consultancy paper

Upload: john-mark-esguerra

Post on 06-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    1/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    BUDGET AND OPERATING PROCEDURES OF BARANGAY 66

    ZONE 8 PASAY CITY, METRO MANILA

    A Consultancy Paper

    Presented to

    The College of Business Administration

    Adamson University

    Manila

    In Partial Fulfillment

    of the Requirements for the Degree

    BACHELOR OF SCINCE IN ACCOUNTANCY

    Submitted by:

    Caron, Joan Bernadette C.

    Condol, Marcel Jan M.

    Esguerra, John Mark F.

    Noceda, Jennica Eloise F.

    Rodulfa, Maricris R.

    MARCH 2011

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    2/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    INTRODUCTION

    B ara ng ay is the smalle st u nit of loc al go ve rnmen t in th e

    Phil ippines. Each city or municipali ty contains numerous barangays and

    each barangay is adminis tered by a Barangay Captain and a communi ty

    counci l whose members are elected by the res idents of the barangay. I t

    serves as the pr imary planning and implement ing unit of government

    policies, plans, programs, projects , and activit ies in the community, and

    as a forum where in col l ec t ive v iews of the people may be expressed ,

    crystallized, and considered, and where disputes may be amicably settled.

    (Sec 384) Barangays are composed of a Punong Barangay or Barangay

    Captain, seven (7) Barangay Counci lors or Barangay Kagawad, a n d a

    Y ou th C ou nc il o r Sangguniang Kabataan (SK) Chairman which is

    considered as a member of the Council.

    A barangay is given an annual budget by the national government.

    As ide f rom being a f inancial p lan , the barangay budget serves as an

    instrument for barangay officials to effectively manage the development

    of the barangay. A wel l-prepared barangay budget serves as bas is for

    p lanning and policy adaption , program and projec t implementa tion,

    financial control and management information. A barangay budget consist

    o f e st imat es o f i ncome and t ot al appropr ia ti ons cover ing cur rent

    expendi tures and capi ta l outl ays. In implementing or executing the

    barangay budget , barangay off icials shall ensure that the revenues as

    es t imated are real ized, that the approved programs and projects in the

    barangay development plan and in the annual budget are implemented,

    that barangay funds are disbursed in accordance wi th the appropr iat ion

    ordinance and reviewed annual budget, that al l f inancial transactions of

    the barangay follow accounting and audit ing rules. Barangay records and

    repor ts of budgetary t ransact ions must be prepared and kept to provide

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barangay_Kagawadhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sangguniang_Kabataanhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barangay_Kagawadhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sangguniang_Kabataan
  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    3/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    information on the status of project implementation and serve as basis for

    the necessary correct ive act ion for ident i f ied deviat ions , to ensure that

    obligations are incurred within the l imits of the approved appropriat ions,to r ecord unpaid obliga tions , both current and those cert if ied to as

    accounts payable at the end of the year, to make transactions transparent

    and the f inancial s tatus of the barangay a matter of public knowledge, to

    serve as basic input into the next budget preparat ion . The barangay

    officials must report to the general public the income actually realized for

    the quarter, expenditures actually spent for the quarter and

    accomplishments for the quarter.

    In connection to this , a s tudy was conducted regarding the f low of

    operat ions in a barangay. The barangay that we vis i ted to conduct our

    study was Barangay 66 Zone 8 Pasay, City Metro Manila si tuated within

    the hear t of Pasay Ci ty , whose boundar ies were Nor th Lakandula, Eas t

    Dolores , West Tramo Lane South Arnaiz Avenue. The said communi ty

    was headed by Barangay Captain Eduardo Balanova.

    Residential , commercial and industr ial establishments are erected

    within the area, having a total land area of 0.0281 square ki lometres .

    Most of the people l iving in Zone 8 are employees and do have sari-sari

    store as their major source of livelihood.

    Like any organizat ion, ent i ty or local government uni t , funds are

    indispensable to the barangay for payment of its operational expenses and

    to successfully perform its powers, functions and duties vested upon by

    law. The said barangay has a total al lot ted annual budget for 2011 of P2,

    142,317.91 to be allocated to theirs programs and projects. Disbursements

    of funds are made in compliance with the exist ing rules and regulations

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    4/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    and the Barangay Chairman is held primarily responsible for its execution

    of and accountability.

