cii annual report - chartered insurance institute institutes case study: east anglia, ......
TRANSCRIPT
TODAY, EVERYEVENT ISREPORTED,ANDEVERY REPORTDISTRIBUTED,ATLIGHT SPEED.
WITHOUT THECONSTANT OFPROFESSIONALSTANDARDS,SOCIETY PAYSTWICE FOREVERY ACCIDENTOR EMERGENCY.
6 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
A MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENTA MESSAGE FROM THE CEOSTRATEGYPRINCIPAL ACTIVITIESMembershipFinancial ServicesGeneral InsuranceLocal Institutes case study: East Anglia, Scotland & Northern IrelandGI Evolution projectQualifications and the QCAFinancial Services Skills CouncilFaculties & SocietiesPersonal Finance SocietyInternational
PUBLIC POLICY ENVIRONMENTThoresen Review and generic financial adviceFSA’s Retail Distribution ReviewSkillsTalent Initiative
CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY GOVERNANCEBusiness EnvironmentFinancialsCommittees & Boards
08101422
44
5258
current practices and structures against those of other professions.
This produced an honest appraisal of where we are and where
there are still gaps which need to be addressed. It is right that
the profession should face up honestly to both its strengths and
its weaknesses.
The CII has been offering leadership and ideas on how
professionalism – both in terms of qualifications and behaviour –
can be developed and promulgated more widely. We published five
position papers, as well as a comprehensive response to the FSA’s
discussion paper on the retail distribution review, setting out an
excellent prospectus for improvement and change.
The CII has also developed its support both to individual members
and to firms, as they embrace the skills challenge, in the fiercely
competitive environment of financial services. More and more
people are coming to realise the hard fact: “Who trains, wins”.
I have also been encouraged during my tours of local institutes
at the determination to raise standards and to lead the industry
to inspire higher levels of public trust and confidence.
The CII name carries resonance around the world and this year has
seen excellent development in taking professionalism and standards
to major markets throughout the world – including India, the Far
East and Middle East as documented in this report. This will be
an excellent platform for sustained development in the years ahead.
It has been an honour for me to serve this year as the first CII President selected from outside the
Institute’s ranks, at such a pivotal time in the Institute’s history. As a former chairman of the CII’s
Professional Standards Board, I was already aware of the Institute's proud history, but even more
acutely aware of its ambition to build for the future. Never has the need for professionalism and
the championing of professional standards been more relevant.
Despite increasing turmoil in financial services markets, 2007 was a good year for the CII, though
like many others we have learned to adapt to changing circumstances in developing plans for the
future. Fortunately I took over the Institute from the safe hands of a predecessor, Ian Templeton,
who had undertaken a sterling job, overseeing the completion of the daunting but necessary task
of overhauling the CII’s governance procedures and structures. He ensured the CII could be run in
a manner befitting a modern professional body.
I have made professionalism my presidential theme. Against the backdrop of the FSA’s Retail
Distribution Review and the long-standing issue of public trust and confidence in financial services,
the CII commissioned an independent review of the framework for professional standards, comparing
WELCOME TO THIS YEAR’SANNUAL REPORT OF THECHARTERED INSURANCEINSTITUTE.
A MESSAGEFROM THE PRESIDENT
It is with pride that I will hand on the torch
at the end of my presidential year. I believe the
CII is making great strides in building the right
framework for professional standards, as a body
that is prepared to take risks to promote
professionalism in the public interest.
Rt Hon the Lord Hunt of Wirral MBE
8 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
2007 proved to be a year of substantial progress for the CII
despite the prevailing economic climate. The CII Group
announced its best year for membership growth since 1935.
CII membership grew to 92,000 members, representing a
7.2 per cent increase on 2006. Our financial strength grew
further allowing us to consolidate to our position as an
innovative professional body taking an increasingly active role
in shaping the future of professionalism in the financial
services sector.
The growth in membership has been driven by a number of
successful partnerships, including Zurich; HSBC; Towry Law;
the AXA-owned brokers Stuart Alexander, Smart & Cook;
Layton Blackham; and Towergate.
OUR MESSAGE IS REFORMSARE IMPORTANT BUT MUST BE CONDUCTED WITHIN THEFRAMEWORK OF MAINTAININGHIGH STANDARDS.
Growth has also increased thanks to the rising support for professional body membership
in the financial services sector, as more financial advisers and IFA firms seek to step up
to the challenges and opportunities presented by the FSA's Retail Distribution Review (RDR).
A strong professional body can play an important role,
especially in the squall of disruptive economic times, for
our individual members and firms in shaping and driving
the development of professional standards.
We are playing an active part in the debates, not just over
financial regulation reform like the RDR where we have
championed industry-led solutions, but also in educational
and qualifications reform.
A MESSAGEFROM THE CEO
Pacific hurricanes - - Peru earthquake - - UK flooding - - International airport attacks - - San Francisco oil spill - - Grayrigg rail crash - - Greek forest fires - - Chittagong mudslide - - Florida tornadoes
10 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
As part of this ambition, and to
support our attempt to rebuild
increased public trust and
confidence in our sector, we
commissioned a ground-
breaking independent study
looking at the development of
professional standards in our
sector and comparing them to
other professions. This showed
considerable progress on the road
to professionalism but indicated
there was more we could all do,
including the development of
a new professional standards
framework.
The FSA’s Retail and Distribution
Review provides an ideal
platform to develop our ideas
for enhancing professionalism.
We published five position
papers in the autumn
culminating in a response to
the FSA setting out a package
for professionalism. We believe
this is a good start in our
progress towards developing
the CII as a ‘new wave’
professional body and 2008 will
see a raft of further initiatives
to build on these foundations.
Despite great advances we
will not rest on our laurels. Our
governance structure has now
been modernised and reformed.
We continue to develop our ideas
to improve the standing of the
profession and buttress this
through improving the capability
of the CII Group: growing our
global reach; improving our
proposition and operations
and ensuring we invest in our
own people.
A big focus for the coming year
is the development and
implementation of our plans
for growth in selected global
markets like India, the Middle
East and parts of the Far East,
where financial services growth
requires the blend of our
traditional image but modern
qualifications know-how to help
professionalise these markets.
I would like to pay tribute to our
current president Lord Hunt for
his unstinting support, enthusiasm
and personal commitment to the
task of promoting professional
standards.
The increasing size and breadth
of our membership, our financial
strength and increasing reputation
and growing international reach
all pay testament to the growing
role the CII Group can and will
play in developing professional
standards in the future.
Dr Alexander Scott,
Chief Executive Officer, CII
In an uncertain year, wehave grown membershipfaster than at any timesince 1935.“”
12 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
GROWINGGLOBALLYThe CII is now a global presence, with overseas operations
in India, Middle East, and Singapore, to name a few, and
with 67 affiliated institutes and partners around the world.
We know, however, such success must never come at the
expense of our UK work. We therefore continue to
consolidate and expand the role of our local institutes.
We now have members in 150 countries and are working
to expand rapidly, but are also keen to do so as efficiently
as possible. We are also developing our proposition for new
agent sales forces, particularly in Asian and bancassurance
markets.
All of this is to better serve the profession by promoting
our standards and values, and serving the public in providing
the best in what we do both at home and abroad.
RAISING THE STANDING OF THE PROFESSIONCII strives at all times to raise the standards of our profession. We are dedicated to creating
a ‘new wave’ professional body, one that works hard for both industry and the consumer by
demanding the highest level of integrity, dedication and competency from its members – in
other words, by promoting professionalism at all times.
To that end, we are shaping the debate on policy issues that affect our industry. Our campaign
to raise awareness of RDR with our members has been judged by them to be a success, and
we were regularly consulted by Otto Thoresen’s review team in their work in proposing Money
Guidance service, with many of our recommendations emerging in the final report.
We will continue our efforts in our industry-sponsored talent programme in the general
insurance sector, and continue to seek support in the financial services market. We will also
continue our engagement with the Government’s post-Leitch skills agenda to better inform
and lead the debate around the development of professional qualifications.
IMPROVING OURPROPOSITIONWe will continue to set the highest standards in
professional education, moving beyond qualifications
to create competent, well-rounded professionals
through a culture of career-long learning, ethical
behaviour and continued professional development.
We are particularly keen to extend professionalism
to the whole industry, specifically in areas that
are growing and new, such as call centres and
bancassurance. We are also reviewing the total
membership experience for our members and
striving to improve it.
16 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
18 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
PEOPLEThe CII is an Investor in People and places a strong emphasis on the learning
and development of its employees. Particular focus has been placed on developing
management competencies, project management skills, customer service and
market knowledge.
2007 saw the introduction of the Knowledge First Framework, designed to support
our commitment to customer service. We have an active Social Committee, and
our staff engagement survey showed positive results about our overall working
atmosphere. We are committed to open communication, and one way this is
maintained is through the Information & Consultation Forum (ICF). This is an
important component of the CII’s strategy of employee engagement and information
sharing. It is intended to be a two-way exchange of information between the CII’s
senior management and representatives of staff in the various departments and
locations regarding significant changes, developments and initiatives that affect
the business. Meetings are held at least four times a year.
We aim at all times to attract, retain and develop the best people and provide them
with an environment that allows them to excel.
IMPROVING OPERATIONSWhile we know the importance of maintaining a high external profile, we must
never neglect our own operational improvements.
As a customer-driven organisation, we will continue to build on our change
programme in improving our service to customers, while simplifying and clarifying
our prices in the UK and overseas to keep all our dealings fair and straightforward.
Finally, we must better utilise our Faculties, Local Institute and Regional networks
to drive member benefits, acquisition and retention.
