City of Los AngelesCALIFORNIA

OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK

HOLLY L. WOLCOTT CITY CLERK

Election Division 555 Ramirez Street, Space 300

Los Angeles, CA 90012 (213) 978-0444

FAX: (213) 978-0376

SHANNON D. HOPPES EXECUTIVE OFFICER 304

m JINNY PAK DIVISION MANAGER$DEcQ‘

clerK.lacitv.org

ERIC GARCETTI MAYOR

June 21, 2019

The Los Angeles City Council City Hall, Los Angeles, California

REGARDING: ASSESSMENT BALLOT PROCEEDING FORVALERIO STREET AND NOBLE AVENUE LIGHTING DISTRICT COUNCIL FILE NUMBER 19-0900-S34

Honorable Councilmembers:

In accordance with Proposition 218, the City of Los Angeles provided notice to the property owners of the parcels in the proposed Valerio Street and Noble Avenue Lighting District, as specified in the subject Council File. Along with that notice, each property owner received an assessment ballot weighted by the amount of the parcel’s proposed assessment. I have tabulated the assessment ballots delivered to my office by the final hearing date of June 11,2019.

The proposed assessment district failed because it received a weighted majority of “no” ballots as defined in Article XIII D (Proposition 218) of the State Constitution. As a result, the City may not impose an assessment for the improvement and maintenance of lighting in the proposed district. The certified results of the tabulations are attached. I have also forwarded a copy of these results to the Department of Public Works, Bureau of Street Lighting, for their information.

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR COUNCIL ACTION:

In accordance with Council policy adopted on December 19, 1997 (CF 97-0843) and the report of the Board of Public Works adopted by the Council on May 9, 1998:

1. FIND that a majority protest exists in the Street Lighting Maintenance Assessment District and therefore the proposed assessment cannot be enacted.

2. ADOPT the abandoning Ordinance attached to the Council File.3. INSTRUCT the Director, Bureau of Street Lighting, to assure that the streetlights are not installed

or are removed from service if previously installed, in accordance with Council policy.

Sincerely,

HOLLY L. WOLCOTT \j/ City Clerk

Attachments

cc: Department of Public Works, Bureau of Street Lighting

AN EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY - AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYER

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )) SS

COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES )

I, HOLLY L. WOLCOTT, City Clerk of the City of Los Angeles, hereby certify to the City Council that 53 ballots were submitted on or before June 11, 2019, in connection with the assessment ballot proceeding for the proposed Valerio Street and Noble Avenue Lighting Maintenance Assessment District, as specified in Council File Number 19-0900-S34. I further certify the attached report to be a true, correct and complete tabulation of the returns of that assessment ballot proceeding.

, IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my seal this day of June 2019.

Sincerely,

, HOLLY L. WOLCOTT r City Clerk

Proposition 218 Assessment Ballot Tabulation forValerio Street and Noble Avenue Lighting District

Election # 4934 Council File # 19-0900-S34Final Public Hearing June 11, 2019

Ballot Tally

Assessment Ballot Weight Vote Y/N

Weighted Vote No Vote/ Challenged

Assmnl County APN

1 2221-012-012

OwnerYes NoNo.

JENKINS CRUZ,WENDY L TRUST, ET AL $81.35

$81,35

Not Cast Not Cast2 2221-012-013 LINARES,JOSE L AND MORENA AND LINARES,LESLIE Not CastNot Cast3 2221-012-014 SAMSON,DAVID E TRUST, ET AL $ 81.35$81.35

$81,35

$81.35

Y2221-012-0154 WYTHE,W GERALD CO TRUST. ET AL Y $ 81.35

$ 81.352221-012-0165 KLEINMAN.MARGIT V Y

6 2221-012-017 TOTLAND,STEVEN B AND FRIEDMAN,MERYL $81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

N $ 81.35

7 2221-012-018 DANIELIAN.GEVORK Not Cast Not Cast

8 2221-013-015 HANDLER,ESTELLE R TRUST, ET AL $ 81.35

81.35 Not Cast

Y9 Y $2221-013-016 LEVINE,LAWRENCE AND JENNIFER TRUST, ET AL

2221-013-017

2221-013-018 REYES.NOU ET AL REYES.JOYCE

10 Not CastMATHEWS.PHILLIP S

11 $81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$101.69

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$101.69

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81,35

$81,35

$ 81.35

$ 81.35

N12 2221-013-019 TENE, SANDRA R N

2221-013-02013 SLATON,RACHEL AND RICHARD Not Cast Not Cast2221-013-02114 GABRIEL.JEEDA H Not Cast Not Cast

