christological controversy and the division of the church - father v.c. samuel

8/3/2019 Christological Controversy and the Division of the Church - Father V.C. Samuel

1/27

78944.,43974;078,3/90;8434190:7.

,907'$,2:0

3974/:.943

%0,2-7/0&3;0789!708870,979,35:-80/3703/8-44 %0

#80 41 9043458904;02039 3 9 90 ,:947 /0,8 9 90 859 3 90:7. 9,9

4..:770/8:-806:03994904:3.41,.0/433%8.4:3.,890430-014709

. ,/ 209 ,9 508:8 3 ,/ .,:80/ 90 789,3 .422:3908 3 90 ,89 94 -0

/;/0/703/9,08:5147/8.:884390.4:3.4170107739490:7.97,/9439,9

700.90/9,8902434589024;02039%09904190-4440;078-4:3/947,8090

6:08943,8 9070, 2434589024;02039 3789,38947 0907 3 ,3.0399208 47

83.090335483906:08943398,4:75:7548083499441107,7043/0794703/47

,3-4/080-:94394850.190543941/05,79:70.0,88:2034:7970,92039

%0 9072 24345890/408349,;0 , 89479,9 408-,.94909.039:79,8

.430/31,724/073920839008907347/.42-3,943419070047/824348

,3/ 588 24345890 20,38 8303,9:70/ %0 147/ .943,7 41 90 789,3

:7. 3980/943/08.7-0843458982,8%0/4.9730 9,9390!0784341

903.,73,907899070,8-:9430830,3/9,9,;30,9:70,8,,38990794/4

90,.341, /4:-0,9:70;30,3/:2,3,1907 90 3.,73,943 ,9 83490/3 98

,79.0 8 4-;4:8 349 90 90,.3 41 90 :7. 97,/943 9,9 700.90/ 90 4:3. 41

,.0/4398902,3,94341907907.900/947,-4,7/4190705:90/70548947

4190-089388.4,7853:7.89477,907.,4:8,5574;0/

%0:804190907297010703.09490,89073:7.08.7034:3.0/90.4:3.41

2508 90 383:,943 9,9 907 700.94341 ,.0/43.43899:90/0708 03/ 98


2/27

;090700890388903.09,990430:7..4310880/390700/.438890/419089,90

:7.41,3.039#42,32570%01,,.390,7:20398.0,7

%0708,/0.,905439.84:/-03490/0700890738.4,785,79.:,75078438

41 0..08,89., 0,733 3 90 34$,43 47/ ,70 2470 .,7 41 ,.340/3 90

:7.97,/9439,9700.98,.0/4394-0794/49,3904309,97034:3.08904:3.

