community engagement: a process of learning and …€¦ · learning and change critical questions...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Community Engagement: A Process of Learning and Change
Critical Questions For A Successful Engagement Outcome
March, 2009 Prepared for the CENTRAL LOCAL HEALTH INTEGRATION NETWORK
2
Canada s health care system is undergoing a transformation. Community engagement is a foundational tool in this effort towards sustainability. But there are challenges some of which include:
the need for a common and comprehensive language to describe our intentions around engagement,
the need to shift the prevailing perception of community engagement from one of power distribution to collaboration, and
the need to build capability in health service provider organizations to see engagement as a tool of community and organizational development.
A New Paradigm for Community Engagement
Assessing the Impacts of Public Participation: Concepts, Evidence and Policy Implications
» there is no empirical evidence that the current mechanisms to enhance citizen participation, accountability and responsiveness are likely to be effective.
From control and power to partnership and learning a new paradigm
3
Engagement a strategic conversationFrom control and power to partnership and learning a new paradigm
Arnstein, Sherry R. "A Ladder of Citizen Participation," JAIP, Vol. 35, No. 4, July 1969, pp. 216-224
Sharing information
Searching for
perspective together
Deci
ding
to
geth
er
Acting together
Supporting
people
Com
mitm
ent
Feed
back Engagement a
strategic conversation
with the community to
facilitate learning,
change and commitment
From To
4
Community Engagement Outcomes
1. To inform decision-making respecting engagement practices for Health Service Providers;
2. To create a common language that will facilitate strategic dialogue amongst provider communities;
3. To build community capability for collective and individual self-responsibility for healthcare; and
4. To contribute to the future sustainability of the health care system by creating more opportunities for engagement in health system transformation.
Project outcomes were developed from interviews with LHIN management and Task Group members
5
The Framework for Community EngagementTABLE OF CONTENTS
The engagement frameworkDefinition, principles and expected outcomes.
How to use this frameworkFour steps initiation to tools.
Dynamic engagement processesBegin with a readiness assessment.
Dynamic engagement practices.Guidelines for choosing a practice.
Tools, tips and techniquesThe best web sites.
Champions of engagementSupporting human systems interveners
Engagement a strategic conversation
with the community to facilitate learning,
change and commitment
This framework is a decision-making tool that health service providers (hospitals and community organizations) can employ in developing and executing community engagement programmes. The framework positions community engagement as a practice of learning and change. It suggests that difficult decisions can collaboratively be made when the community co-creates with each other and is guided by explicit processes that respect adult learning principles.
6
Definition of CommunityThroughout this framework community means
(a) patients and other individuals in the geographic area of the network,
(b) health service providers and any other person or entity that provides services in or for the local health system, and
(c) employees involved in the local health system.
Engagement Framework PrinciplesEngagement is about learning, change and commitment, not about power and control;
Engagement must always be associated with an outcome or commitment
Engagement, by its nature, is an interactive process
Engagement is a connective process that is focused on building a relationship with the community ;
Engagement is an adaptive, emerging process requiring organizational and leadership support
Community Engagement: definition and principles
7
The Framework for Community Engagement
Dynamic Engagement is a process that is directed by four psychological realities:
that engagement is an opportunity for learning and change by the community,
that people, the community, do not fear change, they fear the unknown
that any change or transition evokes a natural, emotional reaction, and
that people own what they help to create ,
Dynamic Engagement is an on-going strategic conversation
with the community that has the desired outcome of building
capability to contribute to the achievement of a sustainable
health care system.
8
Community Engagement Framework | INTRODUCTION
To move from the current state to a new state requires a creative mix of practices and processes over time.
PracticesIn shifting to a new paradigm, the framework includes a change in the traditional thinking of engagement as a linear practices to a more systems, connective and holistic view of engagement. These practices might be considered thewhat of engagement, the end goal.
Processes The processes reflect the how of engagement. They define over time a disciplined process that must each be competently and sequentially addressed for the engagement initiative to maintain a precarious balance on the engagement curve. The process is also interactive as additional understanding and awareness is developed.
A CURVE OF LEARNING AND CHANGE
The PracticesIn addition to the Initiation of the engagement initiative there are six (6) practices. Each practice represents a stance or goal that the sponsoring organization has initially taken with respect to the engagement initiative. Each practice is a legitimate end, however, the practice or stance may change as more information is revealed.
The ProcessesThe processes are structured along a curve of engagement. The process reflect three elements:1) change management experience, 2) a process consulting approach and 3) the questions associated with each process are built around the factors that are commonly seen in the development of an effective learning environment. The slope of the curve is important. Too steep a slope and you risk falling off the curve; too much dip and you risk compliance; too flat and complacency sets in.
