cnk & associates llpincome computation and disclosure standards – background and general...
TRANSCRIPT
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 CNK & Associates LLP www.cnkindia.com
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 2 of 23
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARDS –
BACKGROUND AND GENERAL PRINCIPLES
1. Background
The Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS) earlier known as Tax Accounting
Standards (TAS) were first introduced by the CBDT in 2012. Initially 14 TAS were issued and on
basis of comments and suggestions received from the stakeholders, the CBDT revised and
issued 12 drafts ICDS for public comments in December 2014.
On 31st March, 2015, the Central Government notified 10 ICDS with effect from 1st April, 2015
vide notification No. 32/2015 [F.NO.134/48/2010-TPL] dated 31 March 2015. The introduction
of these ICDS will significantly alter the way the taxable income is computed and have a
significant impact on the tax computation. Though there have been various representations to
postpone the applicability of the ICDS, the same have not been acceded to.
Introduction of the ICDS will involve additional compliance and significant effort for computing
the taxable income. It will also lead to considerable increase in litigation as there is ambiguity
on the manner in which the tax is to be computed in accordance with the ICDS. There is likely to
be significant mismatch between the book profit under MAT and computation under normal
provisions which could lead to unintended double taxation.
Impact of the ICDS is to be disclosed in the Income Tax Return (ITR) forms for A.Y. 2016-17
relevant to financial year 2015-16 which have been notified by the CBDT on 30th March, 2016.
Disclosures as well as impact of the ICDS are also likely to be a part of the Tax Audit Report,
which has however not been notified till date.
The purpose of this note is to provide a general guideline on the major areas of likely impact on
the computation of income for the year ended 31st March 2016. For any specific query that you
may have, the Tax Team would be happy to assist.
2. General Principles
Following are the general principles regarding the ICDS:
(i) ICDS are applicable for computation of income chargeable under the head “Profits and
Gains from Business and Profession” and “Income from Other Sources”.
(ii) ICDS are applicable to all assessees.
(iii) ICDS are applicable only to taxpayers that follow mercantile system of accounting.
(iv) The ICDS are only for the purpose of computation of income and not for maintaining
books of accounts. However, practically one may need to prepare memorandum tax
accounts.
(v) ICDS is not applicable for computation of Book Profit for the purpose of MAT Provisions
under section 115JB.
(vi) In case of conflict between ICDS and the Income Tax Act, the provisions of the Act will
prevail.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 3 of 23
(vii) ICDS shall not apply to assessees not required to maintain books of account and
covered under the provisions of presumptive income as per sections 44AD and 44AE of
the Act.
(viii) Non-compliance of ICDS would result in Best Judgment Assessment as per the
provisions of Section 144 of the Act.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD I – ACCOUNTING POLICIES
Scope: ICDS I deals with significant accounting policies. The accounting policies refer to the specific accounting principles and the methods of applying those principles adopted by a person. Accounting policies are to be chosen to represent true and fair view of state of affairs and of the income and expenditure incurred during the year. The following are fundamental accounting assumptions that form the basis for maintenance of books of
accounts are as under:
a) Going Concern
b) Consistency
c) Accrual
If any of the above assumptions are not followed, it must be disclosed.
Comparison between AS and ICDS - Considerations for selection and change in accounting policies:
AS 1 – Disclosure of Accounting Policies ICDS I – Accounting Policies
Prudence
Concept of prudence is one of the fundamental pillars of accounting, which requires recognition of all expected losses and liabilities in the books on best estimate basis. Recognition of anticipated profits is not required.
The concept of ‘Prudence’ does not find place in ICDS. Hence Mark to Market losses are not to be recognized unless covered by any specific ICDS. For e.g. Mark to Market loss can be recognized on certain revenue items as per ICDS VIII on Effects of Fluctuation in Foreign Exchange. ICDS is silent on Mark to Market gains
Materiality
AII accounting and treatment of items based on materiality
The concept of ‘Materiality’ does not find place in ICDS. This could result in various adjustments to the computation of income such as small items of capital expenditure written off.
Substance over Form
The treatment and presentation of transactions and events are be governed by their substance and not merely by the legal form
Same as AS I
Change in Accounting Policy
Is allowed only if required by statute, or compliance with AS, or for more appropriate presentation
Permitted for any “reasonable cause”
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 4 of 23
Impact on Computation of Income / Disclosure requirements:
All significant policies should be disclosed.
If fundamental accounting assumptions are not followed, disclosure of the same is required.
Non recognition of Materiality would lead to increase in compliance burden and increase in cost of
compliance. One example could be of valuation of inventories, especially in case of services, since even
very insignificant items may have to be valued. Another example could be capitalization of small value
items as per accounting policy. Adjustments would need to be made in the computation of total
income.
