congressional 2002 racegovernor’s 2002 race (major candidates) district candidate name (last,...

Key For 2002 Election Guide Florida Health Care Association

November 22, 2002

The following chart lists all candidates who were elected for the State Legislature and in SELECT Congressional and statewide races. The table contains the following information: Candidates in boldface were supported by FHCA-PAC. Columns *District – Denotes the Congressional, Senate or House legislative district. *Candidate Name as it appeared on the ballot. *Party

Dem – Democrat Gre – Green Party Lib – Libertarian Npa – No party affiliation Rep – Republican Wri – Write In candidate *Occupation *2001-2002 Performance for Incumbent Legislators - Comments on incumbent legislators’ role in passing legislation regarding LTC in the 2001- 2002 legislative sessions (block print is 2001 session – Italic Print is 2002 session). *Comments on Campaign - Comments on the race in general and candidate comments, which come from FHCA member and staff contact with candidates, the Associated Industries of Florida (AIF) candidate questionnaire and interview. AIF ENDORSEMENT means that AIF’s political action committee has endorsed the candidate as a candidate who the business community should support. Italic print is a summary of candidate answers to the following questions from the AIF questionnaire:

On a scale of 1 to 5 with 1 being "poor" care and 5 being "excellent" care, how do you rate the care that Florida nursing homes provide their patients?

(1=poor; 2=fair; 3=adequate; 4=good; 5=excellent) 1 2 3 4 5

Do you believe that nursing homes are adequately funded by the state and federal government to care for their patients? Yes No

Do you support increasing state funding for nursing homes so nursing homes are able to increase the number of hours of skilled care that they can give to their residents?

Yes No Do you feel the negative billboards and commercials about nursing homes by trial lawyers is intended to make nursing homes improve care or are they done to create a hostile climate for the nursing homes in case a lawyer sues one?

Improves care Creates hostile climate

1

In general do you believe damages should be capped? Yes No

If no, why? See comments below If yes, what amount (approximately)? See comments below

A.Specifically: Punitive damages Yes No


B. Economic (i.e. lost wages)

Yes No


C.

Non-economic (mental anguish) Pain & suffering

Yes No


2

3

SELECT CONGRESSIONAL 2002 RACE District Candidate Name

(Last, First) Party Occupation 2001-2002 Performance for

Incumbent Legislators Comments on Campaign

05 (CD) Brown-Waite, Ginny Rep Legislator Spent countless hours crafting a fair SB 1202; brought parties together to negotiate what could be worked out; took lead on getting more funding, balanced quality proposals and fair litigation reform. Fought to keep SB 1202 full funding in special and regular sessions. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill, sponsored “grannycam” study,assisted when AHCA overstepped regulatory authority and attempted to de-license 4 nursing homes; attempted to mediate liability insurance solution; is FHCA’s Senator of the Year.

17 (CD) Meek, Kendrick B. Dem Legislator Voted against bill first time; on final vote supported SB 1202. Sponsored SEIU bill to prohibit Medicaid reimbursement of union or antiunion activities and worked with FHCA to remove onerous provision.

24 (CD) Feeney, Tom Rep Legislator Once SB 1202 came to House, ensured it passed with strong litigation provisions against the wishes of Representative Argenziano; lead House to accept the balanced Senate bill. Established a select committee to review the nursing home liability insurance crisis; helped obtain funding for rebasing of operating costs and Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

25 (CD) Diaz-Balarat, Mario Rep Voted for SB 1202

GOVERNOR’S 2002 RACE (MAJOR CANDIDATES) District Candidate Name


Incumbent Legislators Campaign Comments

Bush, John Ellis (Jeb) Rep Governor Leader in support of SB 1202; held press conferences; made positive statements to press; worked with legislators privately. Supported full funding for SB 1202 provisions in 02 &03 budgets. Took lead to create lease bond alternative.

ATTORNEY GENERAL 2002 RACE District Candidate Name



Crist, Charlie Rep CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER 2002 RACE District Candidate Name



Gallagher, Tom Rep Stated that we need an insurance solution. Department of Insurance staff helpful in providing data but reluctant to take strong tort reform position publicly. Worked behind scenes for Insurance solution that limited amount of liability. Staff testified before House on the insurance unavailability facing nursing homes and assisted in discussions to create nursing home self insurance language.

4

SENATE 2002 RACE District Candidate Name



001 Hill, Anthony C. Tony Dem Organizer for SEIU

002 Peaden Jr., Durell Rep Retired Physician

Strong advocate in Senate on litigation reform; sponsored pro-long term care quality and risk management amendments in Committees. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill; spoke in favor of full funding for SB 1202; sponsored FHCA amendment on controlled substance reporting; advocated FHCA sponsored lease bond alternative in special session.