INSTITUTECONSOLIDATIONWe are committed to matching our customers’ expectations of greater efficiency
and effectiveness through consolidation and appropriate strategic alliances in the
UK and abroad. Any collaboration with other institutes allows us to increase our
delivery capability and breadth of content for our members.
Our ongoing work with institutions all over the world, including but not limited
to Australia and New Zealand, India, Singapore and the Middle East, serves as an
excellent stepping-stone to expand our presence in other global markets, such as
China and the ASEAN region. Being strong in international markets and continuing
to grow is the best way to support UK FS plc and achieve the kind of pan-
institutional cooperation to which we aspire.
20 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
WE HAVE TOLOOK HARD ATOUR OPERATIONS,OR SOMEONEELSE WILL. IT IS A FACT OF LIFE.
MEMBERSHIP2007 was a very positive year for CII
membership growth and indicators from the
annual membership survey have shown that
members recognise our committed efforts
to maintain high standards and improve the
service and benefits which we provide.
Overall, the 2007 survey indicates that the
key improvement areas have been in our
online knowledge services, the production
of the informative Knowledgepack booklet,
the provision of our technical and regulatory
updates and the general improvement to our
web site content.
Membership is now in excess of 92,000 and
organic growth for 2007 was the largest since
1935. This was achieved by an overall 30 per
cent increase on new member levels compared
to 2006. A major contributor to this growth
was the creation of a number of corporate
partnership arrangements.
The CII is a member-led organisation and is the largestprofessional body in our sector. Through our network offaculties and societies, and through the work of local institutes,
we represent individuals working across the fullrange of insurance and financial services operations.
In a major development aimed at promoting
standards and professionalism within the
industry, the CII began accrediting firms with
chartered status in 2007. By year’s end, we
had accredited 101 firms as Chartered Financial
Planners and 39 Chartered Insurance Brokers.
That so many firms would seek to be awarded
this status speaks of the CII’s influence and
reputation as leaders in the industry.
Supporting the overall growth has been the
improved retention of current members which
shows a 6.5 per cent improvement since
January 2006.
International membership continues to grow
with nearly 15 per cent of the membership
now based outside the UK. Chartered title
holders have also increased with the number
of Chartered Financial Planners growing by
56 per cent since the end of 2006.
24 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
26 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
FINANCIAL SERVICESOver the past year we have made significant progress in developing
our corporate relationships, reinforcing our strong position with leading
life companies whilst building increasingly strong links with IFA’s and
Bancassurers.
We have been working extensively across the sector to support programmes
of professional development – with a particular focus on Financial Advisers
in the light of the FSA Retail Distribution Review, and our partnerships
with Norwich Union and Scottish Widows have attracted significant interest.
A number of major advisory firms have also committed their staff to
professional body membership of the PFS – such firms include HSBC, Towry Law,
Zurich Intermediary Group and Edward Jones.
In addition, progress has been made with a number of the major retail banks
and we are particularly pleased to welcome HBOS and Abbey as major new
customers to the CII Group.
It is important that our services also benefit staff not directly involved
in financial advice. An example of which, in terms of embracing young
talent and providing career focus, would be the partnership that we have
developed with Norwich Union. The NU Customer Academy is focused on
developing the technical knowledge and soft skills of up to 2,000 customer
support staff through an extensive programme of e-learning, and is now
playing a key role in the career development of this group of front line staff.
GENERAL INSURANCEIn the general insurance market we have worked with an increasing
number of companies to help design and deliver tailored training and
development programmes to address their specific business objectives.
Zurich has enrolled all of their underwriting and claims staff as members
of the CII and we have provided a tailored schedule of activities and
benefits to encourage their staff to take qualifications and to support
those who are studying. We accredited RSA’s market leading ‘Underwriting
Excellence’ programme and provided E Learning content to support
technical development.
We have rolled out E Learning programmes across AXA Insurance to support
technical development through the company’s own academies. We have
also worked with Kwik Fit to accredit some of their in house training.
Towergate is one of the companies that has been awarded Chartered
Insurance Broker status and they have enrolled all their insurance staff
as members of the CII. Towergate have also worked closely with us to
create a tailored professional development programme which includes
the CII’s E Learning services.
Through the Broking Faculty, we have worked with AXA and BIBA and
taken feedback from a number of broking firms to launch the CII ‘Broker
Academy’ – a one stop shop giving all brokers access to high quality
professional development. This now includes a competency framework,
a comprehensive E Learning and assessment service and access to regional
face to face training. This has proved tremendously popular and our
support to promote the professional status of brokers has also been
reinforced by the introduction of the corporate Chartered title for brokers.
28 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
THE GENERALINSURANCEEVOLUTIONPROJECTThe CII provides market-led qualifications which
serve all sectors of the insurance industry and
cater for all levels of knowledge and experience.
General insurance has in recent years gone
through a period of unprecedented challenges
and change. Technology and regulation have had
a major impact on the structure of the market
and the way business is conducted. Competition
is intense; individuals are moving freely between
disciplines and gone are the ‘jobs for life’ that
once characterised the sector.
The CII qualifications framework reflects and
embraces the massive changes that have taken
place and the CII has recently completed a
comprehensive consultation programme to
ensure that it continues to meet the needs of the
market. Based on extensive market research,
the General Insurance Evolution project has been
set up to build on the improvements introduced
in 2004. It is a progressive enhancement of the
learning and exam provision designed to give
individuals both the technical knowledge and
application skills to perform effectively and
efficiently in the workplace.
The project will match qualifications to industry
needs, job roles and provide an increased choice
of technical subjects together with an improved
management offering. There will be a sharper
focus on key disciplines – broking, underwriting
and claims – to provide the core knowledge and
skills needed across today’s diverse industry.
The improved units within the framework will
be designed to comply with educational best
practice and designed to meet the externally
validated exam standards set by the Government’s
educational regulator.
The improvements will be phased in over the
next three years so as not to disrupt students’
current learning plans and we believe will
cement the CII’s status as the premier provider
of learning and exam provision both now and
into the future.
LOCALINSTITUTESCASE STUDY:EAST ANGLIA,SCOTLAND &NORTHERNIRELANDThe local institutes predominantly exist to
provide members with events, activities and
guidance at a local level.
East Anglia, Scotland & Northern Ireland differ
slightly from the other UK institute groups in
that they are all currently serviced by an Area
Marketing Manager whose primary objective is
to help local institutes enhance the membership
service and experience for existing members, and
to encourage more new members to join through
local marketing activity.
2007 has seen a number of successes for the Area
Marketing Managers. First, the initial launch of
Local Institute Marketing ToolKits aimed to
provide the institutes with a distinct identity has
helped raise the local profile in both East Anglia ,
Scotland & Northern Ireland – with awareness of
local events and activities far above the national
average, with an approximate 20 per cent
increase. 2008 will see the ToolKit rolled out
to all the institutes across the UK.
Second, relationships with key partner
organisations have been developed with
organisations such as the ACCA and the CIOBS
with joint events being run with BIBA.
Finally, initiatives such as a local welcome
strategy and the development of member
acquisition campaigns have all been welcomed
by the local institutes and are starting to provide
the results we feel are necessary to continue
building on our progress and momentum in
this area.
QUALIFICATIONSAND THEQCA/OFQUALThe CII’s relationship with the Qualifications and Curriculum
Authority (QCA) strengthened yet further during 2007. Not only
were our examination policies and procedures reviewed and
updated to ensure that they continue to meet the requirements
of the regulatory authorities, we worked very closely with the
regulator on testing and trialling its new qualifications framework.
As a result of this work, we have had the following qualifications
accredited into the new credit and unit-based framework known
as the Qualifications and Credit Framework (QCF):
• Diploma in Financial Planning at Level 4
(first year degree equivalent)
• Advanced Diploma in Financial Planning at Level 6
(final year degree equivalent)
This means that our entire suite of financial planning
examinations is now accredited.
We also responded to the major consultations on the new
arrangements for regulation, with the introduction of Ofqual,
and on regulatory arrangements for the QCF.
We have also been actively engaged in supporting work with
other UK and European Qualification Frameworks.
FINANCIALSERVICES SKILLSCOUNCIL (FSSC)The CII also has a growing involvement in the work of the
Financial Services Skills Council. We have worked closely
with the FSSC on a number of matters during 2007, including:
• Appropriate Examinations
• Sector Qualification strategy
• Developments in the Business, Administration and Finance Diploma
• Apprenticeships
30 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
32 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
Faculties and societies are central to our strategy for engagingwith the market. They deliver targeted added value and careeradvantage to members working within specific disciplines.
Our faculties and societies enable the CII to address the needs of specific sectors. Each provide thought leadership andsupport to their particular community while also contributing to the overall objectives of the Institute.
They provide members with a programme of CPD events,access to technical qualifications, learning materials, supportservices and practical benefits, thereby setting the standard for technical knowledge, customer service and ethical practice.They also work with the regulator to represent members’interests and help to shape the broader environment in which they work.
UNDERWRITINGIn December the faculty, in partnership with Ernst
& Young, released the research report, The Future
of Distribution in SME Commercial General
Insurance: The Impact on Underwriting and the
Underwriter of the 21st Century, to an excellent
reception from industry. The CII’s Underwriting,
Broking and London Market faculties also hosted
a keynote event on 10 July 2007, reflecting on
themes parallel to those beginning to appear in our
research. The one day, maximum capacity event,
titled, ‘Underwriting and distribution in focus’
was a great success. Finally, the new Underwriting
practice exam syllabus has been shaped to include
content specifically addressing some of the major
outcomes of the report, and received additional
industry input which was facilitated by the faculty.