41508:83$3.0,.0/43,/890/7410,3/7,990794/490.43

8/072,243901,90784190:7.3,847941,3:30,8,-:990,70439040

/11/039 94,88390 8,2070.43943 9494804 970/94 574249078904450780

,1907,.0/43 703/2801,3/, 3:2-074149078,/29 9,9 90 90,.341$0;07:841

394.4 1440/7 ;07 4, 8 3/00/84:3/ 09147902$0;07:88, 2434

5890,3/24704;0790,70349/85480/948903948.79.8241,.0/4307090

3.,35,79,914790:3/;/0/:7.4190178914:7.:203.,4:3.82,70,

-0 ,9472470 9,3 8947., 1,.98 %,9 90 ,;0 34 ,-,3/430/ 907 147207570:/.0

,,38908947:8,3/9020341908.44.07057080390//0807;0857,80

%700 70,84382, -0 3490/ 147 98 ;05439 30 907 :3.4252039,7;0 41 90

50784341748.47:8,3/49078;0394804,.340/0794-0794/438

90,.3 ,70;07 70:.9,3994 /0103/8.,7,.907,3/,.9438 3 907 ;07,82489

:31,7 94 08947:8 ,3/ 0 :80/ ;07 /0;4:8 ,8 94 -73 ,-4:9 8 ,/;078,78 /431,

788:..0884781440/:5,90,/39,90/3,,3/0/2,3307398897.9:70

90,702470;002039,-4:948.47:89,3,-4:9798,2,39,9908.4,784190

089073:7.08,70,24892507;4:8940;,:,909089,3/54394190,39,.0/43,38/0

4-0.9;0

%47 49, 70,809-,.,9,.0/43 47430 93 8 8:..0884748.47:8,8

2489 34-970,90/,990.4:3. 0907789044347904:3.41508:84;07

. 0 5708/0/ 3 ,8 ,5574;0/ - 90 .4:3. 41 3 907 039709 %0 ,9907

,5574;0/411.,43430099074179408947:8,3/,89,90203941,7002039-09003

7,3/900,/074190394.0308/03,.0/43,.340/0/90.4:3.41

20703,.,8:,,5488-3499441103/90,890735,79.5,39840/93


3/27

434:7%4,//94,90801,.98,890970,920392090/4:9-,.0/4394%04/47041

458:089,%04/4709417:8,3/-,841/088,9700-:,78419008947,390,.3

94:9900,89/02:790801,.98,703490/-90.79.841,.0/43,890.4:3.8

/010.98-:990,70 440/:543- 90 8:5547907841 90.4:3. ,80;/03.09,9,.0/43

8419030/90/0.8438413,702,7,-0,

%70024/0730890739044,3830307,/43494-901472:,94384190/4.97308

41,3.039904478988947.9,3/:2,370,9,70247025479,391479029,38

/;3939874:3/90,70.79.,,82:.41,.0/43,841508:8

8947., ,.0/43 411070/ #420 , 70, ;.947 4;07 0,3/7, 3 9044 ,3/

4389,393450,574794;079003970,893,/23897,9;0,77,30203909901,.989,9

90/;843.9.,:80/,80,8908591443904:3.41508:8389

.4393:08849,990,7041.43902547,7700;,3.0,3/0.:203.,831.,3.0%0701470

90 6:08943 ,8 94 4 90 /;843 ,7480 ,3/ ,9 90 9044., 88:08 9,9 805,7,90/ 90

.422:3908,7084://0807;0,34-0.9;00;,:,94394:9-030/,,-97,/943,

570:/.0874298543941;09014436:08943884:/-0,38070/-,34304

9,0894,89:/41908:-0.9

O 484:/90/;8434190789,3.422:39083.43806:03.041909.039:7.4:3.8-005,30/

O ,8990708:941,.431.9-09003794/4,3/0708O 19,93/00/,890.,80,9,8794/4-0147090.4:3.8209O ,9570.80070 90 070808 90 .4:3.88,3 9020342 90 .43/0230/

3,2008947:8,3/48.47:8

O 07090070808089,-80/,,389902439089703941,..059,-00;/03.03,/85,8843,902,3307

O 10708,83499088:04.,390/;8438-005,30/O 40,;0,30;/03.0948,9,990:7.97,/9438.944:590.,:804190

.43/0230/2030/,35489430.:/0/-90.4:3.8.43.0730/


4/27

O / 90 701:80 94 .43807;0 3 573.50 ,3 ,850.9 41 90 789,3 97:9 . 90.4:3.884:994.43807;0

3 98 5,507 ,3 ,990259 8 2,/0 94 ,3807 9080 6:089438 43 90 897039 41 700;,39

0;/03.098,1,.99,903909.039:7-0,390:7.,/,347241794/4,3/

, 1,7 .42243 -,88 147 10 3 90 #42,3 2570 94: 9070 070 4., ;,7,9438 ,8

70,7/890,99071908094,850.98985,507800894-734:990347241794/494

-039989031440/-,-701970,920394108947,382,3/90945489438147,3/

,,389,.0/43%0.43.:84385488-094-0/7,3,70019949070,/078

$:5071.,,3.0394909,3/

9.039:708

%09,3/

9.039:708,;0831.,3.0390894741,3.039789,39.84:/

-0850.,3490/070%080.039:708/431,.9.43899:90905074/3.90:7.3

90#42,3257041,3.0399208,.6:70/1479801,.,7,.907310,3//4.9730

09 9070 ,70 8420 1:3/,2039, /110703.08 -09003 90 .039:708 47 430 93 ,9 90

-033341 909 .039:7 94: 90:7. -00;0/ 9,9 9 0/ 94 90 1,943.0 147,

/0;070/94908,398:/0,3/05994,97,/94334785,3/8,.7,203985,79.:,7,5982 ,3/ :.,789 ,3/ , 10 41/8.530 9 0890/ 3 , 8479 41 1:/ 89,90 %0 1,9