003 Argenziano, Nancy Rep Legislator Opposed strong litigation reform as Chairwoman of Council for Healthy Communities; was the primary opponent to strong litigation reform on Task Force and in legislature; sponsored Jim Wilkes amendments on litigation and quality; voted against SB 1202 on floor every time. Sponsored and actively advocated unfunded wage mandate bill; only Legislator to vote against Medicaid funding bill after speaking out against Medicaid “subsidy” of nursing homes.

004 Clary III, Charles W. Rep Architect Voted for SB 1202; did not advocate for strong litigation reform in Senate Health Committee. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits

5

6

District Candidate Name(Last, First)

Party Occupation 2001-2002 Performance for Incumbent Legislators

Campaign Comments

005 Wise, Stephen Rep Consultant Supportive of long term care during 2000 campaign; spent much time in nursing homes learning our issues.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports increased funding; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports cap on “pain & suffering” but not punitive damages in lawsuits

006 Lawson, Jr., Alfred “Al”

Dem InsuranceAgent

Voted for SB 1202.

007 Lynn, Evelyn J. Rep Legislator Vocal supporter of strong litigation reform in Council for Healthy Communities and Fiscal Responsibility Councils.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits; AIF ENDORSMENT

008 King Jr., James E. Rep Retired Personnel Recruiting

Voted for SB 1202; helped in effort to have trial lawyers back away from diluting punitive damage limits.

Designated as next Senate President AIF ENDORSMENT

009 Webster, Daniel Rep Owner, Webster A/C and Heating

Voted for SB 1202; sponsored Jim Wilkes amendments on CON moratorium, contemporaneous charting and fraudulent altering of records; not a supporter of strong litigation reform.

010 Lee, Tom Rep VP of Finance, Sabal Homes of Florida

Voted for SB 1202.

7



Campaign Comments

011 Fasano, Mike Rep Associate VP for Investments/Morgan Stanley

Initially did not support strong litigation reform. When SB 1202 was in House, he defended it in Healthy Communities Council; led floor debate to ensure passage of bill and opposed amendments to weaken litigation provisions; on negative side sponsored amendment in Council to remove retroactivity of punitive damage limitations and put in whistleblower provisions. Worked closely with FHCA on consumer directed care bill to ensure it did not impede institutional funding for nursing home liability insurance costs; worked with FHCA to fix anti-terrorism continuing education requirements; helped kill electronic surveillance study bill; helped obtain funding for rebasing of operating costs and Insurance Risk Retention Group in special sessions. Providers.

Rates nursing home care as fair; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

012 Crist, Victor Rep President Advertising Agency

Voted for SB 1202; sponsored then withdrew Jim Wilkes’ amendment to gut confidentiality protection; neither spoke in favor nor against bill on Senate floor. Sponsored Gold Seal bill, which FHCA did not initially support. Worked with FHCA on a positive amendment that improves the Gold Seal panel.

013 Jones, Dennis L. Rep Chiropractor Was supportive of LTC when previously in House. Is supported by LTC providers in his district. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; does not support caps on damages – should be based on each case. AIF ENDORSMENT

8



Campaign Comments

014 Smith, Rod Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202; sponsored trial lawyer amendment for criminal referrals when punitive damages awarded.

Is not a strong proponent of tort reform generally; Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; does not supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

015 Dockery, Paula Rep Legislator Voted for SB 1202. 016 Sebesta, Jim Rep Real Estate

Broker, Developer

Voted for SB 1202 on Senate floor and in Judiciary Committee. Sponsored FHCA supported bill to clarify that bingo is allowed in nursing homes.

Feels nursing homes provide good care; are adequately funded; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages. AIF ENDORSMENT

017 J.D. Alexander Rep Legislator Supporter of strong litigation reforms; worked behind scenes to pass SB 1202.

Is very concerned about the liability costs faced by nursing homes. Had a “wonderful” facility in his district. It had only one lawsuit and faced massive liability premium increases. Also concerned about the small businesses that have contracts with nursing homes that will be hurt if the nursing home closes due to a large judgment. Wants to find a balanced resolution to this problem. Believes nursing homes are not adequately funded; supports increased funding for staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; does not support caps in lawsuits; punitive damages over $500,000 should go to state.

018 Miller Jr., Lesley Dem Manager, Minority Business Enterprise

Voted for SB 1202. Has mother in a nursing home. Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; opposes caps on damages in lawsuits

019 Siplin, Gary A. Dem Legislator Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Nursing homes are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; undecided on caps on damages in lawsuits.

020 Cowin, Anna P. Rep Educator/ Legislator

Voted for SB 1202. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill

Rates nursing home care as fair; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT.



Campaign Comments

021 Bennett, Michael Rep ElectricalContractor

Introduced FHCA supported bill in House; worked publicly and behind scenes to pass SB 1202; was leader on issues for long-term care. Sponsored FHCA amendment to improve makeup of Gold Seal Panel Helped obtain funding for Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

Feels nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on punitive and non-economic damages.