BOARD MEMBERS:Alan Woof (Chairman) Head of Underwriting Development – Zurich Financial Services
Chris Hanks, General Manager Commercial, Allianz Insurance
Terry Hayday, Manager of Professional Standards, Lloyd’s Market Association
Clive Nathan, Chief Executive Officer Underwriting, Towergate Partnership
Donny MacLeod, Reinsurance & Underwriting Manager, NFU Mutual Insurance Group
Mark Hynes, Director of Commercial Underwriting, Norwich Union Insurance
Nick Hankin, Underwriting Technical Director, RSA UK
Former members:
John Seaton
Andy Baldwin
Sid Gibson
Bernard Mageean
Mark Cliff
Brendan McManus
FACULTIES AND SOCIETIES
Alan Woof, Chairman
Head of Underwriting Development –
Zurich Financial Services
34 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
BROKINGThe Broking Faculty enjoyed a number of
successes in 2007. The Faculty launched the
Broker Academy in partnership with BIBA and
AXA, to give all brokers access to the highest
standards of training and development support.
The Broker Academy includes a new E-learning
service. AXA’s E-learning service, ‘Campus’,
was merged with the CII’s own product, Broker
Assess. The new service retains the name ‘Broker
Assess’ and has 20,000 users. It is a market leader
in broker training and assessment and gives
brokers access to a wide range of E-Learning
modules to support professional development.
In addition, the Broker Academy includes a
competency framework specifically designed
for brokers and accessible through the website.
The faculty also began designing a programme of
regional face to face training courses for brokers,
again accessible through the Broker Academy.
A September seminar consulted brokers from all
over the industry, seeking their input on content
and expectations. Starting in 2008, face to face
training would be available for as little as £120
a head, with training centres all over England
and Scotland.
Finally, the Broking Faculty was closely involved
with the launch of the corporate Chartered title
for broking firms and around 50 firms have now
been appointed as Chartered Insurance Brokers.
BOARD MEMBERS:Mark Radburn (Chairman), Managing Director, Willis Commercial Network
Alec Finch, Chairman, Alec Finch Group Ltd
Stephen James, Managing Director, Bartholomew & James Ltd
Lynn Richards-Cole, Associate Director, Perkins Slade
Eric Galbraith, Chief Executive, British Insurance Brokers’ Association
David Slade, Chief Executive, Perkins Slade
John Moore, Chief Executive Officer, Thomas Carroll Group PLC
Stephen Lark, Managing Director, Lark Group
Amanda Blanc, Chief Executive Officer UK Broking Division, Towergate Partnership
Matt Donnelly, Managing Director, Griffiths & Armour
Liz Foster, Managing Director, Ingram Hawkins & Nock Limited
Former members:
Paul Meehan
Kevin Sinclair
LONDON MARKET The London Market Faculty is committed to
maintaining its place as a centre of excellence
and best practice for the London insurance
market. The London Market Claims project, in
partnership with the Lloyd’s Market Association,
has made a significant contribution to the
professionalism of this area of the market. The
project delivered a new competency framework,
which has been agreed by the market as being
extremely practical and useful, and the virtual
‘London Market Claims College’ which signposts
all that the CII offers which is relevant to that
sector, via examinations, face to face training
and online learning. These initiatives have been
presented at a number of industry forums to a
positive reception.
BOARD MEMBERS:David Gittings (Chairman), Chief Executive Officer, Lloyd’s Market Association
Adrian Ballardie, Chief Underwriting Officer, Tokio Marine Global Ltd
Paul Maynard, Broking Director, Willis
Julian James, Chief Executive Officer, Lockton International
Sian Fisher, Head of Agency Operations, Oxygen Insurance Managers
Dave Matcham, Chief Executive Officer, International Underwriting Association
Max Taylor, holds a number of non-executive and advisory roles within insurance
Nick Gooding, Senior Cargo Underwriter, XL London Markets Ltd
Former members:
Derek Thornton
Peter Ward
David Gittings, Chairman
Chief Executive Officer, Lloyd’s Market Association
Mark
Rad
bu
rn,
Ch
air
man
Man
agin
gD
irecto
r,W
illi
sC
om
merc
ial
Netw
ork
36 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
CLAIMSDuring 2007 the Claims Faculty worked to produce
a significant piece of research titled, The Evolution
of Claims, highlighting the importance of the claims
function and its increasing recognition as a key
business driver, which was extremely well received.
The July 2007 one day event, The Future of Claims
in Focus, was a resounding success. We have also
secured feedback from the market which has helped
structure the new claims practice exam syllabus.
The faculty continues to focus on providing
appropriate exams, assessments and qualifications
for the various roles in the claims environment;
maintaining and enhancing competence by getting
members the best, up-to-date information on
training and support; and at all times raising
standards and levels of professionalism across the
claims community.
BOARD MEMBERS:Gerry Loughney (Chairman) Chief Executive Officer, Cunningham Lindsey
David Williams, Claims Director, AXA Insurance
Graham Cave, Executive Director, Chartered Institute of Loss Adjusters
Jonathan Clark, Director of Claims, Financial Services Compensation Scheme
Stan Noakes, Operations Director, Tadley Services Group
Gary Bass, Claims Consultant, Lloyd’s Market Association
John O’Neill, Chief Operating Officer, Cavell Management Services Ltd
Tony Emms, UK GI Motor Claims Director, Zurich Insurance Company
Jim Pittman, Managing Director, VFM Services Ltd
Angus Tucker, Deputy President, Chartered Insurance of Loss Adjusters
Former members:
Bill Paton
John Farthing
LIFE & PENSIONSMembership levels of the Faculty continued
to increase over the last year to more than 5,100.
The Faculty has been key in supporting our
contribution to the RDR debate with particular
input from the Faculty Board. A joint Faculty/PFS
working group, with members nominated by the
board, was instrumental in informing the CII
Group’s final response to the RDR Discussion Paper.
In addition we have regularly researched members’
views regarding attitudes to the changes proposed
by the RDR.
Continuing on the theme of developing professional
standards within the market, the Faculty also
successfully launched its second Future Leaders’
Forum, which was again sponsored by Accenture
and supported with 20 nominations from the major
providers, distributors and bancassurers. The
Future Leaders’ Forum is an initiative to aid the
retention of talent and the development of
tomorrow's leaders. The programme is designed
with an emphasis on providing new skills and
insights relevant to the modern life and pensions
industry and is supported by a programme of
events and workshops.
BOARD MEMBERS:Peter Hales (Chairman), Non Executive Director, Just Retirement
Paul Evans, Chief Executive Officer, AXA Sun Life
Ben Gunn, Chief Executive, Friends Provident Life & Pensions Limited
Jo Dawson, Chief Executive, Retail Distribution, Insurance & Investment, HBOS
Patrick Gale, Non Executive Director, HBOS Financial Services
Elaine MacLean, Human Resources Director, UK Operations, Legal & General
Carole Jones, Human Resources Director, Norwich Union
Nick Prettejohn, Chief Executive Officer, Prudential UK
Richard Anderson, Wealth Management Account Director, Scottish Widows
Paul Matthews, Managing Director – Distribution, Standard Life
Ken Davy, Chairman, SimplyBiz
Robert Reid, Managing Director, Syndaxi Financial Planning Ltd
John Simmonds, Chief Executive, Thinc Group
Margaret Craig, Director of Life & Savings, ABI
Barry Kayes, Chairman, AIFA Board Working Group
Peter Hales, Chairman
Non Executive Director, Just Retirement
Gerry Loughney, Chairman
Chief Executive Officer, Cunningham Lindsey
38 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
SOCIETY OF MORTGAGEPROFESSIONALSThe Society of Mortgage Professionals continues to grow
with increasing membership among the broker population
and greater interest from lenders and other corporate
bodies. The Home Reversion bridge examination has
been well received by holders of a Certificate in Financial
Planning and Lifetime Mortgage Activities, and the
Society will continue to focus upon the needs of all
members providing relevant information, learning
and examinations.
ADVISORY BOARD MEMBERS:Richard Fox, Chief Executive, Society of Mortgage Professionals
Chris Cummings, Director General, Association of Independent Financial Advisors
Nick Baxter, Managing Director, Baxters Business Solutions
Liz Sully, Compliance Director, I Group Servicing Limited
Stephen Smith, Housing Director, Legal & General Assurance Society Limited
Robert Clifford, Chief Executive, Mortgageforce
Jon O'Brian, Manager Intermediary Sales, Newcastle Building Society
John Malone, Managing Director, Premier Mortage Services
John Goodfellow, Chief Executive, Skipton Building Society
Dave Thompson, Sales Director, Trigold
The PFS delivered an enhanced Faculties programme
during 2007, and this included a range of paid and
free to attend events, a dedicated website and regular
technical bulletins. 6,000 members have now joined
these Faculties, a free benefit for all PFS members
qualified at DipPFS level and above.
The content, style and publication frequency of the
PFS in-house magazine ‘Financial Solutions’ was
reviewed to better reflect membership requirements
and the changes received excellent feedback.
The PFS instigated and facilitated a Leaders’ Summit
debate during the 2007 Conference with CEO’s and
key directors from the major Financial Services
Distributors and Providers. A programme of
communications for this group continues through 2008.
The Society has threeseparate Faculties:Personal Financial
Planning, CorporateFinancial Planning and
Retirement & Care
PERSONAL FINANCE SOCIETY (PFS)During 2007, the PFS increased its turnover by 12 per cent over the
previous year, and the number of PFS members increased to over
24,000, almost 7 per cent ahead of 2006. We also delivered a more
substantial and comprehensive continuing professional development
(CPD) programme, increased Chartered members by 42 per cent (which
stands at over 1,200) and launched the Chartered Financial Planners
title for firms, with 101 accredited by year end.
The PFS ran 96 regional meetings during 2007 which gave member
delegates access to local networks comprising financial services
expertise, mentoring, support and guidance. The full-day meeting
programme, free to members, included both business development
and technical sessions.
