component award 2014 - passivhausfenster · 1 lorber i pro phf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 price:...

21
Producers of certified passive house windows were invited to make an offer for the windows of a single family home. 41 windows took part in the catego- ries timber, timber-alu, alu and vinyl. These offers were compared to each other and to a “standard window” according to German legal standard. THE RESULT: Passive house windows are profitable for building owners. THE CHALLANGE COMPONENT AWARD 2014 Photos: passivhaus-eco® Hersteller zertifizierter Passivhaus- Fenster waren eingeladen, ein Ange- bot für die Fenster eines Einfamilien- hauses zu machen. 41 Fenster nahmen in den Katego- rien Holz, Holz-Alu, Alu und PVC teil. Die Angebote wurden untereinander und mit einem “Standard-Fenster” nach EnEV verglichen. DAS ERGEBNIS: Passivhaus-Fenster sind profitabel für Bauherren.

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Producers of certified passive house windows were invited to make an offer for the windows of a single family home.

41 windows took part in the catego-ries timber, timber-alu, alu and vinyl.

These offers were compared to each other and to a “standard window” according to German legal standard.

THE RESULT: Passive house windows are

profitable for building owners.

THE CHALLANGE

COMPONENT AWARD 2014

Photos: passivhaus-eco®

Hersteller zertifizierter Passivhaus-Fenster waren eingeladen, ein Ange-bot für die Fenster eines Einfamilien-hauses zu machen.

41 Fenster nahmen in den Katego-rien Holz, Holz-Alu, Alu und PVC teil.

Die Angebote wurden untereinander und mit einem “Standard-Fenster” nach EnEV verglichen.

DAS ERGEBNIS:Passivhaus-Fenster sind profitabel für Bauherren.

Page 2: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Living area: 155 m²Heating demand: 14 kWh/(m²a)PE-demand: 61 kWh/(m²a)Airtightness (n50): 0,2 1/hArchitects: passivhaus-eco

THE REFERENCE BUILDING

COMPONENT AWARD 2014

Photos: passivhaus-eco®

www.passivhausprojekte.de: ID 1200

Page 3: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

THE WINNERS: Timber-Aluminum (18 participants)

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

1 Lorber I pro PHf.smartwin compact

45124%288

Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

1 Bieber I OPTIWINFUTURA

45022%246

2 Freisinger I OPTIWINAlu2Holz

45220%214

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 4: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

THE WINNERS: Timber-Aluminum (18 participants)

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

1 Lorber I pro PHf.smartwin compact

45124%288

Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

1 Bieber I OPTIWINFUTURA

45022%246

2 Freisinger I OPTIWINAlu2Holz

45220%214

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 5: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?

For a Passive House Window the Investment is a bit higher

Page 6: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?

Most important are the annual costs (investment+heating).

2% real interest rate means: effective and including inflation

Page 7: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

LCC savings [%]: What does it mean?

My loan repayment is €90 more for my Passive House Window .

PHPP gives me the annual cost for heating energy.

Page 8: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Energy costs rise and rise

But there is a peak, because of more renewable energy.

Page 9: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Energy costs come from the energy balance

Without PHPP you just have „wild speculation“

Page 10: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Investment + energy = total amount

Passive House Windows save €160/yr.

Page 11: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Investment + energy = total amount

Passive House Windows save €160/yr.

Page 12: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

What happens in 20 years when the loan is repaid?

We only have to pay the energy costs.

Page 13: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

What happens in 20 years when the loan is repaid?

Now the Passive House Windows save €247/yr for the rest of

their life.