Mark-to-market or expected loss not to be recognized unless otherwise provided by other ICDS
If a change is made in the accounting policy which has no material effect for the current year but which
is likely to have a material effect in later years, the fact of such change shall be appropriately disclosed
in the previous year in which the change is adopted
Transitional Provisions:
All contracts or transactions existing on the 1st day of April, 2015 or entered into on or after the 1st
day of April, 2015 have to be dealt with in accordance with the provisions of this standard after taking
into account the income, expense or loss, if any, recognised in respect of the said contract or
transaction for the previous year ending on or before the 31st March, 2015.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD II – VALUATION OF INVENTORIES
Scope:
ICDS II is applicable for valuation of inventories except:
a. Work-in-progress (WIP) arising under ‘Construction Contract’; b. WIP which is dealt with other ICDS; c. Shares, debentures and other financial instruments held as stock-in-trade which are dealt with
by ICDS on securities; d. Producers’ inventories of livestock, agriculture and forest products, minerals oils, ores and
gases to the extent that they are measured at NRV; e. Machinery spares which can be used only in connection with tangible fixed asset and their use
is expected to be irregular, which is dealt with the ICDS on tangible fixed assets. Inventories are defined as assets held for sale in the ordinary course of business, or in the process of
production for such sale, or in the form of materials or supplies to be consumed in the production
process or in the rendering of services.
The Net Realizable Value (NRV) of inventory is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of
business as reduced by the estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make
the sale.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 5 of 23
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Valuation:
AS 2 – Inventories ICDS II – Valuation of Inventories
Valuation of Inventories
At cost or NRV whichever is lower Same as AS
Valuation of work- in- progress (WIP) for Service Providers
Does not apply to WIP in the ordinary course of business of service providers.
Applicable to WIP arising in the course of business of service providers. Cost of Service would consist of labour and other cost of personnel directly engaged in providing the service including supervisory personnel and attributable overheads
Determination of cost of purchase
Cost of purchase would consist of purchase price, duties & taxes(other than recovered from tax authorities), freight inwards and other expenditure directly relating to acquisition
Same as AS
Valuation of inventories in case of dissolution of Partnership Firm, AOP/BOI
Silent. In case of dissolution of partnership firm, AOP/BOI, notwithstanding whether business is discontinued or not, the inventory on date of dissolution shall be valued at NRV.
Cost Formulae
Standard Cost is also acceptable cost formula Specific Identification for items that are not ordinarily interchangeable and goods/ services produced and segregated for specific projects. Items other than the above should be assigned by using FIFO or Weighted Average cost.
Other points to be considered:
Difficulty would arise in valuation of WIP of service provider in case of services whose chargeability
depends on success of the service, which are contingent in nature.
Valuation of inventory as per ICDS shall be at NRV on dissolution of Partnership firm, AOP, BOI
irrespective of whether the business is discontinued or not. The same is contrary to the law laid down in
Sakthi Trading Co v CIT [250 ITR 871 (SC)] and A.L.A Firm v CIT [189 ITR 285 (SC)]. Therefore, as per ICDS
even if the business is continued after dissolution, inventory should be valued at NRV.
Interest and Other Borrowing Cost shall not be included in the cost of inventories unless they meet the
criteria for recognition of interest as a component of the cost as specified in ICDS on borrowing cost (i.e.
where inventories require a period of twelve months or more to be in a saleable condition)
Method of valuation of inventory shall not be changed without reasonable cause; however reasonable
cause is not defined.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 6 of 23
Impact on Computation of Income and Disclosure Requirement:
Valuation of Inventory for service providers is required to be done.
Valuation of Inventory at NRV on dissolution of partnership firm/ AOP/BOI even if business is continued.
Accounting policies adopted in measuring inventories including cost formulae used; and total carrying
amount of inventories and its appropriate classification.
Transitional Provisions
Interest and other borrowing costs, which are included in the cost of the opening inventory as on the
1st day of April, 2015, shall continue to be taken into account for determining cost as long as it
continues to remain part of inventory.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD III- CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS
Scope:
This ICDS should be applied in determination of income of a contractor arising from construction
contract.
Construction contract is defined as a contract negotiated for the construction of an asset or assets that
are interrelated and interdependent in terms of their design, technology and function and includes
rendering of services related to the said construction. Construction contract would also include contract
for destruction or restoration of assets and restoration of environment following demolition of assets.
Comparison between AS and ICDS:
AS 7 – Construction Contracts ICDS III – Construction Contracts
Recognition of Revenue
Revenue shall be recognised using Percentage of Completion Method (POCM) if it is possible to reliably measure the outcome
Revenue is to be recognised using POCM if there is reasonable certainty of ultimate collection
Recognition of retention money
Silent on retentions Normally recognised only when right to receive such sum is established.
Retention money is to be included in the contract revenue as per POCM basis.
Recognition of Expected Loss
Is to be recognised in full To be recognised only when actually incurred following POCM- i.e. to the extent of percentage of completion
Recognition of Actual losses
Is to be recognised in full To be recognised to the extent of percentage of completion
Early stage of completion of contract
Does not define early stage of completion.
Early stage means contract which has not crossed 25% of its completion. For these contracts if outcome cannot be estimated revenue shall be recognised only to the
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 7 of 23
AS 7 – Construction Contracts ICDS III – Construction Contracts
extent of cost incurred. Therefore it is mandatory to recognise revenue once the contract extends beyond 25% of its stage of completion.
Contract Cost relating to future activity
It is to be recognised as an asset when it is probable that such costs are recoverable.
Recognised as an asset irrespective of probability of recovery.
Reversal of contract revenue recognised
Reversal of contract revenue booked as income is not allowed. However the same can be separately provided to reflect the uncertainty of collectability.
Will be allowed as a bad debt as per amended Sec. 36(1)(vii) of the Income Tax Act 1961 introduced by Finance Act 2015.
