commercial building energy alliance high-performance ... · 5/6/2011 · parking structure...
TRANSCRIPT
Program Name or Ancillary Text eereenergygov
Commercial Building Energy AllianceHigh-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
May 6 2011Michael Myer Pacific Northwest National LaboratoryJohn DrsquoAngelo Cleveland Clinic
PNNL-SA-79759
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
2 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
3 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Overview US Energy Use
4 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
EnergyEfficiency
Overview Commercial Building Energy Alliances
Common Challenges
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
Energy usage of parking structures ndash ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
5 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
2 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
3 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Overview US Energy Use
4 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
EnergyEfficiency
Overview Commercial Building Energy Alliances
Common Challenges
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
Energy usage of parking structures ndash ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
5 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
3 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Overview US Energy Use
4 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
EnergyEfficiency
Overview Commercial Building Energy Alliances
Common Challenges
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
Energy usage of parking structures ndash ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
5 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
4 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
EnergyEfficiency
Overview Commercial Building Energy Alliances
Common Challenges
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
Energy usage of parking structures ndash ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
5 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
Energy usage of parking structures ndash ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
5 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationQuick Facts
Approx 110 Million spaces bull NOT structures
LowMedium Fixture Wattage bull Typically 50W ndash 200W
Long Daily Operation bull 18 hoursday = 6570 hoursyear
= High Energy Use bull 281 TWhyr
Infrequent occupancy at times Low occupancy at times Daylight and controls potential
Tufts University
Old Orchard Mall 6 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationEnergy Usage
Light Source Portion of Installed Equipment Number of Lights (000s)
Incandescent 16 600 Halogen 22 800 Fluorescent 459 16600 Induction 74 2700 Mercury Vapor 01 44 High Pressure Sodium 232 8500 Metal Halide 153 5600 LED 41 1500 Total 100 36400
DOE Energy Savings Estimates of Light-Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications (January 2011)
7 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationCosts
Table from Parking Structures 3rd Edition Planning Design Construction Maintenance and Repair (2001)
Cashiering Salaries amp Benefits $18457 33 Management Costs $5769 10 Security Costs $9065
16 Utilities $5000 9 Insurance $1376 2 Supplies $661 1 Routine Maintenance $3702 7 Structural Maintenance $3807 7 Snow Removal $407 1 Equipment Maintenance $607 1 Other Expenses $7543 13 Total $56403 100
Cost Type Median Annual Cost per Space Part of Total
8 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationMaterials
Natick Collection Arizona State University Natick MA Tempe AZ
9 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Department of Labor Headquarters Site Overview bull Subterranean parking deck bull Directional flow traffic bull Parking for office building bull T12 rarr HPS rarr LED bull LED demo bull LED fixtures use occupancy
sensors bull LED fixtures Next Generation
Luminaire (NGL) winners
10 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataThursday January 27
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
11 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Ampe
rage
01
01
00
Controls Sample Usage DataSaturday January 29
Daily Fixture Amperage 03
02
02
1201AM
1230AM
1259AM
128
AM
157
AM
226
AM
255
AM
324
AM
353
AM
422
AM
451
AM
520
AM
549
AM
618
AM
647
AM
716
AM
745
AM
814
AM
843
AM
912
AM
941
AM
1010AM
1039AM
1108AM
1137AM
1206PM
1235PM
104
PM
133
PM
202
PM
231
PM
300
PM
329
PM
358
PM
427
PM
456
PM
525
PM
554
PM
623
PM
652
PM
721
PM
750
PM
819
PM
848
PM
917
PM
946
PM
1015PM
1044PM
1113PM
1142PM
Hour of Day
PRELIMINARY DATA ndash Dept of Labor
12 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Parking Structure InformationPossible Use of Controls
Results bull Operating profile
ndash Operating in high state asymp30 of time
ndash Operating in low state asymp70 of time
bull Time out of sensor affects savings
bull One way traffic affects usage
bull Columns affect coverage
LED on left HPS on right
13 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
14 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
What is a specification
Performance Specification bull Adopted by end user site