Some definitions:
SponsorIndividual/group who legitimizes the engagement initiative and has the power to make it happen
Engagement agentIndividual/group who is responsible for implementing the engagement initiative .
What are the practices and processes involved ?
9
The Engagement Curve - A Curve of Learning & Change
Building Relationships
Sharing Information
Search for Perspective
Deciding Together
Acting Together
Supporting People
Commitment & Feedback
NEW STATE
CURRENT STATE
Readiness Assessment
Awareness of Need
Collaborative Contract
Understand the Change
Positive Perception
Testing and Modifying
Commit to Action
PROCESSES informed by focused questions
Initiation1
2
3
4
5
6
PRACTICES
TIME
LE
VE
L O
F C
OM
MIT
ME
NT
FO
R T
HE
CH
AN
GE
Adapted from ODR
Leading at the Edge of Chaos
10
How to use this framework
STEP ONE : INITIATION
Sponsoring Organizations must go through an INITIATION process to review of the scope of the engagement initiative. See COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT INITIATION
STEP TWO : DETERMINE ENGAGEMENT PRACTICE
Sponsoring Organizations must make a choice on the ENGAGEMENT PRACTICE they wish to initiate. See GUIDELINES FOR CHOOSING AND ENGAGEMENT PRACTICE
STEP THREE : EXECUTE ENGAGEMENT PROCESS
Sponsoring Organizations must address a series of questions for each ENGAGEMENT PROCESS to the extent of the engagement practice they have determined above. The Engagement Process questions can be supported by a variety of Tools and Techniques. Remind yourself of the definition of community and the practice of Engagement.
STEP FOUR : SELECT EFFECTIVE TOOLS
In the selection of tools, tips and techniques for community engagement, there are best practices that can be applied to comparable situations. However, all engagement is situational. The level of confidence and capacity in the engaged population is different; the environmental conditions which influence the population are different; the history of the system within which engagement is initiated is different. Examples of tools and techniques are provided
11
The Engagement Curve - an Overview
1. INITIATION is the point at which something triggers the need to engage the community , and you start to think what that involves. This will be largely influenced by the engagement requirement, strategic planning, HAPS, type of integration such as volunteer, facilitated or required and other considerations such as those associated with health equity issues, access, etc.
INITIATION
A. SHARING INFORMATION
B. SEARCH FOR PERSPECTIVE
C. DECIDING TOGETHER
D. ACTING TOGETHER
E. SUPPORTING PEOPLE
F. COMMITMENT AND FEEDBACK
DETERMINE PRACTICES
2. READINESS
3. BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE COMMUNITY
4. AWARENESS OF THE NEED FOR CHANGE
5. COLLABORATIVE CONTRACT
6. CREATING THE CHANGE REQUIRED
7. POSITIVE PERCEPTION OF THE AGREED TO CHANGE
8. TESTING AND MODIFYING THE CHANGE
9. COMMIT TO ACTION
EXECUTE PROCESSES
CU
RR
EN
TS
tate
NE
WS
tate
The operating phrase in the selection and application of tools is: it depends. There are literally hundreds of tools, tips and techniques that are relevant to community engagement; and because community is defined inclusively in the Act to include patients, the public, providers and employees, the range of tools increases dramatically. It does so because the scope of engagement, from sharing information to supporting people; and the broad nature of the community being engaged begins to move into the fields of community and organizational development.
SELECT TOOLS & TECHNIQUES
12
Community Engagement Curve | INITIATION
Initiation is the point at which something triggers the need to engage the community , and the sponsoring organization begins to think what that involves.
This will be largely influenced by the engagement requirement, strategic planning, HAPS, type of integration such as volunteer, facilitated or required and other considerations such as those associated with health equity issues, access, etc.
1. INITIATION
What does your organization want to achieve the desired outcomes ?
What does your organization want to preserve?
What does your organization want to avoid?
What is most important in this initiative?
What is most uncertain in this initiative?
Have you undertaken a stakeholder analysis to identify the community , key stakeholders and influencers? Who are the
principal stakeholders in the community ?
Do the stakeholders control, influence or give input to the initiative?
What are the perceived barriers to overcome?
What is the principle engagement practice or stance the sponsoring organization is taking in managing this engagement initiative? (See Guidelines for Choosing an Engagement Practice)
clarify the scope of the Engagement Initiative
Building Relationships
Sharing Information
Searching for Perspective
Readiness
Awareness of Need
PROCESSES
PRACTICESCURRENT STATE
Initiation
NB: A series of implementation questions have been developed for each process the following two slides are examples for the reader