70107739490970014/3,204190,90790$43,3/904$579,3/949050784341

08:8789,/349-003.,710/10,99025989405,3902.4:/34913/1,;4:79

90:7. ,8 ,40 03 90 9 .039:7 -0,3 90 89:,943,8 /1107039 %0 1,9

.43.0733 90 970014/ 3,20 ,/ -003 /0130/ 8 94 90 507843 41 08:8 789 9 ,8

0307,,..0590/9,90,8903.,73,943414/90$43-:9906:08943.43.073390

3.,73,943,89449,894-0,11720/,/34909-003/0130/9,8909.039:79,9

944:59,99,8

%0,71.,9434190%70014/,20


5/27

44380;07,01147989405,39028907414/7,382.,2043908.0301742

90 80.43/ /0.,/0 41 90 9 .039:7 %0 7,38 -00;0/ 9,9 907 90,.3 .43807;0/

794/4,3/ 450/ 9,9 94:/ 1, 43 109 ;,.::2 :990070 9446:. 3 907

050.9,943,89070070:7.202-07847057080390/,2470794/43041789,3

933%0805045084:994357,382390-:/974:904:3.41.0,.

250747 4389,3930 .43;030/ 3 %0 070 349 220/,90 8:..0881: 3 907 ,2

$:554790/-8420419002507478,3/,702,47941,89073:7.20348:850.90/90

1,941.0,94-0,478007089,37,382907,35,792,/08:-89,39,5747088147

4;07,1,.039:7:91742,-4:99,/,70;078,.0/94980;039:,/8,550,7,3.0

174290:7.

