committee on budgetary control - european parliamentpv\1181779en.docx pe636.387v03-00 enunited in...

PV\1181779EN.docx PE636.387v03-00

EN United in diversity EN

European Parliament2014-2019

Committee on Budgetary Control

CONT_PV (2019)0220_1

MINUTESMeeting of 20 February 2019, 9.00 – 12.30 and 15.00 – 18.30

BRUSSELS

The meeting opened at 9.07 on Wednesday, 20 February 2019, with Ingeborg Gräßle (Chair) presiding.

1. Adoption of agenda

The draft agenda was adopted in the form shown in these minutes.

2. Chair’s announcements

The Chair drew the attention of Members to the information in the CONT News.

3. Discharge 2017: Presentation of the Council recommendations by the Romanian Council Presidency, Luminița Odobescu, AmbassadorCONT/8/15529

The following spoke: Inés Ayala Sender, Ingeborg Gräßle, Petri Sarvamaa, Luminita Odobescu, Romanian Ambassador.

*** Electronic vote ***

4. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European CommissionCONT/8/14083

2018/2166(DEC) COM(2018)0521[01] – C8-0318/2018

Rapporteur:Inés Ayala Sender (S&D) AM – PE634.491v01-00

Responsible:CONT

Opinions:AFET, DEVE, INTA, BUDG, ECON, EMPL, ENVI, ITRE, IMCO, TRAN, REGI, AGRI, PECH, CULT, JURI, LIBE, AFCO, FEMM, PETI

Adoption of draft report

PE636.387v03-00 2/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

The draft report was approved as amended by 20 votes in favour, 2 votes against and 0 abstention.

Amendments adopted: AM48, AM51+OA, AM55, AM56, AM57, AM 58, AM 59, AM64, AM67, AM 68; AM69, AM70, AM74+OA, AM75, AM81, AM82, AM85, AM86, AM87, AM89, AM90, AM91, AM97, AM98, AM99, AM107, AM108, AM109, AM110, AM111 first part, AM112, AM113, AM115, AM117, AM118, AM119, AM127, AM128, AM129+OA, AM148, AM152, AM154, AM155, AM158, AM160, AM162, AM165, AM171, AM172 first and third parts, AM174, AM176, AM177, AM178AM181, AM182 first and third parts, AM184, AM185, AM198, AM199, AM200, AM203, AM201, AM202+ OA, AM204, AM205+ OA, Am207, AM208, AM209, AM211, AM212, AM214, AM215, AM216, AM217, AM221, AM223, AM224, AM226, AM227, AM232, AM235, AM238, AM240, AM241, AM242, AM243, AM244, AM249, AM250, AM252, AM266, AM268, AM272, AM273, AM274, AM275, AM276, AFET4, DEVE1, DEVE2, DEVE3, DEVE4, DEVE5, DEVE6, DEVE7, DEVE10, DEVE12, DEVE13, DEVE14, DEVE17, DEVE19, EMPL3, EMPL6, EMPL7, EMPL8, EMPL9, EMPL12, ENVI4, ENVI5, ENVI6, ENVI7, ENVI8, ENVI10, ENVI11, ENVI16, ENVI17, TRAN3, TRAN5 first part, TRAN6 firts part, TRAN7, TRAN8, TRAN10, TRAN11, TRAN12, TRAN13, TRAN15, TRAN17, REGI10, AGRI5, AGRI6, AGRI7, AGRI8, AGRI9, AGRI10, AGRI13, AGRI14, PECH3, PECH7, CULT1, CULT2, CULT4, CULT5, CULT8, CULT9, CULT11, CULT12, CULT13, FEMM1, FEMM2, FEMM3, FEMM4

Amendments rejected: AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM1, AM2, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM7, AM12, AM13, AM14, AM11, AM16, AM17, AM18, AM15, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM19, AM23, AM24, AM26, AM27, AM28, AM25, AM31, AM29, AM30, AM44, AM45, AM46, AM50, AM52, AM54, AM76, AM77, AM78, AM79, AM84, AM111 second part, AM122, AM123, AM125, AM156, AM157, AM161, AM164, AM169, AM170, AM172 second part, AM173, AM175, AM182 second part, AM183, AM189, AM194, AM210, AM213, AM225, AM228, AM230, AM239, AM245, AM258, AM271, AM32, DEVE8, DEVE9, DEVE11, DEVE15, DEVE16, DEVE18, EMPL1, ENVI1, ENVI2, ENVI3, ENVI9, ENVI12, ENVI13, ENVI14, ENVI15, TRAN4, TRAN5 second part, TRAN6 second part, TRAN9, TRAN14, TRAN16, AGRI2, AGRI3, AGRI15, AGRI16, AGRI17, AGRI18; PECH6, CULT3, CULT6, CULT7, CULT10, CULT14, CULT15, CULT16, CULT17FEMM5, FEMM6, FEMM7, FEMM8, FEMM9, FEMM10, FEMM11, FEMM12

Amendments fallen: AM38, AM39, AM40, AM43, LIBE1, EMPL2, TRAN1, TRAN2, AM42, AM236, AM47, AM126, AFET1, LIBE2, AM61, AM62, AM63, AM65, AM66, REGI5, REGI6, AM93, AM94, AM95, REGI4, AM71, AM72, AM73, AM167, AM168, AM120, AM124, AM121, AM179, AM180, AFET5, AM233, AM234, AM88, AM254(d), AM96, AM102, AM254(c), AM35, AM254(b), AM159, AM122, AM114, AM219, AM220, AM254(a), AM150, AM153, AM151, AM247, AM248, AM36, AM37, AM41, AM246, AM253, AM255, AM256, AM257, AM49, AM151, AM163, AM103, AM145, AM100, AM101, AM92, AM138, AM139, AM130, AM131, AM132, AM133, AM134, AM135, AM136, AM137, AM261, AM262, AM263, AM264, AM267, AM269, AM270, AM259, AM260, AM265, AM140, AM141, AM142, AM143, AM144, AM145, AM146, AM116, AM104, AM105, AM106, AM218, AM53, AM229, AM231, AM34, AM186, AM187, AM188, AM189 first part, AM190, AM191, AM192, AM193, AM195, AM196, AM197, AM206

Amendments withdrawn:

PV\1181779EN.docx 3/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments AM38, AM39, AM40, Compromise 2 replacing amendments AM38, AM43, LIBE1, EMPL2, TRAN1, TRAN2, Compromise 3 replacing amendments AM42, AM236, AM47, AM126, AFET1, LIBE2, Compromise 4 replacing amendments AM61, AM62, AM63, Compromise 5 replacing amendments AM65, AM66, REGI5, REGI6, Compromise 6 replacing amendments AM93, AM94, AM95, REGI4, Compromise 7 replacing amendments AM71, AM72, AM73, AM167, AM168, Compromise 8 replacing amendments AM120, AM124, AM121, Compromise 9 replacing amendments AM179, AM180, AFET5, Compromise 10 replacing amendments AM233, AM234, Compromise 11 replacing amendments AM88, AM254(d), AM96, AM102, Compromise 12 replacing amendments AM254(c), AM35, Compromise 13 replacing amendments AM254(b), AM35, AM159, AM122, Compromise 14 replacing amendments AM114, AM219, AM220, Compromise 15 replacing amendments AM254(a), AM35, AM150, AM153, Compromise 16 replacing amendments AM151, AM247, AM248, Compromise 17 replacing amendments AM35, AM36, AM37, AM41, AM246, AM253, AM255, AM256, AM257, Compromise 18 replacing amendments AM49, AM151, AM163, Compromise 19 replacing amendments AM103, AM145, AM100, AM101, Compromise 20 replacing amendments AM92, AM138, AM139, Compromise 21 replacing amendments AM130, AM131, AM132, AM133, AM134, AM135, AM136, AM137, AM261, AM262, AM263, AM264, AM267, AM269, AM270, Compromise 22 replacing amendments AM259, AM260, AM265, Compromise 23 replacing amendments AM100, AM101, AM140, AM141, AM142, AM143, AM144, AM145, AM146, AM116, Compromise 24 replacing amendments AM104, AM105, AM106, AM218, Compromise 25 replacing amendments AM53, AM229, AM231, Compromise 26 replacing amendments AM34, Compromise 27 replacing amendments AM186, AM187, AM188, AM189 first part, AM190, AM191, AM192, AM193, AM195, AM196, AM197

The following amendments were covered: AFET 2, AFET3, AFET6, AFET7, DEVE20, EMPL4, EMPL5, ENVI18, TRAN18, REGI1, REGI2, REGI3, REGI6, REGI8, REGI9, AGRI1AGRI4, AGRI11, AGRI12, PECH1, PECH2, PECH4, PECH5, PECH8, LIBE5, LIBE5

Technical amendments, no vote: AM33, AM60, AM80, AM83, AM147, AM166, AM237

5. Discharge 2017: Court of Auditors' special reportsCONT/8/14385

2018/2219(DEC) COM(2018)0521[52] – C8-0370/2018

Rapporteur:Inés Ayala Sender (S&D) AM – PE634.626v02-00

Responsible:CONT



Amendments adopted: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM7, AM9, AM10, AM13, AM17, AM18, AM24, AM31, AM32, AM37+OA, AM38, AM49, AM50, AM51, AM55, AM56, AM57+

PE636.387v03-00 4/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

OA

Amendments rejected: AM6, AM8, AM12, AM14, AM15, AM16, AM19, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM23, AM25, AM26, AM27, AM28, AM29, AM30, AM33, AM34, AM35, AM36, AM39, AM40, AM41, AM42, AM43, AM44, AM45, AM46, AM47, AM48, AM52, AM53, AM54, AM1

Technical amendments, no vote: AM11

6. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European ParliamentCONT/8/14103

2018/2167(DEC) COM(2018)0521[02] – C8-0319/2018

Rapporteur:Claudia Schmidt (PPE) AM – PE634.457v02-00

Responsible:CONT




Amendments adopted: AM5, AM13, AM17, AM21, AM22, AM23, AM25, AM26, ZM28, AM29, AM31, AM37, AM39, AM42 part 1, AM48, AM49, AM52, AM54, AM56, AM57, AM59, ZM62, ZM64, AM65, AM70, AM71 first part, AM73, AM75, AM76, AM77, AM78, AM79, AM80, AM82, AM89, AM90, AM91, AM92, AM93, AM94, AM95, AM96, AM97, AM98, AM99, AM100, AM101, AM102, AM103, AM104, AM107, AM108, AM109, AM110, AM111, AM112, AM114, AM115, AM116, AM117, AM119, AM120, AM121, AM122, AM127, AM129, AM131, AM132, AM133, AM134, AM167, AM168 first part, AM169, AM176, AM177, AM178, AM179, AM180, AM181, AM182, AM184, AM185, AM188, AM192

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM3, AM4, AM6, AM10, AM16, AM24AM32, AM33, AM38, AM41, AM42 part 2, AM50, AM51, AM53, AM55, AM58, AM61, AM63, AM71 second part, AM72, AM81, AM88, AM105, AM106, AM113, AM118, AM123, AM124, AM125, AM126, AM141, AM142, AM144, AM145, AM147, AM148, AM166, AM157, AM168 second part, AM170, AM171, AM172, AM173, AM174, AM175, AM183, AM186, AM187, AM189, AM191, AM193, AM194, AM195, AM196

Amendments fallen: AM7, AM8, AM9, AM8, AM11, AM12, AM14, AM15, AM18, AM19, AM20, AM27, AM34, AM35, AM36, AM40, AM43, AM44, AM45, AM46, AM47, AM60, AM66, AM67, AM68, AM69, AM74, AM83, AM84, AM85, AM86, AM87, AM128, AM130, AM135, AM136, AM137, AM138, AM139, AM140, AM146, AM149, AM150, AM151, AM152, AM153, AM154, AM155, AM156, AM157, AM158, AM159, AM160, AM161, AM162, AM163, AM164, AM165

PV\1181779EN.docx 5/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments AM7, AM8, AM9, Compromise 2 replacing amendments AM11, AM12, Compromise 3 replacing amendments AM14, AM15, Compromise 4 replacing amendments AM19, AM20, Compromise 5 replacing amendments AM34, AM35, AM36, AM40, AM43, Compromise 6 replacing amendments AM44, AM45, AM46, AM47, Compromise 7 replacing amendments AM83, AM84, AM85, AM86, Compromise 8 replacing amendments AM135, AM136, AM137, AM138, AM139, AM140, AM146, Compromise 9 replacing amendments AM149, AM150, AM151, AM152, AM153, AM154, AM156, AM158, AM159, AM160, AM161, AM162, AM163, AM164, AM165