Other Points to be considered:
Contract revenue comprises of initial amount of revenue agreed in the contract including retentions
and variations in contract work, claims and incentive payments to the extent that it is probable that
they will result in revenue and are capable of being reliably measured.
Contract cost comprises of costs that relate directly to the specific contract, other allocable costs, such
other costs as are specifically chargeable to the customer under the terms of contract, allocated
borrowing costs in accordance with ICDS IX and costs that are incurred in securing the contract if they
can be separately identified and it is probable that the contract shall be obtained.
Stage of completion of a contract to be determined with reference to any of the following parameters:
a. Proportion of contract costs (Excluding Advance Payments to sub-contractors and costs that relate to future activity of the contract) incurred upto date of reporting to estimated total contract costs; OR
b. Survey of the work performed; OR c. Completion of the physical proportion of the work
The ICDS provides that progress payments and advances received from customers are not determinative of the stage of completion of a contract.
Impact on Computation of Income and Disclosure requirements:
Recognition of retention money as contract revenue will result into earlier taxability. Also, retention
money considered as income as per ICDS, may be accounted as income in the later years in the books of
accounts as per normal accounting practice when contract conditions are satisfied, which may result in
payment of tax under MAT, leading to double taxation.
Recognition of expected losses on POCM basis will have impact on book profits of later years and could
result into payment of taxes as per MAT provisions.
For entities following Completed Contract Method (CCM), use of POCM for computation of Income as
per ICDS will result in higher book profits in the year of recognition of revenue in the books of accounts,
resulting in payment of tax under MAT provisions leading to double taxation.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 8 of 23
Future / anticipated / actual losses are not fully deductible. Hence tax impact will be postponed basis
the percentage of work completed.
The amount of contract revenue recognised as revenue in the period and the methods used to determine the stage of completion of contracts in progress have to be disclosed.
In respect of contracts in progress on the reporting date, the amount of costs incurred and recognised profits (less recognised losses) upto the reporting date, amount of advances received and amount of retentions.
Transitional Provision:
Contracts commenced prior to 31st day of March, 2015, but pending completion as on 31st March 2015 shall be recognised in accordance with the provisions of ICDS using POCM.
Revenue, costs or expected loss, if any, recognised for the said contract for any previous year commencing on or before the 1st day of April, 2014 shall be taken into account for recognising revenue and costs of the said contract in the subsequent years.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD IV- REVENUE RECOGNITION
Scope:
This standard deals with recognition of revenue arising in the course of ordinary activities of a person
from sale of goods, from rendering of services or from the use by others of the person’s resources
yielding interest, royalties or dividends. This Standard would not apply to revenues dealt by other
specific ICDS e.g. Construction Contracts, Government Grants, Securities etc.
Comparison between AS 9 and ICDS IV:
AS 9 – Revenue Recognition ICDS IV- Revenue Recognition
Method to be adopted for recognizing revenue for service providers
Proportionate Completion Method or Completed Service Contract Method (CSCM)
Percentage Completion Method (POCM) except in early stages. Early stage means contract which has not crossed 25% of its completion. For such contracts, if outcome cannot be estimated revenue shall be recognised only to the extent of cost incurred. It is mandatory to recognise revenue once the contract extends beyond 25% of its stage of completion.
Concept of Prudence
Revenue to be recognised only if there is reasonable certainty of ultimate collection.
ICDS has not incorporated the concept of prudence. Hence revenue cannot be postponed merely on the grounds of inability
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 9 of 23
AS 9 – Revenue Recognition ICDS IV- Revenue Recognition
to measure the revenue reliably unless otherwise stated in any other ICDS
Foreseeable/ Estimated Losses
Estimated or imminent losses to be fully recognised irrespective of stage of completion
Can be recognised only to the extent of percentage of work completed
Reversal of revenue recognised
Reversal of revenue is not allowed, however provision to reflect the uncertainty of collectability should be made.
Will be allowed as a bad debt as per amended Sec. 36(1)(vii) of the Income Tax Act 1961 introduced by Finance Act 2015.
Other Points to be considered:
The provisions of ICDS III applicable to construction contracts on method of recognition of revenue and
associated cost shall apply to service providers on mutatis mutandis basis.
The stage of completion of service can be determined on the basis of percentage of cost incurred,
survey of work performed or completion of the physical proportion of the work.
As per the provisions of section 36(1)(vii), bad debt shall be allowed as a deduction in the computation
of income only if it was written off in the books of accounts. Income booked and treated as receivable
under ICDS may not get reflected as a debt in books of accounts following the principles of prudence.
The said amount offered to tax under ICDS turning bad therefore will not be written off as bad debt in
books of accounts. Since write off of debt in books is a condition for allowability of bad debt, proviso to
section 36(1)(vii) has been inserted permitting the claim of debt turning bad even if it is not written off
in the books of accounts.
In an agency business, revenue is the amount of commission.
Interest shall be determined on time basis based on the outstanding amounts and applicable interest
rates. Hence where interest accrues on a date other than 31st March, calculation of broken period
interest till the end of the year for each of the investments would need to be done if the ICDS is
applicable.
ICDS is not applicable to interest received on compensation or enhanced compensation and it is to be offered to tax as per the provisions of Section 145A (b) i.e. on receipt basis.
