commonwealth of kentucky before the public ... - … cases/2018-00157...commonwealth of kentucky...
TRANSCRIPT
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
Case No. 2018-00157 In the Matter of
CMN-RUS, INC. RECF!VFD
COMPLAINANT
v. SEP 0 7 2018
WINDSTREAM KENTUCKY EAST, INC. PUBLIC SEFz\!ICE
COMMISSiON RESPONDENT
WINDSTREAM KENTUCKY EAST, INC.'s SUPPLEMENTAL PETITION CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT OF RATES AND CONFIDENTIAL CONTRACTS
Comes the Defendant, Windstream Kentucky East, Inc. ("Windstream"), and for its
Supplemental Petition for Confidential Treatment of Confidential Contracts, hereby states as
follows:
Windstream previously filed its Motion for Confidential Treatment of Rates and
Confidential Contracts, pursuant to 807 KAR 5:001, Section 13, on August 27, 2018 requesting
the Commission to classify and protect as confidential certain information contained in Responses
to Requests No. 7 and 8 for Information from the Public Service Commission ("PSC''). As
required by 807 KAR 5:001, Section 13(2), Windstream provided one copy of the documents for
which it is requested confidential treatment, under s.eal, with the material for which confidential
treatment is requested highlighted (or in a case where Windstream is seeking confidential treatment
of whole documents, the entire, unredacted document was provided), and six copies of the
documents with the confidential material redacted.
In the course of providing to the PSC more than 7,000 documents with only two weeks to
respond, Windstream inadvertently disclosed one contract that contained a confidentiality clause
and should have been held confidential pursuant to KRS 61.878(1)(c), WIN1473-1507. Just as
with the contracts for which Windstream previously sought confidentiality, Windstream has
entered into this contract in a competitive field and gave the other party to the contract the
expectation that their terms would remain confidential. Further public disclosure of this contract
"would permit an unfair commercial advantage to competitors of the entity that disclosed the
records" pursuant to KRS 61.878(1)(c) . To protect its business and proprietary interests,
Windstream now seeks confidential treatment, for an indefinite period, of this contract.
Specifically, Windstream requests the PSC to enter an order that the original WIN1473-1507 be
removed from the public record and the attached redacted copies be substituted.
WHEREFORE, Windstream requests the PSC to grant its Supplemental Petition for
Confidential Treatment of Confidential Contracts.
Respectfully submitted,
CASEY . STANSBURY TIA J. COMBS MAZANEC, RASKIN & RYDER CO. , LPA 230 Lexington Green Circle, Suite 605 Lexington, KY 40503 (859) 899-8499 (859) 899-8498 - Fax [email protected] tcombs@rnrrlaw .com Counsel for Respondent, Windstream Kentucky East, Inc.
2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and accurate copy of the foregoing was served on September
6, 20 18 upon the following :
Katherine K. Yunker, Esq. McBrayer, McGinnis, Leslie & Kirkland, PLLC 201 East Main Street, Suite 900 Lexington, KY 40507 [email protected] Counsel for Complainant, CMN-RUS, Inc.
3
JutQ. ~ Counseffi;r Respondent, Windstream Kentucky East, Inc.
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
':W.IRELESS7AlfillAGHMEN:E<eOLE;Al':illAcJHMEN:E:;.£icENSE,A_(iitE~EMENtf0
:.!l¥i.ANQ:·.U,11!!fW~t~
··wiNDS11REAM'KEN!f;l:Jf)KY:;EAST:~~J:::;L<Z;
~~ij
NEW:CIN'Gl)LAR.\YJRELESSR(:S,;Lt:C
WIN1473
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
.SEC.TIQN ~~
:SECTION:J·
·sEpJ1QN'~f
SECTH:>N 5 ...,_ -~· t>
SECT10N6<
SEC.l'i01SI 7 .• ··.';--'•') f'
SEG'fJC>N8
·PA~TIES
·SGOPE,
TERM. AND TERMJN:ATION OF AGREEMENT ~ . . .·'~· .. ' , .. ~.- ~ .. '• ' ... .. . ~ ..
TERJ\.1Jb!ATIQN0FLiCElNSES
RA TES<FEES ANDXJHARGES ~ ·• '. -~--- . ' -· . :-" . u,. "·' l. • •.
Pi\YMEN'r;~SECURFrY: ,BDNDA1iJDbl.$N·
·Nn}A(i1BM!!NTREQJ)E.stA'N,o.tteENsE PR<D@Ess
,AU~rB0R:!TY'F0R]>.L;\OEtJENT ·qF ATJA¢tu\.1ENt
SEC'nd&:TfError!Refct_en~es.~~~~.t(~ll.9t;(9!J?d: . INTERFERENCE 'J,OF:_q:or! Rookmarkoo't defiiicil ..
-~Ecrt0~r.r2 Ma.oiEitAtieNs;.&rioirioNs; REPL.ActfV!E:&;ts AI'm -REARRANQEM.m{rs · · ·· · · · · · · · ·· · ·· ·
SECTION! 3 EME:RdE'NCY; R.Es;r'!§&AtlON
S:ECTIQ~ }4 FAILURE TO':PLACE,::ATTACHMENts - . . . < ~ . ~ .. . . •' .. ·. .
