clerk u.s. district court apr 2 i 2011court.cacd.uscourts.gov/cacd/recentpubop.nsf... · trendy...
TRANSCRIPT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
FILED CLERK U.S. DISTRICT COURT
APR 2 I 2011
C NTRAL DISTRICI OF CALIFORNIA BY "DEPUTY
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
11 MATTEL INC., Case No: CV 04-09049-DOC (RNBx)
12 Plaintiff,
13 v.
14 MGA ENTERTAINMENT INC., ET AL.
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Defendant.
VERDICT FORM - REDACTED
-
VERDICT FORM
We answer the questions submitted to us as follows:
MatteI's Claim for Declaratory Relief 1. Has MatteI proven that it owns the following:
Yes No Four Sketches:
V TX 5-39, TX 5-40, TX 5-41, TX 5-42 Pitchbook: TX 1, TX 2, TX 5-102, TX 5-103, TX 5-104, TX 5-105, TX 5-106, TX 5-107, V TX 302, TX 323 Notarized Drawings: TX 5-52 (also TX 62-1),5-54 (also TX 62-2),5-55 (als9_ TX 62-3), 5-61 (also TX 62-4),5-62 (also TX 62-5),5-64 (also TX 62-6), 5--67 V (also TX 62-7), 5-68 (also TX 62-8), 5-70 (also TX 62-9), TX 62-10 through 15 Fashion Drawings:
~ TX 1107, TX 1108, TX 1109, TX 1110, TX 5-30, TX 5-51, TX 5-96 Sculptural Head and Body Drawings:
V TX 5-88, TX 5-89 (also 1129), TX 1327, TX 1328 Formalwear Drawings:
", TX 5-26, TX 5-27, TX 5-79, TX 5-80, TX 5-81, TX 5-82, TX 5-83, TX 5-84, ~ TX 5-85, TX 5-86, TX 5-87, TX 5-108, TX 10-2 Posterboards: TX 3-1 (also TX 779), TX 3-2, TX 3-3, TX 3-4, TX 3-5 (also
V ~ TX 791), TX 3-6, TX 3-7, TX 3-8, TX 3-9, TX 3-10, TX 3-11, TX 3-12, TX 3-13
Line Drawings & Notes: TX 5-38, TX 5-46, TX 5-53, TX 5-56, TX 5-58, TX 5-59, TX 5-60, TX 5-63,
V ,. TX 5-66, TX 5-72, TX 5-73, TX 777, TX 5-43, TX 5-35, TX 5-36, TX 5-37, TX 5-49, TX 5-50, TX 5-65, TX 5-69 ~ Sculpts: TX 1136A; TX 1141
V" 2. Has MatteI proven that it owns the following:
Yes No The idea for the name "Bratz" V The concept for a multi-ethnic group of hip, urban, edgy, trendy fashion dolls and accessories that are high school friends with attitude, distinctive names, nick names, fashions, personalities, back stories and mascots, as well
V as teen age girls fashion dolls and accessories, collectively known as "Bratz," including designs for large, oversized heads and feet, large eyes, large lips, and small, almost non-existent noses, and small bodies.
1
! .. I, __ ~ _______ ._~
MatteI's Claim for Copyright Infringement
3. Has Mattei proven that the First Generation Cloe doll (TX 12286), the First Generation Sasha poll (TX 17558), the First
Generation Jade Doll (TX 17551), the First Generation Hallidae Doll (TX 17561), the Fonnal Funk Dana Doll (TX 17529),
and/or the Ooh La La Cloe Doll (TX 17540) infringed creative works in which MatteI owns a valid copyright? To detennine
whether MatteI owns a valid copyright in a particular creative work, refer to your answers to question 1.
Yes ---- No ___ _ ~ Proceed to Question 4.
4. Has MatteI proven that the First Production Sculpt (TX 17732) and/or the Second Production Sculpt (TX 17733) infringed
creative works in which Mattei owns a copyright? To detennine whether Mattei owns a valid copyright in a particular creative
work, refer to your answers to question 1.
Yes ----- No_'---__ _ ~ If you answered "no" to questions 3 and ~, ~top and proceed to Question 7.
If you answered 'yes" to either question 3 or question 4, proceed to complete the Chart in Question 5.