The PFS Annual Conference and Exhibition ran over two days in
November 2007; essentially a technical and training event with
35 individual training sessions covering the full range of Financial
Planning topics, it attracted a record breaking 1,300 delegates.
500 delegates also attended a black tie gala dinner.
BOARD MEMBERS:Carole Nicholls, (President) Principal, Nicholls Stevens
Robert Reid, (Vice President) Managing Director, Syndaxi Financial Planning Ltd
Peter Williams, (Vice President) Chartered Financial Planner, Aegon UK
Simon Holt, Managing Director, Skipton Financial Services
Michael Fosbery, National Head of Financial Services, Smith & Williamson
Robin O’Grady, Williams de Broë Investment Managers
Paul Lothian, Chartered Financial Planner, Verus Financial Planning Ltd
Tim Eadon, Chief Executive, The Personal Finance Society
Bob Bullivant, CII Deputy Director General
Sandy Scott, CII Chief Executive
Peter Martin, CII Finance Director
David Thomson, CII Policy & Public Affairs Director
Former Members
Gill Cardy
John Ellis
Ric
hard
Fox,C
hie
fE
xec
uti
ve
Soci
ety
of
Mort
gage
Pro
fess
ion
als
Tim
Eadon
,C
hie
fE
xecu
tiv
eoff
icer
Th
ePer
son
al
Fin
an
ceSoci
ety
40 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
INTERNATIONALINDIAOur work in India remains a top priority, and we
were pleased to see the CII’s new Liaison Office in
Mumbai approved by the IRDA (Insurance
Regulatory and Development Authority) in 2007.
We also continue to work closely with our affiliated
institutes there (the Insurance Institute of India and
the Institute of Insurance and Risk Management) as
well as the regulator and trade bodies as they seek
to raise professional standards in the Indian market.
Much of our focus at present is on developing a
qualification and learning support programme for
the up-skilling of life agents in India.
SE ASIAWe have established a significant strategic alliance
with the Singapore College of Insurance: the CII-SCI
Educational Alliance (Asia-Pacific). This agreement
is targeted at raising overall standards of
professionalism in the insurance industry in the
Asia-Pacific region through qualifications and
training. Similar strategic partnerships are now at
an advanced stage in both Hong Kong and Thailand
with plans to have these up and running by
mid 2008.
MIDDLE EASTThe CII has now added to its existing strategic
relationships, and now has a presence on the
ground throughout the region, from Egypt and
Jordan to Oman and Yemen.
Further developments include the launch of the
Takaful module, in partnership with the BIBF
in Bahrain, and work continues on the translation
of key elements into Arabic. Outside of this, we
continue to work very closely with the leading
regulators, particularly in the area of creating
minimum standards for both the life and
non-life market.
42 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
IT’S EASY TO SEE THE CIIAS HAVING AN EYE FORIMPORTANT DETAILS,LESS WELL PUBLICISED ISTHE WORK WE DO TOADVANCE DEBATE ONTHE BIGGER ISSUESFACING THE INDUSTRY.
46 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
THORESEN REVIEW ANDGENERIC FINANCIAL ADVICEIn March 2008, the final report of the Government-commissioned
Thoresen Review into providing a generic financial advice service,
or ‘money guidance’ (MG), was published. The Thoresen Review
was established in early 2007 to examine the feasibility of
delivering MG nationally at low or no cost to the consumer.
The CII has been engaged with the review’s work from the
beginning. Building on our considerable relevant experience in the
area of financial advice, and taking the view that a quality service
Political and regulatory issues play amajor role in the oversight of financialservices as does the qualificationsframework within which the CIIoperates. The CII's aspirations forimproving standards of professionalismand raising our profile and impact as aprofessional body mean it is vital thatwe have an influence in the politicaland regulatory environment. We haveinvested in a new Policy and Publicaffairs capability within the CII andhave played a leading part in a numberof major debates over regulatory andother issues in 2007. Four examples ofissues we have been involved inshaping are set out below.
is needed and would help both consumers and society, we were consulted by the Thoresen Review
team during their work. In 2007 the Personal Finance Society continued its work with Citizens
Advice into the feasibility of pro bono financial advice. Our second project, which followed 2005’s
successful work, is expected to run until March 2009. The project currently enlists 75 IFAs – who
are all participating on a strictly voluntary basis. Our research clearly demonstrates that even the
most basic of information made available to consumers will result in them taking action that will
have long-term benefits.
We were observers to the Thoresen ‘prototypes’, where we reviewed the skill and efficiency of advisers,
and we met regularly with Treasury officials and hosted the Review Team here at CII to discuss issues
of governance, training and accreditation. We also regularly engaged other stakeholders to share and
discuss mutual areas of concern.
The final report was well-received, and all indications are that a programme based around Thoresen’s
work will be established in the near future, with trial pathfinders starting in 2008.
Many of our suggestions were featured in the final report, and we plan on being involved throughout
the implementation stages in 2008. We believe that money guidance is an essential part of building
better financial capability in society.
FSA’S RETAIL DISTRIBUTION REVIEW (RDR)In June 2007 the Financial Services Authority (FSA) launched a Discussion Paper into
the market for retail investment products. One central recommendation supported
higher standards of behaviour and competence for financial advisers. The impact
on our membership will be significant, and so it was on this theme we based an
integrated public affairs and membership support campaign.
We designed a dedicated RDR website containing briefings, podcasts and event
information. This proved popular with 13,000 visitors and led to 4,000 downloads
from September 2007 to mid-February 2008. Regular ‘e-flyers’ were sent to inform
members of relevant policy developments and publications. Sixty road shows were
held nationwide for members to learn more, question key industry experts and put
forward their views.
The CII produced a series of five position papers, setting out our
position in an attempt to foster an industry consensus around
building a step-change in professional standards and developing
a new professional body framework including the idea of a single
independent professional standards board. These were sent to key
opinion formers, receiving excellent coverage and industry response.
Our members contributed to our final submission through our CII
working group and two member surveys – which received 800 and
1,300 responses. Key stakeholders were also involved, via regular
dialogue, in the development of our proposals.
The response to our campaign has been overwhelmingly positive,
with awareness running at 82 per cent of CII members. A recent
membership survey showed that two thirds of our members felt
we should run similar campaigns in the future.
The FSA initial feedback statement has taken on board a number
of these suggestions and we are working with them on how they
can be taken forward.
TheTalen
tInitiative
was
awarded
the
Assoc
iation
ofGraduateRec
ruiters(A
GR)
prize
forBes
tIntegratedCam
paignof
2007
48 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
SKILLSThe issue of skills continued to be an important
topic in 2007 following the groundbreaking 2006
report by Lord Leitch on UK skill levels and
international competitiveness. Our April 2007
skills survey established that 71 per cent of
employers perceive a shortage of technical skills,
and 63 per cent also believe that the demand for
professional qualifications will increase over the
next five years. Perhaps most tellingly, 46 per
cent of CII members believe that new entrants
into the industry were not as well equipped as
entrants only ten years ago.
On the back of this survey we undertook further
detailed research studies into two particular
areas. The Evolution of Claims and The Future of
Distribution in SME General Insurance examined
the problems and shortages faced by the claims
and underwriting sectors, and what action is
needed to address these in the future.
As part of our continuing efforts to engage educational stakeholders in addressing
the skills shortage, we established the CII Accredited Provider process, a quality
benchmark for CII providers in the education sector. The first school to receive
this designation was Glasgow’s Cardonald College in December. The College is now
accredited to offer the CII’s Certificate in Financial Planning course, which is the
benchmark qualification for financial advisers.
As proponents of the need for training, the CII has long been in favour of
apprenticeships as another way of filling the skills gap, and is in full support of
programmes such as Train to Gain, which incorporates the employers’ skills pledge.
The Government’s support of the apprenticeship approach is well documented and
the programme offers firms an excellent value-for-money recruitment and retention
tool, due to the funding available from the Learning and Skills Council. The revamped
apprenticeship scheme covers a whole host of sectors, including financial services,
and offers advantages such as the awarding of a technical qualification (e.g. the CII
Certificate in Insurance and the CII Certificate in Financial Planning).
By linking apprenticeships with a wider training and development
offer, such as Broker Academy, the CII is ensuring that the
training and development needs of the employer (including the
SME market) are being met.
Building on 2007’s work, we began 2008 by hosting a skills event
at which the Skills Minister David Lammy was able to listen to
the challenges we face as an industry and how we are beginning
to tackle them. This initial liaison will provide a basis for future
work as we continue to develop our skills policy.
The Talent Initiative was launched in responseto a commissioned study by the CASS BusinessSchool which showed that 90 per cent of UKgraduates wouldn’t consider a career ininsurance. This was supported by strongfeedback from senior managers and directorsthat it was an industry priority to improve theimage of insurance in the recruitment market.
The overall marketing strategy was to promote careers in insurance as adeliberate choice and to attract top talent into the industry. We recognisedthat what was needed was an ongoing ‘marketing campaign’ for the wholeindustry – rather than just a one-off recruitment campaign.
The CII Group created a wide and far reaching range of marketingtechniques for the Talent Initiative: a unique website, brochure, and othermarketing material including a three-minute original film on DVD forinsurance industry and careers advisors.
The In-Insurance initiative now delivers a consolidated framework andproposition that is supported by a comprehensive selection of activeresources and services available to both graduates and employers.
For the graduate, the Talent Initiative delivers a comprehensive careers information portal www.insurancecareers.cii.co.uk whichfeatures industry information and background. For employers, we have created a central industry information portal that offers targetedgraduate searches and promotion.
The Talent Initiative was awarded the Association of Graduate Recruiters (AGR) prize for Best Integrated Campaign of 2007.