Effect on Computation of Income/ Disclosure requirements:
Taxpayers, who were following CSCM for the purpose of accounting as well as for computation of Income, will now be required to follow POCM as per ICDS. This would result in preponing of income and consequential tax thereon. Since there is no materiality threshold, all service providers would be impacted. Use of POCM for computation of Income as per ICDS would result in higher book profits in the year of recognition of revenue in the books of accounts following CSCM, this could result in payment of tax under MAT provisions leading to double taxation.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 10 of 23
Unlike ICDS since AS 9, permits recognition of revenue on "systematic & rational basis” the same may result into difference in recognition of income as per books and as per ICDS.
If the security is sold before interest is received, the interest upto the date of sale will be taxable in the hands of the transferor though the same will actually be received by the transferee.
In a transaction involving sale of goods, total amount not recognised as revenue during the previous year due to lack of reasonable certainty of its ultimate collection along with nature of uncertainty.
The amount of revenue from service transactions recognised as revenue during the previous year and the method used to determine the stage of completion of service transactions in progress. For service transactions in progress at the end of previous year, the amount of costs incurred and recognised profits (less recognised losses) up to end of previous year, the amount of advances received, and the amount of retentions.
Transitional Provisions:
Services commenced prior to 31st day of March, 2015, but pending completion as on 31st March 2015 shall be recognised in accordance with the provisions of ICDS using POCM considering revenue, costs or expected loss, if any, already recognised. If foreseeable loss is already recognised in past, transitional provision does not require reversal on account of applicability of this Standard. Test for recognition of revenue from other than service transaction continues to be the same and hence may not have any transitional impact.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD V- TANGIBLE FIXED ASSETS
Scope:
This ICDS deals with the treatment of tangible fixed assets.
Comparison between AS and ICDS
AS 10 – Accounting for Fixed Assets ICDS V – Tangible Fixed Assets
Applicability
It deals with all fixed assets including goodwill except forest, wasting assets, and livestock.
It deals only with tangible fixed assets such as land, building, machinery, plant, furniture held with the intention of being used for the purpose of producing or providing goods or services and is not held for sale in the normal course of business.
Cost of Fixed Asset
The cost of an item of fixed asset comprises its purchase price, including import duties and other non-refundable taxes or levies and any directly attributable cost of bringing the asset to its working condition for its intended use. Any trade discounts and rebates are deducted
It is similar as stated in AS 10 except the words used are “actual cost” instead of cost as per AS 10.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 11 of 23
AS 10 – Accounting for Fixed Assets ICDS V – Tangible Fixed Assets
in arriving at the purchase price.
Determination of actual cost of tangible Fixed Asset acquired in exchange of another assets or in exchange of shares or other securities
In case of acquisition of a fixed asset in exchange of another asset, the cost shall be determined by reference either to the asset given up or asset acquired whichever is more clearly evident.
In case of acquisition of a fixed asset in exchange of shares or others securities, the cost shall be the fair market value of the asset acquired or fair market value of securities given up whichever is more clearly evident.
In case of acquisition of a tangible fixed asset in exchange of another asset, the fair value of the tangible fixed asset so acquired shall be treated as its actual cost.
In case of acquisition of a tangible fixed asset in exchange of shares or other securities, the fair value of the tangible fixed asset so acquired shall be treated as its actual cost.
Valuation of assets in special cases
In case of hire purchase transaction Assets are required to be recorded at their cash value by the hirer.
Assets purchased for consolidated price Apportioned on fair basis as determined by competent valuer’s report.
In case of hire purchase transaction Silent on this issue.
Assets purchased for consolidated price Apportioned on “fair basis”.
Treatment of expenditure incurred during the interval when the project was ready to commence its production and actual production:
Expenditure incurred during this interval should be written off as expense or may in certain cases be deferred over a period of 3-5 years after commencement of production.
Silent on the treatment of expenses.
Treatment of Inspection Cost
Inspection cost incurred at the time of initial installation of tangible fixed asset should be capitalised. However, cost incurred after initial installation shall be charged to Profit & Loss A/C.
Silent on the treatment of inspection cost. It is merely stated that any expenditure which increases future benefits beyond its previously assessed performance, can be added to the cost of the asset. Since inspection cost does not normally increase future benefits, it would not be permitted under ICDS to be added to the cost of fixed asset.
Treatment of Revaluation of Assets
AS deals with revaluation of fixed assets and the accounting treatment and disclosures.
ICDS does not deal with revaluation. As per the Income Tax Act, revaluation is not considered as an adjustment to the cost of the asset. The effect of revaluation is also ignored for computation of book profit for the purpose of MAT.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 12 of 23
Other Points to be considered:
Actual Cost
As per ICDS, actual cost of fixed assets includes purchase price, import duties and other non-refundable
taxes or levies and any directly attributable cost of bringing the asset to its working condition for its
intended use. Any trade discounts and rebates are deducted in arriving at the purchase price.
Actual cost is defined in section 43(1) of the Income Tax Act which as actual cost of assets to the
assessee reduced by that portion of cost as has been met directly or indirectly by any other person or
authority.
In case of any difference in ICDS and the Act, the provisions of the Act shall prevail.
Fair Basis as per ICDS
Since fair basis is not defined under ICDS it would become subjective and be prone to litigation.