2
.. , .1 .. _" _ ,-_., ... _-'_, __ .~ ___ .. ~_._
Below is a chart that identifies each allegedly infringing product
Identify: (1) the specific creative works that the product infringes (identify the creative works by writing in their corresponding
exhibit numbers into column 1)
(2) whether MGA Entertainment, Inc. is liable for that product's infringement (in column 2);
(3) whether Isaac Larian is liable for that product's infringement (in column 3);
(4) whether MGA Entertainment (Hong Kong) Limited is liable for that product's infringement (in column 4);
(5) the amount of damages, if any, owed to MatteI by MGA Entertainment, Inc. for that product's infringement (in column
5); (6) the amo of damages, if any, owed to Mattel by MGA pr.rfertainment (Hong Kong) Limited for that product's
infringement . column 6); ,
(7) the amount of dam es, if. any, owed to Mattel b¢aac Larian for that product's infringement (in column 7);
(8) The total amount of d ges, if any, owed to }fattel for that product's infringement (in column 8);
1 1: ~ Q
~
~
Product Larian liable? MGAE DamalZes
Total Damages
First Generation Cloe doll (TX 121 First Generation Sasha Doll (TX 17558) First Generation Jade Doll (TX 17551) First Generation gaJlj~ \/. Doll (TX /. 17561)
3
I 11. ,
Formal Funk Dana Doll (TX 17529) Ooh La La CloeDoll le (TX 17540)' First Production Sculpt (TX 17732) Second Production Sculpt (TX 17733),
_.1
~
I' . . ~ 0 e~~e the fOllo~ing dates, did MatteI discov~ should it have discover~hrough the exercise of reasonable
~~~, diligence, claimed copyright infringement by MGA ~ertainment, Inc., MGA ~ertainment (Hong Kong) Ltd., or Isaac ri)fP Larian? .
. "J- Complete each box ~e answers 'yes" or "no" in response~ tis question. '-,
Once you make a choice 'CiQJswer 'yes" to any date, then all later tes as to that defendant m
Once you make a choice and a "no " as to any date, then all prior da
.her 20, 2003 MGA Entertainment, Inc. MGA Entertainment (HK) Ltd. Isaac Larian
4
--
"'-,
[, ,
--
MatteI's Claim for Trade Secret Misappropriation
7. Has MatteI proven that any of the items listed in the chart in Question 9 are its trade secrets?
Yes ~ No ________ __
If no, stop here and go to Question 14.
If yes, proceed to Question 8.
8. Has MatteI proven that MGA Entertainment, Inc. and/or Isaac Larian misappropriated any of the listed items that
qualify as trade secrets in the chart in Question 9?
Yes No ~ ---------
If no, stop here and go to Question 14.
If yes, proceed to complete the Chart in Question 9.
5
#
l.
2.
:... I
9. Below is a chart that lists Mattel' s claimed trade secrets. Identify: (1) whether MatteI has proven each entry is a trade secret (answer "YES" or "NO" in column 1). (2) whether MatteI has proven that MGA Entertainment, Inc. misappropriated the claimed trade secret (answer
"YES" or "NO" in column 2); (3) whether Mattel has proven that Isaac Larian misappropriated the claimed trade secret (answer "YES" or ''NO''
in column 3); (4) the amount of damages, if any, that MatteI is owed from MGA Entertainment, Inc. for the misappropriation of
the claimed trade secret (in column 4); (5) the amount of damages, if any, that Mattel is owed from Isaac Larian for the misappropriation of the claimed
trade secret (in column 5); and (6) the total damages, if any, owed to MatteI for the misappropriation of the claimed trade secret (in column 6).
1 2 3 4 5 6
Description MatteI's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against. - Damages Total Damages owed to Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian Mattei
Secret? ? riate?
A multi-ethnic group of hip, urban, edgy, trendy teen age girls fashion dolls and accessories, collectively known as
JJO /JO NO ",0 NO tV (J "Bratz," including designs for large, oversized heads and feet, large eyes, large lips, and small, almost non-existent noses, and small bodies. The dolls are four high school, multi-ethnic friends with attitude; each have distinctive names, nick names, fashions, personalities, back stories and icons descriptive of the doll's personal mascot. The name "Bratz" used in connection
fJo with a multi-ethnic group of hip, urban, flO ,.JO /vo NO NO edgy, trendy teen age girls fashion dolls and accessories, collectively known as
6
1 2 3 4 5 6
# Description Mattei's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian Mattei
Secret? ? riate? "Bratz," including designs for large, oversized heads and feet, large eyes,
bo~ ~fO ~~ large lips, and small, almost non- <:!. ~ existing noses, and small bodies. The -dolls are four high school, multi-ethnic
friends with attitude; each have distinctive names, nick names, fashions, personalities, back stories and icons descriptive of the doll's personal mascot.