%4 147.08 -74:9 ,-4:9 90 /431, 417,382 3 90 1789 5,.0 ,8 90 2507,

/81,;4:7.98:89,30/%4:2507474389,3930;07/013901,;4:70/789,39

,3/,8908407:074190025701742948/0,930,/829,94380//

349 47 5488- .4:/ 349 ,.340/0 90 :7. ,8 90 411., 7043 41 90 02570

0907//,34188:..08847899,0:59,9890539,90,7%04/48:8,$5,3,7/

,89,03-9002507478,8,3,884.,903904;07320393,/070394190.0301,90

4-9,30/ 90 .44507,943 41 8 2507, .40,:08 94 88:0 ,3 0/.9 3 706:73 41 ,

.9038 94 144 90 1,9 41 .0, 3 98, 0250747 %04/48:8 944 90 39,9;0 3

/0.,73 .030 794/4 90 25708 11., 7043 742 9,9 920 90 02507478 41

4389,393450.,2094-070.430/,8,847941:,7/,3841901,9%8,890439093

.904:3.414389,393450,80/3%8.4:3.,11720/901,941.0,

$0.43/9070,8,9044.,/0;0452039390,89./0103/0/901,9,5574;0/

- .0, :3/07 90 0,/0785 41 90 ,55,/4.,3 9044,38 9,9 920 90 0,89073

:7.203,/7430,74190 8:5071.,9417,3 3900.9:,82,3/070394

890394 90.030 0,/078 490,55,/4.,38070,-094.,71 94900,89073078 9,9

9078:85.4341.0,,814:3/0/,3/9,9,3,..059,3.04190.4:3.8025,88,8

9043,94.43807;0901,9,89090280;08.4310880/


6/27

%0.4397-:9434190,55,/4.,31,90783980;4:943/0807;08850.,203943070

30419070,8438907,38/0.4:/,/;,3.0,890,.41907234494.,7190

70,943,2439097,/4190,90790$43,3/904$579.0,,/02540/909072

4:8,08803.047-03,3/,11720/9,990,907,3/90$43,/908,20 4:8,%8.4:/

-0/030/943.:/0904$579,80%:89,85488-0944110790.,71.,9439,9

,909700070:390/3908,20-03490307090970094-0/893:80/98

570.800709,9 90,55,/4.,382,/0 907 ,893.4397-:943 %0/1107039,90/94

907284:8,,3/5489,88430174290490794:09244.,,3/3:80841,790,/

908,2020,33:8,,1023305,79.504190;07-023700.20,3994-0

47 ,2 8944/ 147 -03 507 80 ,3/ 5489,88 147 90 70,9 :3/073 , 93 %0

,55,/4.,39742,39,30/9,9901472079072.4:/-070807;0/1479,9.8.42243

,3/90,9907147905,79.:,73.:/0/390.42243%:8390.,80414/4:8,7010770/

944/0,/,3/5489,88940,.41909700398,90%739,7,31472:,,85745480/

- 90 ,55,/4.,3 9044,38 3 .43843,3.09 90 .030 ,1172,943 ,3/ 90 :7.

,..0590/9%81472:,,3/90.431088439,990$439080.43/50784341904%739

-0.,203.,73,90308:8789.43899:90/90,..0590/347241794/4,990-033341

909.039:7%0$43,89:8,11720/94-041908,20-03990,907,3/90

4$579909700070.4310880/94-041908,20-039430,349074903

,8903.,73,94394-0:3/078944/

#00.90/39075709,943

%06:08943,8,38070/-,-4:9909200390,55,/4.,3807003,0/3907

9044., ,.9;9-543,7:841,4/.0,4/0/. 8.43.073,8 94 .431088

7898:39,,389,,990259894/;/02%4903/03.080709070390:7.43

9888:0304190238890/437898:3-7403.4393:994/90$43,3/90:39

4183.,73,90507843,3/10%049078,32,2,3:36:03/09-4/90$43

543,7:857010770/901789,3/455480/9080.43/789,8430,3/3/;8-002,/0

4:9 347/0794089,-89897:90,/70.4:78094, 8479.:9 78902,39,30/,8

1:4/4/90$43,8904:3.41.0,,/9,:9:9,82,394:0,870,

:2,30,8349843901:80380%0:2,3.4/90$43,88:20/,8/0;4/41


7/27

90 7,943, 573.50 90 34:8 .43899:93 23/ ,3/ . 3 0;07 :2,3 507843

439740/ 807 10 ,3/ ,.9;908 8 4/ 90 $43 :/0/ 90 10 41 08:8 789

543,7:80/9070,834300/3241,:2,323/,3/

543,7,3,82,8.43/0230/-90:7.3,3:2-0741.4:3.83.:/390430

,9#420 ,3/ 9,941 4389,393450 3 40;07 3 ,3.039 9208 9 ,87047

,,30343041 90,55,/4.,397484.79.0/9248954390/ 08,/9,923/

-03901,.:932,39,9:/0/8,.94389300/0/8,;,9432489849,9190$,;4:7

,.0/:2,323/2,3,/34970,-0038,;0/,9,8349-003,88:20/,8349-003

8,;0/ %0700.94341 90543,7,3890,.3 ,//0/ 4302470 002039 3 90347241

794/43,209,9902,344/41789,850710.982,30,8:390/3908,20

-03,89,941,32,3

%4%7,/9438390,89

543,7:8,831,.970,.9394909044.,/70.943,/4590/390,89-20341

90394.030$.4441933,3/9,890203419,98.444.,20147,7/0,07

94701:902,3/81440780907,3890543,7,38,84970/945745,,90907

;08,3/.,59:70789,3933949078/0:9,/0703984190394.030$.441,.0/

907.,030

$9,790/5488-3903/ .039:7,8,5747,220 14725,793 3897:.94394 .43;079894

789,39 3 90 1,9 ,3//8.530 90 8.44 /0;0450/ 394 , .0397041 0,733.

