“commercializing advanced (second and third generation
TRANSCRIPT
“Commercializing Advanced (Second and Third Generation)
Biofuels Technologies”
E. Kendall PyeChief Scientific Officer,
Lignol Energy CorporationBurnaby, BC
Commercial Progression of the Biofuels IndustryCommercial Progression of the Biofuels Industry
• 1st Generation Biofuels – primarily made from food and feed crops
– Brazil; ethanol from cane sugar since 1970’s, now ~ 7 billion gallons/yr
– USA; ethanol from corn starch since the early 1980’s, now ~12 billion gallons/yr
– EU; primarily biodiesel from vegetable oils and animal fats, some ethanol ~ 1 billion
• food versus fuel controversy
• impacts on land use, more crop land
• annual production dependant on climate and disease, volatile feedstock prices
• 2nd Generation Biofuels – primarily from lignocellulosic biomass
2
• 2nd Generation Biofuels – primarily from lignocellulosic biomass
– Only now nearing commercialization in many parts of the world
– Various technologies under development;
• pyrolysis or gasification with chemical or biological synthesis from syngas
• pretreatment of feedstock with acid, steam, ammonia, etc.
• high cost of enzymatic saccharification
• 3rd Generation Biofuels - lignocellulosic biorefineries and algae
– multiple product streams created from biomass, improved economics
– preserves the higher values of the products
Conventional
Oil Refinery
Gasoline
Cellulosic ethanol
Biorefinery
3
Petrochemicals
Bio-based
chemicals
Diesel fuel Lignin
Maximizing Value from Biomass Fractions; Maximizing Value from Biomass Fractions;
retaining important chemical structuresretaining important chemical structures
Cellulose
40%-45%
C6 Sugars
Ethanol
Enzymes
Yeast
HP-L™ Lignin
Extractives
4
C5 &C6 Sugars
Biofuels & Bio-Based Chemicals
This approach accelerates commercialization:1. Diversification of revenue streams lowers risks2. Smaller size biorefineries are profitable (lower plant capex)3. Substantial GHG emissions reduction (carbon credits)
• Emerging cellulosic ethanol company deploying the Biochemical Biorefinery Concept
• Operations in Western Canada & Eastern US (Philadelphia)
• ~40+ employees
• Well-funded in the past 4 years (has gained access to ~$79M including
Introduction to LignolIntroduction to Lignol
5
• Well-funded in the past 4 years (has gained access to ~$79M including a $30M US DOE grant to build a demo scale facility)
• Much of its technology is already proven on a semi-commercial scale
• Goal: Commercialize a biorefinery process for low cost cellulosic ethanol production with the greatest environmental benefits
Lignol’s
Pretreatment
Process
Solven
t
Rec
ove
ry HP-L™ Lignin
Recovered Solvent
Industrial Sugars
Furfural
Hardwood, Softwood, Agricultural Residues
Lignol’s Process OverviewLignol’s Process Overview
6 6
Enzymatic
Saccharification
&
Fermentation
“Clean”
cellulose-
rich
substrate
Enzymes &Yeast
Spent Solvent
Distillation
Distillation
Industrial Sugars
Ethanol
Stillage
Lignol acquired technology developed byLignol acquired technology developed byGeneral Electric and Repap (Alcell)General Electric and Repap (Alcell)
GE
• Wood-to-ethanol pilot plant; gas turbine fuel
Alcell
7
• Wood pulp production on industrial scale
• Proved markets for novel “High Purity Lignin” (HP-L™ lignin)
• Over $100 million spent on development
Proven 1Proven 1stst Gen. Biomass Pretreatment TechnologyGen. Biomass Pretreatment Technology
New Brunswick, Canada (1988 – 1996)60 tpd feed capacity (hardwoods)
8
“Clean” Cellulose“Clean” Cellulose--Rich SubstrateRich Substrate
Lignol’s Pretreated Wood
Dilute-Acid-Pretreated Corn Stover
Steam-ExplodedWood
Other leading pretreatment technologies:
9
Only ~60% Fermentable Components
~95% Fermentable Components
Woody Biomass Contains Valuable ChemicalsWoody Biomass Contains Valuable Chemicals
•Lignin is a matrix aromatic
polymer composed of phenolic
structures; the only major
natural source of benzene rings
Lignin
10
Possible HPPossible HP--L™ Lignin StructureL™ Lignin Structure
OH
OCH3
O
HOCH2
11
H3CO
O
CH2OH
HCOH
OH
H3CO
HO
CH2
OCH3
HOCH2
O HCOH
HCOH
CH2OH
H3CO
Current World Output110 MM Tons/yr
Current Petrochemical Industry Uses Oil and Gas to Produce Primary Olefins and Aromatics
12
110 MM Tons/yr