3. Sculpt TX 1136A NI) tJtJ tJO -e- -e- ~ 4. Sculpt TX 1141 #JO tJO NO ..e-- -e- 71Jr.O 5. Bratz Hero Shot, TX 302B-00OI NO NO NO -e- e- ., b.Jf ~ ., ......-6. The following Bratz drawings: TXs 1,
2,3,5-26,5-27,5-79,5-81,5-82,5-83, 5-84, 5-30, 5-52, 62, 5-88, 5-35, 5-36, 5-37,5-38,5-39,5-40,5-41,5-42,5-43, 5-46, 5-49, 5-50, 5-53, 5-54, 5-55, 5-56, 777,5-58,5-59,5-60,5-61,5-62,5-63, 5-64, 5-65, 5-66, 5-67, 5-68, 5-73, 5-72, 5-70,5-69,779,5-107,5-106,5-103,5-104, 791, 5-108, 5-85, 719, 10-2,5-80, 5-86,5-87,5-89 (also 1129), 10-3,5-102,5-105, 1107, 1108, 1109, 1110, 1327, 1328,5-96,302,323-4 through 323-35
7. Barbie 2005 Preliminary Line List: TX y~s JJD tJO -9-7104 --8- 2RrtO
8. Viability Testing Report: TX 6739 "e~ NO NO ...er ..a- ?-~
7
,[ , ... J
1 2 3 4 5 6
# Description Mattei's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Lanan Mattei
Secret? ? nate? 9. International Overview Strategic Plan ytS No 1'40 .e- .£r- 2!ef-c> Meetings Document: TX 24033 10. Forecasting and Inventory Management
tJ° NtJ NO -G- er zelUJ Documents: TX 7168 II. Forecasting and Inventory Management
,JO ND ~O -e-- .,e,- ~ Documents: 7169 12. Forecasting and Inventory Management
IJO NO NO ~ -e- ~ Documents: TX 7170 13. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO ~o NO ~ -t::r -:z...e/Lo Documents: TX 7171 14. Forecasting and Inventory Management
fJO tJO NO ~ -t!7- ;Z.e(l.o Documents: TX 7172 t;
15. Forecasting and Inventory Management rJO rJ{} NO -e- -er .z.e~ Documents: TX 7173
16. Forecasting and Inventory Management tlO NO tJo -a- -B- z.elLo Documents: TX 7174 17. Forecasting and Inventory Management tJ(j 1'10 ,JO -GJj- -6- Ze/<.o Documents: TX 7175 18. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~O tJl) ~O -er -C>- 2.el2.o Documents: TX 7176 19. Forecasting and Inventory Management
rJO 110 ND -e- -0- 2,e/i...o Documents: TX 7177A 20. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO NO NO 4- -e- :Ze~G Documents: TX 7178 2I. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~O tJO tJO -e- -G- zel'J..O Documents: TX 7179 22. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO tJo tJo ~ -G- 'Z:e/l..e) Documents: TX 7180 23. Forecasting and Inventory Management ~~ ;""'Y\~ • It:. n~ ~ , r
8
1 2 3 4 5 6
# Description MatteI's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian MatteI
Secret? ? riate?
Documents: TX 7181 NO NO NO e ...e- *'2~"'o 24. Forecasting and Inventory Management tJ() rio NO -6- ,e- :zeRo Documents: TX 7182 25. Forecasting and Inventory Management
NO NO No -G -e- ze(U!) Documents: TX 7183 26. Forecasting and Inventory Management . NO ,Jo tit) -e- -e- zeA-o Documents: TX 7184 27. Forecasting and Inventory Management
NO tJo NO -C7 -9- ze.t<.CJ Documents: TX 7185 28. Forecasting and Inventory Management ND ,J" ,.JD -8- -9- ze/l..O Documents: TX 7186 29. Forecasting and Inventory Management fJO Jo tJO 0- -e- :z.e{(..o -Documents: TX 7187 30. Forecasting and Inventory Management
tJo NO ,Jo -6- 4- -:ze(J...(J Documents: TX 7188 31. Forecasting and Inventory Management rJO NO tJa -e .g- Z-Q./l-O Documents: TX 7189 32. Forecasting and Inventory Management tJO tit> tic) -e- -G- .;;?elU) Documents: TX 7191 33. Forecasting and Inventory Management I'll> ';0 ,JtJ -G- e- z.elto Documents: TX 7192 34. Forecasting and Inventory Management
"'0 tit; Nd ..0 ..a- zelLO Documents: TX 7193 35. Forecasting and Inventory Management MO NO NO ~- -a- ::z.e/J-O Documents: TX 7194 36. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO NO No --0 -e- Z-etU:J Documents: TX 7195 37. Forecasting and Inventory Management rJO riC) NO -G- ..g-- .,;z. e/~.:O Documents: TX 7197
9
1 2 3 4 5 6
# Description Mattei's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian Mattei
Secret? ? riate? 38. Forecasting and Inventory Management
YeS f.-lO, tJ{) 0'" -0- ~e~O Documents: TX 7203 39. Forecasting and Inventory Management •
tiD -e- ;;2e'-("o tJO I'll> ~ Documents: TX 7204 40. Forecasting and Inventory Management yeS Nfl NO -c:r -e ::ze..~O Documents: TX 7207 41. Forecasting and Inventory Management yes NlJ Nb -e- -e- ze~o Documents: TX 7210 42. Forecasting and Inventory Management yes Nil tie; -8)- -0 ;;?e~O Documents: TX 7211 43. Forecasting and Inventory Management '1es; rJD NO e!r -e- :2.~D Documents: TX 7212
Forecasting and Inventory Management • f{D -er -0
44. yeS Na 2el<D Documents: TX 7218 45. Forecasting and Inventory Management I NO NO ~ -e yes Z~lJ Documents: TX 7219
Forecasting and Inventory Management .