No vote (inadmissible): AM2

7. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - 8th, 9th, 10th and 11th EDFsCONT/8/14268

2018/2177(DEC) COM(2018)0519 – C8-0328/2018

Rapporteur:Marco Valli (EFDD) AM – PE634.541v02-00

Responsible:CONT

Opinions:DEVE, BUDG



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM5, AM10, AM13, AM14, AM15, AM16, AM17, AM18, AM19, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM23, AM24, DEVE3, DEVE4, DEVE5, DEVE6, DEVE7, DEVE8, DEVE9, DEVE10, DEVE12, DEVE13, DEVE15, DEVE16, DEVE17, DEVE18, DEVE19, DEVE20, DEVE21, DEVE22, DEVE23, DEVE24, DEVE25, DEVE26

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM6,

Amendments fallen: AM8, AM9, AM11, AM12

Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments AM8, AM9, Compromise 2 replacing amendments AM11, AM12

The following amendments were covered: DEVE1, DEVE2, DEVE11, DEVE14

No vote: AM4

*** End of electronic vote ***

20 February 2019, 15.00 – 18.30

*** Electronic vote ***

PE636.387v03-00 6/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

Discharge 2017: Other Institutions

8. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European External Action ServiceCONT/8/14263

2018/2176(DEC) COM(2018)0521[10] – C8-0327/2018

Rapporteur:Arndt Kohn (S&D) AM – PE634.539v02-00

Responsible:CONT

Opinions:AFET, DEVE, INTA, AFCO



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM7, AM11, AM12, AM13, AM14, AM15, AM16, AM19, AM20+ OA, AM21, AFET1, AFET2, AFET4

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM2, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM18, AM22, AM23, AM24

Amendments fallen: AM17

The following amendments were covered: AFET3

9. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Council and European CouncilCONT/8/14123

2018/2168(DEC) COM(2018)0521[03] – C8-0320/2018


Responsible:CONT



The draft report was approved as amended by 19 votes in favour, 0 votes against and 0 abstentions.

The vote in committee was inverted due to a technical error of a misleading voting instruction, the result of the final vote is 19 votes in favour to postpone the discharge of the Council and the European Council.

Amendments adopted: AM1, AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM11, AM12, AM13, AM14, AM16

PV\1181779EN.docx 7/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Amendments rejected: AM6, AM7, AM15

10. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Court of AuditorsCONT/8/14163

2018/2171(DEC) COM(2018)0521[05] – C8-0322/2018


Responsible:CONT




Amendments adopted: AM1, AM7, AM8, AM10, AM11, AM12, AM16, AM17, AM18, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM23, AM24, AM30, AM31, AM32, AM33AM37, AM38

Amendments rejected: AM5, AM6, AM14, AM15, AM19,

Amendments fallen: AM2, AM4, AM9, AM13, AM25, AM26, AM27, AM28, AM29, AM34, AM35; AM36

Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments AM9, Compromise 2 replacing amendments AM13, Compromise 3 replacing amendments AM25, AM26, AM27, Compromise 4 replacing amendments AM28, AM29, Compromise 4 replacing amendments AM34, AM35; AM36

11. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Court of JusticeCONT/8/14147

2018/2169(DEC) COM(2018)0521[04] – C8-0321/2018


Responsible:CONT




PE636.387v03-00 8/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

Amendments adopted: AM1, AM9, AM11, AM15, AM16, AM26, AM27, JURI2, JURI4, JURI8, JURI9, JURI13, JURI14, JURI15

Amendments rejected: AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM10, AM12, AM13, AM17, AM18, AM19, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM23, AM24, AM25, AM28

Amendments fallen: AM2, AM3, AM14

The following amendments were covered: JURI1, JURI3, JURI5, JURI6, JURI7, JURI10, JURI11, JURI12JURI16, JURI17

12. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Economic and Social CommitteeCONT/8/14183

2018/2172(DEC) COM(2018)0521[06] – C8-0323/2018


Responsible:CONT




Amendments adopted: AM1, AM14, AM15, AM16, AM18, AM19, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM24

Amendments rejected: AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM11, AM12, AM13, AM17, AM23

Amendments fallen: AM2, AM3

13. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Committee of the RegionsCONT/8/14203

2018/2173(DEC) COM(2018)0521[07] – C8-0324/2018


Responsible:CONT



PV\1181779EN.docx 9/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN


Amendments adopted: AM1, AM10, AM11, AM14, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM25, AM26, AM27, AM28, AM29

Amendments rejected: AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM12, AM13, AM15, AM16, AM17, AM18, AM19, AM24, AM28 part 2

Amendments fallen: AM2, AM3, AM23

14. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European OmbudsmanCONT/8/14223

2018/2174(DEC) COM(2018)0521[08] – C8-0325/2018


Responsible:CONT



The draft report was approved as amended by 20 votes in favour, 0 vote against and 2 abstentions.

Amendments adopted: AM1, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM11, AM12, AM13, AM14

Amendments rejected: AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM10

Amendments fallen: AM2

15. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Data Protection SupervisorCONT/8/14243

2018/2175(DEC) COM(2018)0521[09] – C8-0326/2018


Responsible:CONT



PE636.387v03-00 10/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN


Amendments adopted: AM1, AM4, AM7, LIBE2

Amendments rejected: AM5, AM6,

The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE3, LIBE4

Discharge 2017: Agencies

16. Discharge 2017: Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the agencies of the European Union for the financial year 2017: performance, financial management and controlCONT/8/14341

2018/2210(DEC) COM(2018)0521[43] – C8-0361/2018

Rapporteur:Petri Sarvamaa (PPE) AM – PE634.521v01-00

Responsible:CONT



The draft report was approved as amended by 21 votes in favour, 0 vote against and 0 abstention.

Amendments adopted: AM2, AM3, AM4 parts 1 and 3, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM11, AM14, AM15, AM16 part 1, AM17, AM18, AM22, AM24, EMPL1, EMPL4Amendments rejected: AM1, AM4 part 2, AM5, AM12, AM13, AM16 part 2, AM19, AM20, AM21, AM23The following amendments were covered: EMPL2, EMPL3, EMPL5, EMPL6, EMPL7, EMPL8, EMPL9, LIBE1, LIBE2, LIBE3, LIBE4, LIBE5, LIBE7

17. Discharge 2017: Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER)CONT/8/14330

2018/2205(DEC) COM(2018)0521[38] – C8-0356/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE


The draft report was approved as amended by 20 votes in favour, 1 vote against and 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 11/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

abstention.

Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM8, AM9Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM7, AM10, AM11, AM12No vote (inadmissible): AM1

18. Discharge 2017: Office of the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC)CONT/8/14332

2018/2206(DEC) COM(2018)0521[39] – C8-0357/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE, IMCO



Amendments adopted: AM4, AM5, AM7Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM6, AM8, AM9No vote (inadmissible): AM1

19. Discharge 2017: Translation Centre for the Bodies of the European Union (CdT)CONT/8/14285

2018/2184(DEC) COM(2018)0521[17] – C8-0335/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:CULT



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM5, AM7, CULT1, CULT2, CULT3, CULT4, CULT5, CULT6Amendments rejected: AM2, AM4, AM6, AM8, CULT7No vote (inadmissible): AM1

20. Discharge 2017: European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (Cedefop)

PE636.387v03-00 12/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

CONT/8/142712018/2178(DEC) COM(2018)0521[11] – C8-0329/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:EMPL, ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM10, AM12, EMPL3, EMPL4, EMPL6, EMPL7, EMPL10, EMPL11Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM11, AM13, The following amendments were covered: EMPL1, EMPL2, EMPL5, EML8, EMPL9, EMPL12No vote (inadmissible): AM1

21. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Training (CEPOL)CONT/8/14305

2018/2194(DEC) COM(2018)0521[27] – C8-0345/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE


The draft report was approved as amended by 21 votes in favour, 0 vote against and 0 abstention.Amendments adopted: AM5, LIBE2, LIBE4, LIBE6, LIBE7, LIBE8Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM6, AM7The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE3, LIBE5

22. Discharge 2017: European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA)CONT/8/14295

2018/2189(DEC) COM(2018)0521[22] – C8-0340/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:

PV\1181779EN.docx 13/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

TRAN Adoption of draft report

The draft report was approved as amended by 20 vote in favour, 1 votes against and 0 abstention.

Amendments adopted: AM4, AM8, AM11, AM12, TRAN5, TRAN9, TRAN10, TRAN11, TRAN12, TRAN13Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM6, AM7, AM9, AM10, AM13, TRAN7, TRAN8Amendments fallen: AM5, AM14, AM15, TRAN3Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments AM14, AM15, TRAN3The following amendments were covered: TRAN1, TRAN2, TRAN4, TRAN6, TRAN14No vote (inadmissible): AM1

23. Discharge 2017: European Asylum Support Office (EASO)CONT/8/14337

2018/2208(DEC) COM(2018)0521[41] – C8-0359/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE



Amendments adopted: AM1, AM2, AM3+OA, AM4, AM5+ OA, AM6, AM7, AM10, AM11, AM12, AM14+ OA, AM15, AM16, LIBE2, LIBE5Amendments rejected: AM8, AM9, LIBE7Amendments fallen: AM13The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE3, LIBE4, LIBE6

24. Discharge 2017: European Banking Authority (EBA)CONT/8/14323

2018/2202(DEC) COM(2018)0521[35] – C8-0353/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ECON


PE636.387v03-00 14/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN


Amendments adopted: AM5, AM9, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM9, AM10, ECON11Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM10The following amendments were covered: ECON1, ECON2, ECON8, ECON9, ECON12No vote (inadmissible): AM1

25. Discharge 2017: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC)CONT/8/14299

2018/2191(DEC) COM(2018)0521[24] – C8-0342/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI



Amendments adopted: ENVI3, ENVI4, ENVI5, ENVI6, ENVI8Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5The following amendments were covered: ENVI1, ENVI2ENVI7, ENVI9, ENVI10, ENVI11No vote (inadmissible): AM1

26. Discharge 2017: European Chemicals Agency (ECHA)CONT/8/14314

2018/2198(DEC) COM(2018)0521[31] – C8-0349/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM4, AM8AM9, ENVI1, ENVI7, ENVI9Amendments rejected: AM2, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM10, ENVI2, ENVI10The following amendments were covered: ENVI3, ENVI4, ENVI5, ENVI6, ENVI8, ENVI11, ENVI12, ENVI13No vote (inadmissible): AM1

PV\1181779EN.docx 15/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

27. Discharge 2017: European Environment Agency (EEA)CONT/8/14281

2018/2182(DEC) COM(2018)0521[15] – C8-0333/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI



Amendments adopted: AM4, AM5, ENVI3, ENVI4, ENVI7Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM6, The following amendments were covered: ENVI1, ENVI2, ENVI5, ENVI6, ENVI8, ENVI9No vote (inadmissible): AM1

28. Discharge 2017: European Fisheries Control Agency (EFCA)CONT/8/14312

2018/2197(DEC) COM(2018)0521[30] – C8-0348/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:PECH



Amendments adopted: PECH6, PECH7, PECH8, PECH9, PECH13Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, PECH10, PECH11, PECH12; PECH14The following amendments were covered: PECH1, PECH2, PECH3, PECH4, PECH5No vote (inadmissible): AM1

29. Discharge 2017: European Food Safety Authority (EFSA)CONT/8/14297

2018/2190(DEC) COM(2018)0521[23] – C8-0341/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:

PE636.387v03-00 16/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

ENVI Adoption of draft report


Amendments adopted: AM3, AM6, AM7, ENVI3, ENVI4, ENVI6, ENVI7, ENVI9, ENVI10, ENVI11Amendments rejected: AM2, AM4, AM5, AM8The following amendments were covered: ENVI1, ENVI2, ENVI5, ENVI8, ENVI12, ENVI13, ENVI14No vote (inadmissible): AM1

30. Discharge 2017: European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE)CONT/8/14321

2018/2201(DEC) COM(2018)0521[34] – C8-0352/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:FEMM



Amendments adopted: AM7, AM9, AM11, AM14, FEMM1, FEMM2, FEMM3, FEMM4, FEMM5, FEMM7, FEMM9, FEMM12Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM8, AM10, AM12, AM13, AM15, FEMM6, FEMM8, FEMM10, FEMM11The following amendments were covered: FEMMA, FEMMB, FEMM13, FEMM14; FEMM15, FEMM16No vote (inadmissible): AM1