    This study of the operations of a barangay aims to provide a better

    unders tanding to the communi ty of the sa id barangay regarding the

    uti l ization of f inancial resources of their barangay. This study will also

    give them awareness and eventually help their barangay in i ts functions

    and operations.

    In this study, the researchers gained knowledge of how a barangay,

    the smal les t uni t of the local government , conduct i t s operat ions and

    handle their financial resources efficiently for the whole year in a manner

    that will benefit the whole community.

    The future researchers can also make use of this study as a basis or

    reference for further investigation and analysis of the subject or situation.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    5/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    DESCRIPTION OF THE PROCESS

    THE BUDGET CYCLE

    The Punong Barangay, w ith the ass is tance of the

    Barangay treasurer, prepares the barangay budget.

    A Barangay budget consist of the following:

    o Estimates of income; and,

    o Total appropriations covering current operating

    expenditures and capital outlays.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    6/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    The Barangay Treasure is responsible for determining

    the estimated income to be used as a source of fund in

    the budget.

    The Barangay Treasurer should submit to the Punong

    Barangay on or before September 15 of each year the

    detai led Statements of Income and Expenditures as a

    basis for the preparat ion of the Budget for the next

    fiscal year.

    Flowchart of the Barangay Budget Process

    Est imated sav ings at the end of the current year

    forms paart of the Beginning balance for the budget

    year.

    It includes projected balances of any appropriation

    which remain freeof any obligation or encumbrances

    and which are still available at the end of the current

    year a fter the satisfactory completion, or the

    unavailable of the discontinuance or abandonment of

    the work, activi ty or purpose for which the funds

    where authorized.

    The barangay annual budget must inc lude the

    following:

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    7/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    o Appropriation for development projects of not

    less than 20% of the total IRA of the barangay

    for the budget year (Development Fund);

    o Appropriation for Sangguniang Kabataan (SK)

    programs, projects and activities equivalent to

    10% of the general fund of the barangay for the

    budget year (SK Fund);

    o Appropr iations for unforeseen expendi tures

    arising from the occurrence of calamities at 5%

    of regular incomefor the budget year; and

    o Provision for the del ivery of basic services

    pursuant to Section !& of RA No.7160, and

    effective local governance.

    I. Disbursement By Check

    a.All disbursement shall coverd with duly processed and

    approved DVs/payroll;

    b.The DVs/Payroll shall be prepared by the BRK;

    c.The BT shall be responsible for paying claims againstthe barangay. All disbursements shall be in accordance

    with existing rukes and regulations;

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    8/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    d.All claims shall be approved by the PB and certified as

    to the validity, propriety and legality of the claim. In

    case of claimchargeable against SangguniangKabataan Funds (SKF), The Chairman Sangguniang

    Kabataan (SK) shall initial under the name of the PB;

    e.Payment shall be drawn against the depository account

    maintained with depository bank by the barangay.

    f. The check shall be issued in the name of the payee as

    indicated in the DV/payroll.

    g.The chekh shall be signed by the BT and countersigned

    by the PB;

    h.A ll d isbursement by check shall be reported in the

    summary of Checks Issued (SCKI); and

    i. In case checks are waylaid, lost through theft or force

    majeure, etc. the BT shall immediately notify and issue

    a Stoppage of Payment notice to the banks; and

    j . Stale check shall be replaced only when the original is

    submitted to the BT for replacement.

    II. Disbursement out of Cash Advance for Payroll

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    9/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    a. Cah payment shall be made out of the cah

    advance given to the BT/AO;

    b. The cash advance sha ll be used so le ly for payment

    of salaries, honoraria, and other allowances due to the

    barangay officials and employees;

    c. The cash advance shall not be used for the

    encashment of checks or for liquidation of previous cashadvance;

    d. The cash advance shall be equal to the net

    amount of the payroll corresponding to the pay period;

    e . The cash sha ll be liqu iodated wi th in 5 days af te rthe end of the pay period.

    f . Any uncla imed Honoraria/sa laries/allowances sha ll

    be refunded to close the account;

    g. All paid DVs/Payrolls shall be recorede in the

    Summary of Cash Payments (SCP);

    h. The SCP supported by paid DVs/Payroll shall be

    accompl ished to support the l iquidation of the cash

    advance for payrol l . In case the cash advance is more

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    10/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    than the disbursement, the excess shal l be refunded

    and an OR shall be issued.

    i. Succeeding cash advance shall be granted only

    after full liquidation of the previous cash advance.