Impact on Computation of Income/ Disclosure Requirements: Following disclosures are to be made in respect of tangible fixed assets:
Description of asset or block of assets, rate of depreciation, actual cost or opening WDV of the asset,
additions with date of put to use or deductions during the year with dates, adjustment relating to
foreign exchange fluctuation, subsidy or reimbursement received, Vat claimed and allowed,
depreciation and WDV of the asset at the end of the year
Transitional Provisions:
The actual cost of tangible fixed assets, acquisition or construction of which commenced on or before
the 31st day of March, 2015 but not completed by the said date, shall be recognised in accordance with
the provisions of this standard. The amount of actual cost, recognised for the said assets for any earlier
years shall be considered. Depreciation will be dealt with under the provisions of the Act.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD VI – EFFECTS OF CHANGES IN FOREIGN
EXCHANGE RATES
Scope:
ICDS VI on Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates deals with treatment of transactions in foreign
currencies, translating the financial statements of foreign operations and treatment of foreign currency
transactions in the nature of forward exchange contracts
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Applicability and Valuation:
AS 11 -- Effects Of Changes In Foreign Exchange Rates
ICDS VI - Effects Of Changes In Foreign Exchange Rates
Foreign Exchange Fluctuations on Monetary Items
Gain or Loss to be accounted on actual settlement. Same as AS 11, subject to provisions of section
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 13 of 23
AS 11 -- Effects Of Changes In Foreign Exchange Rates
ICDS VI - Effects Of Changes In Foreign Exchange Rates
If monetary items are outstanding at year end, it should be Marked to Market (MTM) by applying closing rate
43A read with Rule 115 for acquisition of fixed assets from a country outside India wherein the foreign exchange fluctuation on actual settlement would be adjusted against the cost of asset.
Foreign Exchange Fluctuations on Non-Monetary Items
Non-Monetary Items carried at historical cost
Converted at the exchange rate on date of transaction
Converted at the exchange rate on date of transaction
Non-Monetary Items carried at fair value
Converted at closing rate Exchange difference on conversion at the closing rate is not considered as income or expense.
Integral Operations (eg. Liaison Office)
Monetary Items
To be converted at closing rate Same as AS 11, subject to provisions of section 43A read with Rule 115 for acquisition of fixed assets from a country outside India wherein the foreign exchange fluctuation on actual settlement would be adjusted against the cost of asset.
Non-monetary Items
To be converted at closing rate Such exchange difference is not recognized as income or expenses.
Non-integral Operations (eg. Independent Branch)
Capital Items both monetary and non-monetary:
MTM gains/ losses to be transferred to Foreign Currency Translation Reserve
Converted at closing rate
Revenue Items
MTM gains/ losses to be transferred to Foreign Currency Translation Reserve
Converted at the exchange rate on the date of transaction/ closing rate as applicable
Forward Exchange Contracts
For Trading/Speculation/Firm Commitments/Highly Probable Forecast
Loss or Gain is to be accounted on MTM basis Loss or Gain including premium/ discount is to be recognized on actual settlement
For Other Contracts:
Premium/Discount is to be amortized over the life of the contract. Loss or gain is accounted on MTM Basis
Premium/Discount is to be amortized over the life of the contract. Loss or gain is allowed on MTM Basis
Other points to be considered:
Translation and recognition of exchange differences in cases referred to in section 43A or Rule 115 shall
be carried out in accordance with the provisions contained therein
When there is a change in the classification of a foreign operation, the translation procedures
applicable to the revised classification should be applied from the date of change in the classification.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 14 of 23
No distinction between capital and revenue items. Hence MTM gains/ losses to be recognized even on
tangible fixed assets in case of non-integral operations.
ICDS does not make a distinction between capital and revenue
Effects on Computation of Income/ Disclosure requirements:
In case of monetary items, gain or loss is to be recognized on MTM basis, subject to the provisions of
Section 43A of the Act and Rule 115 of Income Tax Rules.
However this may be contrary in case of exchange fluctuation on capital assets (other than imported
assets) where section 43A does not apply.
In case of non-monetary items carried at historical cost, there will be no impact on the computation. In
case of non-monetary items carried at fair value, ICDS does not permit recognition of exchange
difference. Hence the exchange gain/loss as per books of accounts will have to be reduced/added back
while computing income.
In case of trading/speculation/firm commitments/highly probable forecast, loss or gain has to be
adjusted only at the time of settlement; resulting in mismatch between book profit and taxable income.
Forex derivatives like cross currency swaps, interest rate swaps are not covered by this ICDS. Hence
MTM losses or expected losses on such contracts may not be deductible in view of the provisions of
ICDS 1.
Transitional Provisions:
All foreign currency transactions undertaken on or after 1st April, 2015 would be recognized in
accordance with the ICDS
Exchange differences arising in respect of monetary items or non-monetary items, on settlement during
the year or on conversion at the last day of the year would be recognised in accordance with the
provisions of this ICDS after taking into account amount already recognised in the earlier years.
Financial statements of foreign operations would be translated using principles and procedures
specified in this ICDS after taking into account amount already recognised in the earlier years.
All forward exchange contracts existing on 1st April, 2015 or entered thereafter would be dealt with in
accordance with the provisions of this ICDS after taking into account income or expenses recognised in
earlier years.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD VII – GOVERNMENT GRANTS
Scope
ICDS VII deals with the treatment of government grants. “Government grants” are defined as assistance
by government in cash or kind to a person for past or future compliance. Government grants can be in
the form of subsidies, cash incentives, duty drawbacks, waiver, concessions, reimbursements, etc.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 15 of 23
However this ICDS does not deal with government assistance other than in the form of government
grants and government participation in the ownership of the enterprise
Recognition Criteria
Government grants are to be recognized only when there is a reasonable assurance that the person
shall comply with the conditions attached to them and the grant would be received. However
recognition cannot be postponed beyond the date of actual receipt.
