coastal ecosystems saving chesapeake bay? lecture 19 mar 27 ; nasa: phytoplankton pigment...

52
Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27 http://books.nap.edu/ ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing Wide Field-of-view Sensor (SeaWiFS). Excellent resource for info. on Chesapeake Bay and its struggles. http://www.chesapeakebay.net / Extra Credit Letter Due Apr. 4 th (Angel Dropbox) The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald --Gordon Lightfoot Shark in the Water --VV Brown Texas Flood Stevie Ray Vaughan

Upload: colleen-goodman

Post on 29-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Coastal EcosystemsSaving Chesapeake Bay?

Lecture 19Mar 27

http://books.nap.edu/ ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing Wide Field-of-view Sensor (SeaWiFS).

Excellent resource for info. on Chesapeake Bay and its struggles. http://www.chesapeakebay.net/

Extra Credit Letter Due Apr. 4th (Angel Dropbox)

The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald--Gordon Lightfoot

Shark in the Water --VV Brown

Texas FloodStevie Ray Vaughan

Page 2: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

• Homework 3 due Apr 1

Required Reading: Endangered sharks and rays win a modicum of protectionAppendix II of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES)

Read Chapter 15 and Website notesThanks to Rebecca W.

Page 3: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

I understand that extra credit letters are worth up to 5% of my final course grade, and:

A. are due Apr 4th and will be subject to electronic plagiarism checking and against previous papers submitted for this class

B. must be submitted as a file named with my name, for example Albert Einstein’s file would be: Einstein_Albert.doc or Einstein_Albert.pdf

C. are submitted via Angel Dropbox by uploading my file. I will not copy the text of my letter and paste it into the Angel page.

D. All of the above

E. I do not intend to submit and Extra Credit Letter

Page 4: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Corals forming reefs require:a) Clear, warm, shallow waters and sunlightb) High nutrients supplied in upwelling zonesc) Abundant dissolved silicon for their

skeletonsd) Cold water and dark conditionse) a and b

• Too many Nutrients:

Parrot fish eating blue-green algae which is growing over coral

Page 5: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Corals :a) Don’t need nutrients and sunlight because

they are really just rocks and are not alive. b) East mainly Small fish and shrimpc) Obtain 98% of their food from symbiotic,

photosynthetic algaed) Thrive in environments where suspended

sediment is high, such as near river mouthse) None of the above

Page 6: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The Chesapeake Bay watershed includes the Susquehanna River drainage (shown in green!)

Pennsylvania's massive Susquehanna river is Chesapeake bay's biggest tributary

Coastal EcosystemsEutrophication & Hypoxia

Page 7: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Chesapeake Bay: Is there a problem? (yes!)

Susquehanna River flooding, Port Deposit, Md

Pennsylvania's massive Susquehanna river is Chesapeake bay's biggest tributary

…Teeming with raw sewage, animal waste and fertilizer runoff, yet responsible for half the Chesapeake Bay's fresh water, the Susquehanna River is the most endangered river in the United States, according to a recent report by American Rivers, a national conservation group

Page 8: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Recall:Marine Photosynthesis 6CO2 + 6H2O + energy -->

C6H12O6 + 6O2

Requires Nutrients: such asCarbon/Nitrogen/Phosphorous

And the sources of these nutrients?In the Oceans:

Rivers, Upwelling, Mixing.

But too much of a good thing isn’t good! Eutrophication & Hypoxia

Page 9: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The Chesapeake Bay Watershed

• The Chesapeake Bay watershed includes the Susquehanna River system and the Potomac among other smaller rivers and tributaries. In all, parts of 6 states, including some large cities (e.g. Baltimore, Washington DC, Richmond) and industrial regions as well as extensive agricultural tracts, compose the watershed

• Chesapeake Bay is a drowned estuary, incised by rivers during the last glacial sealevel lowstand and flooded during glacial melting and accompanying sea level rise (by about 6 kyrs. ago)

Page 10: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

You are in the Chesapeake Bay watershed

• The Susquehanna River drains into Chesapeake Bay• PennState practices impact the Bay (you can “act locally”)