50 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
54 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
“The Prince’s Trust’s ‘GetInto’ programme is afantastic opportunity foryoung people, helping themchange their lives and gaina vital insight into thehospitality industry. Theskills they learn not onlybenefit them but thehospitality sector in thefuture. We have offered allthe young people on thiscourse a position here atThe Ritz – this is a realtestament to their hardwork and determination.They really have exceededall expectations.”
Stephen Boxall, General Manager, Ritz
PRINCE’S TRUST
Since 2006, the CII has been a corporate Patron
of the Prince’s Trust, the UK’s leading youth
charity dedicated to delivering and developing
programmes and services for young people. The
CII strongly supports the Trust’s activities, and
continues to help members get involved. They
provide mentoring support to disadvantaged
young people, encouraging and assisting them
in achieving their ambitions. In 2007, the Trust
helped over 37,000 of the most disadvantaged
young people in the UK, and made great progress
in further developing the ‘Get Into’ Programme
and research into the cost of exclusion.
The CII is committed to giving back to the community and encouragesits employees and members to getinvolved in making a difference. In this section we summarise ourcorporate social responsibility (CSR)activity in relation to staff and ourown activities.
56 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
TREES FOR LIFE
Given the increased focus
on environmental issues and
climate change, we all need
to play a part to help preserve
the environment by cutting
down on unnecessary waste
where we can.
The CII is actively trying to
help by reducing the amount of
paper mailings sent to members
and has been encouraging them
to accept all correspondence
from us via email. Email is
more efficient, it’s faster and
it’s better for the environment.
For every email address we
receive, we donate 10p towards
Trees for Life’s reforestation
programme in the Scottish
Highlands. That means for
every 2,000 email addresses
we receive, an acre of land will
be purchased by Trees for Life
for planting with native trees.
DIVERSITY
The CII provides leadership
and services to a diverse
profession. It seeks to promote
ethical business and professional
practices among persons
engaged or employed in
financial services, and employs
staff from many different
backgrounds.
The CII values and respects this
diversity and strives in all of its
activities to take account of and
reflect the interests of all the
people it serves. Its Equality
and Diversity policy outlines
our commitment to eliminating
unfair discrimination,
promoting equality at all levels
of our organisation, and
improving diversity within
its own staff and the industry
as a whole.
VOLUNTEERING:OUR WORK WITHCITIZENS ADVICE INTOFINANCIAL ADVICE
In 2007 the CII, with fellow
group member the PFS,
continued research into the
feasibility of pro bono financial
advice. Our second project,
which followed 2005’s
successful work, is expected
to run until March 2009.
Thanks in part to funding from
Barclays and Aegon, we have
expanded from England and
Wales into Scotland and are
now covering 30 CAB offices.
The project currently enlists
38 IFAs – all participating on
a strictly voluntary basis.
INSURANCE CHARITIES
We also support the Insurance
Charities, an independent
organisation who give vital
support to past and present
employees of the insurance
industry and their dependent
relatives who are suffering
financial hardship. Under an
agreement with the credit
card company, the Insurance
Charities receive a dividend
on all purchases made using
the CII credit card, and we
also hold a specific annual
fundraising day. The Insurance
Charities also share
accommodation with us at
Aldermanbury, and we support
them with on-site facilities.
Local institutes nominate CII
members to act as volunteers
in assisting and fundraising in
their respective areas.
"The Insurance Charities providescommunity care and support to individualswho have worked within the insuranceindustry for a period of five or more yearsduring their career. Support comes inmany forms, including personal visits froma Charities representative, funding supportwith essential items such as wheelchairsand the provision of financial help with billpayment helping meet the cost of living.Beneficiaries are so pleased (and oftensurprised) with the breadth of supportwhich the Insurance Charities is able tooffer them.”
Caroline Ford, FCII, of BGL Group
60 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENTThe market situation for our members may be difficult,but there are significant signs for optimism and recovery,and the CII stands poised to continue offering the higheststandards in service and guidance.
In General Insurance, there were signs of hardening ratesbut for all other markets, rates continued to soften with the exception of the large catastrophe market. Insurancebrokers continue to be under pressure, and thepound/dollar exchange rate continues to be problematic.
The CII will continue to work in this challenging businessenvironment. The industry faces many changes andopportunities, including but not limited to:
• The credit crunch and its impact • Reputation and trust• Globalism• Longevity• Climate change
Demand for insurance
qualifications, professional
membership services and
learning opportunities will
continue to grow, as we have
seen in the key markets of
India, Southeast Asia, China
and the Middle East. We see
no reason why our growth in
membership will not continue,
and we will continue to expand
our operations wherever there
is a demand for our products
and services.
As the FSA in the UK continues
its move to pursue a principles-
based regime we see a
significant role for the
profession at the heart of the
industry. To that end, we have
contributed extensively to the
FSA’s review of retail
distribution and applaud the
regulator’s expected demands
for higher levels of
professionalism from within
the industry.
The CII is investing heavily
in its policy and public affairs
function to enhance and extend
its activities as a professional
standards setting body, and
contributing to thinking on
projects such as the RDR, the
Thoresen Review, and the skills
agenda.
We will continue to work with
our members, employers and
bodies such as the Financial
Services Skills Council to
ensure the Institute’s products
and services reflect the needs
of the market and change as
requirements evolve.
We continue to be firmly
committed to our Talent
Initiative, and strive to bring
more high-quality recruits into
the industry. As part of our
ongoing work in skills and
talent, we are engaging in a
programme of communication
and interaction with schools,
colleges and universities to
increase awareness of
insurance as a challenging
and rewarding career.
The Institute’s Governance
protocols have recently been
overhauled and modernised
following extensive
consultation with the
membership. This will
streamline many of our
processes and ensure that we
meet best practice standards.
The Institute has demonstrated
its responsiveness to market
developments with the
introduction of Chartered titles
for firms. This helps our
members to achieve
differentiation from their
competitors and enhance their
standing with customers.
62 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
ALL IMAGES UPTO THISPOINT OF THE DOCUMENT HAVE BEEN SOURCEDFROM FLICKR.COM
Page Member
06 MShades13 Tierney Nowland16 Hometown Invasion Tour18 Mick O24 Viajar24h26 walter menzies28 Jakeliefer30 danny.hammontree40 Swh42 kbaird46 on•tol•o•gy48 kr15tan
saturnismcolodio
51 F Zero54 Kungfootv56 Viton61 Devo In Regress
BOARD, REPRESENTATIVE COUNCILAND COMMITTEE STRUCTURE
Until 19 July 2007, the Council was the governing body of the CII.
Its function was to control and direct the policy of the Institute.
The Management Committee was responsible for the implementation
of policy on behalf of Council. With effect from 19 July both entities
were replaced by the CII Board. Prior to 19 July the CII’s Council
met in January, April and December and the Management Committee
met in March and June.
Numerous committees reported to Council or the Management
Committee throughout the period, the most significant of which were
Audit, Nominations & Remuneration and Professional Standards.
In addition the Executive Committee met on a monthly basis throughout the year.
This Committee also stood down with effect from 19 July.
Following the governance review the revisions to the committee structure mean
that the new Representative Council has a close liaison role with the Board whilst
the Nominations Committee, Remuneration Committee, Professional Standards Board
and Audit Committee report directly to the Board. The Examiners Committee (which
was replaced by the Qualifications, Examinations and Assessments Committee in
2008), Disciplinary Committee and Disciplinary Appeals Committee now report to
the Professional Standards Board.
We see no reasonwhy our growth in membership willnot continue, andwe will continue to expand ouroperations wherever there is a demand for our products andservices.
66 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
68 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
LORD HUNT
T J MATTHEWS
I J TEMPLETON
S FISHER
C MUNN
P HUBBARD
J WELLS C BRAND
M C ROGERSON
B BJELOBABA E A COYLE
P N MARTINA W SCOTT
70 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
REPORT FROM THE BOARDROLE OF THE BOARDThe Board’s role is to provide entrepreneurial strategic leadership of the CII Group within a framework
of prudent and effective controls which enables risk to be assessed and managed. The Board sets the
CII’s strategic aims, ensures that the necessary financial and human resources are in place for the CII
to meet its objectives and reviews management performance. The Board sets the CII’s values and
standards based on the recommendations of the Professional Standards Board and ensures that its
obligations to stakeholders are understood and met.
REPORT FROM THEREPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL(THE “COUNCIL”)
Composition of the BoardPresident and Chairman appointed July 2007 D.J. Hunt Hon FCII
Immediate Past President appointed July 2007 I.J. Templeton FCII Chartered Insurer
Deputy President appointed July 2007 T.J. Matthews
Employer Member appointed November 2007 S. Fisher ACII, Chartered Insurer
Employer Member appointed November 2007 P. Hubbard
Lay Member appointed November 2007 C. Munn
Lay Member appointed November 2007 J. Wells
Elected Member appointed November 2007 C. Brand ACII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner
Elected Member appointed July 2007 B. Bjelobaba FCII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner
Elected Member appointed July 2007 E.A. Coyle ACII, APFS, Chartered Insurer
Elected Member appointed July 2007 M.C. Rogerson
Chief Executive Officer appointed July 2007 A.W. Scott
Finance Director appointed July 2007 P.N. Martin
MeetingsTwo meetings were held during the last year with
the attendance records as follows:
12 September 2007 – 8 out of 8 members
22 November 2007 – 12 out of 13 members
Activities of the BoardAt its inaugural meeting the Board approved
the remaining Board member appointments and
confirmed the further appointments of Robin
Jordan as independent Chairman of the new
Nominations Committee. In accordance with the
Terms of Reference, Peter Hubbard was confirmed
as Chairman of the new Remunerations
Committee. Much of the year, however, was taken
up with consideration of the CII’s strategic
approach to the FSA’s Retail Distribution Review
comprising the Institute’s stance and researched
response along with the production of five
Position Papers. Every indication to date is that
the CII has shown effective industry leadership
and has achieved considerable support and
consensus of views amongst the principal
professional and trade bodies.