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Recognition and Treatment of Government Grants
AS 12 – Accounting for Government Grants ICDS VII – Government Grants
Recognition of Government Grants:
When there is reasonable assurance that the person would comply with the conditions attached to them and grant would be received
When there is reasonable assurance that the person would comply with the conditions attached to them and the grant would be received. However recognition cannot be postponed beyond the date of actual receipt.
For Depreciable Assets:
Can be reduced from the asset or can be treated as deferred income over the useful life of the asset
Must be reduced from the cost of the asset or from the WDV of block of assets. No option to recognize as deferred income over the useful life.
For Non-Depreciable Assets or Assets requiring fulfilment of certain obligations:
Can be reduced from the cost of the asset or credited to the capital reserve
To be treated as deferred income over the period over which the cost of obligation is charged to income Grant for non-depreciable asset with no obligation may be required to be recognized upfront as income, in the year of recognition.
For Other Grants:
Treated as income in the year of receipt Same as AS 12
For Non-Monetary Assets given at concessional rate:
To be accounted for on the basis of their acquisition cost
Same as AS 12
For Compensation of Expense/ Loss:
Recognised in the year in which the grant is receivable.
Same as AS 12
Other Points to be considered:
This ICDS does not cover grants in the nature of promoter’s contribution.
Where the government grant is not directly relatable to the asset acquired, amount of grant will be
proportionately reduced from the cost/WDV of the assets for which the grant is received.
Section 2(24)(xviii) is amended by the Finance Act, 2015 to include assistance in the form of subsidy or
grant or cash incentive or duty drawback or waiver concession or reimbursement by whatever name
called by any government authority.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 16 of 23
In case of refund of government grants:
In case of fixed assets – actual cost or WDV to be increased
(i) Depreciation on revised value to be provided prospectively
(ii) If refund exceeds any deferred credit or where no deferred credit exists – amount to be
charged to Profit & Loss Account.
Impact on Computation of Income/ Disclosure requirements:
ICDS requires recognition of subsidy related to non-depreciable assets as income or as deferred income
if there is a cost of obligation, as against treatment in the books, where it is reduced from the asset or
shown as capital reserve.
Nature and extent of government grants deducted from the actual cost of asset or WDV during the
previous year
Nature and extent of government grants recognized during the year as income
Nature and extent of government grants not recognized by way of deduction from actual cost of asset
or WDV
Nature and extent of government grants not recognized as income during the year
Transitional Provisions:
All Government grants which meet recognition criteria to be recognised for the previous year
commencing on or after 1st April, 2015 in accordance with the provisions of this ICDS after taking into
account the amount of the Government grant recognised for any earlier years.
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD VIII – SECURITIES
Scope:
ICDS VIII deals with securities held as stock-in-trade. However, it does not apply to -
a) Insurance Companies; Mutual Funds; Venture Capital Funds; Banks; Public Financial Institutions
b) Derivatives in view of the specific definition of Securities in the Standard The standard may not be applicable to FIIs/FPIs, since securities are deemed to be capital assets in their
hands as per amendment in Section 2(14) of the Act defining Capital Asset.
Recognition:
Securities to be recognised at actual cost which includes purchase price, brokerage, fees, tax, duty, or
cess.
Securities acquired in exchange of another security / asset, actual cost will be the fair value of security /
asset acquired.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 17 of 23
Securities held as stock-in-trade are to be valued at cost initially recognised or net realisable value
whichever is lower.
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Applicability and Valuation:
AS 13- Accounting for Investments ICDS VIII - Securities
Applicability
Covers long term, current investments but excludes Securities held as stock in trade
Deals only with Securities held as stock in trade
Approach for Year-End Valuation
Individual Security Approach for year-end valuation
Portfolio (Bucket) Approach for year-end valuation
Valuation of Unquoted Investments
Unquoted Investments valued at lower of cost or net realizable value
Unquoted investment to be valued at cost
Method of Valuation
Weighted Average Method to be used to determine the cost where specific identification not possible
FIFO method to be used to determine the cost where specific identification not possible
Impact of Portfolio (Bucket) Approach can be understood by the following example:
Individual Security Cost NRV Valuation
Company A 100 25 25
Company B 100 35 35
Company C 100 20 20
Company D 100 300 100
400 380 180
Valuation (AS-13) 180
Valuation (under ICDS) 380
Other Points to be considered:
Loss, if any, in value of unquoted investments would be realizable only on disposal.
The comparison of actual cost and NRV should be done category-wise and not for each individual
security. The securities are to be classified into following categories:
(a) Shares
(b) Debt Securities
(c) Convertible Securities
(d) Any other securities not covered above
ICDS does not specify when securities can be considered as stock-in-trade. Therefore, if the Assessing
Officer takes a stand, that securities are stock in trade and not investments as disclosed by assessee, the
applicability of this Standard will have to be considered.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 18 of 23
Impact on Computation of Income:
For the purpose of computation of income, any reduction in value within a class of asset would be off-
set against the gains within that class. In other words, Portfolio (Bucket) approach results in accelerated
taxation of appreciation.