NO tJD -0 ~e/J..'C> 46.
yeS e-Documents: TX 7220 47. Forecasting and Inventory Management iJD lJo NO -e-- ..er- 2eM Documents: TX 7222 48. Forecasting and Inventory Management N6 tJ() tJO ---er k?)- ze~O Documents: TX 7223 49. Forecasting and Inventory Management ,/es tJo NO -G- ..@ Ze./lo Documents: TX 7224 50. Forecasting and Inventory Management Yes NO ;Vo ~ ..e- ~el<-O Documents: TX 7225 51. Forecasting and Inventory Management I
~ ;./0 -a. -0 ze.t<-6 Jjt) Documents: TX 7226 52. Forecasting and Inventory Management SJ: e A/evT D~
10
1 2 3 4 5 6 ,. # Description MatteI's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to
Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian MatteI Secret? \ ? rillte?
Documents: TX 7228 ·Nil NO NO ~ {) ~ 53. Forecasting and Inventory Management
rJ'D N'b ND 4J ¥ ~ Documents: TX 7230 54. Forecasting and Inventory Management
Nt> ~() Nt> ¥ % ~ Documents: TX 7232 55. Forecasting and Inventory Management
1'10 ND Documents: TX 7233 f'.)D k iF ~~ 56. Forecasting and Inventory Management
tJO N6 N'D .ff Af V~ Documents: TX 7234 57. Forecasting and Inventory Management ,tolD No Nt> ~ 1Y .~ Documents: TX 7236 58. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO ~(J N1) ;b" J?f ~ Documents: TX 7237 59. Forecasting and Inventory Management
NO ~t Nb k X -Z&fbb Documents: TX 7239 60. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO ~O t'-lD % ¥' ~ Documents: TX 7240 61. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~O ~D Nb g )? .~ Documents: TX 7241 62. Forecasting and Inventory Management
l'1D tJrJ NO ~ ¥ lr~' Documents: TX 7242 63. Forecasting and Inventory Management
:~O ~O ~{) ~ y ~. Documents: TX 7243 64. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO tJo f'll> % ~ -u:to Documents: TX 7245 65. Forecasting and Inventory Management rJO tJO NU fir .fr ~~ Documents: TX 7246 66. Forecasting and Inventory Management ).]1 () NO f'JO ty 17 ~ Documents: TX 7247
11
1 2 3 4 5 6 I -# Description Mattei's DidMGA Did Larian Damages Against Damages Total Damages owed to
Trade Misappropriate Misapprop MGA against Larian Mattei Secret? ? riate?
67. Forecasting and Inventory Management if.J1) ~t> ~b -er .~ ~ Documents: TX 7248
68. Forecasting and Inventory Management NO ~ ~t At 11 ~ Documents: TX 7249 69. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~1) ~ ~~ 45 ~ I~ Documents: TX 7252 70. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~'() ~1l f'11) ~ A1 -Zed20 I Documents: TX 7253
71. Forecasting and Inventory Management ~t ~1) ~O jr % -pefliJ Documents: TX 7254
72. Forecasting and Inventory Management Nb ~1> \'l~ ¥ Jf l£1l:o Documents:: TX 7255 73. Forecasting and Inventory Management
f'% ~fi ~t) 11' )J 7itP-o Documents:: TX 7256 74. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~D No ~~ k % &-/4-0 Documents: TX 7258 75. Forecasting and Inventory Management tJl) pt ~O f( ff ylfP>. r;,.
Documents: TX 20474 76. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~1) tl1) ~"() 1J ;pJ ~ Documents: TX 23696 77. Forecasting and Inventory Management
~t ~n ~t) Pr 1f ~et:o Documents: TX 23697 78. Forecasting and Inventory Management
Nt ~U Documents: TX 23698 ~o -t? ff V~ 79. Forecasting and Inventory Management
,\~t ~O ~{) 11 ;f{ ~ Documents: TX 23699 80. Forecasting and Inventory Management
t-JD ~O ~O % ~ Documents: TX 26939 'T:Y
12
10. What is the total amount owed to Mattei, if any, on its claim for trade secret misappropriation?
MGA Entertainment, Inc. $ m..o (total of all amounts in column 4)
Isaac Larian $ -z.eg.o (total of all amounts in column 5)
Total amount owed to MatteI $ -z,e:tO (total of all amounts in column 6)
11. On or before the following dates, did MatteI discover, or should it have discovered through the exercise of reasonable
diligence, facts that would have caused a reasonable person to suspect that MGA Entertainment, Inc. or Isaac Larian
had misappropriated any Bratz-related concepts and works?