bull Eg Walmart Walgreens Westfield bull Product must deliver X (eg lumens
footcandles uniformity) for Y energy units (eg Wsf W kWh)
Technology (ProductWidget) Specification
bull Can be done via RFPMass Procurement bull Can be incentivized by utility or energy
efficiency program bull Example of lighting product X delivers Y
lumens for Z watts bull Examples ENERGY STAR CEE Premium
T8s Etc
Bentley Medical California
15 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Specification OverviewEnergy Conservation
Energy Conservation 1 018 Wsf Background
1 EPAct 40 Parking Structure LPD 018
2 Parking Structures are covered by EPAct deduction Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-14 Section 6 APPLICATION OF THE INTERIM LIGHTING RULE TO UNCONDITIONED GARAGE SPACE
Hotel Structure
Cupertino CA
16 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Specification OverviewLighting Requirements
Area of Structure Horizontal1
Illuminance Requirement
Vertical2
Illuminance Requirement
Uniformity MaxMin
Uniformity CV
Covered Parking Areas
125 (Min) 05 71 038
Ramps (Day) 200 (Min) 10 101 041 Ramps (Night) 100 (Min) 05 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Day)3 5000 (Min) 250 101 041 Vehicle Entry (Night) 125 (Min) 05 101 041 Uncovered (Top Deck) 075 (Min) 04 101 041
1 Measured on parking surface 2 Vertical measurements at 5rsquo AFG 3 Contributions from the sun should be factored in
17 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Specification OverviewTechnologies
Fluorescent LED
Induction 18 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
A Daylighting Controls 1 Luminaires within 20rsquo of perimeter
and if wall is 40 open must be controlled with daylight harvesting
2 Luminaires in vehicle exitentry area turn off additional lighting at night
3 Photocell requirements a 15 ndash 30 second time delay b 10 fc set point for sensor c Mounted in an unobscured location d Use relays that are UL 773 or UL
773 A
Electric Lighting amp Daylight Cupertino CA
19 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Specification OverviewLighting Controls
B Occupancy Sensor Controls 1 1 occ sensor per luminaire
maximum coverage
2 Sensors comply with WD 7-2000 3 Sensor Type Infrared or microwave 4 Sensors not affected by ambient
temperature 5 Failsafe feature to fail ldquoonrdquo in event
of sensor failure 6 Site owner to specify if sensors are
onoff or highlow
Integral Occupancy Sensor
Univ at Shady Grove
Rockville MD 20 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction ndash DSIRE ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
21 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Financial Incentives for LPDs bull Sliding scale reductions for taxes bull $030 sf when lighting is 0225 Wsf bull $060 sf when lighting is 018 Wsf bull Applicable to covered floors
bull Open-to-sky top floors not applicable bull Extended from expiring in 2009 to December 31 2013 bull IRS Notice 2008-40 issued March 7 2008 bull Govrsquot Structures $$ rarr Design Team
Parking Structures rarr Low-hanging fruit bull Large footprint but low equipment density
bull High tax incentive with low-capital outlay
22 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Sample Parking Structure 10 $248400 15 $372600 25 $621000 28 $695520 33 $819720
Tax Bracket 018 Wsf
bull asymp41400 sq feet Federal $ from tax deduction bull Final amount per tax bracket
35 $869400
23 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Caution bull Low consumer awareness bull Not applicable to tax exempt
organizations ndash Proposal to cover REITs
bull Sens Bingaman amp Snowe ndash Other modifications proposed by
others ndash Organizations request increase $sf
bull Extended to December 31 2013
bull Requires post installation documentation amp verification
Rhode Island Convention Center Rhode Island
24 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
Contains bull Information
bull Draft letters
bull IRS Bulletins
bull FAQs bull Resources
httpwwwlightingtaxdeductionorg
25 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives 179D Tax Incentive
NO ENDORSEMENT
httpwwwgeconsumerandindustrialcomenvironmentalinfotools_calculatorseligibility_estimatorhtm
26 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives Database of Programs
wwwdsireusaorg
27 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives Example
Utilities offer money bull ComEd (utility) offers
ndash $15 - $110 per induction fixture depending on HID fixture replaced
ndash $100 per ceiling fixture under smart bi-level option
Total Incentive $ bull 39 fixtures (41400 sf example)
ndash $50 fixture (middle above) = $1950
bull $6210 (Federal tax deduction 25 bracket)
bull $8160 total
28 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Product-specific
specifications bull ONLY LED bull Updated over
time
httpwwwdesignlightsorg 29 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull Multiple utilities bull Focuses on lamp amp ballast
ndash T8 systems only
bull Specific only to light source not application
bull Does not include fixture information
httpwwwcee1orgcomcom-ltcom-lt-mainphp3
30 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Financial Incentives Example