Where a security becomes thinly traded during a particular year, there could be a notional gain in that
year as that security may need to be recognized at cost.
In case of conversion of convertible debentures/bonds etc. held as stock in trade to equity shares, fair
value of equity shares would be considered as cost of shares, which will also result in notional gain/loss.
Interest relating to a period prior to acquisition of a debt security must be reduced from the cum-
interest cost.
Where the actual cost initially recognized cannot be ascertained with reference to specific
identification, the cost shall be determined on FIFO basis. Since weighted average cost cannot be used
to determine actual cost, it could have a significant impact on the income computation (for example in
case of sale of bonus shares).
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD IX- BORROWING COSTS
Scope
ICDS IX deals with treatment of borrowing cost. However it does not deal with the actual or imputed
cost of owner’s equity and preference share capital.
Definition
Borrowing costs are interest and other costs incurred by a person in connection with the borrowing of
funds and include:
i. Commitment charges on borrowings;
ii. Amortised amount of discounts or premiums relating to borrowings;
iii. Amortised amount of ancillary costs incurred in connection with the arrangement of
borrowings;
iv. Finance charges in respect of assets acquired under finance leases or under other similar
arrangements.
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Qualifying assets and capitalisation
AS 16 – Borrowing Costs ICDS IX – Borrowing Cost
Qualifying Assets
A qualifying asset is an asset that necessarily takes a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale. Ordinarily a period of twelve months is considered as a substantial period of time.
Land, building, machinery, plant or furniture, being tangible assets; Know-how, patents copyrights, trademarks, licenses, franchises or any other business or commercial rights of similar nature, being
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 19 of 23
AS 16 – Borrowing Costs ICDS IX – Borrowing Cost
intangible assets;(Not included in the definition of qualifying asset as per AS 16) Inventories that require a period of twelve months or more to bring them to saleable condition.
Commencement of Capitalisation
Date when activities necessary for construction/production/acquisition of an asset commence.
In case of general borrowing, from date on which funds were utilised. In case of specific borrowing, from date on which funds were borrowed.
Quantification of Borrowing Costs
Funds borrowed specifically for acquisition/construction/production of qualifying asset should be capitalized at the actual cost of borrowings incurred during the period the funds were so borrowed. The amount of borrowing costs eligible for capitalisation should be determined by applying a capitalisation rate to the expenditure on that asset.(The capitalisation rate should be the weighted average rate of the borrowing costs applicable to the borrowings of the enterprise that are outstanding during the period)
Funds borrowed specifically for acquisition/construction/production of qualifying asset should be capitalized at the actual cost of borrowings incurred during the period the funds were so borrowed. The amount of borrowing costs to be capitalized for funds borrowed generally and utilized for the purposes of acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying assets shall be as per the following formula: A*B/C where, A = borrowing costs incurred excluding borrowing directly relatable to specific purpose B = (i) Average cost of qualifying asset as
appearing in the balance sheet on first day and last day of the previous year. OR
(ii) Where the qualifying asset does not appear in the balance sheet on first day or both on first day and last day of the previous year; half of cost of such qualifying asset OR (iii) Where the qualifying asset does not appear in the balance sheet on last day of the previous year, average of cost of such qualifying asset on first day of the previous year and on the date the said asset is put to use or completion as the case may be.
C = Average of total assets as appearing in the balance sheet on first day and last day of the previous year.
Suspension of capitalization
When development of asset/inventory is interrupted.
No such provision in ICDS. Hence capitalisation will continue even during interruption of development of asset.
Cessation of capitalization
When substantially all activities necessary to prepare asset for intended use are complete.
When asset is first put to use for qualifying asset other than inventory and in case of inventory
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 20 of 23
AS 16 – Borrowing Costs ICDS IX – Borrowing Cost
when substantially all the activities necessary to prepare such inventory for its intended sale are complete.
Exchange differences arising from foreign currency borrowings to the extent regarded as interest costs
Borrowing cost include exchange differences arising from foreign currency borrowings to the extent they are regarded as an adjustment to interest cost.
These are not treated as borrowing costs under ICDS.
Interest on temporary investment from borrowed funds
Interest received on temporary investments from borrowed funds is reduced from borrowing costs to be capitalised
No such provision thereby implying that the same is liable to tax which is in accordance with the judicial precedents in this regard.
Other Points to be considered:
Interest attributable to any tangible or intangible asset after the same is put to use is to be treated as
revenue expense.
Interest on capital contributed by partners of firms/LLP may not be considered as borrowing cost.
Impact on Computation of Income/ Disclosure requirements:
The assets capitalized as per books and those capitalized as per ICDS may differ on account of difference
in definition in qualifying asset, difference in timing of commencement of capitalisation, suspension and
cessation of capitalisation.
Section 36(1)(iii) of the IT Act, has been amended with effect from AY 2016-17 to provide that interest
on funds borrowed and utilized for acquisition of an asset from the date on which borrowing was
done for acquisition of the asset till the date on which such asset is put to use, would not be allowed
as deduction. Hitherto such restriction for allowability of interest was applicable only for acquisition
of asset for extension of existing business.
Disclosure in respect of the accounting policy adopted for borrowing costs and the amount of borrowing cost capitalized during the year is required to be made.
