community land trust fund 1 report
DESCRIPTION
Learnings from The Community Land Trust Social Investment FundTRANSCRIPT
COMMUNITY LAND
TRUST FUND I
What we’ve learned by supporting communities to
build their forever affordable homes
1
Registered Charity number 268369
Background
2
Registered Charity number 268369
Notes on reporting
1 Alongside the Fund, the Technical Assistance Fund was an important source of funding that supported CLTs.
It provided grants to fund the early stages of setting up a CLT. This fund was first managed by The Tudor Trust and then by the National CLT Network. It has since closed and been picked up by the CLT Start-up Fund, also managed by the National CLT Network.
3
Registered Charity number 268369
1) Key Findings
4
Registered Charity number 268369
5
Registered Charity number 268369
2) Introduction
2 Source: National CLT Network.
6
Registered Charity number 268369
funding the costs of construction
funding scheme specific costs to get
to planning permission
Pre-development Development
CLT Fund I
fund initial costs (technical assistance) and help scope a
project (feasibility)
Technical Assistance Fund (today the Start-up Fund, managed by the
National CLT Network)
7
Registered Charity number 268369
3) Detailed Findings
3 The second CLT Social Investment Fund charges a higher interest rate of 7.5% fixed to encourage other
funders to come in as second secured lenders. 4 The Fund supported 24 unique CLTs. At the close of the Fund in 2013, there were an estimated 110 CLTs. We
know that about half of CLTs are at an advanced stage (including advanced not yet on site, started on site, and completed a site). This means that c. 55 CLTs were at this advanced/past incorporation stage in 2013. Thus, the Fund supported c. 22% of CLTs and c. 44% of CLTs that were at an advanced stage. Source: the National CLT Network, CAF Venturesome. 5 Although the initial Fund size was £2.1m, the Fund managed to offer £3.2m because £1.1m was recycled.
6 Note: Some schemes were offered more than one loan.
8
Registered Charity number 268369
Were Fund Objectives Met?
7 This total does not include several schemes which were undrawn or were not granted planning permission.
Affordability
Homes are made affordable into perpetuity by the CLT to ensure that affordable housing is available to local people for generations to come. This can be done in several ways including through shared ownership/shared equity (where CLT retains a portion of the ownership) and resale price covenant (resale price has to be affordable to the new buyer). It can also be done through providing affordable rental homes where rents are defined based on local affordability criteria. A typical scheme supported by the Fund aimed to develop 9 affordable homes. To make affordability viable, some schemes develop open market homes to subsidise the construction costs while others partner up with housing associations which develop social housing.
9
Registered Charity number 268369
Leveraging additional capital
Lyvennet Community Trust needed £1.06 million development finance to build 12 affordable homes. Of this, they raised funding from several sources, including the Homes & Communities Agency (HCA), the local authority and a high street bank, but they needed to borrow an additional £300k. The Fund enabled the scheme to go forward by providing a secured loan for the remaining £300k (28% of the total), enabling 12 affordable homes to be built. All loans were repaid and the Fund leveraged in £760k of external finance.
10
Registered Charity number 268369
Fund activity
11
Registered Charity number 268369
What was the Fund’s financial performance?
8 One pre-development loan was offered to a CLT based in Wales but fell away as it did not need the funds.
12
Registered Charity number 268369
9 A success fee (if a pre-development loan) or interest rate income (if a development loan) is not included in
this figure here.
13
Registered Charity number 268369
10
The mean average development loan provided was £228k, indicating there were not significant outliers. 11
The mean average pre-development loans provided was £29k, indicating there were not significant outliers. 12
Five repaid in full; five repaid without drawing down; and one repaid after partially drawing down.
14
Registered Charity number 268369
What were the major challenges?
15
Registered Charity number 268369
16
Registered Charity number 268369
17
Registered Charity number 268369
13
Section 106 is a type of planning obligation where planning approval is granted subject to a restriction e.g, the number of homes being build, how affordable homes will be allocated, etc.
18
Registered Charity number 268369
19
Registered Charity number 268369
20
Registered Charity number 268369
14
Based on the survey, approximately 23% of schemes had a self-build or self-finish element ranging from light self-finish work such as painting walls to self-build schemes where homes are built entirely by the prospective residents.
21
Registered Charity number 268369
22
Registered Charity number 268369
4) What does the future hold for CLTs?
23
Registered Charity number 268369
5) Conclusion
24
Registered Charity number 268369
Appendix I: Community Land Trust – a technical
definition
o
o
o
o
o
25
Registered Charity number 268369
Appendix II: Acknowledgements
26
Registered Charity number 268369
Charities Aid Foundation (CAF) and CAF Venturesome