Page 11: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Key Definitions• Hypoxia--

development of low concentrations of dissolved oxygen. Primarily occurs near bottom and is deleterious to organisms (different organisms have different tolerances)

• Eutrophication-- an environmental

nutrient excess. Occurs when algal production of organic matter exceeds that which can be respired without reducing available dissolved oxygen below dangerous levels

Page 12: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

• Eutrophication-- nutrient excess that leads to excess algal

production of organic matter

Page 13: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The vicious cycle (Example of Chesapeake Bay):1. Excess nutrients supplied in rivers to the Bay support

luxurious blooms of phytoplankton (microscopic plants)2. sinking organic matter (that is, the phytoplankton, but

sewage and sludge have the same net effect) is oxidized by bacteria, thereby consuming oxygen

3. oxygen deficits occur in bottom waters--these are harmful to benthic organisms, many of which have economic value

4. the nutrients released during respiration in deeper waters are cycled back to the surface and produce more blooms and further organic matter loading

• a lack of mixing (stratification) resulting from seasonally strong salinity and temperature gradients (surface to bottom) prohibits oxygenation of bottom waters.

A Major Problem: Eutrophication

Page 14: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Linkages in the Bay

How does it work?

Page 15: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Phytoplankton Blooms in an Eutrophic Estuary

• Top panel--May 16, 1995 (source NOAA) Note gradient of chlorophyll concentrations (mg/liter)with highest values near river mouths

• Eutrophication leads to blooms of nuisance phytoplankton (low food value) and/or toxic “red tides” Note Ceratium dinoflagellate to right as an example.

Page 16: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Which of the following is/are true

A. Fishes and other animals require dissolved oxygen to live in seawater

B. Many species of fishes require dissolved oxygen levels of 4 mg/L or higher

C. Hypoxia and low levels of dissolved oxygen in the bottom waters of Chesapeake Bay are exacerbated by thermal stratification of the Bay water.

D. All of the aboveE. None of the above

Watershed for Chesapeake bay

Page 17: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Which of the following is/are true about Eutrophication

A. It starts with excess nutrients, which cause blooms of

algae

B. It involves bacteria that use (and eventually severely

deplete) dissolved oxygen in the process of

decomposing organic matter

C. It can be cause by sewage discharge into streams and

lakes

D. the nutrients released during respiration in deeper

waters are cycled back to the surface and produce

more blooms and further organic matter loading

E. All of the above

Page 18: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The vicious cycle (Example of Chesapeake Bay):1. Excess nutrients supplied in rivers to the Bay support

luxurious blooms of phytoplankton (microscopic plants)2. sinking organic matter (that is, the phytoplankton, but

sewage and sludge have the same net effect) is oxidized by bacteria, thereby consuming oxygen

3. oxygen deficits occur in bottom waters--these are harmful to benthic organisms, many of which have economic value

4. the nutrients released during respiration in deeper waters are cycled back to the surface and produce more blooms and further organic matter loading

• a lack of mixing (stratification) resulting from seasonally strong salinity and temperature gradients (surface to bottom) prohibits oxygenation of bottom waters.

A Major Problem: Eutrophication

Page 19: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The Energy Cycle

Note that photosynthesis (and formation of plant organic matter) requires sunlight and nutrients

Organic matter is consumed by animals and plants (respiration), supporting their growth

Nutrients must be “recycled” (excreted by animals, “regenerated” by bacteria) to be reused by plants

Photosynthesis

Consumers

Consumers

nutrients

Page 20: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

• Prolonged periods of dissolved oxygen below ~ 2 mg/L eliminate most “seafood” from the affected region

• Each organism has its own tolerance limits

• Values of dissolved oxygen at or above 5 mg/L are considered “healthy”

• During the summer, 30-40 % of the volume of the Bay experiences values <5 mg/L

A Major Problem: Hypoxia

Dis

solv

ed

Oxygen

C

on

cen

trati

ons

Page 21: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Oxygen Concentrations in Chesapeake Bay, Hypoxia

• Plan view and cross sections down the Bay showing seasonal contrasts (top March, bottom July) in dissolved oxygen concentration.

March

July

Page 22: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Oxygen Concentrations in Chesapeake Bay, Hypoxia• Plan view and

cross sections down the Bay showing seasonal contrasts (top March, bottom July) in dissolved oxygen concentration.