15 2221-013-022 CHAO,JASON J AND HANNAH K Y $ 81.35

2221-013-00216 SCHORI.PAUL AND LISA Y $ 101,69

2221-014-00717 SMITH.FRANCIS J.JR AND MARCIA L $ 81.35N2221 -014-006 CALDWELL.ELLEN G TR STOUGHTON FAMILY TRUST18 Y $ 81.35

2221-014-005 OTTO,JAMES A19 $ 81.35

$ 81.35

N2221-014-004 VISITISOMSUK.CHUCHAI20 N2221-014-003 ARCHEY.LAMON D21 Y $ 81.35

2221 -014-003 ARCHEY.LAMON D22 Not CastNot Cast

23 2221-014-020 HAYASHI.MlSATO TRUST, ET AL Not Cast Not Cast24 2221-015-019 DOGRA.CHRISTOPHER , ET AL Not Cast Not Cast

2221-01 5-018 TONAPETYAN,ARSHAK AND ANGELIKA25 $ 81.35N

26 2221-015-017 SILVA,CARLOS E $ 81.35Y2221-015-016 HAWKS .MICHAEL27 Y $ 81.35

2221-015-01528 RADOVICH,KATHLEEN A TRUST. ET AL Not Cast Not Cast

29 2221-015-008 WEILER,TERRY M AND CYNTHIA M TRUST, ET AL $ 81.35N

30 2221-015-006 WALTERS,DENNIS A AND ROSE M TRUST, ET AL $ 81.35$81.35

$81.35

N

31 2221-015-003 LE,THANH L Not Cast Not Cast

32 2221-009-012 DE LA ROCHA.MARTIN E AND BALDENEBRO,LETICIA Y $ 81.35$81.35

$81.3533 2221-009-010 TRUONG.THO VINH AND VI THI Not Cast Not Cast

(6/17/2019)

2221-009-008 rodriguez.redentor and martha34 $ 81.35$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

Y35 2221 -009-006 petikyan.onik and verginia $ 81.35Y36 2221-009-004 arreguin,gloria j

2221 -009-002 berger.james h jr and Carolyn k

2221 -008-020 guzman,hector and aurora, et al

2221-008-018 JACOBS,BARBARA D

Y $ 81.35

37 Not CastNot Cast38 Not CastNot Cast

39 $$81.35

$81.35

Y 81.35

40 2221-008-016 BABLUMYAN, ARMAN $Y 81.35

41 2221 -008-014 MELGAR,CARLOS AND ESTRADA,GLORIA A Not Cast Not Cast$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81 35

$81.35

$698.24

$81.35

$81.35

42 2221 -008-01 2 GARLINGTON,CHRISTOPHER R $ 81.35Y2221-008-01 0 MATTA.WAGIH AND MARGARET43 Not CastNot Cast2221 -008-008 jimenez.diana and jimenez,carlos44 $Y 81.35

45 2221-008-006 arceo.jose and vinas Y $ 81.35

2221-008-004 littlejohn.alpha decd est of46 C/O DAVID LITTLEJOHN $ 81.35N2221 -008-002 mora.carlos and maria g47 Not Cast Not Cast

48 2221-010-008 CITY STORAGE OF VAN NUYS LP $ 698.24

Not Cast

N2221-010-001 PALACIOS.MARITZA E49 Not Cast2221-010-002 FELTON,DIANNE K TRUST, ET AL50 Y $ 81.35

2221-010-003 VARDANYAN,MARGARITA51 Not Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81 35

$81.35

$81.35

$89.48

$81.35

$81.35

$89.48

$81.35

$101.69

$101.69

$81.35

$89.48

2221-01 0-004 TRUEX,ROBERT WAND NGUYEN52 Not Cast53 2221-010-005 VENIAMINOVA.MARIANNA Not Cast Not Cast54 2221-010-006 grant.marykay $ 81.35N

2221-010-016 MUNOZ.JUANA H55 N $ 81.35

$ 81.35

Not Cast

56 2221-011-001 MARQUEZ,EVARISTO H AND ARMIDA N2221-011-002 GRIFFIN,KATHLEEN57 Not Cast2221-011-003 CASTILLO,JUAN R ET AL58 RODRIGUEZ,SONIA Not CastNot Cast2221-011-004 MCCOY.RAYMOND D AND MELISSA B59 $Y 81.35