    III. Disbursements out of Cash Advance for Travel and

    Special Purpose/Time-bound Undertaking

    a.For local/foreign travel, liquidation shall be done withina period of 30/60 days upon return to the personnels

    workstation;

    b. Cash advance for special purpose/time-bound

    undertaking shall be liquidated upon accomplishment

    of the purpose for which it was granted;

    c . Excess cash advance shall be re funded and an OR

    shall be issued by the BT;

    d. The liquidation report with appropriate

    supporting documents shall be submitted to the BRK,

    who in turn sha ll submi t it to the C ity/Municipa l

    Accountant for recording in the books on or before the

    fifth day of the following month.

    IV. Disbursement out of the Petty Cash Fund

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    11/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    a) The Petty Cash Fund (PCF) shall be maintained using

    the Imprest system. The balance of the PCF shall not

    closed at the end of the year.

    b) The fund shall be kept separately f rom the regular

    col lect ions and advances granted for a particular

    purpose and shall not be used for payment of regular

    expenses;

    c)The amount of the PCF shall be determined by the SB

    but not to exceed twenty percent (20%) of the fundsavailable and to the credit of the barangay treasury

    d) All disbursements out of PCF shall be covered by duly

    approved and accomplished Pet ty Cash Vouchers

    supported by cash invoices, ORs or other evidence of

    disbursements required undeper applicable accounting

    and auditing rules and regulations;

    e) All paid Petty Cash Vouchers (PCVs) shall be reported

    in the summary of paid PCVs (SPPCV) to be certified by

    the Petty Cash fund Custodian (PCFC).

    f) The PCF shall be replenished as soon as disbursements

    reach seventy five percent (75%) or as needed;

    g) Replenishment of the PCF shall be made by submitting

    a DV for the purpose supported by duly cert if ied

    SPPCV, paid PCVs and supporting documents;

    h) In case the PCFC resigns or ceased as custodian of the

    Fund, ful l accounting/l iquidation of the Fund shall be

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    12/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    made. any remaining cash shall be refunded to close

    the account; and

    i) In no case shall the remaining cash of the former PCFC

    be transferred to the incoming PCFC. For a complete

    accounting, the account of the former PCFC shall be

    c losed and a new account shall be opened for the

    incoming PCFC.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    13/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Legend:

    DV - Disbursement Voucher

    P - PayrollI - Invoices

    DTR - Daily Time Record

    OSD - Other Supporting Documents

    CCC - Carbon Copy of the Check

    OR - Official Receipt

    AP - Approved Payroll

    CA - Certificate of Appearance

    RIT - Revised Itenirary of Travel

    I/T - Invoices/Tickets

    SEP - Summary of Expenses Paid

    LR - Liquidation ReportLB - Log Book

    BT/AO- Barangay Treasurer/ Accountable Officer

    SBR - Sanggunian Barangay Resolution

    PCV - Petty Cash Fund

    SPPVC- Summary of paid petty cash fund

    Symbols:

    - Flow of Documents

    - Records

    - file

    - Document

    - Check

    - Process

    - Book -

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    14/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    -

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    15/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Area of

    Responsibility/Person

    Responsible

    Sequence Activity

    Barangay Treasurer

    Punong Barangay

    Barangay Treasurer

    Payee/Supplier

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    Receives the approved

    DV/Payroll.

    Verifies completeness of

    signatures on the DV/Payroll.

    Prepares the check in thename of the payee for the

    amount indicated in the

    DV/Payroll.

    Note 1. The check shall beprepared eith a carbon copy,

    to be distributed as follows:

    Original PayeeCarbon Copy at tached

    to the DV/Payroll

    Signs the check.

    Forwards the check together

    with the DV/Payroll andsupporting documents to thePB for countersignature on the

    check.

    Countersigns the check and

    returns it to the BT together

    with the supporting documents

    for release.

    Receives and releases the

    check to the payee. Attachesthe carbon copy of the check

    to the paid DV/Payroll.