• Oxygen concentrations drop in July because of thermal stratification (reduced mixing) and increased deep respiration.

March

July

Page 23: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Dissolved Oxygen in Bottom Waters, Hypoxia

• Dissolved oxygen at the bottom varies over the seasons and by region in Chesapeake Bay.

• Note that summer warming and stratification can bring stressful or lethal conditions.

• The upper panel provides measurements for 2001-2 at the Bay Bridge, while the bottom panel shows measurements in the Potomac R. sector.

• Generally, oxygen deficiencies are more severe in the upper Bay.

Page 24: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

• Dissolved oxygen at the bottom varies over the seasons and by region in Chesapeake Bay.

• Note that summer warming and stratification can bring near lethal conditions.

Page 25: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Which of the following are true?A) Rainwater from State College ends up in The

Chesapeake BayB) Excess nutrients in The Bay, and other bodies

of water, can cause Eutrophication, which means that dissolved oxygen becomes very low

C) Hypoxia is primarily caused by strong winds, which blow away the clouds and evaporation

D) All of the aboveE) (A) and (B)

Page 26: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Oxygen Concentrations in Chesapeake Bay

A. Are generally higher in surface waters, because oxygen mixes into the water from the air

B. Are generally lower in bottom waters

C. Generally increase in bottom waters during summer when thermal stratification is strongest

D. All of the aboveE. (A) and (B)

Page 27: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Oxygen Concentrations in Chesapeake Bay

A. Can become dangerously low during winter when thermal stratification is strongest

B. Are especially low near the surface because of wind, waves and mixing

C. Become higher during periods of extreme eutrophication

D. Are only important for larger fishes; clams and snails can use oxygen from the H20 molecule

E. None of the above

Page 28: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Eutrophication and Hypoxia

• Dissolved oxygen in bottom waters varies over the seasons and by region in Chesapeake Bay.

• Note that summer warming and stratification can bring stressful or lethal conditions.

• Generally, oxygen deficiencies are more severe in the upper Bay.

Page 29: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

What’s the source of the problem?Source of Nutrients and Sediment

• Clearly, agricultural operations are a major source of nutrients on a per acre basis.

• Widespread adoption of “best practice” methods of tilling and fertilizer application would reduce runoff of nutrients

• Increasing forested regions and/or forest or wetland “buffers” along streams could also help reduce nutrient runoff.

Page 30: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Excess Nutrients and Sediment in the Bay

Page 31: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The Role of Forests and Wetlands• When colonists first

arrived virtually 100 % of the Chesapeake Bay watershed was forested.

• By 1850, about 50% of the forests were gone--to clearing for agriculture, timber harvested for building and for fuel.

Page 32: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Forests and Forest Buffers• When colonists first arrived

virtually 100 % of the Chesapeake Bay watershed was forested.

• By 1850, about 50% of the forests were gone--to clearing for agriculture, timber harvested for building and for fuel.

• Whole hillsides were stripped of cover and sediment eroded and carried to the Bay in the mid-19th Century.

• Seagrass beds and suitable habitats for Blue Crabs, oysters and other shellfish were destroyed as a result.

• Riparian woodlands are being replanted in new programs.

Page 33: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Progress in reducing Nutrient Discharges

• Phosphorus discharges were reduced after the early 1970s as result of ban on P in laundry detergents! (see, activism can help!).

• Nitrogen inputs, however, increased but have now started to level off.

• What are sources of N that could be reduced?

Page 34: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Progress in reducing Nutrient Discharges

http://www.chesapeakebay.net/indicators/indicator/reducing_nitrogen_pollution

Page 35: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Progress in reducing Nutrient Discharges

http://www.chesapeakebay.net/indicators/indicator/reducing_nitrogen_pollution

Page 36: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

• When colonists first arrived virtually 100 % of the Chesapeake Bay watershed was forested.

• By 1850, about 50% of the forests were gone--to clearing for agriculture, timber harvested for building and for fuel.

• Whole hillsides were stripped of cover and sediment eroded and carried to the Bay in the mid-19th Century.

• Seagrass beds and suitable habitats for Blue Crabs, oysters and other shellfish were destroyed as a result.