022 Constantine, Lee Rep Real Estate Broker

Voted for SB 1202.

023 Carlton, Lisa Rep Co-Owner/ Manager Cattle, Citrus Business/ Attorney

Voted for SB 1202. Worked with FHCA to ensure that resident rights cases were not part of new elder abuse statute ensuring that Chapter 400 remains an exclusive remedy. Ensured SB 1202 was fully funded and supported funding for operating cost rebase and Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

024 Posey, Bill Rep Realtor Voted for SB 1202; sponsored Jim Wilkes amendment to eliminate retroactivity of punitive damage limitations.

Believes nursing homes provide good to excellent care; supports more money to increase staffing; supports cap on punitive but not “pain & suffering” damages in lawsuits AIF ENDORSMENT

025 Atwater, Jeff Rep FloridaAtlantic University

Voted for SB 1202. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill in committee.

AIF ENDORSMENT

026 Futch, Howard E. Rep Retired Federal Government Senior Level Management

AIF ENDORSMENT

9



Campaign Comments

027 Aronberg, David Dem Attorney Strong candidate. Attorney who works for Office of the Attorney General. Has done defense work in past. Some unscrupulous lawyers see business as a walking ATMs. Must cut out people who give lawsuits a bad name. There should be some tort reform to improve medical malpractice but it should be middle of the road reforms. Rates nursing home care as fair to adequate; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment. AIF ENDORSMENT

028 Pruitt, Ken Rep Realtor Voted for SB 1202; sponsored trial lawyer amendment to weaken punitive damage limits; spoke against “for profit” nursing homes in Health Committee. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano.

029 Dawson, M. Muriel Dem Legislator/ Consultant

First vote was against SB 1202; on final vote supported SB 1202. Sponsored union backed bill to prevent anti-union activities in nursing homes. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano.

Strongly supported by organized labor.

030 Klein, Ron Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill but only after explaining position to FHCA lobbyists and pledging to only further support of the bill if it is funded; agreed FHCA recommendation to amend nursing homes out of his CON reform bill; as next leader of Senate Democrats, met with FHCA Board of Directors to build closer ties with LTC providers.

Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment.

031 Geller, Steven A. Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202 on final vote.

10



Campaign Comments

032 Campbell, Walter “Skip”

Dem Attorney Sponsored trial lawyer amendments to dilute litigation reform and create a Joint Underwriting Association, but in end worked out punitive damage language and advised trial lawyers to support bill; supported final version SB 1202. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano. Sponsored FHCA amendment to prevent duplication of adverse incident reporting.

033 Wilson, Frederica S. Dem Founder and Executive Director, 5000 Role Models of Excellence

Supported SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor. Served on House Special Committee on nursing home liability insurance but did not take active role in deliberations.

034 Wasserman-Schultz, Debbie

Dem Legislator Spoke out against litigation reform provisions in Health Committee; sponsored amendment on Senate floor to water down punitive language limits; also sponsored high staffing standard amendment; spoke in favor of “electronic surveillance” in Committee; Voted for SB 1202. Sponsored and actively advocated unfunded wage mandate bill; spoke against bingo bill because she does not believe nursing home residents should “gamble;” sponsored amendment in special session for unfunded wage mandate; stated that state “subsidizes” nursing homes, we “don’t get it”, and will be back next year sponsoring unfunded wage increase mandate bill.

035 Margolis, Gwen Dem Realtor – Developer

Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on punitive and economic damages in lawsuits.

11



Campaign Comments

036 Diaz De La Portilla, Alex

Rep Legislator/Sales Director Demattress

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote.

037 Saunders, Burt L. Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202; as Health Committee chairman he stripped tort provisions from the bill in Committee so it could not be weakened and helped pass bill thru his Committee. Did not vote on unfunded wage mandate bill; bottled up FHCA opposed background screening bill in his committee; sponsored FHCA fraud & abuse amendments in special session.

038 Villalobos, J. Alex Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. Was not a strong supporter of litigation reform in Committee.

039 Bullard, Larcenia J. Dem Assistant Principal

Has not seen the trial lawyer billboards and is not familiar with their impact on nursing homes. She is very concerned that family members who have had a negative incident have access to legal representation. She wants to meet with representatives from nursing homes to discuss this issue further. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards improve care; needs additional information to support caps on damages.

040 Garcia Jr., Rodolfo “Rudy”

Rep Businessman Voted for SB 1202 in Judiciary Committee and on Senate floor; sponsored positive ALF amendments.

End of 2002 Florida Senate Race

12

HOUSE 2002 RACE District Candidate Name



001 Evers, Greg Rep Farmer and Small Businessman

Newly elected. Did not take position on our issues.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSMENT

002 Murzin, Dave Rep Former Legis Aide

Former aide to Rep. Maygarden and endorsed by him. Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on “pain & suffering” but not punitive damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSMENT

003 Benson, AnnaHolliday

Rep MunicipalBond Lawyer

Voted for SB 1202. Sponsored FHCA fraud and abuse amendments during special session.

Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

004 Sansom, Ray Rep Is open to capping non-economic damages if it can be demonstrated that claims are what is driving up health care costs. However, need to look at a full range of reforms. Rates nursing home care as fair.

005 Brown, Donald D. Rep Insurance Agent

Voted for SB 1202. Openly opposed nursing home electronic surveillance legislation.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

13


Political Affiliation

Occupation 2001-2002 Performance for Incumbent Legislators

Campaign Comments

006 Bense, Allan George Rep Road Builder Construction Real Estate Developer Golf Course Development/ Ownership

Chairman of Infrastructure Council that passed strong litigation reform bill in House. Leader publicly and behind scenes for strong litigation reform. Sponsored FHCA amendment to improve makeup of Gold Seal Panel

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

007 Kilmer, Bev Rep AssociationExecutive

Voted for SB 1202. Sponsored amendment to fix cosmetology license problem in LTC facilities.

Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

008 Richardson, Curtis B. Dem Consultant Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Is working closely with LTC providers in his district and willing to help on our issues. Nursing homes are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing.

009 Ausley, Loranne Dem Attorney Voted for final version SB 1202; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Concerned about doctors leaving because of the large medical malpractice rates. Do not think that a constitutional amendment capping awards is a smart idea. Rates nursing home care as good; unsure if they are adequately funded or if she supports more money to increase staffing; opposes caps on damages in lawsuits.

010 Kendrick, Will S. Dem Banking Voted for SB 1202. Ranked top pro-business Democratic Legislator by AIF. Rates nursing home care as adequate; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

011 Stansel, Dwight Dem FarmerBusinessman Nurseryman

Voted for SB 1202. Ranked second highest pro-business Democratic Legislator by AIF. Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

14



Campaign Comments

012 Bean, Aaron Rep Banker Supported strong litigation reform on floor and in Ready Infrastructure Council. Sponsored ALF mental health study bill.

013 Hogan, Mike Rep HumanResources & Safety Consultant

Voted for SB 1202.

014 Fields, Terry L. Dem Consultant Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Is Vice Chairman of the Black Business Caucus and is working closely with business community. Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment;

015 Gibson, Audrey Dem BusinessCommunity Liaison

Believes that we need to train more CNAs. Wants more information on our reimbursements system and on new ways to train CNAs. Supports caps on awards. Rates nursing home care as fair.

016 Mahon, Mark Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202; sponsored Jim Wilkes amendment to remove punitive damage limitation retroactivity from bill in Ready Infrastructure Council.

017 Jordan, Stan Rep President of Sterling Company

Voted for SB 1202. Parent was in nursing home for 9 years and was happy with care provided. Opposes the “bounty hunter” attitude among plaintiff attorneys. Does not like the attorney advertising. Supported J.C. Gentry over Senator Wise. Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards improve care and create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

15

District Candidate Name

(Last, First) Political Affiliation


Campaign Comments

018 Davis, Don Rep V.P. of Corporate Relations Gate Pretroleum

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

019 Kravitz, Dick Rep Insurance/Business Consultant

Voted for SB 1202. Nursing home reform important – need to get insurers back in state – punish “bad performing” homes with higher rates and reward good performers with lower rates. The Insurance Commissioner needs to recruit insurance companies to come back to Florida. Tort reform is also needed to bring them back. Open minded – not against trial lawyers per-se but oppose certain trial lawyers that exploit the system and drive up settlements. Rates nursing home care as adequate; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

020 Wiles, Doug Dem President/ Owner Herbie Wiles Insurance

Voted for SB 1202. As 2nd ranking Democrat in House, he continually kept us briefed and allowed us to voice our concerns to Dem caucus as needed.

Feels nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; support caps on damages in lawsuits.

021 Pickens, Joe H. Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. Rates nursing home care as good; uncertain if adequately funded or to provide more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

16




Campaign Comments

022 Cretul, Larry Rep Real Estate Broker

The district is a retirement area and nursing home and ALF issues are important and must be addressed by the legislature. The legal system is a good system with some flaws. Is undecided on whether to cap “pain and suffering” portion of awards. However, knows issues must be addressed and willing to listen. Rates nursing home care as good; are adequately funded; opposes more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment.

023 Jennings Jr., Ed Dem Real Estate Developer


Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on punitive but not “pain & suffering” damages in lawsuits.

024 Baxley, Dennis K. Rep Funeral Director

Voted for SB 1202; worked behind scenes to pass it. Openly opposed nursing home electronic surveillance legislation.

Father recently died of Alzheimer’s and caring for elderly is major issue for him. Rates nursing home care as good; are adequately funded; opposes more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

025 Baker, Carey L. Rep Owner, A.W.Peterson Gun Shop

Voted for SB 1202. Understands the litigation and liability costs to health care providers and will work with us on solutions. Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are adequately funded; does not support more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps on lawsuits.

026 Patterson, Pat Rep Ins. Agent – Former Legislator

Have been hearing from nursing homes in district on the problems they face. Other side shares “horror stories.” No easy answers to the problems you face but wants to work on finding solutions. Rates nursing home care as adequate; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

17

18




Campaign Comments

027 Cusack, Joyce Dem RegisteredNurse

Spoke in favor of SB 1202 on the House floor. Told Representatives “Do not drop the ball.” Supported bill on final vote; however supported motion to weaken bill on House floor. Fought to keep SB 1202 full funding in special sessions.

Wants to work in partnership with FHCA on LTC issues to improve care to seniors and to make it more attractive to those who provide the hands on care. Believes nursing homes provide good care; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; no comment on trial lawyer billboards; does not support caps on damages in lawsuits.

028 Kosmas, Suzanne M. Dem Owner, Broker Prestige Properties

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor; sponsored 2.9 staffing bill with no litigation reform; spoke at FHCA Rally. Despite struggling with this issue, she was accessible and tried to work with us when possible. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill but told us after she would only further support the bill if funded.

Rates nursing home care as adequate; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on punitive and “pain & suffering”damages in lawsuits.

029 Poppell, L. Ralph Rep Citrus & Manufact.

Pro-business candidate. Rates nursing home care as adequate; are adequately funded; unsure if supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

030 Haridopolos, Mike Rep AssistantProfessor of History

Voted for SB 1202. Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; no comment on funding; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment. Supports caps on civil litigation damages. AIF ENDORSEMENT

031 Needelman, Mitch Rep Legislator Voted for SB 1202. 032 Allen, Bob Rep Economic

Dvlpmt & Educ Tech

Voted for SB 1202.

033 Adams, Sandra Seton Rep Law Enforce-ment

Strong candidate. Knowledgeable of nursing home issues but wants to visit nursing homes to learn more. Supportive of litigation reform efforts. Endorsed by Registered Nurses group. Feels nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment. AIF ENDORSEMENT




Campaign Comments

034 Mealor, David J. Rep Professor Regional Campus Director – UCF

Voted for SB 1202. AIF ENDORSEMENT

035 Kallinger, Jim Rep GeneralContractor

Voted for SB 1202. AIF ENDORSEMENT

036 McInvale, Sheri Dem Unfamiliar with nursing home issues. Supports cap on “pain & suffering” in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

037 Simmons, David Rep Attorney Worked hard to craft fair litigation reform provision and find compromise between long term care and the trial lawyers; defended strong litigation reform on House floor; Voted for SB 1202. As member of Select Committee on Liability Insurance worked to craft an insurance solution for nursing homes; advocated joint underwriting association for nursing homes; participated in FHCA press conference on staffing.

Believes that SB 1202 did not go far enough because it allowed an influx of suits under the old law during the transition period. He will be an advocate for nursing homes on finding affordable liability insurance. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; support caps on damages.

038 Brummer, Frederick Rep CPA Voted for SB 1202. Strong supporter of LTC issues including tort reform. Believes nursing home tort reform did not go far enough to stem lawsuits. Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

039 Antone, Bruce Dem 040 Gardiner, Andy Rep Executive

Director, Apopka Chamber of Commerce

Voted for SB 1202.

041 Johnson, Randy Rep CEO, CentralFL Sports Authority

Voted for SB 1202.

19




Campaign Comments

042 Gibson III, Hugh H. Rep Retired Fire Chief


Rates nursing home care as fair; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits.

043 Dean, Charles S. Rep Sheriff AIF ENDORSEMENT 044 Russell, David D. Rep Swimming

Pool Contractor

Voted for SB 1202. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano; sponsored FHCA supported amendment to Gold Seal Panel

Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages. AIF ENDORSEMENT

045 Anderson, Tom Rep Mayor of Dunedin

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps in general on damages in lawsuits.

046 Fiorentino, Heather Rep Teacher Voted for SB 1202. 047 Ambler, Kevin C. Rep Attorney Feels nursing homes provide good care; are

not adequately funded; supports more money to increased staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; does not support caps on damages in lawsuits.

048 Bilirakis, Gus Michael Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. 049 Quinones IV, John P. Rep 050 Berfield, Kim Rep Director

Marketing Promotions and Special Events

Voted for SB 1202. Feels nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increased staffing; trial lawyer billboards improve care and create a hostile environment; does not support caps on damages in lawsuits.

051 Waters, Leslie Rep Legislator Voted for SB 1202. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano; spoke favorably of FHCA supported amendment to Gold Seal Panel. As chairman of Insurance Committee offered to hold hearing on nursing home liability insurance crisis.

No position stated on care provided by nursing homes or funding; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; no position on caps. AIF ENDORSEMENT

20

21




Campaign Comments

052

Farkas, Frank Rep Chiropractor Voted for SB 1202. Supported full funding for SB 1202 in special session.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps on lawsuits with certain percentages. AIF ENDORSEMENT

053 Justice, Charlie Dem AcademicAdvisor, University of South Florida

Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; some trial lawyer billboards are genuine; can supports caps on damages in lawsuits as part of common sense compromise.

054 Carassas, John Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. Sponsored Gold Seal Panel bill that FHCA did not initially support; opposed FHCA supported amendment to fix the bill in Committee; eventually worked with FHCA on bill we could support.

055 Peterman Jr., Frank Dem Director of Developments Juvenile Services Program





Campaign Comments

056 Murman, Sandra L. Rep Community Activist

Voted for SB 1202. As Chairman of Health Appropriations she ensured SB 1202 was fully funded in special session; advocated funding for nursing home liability insurance costs; at FHCA request withdrew amendment to cap Medicaid patients; sponsor of FHCA supported nursing home “bed banking” amendment; bottled up unfunded wage mandate bill in committee; sponsored managed LTC pilot project in 1 area of state; supported funding for operating cost rebasing and Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

Feels nursing homes provide fair care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; no position on caps on damages in lawsuits.

057 Culp, Faye Rep FormerLegislator

Believes nursing home care is fair; doesn’t know about if adequately funded or if increased funding is necessary; trial lawyer billboards create hostile climate; in favor of caps on lawsuits but depends on the situation.

058 Henriquez, Bob Dem Planner,Coach

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor; sponsored trial lawyer amendment to weaken punitive damage protections in Infrastructure Council.

Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are adequately funded; does not support more money to increase staffing; no comment on trial lawyer billboards; does support caps on punitive and “pain & suffering”damages in lawsuits.

059 Joyner, Arthenia L. Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Opposes caps on awards but is open to looking at it because the system is in distress. Willing to look at seeing if we can find a compromise in this area. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials improve care and create a hostile environment.

060 Homan, Ed Rep Doctor Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are adequately funded; does not support more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; support caps on pain and suffering and non-economic.

22




Campaign Comments

061 Littlefield, Ken Rep BusinessOwner

Sponsored amendments to strip punitive damage retroactivity and put back whistleblower provision in SB 1202 in Council for Healthy Communities. Spoke in favor of FHCA supported Senate bill on House floor.

062 Byrd Jr., Johnnie B. Rep Attorney Became a supporter of litigation reform. Offered motion to cut off debate when Democrats attempted to weaken litigation provisions on House floor.

Will be next Speaker of the House.

063 Ross, Dennis A. Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Rates nursing home care as adequate; are adequately funded; opposes more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on punitive damages in lawsuits. Unsure on “pain & suffering” damages.

064 Stargel, John Rep VP Richland Towers

Believes that we need to see more LTC paid for by private insurance and private pay. Concerned about the cost of excessive lawsuits against nursing homes. There are abuses out there but trial lawyer advertising is excessive. Rates nursing home care as good; opposes more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF Endorsement

065 Bowen, Marsha Rep Agri-Business Believes that damages can be capped in certain situations. However, in cases of outright abuse a cap may not be appropriate. Feels nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increased staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment

23




Campaign Comments

066 Troutman, Baxter Rep Fair Labor Solutions

Supports caps on awards; is not sure what criteria to use to establish a cap. Rates nursing home care as adequate; unsure if adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment. AIF ENDORSEMENT

067 Reagan, Ron Rep Ins. Agent Lost election to Mike Bennett in 2000. Endorsed by Rep. Bennett. Rates nursing home care as good; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

068 Galvano, William Rep Attorney Supported by trial bar. 069 Clarke, Donna L. Rep Owner/

President Engineering Consulting Firm

Voted for SB 1202. Assisted when AHCA overstepped regulatory authority and attempted to de-license 4 nursing homes,

Rates nursing home care as fair; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

070 Detert, Nancy C. Rep Legislator/ Mortgage Broker

Voted for SB 1202.

071 Paul, Jerry S. Rep Attorney/ Engineer

Voted for SB 1202; sponsored pro-long term care amendments in Elder Affairs Committee; spoke in favor of strong litigation reform; was advocate for long term care in meetings with House leadership. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano; led the debate for FHCA Gold Seal Panel amendment; advocate for LTC provider solutions on Select Committee on Liability Insurance; supported funding for operating cost rebasing and Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

24

25




Campaign Comments

072 Harrington, Lindsay Rep Realtor Advocated strong litigation reform on floor and in Infrastructure Council.

Does not believes can state average quality of care in FL, every home should be judge individually; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps on lawsuits.

