community perspectives on haze surrounding a protected...

26
Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected Area in South Sumatra, Indonesia Faculty of Forestry 2017 Lies Rahayu WF K. Fajar W Wahyu Tri Widayati Hatma Suryatmojo Muhammad Ali Imron

Upload: trinhnga

Post on 02-May-2019

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Community Perspectives on Haze

Surrounding a Protected Area in South Sumatra,

Indonesia

Faculty of Forestry2017

Lies Rahayu WFK. Fajar W

Wahyu Tri WidayatiHatma Suryatmojo

Muhammad Ali Imron

Page 2: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Forest fires, mainly in Indonesia’s peatlands have caused severe

environmental, economic, and,health problems. In 1997/1998, one of these fires burnt through

2,124,000 hectares of peatland and mangrove. (Tacconi, 2003).

Both Indonesia and the international community have paid a very high cost because of haze. For example, peat-fire have claimed many lives.(Butler, 2014).

In the most severe cases, more than 12 million Indoensians were

affected by haze, while outpatient attendance increased by 30% in

Singapore (Emmanuel, 2000).

Page 3: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

The world’s protected areas (PAs) provide multiple ecosystem services including biodiversity conservation and carbon sinks. Despite efforts to protect and manage these areas, forest fires still occur.

A local and longstanding tradition of fire management, and the regular

occurrence of haze disasters in the last two to three decades in

Indonesia, indicate a cultural shift in the local population towards using

fire for cultivation.

Therefore, it is necessary to gain insights how local people (surrounding a protected area ) perspective on the effect of haze into their livelihood and understanding how their local knowledge

and skills to manage fire as well as to find possible solutions.

Page 4: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

To explore the social, economic, environmental and health effect of hazeon the local communities

To find local knowledge and practices which have

the potential to encourage local communities to

adopt more sustainable land management

practices

To analyze the stakeholders’ roles and abilities in

reducing and controllinghaze’s effects

4

AIMS

Page 5: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Research Location

South Sumatera: Rambutan : Suka Pindahand Tanah Lembak VillageAir Kumbang District: Sebokor Village close to Padang SugihanWildlife Sanctuary.

During July 2017

5

METHODS

Page 6: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Case StudyQualitative

Quantitative

6

Communityperspectives

on haze’s effects

Local - knowledge and practices

-stakeholders’ roles in land and fire management

-housholds-interview

-FGD-literature

Page 7: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

7

research approaches & toolsResearch Method Case Study

Research Approach Quantitative Approach, Survey Method

Qualitative Approach

Focus of Study Community perspectives on haze’s effects

Local knowledge and practices and stakeholders’ roles in land and fire management

Population Two groups :Sebokor & Air Kumbang District

Target groups: key informants

Sampling Technique Cluster Random Sampling -

Unit of Analysis Households/ Family Stakeholders involved in land and fire management

Data Collection/Source of Evidences

Observation, interviews Observation, literature study, data documentation, and in-depth interviews

Research instrument Guided questionnaire s Guided Interviews

Data Analysis Quantitative Analysis (cross tabulation)

Reduction, presentation, & conclusion making

Page 8: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

RESULTS: Health Conditions

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com8

Age classes Sebokor Suka Pindahand Tanah

LembakChildren 223

(95,71%)206 (96,26%)

Adult 7 (3%) 7 (3,27%)Old People 3 (1,29%) 1 (0,47%)

Page 9: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com9

Policy

Page 10: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Economic Lost

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com10

Economic Loss

Sebokor Suka Pindahand Tanah

LembakYes 174

(74,68%)158 (73,83%)

No 59 (25,32%)

56 (26,17%)

Page 11: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Environmental Impact

a common annual phenomena

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com11

Page 12: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

12

Page 13: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

2. LOCAL KNOWLEDGE AND PRACTICES ONLAND MANAGEMENT

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com13

No. Local Knowledge Description

1 Rompokan - collecting litter and plants to be burned into severalparts (small clumps) and burned gradually.

- Fire were managed by landowner and neighbours untilcompletely extinguished

- fire will not spread to other surrounding land..

2 Pelarian - Land preparation cooperation between landownersand their relatives

- to clear the land

Page 14: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

14

Page 15: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

15

No. Local Knowledge Description

3 Backfire technique - To runs out of fuel near source of fires.

- between canals.

- The burning is carefully conducted and directed to theburning field (from the inside out).

- Fires are directed to the large flame (does not spread)

- Guarding for 2 x 24 hours to ensure no more firesignition and spreading to other land.

4 Parit Keliling - small trenches to prevent fire to spread to theirfarmland.

Page 16: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

16

phase 1

Clearance of the boundary

line

phase 2

Burning land to clear the

swamp grass

phase 3

Land clearing

phase 4

Direct rice seeding

phase 5

Harvesting

- Direct seeding of rice cultivation in peatland

- Limited on Suka Pindah(sites)

Page 17: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

3. The Role of Stakeholder to reduce and Control the Impact of Haze

17

coordinationcommand implementation

Page 18: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

18

Page 19: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Discussion

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com19

Impact of Haze on Education, Economic and Environment

Page 20: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

2. Local knowledge and Practices on Land Management

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com20

Page 21: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

3. The Role of Stakeholder to reduce and Control the Impact of Haze

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com21

Page 22: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

CONCLUSSION

The Power of PowerPoint | thepopp.com22

Page 23: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

CONCLUSSION

pre-disaster

23

Page 24: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

Terima Kasih

24

Camat Rambutan & Air KumbangKepala Desa: Suka Pindah, Tanah Lembak, Sebokor Village. Research team

Page 25: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

25

Page 26: Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected ...mucp-mfit.org/wp-content/uploads/1.-Presentasi-Laporan-Akhir... · Community Perspectives on Haze Surrounding a Protected

26

Research Method Case StudyResearch Approach Quantitative Approach, Survey

MethodQualitative Approach

Focus of Study Community perspectives on haze’s effects

Local knowledge and practices and stakeholders’ roles in land and fire management

Population Two groups :Sebokor & Air Kumbang District

Target groups: key informants

Sampling Technique Cluster Random Sampling -

Unit of Analysis Households/ Family Stakeholders involved in land and fire management

Data Collection/Source of Evidences

Observation, interviews Observation, literature study, data documentation, and in-depth interviews

Research instrument Guided questionnaire s Guided Interviews

Data Analysis Quantitative Analysis (cross tabulation)

Reduction, presentation, & conclusion making