2221-011-005 MARQUEZ,JULIO AND ANAG60 Not Cast Not Cast2221-011 -006 CRUZ,MANUEL AND MERCEDEZ, ET AL61 Not CastNot Cast2221-011-007 GARRISON,HEIDI R62 $Y 81.35

63 BARDALES,DAGOBERTO $ 81.35Y2221-011-00864 ROMERO,RAMON AND NOEMI, ET AL $ 81.35

Not Cast

N2221-011-009 2221-011-010 KIM,HELEN65 Not Cast2221-012-009 CORTEZ,ELISEO AND MARIA E AND CORTEZ,ELISEO JR

2221-011-011 CALTE.GABRIEL AND FLORES,MARIA V

2221-012-010 MELKONYAN.MELKON

66 Not Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast

67 Not Cast

68 Not Cast2221-01 2-011 VISCARIELLO.RICHARD AND VAN DER MERWE,DANIEL C69 Y $ 81.35

2221-01 7-014 APPLEGATE,DAVID AND MANALO.ANNA70 Y $ 101.69

2221-016-001 GALSTYAN,MKRTICH71 Not CastNot Cast

72 2221-016-015 KELLY L LESTRANGE Not Cast Not Cast2221-015-025 ramirez,william and maria73 Not CastNot Cast

(6/17/2019)

74 2221-015-027 ortega.juan c and martha Not Cast$101.69

$101.69

$111.86

$101.69

$81.35

$101.69

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$101.69

$83.89

$101.69

$122.02$122.02$81.35

$81.35

$81.35

$10.17

$81.35

$61.01

$61.01

$61.01

$61.01

$61.01

$81.35

Not Cast

75 2221-017-013 HILL.JOSEPHP $ 101.69

Not Cast

N

76 2221-016-002 AY ALA,CLAUDIA M AND DANIEL Not Cast2221-016-003 MENASHE,ABRAHAM AND LYNN77 Not CastNot Cast2221-016-006 LUNA,RICARDO AND LILIA E78 Not CastNot Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast

2221-016-007 MARTINEZ,JAVIER s GARCIA,ALICIA G79 Not Cast2221-016-021 MARQUEZ,GREGORIO M AND LY KIM THI LE

2221-016-022 zolud,mario r

2221-016-017 MELIKYAN,SHAGEN AND PETROSYAN.NUNE

80 Not Cast

$ 81.35

Not Cast

Not Cast

$ 101.69

81 N

82 Not Cast2221-016-018 KOSOYAN,ABRAHAM83 Not Cast

84 2221-016-016 GOMEZ.EDGAR L AND GONZALEZ,BERTHA A N2221-015-026 nelson.leander jr85 $ 83.89Y2221-019-023 bermann ,peter m and hilda f trust, et al86 $ 101.69

Not Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast

Not Cast

$ 81.35

$ 10.17

N2221-019-020 TRUONG,HUONG H87 Not Cast2221-019-019 IGLESIA DE DIOS FUENTE DE LOS MILAGROS88 Not Cast2221-019-036 theis.george a and tava89 Not Cast

90 HOWARD,STOTT Not Cast2221-019-035 2221-019-032 peterson,Gary d and sau ping c

2221-019-042 peterson,Gary d and sau ping c

91 N92 N93 2221-019-113 neuman.r paul $Y 81.35

2221-019-112 KIM.SEUNG HAND JINS94 Not CastNot Cast95 2221-01 9-111 REKHTMAN,ALEKSANDR AND RHATZ,IRINA $ 61.01

Not Cast

$ 61.01

$ 61.01

$ 81.35

N2221-01 9-110 GASPARIAN,ARSINE TRUST, ET AL96 Not Cast2221-019-109 GRACA.WILLIAM AND MILA R97 N

98 2221-019-108 AGHJAYAN.IKEN G AND SETA TRUST, ET AL N99 2221-019-107 beard,bettyt N

$ 2,321.02 $2,579.46$8,839.84TOTAL99

028 2553TOTAL VOTES

(6/17/2019)

Proposition 218 Assessment Ballot Tabulation forValerio Street and Noble Avenue Lighting District

Election # 4934 Council File # 19-0900-S34Final Public Hearing June 11, 2019

Voting/Ballot Summary

Assessment Percent of Votes Cast Number of BallotsWeighted TotalVote

2847.36%$2,321.02Yes52.64% 25$2,579.46No

0No Vote0Challenged

Assessment District Summary

PercentTotal Voted54%5399Parcels55%$4,900.48$8,839.84Assessment

(6/17/2019)