073 Kyle, Bruce Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. AIF ENDORSEMENT 074 Kottkamp, Jeff Rep Attorney/

Mediator Voted for SB 1202. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care;

are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; does not support caps on damages – should be a case by case bases. AIF ENDORSMENT

075 Green, Carole Rep RetiredHealth Care Admin.

Chairman of Elder Affairs Committee that drafted first House bill without FHCA input and with weak litigation reform. However, as Senate bill evolved, spoke in favor of that stronger bill; took lead on House floor to accept Senate bill, ensuring final passage. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill; withdrew electronic surveillance amendment at FHCA’s request; sponsored self-insurance amendment

Continuation of 2001 – 2002 Role chart for teaching nursing homes and made attempt to allow self-insurance products for all nursing homes and ALFs; as member of Select Committee on Liability Insurance advocated against new tort reform but supported funding for liability insurance costs; was made FHCA Representative of the Year.

076 Goodlette, J. Dudley Rep Attorney Key supporter on House floor and in Infrastructure Council to pass strong litigation reform; crafted punitive damage language that passed Infrastructure Council; was advocate for long term care in meetings with House leadership. Chaired select committee on nursing home liability insurance; worked hard to find solution to liability insurance crisis; strong advocate for operating cost rebasing and fund for Insurance Risk Retention Group in special session.

077 Spratt, Joseph R. Rep Real Estate Voted for SB 1202.




Campaign Comments

078 Machek, Richard Dem Agriculture Sponsored whistleblower protection amendment on floor; supported SB 1202 on House floor. Voted against unfunded wage mandate bill; spoke in favor of FHCA supported amendment to Gold Seal Panel.

Is very concerned about doctors retiring early because of malpractice costs. Has mother in a nursing home and understands that accidents happen and families should not automatically sue. Need to put caps in place across the board. Medical insurance will be a big issue in the next session. Feels nursing homes provide fair care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment.

079 Attkisson, Frank Rep Businessman Voted for SB 1202. Does not support caps on civil awards. Nursing home reforms will take several years before insurers come back into the market. Nursing homes are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment.

080 Mayfield, Stanley Rep ProfessionalEngineer Gen. Contractor Consultant

Voted for SB 1202.

081 Harrell, Gayle Rep BusinessManager Health Care Admin.

Voted for SB 1202. Rates nursing home care as adequate; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps on civil awards. However, the State's contribution to the health and welfare of the individual needs to be taken into consideration.

082 Negron, Joe Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202; sponsored amendments in Elder Affairs Committee to weaken litigation reform provisions and create a Joint Underwriting Association. Spoke in favor of final version SB 1202 on House floor. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano.

Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; no position on trial lawyer billboards; does not support caps on damages.

26




Campaign Comments

083 Domino, Carl J. Rep Money Manager

Ran in 2000 Unsure how to rate nursing home care, if adequately funded, and whether to support more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment; supports caps only on punitive damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSMENT

084 Harper Jr., James “Hank”

Dem ConsultantPublic Relations


085 Vana, Shelley Dem 086 Gannon, Anne Dem Government

Affairs and General Consulting

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor. Her September 2001 newsletter states, “I’m disappointed that the trade off for quality care was putting a limit on the right to hold even the worst nursing homes accountable when they harm residents.”

Currently conducting voter registration drive of all nursing home residents in district. Rates nursing home care as adequate; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment and improve care; opposes caps on damages in lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

087 Hasner, Adam Rep AttorneyHealth field

Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; not enough knowledge on funding to make comment; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps on industry basis.

088 Bucher, Susan Dem Legislator Sponsored whistleblower amendment on House floor; spoke against SB 1202 on floor.

27

28

District Candidate Name

(Last, First) Political Affiliation


Campaign Comments

089 Brandenburg, Mary Dem Ownselectrical engineering firm/ former CC in WPB

Medical malpractice costs need to be controlled. Can support caps on non-economic damages if that is what it takes to bring back affordable insurance. Afraid that a cap would be seen by a jury as the amount to award in all cases thus increasing the costs to providers. Believes nursing homes provide adequate care but varies among providers; are not adequately funded; supports more money for increase staffing; doesn’t know what the trial lawyers intend with billboards/commercials.

090 Slosberg, Irving Dem Businessman Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

091 Mack, Connie Rep Executive – LTP Management

Voted for SB 1202.

092 Seiler, John P. Dem Legislator Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor; spoke in favor of bill on House floor.

093 Smith, Chris Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

Supports a cap on punitive awards but does not support caps on economic or non-economic damages. Could support a presumptive cap that a judge can exceed in extremely egregious cases. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment.

094 Meadows, Matthew Dem Legislator Voted for SB 1202; his September 2001 newsletter states, “I’m disappointed that the trade off for quality care was putting a limit on the right to hold even the worst nursing homes accountable when they harm residents.”