Complete each box with the answers 'yes" or "no" in response to this question.
Once you make a choice and answer 'yes" to any date, then all later dates as to that defendant must be marked 'yes. "
Once you make a choice and answer "no" as to any date, then all prior dates as to that defendant must be marked
"no.
MGA Entertainment, Inc. Isaac Larian
13
12. Has MatteI proven that MGA Entertainment, Inc. or Isaac Larian used improper means to acquire any of the following
claimed trade secrets? (answer "YES" or ''NO'' in each box)
MGA Entertainment~ Inc. Isaac Larian
A multi-ethnic group of hip, urban, edgy, trendy teen age girls fashion dolls and accessories, collectively known as "Bratz," including designs for large, oversized
~ heads and feet, large eyes, large lips, and small, almost non-existent noses, and small No bodies. The dolls are four high school, multi-ethnic friends with attitude; each have distinctive names, nick names, fashions, personalities, back stories and icons descriptive of the doll's personal mascot. The name "Bratz" used in connection with a multi-ethnic group of hip, urban, edgy, trendy teen age girls fashion dolls and accessories, collectively known as "Bratz," including designs for large, oversized heads and feet, large eyes, large lips, and small, ND ~O almost non-existing noses, and small bodies. The dolls are four high school, multi-ethnic friends with attitude; each have distinctive names, nick names, fashions, personalities, back stories and icons descriptive of the doll's personal mascot. Sculpt TX 1136A 1'IT) k)6 Sculpt TX 1141 NO ~1) Bratz Hero Shot, TX 302B-00OI fJ() ND The following Bratz drawings: TXs 1,2,3,5-26,5-27,5-79,5-81,5-82,5-83,5-84, 5-30,5-52,62,5-88,5-35,5-36,5-37,5-38,5-39,5-40, 5-41, 5-42, 5-43, 5-46, 5-49, ~O 5-50, 5-53, 5-54, 5-55, 5-56, 777, 5-58, 5-59, 5-60, 5-61, 5-62, 5-63, 5-64, 5-65, 5-66, ~ 5-67,5-68,5-73,5-72,5-70,5-69,779,5-107,5-106, 5-103, 5-104, 791, 5-108, 5-85, 719, 10-2,5-80,5-86,5-87,5-89 (also 1129), 10-3,5-102,5-105, 1107, 1108, 1109, 1110, 1327, 1328,5-96,302,323-4 through 323-35
13. Has MatteI proven by clear and convincing evidence that MGA Entertainment, Inc. and/or Isaac Larian acted willfully
and maliciously in the misappropriation of any trade secrets?
~ ~ ~ MGA En~ertainment, Inc. ~ Isaac Lanan
14
I
MGA's Claim for Trade Secret Misappropriation
14. Has MGA E~rtainment, Inc. proven that any of the items listed in the chart in question 16 are its trade secrets?
Yes V No -----If no, stop here and go to Question 20.
If yes, proceed to Question 15.
15. Has MGA Entertainment, Inc. proven that MatteI, Inc. misappropriated any of listed items that qualify as trade secrets
in the chart )p Question 16?
Yes __ V~ __ No ____ _
If no, stop here and go to Question 20.
If yes, proceed to complete the chart in Question 16.
15
#
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
16. Below is a chart that lists MGA Entertainment. Inc.'s claimed trade secrets. Identify: (1) whether MGA Entertainment, Inc. has proven each entry is a trade secret (answer "YES" or ''NO'' in column 1). (2) whether MGA Entertainment, Inc. has proven that Mattel, Inc. misappropriated the claimed trade secret (answer
"YES" or "NO" in column 2); (3) whether MGA Entertainment, Inc has proven that Mattel, Inc. used improper means to acquire the claimed trade
secrets (answer "YES" or "NO" in column 3); (4) the amount of damages, if any, that MGA Entertainment, Inc. is owed from Mattel, Inc. for the
misappropriation of the claimed trade secret (in column 4).