ROLE OF COUNCILThe aims of the Council include:
• To be the intellectual engine of the CII
• To ensure that projects and initiatives are
relevant, forward looking and together have
a cohesion to deliver the CII’s vision
• To help the CII to maintain a proper balance
in its programme
• To provide the optimum relationship between
“trusteeship/directorship” in their broadest
senses (provided by the Board) and
representation of the wider interests of the
membership and the general public for whose
benefit the CII exists
• To be the conscience of the CII and the forum
in which the Board is held to account
• To advise the Board on recommendations for
the future direction of the Institute
Composition of the CouncilThe Council is made up of Members elected by
their respective Local Institute constituencies,
plus nationally elected representatives of the
Student, Certificate level, Diploma level,
Advanced Diploma level and Fellowship
communities.
In addition the CII appoint certain ex officio post
holders such as the President (who is also
chairman), the Deputy President, the Immediate
Past President, Vice Presidents, Past Presidents,
The President of the Personal Finance Society,
Faculty and Committee chairs and for the first
time lay representatives (i.e. non Members) whose
role is to bring an independent and objective view
to the proceedings.
Meetings Two meetings were held in the year with the
attendance records as follows:
12 September 2007 – 24 out of 41 members
22 November 2007 – 22 out of 42 members
Activities of the CouncilThe inaugural session of the new Council took
place in September and among other things
it was agreed to set up a task force making
recommendations in connection with a publicly
searchable database of members.
The Local Institute Development Committee was
asked to consider and make recommendations
concerning the triennial review of Local Institute
boundaries.
The Chief Executive reported formally to Council
on issues and developments currently facing the
CII and the Finance Director reported on risk.
Both were on hand to answer questions.
At the November session the database task
reported back with their suggested parameters
and the CII’s web team agreed to scope and cost
out the project.
In addition to the Chief Executive and Finance
Director’s reports, the CII’s Director of Strategy
and Change updated the meeting on current
developments internationally, the Area Marketing
Managers reported on the emergence and
development of Local Institute “ToolKits” and the
Customer Service Director presented on the CII’s
internal project to improve the customer interface
with the Institute.
A section of each meeting in 2007 was devoted
to issues of critical strategic importance for
the Institute.
72 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
REPORTS FROM COMMITTEES. AUDIT
Financial AccountsThe Committee reviewed the financial statements
for the year ended 31st December 2007 and the
various reports from the external auditors
Deloitte’s. This process was finalised at the
Committee’s meeting in March 2008. The review
of the accounts for the period ending 31 December
2006 was finalised in March 2007 and cleared for
presentation to the Management Committee and
Council for approval. See Conclusions below.
Internal financial controls and riskmanagement systemsDuring the year management continued to
develop and refine the presentation of the Risk
Report. It was agreed that full consideration of
risk would become a scheduled topic of
consideration for the Board. This has now been
incorporated into the Board’s annual Schedule of
Work as agreed by the Board in September. It was
also agreed with management that there would
be more frequent reports to the Committee on the
progress against the Strategic Business Plan.
An innovation in the period was the establishment
of a CII policy on the appointment of auditors in
relation to non-audit work. This policy was
agreed with the Committee at its March meeting
and is now being implemented.
The Committee also noted and concurred with
the Institute’s improved approach to revenue
forecasting and the re-structuring of the Finance
ROLE OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEEThe role of the Audit Committee is to review the integrity of financial reporting and the audit process and to
ensure that The Chartered Insurance Institute has sound internal financial control systems and systems for the
control of non-financial risks.
Composition of the Audit Committee during the yearBoyle, L, FCII, LL.B, TEP, FSI, Chartered Insurer, Chairman, Isle of Man – Appointed Chairman September 2004
Jarrett, JM, FCII, Cheltenham & Gloucester, Chartered Insurance Practitioner – Appointed November 2004
Harding, A, ACA, FCCA, BSc (Econ), MBA, London – Appointed March 2006
Killick, BE, ACII, B Com, CA (NZ), Chartered Insurance Practitioner, London – Appointed November 2006
Whitaker, RA, FCII, LLB, DMS, Chartered Insurer, London – Appointed 1999 (retired June 2007)
Whitehouse, R, FCII, B.Soc Sc., MCMI, ACIArb, Chartered Insurer, London – Appointed November 2006
Howard, P, FCII, Chartered Insurer – Appointed November 2007
MeetingsThree meetings were held during the last year with the attendance records as follows:
20 March 2007 – 6 out of 6 members
26 June 2007 – 6 out of 6 members
27 November 2007 – 6 out of 6 members
function as discussed in the external auditor’s
management letter for the 2006 audit. It is also
incumbent upon the committee to consider from
time to time whether there is suitable resource
to allow management to mitigate risks. The
Committee confirms that there are no issues
of concern in relation to capacity in this area.
Governance IssuesThe Committee was kept informed of the
Institute’s progress with the corporate governance
changes up to and including the Special General
Meeting on 11 April 2007. There were no issues
of concern arising. Following acceptance of the
new constitutional arrangements by Members,
the Committee will continue to monitor the CII’s
governance and in particular the effectiveness
of the interface between it and the Board.
In line with recognised good governance
standards a protocol for the re-tendering of
the external auditors was agreed with the CII’s
management and a full re-tendering exercise
will take place in 2008.
ConclusionThe Committee believes that the substance of
its discussions is fairly recorded in its minutes
of proceedings. It is pleased to report that, from
the extensive information that has been made
available, it does not consider that there are
any other issues that need to be drawn to the
attention of the Board or Members.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL 2008-2009
Appointments from the BoardAppointed Ex-officioPresident (Chairman) D.J.F. Hunt, HonFCIIDeputy President T. MatthewsImmediate Past President I.J. Templeton, FCII, Chartered Insurer
Vice PresidentsVice President R.J. Anderson, FCII, FPFS, Chartered Financial PlannerVice President S. Fisher, ACII, Chartered InsurerVice President C.D. Hanks, ACII, Chartered InsurerVice President J.T. James, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerVice President K.J. Wallace, FCII, Chartered Insurer
Chairmen of SocietiesPersonal Finance Society President R. Reid, ACII, APFS, Chartered Financial Planner
Past PresidentsPast President A.C. Homer, FCII, Chartered InsurerPast President R.O. Hudson, FCII, Chartered Insurer
Committee ChairmenRemuneration P. HubbardAudit L. Boyle, FCII, Chartered InsurerDisciplinary J.L. Neilson, FCII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerAppeal P.J. Finch, ACII, Chartered InsurerExaminers P.J. Williams, FCII, FPFS, Chartered Financial Planner
Lay RepresentativesLay Representative 1 M. Saunders
Elected Local Institute RepresentativesScotland A N.D. Toothill, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerScotland B T.L.W. Torrance, FCII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerNorth East A B.W. Thornton, FCII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerNorth East B D.G. Cummings, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerNorth East C E.A. Coyle, ACII, APFS, Chartered InsurerNorth West A K.P. Wood, Cert PFSNorth West B L. Bamber, FCII, Chartered Insurance BrokerNorth West C P.J. Heathcote, ACII, Chartered Insurance BrokerSouthern A C.A. Brand, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerSouthern B T.H.S. Wiseman, ACIISouth East A K.V. Peraux, Cert PFSSouth East B VacantSouth West A P. Regan, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerSouth West B S.M. Riches, ACII, Chartered InsurerSouth Central B. Bjelobaba, FCII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerEastern A VacantEastern B L.M. Harold, DipCIIEast Midlands M.C. RogersonWest Midlands C.A. Hayward, ACII, Chartered Insurance BrokerSouth West/South Wales A.J. Greensweig, ACII, Chartered InsurerNorthern Ireland S. S. Wallace, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerLondon A T.J. Doherty, FCII, Chartered InsurerLondon B D. Brewer, CMG FCII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerLondon C C.E.L. PhilippsAssociated C. Lacey, ACII
Members Elected by National Membership RepresentativesACII C.P. Leahy, ACII, Chartered Insurance PractitionerFCII C. Smith, FCII, Chartered Insurer
MAIN ACTIVITIES OF THE COMMITTEE IN 2007
74 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
REPORTS FROM COMMITTEES. NOMINATIONS & REMUNERATION
Composition of the Nomination and Remunerations Committee until July 2007Note – Appointments to the Committee are on an ex officio basis.Independent non executive chairman appointed 2002/3 R.E. Brown FCII Chartered Insurer
President appointed 2005/6 I.J. Templeton FCII Chartered Insurer
Deputy President appointed 2006/7 D.J. Hunt Hon FCII
Immediate Past President appointed 2004/5 P.R. Hales ACII Chartered Insurer
Representative from Manco appointed 2004/5 L. Williamson ACII Chartered Insurance Practitioner
Chief Executive Officer appointed 2000/1 A.W. Scott
ROLE OF THE NOMINATIONS &REMUNERATION COMMITTEEThe role of the Nominations and Remuneration
Committee is to:
• Receive and originate suggestions of possible
candidates to be Officers of the CII and
Chairmen of CII Committees and to make
recommendations
• Oversee from time to time, the selection and
appointment of the Director General of the
Institute and to make recommendations
• Receive and originate suggestions of candidates
for Honorary Fellowship of the CII, and to make
recommendations to the Honorary Fellowship
Assessment Board
• Receive, originate and approve suggestions of
candidates for nomination for New Year and
Queen’s Honours and to oversee the submission
of nominations to HM Government
• Determine the remuneration packages,
including payment procedures and benefits
of any kind of the Director General and other
Director members of the CII Executive
Committee
• Mitigate against any perceived conflict of
interest between the different functions of the
Nominations and Remunerations Committee
The committee was split into separate
Nominations and Remunerations Committees
in July 2007 as part of the governance changes.