• Riparian woodlands are being replanted in new programs.

Forests and Forest Buffers

Page 37: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Other Impacts

• Sedimentation (particulates carried by rivers) and shading by phytoplankton blooms has contributed to reductions of the area of Bay grasses, which are habitats for many organisms, especially during larval stages.

• Bay grass distribution at present is probably only about 20% of the area once inhabited in the Bay. Some recovery is occurring as the result of efforts to reduce sediment and nutrient flux.

Page 38: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Oysters in Chesapeake Bay• Once plentiful in banks or

reefs in the Bay, oysters have been seriously overharvested and have declined for other reasons as well. Commercial landing plummeted around 1980 and have remained low (gray is MD, blue is VA data)

• Two viral diseases (MSX and Dermo) presently infect Bay oyster populations.

• In addition, bottom conditions have changed significantly over the past several decades (increased sedimentation, low oxygen).

Source: www.assateague.com

Page 39: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Blue Crab Holding Pattern

• Blue crab (Callinectes sapidus, meaning “beautiful swimmer”) stocks are presently on the verge of a potential decline in Chesapeake Bay. Fishing limits have been imposed, but more “management” may be necessary to preserve this resource. Read William Warner’s “Beautiful Swimmers” for a great treatment of Chesapeake Bay ecology as it existed in the 1970s.

Page 40: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

American Shad (a shad tale?)• Once very abundant in mid-

Atlantic region rivers, they nearly disappeared. Now making a slow recovery (note: well below carrying capacity) as result of restocking, harvest moratoriums and improved “fish passages.”

• Shad are very bony fish but delectable when cooked properly. Shad roe is a delicacy. See 2002 New Yorker article by John McPhee for very well written description and shad recipes.

Page 41: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Evidence of Improvement

Increased access to spawning grounds, moratoriums on catches and/or strict limits on harvest have increased striped bass stocks!

Page 42: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

The Chesapeake Bay Program Encourages Better Practices

• Voluntary programs of nutrient management appear to have worked to reduce nitrogen levels in many tributaries.

• New targets need to be set to continue the beneficial trend and to eliminate “hot spots.”

• Remember, you can make a difference!

Page 43: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Gulf of Mexico “Dead Zone”

Gulf of Mexico, associated with Mississippi River

“Hypoxia”: large area of oxygen- deficient seawater

Excess nutrients to blame?

Page 44: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Hypoxia in Long Island Sound Decreasing area of habitable seafloor as result of

increasing oxygen deficiency Factors: poor circulation (restricted exchange with

open waters) and eutrophication resulting from progressively increasing inputs of nutrients from land.

Page 45: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

http://www.chesapeakebay.net/

Page 46: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Nutrients that cause Eutrophication and, ultimately, Hypoxia include

A. NitrogenB. CalciumC. PhosphorousD. GatoradeE. (A) and (C)

Page 47: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Why are oxygen concentrations during times of eutrophication generally lowest in the upper Chesapeake Bay?

A. This is where the water is deepest?

B. This is where thermal stratification is weakest

C. This is where nutrients enter the bay, from the Susquehanna and other rivers

D. All of the aboveE. None of the above

Page 48: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Effects of Climate Change or Development?

Page 49: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Chesapeake Bay “Report

Card”

Page 50: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Eutrophication

A. Is a sign of a healthy ecosystem

B. Results from an excess of solar energy

C. Is accompanied by low surface-water productivity

D. Results from an excess of nutrients

E. All of the above

Page 51: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

Which of the following typically cause(s) excess nutrient and pollutant flows to rivers?

A. Croplands

B. Clearcut forest tracts

C. Storm water runoff

D. Automobile emissions

E. All of the above

Page 52: Coastal Ecosystems Saving Chesapeake Bay? Lecture 19 Mar 27  ; NASA: Phytoplankton pigment concentration data collected with the Sea-viewing

A. higher in the winter, in part because bacteria migrate south in winter

B. higher in the winter, in part because sunlight is stronger in winter

C. lower in the summer, in part because thermal stratification is greatest in summer

D. lower in the summer, in part because thermal stratification is weakest in summer

Eutrophication causes dissolved oxygen levels to be __: