7/31/2019 CONCLUSION WAS CHARLES BECKER GUILTY

1/2

CONCLUSIONWAS CHARLES BECKER GUILTY IN ORDERING THE

MURDER OF HERMAN ROSENTHAL?

The $64,000 question is: Did Lieut. Charles Becker order the murder of Herman

Rosenthal, or was he framed? And if Becker was framed, who did the framing, and why?The answer to the first question, to me, is self-evident. Charles Becker did not order the

murder of Herman Rosenthal. Yes, Becker was a lout, a ruffian, a crooked cop, and much worse,

and he certainly had the makeup to be a murderer; if thats what Becker thought was in his best

interest. But that doesnt mean Becker ordered Rosenthals murder.As for the motive, some people might say Becker had plenty of reasons to want

Rosenthal dead. I say it was in Beckers best interest to keep Rosenthal alive.

Lets examine the facts as we know them.

It was obvious that Becker and Rosenthal were partners in an illegal gambling house, and

at the time of his death, Rosenthal had already informed on Becker in the most open of forums

the New York City press. Killing Rosenthal would not have undone the damage Rosenthal had

already wrecked on Becker and his career. Keeping Rosenthal alive was the best thing forBecker, since it would give Becker a chance to discredit the gambler and possibly clear his own

name in the process. Becker had a lot of pull in law enforcement and in Tammany Hall. It is not

inconceivable that Becker could have walked away from Rosenthals accusations unscathed.

And surely, Becker was not a stupid man. If Rosenthal were to be killed just hours before

he was to visit District Attorney Whitmans office to make a formal affidavit against Becker,

Becker would be the first person to come under suspicion. This fact made Becker the perfect

pigeon for a frame.

Who else who stood to gain if Rosenthal were croaked?

Bald Jack Rose certainly fits that description. With Rosenthal out of the way, Rose, and

his pals Harry Vallon, and Bridgey Webber presumed they would be standing pretty in the

Tenderloin. With the competition from Rosenthals gambling house out of the way, these threecreeps probably figured they would rake in the fallen crumbs from Rosenthals gambling residue.

As events further unfolded, they were chased from the Tenderloin instead, by irate members of

the underworld, who, by nature, despised informers.

Lets assume for a moment that Rose arranged Rosenthals murder without Beckers

knowledge. It could have been the perfect crime if Rose and his pals werent so stupid.

Why rent a car for the murder; a car that could be traced back to Rose? Efficient killers

would have stolen a car to do the dirty deed. And surely, if Becker were arranging Rosenthals

murder he would have been intelligent enough to make sure the killers didnt use a rented car.

Once the owner and the driver of the murder car (William Libby and Louis Shapiro) were

caught, and they were caught quickly, the entire scheme fell apart.

This is where Rose used his ingenuity, his ability to survive. As soon as Libby and

Shapiro were arrested, Rose knew he was in deep spit unless he came up with a plan. Rose

decided to turn chicken crap into chicken salad by first turning himself in. Soon, Webber and

Vallon were sitting in the same Tombs prison cell next to Rose, so they could plan and scheme to

their hearts delight.

Behind bars was where Rose transformed himself from a dumb murderer into a smart

witness; a witness against Becker, whom was dumfounded - first when Rosenthal was killed, and

again when he was arrested for Rosenthals murder. Bridgey Webber, Sam Schepps, and Harry

7/31/2019 CONCLUSION WAS CHARLES BECKER GUILTY

2/2

Vallon, out to save their own skins, backed up Roses play, and this was the start of the demise

of Lieut. Charles Becker.

Rose also knew he had two aces in the hole: two men who wanted Roses story to be true

for their own personal ambitions - District Attorney Charles Whitman and newspaper columnist

Herbert Bayard Swope.

Whitman wanted to be Governor of the state of New York; then President of the UnitedStates of America. The best way to accomplish this exacta was to successfully prosecute a highly

visible case; especially one where the accused was a decorated New York City police lieutenant

(a variation of this same strategy was later employed by New York City Special Prosecutor

Thomas E. Dewey and New York Attorney for the Southern District Rudolph Giuliani, amongst

others).

Whitman didnt want to know the truth, and like Jack Nicholson once said in a movie,

He couldnt handle the truth. The truth was three lowlife gamblers arranged the killing of

another lowlife gambler. This was not the stuff dreams were made of; at least not Whitmansdreams. Whitman needed a big splash to further his political career, and his two successful

prosecutions of Becker was the right ticket Whitman needed to propel him upward politically;

the truth be damned.As for Swope, he was just a huckster who knew a good story when he saw it, even if the

story lacked the ingredients of the truth. Swope, who later won the first Pulitzer Prize in 1917 for

his reporting on Inside the German Empire, once said, It occurred to me that nothing is more

interesting than opinion when opinion is interesting, so I devised a method of cleaning off the

page opposite the editorial, which became the most important in America. And thereon I decided

to print opinions, ignoring facts."

And thats exactly what Swope did concerning the murder of Herman Rosenthal. Swopeknew the most sensational opinion to have was that a corrupt police lieutenant had ordered the

killing of Rosenthal. Swope, like Whitman, saw no career advantage in stating the truth, so he

tilted his reporting in a manner that would assure a guilty verdict for Becker.