31. Discharge 2017: European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA)CONT/8/14325

2018/2203(DEC) COM(2018)0521[36] – C8-0354/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ECON, EMPL


PV\1181779EN.docx 17/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN


Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM7, ECON1, ECON2, ECON3, ECON4, ECON5, ECON6, ECON7, ECON9, ECON10Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM8, AM9, AM10The following amendments were covered: ECON8, ECON11No vote (inadmissible): AM1

32. Discharge 2017: European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT)CONT/8/14335

2018/2207(DEC) COM(2018)0521[40] – C8-0358/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM4, AM5, AM10, AM11, AM13Amendments rejected: AM1, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM12, AM14, AM15, AM16No vote (inadmissible): AM2

33. Discharge 2017: European Medicines Agency (EMA)CONT/8/14287

2018/2185(DEC) COM(2018)0521[18] – C8-0336/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM4, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM11, AM12, ENVI5, ENVI6, ENVI7, ENVI9, ENVI11Amendments rejected: AM2, AM5, AM6, The following amendments were covered: ENVI1, ENVI2, ENVI3, ENVI4, ENVI8, ENVI10,

PE636.387v03-00 18/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

ENVI12, ENVI13, ENVI14No vote (inadmissible): AM1

34. Discharge 2017: European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA)CONT/8/14278

2018/2181(DEC) COM(2018)0521[14] – C8-0332/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI, LIBE



Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE2, LIBE3, LIBE4, LIBE5No vote (inadmissible): AM1

35. Discharge 2017: European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA)CONT/8/14293

2018/2188(DEC) COM(2018)0521[21] – C8-0339/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:TRAN



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, TRAN4, TRAN5, TRAN7, TRAN8, TRAN9, TRAN10, TRAN13Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM10, TRAN14The following amendments were covered: TRAN1, TRAN2, TRAN3, TRAN6, TRAN11, TRAN12, TRAN15, TRAN16No vote (inadmissible): AM1

36. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Network and Information Security (ENISA)

PV\1181779EN.docx 19/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

CONT/8/143012018/2192(DEC) COM(2018)0521[25] – C8-0343/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM7, AM8, AM12Amendments rejected: AM2, AM4, AM6, AM9, AM10, AM11, AM13, AM14No vote (inadmissible): AM1, AM3

37. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Railways (ERA)CONT/8/14303

2018/2193(DEC) COM(2018)0521[26] – C8-0344/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:TRAN



Amendments adopted: TRAN2, TRAN3, TRAN4, TRAN5, TRAN7, TRAN8, TRAN9, TRAN10Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8Amendments fallen: TRAN11Compromise amendments adopted: Compromise 1 replacing amendments TRAN11, The following amendments were covered: TRAN1, TRAN6, TRAN12, TRAN13, TRAN15No vote (inadmissible): AM1

38. Discharge 2017: European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA)CONT/8/14328

2018/2204(DEC) COM(2018)0521[37] – C8-0355/2018


Responsible:CONT

PE636.387v03-00 20/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

Opinions:ECON



Amendments adopted: AM4, ECON2, ECON3, ECON4, ECON5, ECON6, ECON7, ECON8, ECON9, ECON11, ECON12Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM5, AM6, AM7, ECON1The following amendments were covered: ECON10, ECON13No vote (inadmissible): AM1

39. Discharge 2017: European Training Foundation (ETF)CONT/8/14291

2018/2187(DEC) COM(2018)0521[20] – C8-0338/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:EMPL



Amendments adopted: EMPL2, EMPL3, EMPL6, EMPL9, EMPL10, EMPL11Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4,The following amendments were covered: EMPL1, EMPL4, EMPL5, EMPL7, EMPL8No vote (inadmissible): AM1

40. Discharge 2017: European Agency for the operational management of large-scale IT systems in the area of freedom, security and justice (eu-Lisa)CONT/8/14339

2018/2209(DEC) COM(2018)0521[42] – C8-0360/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE


The draft report was approved as amended by xx votes in favour, xx votes against and xx

PV\1181779EN.docx 21/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

abstentions.

Amendments adopted: AM4, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM11, AM13, AM14, AM17, AM18, AM20, AM21, AM22, AM24, LIBE3, LIBE4Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM5, AM6, AM12, AM15, AM16, AM23Amendments fallen: AM10, AM19The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE2, LIBE5, LIBE6, LIBE7No vote (inadmissible): AM1

41. Discharge 2017: European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA)CONT/8/14283

2018/2183(DEC) COM(2018)0521[16] – C8-0334/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:EMPL



Amendments adopted: AM5, EMPL2, EMPL3, EMPL4, EMPL9, EMPL10, EMPL11, EMPL12Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, EMPL6The following amendments were covered: EMPL1, EMPL5, EMPL7, EMPL8, EMPL13No vote (inadmissible): AM1

42. Discharge 2017: Euratom Supply Agency (ESA)CONT/8/14316

2018/2199(DEC) COM(2018)0521[32] – C8-0350/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3No vote (inadmissible): AM1

PE636.387v03-00 22/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

43. Discharge 2017: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions (EUROFOUND)CONT/8/14274

2018/2179(DEC) COM(2018)0521[12] – C8-0330/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:EMPL



Amendments adopted: EMPPL2, EMPL4Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, EMPL9, EMPL10The following amendments were covered: EMPL1, EMPL5, EMPL6, EMPL7, EMPL8, EMPL11No vote (inadmissible): AM1

44. Discharge 2017: European Union Judicial Cooperation Unit (Eurojust)CONT/8/14289

2018/2186(DEC) COM(2018)0521[19] – C8-0337/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM10 first part, LIBE2, LIBE4, LIBE5Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM7, AM8, AM10 second partThe following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE3No vote (inadmissible): AM1

45. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation (Europol)CONT/8/14318

2018/2200(DEC) COM(2018)0521[33] – C8-0351/2018


PV\1181779EN.docx 23/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM5, AM6AM8, AM9, AM11, AM14, AM17, AM18, LIBE3, LIBE4Amendments rejected: AM2, AM4, AM7, AM13, AM15, LIBE2Amendments fallen: AM10, AM12The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE5, LIBE6No vote (inadmissible): AM1

46. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA)CONT/8/14276

2018/2180(DEC) COM(2018)0521[13] – C8-0331/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:LIBE



