component award 2014 - passivhausfenster · 1 lorber i pro phf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 price:...
TRANSCRIPT
Producers of certified passive house windows were invited to make an offer for the windows of a single family home.
41 windows took part in the catego-ries timber, timber-alu, alu and vinyl.
These offers were compared to each other and to a “standard window” according to German legal standard.
THE RESULT: Passive house windows are
profitable for building owners.
THE CHALLANGE
COMPONENT AWARD 2014
Photos: passivhaus-eco®
Hersteller zertifizierter Passivhaus-Fenster waren eingeladen, ein Ange-bot für die Fenster eines Einfamilien-hauses zu machen.
41 Fenster nahmen in den Katego-rien Holz, Holz-Alu, Alu und PVC teil.
Die Angebote wurden untereinander und mit einem “Standard-Fenster” nach EnEV verglichen.
DAS ERGEBNIS:Passivhaus-Fenster sind profitabel für Bauherren.
Living area: 155 m²Heating demand: 14 kWh/(m²a)PE-demand: 61 kWh/(m²a)Airtightness (n50): 0,2 1/hArchitects: passivhaus-eco
THE REFERENCE BUILDING
COMPONENT AWARD 2014
Photos: passivhaus-eco®
www.passivhausprojekte.de: ID 1200
THE WINNERS: Timber-Aluminum (18 participants)
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
1 Lorber I pro PHf.smartwin compact
45124%288
Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
1 Bieber I OPTIWINFUTURA
45022%246
2 Freisinger I OPTIWINAlu2Holz
45220%214
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
THE WINNERS: Timber-Aluminum (18 participants)
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
1 Lorber I pro PHf.smartwin compact
45124%288
Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
1 Bieber I OPTIWINFUTURA
45022%246
2 Freisinger I OPTIWINAlu2Holz
45220%214
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?
For a Passive House Window the Investment is a bit higher
LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?
Most important are the annual costs (investment+heating).
2% real interest rate means: effective and including inflation
LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?
My loan repayment is €90 more for my Passive House Window .
PHPP gives me the annual cost for heating energy.
Energy costs rise and rise
But there is a peak, because of more renewable energy.
Energy costs come from the energy balance
Without PHPP you just have „wild speculation“
Investment + energy = total amount
Passive House Windows save €160/yr.
Investment + energy = total amount
Passive House Windows save €160/yr.
What happens in 20 years when the loan is repaid?
We only have to pay the energy costs.
What happens in 20 years when the loan is repaid?
Now the Passive House Windows save €247/yr for the rest of
their life.
THE WINNERS: Timber (6 participants)
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
1 M SORANATURA OPTIMO XLT
38423%228
Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
1 Pfeffer FensterRPS39622%222
2 Freisinger I OPTIWINHolz2Holz
45213%201
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
THE WINNERS: Aluminum (3 participants)
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
1 RAICOFRAME 90 WI
49214%185
Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
1 PURALeco9054012%230
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
THE WINNERS: PVC (3 participants)
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
1 HilzingerVADB 550
22437%257
Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
SPECIAL PRIZES
Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]
Timber-GRP, dHPtDelta Plus cold climate
35327%225
Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)
Glazing, WiegandDWplus
54312%237
U-value, PazenENERsign arctis*
5998%276
Photo: passivhaus-eco®
Passive house windows are profitable for buildiung owners
RESULTS: Savings compared to reference
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33
Hilzinger VADB 550: 1st Prize PVC
dHPt Delta Plus: Special prize Timber-Glasfibre
Lorber I pro Passivhausfenster smartwin compact: 1st Prize Timber-Alu
M Sora NATURA OPTIMO XLT: 1st Prize Timber
Pfeffer Fenster RPS: 1st Prize Timber
Freisinger I OPTIWIN Holz2Holz: 2nd Prize Timber
Bieber I OPTIWIN Futura: 1st Prize Timber-Alu
Freisinger I OPTIWIN Alu2Holz: 2nd Prize Timber-Alu
RAICO FRAME 90 WI: 1st Prize Aluminium
Pural eco90: 1st Prize Aluminium
Wiegand DWplus: Special prize Glazing
Pazen ENERsign arctis*: Special prize lowest heat losses
Av. saving (life-cycle): 13% = 5000 €. Av. invest (inst. window): 490 €/m²
PVC Timber-Alu Timber Aluminium Special Prize
Passivhaus-Fenster sind profitabel für Bauherren
-100
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
PV
C R
efer
ence
VA
DB
550
+
Ti-A
l Ref
eren
ce
smar
twin
com
pact
FU
TU
RA
Alu
2Hol
z
Tim
ber
Ref
eren
ce
NA
TU
RA
OP
TIM
O X
LT
Pfe
ffer
RP
S
Hol
z2H
olz
Alu
min
um R
efer
ence
RA
ICO
Fra
me
90 W
I
Pur
al e
co90
€/m
² w
indo
w
Investment (installed window) Energy costs (life-cycle, present value)
PVC Timber-Aluminum Timber Aluminum
Investment and energy costs I Investitions- und EnergiekostenNo energy costs for passive house windows I Keine Energiekosten für Passivhausfenster
RESULTS: The winners
RESULTS: The winners – CO 2 savings
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
VA
DB
550
+
smar
twin
com
pact
FU
TU
RA
Alu
2Hol
z
NA
TU
RA
OP
TIM
O X
LT
Pfe
ffer
RP
S
Hol
z2H
olz
RA
ICO
Fra
me
90 W
I
Pur
al e
co90
kg C
O2-
eq/m
² w
indo
w
CO2-sayings rel. to ref. window [kg CO2-eq/m²window] (40a, natural gas)PVC
Timber-Aluminum Timber Aluminum
RESULTS: The winners – fuel savings
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
VA
DB
550
+
smar
twin
com
pact
FU
TU
RA
Alu
2Hol
z
NA
TU
RA
OP
TIM
O X
LT
Pfe
ffer
RP
S
Hol
z2H
olz
RA
ICO
Fra
me
90 W
I
Pur
al e
co90
oil s
avin
g [li
ter
per
m²
win
dow
] (lif
e cy
cle)
liter oil saving rel. to ref. window [l/m²window] (life cycle, 40a)PVCTimber-
Aluminum
Timber Aluminum