collecting qual data
DESCRIPTION
b r mTRANSCRIPT
Slide 1MANG6129
MANG7001 Research Methods 2011-12
Sohail Yunise-mail : [email protected]
Collecting qualitative data
Slide 2MANG6129
You familiar with these terms??
• Population
• Sample
• Probability and Non-probability sampling
• Primary Data & Secondary Data
Slide 3MANG6129
Qualitative data collection methods
• Observation
• Interviews & Focus Groups
• Diaries (Reflexive & Photographic)
• Life Histories
• Narrative / story telling
• Secondary qualitative data
• Multiple Methods
Slide 4MANG6129
What will be your data collection method ?
• Purpose of your research• How much time you have• Your personal characteristics• Organisational access
Slide 5MANG6129
Who and how many?
Slide 6MANG6129
Who and how many?
• Non-probability sampling
– Purposive sampling– Snowball sampling– Convenience sampling– Quota sampling
Saunders et al (2009)
Slide 7MANG6129
Observation
Slide 8MANG6129
Observation
• Observational techniques are methods by which an individual or individuals gather first hand data on events, processes, or behaviours.
• Observer can use senses and technology to recoded events , process or behaviours.
• Extended period of time
Slide 9MANG6129
Observation
Can be• Non-participatory • Semi-participatory• Participatory
Can be Structured and unstructured
Can beCovert and overt
Slide 10MANG6129
Advantages of observation
• Explains ‘what is going on here?’
• Heightens researcher awareness
• Useful in researcher’s own organisation
• Experience emotions ‘for real’
• Lots of useful data
Slide 11MANG6129
Disadvantages of observation
• ‘Observer effect’
• Very time consuming
• Ethical dilemmas
• Role conflict (researcher vs colleague)
• Observer bias (going native)
• Very demanding (physically and emotionally)
• Access issues
• Data recording difficulties
Slide 12MANG6129
Interviews & Focus Groups
Slide 13MANG6129
Interviews• Definition
– A purposeful discussion between two or more people
• Use in research:– Preliminary: helps to clarify issues when formulating
research proposals– Data gathering: provides rigorous data for subsequent
analysis– Validation: helps to explore whether research
conclusions are reasonable
Slide 14MANG6129 Saunders et al (2006)
Forms of interview
Slide 15MANG6129
Structured Interviews• All questions (and most responses) are pre-determined
• Researcher is administering a questionnaire
• Approaches - Face-to-face, telephone, webcam
• Gathering structured data:– Higher response rate than postal questionnaires– Researcher has ability to clarify questions, not
possible with questionnaire– No unexpected issues can be explored
Slide 16MANG6129
Semi-structured Interviews• Based on list of themes & issues
– Used to focus discussion
• No rigid list is adhered to
• Approach - Face-to-face
• List of themes may be advised to interviewee
• Usually more emergent, less pre-defined, data
• Flexibility to explore particular and/or unexpected issues
Slide 17MANG6129
Unstructured Interviews
• Based on ideas of issues, but no list of questions or themes
• Mostly face-to-face
• Non-directive: researcher follows issues and themes as they emerge
• In-depth: research may concentrate on key emergent issues without feeling need to cover pre-determined list of questions/themes
Slide 18MANG6129
Focus Groups
• Also called “Group Interview”• Unstructured & Free flowing• Research = Facilitator
– Raise questions, let the group discuss• Multiple views• Group evaluation• Identify key themes• Potential problem of ‘group think’
Slide 19MANG6129
Types of questions…
•Closed vs. open
– Where do you live?– What time is it?– Are you happy with your current supplier? – Would you like to find a better supplier?
http://changingminds.org/techniques/questioning/open_closed_questions.htm
Slide 20MANG6129
Types of questions…
• Who, why, where, when, how and what
• Closed vs. open– What did you do on you holidays?– How do you keep focused on your work?– Why is that so important to you?– How have you been after your operation?
http://changingminds.org/techniques/questioning/open_closed_questions.htm
Slide 21MANG6129
Types of questions…
To Do•Probing… ‘can you tell me more about that?’