Transitional Provision:
ICDS will have impact only on interest expense incurred on or after 1st April, 2015 after taking into
account the amount of borrowing cost capitalized, if any, for the earlier years.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 21 of 23
INCOME COMPUTATION AND DISCLOSURE STANDARD X – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT ASSETS
AND CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
Scope:
ICDS X deals with provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets. This ICDS does not apply to
provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets resulting from financial instruments, executory
contracts, insurance business from contracts with policy-holders, and those covered by another ICDS
such as Valuation of Inventories, Construction Contracts and Revenue Recognition.
Comparison between AS and ICDS – Recognition:
AS 29 - Provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets.
ICDS X - Provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets.
For Provisions:
Provision shall be recognized when: (i) It is as a result of a past event (ii) There is a probability of an outflow of
economic resources to settle the obligation (iii) Reliable estimate can be made of the
obligation
Provision shall be recognized when: (i) It is as a result of a past event (ii) There is a reasonable certainty of an
outflow of economic resources to settle the obligation
(iii) Reliable estimate can be made of the obligation
For Contingent Liabilities:
Not to be recognized Same as AS 29
For Contingent Assets:
To be recognized if inflow of economic benefit is virtually certain
To be recognized if inflow of economic benefit is reasonably certain
Other Points to be considered:
No provision is to be recognized for costs to be incurred to operate in future
Provision is not to be discounted to Net Present Value
Provision for depreciation, impairment of assets and doubtful debts is not covered by this ICDS
In case of proposed law – obligation arises only when legislation is enacted
Amount recognized as provision should be best estimate of expenditure required to settle present
obligation at the end of the year. When expenditure required to settle a provision is expected to be
reimbursed, the reimbursement should be recognized based on reasonable certainty of receipt
When a person is jointly and severally liable for the obligation, it is a contingent liability to the extent it
is expected that the obligation will be settled by other parties.
All provisions, contingent liabilities and contingent assets are to be reviewed at the end of the previous
year and adjusted to reflect best estimate. Reversal of provisions is also possible.
Second proviso to Section 36(1)(vii) has been inserted in the Act to provide for deduction of bad debts,
in regard to income recognized as per the ICDS without recording in the books of account, in the year
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 22 of 23
in which such debt becomes irrecoverable. Such income is deemed to be written off in the books of
accounts.
ICDS is silent on onerous contracts
Impact on Computation of Income/ Disclosure requirements:
Recognition of provision on the basis of “Reasonable Certainty” as against “Probability” may result in
postponement of recognition of expenses. Recognition of income on the basis of “Reasonable
Certainty” as against “Virtual Certainty” would result in accelerated recognition of income. This could
also result in MAT mismatch. Since reasonable certainty is not defined in the Standard, it could lead to
litigation.
Following disclosures are to be made:
For each class of provision:
Brief description of nature of obligation, carrying amount at the beginning and end of the year,
additional provisions made during the year, amounts incurred and charged against the provision
during the year, unused amounts reversed during the year, and amount of any expected
reimbursement.
For each class of asset and related income:
Brief description of nature of asset, carrying amount at beginning and end of the year, additional
amounts recognized during the year, and amount reversed during the year.
Transitional Provisions:
Recognition of all provisions and recognition of all assets and related income should be as per the ICDS
for the previous year commencing on or after 1st April, 2015 after reducing amounts recognized, if any
earlier.
CNK Direct Tax Tracker Issue 2 of 2016-17 For Private Circulation only
CNK & Associates LLP Page 23 of 23
DISCLAIMER AND STATUTORY NOTICE
This e-publication is published by CNK & Associates, LLP, Chartered Accountants, India, solely for the purposes of
providing necessary information to employees, clients and other business associates. This publication summarises
the important statutory and regulatory developments. Whilst every care has been taken in the preparation of this
publication, it may contain inadvertent errors for which we shall not be held responsible. The information given in
this publication provides a bird’s eye view on the recent important select developments and should not be relied
solely for the purpose of economic or financial decision. Each such decision would call for specific reference of the
relevant statutes and consultation of an expert.
This document is a proprietary material created and compiled by CNK & Associates LLP. All rights reserved. This
newsletter or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or sold in any manner whatsoever without the consent
of the publisher.
This publication is not intended for advertisement and/or for solicitation of work.
Our Offices
Bengaluru Chennai
96, 7th Cross, "Brindavan",
Domlur, Old No.23, New No.13,
Bengaluru - 560 071 Mc Nichols Road, Chetpet
Tel. No.+91 80 2535 1353 Chennai - 600 031
Tel. No.+91 44 4384 9695
Dubai Mumbai
Suite#17.06 Dubai World Trade Centre Mistry Bhavan, 3rd Floor,
Shaikh Zayed Road, Dubai, P.O.Box.454442 Dinshaw Vachha Road, Churchgate
Tel. No. +971 04 355 9533 Mumbai 400020
Tel No. +91 22 6623 0600
Mumbai (Suburban Office) Pune
501/502, Narain Chambers, 4, Kumar Panorama, 1st
Floor
M.G. Road, Vile Parle ( East) 45/18 Shankerseth Road
Mumbai 400 057 Pune 411 037
Tel No:91 22 6457 7600/01/02 Tel No: 91 20 26457251/52
Vadodara
C-201/202, Shree Siddhi Vinayak Complex,
Faramji Road,
Alkapuri,
Baroda - 390 005
Tel. No. +91 265 234 3483