MeetingsTwo meetings were held during the year
with the attendance records as follows:
15 February 2007 – 5 out of 6 members
23 March 2007 – 5 out of 6 members
ROLE OF THE NOMINATIONS COMMITTEE
The role of the Nominations Committee is to:• Give full consideration to succession planning for such Members
of the Board as are appointed by the Board itself
• Be responsible for identifying and nominating for approval of the
Board, candidates to fill vacancies on the Board and committees
• Make recommendations to the Board concerning succession for
Council members and in particular the key roles of President
and Chief Executive
• Make recommendations to the Board concerning chairmanship
of the various Board committees
• Make recommendations to the Honorary Fellowship Assessment
Board concerning candidates for Honorary Fellowship
• Make recommendations to the Board concerning candidates
for nominations for National Honours
Composition of the Nominations CommitteeIndependent non executive chairman appointed November 2007 R. Jordan
Immediate Past President appointed July 2007 I.J. Templeton FCII Chartered Insurer
President appointed July 2007 D.J. Hunt Hon FCII
Deputy President appointed July 2007 T.J. Matthews
Board Member from Council appointed September 2007 E.A. Coyle ACII, APFS Chartered Insurer
Note Mr R.E. Brown FCII – Chartered Insurer, acted as interim chairman for the September 2007 meeting. The CII would
like to record its thanks to Reg for his hard work and influence as Chairman of the Nominations and Remuneration
Committee from 2002/3 to his well deserved retirement in September 2007.
MeetingsTwo meetings were held during the last
year with the attendance records as follows:
12 September 2007 – 2 out of 2 members
22 November 2007 – 3 out of 4 members
Main Activities of theCommittee in 2007The separation of the duties
of the Nominations and
Remuneration Committee arose
following Member consultation
under the governance review.
There was considerable confusion
relating to the role and authority
of the old committee and a widely
held misconception concerning
its authority.
In the interests of openness and
transparency, the two elements
of the committee’s role were
separated and a wholly
independent lay chairman
was engaged.
The CII consequently welcomed
in post its first Nominations
Committee chairman from outside
the membership of the CII.
Robin Jordan joined the
Committee as lay chairman
in November 2007 following
a Nolan based recruitment
procedure now formalised
and published in the new
committee’s Terms of Reference.
He is a Chartered Companion
of the Chartered Institute of
Personnel and Development
and holds an MA in Economics
and Maths from the University
of Edinburgh. His extensive
experience includes being an
Assessor for Ministerial Public
Appointments in Scotland and
Chairing the CIPD Board as
well as being a member of its
Remuneration and other
committees. One of his ongoing
priorities is to continually
review the methods by which
potential candidates are
currently identified and
recommended in the light
of best practice and with
special focus on simplicity
and openness and transparency
of process. He is keen to point
out that any improvements in
process should be with the
primary aim of identifying
and recommending the best
candidates for office/honour
from the widest pool possible,
while at the same time as
recognising the highly
confidential nature of the
majority of the work of this
committee.
During 2007 the committees
pre-and post-July considered
in excess of 50 names of
individuals as having potential
in relation to the Institute’s
succession planning process.
76 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
ROLE OF THE REMUNERATIONS COMMITTEE
The main role of the Remunerations Committeeincludes making recommendations to the Board on:• The framework or broad policy for the remuneration of the
executive members of the Board;
• The on-going appropriateness and relevance of the remuneration
policy for staff;
• The design of and targets for any staff performance related pay
schemes and the total annual payments made under such schemes.
Composition of the Remunerations CommitteeChairman appointed September 2007 P. Hubbard
President appointed July 2007 D.J. Hunt Hon FCII
Deputy President appointed July 2007 T.J. Matthews
Note – Mr R.E. Brown FCII, Chartered Insurer served as interim Chairman
for the July meeting before stepping down in September.
MeetingsTwo meetings were held during the last year
with the attendance records as follows:
12 September 2007 – 2 out of 3 members
22 November 2007 – 2 out of 3 members
Main Activities of theCommittee in 2007The proposals for the staff
salaries and the Achievement
Bonus Scheme were discussed
in 2007. The Achievement
Bonus Scheme has now been
revised to introduce an
individual and team element
bonus scheme in addition to a
corporate element. The new
design is intended to focus
everyone on achieving the
business plan for 2008.
All staff members are subjected
to both mid year and year end
Performance & Development
Reviews which can affect any
incentive payments under the
Achievement Bonus Scheme,
for example the achievement of
departmental budgets in respect
of directors and heads of
departments. The President
systematically reviews the
performance of the Chief
Executive and reports to the
committee accordingly.
PROFESSIONALSTANDARDS BOARDROLE OF THE PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS BOARDThe role of the Professional Standards Board (PSB) is to develop policy and
standards for CII members, including professional conduct and trust, discipline,
ethics and competence; to develop appropriate policy and standards for the CII’s
governance, including accountability, diversity, consumer representation and
transparency; to monitor and review these standards; to communicate the standards
to the members and committees; to promote professionalism and the adoption
of high standards within the industry, with government, with regulators and most
importantly to consumers.
Composition of the PSB during the yearIndependent non exec chairman appointed 2006 D. McIntosh
Research & Events appointed 2002 K. Borrett FCII, Chartered Insurer
Regulatory Representative appointed 2003 A. Darling FCII, Chartered Insurer
Loss Adjusting Representative appointed 2003 A. King
Wholesale Market Representative appointed 2005 D. Gamble
Financial Services Representative appointed 2003 R. Rennison FCII, FPFS, Chartered Financial Planner
Consumer Interest Representative appointed 2005 S. Locke
Academic Representative appointed 2006 J. Navare FCII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner
Chief Executive Officer ex officio appointed 2000 A.W. Scott
Deputy Director General ex officio appointed 2004 R.A. Bullivant, FCII, APFS, Chartered Financial Planner
Consumer Interest Representative appointed 2007 N. Mullany
MeetingsFour meetings were held during the last
year with the attendance records as follows:
23 January 2007 – 9 out of 10 members
25 April 2007 – 5 out of 10 members
Main Activities of the Board in 2007The governance review sought to
raise the profile of the Professional
Standards Board and in so doing
amended the reporting lines of
the CII’s standing Committees.
This saw the transfer of direct
responsibility for the Examiners
Committee being transferred from
the governing body to the
Professional Standards Board.
This gave the PS Board specific
responsibility for the Disciplinary
Committee, the Disciplinary
Appeals Committee and Examiners.
Much of the year’s programme
followed on from 2006 with
considerable progress being made
with leading the industry’s
response to the FSA’s Retail
Distribution Review. Roderic
Rennison chaired the FSA’s
Industry Group on
Professionalism, and apart from a
comprehensive submission to the
FSA the CII also issued 5 Position
Papers the reaction to which was
predominantly positive.
Responses and contributions were
also made to the Thoresen Review
of Generic Financial Advice.
There was additionally increased
emphasis on matters of equality
and diversity and various
initiatives approved, many of
which will begin to take shape
from quarter one 2008.
In September 2007 the
Professional Standards Board set
up a sub-group under its direction
to review the content style and
impact of the Code of Ethics and
Conduct. The current Code was
issued in September 2004 and was
due for review in the light of
experience within the CII,
especially in the disciplinary arena
but also as a response to world
events such as Enron. A final draft
for consultation purposes was
anticipated by September 2008.
During the year Angela Darling,
Andrew King and Roderic
Rennison all agreed to stand
for a second and final three
year term on the PS Board. Nicola
Mullany attended her first meeting
of the Board in November 2007.
78 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
EXAMINERS COMMITTEEROLE OF THE EXAMINERS COMMITTEEThe role of the Examiners Committee was to oversee the development and operation
of the Institute’s examinations to ensure that their integrity and standard were
maintained and that they remained relevant and ‘fit for purpose’. The committee
reported to the CII Management Committee prior to the governance changes in
July 2007 and to the Professional Standards Board thereafter.
However, in 2007 the Committee recommended a restructure with change of
emphasis to ensure that it was in alignment with QCA requirements, the CII’s
Regulator. The Examiners Committee were instrumental in drafting and approving
the Terms of Reference for the new Qualifications, Examinations and Assessments
Committee (QEAC) which held its first meeting in April 2008.
Composition of the Examiners Committee during the yearAlexander, EVC, ACII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner Appointed 1992
Bamford, N, APFS, Chartered Financial Planner Appointed 2005 Resigned 1 August 2007
Gilbey, MA, FPFS, Chartered Financial Planner Appointed 2005
Kenney-Wallace, G Appointed 2005
Lacey, C, ACII Appointed 2002
Morton, IS, FCII, FPFS, Chartered Financial Planner Appointed 2005
Nicholls, L (lay member) Appointed July 2006
Parsons, C, FCII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner Appointed 1990
Smith, A, FCII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner Appointed 2005
Smith, PRA, FCII, Chartered Insurer Appointed 2001
Stein, WM, FCII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner Appointed 2004
Williams, PJ, FCII, FPFS Appointed 2003 Appointed Interim Chairman January 2007
Chartered Financial Planner Vice Chairman
Warr, C, ACII, Chartered Insurer Appointed 2005
MeetingsFive meetings were held in the year with the attendance records as follows:
1 February 2007 – 7 out of 13 members
26 April 2007 – 8 out of 13 members
25 July 2007 – 7 out of 13 members
10 October 2007 – 6 out of 12 members
5 December 2007 – 8 out of 12 members
Main activities of theCommittee in 2007
Examination Standards
The committee reviewed the
policies adopted in relation to
the setting and marking of
exams to ensure that all
candidates received a fair result.