65 MM Tons/yr
70 MM Tons/yr
HP-LTM Lignin Markets
• Legislation, innovation and consumer demand is driving adoption of “green” products – formaldehyde is restricted in California, France, Finland and Japan
– fuel efficiency, vehicle weight reduction (LCCF) - US DOE
FreedomCAR program
• Applications in resin systems are significant: – PF resins and their products
13
– PF resins and their products
– Epoxy resins and their derivatives
– Polyurethane resins and derivatives
– Furan resins and their derivatives
• Animal Feed Additives; non-antibiotic growth promoters, antioxidants
• Carbon fiber development with Oak Ridge National Labs and companies like BAE Systems (British Aerospace) � potential markets to support a large number of biorefineries
Engineering HPEngineering HP--LLTMTM Lignins (Substitution)Lignins (Substitution)
14
Customized HPCustomized HP--LLTMTM Lignin Chemistry for Specific NeedsLignin Chemistry for Specific Needs
Making Lignol’s Lignins Work for the Wood Adhesive Industry
15
PB & MDF Wood Panels Containing Lignol’s HP-LTM Lignins
Products Made with Products Made with Lignol’sLignol’s HPHP--LLTM TM LigninsLignins
16
HP-LTM Lignins For Automotive Carbon Fiber (LCCF)
CARBON FIBER MERCEDES AMG SLS CF is 4x lighter than steel
CF is 5-6x stronger than steel
17
Tokyo Auto Salon 2008- Honda Civic Mugen Type-RR
ORNL13,000,000 cars & light trucks produce annually in the USA
~220 lbs LCCF /vehicle (on average)~440 lbs HP-LTM Lignin/vehicle (on average)
~$3.0B/year potential US HP-LTM Lignin market for automotive LCCF
HP-LTM Lignins For Automotive Carbon Fiber (LCCF)
18
Application LCCF
Time-to-Market
Lignol’s Commercial Plants
(2,000 tpd feed)
Ethanol (gal/year)
Vehicles ~5-10 years 27 commercial plants 1.5B (at <$2.00/gal)~10% 2011 RFS2
Wind Turbines <5 years Unknown Unknown
Insulating Materials Now Unknown Unknown
Source: Compere A.L. et al. Low Cost Carbon Fiber From Renewable Resources, Oak Ridge National Laboratory & Lignol Innovations Ltd.
Development Partners for HP-LTM Lignin
• Foundry Resins:
– HA International
• Coatings:
– PPG Industries (NYSE:PPG)
19
• Adhesives:
– Huntsman Corporation (NYSE:HUN)
• Construction Materials:
– Kingspan Corporation (KSP:L)
Technology Deployment PathTechnology Deployment Path
Stage Capacity (biomass feed)
Capacity (ethanol)
Status
Pre-Pilot Grams/hour �Complete
Industrial Pilot 1 tonne/day
100,000 L/yr
�Complete
20
100,000 L/yr
Demonstration 100 tonnes/day
10–30 million liters/yr
�Developing
Commercial 400-2000 tonnes/day
40-200 million liters/yr
�Planning
Lignol’s Integrated Biorefinery Pilot PlantLignol’s Integrated Biorefinery Pilot Plant
• Capacity: 1 tonne per day (dry basis)
– Fully integrated mini-biorefinery
– Fully instrumented
– Industrial equipment
– Rated at 100,000 l/yr CE ethanol
21
– Rated at 100,000 l/yr CE ethanol
• Feedstocks: Hardwood & softwood, agricultural residues, energy crops
• Products: Ethanol, HP-LTM lignin, furfural, other chemicals
• Operation: past few weeks 24/7 in campaigns (before 24/5)
Conclusions
• Versatile biorefinery technology with multiple products such as
Cellulosic Ethanol, Pulp, Chemicals and HP-LTM Lignins
Process economics enhanced by multiple revenue streams – process
can be economic at smaller scale
• Multi-objective optimization is needed in a biorefinery to maximize
22
• Multi-objective optimization is needed in a biorefinery to maximize
revenue – this is possible in Lignol’s process.
• Bio-based chemicals can displace and enhance petrochemical-
based products and materials
Significant GHG emissions reductions; isolate from price volatility of oil
• Lignol’s biorefinery technology is “demo ready”
22
Conclusions
• Environmentally-benign
�no harsh chemicals used
�very little process water use
• Flexible and relatively simple production of multiple co-products
from biomass using mostly standard chemical processing equipment
23
from biomass using mostly standard chemical processing equipment
• May be used to revive closed manufacturing sites, such as pulp
mills, and use their infrastructure, services, biomass resource and
skilled labor pool
23
Thank you!Thank you!
For general information visit For general information visit
www.lignol.ca
E. Kendall Pye, CSO, E. Kendall Pye, CSO,