1 2 3 4
Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainment2 Inc.
ate? The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
Vt$? ~&J 'iWl ~~,.'f advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz Mobile ~ l iL...l.-t The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
I~~ I I
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz Styl' It ~efJ 'iffJ ~3 .. r \ilL--Collection
The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ND ( N'D NO ~ plans to advertise on television for Bratz Boys The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz
"-~ 0 'ye) ~ 3·i rt\(L..-WinterWonderland Collection The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
~ '/ I
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz Formal
" ,..-&7 ,~ ~~7 ~ 3· J1 M(L.. Funk Collection The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
\/~ let; 1, advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz Runway \ ~e,7 3.Lff:v\iL Formal Funk Collection The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did MatteI Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen~ Inc.
ate? 8. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
1~ f~ advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz 7t7 j, 3. ~ .11~ Motorcycle 9. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
t~ I advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bratz Pet i-e~ e6 ~ -3..'f' kU ........ Assortment
10. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and I
plans to advertise on television for Bratz City Playsets ~ f\.)D ~O 4r II. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on tel~vision for Lil' Bratz Slumber NO NO ~O 4r Party 12. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Lil' Bratz Spring Break NO ~o ('tn 4J' 13. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Lil' Bratz Loungin' ~G ~() ~D &IT"
Loft 14. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
.~.~ y~ I
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Lil' Bratz 1~ . ]7 3~* \-ttL-
I
Vehicle Assortment I
15. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to f
~~ ,
~ advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Lil' Bratz ,~~ \ lt0 4)1 3 ~ \f \"\ \ L--Deluxe Mall Playset
16. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ~fh ~1e0' j\; 3.l.\" \1( L--- I \ 'fh plans to advertise on television for Bratz Petz !
17. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ,~O !NO NO ;if' plans to advertise on television for Lil' Bratz Dance Party I
18. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and Yt~ \I~ ~2 t)~·tt I
plans to advertise on television for Dazzlin' Disco Cafe " \-il(.....
19. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and \J(h '.~? ~ .th It ':?,l{ nAV! ~ I
/ , 17
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did MatteI Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen~ Inc. .
ate? plans to advertise on television for Sun Kissed Summer
20. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and 1'I£fJ j~ Yrlh '.1> ~ -t tt L,~ plans to advertise on television for Girls Nite Out 21. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and f I /
plans to advertise on television for Wild Life Safari ~e17
, if :;"t \7; \ '-~ r-tGL...
Collection 22. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
~~ ~ ,~ I Y-G.5 ,.~ 3_l{ \-tlV plans to advertise on television for Bratz Diamondz 23. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and f
, ND plans to advertise on television for Bratz Sportz NO tf'JO -fY 24. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
'fe7 plans to advertise on television for Bratz Virtual Buddiez j~S j6 -.~ ~,t Klv Petz
25. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and N-o NO tJtO k plans to advertise on television for Bratz Live In Concert 26. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
~() ~'e tJO ~ plans to advertise on television for Midnite Dance 27. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
'*~ 'i\f5 'lJ?S .~ 3,.4--plans to advertise on television for Bratz Campfire l--tllv 28. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and I, I 1
.~. plans to advertise on television for Wild Wild West ,~~ ~e7 \' It'g-~ 31'f Hll/ . .'
29. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and \~ leh
I
i :3~lf t1lV plans to advertise on television for Bratz Rock Angels \}.~7 " '~<? 30. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and N'%)
, ~O ~ plans to advertise on television for Holiday 2005 tJ~
31. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO N~ tJf) # plans to advertise on television for Bratz phone 32. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
~O rJD ~1J ~ plans to adyertise on television for Funk Fashion L .. - --
18
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen!2 Ioc.
ate? Makeover game (St.e. PliO"- ~)
33. The appearance, . operation, intended play pattern, fuld /VO ~O -G plans to advertise on television for Hopscotch Heather ~O
34. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO 1'10 -e-plans to advertise on television for Dream Baby
35. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and "'0 No NO -e--plans to advertise on television for Bratz 36. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO -e-plans to advertise on television for Jumpin Jenny NO 37. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
NO No NO -e-plans to advertise on television for Scooter Samantha 38. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
1\10 advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Hello Kitty NO NO -0 Be Beautiful Matchmaker Journal and Virtual Crush
39. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to NO NO NO advertise on television, and FOB pricing for iCandy ~ 40. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
'1~S NJO NO -e---advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Liar Liar 41. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
" :1. Lf rn/'J advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Monkey See ~~5 'Ilh '/~S Monkey Do
42. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to advertise on television, and FOB pricing for A New Breed ys NO N.O -e-and Palm Puppies
43. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Hello Kitty ,/-tS rJ° NO e-Scooter
44. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to ytS NO NO' -0-advertise on television, and FOJ:Lpricing for Insect()~ots -L- ----- --- -- ---
19
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen!2 Inc.