    Acknowledges the receipt of

    payment by signing in Box D

    of the DV, and retains 3 r d

    copy for his file.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    16/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Barangay Treasurer

    9

    10

    11

    Issues an OR, if applicable, toacknowledge the payment

    received.

    Returned the signed DV to the

    BT with the OR to the BT.

    Note 2. The Or (if applicable)

    shall be made as anadditional supporting

    document to the

    disbursements.

    Attaches the OR issued by the payee/supplier to the original

    DV together with the carbon

    copy of the check. Retains the2nd copy of the Dv for file.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    17/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    18/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Area of

    Responsibility/Person

    Responsible

    Sequence Activity

    Barangay Treasurer 1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    Receives the check for the cashadvance.

    Encashes the check.

    Pays the officers/employees

    listed in the payroll.

    Note 1. The officers/employeesshall be required to sign in the

    column of the payroll to

    acknowledge the receipt of payment from the BT.

    Refunds any unclaimed

    salaries/wages/honoraria.

    Issues OR for the refund.

    Files the paid DV/payroll

    temporarily to support SCP.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    19/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    20/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Area of

    Responsibility/Person

    Responsible

    Sequence Activity

    BarangayTreasurer/Accountable

    Officer

    Punong Barangay

    Barangay Record Keeper

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    Prepares the LR based on thecertificate of Travel

    completed/Revised Itinerary

    of Travel, Ors, Invoices,tickets, etc. and summary of

    expenses paid.

    Note 1. The LR shall be

    prepared in three copies to brdistributed as follows:

    Original

    City/Municipal Accountant2n d Copy BRK3 r d Copy BT/AO

    Check supporting documents

    against the LR.

    Signs Box A certified portion

    of the LR as to the

    correctedness of the data.

    Submits the duly signed LRtogether with all supportingdocuments to the PB.

    Receives LR together withsupporting documents. Signs

    Box B portion of LR as to the

    purpose of travel/cash advance

    duly accomplished.

    Forwards LR and supporting

    documents to BRK.

    Receives the LR and records

    in the log book.

    Signs Box C of LR as to

    completeness of supportingdocuments.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    21/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    9 Submits the original LR to theCity/Municipal Accountant on

    or before the 5

    t h

    day of thefollowing month. forwards the3 r d copy to BT/AO and retains

    the 2nd copy together with the

    supporting documents.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    22/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    23/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Area of

    Responsibility/PersonResponsible

    Sequence Activity

    Petty Cash Fund Custodian

    Requesting Official/Staff

    Punong Barangay

    A

    1

    2

    3

    B

    4

    5

    6

    Receipt of the authority as

    PCFC and establishment of

    PCF.

    Receives the approved SB

    Resolution designating the BTor an official as PCFC.

    Forwards the documents to the

    BRK for the preparation of theDV for the establishment of

    PCF.

    Note 1. subject toCertification and Approval of

    Payment.

    Receives and encashes the

    check.

    Request for cash from PCF.

    Prepares the PCV and signs the

    requested by portion of Box A.

    Note 2. The PCV shall be

    prepared in two copies to bedistributed as follows:

    Original to support the

    SPPCV2n d Copy Requesting

    Official

    Forwards the signed PCV to

    the PB for approval.

    Signs the approved by portion

    of PCV.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    24/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Petty Cash Fund Custodian

    Requesting Official/Staff

    Petty Cash Fund Custodian

    Requesting officials

    7

    8

    9

    10

    C

    11

    12

    13

    14

    15

    Forwards the PCV to the PCFC

    for payment.

    Pays the amount and signs thepaid by portion of Box B.

    Receives the amount and signs

    the paid by portion of Box B.

    Returns the signed PCV to

    PCFC and retains 2 n d copy for

    file.

    Liquidation of the cash

    received.

    Submit to the PCFC the

    Invoice/Official Receipt andothr evidence supporting the

    disbursements.

    Receives documents and other

    evidence of

    payments/disbursement.

    Retrieves the original PCV and

    computed the amount due

    to/form the recipient of thefund.

    Reimburses the requestingofficial/staff for the advances

    made, if any and signs Box C.

    Note 3. In case the PCF

    received exceeds the

    disbursements made, therequesting officials shall

    return the excess to the PCFC

    and signs Box C.