Overview bull No known nationwide induction
program bull Multiple utilities offer incentives
bull ComED bull PGampE
bull Bi-Level induction generators bull Few made bull Some use 2 lamps
Induction fixture installed
Skokie IL
31 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Agenda
bull Introduction bull Estimates about parking structures
ndash Energy usage of parking structures ndash Typical fixtures ndash Design issues ndash Potential for lighting controls
bull Review of CBEA specification bull Review of financial incentives
ndash 179D Tax Deduction
ndash DSIRE
ndash Example utilityEEP incentives
bull Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
32 | Commercial Building Energy Alliance
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Cleveland ClinicCleveland Clinic
bull 203 Locations - 13 Hospitals - 16 FHCASC
bull 232 million square feet (and growing) bull Highest Acuity hospital in the US bull Consistently top 4 in outcomes
- 1 cardiovascular for 16 years
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
100th Street (BB) Garage100th Street (BB) Garage
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Existing - HPSExisting - HPS
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
New - LEDNew - LED
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
BB GarageBB Garage
bull 970250 sf ndash 1500 spaces bull 6 partially enclosed stories + open roof bull North for patients South for employees
bull 830 main garage fixtures - 620 to have motion sensor - 218 to have photo sensor
bull 65 stairwell fixtures 28 site fixtures
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
CBEA SpecificationCBEA Specification
bull Only LED sections apply bull Specified depreciation conditions bull Strengthened warranty provisions
bull Set CCT between 4000K and 5000K
bull Specified sensorcontrols bull Specified MampV
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
bull 51
bull 10
bull 10
bull 10
bull 9
bull 5
bull 5
RFP ndashRFP ndash BBest Valueest Value
Price Local FBE MBE labor Total Wattage Glare Warranty Extension CRI Max-to-Min Ratio
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
InviteesInvitees
bull Sent to 6 manufacturers bull 5 bid 1 declined
- One bid two separate product lines bull Required contract with manufacturers
device distributorscontractors bull Very competitive bids ndash beat estimated
cost by 28
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Winning Bid ndashWinning Bid ndash 7810078100 pointspoints
bull Lowest cost bull 3 of total contract to MBEFBE bull 2nd lowest total wattage bull Lowest quartile for glare bull Standard warranty (5 year ldquoall-inrdquo) bull CRI = 72 bull Max-to-Min = 33
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
PerformancePerformance
bull Existing = 1558764 kWh per year bull New = 282182 kWh per year
- 12 hourday sensor-based savings - 121 kW installed difference
bull Savings of 1276583 kWh bull 42 year simple payback on energy only
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
IncentivesIncentives
bull Qualifies for Ohio EE Incentive - Exterior Lighting = $050Watt - Interior Lighting = $080Watt
bull Revised simple payback = 38 years
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Next StepsNext Steps
bull Continue with installation and performance monitoring
bull Compile lessons learned bull Revise RFP based on lessons learned
bull Convert the next garage
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-
Presentation Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
webinar_archiveshtml
Specification Download httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliances
parking_structure_spechtml
CBEA Alliances httpwww1eereenergygovbuildingsalliancesindexhtml
- Commercial Building Energy Alliance - High-Performance Lighting for Parking Structures Specification
- Agenda - Introduction
-
- Overview - US Energy Use
- Overview - Commercial Building Energy Alliances
-
- Estimates about parking structures
-
- Parking Structure Information - Quick Facts
- Parking Structure Information - Energy Usage
- Parking Structure Information - Costs
- Parking Structure Information - Materials
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Thursday January 27
- Controls Sample Usage Data - Saturday January 29
- Parking Structure Information - Possible Use of Controls
- What is a specification
- Specification Overview - Energy Conservation
- Specification Overview - Lighting Requirements
- Specification Overview - Technologies
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
- Specification Overview - Lighting Controls
-
- Review of financial incentives
-
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives - 179D Tax Incentive (cont)
- Financial Incentives Database of Programs
- Financial Incentives - Example
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives Example (cont)
- Financial Incentives - Example (cont)
-
- Examples in action ndash Cleveland Clinic
-
- Cleveland Clinic
- 100th Street (BB) Garage
- Existing - HPS
- New - LED
- BB Garage
- CBEA Specification
- RFP ndash Best Value
- Invitees
- Winning Bid ndash 78100 points
- Performance
- Incentives
- Next Steps
-
- Download information
-