plug monitoring in the field

Link Se in muscle plugs and ovaries (non-lethally collected vs. toxicity endpoint)

Page 20: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Mean

Selenium in White Sturgeon Muscle Plugs

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
PRELIMINARY DATA DO NOT CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION
Page 21: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Muscle Plug and Ovary Selenium is Correlated

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
JenniferS
Typewritten Text
JenniferS
Typewritten Text
JenniferS
Typewritten Text
JenniferS
Typewritten Text
PRELIMINARY DATA DO NOT CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION
JenniferS
Typewritten Text
Page 22: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Sturgeon Fin RaysSelenium trend

0

0.5

1

1.5

2000 2005 2010 2015

Sele

niu

m (

pp

m)

Year

20

15

20

10

20

06

20

02

19

99

Vince Palace, University of Manitoba

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
PRELIMINARY DATA DO NOT CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION
Page 23: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Sturgeon OtolithsSelenium trend

Vince Palace, University of Manitoba

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
PRELIMINARY DATA DO NOT CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION
Page 24: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

What’s Next?• Continue developing non-lethal monitoring tools (2017)

• Develop long-term Se monitoring plan (2017 strategy)

• Continue evaluating temporal trends (2019 S&T)

• Draft Sport Fish, Muscle Plug and Derby reports coming Fall 2016

Page 25: Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish · 2016-10-14 · Contaminants in San Francisco Bay Sport Fish Jennifer Sun, Jay Davis, San Francisco Estuary ... Selenium in White Sturgeon

Questions?

JenniferS
Typewritten Text
JenniferS
Typewritten Text