574/:.0/2,3 0,/078 ,2434070 4378489424/47041%,78:8 %04/47041

458:089, ,3/08947:82801 1 90802037848942,8 , 703430/ 570,.07 ,3/

%04/470 ,3 023039 --., 00090 ,3/ 9044., 05079 08947:8 ,8 , /8.50 41

%04/470 4 /0/ 3 90 8,20 0,7 ,8 90 147207 ,8 5742490/ 94 90 58.45, 7,3 ,9

4389,393450%08.441440/,907,89,3/7,943,97,/9433--.,00088;3

;079905,.014790289.,00203937043

39049078/04190850.97:2,8900,3/730$.44998,047.,2094/3

--.,00088,3/289.,0,3339044.,5:78:9,,41:8974:82030


8/27

703 9,3,8:8 ,3/ 90 ,55,/4.,38 ,/4730/ 98 7,38 %0 289., .,7,.907 41 98

9044.,97,/943.4:/,7-4:72,33900.9:,2570.80/0,8,3/901,2041

98 0,/0782,/0 90 8.442470545:,7 3 90,89 9,3 90394.030 7898:3-7403

.4393:994/,3/8507843,:3907090.0397,1,.94783989044.,,1172,943

03 41 90 94 $.448 .4393:0/ 94 .,77 147,7/ 907 70850.9;0 9044., 47

3/0503/039 5488-94:9090741902 349.3,9 904907,8 /43 :903

90.,2094349013/38410,.490790,92485070,8;9,90/-,857941.431.9

,3/2:9:,7;,7,.4190284:9940;,:,9090548943419049074343 9843

74:3/8 843345705,70/3088 94:3/0789,3/ 9049074-0.9;0 %00,3/7308 147

0,250 :/0/ 90394.030 90,.3 3 90 94190 0,3/7305708:55489438 ,3/

.43/0230/ 9,80709., %0394.0308439075,79//908,2097010703.0 9490

0,3/7308 /0.,73 907 90,.3 94 .43899:90 , ;4,943 41 90 789,3 97:9 43 90

74:3/419014720783900.9:,-,.74:3/

%0,8-0900390%7,/9438

%04:3.41508:83

%097,/9438.,2094,34503.,81742%0220/,9088:0,8906:089434190

,55.,-9 41 90 9072 %049448 4304 ,;0 -79 94 4/ 94 ,7 08947:8 41 90

394.030$.444,8903.:2-0394190800414389,393450,/70807;,9438,-4:9

9,3/744..:50/90800410,3/7,38890/9,99070.43943419090729

7010703.09490'73,83/85038,-0147,84:3/:3/0789,3/34178985078437

40;072,/09.0,79,98.43.073,8349,744-:97894402,/04:99,9,

6:08943341%04944897010703.094,74:/259,990./39042-,8349

70,4/3.,73,909,99:808947:8.4397,/.90/901,941.0,,3/9,9907014708

90,.384:/-0.43/0230/%0,7:20398;,/174290543941;0417,3/9480

4 ,700/ 9 2 3 9044., ,88:259438 -:9 349 84 3 90 9 41 90 97,/943

2,39,30/ 3 90 394.030 $.44 %8 -,8. 97:9 ,8 349 7,80/ 3 ,3.039 9208 ,3/

08947:8,8 .,89 4:9 1742 90 .422:34341 90 89,90:7.41 90#42,32570 %0


9/27

0250747%04/48:848:554790/2390-0333,;02:539003/,3/0,8

00/

%0 970,920392090/4:9 9408947:8// 349-73 90 894794 ,3 03/ %4: 0 90

025074788:55479078,84,-,3/430/290.4393:0/94147,7/90.,:80147.0

,/ 14:9 49 8/08 070 3;4;0/ 3 ,3 0..08,89., ,71,70 %4: 974: 90

3907;03943419002507479,9,880990/14790920-03390903843.4393:0/9

,839,9.439099,99088:041:9.08,87,80/34389,393450,3/,97/97,/943

9,94190089.,/90794-003:3343 390,892,/098,550,7,3.0.70,93,

