cidoc 2014

32
Language of Bindings thesaurus Athanasios Velios Nicholas Pickwoad Aurelie Martin

Upload: athanasios-velios

Post on 21-Jun-2015

76 views

Category:

Education


5 download

DESCRIPTION

Presentation about the Language of Bindings thesaurus alongside some interesting conceptual problems of bookbinding surveys.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CIDOC 2014

Language of Bindings thesaurus

Athanasios VeliosNicholas Pickwoad

Aurelie Martin

Page 2: CIDOC 2014

Stitched structures

Page 3: CIDOC 2014
Page 4: CIDOC 2014
Page 5: CIDOC 2014

Multi-cultural developmentavoid language/tradition dominance

1

Page 6: CIDOC 2014

Multi-cultural development

● English bookbinding structures are not dominant

Page 7: CIDOC 2014
Page 8: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Exact match

Page 9: CIDOC 2014

FRENCH ITALIAN

ITALIAN ITALIAN

SPANISH GERMAN

ENGLISH FLEMISH

Page 10: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Partial equivalence– e.g. brochure (french) – pamphlets

● Compound terms– e.g. αιγοπρόβατα (greek) – sheep and/or goats

Page 11: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Partial equivalence– e.g. brochure (french) – pamphlets

● Compound terms– e.g. αιγοπρόβατα (greek) – sheep and/or goats

● Orphan terms– αιγοπρόβατα

● sheep● goats

Page 12: CIDOC 2014

Rapid developmentfunding available for two years

2

Page 13: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Get experts in one place● Intense 3 day workshops● Good volume of data

– lack of referencing

Page 14: CIDOC 2014
Page 15: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Experts divided in teams

● Work on tasks for an hour● Team facilitators record discussions

– SKOS understanding important● Team reps meet to report / ask questions

Page 16: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Experts divided in teams

● Work on tasks for an hour● Team facilitators record discussions

– SKOS understanding important● Team reps meet to report / ask questions

Page 17: CIDOC 2014
Page 18: CIDOC 2014

Progress

● Number of concepts relatively stable (~700)– Bookbinding manual publication

● First level of hierarchies complete– Reviewing others

● Thesaurus website up and running

Page 19: CIDOC 2014
Page 20: CIDOC 2014

scope note(longish)

scope note(longish)

Page 21: CIDOC 2014

hierarchyhierarchy

Page 22: CIDOC 2014

workflow basedon FORTH'sWebTMS

workflow basedon FORTH'sWebTMS

Page 23: CIDOC 2014

users canfollow termsusers can

follow terms

Page 24: CIDOC 2014

Interesting problemsplease help

3

Page 25: CIDOC 2014

Positive negative

● Absence of a characteristic could be meaningful

● Create records of non-existing characteristics

Page 26: CIDOC 2014
Page 27: CIDOC 2014

Survey problems

● Data depends on observation– (Lack of) experience of surveyor– Weak survey method

Page 28: CIDOC 2014

Ioannes Copus, De fructibus libri quatuor, Paris: Christian Wechel, 1535

Page 29: CIDOC 2014

Nature of form

● Materials combined based on a technique● What is the result?

– e.g. thread and longstitch structure

Page 30: CIDOC 2014

"Unraveling ball of string" by Lewis Ronald - Own work.CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Unraveling_ball_of_string.jpg

Page 31: CIDOC 2014

Gio. Felice Astolfi, Cento Avenimmento Meraviglioso, Venice, 1660

L’Epistole d’Ovidio in Terza Rima del Signor Angelo Rodolfini,

Macerata: Guiseppe Picini, 1682

Page 32: CIDOC 2014

www.ligatus.org.uk