Page 14: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

THE WINNERS: Timber (6 participants)

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

1 M SORANATURA OPTIMO XLT

38423%228

Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

1 Pfeffer FensterRPS39622%222

2 Freisinger I OPTIWINHolz2Holz

45213%201

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 15: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

THE WINNERS: Aluminum (3 participants)

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

1 RAICOFRAME 90 WI

49214%185

Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

1 PURALeco9054012%230

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 16: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

THE WINNERS: PVC (3 participants)

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

1 HilzingerVADB 550

22437%257

Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 17: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

SPECIAL PRIZES

Prize , CompanyProductPrice [€/m²inst.w]LCC savings [%]Oil savings [l]

Timber-GRP, dHPtDelta Plus cold climate

35327%225

Price: Investment costs for ref. building [€/m² inst. window incl. VAT]. Life-Cycle Cost savings: compared to ref. case [%]. Oil savings: per m² window compared to ref. window (life-cycle 40 a)

Glazing, WiegandDWplus

54312%237

U-value, PazenENERsign arctis*

5998%276

Photo: passivhaus-eco®

Page 18: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

Passive house windows are profitable for buildiung owners

RESULTS: Savings compared to reference

-15%

-10%

-5%

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33

Hilzinger VADB 550: 1st Prize PVC

dHPt Delta Plus: Special prize Timber-Glasfibre

Lorber I pro Passivhausfenster smartwin compact: 1st Prize Timber-Alu

M Sora NATURA OPTIMO XLT: 1st Prize Timber

Pfeffer Fenster RPS: 1st Prize Timber

Freisinger I OPTIWIN Holz2Holz: 2nd Prize Timber

Bieber I OPTIWIN Futura: 1st Prize Timber-Alu

Freisinger I OPTIWIN Alu2Holz: 2nd Prize Timber-Alu

RAICO FRAME 90 WI: 1st Prize Aluminium

Pural eco90: 1st Prize Aluminium

Wiegand DWplus: Special prize Glazing

Pazen ENERsign arctis*: Special prize lowest heat losses

Av. saving (life-cycle): 13% = 5000 €. Av. invest (inst. window): 490 €/m²

PVC Timber-Alu Timber Aluminium Special Prize

Passivhaus-Fenster sind profitabel für Bauherren

Page 19: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

PV

C R

efer

ence

VA

DB

550

+

Ti-A

l Ref

eren

ce

smar

twin

com

pact

FU

TU

RA

Alu

2Hol

z

Tim

ber

Ref

eren

ce

NA

TU

RA

OP

TIM

O X

LT

Pfe

ffer

RP

S

Hol

z2H

olz

Alu

min

um R

efer

ence

RA

ICO

Fra

me

90 W

I

Pur

al e

co90

€/m

² w

indo

w

Investment (installed window) Energy costs (life-cycle, present value)

PVC Timber-Aluminum Timber Aluminum

Investment and energy costs I Investitions- und EnergiekostenNo energy costs for passive house windows I Keine Energiekosten für Passivhausfenster

RESULTS: The winners

Page 20: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

RESULTS: The winners – CO 2 savings

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

VA

DB

550

+

smar

twin

com

pact

FU

TU

RA

Alu

2Hol

z

NA

TU

RA

OP

TIM

O X

LT

Pfe

ffer

RP

S

Hol

z2H

olz

RA

ICO

Fra

me

90 W

I

Pur

al e

co90

kg C

O2-

eq/m

² w

indo

w

CO2-sayings rel. to ref. window [kg CO2-eq/m²window] (40a, natural gas)PVC

Timber-Aluminum Timber Aluminum

Page 21: COMPONENT AWARD 2014 - Passivhausfenster · 1 Lorber I pro PHf. smartwin compact 451 24% 288 Price: Investment costs for reference building [€/m² ins. Window]. Life-Cycle Cost

RESULTS: The winners – fuel savings

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

VA

DB

550

+

smar

twin

com

pact

FU

TU

RA

Alu

2Hol

z

NA

TU

RA

OP

TIM

O X

LT

Pfe

ffer

RP

S

Hol

z2H

olz

RA

ICO

Fra

me

90 W

I

Pur

al e

co90

oil s

avin

g [li

ter

per

win

dow

] (lif

e cy

cle)

liter oil saving rel. to ref. window [l/m²window] (life cycle, 40a)PVCTimber-

Aluminum

Timber Aluminum