ate? 45. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Monster Yffi NO NO -e-Surgery
46. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to
j'feS ,
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for My Beautiful NO ~O ..e-Mennaid
47. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO e· plans to advertise on television for Hulk Two-Way Radios 48. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to yrs No NO -e-
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Musikids 49. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to yes 13.11 mil advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Lil' Bratz ,/~S· 'Y€,S
Boyz 50. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO No -e-plans to advertise on television for My Beautiful Ballerina 51. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to yes NO advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Pia Back to tJo -e-
School i
52. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to 'ItS advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Jumpin' on tJo NO -0
the Bed Bouncin' Baby 53. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to No advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Rachel LuI A ~S ,..1'0 -0-
Bye Baby 54. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to -e-advertise on television, and FOB pricing for RC Street y:es No NO
I Flyer Samantha 55. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to tJo NO ! yes ~e I
advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Walk 'n Go I
20
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did MatteI Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen~ Inc.
r ate? Jo Jo (c=;ee orio('"" rY1~e. '\
56. The appearaiice, operation, intended play pattern, plans to '}eS NO NO -e-advertise on television, and FOB pricing for Bead Palace 57. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
, plans to advertise on television for Bratz Stylin' Dance NO N° NO -0-Party
58. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and 'Jts ,,'eS $3·Lf MIl plans to advertise on television for Alien Racers ves
59. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ~O ,
plans to advertise on television for Micro Blast Jet Skis NO NO -e 60. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Bratz Luscious NO NO NO -0 Lampl Alann Clocks
61. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO -(3 plans to advertise on television for Flower Fairies 62. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Bratz Internet Cafe NO NO NO -0 Playset
63. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO f'.D NO e plans to advertise on television for Bratz Retro Cafe I 64. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO 0
I
NO !
plans to advertise on television for Lil' Bratz NO I I
Transfonning Bedroom 65. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ves yes it 3.~ mil plans to advertise on television for Bratz Girls Nite Out 'Je5 66. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
, , yes $ 3·Lf mt I plans to advertise on television for Bratz Kidz y.eS \Jes
67. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and .
rJO NO NO -e--plans to advertise on television fOJ," High School Cool
21
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainment2 Inc.
ate? 68. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and -
plans to advertise on television for Bratz Rodeo NO NO NO -8-69. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
$3·4 W\\l plans to advertise on television for Passion for Fashion 'liS v.es \leS 70. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
, t , -e plans to advertise on television for Bratz Baby Sisterz NO NO NO
7l. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO -9 plans to advertise on television for Talking Bratz NO . 72. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO plans to advertise on television for Bratz Costume -8 73. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO No NO plans to advertise on television for Bratz on Ice -e 74. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO ftX) NO -G plans to advertise on television for Holiday Doll
I
75. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and plans to advertise on television for Bratz Play Sportz NO ,JO NO --G-Teamz
76. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and tv,O NO No -e !
plans to advertise on television for Bratz Couture 77. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Story Time Princess NO I'tJ NO --e--Collection Fashion Dolls
78. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and (!) plans to advertise on television for Story Time Classics NO NO NO
Collection Mini Dolls 79. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and No plans to advertise on television for Yummi-Land Soda Pop NO NO 0
Girls 80. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and lJO NO NO ~
""lI; ,J
22
1 2 3 4 ,
# Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen!2 Inc.
ate? plans to advertise on television for Marvel Super Heroes (~R
.......
P("tDY ~e Die-Cast Vehicles 81. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Spider-Man & Friends NO NO NO -e-Crime Cruiser RIC
82. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ~O plans to advertise on television for Spider-Man Fire NO NO -0 Rescue RIC
83. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and Me plans to advertise on television for Land Sea RIC AXI NO N'O -8-' Trespass
84. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO No NO -e ,
plans to advertise on television for 6 Foot Bratz Puzzles 85. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and 'No -e plans to advertise on television for I-Petz ND No 86. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
No NO we ,-(27-plans to advertise on television for Bratz Mobile Phones
87. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and No NO NO -6-plans to advertise on television for Muichiz 88. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ND IV) NO -e plans to advertise on television for Baby Bratz 89. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO tJo NO -G I
plans to advertise on television for Bratz Pretty N' Punk 90. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO e plans to advertise on television for Bratz Fabulous 91. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and !VO NO NO -e plans to advertise on television for Bratz Treasures 92. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and !VO NO No 0 plans to advertise on television for Bratz direct to Video