Feels nursing homes provide good care; are adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards improves care. Continuous trial lawyer advertising creates a hostile environment and encourages lawsuits. AIF ENDORSEMENT

29




Campaign Comments

095 Greenstein, Ron Dem MgmtConsultant

Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor; privately helpful on passing strong litigation reform and moderate quality reforms. As a member of the Select Committee on Liability Insurance was supportive of LTC provider solutions to liability insurance problem. Advocate of full funding for SB 1202 and for nursing home liability insurance costs.

Believes nursing homes provide good care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment; supports caps on lawsuits.

096 Ritter, Stacy Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202. 097 Rich, Nan Dem Professional

Volunteer Voted for SB 1202 on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor. Stated that SB 1202 had to much tort reform and too little quality mandates.

098 Wishner, Roger Dem President & CEO of Nationwide Medical Waste

Supported bill on final vote; supported motion to weaken bill on House floor.

AIF ENDORSEMENT

099 Sobel, Eleanor Dem Legislator/Business President

Voted against SB 1202; spoke against bill and strong litigation reform

Feels nursing homes provide fair care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; no position on trial lawyer billboards or caps.

100 Ryan, Timothy M. Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202; co-sponsored amendment on House floor to increase staffing to 2.9. Offered motion on House floor to weaken bill. Supportive in Democratic Caucus.

101 Davis, Mike Rep Retired102 Arza, Rafael “Ralph” Rep High School

Professor Voted for SB 1202.




Campaign Comments

103 Holloway, Wilbert T. Dem Area Director Bellsouth


Have heard from physicians in his community about the liability insurance costs. Is unsure what needs to be done but knows that the legislature must act to keep health care providers in the state. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards improves care and create a hostile environment; does not support caps on damages in lawsuits.

104 Roberson, Yolly Dem105 Gottlieb, Kenneth Dem Attorney/

President, Best Title

Voted against SB 1202 on House floor and supported amendments to weaken litigation reform and increase staffing to 2.9.

106 Gelber, Dan Dem Attorney Voted against SB 1202; lead opposition to strong litigation reform on House floor; sponsored amendments to weaken punitive damage limitations and increase staffing immediately to 2.9.

107 Barreiro, Gustavo A.

Rep Businessman Voted for SB 1202.

108 Brutus, Phillip J. Dem Attorney Voted for SB 1202; constant supporter of balanced litigation reform; spoke in favor of SB 1202 on House floor; sponsored unfunded wage mandate amendment in Committee. Voted for unfunded wage mandate bill sponsored by Rep. Argenziano.

Believes that a person injured in a nursing home should be “made whole,” reimbursed for all their losses. However, he can support a cap on awards that go beyond the compensation. Believes punitive damages should be capped. Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; believes negative billboards/commercials improve care and create hostile climate.

109 Bendross-Mindingall, Dorothy

Dem PublicSchool Adminis.

Spoke in favor of SB 1202 on House floor; voted for final version SB 1202; supported motion to weaken bill. Sponsored union bill to prohibit Medicaid reimbursement of union or anti-union activities and worked with FHCA to remove onerous provision.

Believes nursing homes provide fair care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards/commercials create a hostile environment but they improve care; does not supports caps on lawsuits.

30

31




Campaign Comments

110 Garcia, Rene Rep PrintingConsultant

Voted for SB 1202.

111 Rubio, Marco Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. Spoke in favor of bill on House floor. Outspoken advocate for LTC.

.

112 Rivera, David Rep Gov. Rel. Consultant

113 Prieguez, Manuel Rep SeafoodExporter

Voted for SB 1202.

114 Cantens, Gaston Rep Attorney Voted for SB 1202. 115 Planas, Juan-Carlos Rep Attorney Has very little experience with long term

care and would like to meet with providers to be educated about it. Understands that jury awards are driving up health care costs but can not commit to supporting caps on awards at this time.

116 Llorente, Marcelo Rep Attorney There is a huge problem with liability costs for health care providers. Wants victims to be fully compensated but would consider a cap on non-economic damages (“pain and suffering”) part of the award. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment. AIF ENDORSEMENT

117 Robaina, Julio Rep BellSouth / Mayor of South Miami

Strong candidate. Does not believe businesses should be sued to where they close their doors but there is egregious behavior and any cap should be on a case per case basis. Need to review this issue much closer. Could support caps if that is what it takes to have insurers continue to write policies for health care providers. Supported by FHCA President, Kelley Schild. Feels nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer billboards create a hostile environment. AIF ENDORSEMENT




Campaign Comments

118 Bullard, Edward Dem AssistantPrincipal


Believes nursing homes provide adequate care; are not adequately funded; supports more money to increase staffing; trial lawyer negative billboards/commercials improves care and creates a hostile environment; supports caps on lawsuits but would depend on case.

119 Zapata, Juan Carlos Rep President CASA

120 Sorensen, Ken Rep RetiredAirline Captain/ Director of Development International Programs FSU

Voted for SB 1202.

32

congressional 2002 racegovernor’s 2002 race (major candidates) district candidate name (last,...

Documents