SECTl~N l:S; A!3ANPONMENT
SECTION l6: 1NSPEGJ~ON~. ANI.tJ1;:.,Y-ENTdRTES'
·s~CTIQl\l, (7 UNAUTHORiZED AT::PAGI-IM~Ji..rrs
SEGBON;:t8; iGO~PL,I~fl!CE \Y-I!\~~I,A.,\Y, AS·SU.rvtP'fiON 0E',~ISJ:<.: if\NP PISOL.NMER~0R. WARRANTJES.
'SEQTI01Cl9 · LJQENSEEG0~JR-4<:rf:q~:.QJ:jA,tif:idAtiO~S·
~sEc:noliiJ~Q r>Ef.AI.J4:f'
(SEO[ION';QiJ. ilNDEMNIFI(]J\:TIOJ\{.~Nb,~qiyirfA[i'ON 6f'::LfAI3IUTY
PAG}:
4
12
J3
:I.s
WIN1474
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
·sECtrol~1:'22: rNslfR;.\NCE :'sEtf.Io!Gt2-i -No:neEs:
SECTioNz2~ <::t:YNEIQENTIAtiJ:y
:s_ .E_c_· . .r.:.l®.N. 25 · · - · · ·· ·· · . DlSBUTE RE~()I.:.p]JQN
SEGTlg't$1:4,6 '(AJ(E$'.
SEC.i'10N:27 WAlMER
~E<:;Trqt~PJ N9.:tlirttbPARTYBENEFictARr~Ss·:
SECTI0N.29 FORGE ryif,JEIJRE
~~CTIQl)t.:W .ASSiGNMENT
SEGTIONlJ APPUQ};:B:I;£..~A VI/
SEC.TiQN;3:2~ WAIVER Q.F JUR¥ XRIA.L
'SEGTION;~.@ 'ENT1!¢:A'OREEMENT;·MODIFI{)~J'J'()f\JS,·Sl1RVIVAL CONFLieTS·ANDTAIUFFS . . . . . .. ~ . ,., '' ,., -
AJ'TACHJ]i).AND IJ'IlCORPOAA1'EDEXHIBITS
EXH!BIT:}\-~J:~EFINitioN:s
EX:fti:Bit::s- FORM APRhiCATION'~FoR POLELiCENSE ~ - - . - . ... . . . .. _.,. ·•"' ., . - . -
EXHIB{r·m -·NotiFiCArioN OF SU RRENDER.0F:ti(;EJ\ISE
-EXHIBIT D- S<SHEJ)V,.Lg:o}' R~TE$, :F"EES AND CHARGES
,EX:f:I):Bit E'~·No;tiGE CONTACTS 1\ND..ADDRJ~s-~ES,
WIN IU:Cvr:s·.2;1d'4 (Pbles:on~y)·.
2Q -~?-.
22
'23
:23·
24
24
WIN1475
DocuSign Envelope ID: 8482E1 89-27D0-486E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1476
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1477
DocuSign Envelope ID: 8482E1 89-27D0-486E-9F98-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1478
DocuSign Envelope 10: 8482E1 89-27D0-486E-9F98-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1479
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1480
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1481
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECUR!tEN'F72466449.0.2 26.-Jun-17 13:.55
WIN1482
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 !3:55
WIN1483
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61A 11 C85
WIN1484
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 -26-Jun-17 13:55
.WIN1485
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724fj64490.2 26-Jun-.1.7 13:55
WIN1486
DocuSign Envelope 10: 8482E1 B9-2700-486E-9F9B-FB5A61A 11 C85
AMECURIU::N"I" 724664490.2 26-J un-17 13:55
WIN1487
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 CBS
AMECUKRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1488
DocuSign Envelope 10: 8482E1 89-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1489
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1490
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-2700-4B6E-9F9B-FBSA61 A 11 C85
WIN1491
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
.AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1492
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1493
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1494
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1495
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
. AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jim-1 1-13:55
WIN1496
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN ILECvrs 2-·1.14 (poles'only)'
AMECURREN'F·724664490.2_26~Jun-17 13:55
Page 25 of3.5
WIN1497
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-2700-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN ILEC vrs 2.1.14 (Poles only) Page 26 of35
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1498
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61A11C85
WIN lLECvrs 2.1.14.(Po/es onlyi
AMECURRE!'\lT 72466449.0.226-Jun-17 13.:55'
WIN1499
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61A 11 C85
WIN1500
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A11 C85
WIN1501
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1502
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61A 11 C85
WIN ILEC vrs 2.1.14 (Poles only)
AMECURRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-1 7 13:55
Page 31 of35
WIN1503
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
AMEClJRRENT 724664490.2 26-Jun-17 13:55
WIN1504
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FBSA61 A 11 C85
WIN ILEC vrs 2.1.14 (Poles only)
AMECURRENT 724664490:2 26-Jun-17 13:55
Pag~ 33of35
WIN1505
DocuSign Envelope ID: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1506
DocuSign Envelope 10: 84B2E1 B9-27D0-4B6E-9F9B-FB5A61 A 11 C85
WIN1507