- -- _I......-.. ---- ---- ---
23
,
1 2 3 4
# Description Trade Did Mattei Iml!rol!er Total Damages owed to Secret? Misal!l!rol!ri Means? MGA Entertainmen~ Inc.
r ate? movie with Twentieth Century Fox (/~ C ("IDC ::>CLO\P \
93. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern';- and , , ~ J
plans to advertise on television for Bratz music album with ~iG NO bJO -0 Universal Music Enterprises
94. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and ND NO NO -e-plans to advertise on television for Livin' Bratz 95. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
NO NO e plans to advertise on television for Giddy Up Girl }NO-96. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and JJo No NO --e-plans to advertise on television for Toby 97. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
NO --e-plans to advertise on television for Bratz Babies AlO Ala 98. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, plans to yes tVO NO -e-advertise on television for, and FOB pricing Lil' Bratz 99. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO Nt; NO e plans to advertise on television for Bratz plug and play 100. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO tJO plans to advertise on television for Lil' Bratz Stylin' NO -D
Sticker Maker 101. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO No NO e plans to advertise on television for Bratz Candyz 102. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO tJo NO plans to advertise on television for Bratz DynaMite e 103. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO C5.
plans to advertise on television for Petz Campfire 104. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO tJO tJO --tr plans to advertise on television for Oooh La La 105. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO e plans to advertise on television for Ponyz
-- -
24
1 2 3 4 ,
# Description Trade Did Mattei Improper Total Damages owed to Secret? Misappropri Means? MGA Entertainmen~ Inc.
ate? 106. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and tJO NO NO --e-plans to advertise on television for Twiinz 107. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and No /NO -e-plans to advertise on television for Bratz digital camera NO 108. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO ~ plans to advertise on television for Bratz miniature radio 109. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO NO NO ~
plans to advertise on television for Bratz MP3 player 110. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO ~ ;NO g
plans to advertise on television for Bratz furniture 111. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and NO f\JO 0 plans to advertise on television for Bratz doll display NO -112. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
plans to advertise on television for Bratz bath and beauty AlO NO NO -e products 113. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
A/O NO NO -9-plans to advertise on television for Bratz stationary 114. The appearance, operation, intended play pattern, and
)/0 No tJO plans to advertise on television for Bratz remote control e --- -,
Kendall
25
!u~~~ ....... i3reiO#".\""
&!!U3!iQJ ~
17. Wh~t is the total amount owed to MGA Entertainment, Inc., if any, on its claim for trade secret misappropriation?
. :tr4-$ '6S.5M\\ (total of all amounts in col~
18. On or before November 20, 2003, did MGA Entertainment, Inc. discover, or should it have discovered through the exercise of reasonable diligence, facts that would have caused a reasonable person to suspect that MatteI has misappropriated any trade secrets listed in Question 16?
Yes j
No V
19. Has MGA Entertainment, Inc. proven by clear and convincing evidence that MatteI, Inc. acted willfully and maliciously in the misappropriation of any trade secrets?
yesL No -----
26
MatteI's Claim for Intentional Interference with Contractual Relations
20. Complete the chart below to respond to the following question: Has MatteI, Inc. proven that MGA Entertainment, Inc.
intentionally interfered with MatteI, Inc.'s contractual relations with any of the following individuals:
Yes No
Contractual Relations with Carter Bryant ~ Contractual Relations with Ana Cabrera V Contractual Relations with Beatriz Morales V Contractual Relations with Maria Salazar V
21. Complete the chart below to respond to the following question: Has MatteI, Inc. proven that Isaac Larian intentionally
interfered with MatteI, Inc.'s contractual relations with any of the following Individuals:
Yes No
Contractual Relations with Carter Bryant V Contractual Relations with Ana Cabrera L Contractual Relations with Beatriz Morales ~ Contractual Relations with Maria Salazar
~-- - - - - -- -
If your answer is 'yes" to Question 20 or 21, proceed to Question 22.
27
22. What amount of damages, if any, do you award to MatteI, Inc. and against MGA Entertainment, Inc. or Isaac Larian for intentional interference with contractual relations?
Amount MGA Entertainment, Inc. ttp ~ 000_ 00 Isaac Larian ~ 5~ 0 0 CJ _ () c: Total Amount Owed to Mattei for Intentional Interference with Contractual Relations _<r J 0 \. Q 0 c. cc
,.,~ -- . . .
23. On or before the following dates, did MatteI discover, or should it have discovered through the exercise of reasonable diligence, facts that would have caused a reasonable person to suspect that MGA Entertainment, Inc. or Isaac Larian intentionally interfered with its contractual relations? Complete each box with the answers 'yes" or "no" in response to this question. Once you make a choice and answer "yes" to any date, then all later dates as to that defendant must be marked "yes" Once you make a choice and answer "no" as to any date, then all prior dates as to that defondant must be marked "no
1 3 3 .; MGA Entertainment, Inc. Isaac Larian
Once this verdict fonn is completed, the foreperson of the jury should sign ?'1d date on the lines below-
DATED: fltvv.;t r:2Jj) ~ , I -Jury Foreperson {/
28