    Signs Box D for the

    r ei mb ur se me nt r ec eiv ed o r

    l iquidation made and re turns

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    25/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    the original of PCV to PCFC.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    26/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    27/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    Area of

    Responsibility/Person

    Responsible

    Sequence Activity

    Barangay Record Keeper 1

    2

    3

    Retrieves paid PCVs andSPPCV on file.

    Preapres the DV for thereplenishment of the PCF.

    Note 1. The replenishment

    shall be equa l to the amount

    disburse per SPPCV.

    Attaches the or iginal SPPCV

    with paid PCVs to the DV forreplenishment of the PCF.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    28/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    FINDINGS

    B as ed o n t he t ho ro ug h e xa min at io ns , a na lys is a nd d at a

    gatherings, the researchers come up with the following findings:

    1. The barangay officials did not adhere to the prescribed policies and

    procedures outlined by Department of Budget and Management, but

    instead they made simple procedures for practicality rather than the

    provided procedures above which is a bit complex compare to their

    current procedures they usually used.

    A cc or di ng t o th em , i f t he y w ill f ol lo w th e s te p- by -s te p

    procedures provided above, i t wil l t ake them l ike 2-3 days of

    process ing . But s ti ll , the procedures are the same. Documents

    needed to be s ign also went through the inspection of the punong

    barangay, barangay treasurer.

    2. The procedures made by the barangay officials were st i l l legal and

    s igned by aut hori zed per sons . I n t er ms o f d is burs emen ts andr ec eip ts , e ve nt ho ug h t he y d o n ot a dh er e t o th e s te p b y s te p

    procedures as prescribed, they make sure that al l s ignatures needed

    are authorized.

    3. There was a proper segregat ion of duti es among the barangay

    off ic ia ls . I n t he cours e o f dat a gat he ri ngs, a wel l s tr uc tu red

    divis ion of labor was observed in the brangay in such a way that

    there is a respective chairman for each projects and functions such

    as Administration, Programs l ike Liga, Environmental and the l ike.

    With this, the community may be assured that all of their respective

    functions are carried at their best.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    29/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    ACCOUNTANCY DEPARTMENT

    RECOMMENDATION

    Based on the f indings formulated , the r esearchers s trongly

    recommend the following:

    1. There must be a better definition of l iabil it ies of the barangay

    offic ia ls to the community and to the national government.

    Through this systematic process, lesser chance for corruption may

    be gained in all aspects of the p rocess.

    2. Transparency and accountabi li ty in al l transact ions should

    observe at a l l t imes. Through the process of t ransparency and

    accountabil i ty, the public wil l have the capabil i ty to examine and

    review the full performance and reports of the public sector which

    will leads to confidence and trust in the government entities.

    3. The Local Government specifical ly the Barangay should be

    participatory to improve public engagements that will enhance

    the Governments effectiveness and the quality of its decisions .

    Knowledge i s widely d ispersed in socie ty , and publ ic off ic ial s

    benefi t f rom having access to that d isper sed knowledge. Local

    agencies should offer i t s community increased opportunit ies to

    part icipate in policymaking and to provide their Government with

    the benef i ts of their collective exper t ise and informat ion. They

    should a lso sol ic it publ ic input on how they can increase and

    improve opportunities for public participation in Government.

  • 8/3/2019 Consultancy Paper

    30/30

    A D A M S O N U N I V E R S I T Y

    4. There must be also participation from the community . They must

    be well informed of the act ivit ies and projects of the barangay

    because people themselves should be a part of the system. Active part ic ipa tion of the communi ty wil l promote socia l awareness

    among i ts members that might increase i ts public part icipation and

    increase opportunities.

    5. L oc al go ve rn men t ag en cie s s ho uld b e c ol la bor at ive .

    Collaboration actively engages i ts local community members in the

    w or k o f t he ir G ov er nme nt . T he l oc al g ov ern me nt s ha ll u sei nnovat ive t oo ls , met hods , and s ys tems t o coopera te among

    themselves , across al l levels of Government , and wi th nonprofi t

    organizat ions , businesses, and individuals in the pr ivate sector .

    They should emanate public feedback to assess and improve their

    l evel o f col labora ti on and t o i dent if y new oppor tuni ti es f or

    cooperation.