It paid particular attention to
the controls which were
introduced as a result of the
transfer of objectively tested
examinations to an on line
format.
Accreditation
The committee oversaw the
granting of requests for
accreditation of prior learning
from a wide variety of students
and educational institutions. Its
policy in considering such
requests was always to ensure
that a candidate was treated
fairly.
Syllabus Content
The committee oversaw the
content which was placed into
CII syllabus areas.
Conclusion
The Committee believes that the
substance of its discussions was
fairly recorded in the minutes of
the Committee which were
submitted to Council for review
prior to July 2007. After July
2007, the Committee reported to
the Professional Standards
Board by exception and were
satisfied that the criteria for this
were met. The Committee were
pleased to report that, from the
extensive information that had
been made available, it did not
consider that there are any
other issues that needed to be
drawn to the attention of the
Professional Standards Board
DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEEROLE OF THE DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEEThe role of the Disciplinary Committee is to:
• Consider any Complaint made against CII Members in accordance
with the Disciplinary Rules and Regulations Procedures. 74 cases
were investigated in 2007 other than cases where members had
failed to produce CPD records
• Oversee the process by which the people who fail to produce CPD
records on request are disciplined
• Appoint a Panel from within the Committee membership to hear Complaints
• Determine the validity of any Complaint
• Where the Complaint is upheld, to decide appropriate disciplinary
action against a Respondent
• Review applications for membership from bankrupts and people
with criminal convictions. Eight applications were considered
in 2007. Four applications were accepted and four were rejected.
Composition of the Disciplinary Committee during the year
* Please note that by a decision of Council dated November 2005 appointment dates are deemed to run from 2002
or actual date of appointment if later
Chairman Davidson, KM, ACII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner, London Appointed 2002 (retired 18 July 2007)
Chairman Neilson, JL, FCII, MSc, MBA, FCII, FCIArb, Chartered Insurance Practitioner
Harrow and Ealing, (Chairman from 19 July 2007) Appointed 2002
Ferguson, J, OBE, FRPharm.S, FPS(NZ) Hon, DSc (lay member) Appointed 2002
Goddard, E, FIOD, FCMI, FGBC, MIAM, RMaPS (lay member) Appointed 2002
McCombe, GJ, FCII, Chartered Insurer, Belfast Appointed 2004
McGregor, S, JP, BA (Hons), Dip Ed FIMI, (lay member) Appointed 2004
McNair, N, FIMS, (lay member) Appointed 2003
Moss, RF, Dip PFS, Cert CII (MP), Bristol Appointed 2002
Robinson, MJS, ACII, BA(hons) Chartered Insurer, London Appointed 2003
Scott, ERD, BSc (Hons), ACII, MRICS, ACIArb, FCILA, FUEDI-ELAE
Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Kendal Appointed 2002
Watson, KJ, ACII, FCILA, Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Nottingham Appointed 2002
Weald, RA, FCII, Chartered Insurer, Peterborough Appointed 2002
Williamson, L, ACII, Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Edinburgh Appointed 2002
Committee MeetingsGenerally four meetings are held in the Institute year although only
three were required in 2007. Two of the meetings held were
convened on the same date as disciplinary hearings which had
taken place in the morning. Committee Members not selected for
the Panels who had to commute long distances and who were not
required for the hearing, were generally excused physical
attendance at the afternoon’s Committee meetings due to issues of
time and cost effectiveness. Adequate provision was nevertheless
made for those living remotely to fully contribute to these
Committee meetings.
8 March 2007 – 5 out of 13 members
17 May 2007 – 6 out of 13 members
27 September 2007 – 8 out of 12 members
80 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
Disciplinary HearingsDates for four hearings are scheduled for each Institute year, however, only three dates were required for 2007.
8 March 2007 – member reprimanded for bringing unauthorised material to an examination
17 May 2007 – member reprimanded for failing to comply with FSA regulations
27 September 2007 – four members were reprimanded and asked to pay £25 towards the cost of the hearing
for failing to treat a member of their organisation fairly
There were also three disciplinary
hearings the details of which are
below (see Disciplinary
Hearings).The Preliminary Screener
adjudicated on one case (apart
from CPD where all cases are dealt
with by the Preliminary Screener)
and a reprimand was issued.
In 2007, 1,841 qualified members
were randomly selected to provide
CPD records and as a result of this
11 people had their designations or
chartered titles rescinded.
Main Activities of the Committee in 2007At the beginning of 2007, a new scheme to select CPD records from up to 10% of the
membership scheme was implemented. Due to the increase in the number of people
who are required to produce CPD records, it is too time consuming and not cost
effective for a disciplinary hearing to be arranged for every member who fails to
produce their CPD record on request, The Disciplinary Rules and Regulations were
amended during 2006 to allow the Preliminary Screener the authority to remove
the chartered titles and designations from CPD defaulters. However, the Disciplinary
Committee have played an integral part of ensuring that this scheme is administered
fairly, ensuring that the Preliminary Screener uses his powers appropriately and the
Committee has also provided CPD defaulters with a right of appeal against the
Preliminary Screener’s decision.
In addition, due to the number of applications for membership which were being
received from bankrupts and people with criminal convictions, the Committee set
up a Membership Application Sub-Committee and drew up a process and criteria
for dealing with such applications.
The Committee have also looked at the content of the Disciplinary Rules and
Regulations with a view to updating them if required. Two particular changes they
have considered are a review of the sanctions to ensure that sanctions can be
rehabilitative rather than punitive and a more effective way to publish the details
of people who have been the subject of disciplinary proceedings. These changes will
be put to the Board for approval in 2008.
The large majority of complaints received are misuse of designatory
letters or complaints not substantiated by the required standard of
evidence or are not appropriate for the CII to deal with in the first
instance. Misuse of designation cases vary and are often dealt with
by simple exchange of letter unless it appears as though the act is
deliberate. Other cases may be referred to the Financial Ombudsman,
the FSA, other professional bodies or are cases which are otherwise
before the courts. There were, however, a number of lengthy
investigations which will result in hearings in the early part of 2008.
APPEAL COMMITTEEROLE OF THE APPEAL COMMITTEEThe role of the Appeal Committee is to:
• Consider Appeals lodged by Appellants against the decisions of the Disciplinary
Committee in accordance with the CII’s Disciplinary Regulations 2004
• Appoint a Panel from within the Committee membership to hear the Appeal
• Act as the Disciplinary Committee’s review and oversight body
Composition of the Appeal Committee during the year
* Please note that by a decision of Council dated November 2005 appointment dates
are deemed to run from 2002 or actual date of appointment if later
Chairman: Kellett, BPD, FCII, Chartered Insurer, London, Appointed 2002 (retired 17 July 2007)
Chairman: Finch, PJ, ACII, MSI, Chartered Insurer
Chelmsford and South Essex
Appointed Chairman from 18 July 2007, Appointed 2002
Azubike D, JP, PhD, BSc,DIC, MIMMM, C.Eng, CMIOSH (lay member), Appointed 2005
Haggis E, ACII, Solicitor, FPMI, Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Manchester, Appointed 2002
Helyar, I, FCII, LLB, MIRM, Chartered Insurance Broker, Leeds, Appointed 2002
Hillier, EDG, FCII, CertPFS, Solicitor, Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Appointed 2002
Royal Tunbridge Wells
Hewitt, P, FCII, LL.B, Chartered Insurer, Appointed 2002
Ipswich, Suffolk and North Essex
Jaffe, P, FCII, Solicitor, Attorney at Law, Chartered Insurer, London, Appointed 2002
Jenner, AJ, FCII, FCIPD, Chartered Insurer, Brighton, Appointed 2002
Greenhill RT, Chartered CCIPD,FCIB, FIoD (lay member), Appointed 2002
Please note: Peter Taylor, Solicitor, Harry Mawdsley, OBE, JP, DL, and Michael Williams, Barrister
(Australia) and Solicitor Advocate (England and Wales) were appointed to the Committee in 2008
Committee MeetingsGenerally four meetings are held in the Institute
year although clearly the requirements for
Appeals and meetings of its Committee are closely
related to those of Disciplinary. The comments
made under the Disciplinary section above apply
equally to Appeals.
9 May 2007 – 8 out of 10 members
27 September 2007 – 7 out of 9 members
Appeal HearingsNo hearings were required in 2007
Main Activities of theCommittee in 2007During 2007, the Committee have
reviewed the current Disciplinary
Rules and Regulations to ensure
that they remain contemporary
and relevant. As a result of this
process and in consultation with
the Disciplinary Committee and
Professional Standards Board
certain changes will go to the CII
Board for approval in 2008. The
changes are focused on increasing
the range of sanctions to make
them rehabilitative rather than
punitive where possible and
identify individuals who
contravene the Code of Ethics with
more certainty when Disciplinary
decisions are published.
The Committee also has an
oversight role for the Disciplinary
Committee and receives case
statistics and matters referred
to it for consideration by the
Disciplinary Committee.
WE BELIEVE THENEED FORPROFESSIONALSTANDARDS HASNEVER BEENGREATER. ANDTHERE IS NO MORESOLID PLATFORMON WHICH TO BUILDTHE CII.
82 ANNUAL REPORT 2007
THE CHARTERED INSURANCE INSTITUTE
20 Aldermanbury, London EC2V 7HYtel: +44 (0)20 8989 8464fax: +44 (0)20 8530 3052
email: [email protected]: www.cii.co.uk
© The Chartered Insurance Institute 2008