1708 .431:843 $420 3:89. 82,79 -09003 9 ,3/ 90 394.030 97,/943 0/ 90

$7,38/0,3/08947:828014,99,9920,8,34/2,3;330094,90

08907397,/943/013903499.0,7:3/0789,3/341989044.,025,88845

04 41#420.,2394-0 90 8:570200,/4190:3;078,:7. ,890 8:..0884741

54890!0907706:70/41-495,7908390,8994,..0598 %420,3/4398-,88948099090

/85:90

%85,341!45004,8349220/,9047,-0-:9905480/901,.99,99070070

970097,/943834994390:7.900,3/73090394.030,3/90089073742

90 0,3/730 97,/943 ,8 /423,93 90 10/ 94 90 ,334,3.041 90 394.030

40441#4204304190,-089-845890089073800,/3,3.0399208039070/90

8.030/0907230/948009,99097,/943.07057080390/705,.0/9,9410,3/7,%0

394.0308,3/ , 80.94341 .:7.203 3 90 ,89 3 907 ,39,438294 900,3/7308

-49 507843, ,3/ /044., 070 /85480/ 94 0.420 90 %420 94: 349 #4208

:78/.943, .,28 %0 0,3/7308 // 349 800 90 24;02039 41 0;0398 3 98 574507

507850.9;0 3890,/ 90 8, 3 90 %420 43 , 89,902039 41 1,9 . 1,;4:70/ 90

394.0308.508:8,/0.:/0/ 3 ,3/.90394.030890280;08 ,/

03/4780/39870,/3900,3/7308070;078:5071.,14790%420.425480/,8

9,/-0033909419008907397,/943.4:/-0390757090/-902,82:.3907

1,;4:7 ,8 3 9078 - 90 394.0308 %0 0,3/730 ;0 9,9 90 394.0308 ,/

,..0590/ 90 .4:3. 41 - 90 #0:343 41 ,8 349 ,940907 .4770.9 %0 ,/

,/2990/ 43 9480 54398 ,-4:9 90 .4:3. . 907 0,/078 ,/ 5489;0 03/4780/


10/27

%0701470900,3/730870,/247039490394.030,/288439,390 ,9907,/31,.9

7,390/

%0 0,3/7308 ,/4590/ 94 89058 3 98 89:,943 -49 41 . -74:9 /43 907

570890390:7.39017895,.0.4:3935488-43902507,8:55479.90

903 0340/ ,3/ 907 /0 545:,79 3 90 ,89 90 039 4:9 41 907 , 94 /0103/

:9.0834/24334389,3934504,/3470.43943,8,.425090399044,3

:9.08,8147902,5,798,345742490/907.,:80390.,59,$0.43/90:80/

9080.43/.4:3.41508:8394050174290:7.,3:2-074125479,390,/07841

90 394.030 8/0 %4: 3 ,/4593 30907 41 9080 89058 90 0,3/7308 .,3 -0

,..:80/41/:93,3 9044.,573.50 9080 ,.9438070349.43/:.;00907 94-73

50,.0390:7.479403,3.0907545:,79390:7.3904907,3/90,;0

#420,4/03455479:399447,30,3,8907317439,,389900,3/730800%0/0,9

410250747%04/48:83,3/90.4239454074180/0788907!:.07,907

:8-,3/,7.,3050/#42094,88079905,5,.,28

%0.4:3.41,.0/43

490 2507, .4:504,;0:50,3/7, 3 1,;4:741#420-:9,20/94 00;,90

4389,39345047/070/90.43;0334190.4:3.41,.0/4394.,774:9905,3%8

.4:3..20937,910/90/;843708:93174290.4:3.41,3/.,:80/,

1708859%0,90.4:3.4197,38,.90/98-:8308883490/39823:908.,8

90 ,;0-003570807;0/ -90574,.0/43,30..08,89.,97,/943,70,;,,-03

907-,88.348947,3419,997,/943.,3 092,90.,36:0894314431,.98

,705488-094-0-74:94:9

43/023,94341:9.08

%4:,.0/43,8,705:9,943147,;3.43/0230/900709.:9.08901,.98