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, LIBE5, LIBE6, LIBE7, LIBE8, LIBE10Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4, AM7, AM8, LIBE9The following amendments were covered: LIBE1, LIBE2, LIE4No vote (inadmissible): AM1

47. Discharge 2017: European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex)CONT/8/14307

2018/2195(DEC) COM(2018)0521[28] – C8-0346/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:AFET, LIBE


PE636.387v03-00 24/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN


Amendments adopted: AM3, AM6, AM8, AM9, AM11, AM12, LIBE1, LIBE6, LIBE7, LIBE8, LIBE9, LIBE10Amendments rejected: AM2, AM4, AM5, AM7, AM10, LIBE2The following amendments were covered: LIBE3, LIBE4, LIBE5No vote (inadmissible): AM1

48. Discharge 2017: European GNSS Agency (GSA)CONT/8/14310

2018/2196(DEC) COM(2018)0521[29] – C8-0347/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM4Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8No vote (inadmissible): AM1

Discharge 2017: Joint Undertakings

49. Discharge 2017: Bio-Based Industries Joint Undertaking (BBI)CONT/8/14371

2018/2214(DEC) COM(2018)0521[47] – C8-0365/2018

Rapporteur:Martina Dlabajová (ALDE) AM – PE634.562v01-00

Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE, REGI



Amendments adopted: AM7, AM8, AM9

Amendments rejected: AM3, AM4

PV\1181779EN.docx 25/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Amendments withdrawn: AM2, AM5, AM6

50. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Aeronautics and Environment (CLEAN SKY)CONT/8/14367

2018/2213(DEC) COM(2018)0521[46] – C8-0364/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI, ITRE, TRAN



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM7, AM9, AM10, AM11

Amendments rejected: AM2, AM3, AM4 , AM6, AM8

51. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Electronic Components and Systems for European Leadership (ECSEL)CONT/8/14383

2018/2218(DEC) COM(2018)0521[51] – C8-0369/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM8, AM9, AM10, AM12, AM13, AM15

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM2, AM3, AM7, AM11

No vote: AM4

52. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Fuel Cells and Hydrogen (FCH)CONT/8/14378

PE636.387v03-00 26/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

2018/2216(DEC) COM(2018)0521[49] – C8-0367/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE



Amendments adopted: AL3, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, AM10


53. Discharge 2017: Joint Undertaking - Innovative Medicines 2 Initiative (IMI)CONT/8/14374

2018/2215(DEC) COM(2018)0521[48] – C8-0366/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ENVI, ITRE



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6AM8, AM9, AM10, AM11, AM11


54. Discharge 2017: International Fusion Energy Organisation (ITER)CONT/8/14362

2018/2211(DEC) COM(2018)0521[44] – C8-0362/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE


PV\1181779EN.docx 27/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN


Amendments adopted: AM8, AM9, AM12, AM13, AM14, AM15, AM17

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM2, AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM10, AM11, AM16

55. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Safety of air navigation (SESAR)CONT/8/14364

2018/2212(DEC) COM(2018)0521[45] – C8-0363/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE, TRAN



Amendments adopted: AM5, AM6, AM8, AM9, AM9, AM10, TRAN2, TRAN5, TRAN6, TRAN7 part 2, TRAN9, TRAN10, TRAN11, TRAN13 part 2, TRAN14


The following amendments were covered: TRAN1, TRAN3, TRAN4 part 2, TRAN7 part 1, TRAN8, TRAN12, TRAN13 part 1, TRAN15

No vote (technical amendment): AM1, AM7

56. Discharge 2017: Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking (SHIFT2RAIL)CONT/8/14380

2018/2217(DEC) COM(2018)0521[50] – C8-0368/2018


Responsible:CONT

Opinions:ITRE, TRAN



Amendments adopted: AM3, AM4, AM5, AM6, AM7, AM8, AM9, TRAN4, TRAN5 part 2,

PE636.387v03-00 28/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

TRAN6; TRAN8 part 2, TRAN9, TRAN10, TRAN11, TRAN12,

Amendments rejected: AM1, AM2

Amendments fallen: TRAN3 part 2

The following amendments were covered: TRAN1, TRAN2, TRAN3 part 1, TRAN5 parts1 and 3, TRAN7, TRAN8 part 1, TRAN13

*** End of electronic vote ***

Derek Vaughan (first Vice-Chair) took the Chair at 16.45

57. Study on Aligning the budget with the Performance-Based Budgeting: lessons from Member StatesCONT/8/15538 Presentation of study

The following spoke: Inés Ayala Sender, Ingeborg Gräßle, T. Van Schoubroeck (Deloitte), Bart Staes, Derek Vaughan, Rosa Aldea Busquets DG Budg

58. 2nd Action Plan to fight the illicit tobacco trade 2018-2022CONT/8/15539 Presentation by Ville Itälä, Director-General of the European Anti-Fraud Office

(OLAF)

59. Any other business

None.

60. Next meetings 4 March 2019, 15.00 – 18.30 (Brussels) 21 March 2019, 15.00 – 18.30 (Brussels) 8 April 2019, 15.00 – 18.30 (Brussels) 11 April 2019, 15.00 – 18.30 (Brussels)

The meeting ended at 17.35

PV\1181779EN.docx 29/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Results of roll-call votes

Contents

4. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Commission - CONT/8/14083344.1. Final vote ................................................................................................................34

5. Discharge 2017: Court of Auditors' special reports - CONT/8/14385 ........................355.1. Final vote ................................................................................................................35

6. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Parliament - CONT/8/14103366.1. Vote on AM 88 .......................................................................................................366.2. Final vote ................................................................................................................37

7. 2017 discharge: General budget of the EU - 8th, 9th, 10th and 11th EDFs - CONT/8/14268.........................................................................................................................38

7.1. Final vote ................................................................................................................388. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European External Action Service- CONT/8/14263.........................................................................................................................39

8.1. Final vote ................................................................................................................399. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Council and European Council- CONT/8/14123.........................................................................................................................40

9.1. Final vote ................................................................................................................4010. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Court of Auditors- CONT/8/14163.........................................................................................................................41

10.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4111. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Court of Justice - CONT/8/14147....42

11.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4212. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Economic and Social Committee - CONT/8/14183...................................................................................................43

12.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4313. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Committee of the Regions - CONT/8/14203.........................................................................................................................44

13.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4414. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Ombudsman - CONT/8/14223.........................................................................................................................45

14.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4515. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Data Protection Supervisor - CONT/8/14243 ......................................................................................................................46

15.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4616. Discharge 2017: Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the agencies of the European Union for the financial year 2017: performance, financial management and control - CONT/8/14341 ...........................................................47

16.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4717. Discharge 2017: Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER) - CONT/8/14330.........................................................................................................................48

17.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................48

PE636.387v03-00 30/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

18. Discharge 2017: Office of the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) - CONT/8/14332 .......................................................................49

18.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................4919. Discharge 2017: Translation Centre for the Bodies of the European Union (CdT) - CONT/8/14285.........................................................................................................................50

19.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5020. Discharge 2017: European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (Cedefop) - CONT/8/14271.....................................................................................................51

20.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5121. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Training (CEPOL) - CONT/8/14305 .....................................................................................................52

21.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5222. Discharge 2017: European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) - CONT/8/14295......53

22.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5323. Discharge 2017: European Asylum Support Office (EASO) - CONT/8/14337 ......54

23.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5424. Discharge 2017: European Banking Authority (EBA) - CONT/8/14323 ................55

24.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5525. Discharge 2017: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) - CONT/8/14299.........................................................................................................................56

25.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5626. Discharge 2017: European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) - CONT/8/14314 .............57

26.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5727. Discharge 2017: European Environment Agency (EEA) - CONT/8/14281 ............58

27.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5828. Discharge 2017: European Fisheries Control Agency (EFCA) - CONT/8/14312 ..59

28.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................5929. Discharge 2017: European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) - CONT/8/14297 ........60

29.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6030. Discharge 2017: European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE) - CONT/8/14321

6130.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................61

31. Discharge 2017: European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) - CONT/8/14325 ......................................................................................................62

31.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6232. Discharge 2017: European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) - CONT/8/14335.........................................................................................................................63

32.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6333. Discharge 2017: European Medicines Agency (EMA) - CONT/8/14287 ................64

33.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6434. Discharge 2017: European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA) - CONT/8/14278.................................................................................................65

34.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6535. Discharge 2017: European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA)- CONT/8/14293 ....66

35.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6636. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Network and Information Security (ENISA) - CONT/8/14301.......................................................................................................67

36.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6737. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Railways (ERA) - CONT/8/14303 .68

37.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................68

PV\1181779EN.docx 31/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

38. Discharge 2017: European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) - CONT/8/14328.........................................................................................................................69

38.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................6939. Discharge 2017: European Training Foundation (ETF) - CONT/8/14291.............70

39.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7040. Discharge 2017: European Agency for the operational management of large-scale IT systems in the area of freedom, security and justice (eu-Lisa) - CONT/8/14339 .........71

40.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7141. Discharge 2017: European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA) - CONT/8/14283.........................................................................................................................72

41.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7242. Discharge 2017: Euratom Supply Agency (ESA) - CONT/8/14316.........................73

42.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7343. Discharge 2017: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions (EUROFOUND) - CONT/8/14274 .....................................................74

43.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7444. Discharge 2017: European Union Judicial Cooperation Unit (Eurojust) - CONT/8/14289.........................................................................................................................74

44.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7545. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation (Europol) - CONT/8/14318.....................................................................................................76

45.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7646. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) - CONT/8/14276.........................................................................................................................77

46.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7747. Discharge 2017: European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex) - CONT/8/14307.........................................................................................................................78

47.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7848. Discharge 2017: European GNSS Agency (GSA) - CONT/8/14310 ........................79

48.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................7949. Discharge 2017: Bio-Based Industries Joint Undertaking (BBI) - CONT/8/14371

8049.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................80

50. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Aeronautics and Environment (CLEAN SKY) - CONT/8/14367 ............................................................................................................81

50.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8151. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Electronic Components and Systems for European Leadership (ECSEL) - CONT/8/14383 ...............................................................82

51.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8252. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Fuel Cells and Hydrogen (FCH) - CONT/8/14378.........................................................................................................................83

52.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8353. Discharge 2017: Joint Undertaking - Innovative Medicines 2 Initiative (IMI) - CONT/8/14374.........................................................................................................................84

53.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8454. Discharge 2017: International Fusion Energy Organisation (ITER) - CONT/8/14362.........................................................................................................................85

54.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8555. Discharge 2017: Joint undertaking - Safety of air navigation (SESAR) - CONT/8/14364.........................................................................................................................86

PE636.387v03-00 32/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

55.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................8656. Discharge 2017: Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking (SHIFT2RAIL) - CONT/8/14380.87

56.1. Final vote ............................................................................................................87

Key to symbols:+ : in favour- : against0 : abstention

PV\1181779EN.docx 33/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

Results of roll-call votes

4. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Commission - CONT/8/14083

4.1. Final vote

20 +

ALDE Nedzhmi Ali, Martina Dlabajová, Wolf Klinz

GUE/NGL Dennis de Jong

PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Julia Pitera, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller

S&D Clara Eugenia Aguilera García, Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, José Blanco López, Eider Gardiazabal Rubial, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan

VERTS/ALE Bart Staes

2 -

ECR John Flack

ENF Jean-François Jalkh

0 0

PE636.387v03-00 34/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

5. Discharge 2017: Court of Auditors' special reports - CONT/8/14385

5.1. Final vote

21 +


EFDD Rosa D'Amato


GUE/NGL Luke Ming Flanagan, Dennis de Jong


S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, José Blanco López, Bogusław Liberadzki, Georgi Pirinski


3 -

ECR John Flack, Czesław Hoc

S&D Derek Vaughan

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 35/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

6. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Parliament - CONT/8/14103

6.1. Vote on AM 88

10 +

ALDE

EFDD

GUE/NGL

S&D

Verts/ALE

Nedzhmi Ali

Rosa D'Amato

Dennis de Jong

Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, José Blanco López, Bogusław Liberadzki, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan

Bart Staes

10 -

ENF Group

GUE/NGL

PPE

Jean-François Jalkh

Luke Ming Flanagan

Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Julia Pitera, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller

1 0

ALDE Martina Dlabajová

Corrections to votes and voting intentions

+ Luke Ming Flanagan

-

0

PE636.387v03-00 36/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

6.2. Final vote

FINAL VOTE BY ROLL CALL IN COMMITTEE RESPONSIBLE

20 +





S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Bogusław Liberadzki, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan


4 -


EFDD Rosa D'Amato

S&D José Blanco López

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 37/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

7. 2017 discharge: General budget of the EU - 8th, 9th, 10th and 11th EDFs - CONT/8/14268

7.1. Final vote

18 +

ALDE Nedzhmi Ali, Martina Dlabajová

EFDD Rosa D'Amato


PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Julia Pitera, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Joachim Zeller

S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Arndt Kohn, Edouard Martin, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan


4 -



PPE Tomáš Zdechovský

0 0

PE636.387v03-00 38/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

8. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European External Action Service- CONT/8/14263

8.1. Final vote

10 +

ALDE Nedzhmi Ali

PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský

S&D Zigmantas Balčytis, Arndt Kohn, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan

2 -

EFDD Marco Valli


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 39/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

9. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Council and European Council- CONT/8/14123

9.1. Final vote

19 +


EFDD Marco Valli



PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský

S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Karin Kadenbach, Arndt Kohn, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan


0 -

0 0

PE636.387v03-00 40/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

10. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Court of Auditors- CONT/8/14163

10.1. Final vote

17 +



PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský



0 -

2 0

EFDD Marco Valli


PV\1181779EN.docx 41/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

11. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - Court of Justice - CONT/8/14147

11.1. Final vote

18 +



PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Marian-Jean Marinescu, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský



0 -

2 0

EFDD Marco Valli


PE636.387v03-00 42/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

12. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Economic and Social Committee - CONT/8/14183

12.1. Final vote

19 +







1 -

EFDD Marco Valli

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 43/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

13. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Committee of the Regions - CONT/8/14203

13.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei



S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Karin Kadenbach, Petra Kammerevert, Arndt Kohn, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan


2 -

EFDD Marco Valli


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 44/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

14. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Ombudsman - CONT/8/14223

14.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei





0 -

2 0

EFDD Marco Valli


PV\1181779EN.docx 45/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

15. Discharge 2017: General budget of the EU - European Data Protection Supervisor - CONT/8/14243

15.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei





2 -

EFDD Marco Valli


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 46/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

16. Discharge 2017: Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the agencies of the European Union for the financial year 2017: performance, financial management and control - CONT/8/14341

16.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli




S&D Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Karin Kadenbach, Petra Kammerevert, Georgi Pirinski, Derek Vaughan


0 -

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 47/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

17. Discharge 2017: Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER) - CONT/8/14330

17.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 48/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

18. Discharge 2017: Office of the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC) - CONT/8/14332

18.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 49/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

19. Discharge 2017: Translation Centre for the Bodies of the European Union (CdT) - CONT/8/14285

19.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PE636.387v03-00 50/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

20. Discharge 2017: European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (Cedefop) - CONT/8/14271

20.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PV\1181779EN.docx 51/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

21. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Training (CEPOL) - CONT/8/14305

21.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli






0 -

0 0

PE636.387v03-00 52/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

22. Discharge 2017: European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) - CONT/8/14295

22.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 53/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

23. Discharge 2017: European Asylum Support Office (EASO) - CONT/8/14337

23.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli






0 -

0 0

PE636.387v03-00 54/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

24. Discharge 2017: European Banking Authority (EBA) - CONT/8/14323

24.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei






1 -

EFDD Marco Valli

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 55/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

25. Discharge 2017: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) - CONT/8/14299

25.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli


PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Marian-Jean Marinescu, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller



1 -


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 56/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

26. Discharge 2017: European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) - CONT/8/14314

26.1. Final vote

22 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli






0 -

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 57/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

27. Discharge 2017: European Environment Agency (EEA) - CONT/8/14281

27.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 58/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

28. Discharge 2017: European Fisheries Control Agency (EFCA) - CONT/8/14312

28.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 59/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

29. Discharge 2017: European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) - CONT/8/14297

29.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 60/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

30. Discharge 2017: European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE) - CONT/8/14321

30.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PV\1181779EN.docx 61/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

31. Discharge 2017: European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) - CONT/8/14325

31.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei


PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller



1 -

EFDD Marco Valli

1 0


PE636.387v03-00 62/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

32. Discharge 2017: European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) - CONT/8/14335

32.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli






0 -

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 63/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

33. Discharge 2017: European Medicines Agency (EMA) - CONT/8/14287

33.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 64/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

34. Discharge 2017: European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA) - CONT/8/14278

34.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 65/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

35. Discharge 2017: European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA)- CONT/8/14293

35.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PE636.387v03-00 66/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

36. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Network and Information Security (ENISA) - CONT/8/14301

36.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





1 -


0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 67/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

37. Discharge 2017: European Union Agency for Railways (ERA) - CONT/8/14303

37.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei





2 -

EFDD Marco Valli


0 0

PE636.387v03-00 68/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

38. Discharge 2017: European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) - CONT/8/14328

38.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei





1 -

EFDD Marco Valli

1 0


PV\1181779EN.docx 69/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

39. Discharge 2017: European Training Foundation (ETF) - CONT/8/14291

39.1. Final vote

18 +

ALDE Nedzhmi Ali, Martina Dlabajová

ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PE636.387v03-00 70/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

40. Discharge 2017: European Agency for the operational management of large-scale IT systems in the area of freedom, security and justice (eu-Lisa) - CONT/8/14339

40.1. Final vote

20 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli





0 -

1 0


PV\1181779EN.docx 71/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

41. Discharge 2017: European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA) - CONT/8/14283

41.1. Final vote

18 +

ALDE Martina Dlabajová, Wolf Klinz

ECR Monica Macovei





1 -


1 0

EFDD Marco Valli

PE636.387v03-00 72/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

42. Discharge 2017: Euratom Supply Agency (ESA) - CONT/8/14316

42.1. Final vote

21 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli






0 -

0 0

PV\1181779EN.docx 73/104 PE636.387v03-00

EN

43. Discharge 2017: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions (EUROFOUND) - CONT/8/14274

43.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli


PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Joachim Zeller



1 -


0 0

44. Discharge 2017: European Union Judicial Cooperation Unit (Eurojust) -

PE636.387v03-00 74/104 PV\1181779EN.docx

EN

CONT/8/14289

44.1. Final vote

19 +


ECR Monica Macovei

EFDD Marco Valli


PPE Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Jos

committee on budgetary control - european parliamentpv\1181779en.docx pe636.387v03-00 enunited in...

Documents