•Active listening… ‘so what you’re saying is…’
Avoid •Loaded/biased
•Double barrelled
Saunders et al (2009)
Slide 22MANG6129
Practical Issues
• Location
• Recording data– Tape/video recording
• Gives accurate account• Can concentrate on questioning & listening;• BUT… intrusive?
– Note taking• Difficulty of writing, listening, and questioning• Taking notes after the interview may be dangerous, as relying
on “accurate” memory
• Transcription
• Feeding back results
Slide 25MANG6129
How should you dress for data collection?…
1. Casual
2. Smart
Slide 26MANG6129
Some other tips for interviews
• Do a pilot study or interview a ‘critical friend’
• Allow plenty of travel time
• Take the respondent’s contact details with you
• Remember notes, pens, tape recorder, spare batteries, etc, etc.
• Remember… the interview doesn’t finish until you leave the premises
• Agree post-interview actions
Slide 27MANG6129
Reflexive diaries
• Daily record of actions, events, thoughts
• Quantitative (logs) or qualitative (diaries)
• Alternative to direct observation
• Issues of bias, motivation, misreporting
• Use as a basis for subsequent in-depth interviews
Hussey & Hussey (1997, pp.153-155)
Slide 28MANG6129
Photo/video diaries
Photos: Emma Lynch via http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/picture_gallery/07/americas_harvest_in_caracas/html/1.stm.
Photo journal: Harvest in CaracasChanging the way Venezuelan city dwellersthink about food through the creation of organicurban gardens to promote self-sufficiency
Slide 29MANG6129
Slide 30MANG6129
Life Histories
• Unstructured interviews combined with personal documents (diaries, letters, photos)
• Look back in detail over an entire life course
• Try to make sense of their organisational reality
Bryman and Bell (2003)
Slide 31MANG6129
Narrative in Research
• Originates in linguistics
• Used as research method & tool in various disciplines including:– Information Systems, Accounting,
Economics, Organisational Behaviour
• At the extreme end of qualitative research
Slide 32MANG6129
Aims of Narrative Research
• Gain insight into participant’s experience of an event and how they make sense of it (Organisational Sensemaking – Weick, 1995)– Imposes order on experiences, events, actions, and the relationship
between them
• Gather different perspectives about the same event
• Understanding interdependency between numerous social factors and the change that underpins the complexity
• Telling and analysis of stories
• Good for uncovering deep understanding of politics or culture
• Very subjective, requires understanding of context
Slide 33MANG6129
Online Narrative Resources…
• The Center for Narrative Studies– http://www.storywise.com/
• Organizational Storytelling– http://www.organizational-storytelling.org.uk/
Slide 34MANG6129
Secondary qualitative data• Data has already been collected
– Large surveys
– Commercial databases
– Qualidata, UK Data Archive, Economic and Social Data Service (www.qualidata.ac.uk)
– http://www.esds.ac.uk/search/allSearch.asp?ct=xmlAll&q1=&Submit1=GO&zoom_cat=-1&zoom_and=1
– http://www.soton.ac.uk/library/catalogues/index.shtml See Saunders et al (2009) Chapter 8, esp. pp.267-268.
Slide 35MANG6129
Other secondary sources
• Personal documents, letters, e-mails
• Historical diaries
• Autobiographies
• In-house publications
• Legal records
• Minutes of meetings
• Blogs / Social networking / Twitter... ???
Slide 36MANG6129
Secondary qualitative data
• Advantages
– Fewer resource requirements
– Allows for comparison over time & geographical locations
– Less effort/cost than primary data
Slide 37MANG6129
Secondary qualitative data• Disadvantages
– Purpose of original collection may not match research objective – context specific
– Access to this data may be restricted
– Type of data may not match research purpose exactly
– Quality of data (check for authenticity and credibility)
Slide 38MANG6129
Other considerations
•
• Cross-sectional vs longitudinal studies
mono method (single data collection and analysis procedure)
multiple methods(more than one data collection and analysis procedure)
Vs.
Saunders et al (2009, pp.151-156)
Slide 39MANG6129
Remember!
Any one data collection methods not inherently better than any other method.
Slide 40MANG6129