9,98.,8070.0;0/34,9903943,9,90700,/-00300/-2507,47/078443,1907

90/0,941%04/48:8:938,-803.0905,7931,;4:741#420,3/90394.0308


11/27

24;0/4390,88:259439,90,8,.431720/0709. %0,880790/985439,,3,3/

,,3380,843,3/4:94180,843%0,924850709:8.70,90/,990.4:3.,88:.9,9

34-4/ 4:/ /,70 94 7,80 90 6:08943 41 57441 147 10,7 41 220/,90 /8.723,943 ,3/

4897,.82

%8,88:2594394-08:70,83/85038,-0147905,7935407-0.,:8090%42041

04 43 . 90 -,.0/,8 , 701:9,943 41 90 8:55480/ 0708 41 :9.08 8 147 90

394.03081:9.08,8349,0709.90,/943;039,070832390701147994

7/.:0900,3/73089,.0/4348.47:82,/09054399,99070,834574413

23:908 41 90 0,707 .4:3.8 9,9 :9.08 ,8 , 0709. . #' $0078 ,8

28:3/078944/ 4 430 ,38070/ 90 0,3/730 !,97,7. %0 1,.9 90701470 8 9,9

,.0/43//349-490794574;0,.,70410708,,389904/2439,88:20/9,90

,8,0709.14719,9,8349/43090.4:3.4:/,;0,/347,943,-,88

43/023,9434148.47:8

%0 507843 42 90 .4:3. 03/0,;4:70/ 94 /0, 9 5:3.94:8 ,8 48.47:8 90

220/,908:..08847417439070,9800410,3/7,%03034:8,3.98

,8470/4:9-8455430398:3/0790,-0:/,3.041900,90841!4500441#4208

3/00/ -70,99,3 40;07 ,1907 , 90 3.723,93 ,..:8,9438,,389 8 507843 3

.903/:0/.4388903990//3498:..00/3089,-83,8305439

%05,7935407,/4590/1;089058347/0794,.0;0984,

, 88443,890,8802-,8.,0/9447/07,3/-01470,390241-:83088,89,03

:590#42,30,9088,9499,9900,3/730!,97,7.,87024;0/1742880,9390

,8802-94 ,5,.070807;0/147 5078438,93 14797,439074:3/9,9 90 ,/47/078

174290!45094 9,9 0110.9 %8,/ 94-0 /430 3 85904190 70243897,3.0;4.0/- 90

2507, .4228843078 203 ,554390/ - 90 02507478 94 :/0 90 574.00/38 41 90

.4:3.


12/27

- %8,81440/:5,-8454,/-003/05480/-90.4:3.41-13,

.,708009.439,33,..:8,9438,,3898507843984:/-070.,0/9,9,90.,708

390-84588:97010770/9490.4:3.41

. 490 97, -0,3 - 90 70,/3 41 9023:908 41 570;4:8 .4:3. %0 .,70

,,38948.47:8,89:8,.,70,,389,.4:3.%831,.9,8905,341#42004

,8 0,07 94 574;0 9,948.47:8 ,/ /423,90/ 90 .4:3. 84 9,9 98 /0.8438 070 90

507843, /0.8438 41 90 !,97,7. 349 41 90 .4:3. %0 23:908 84 9,9 48.47:8

,38070/0;075439 -74:9 ,,389 2 1742 90 5439 41;0410,3/730794/4

94:9080,38078070349;03/:0.438/07,943-90.4228843078%:8,..47/3

944:734728907:/2039.,3349-01:/0103/0/099088:0/907;07/.9,99003/41

90/,089,-8390.43.,7.,7,.9074190/0.843841%83/00/,8,8074:8

-49490#42,30,908-:99007034943940/

/ %0#42,30,908,90/94800090790%4204:/-0,..0590/:3,324:8-

90,8802-,9 9830980884394/,8,907 :998//349,5503 %070070-8458

174290,8947,80/6:08943870107739497005,88,08390/4.:2039,3/8420,390/

247092094.42094,/0.843

0 490 0,908 7084790/ 94 90 ,89 8905 %,9 ,8 94 4/ ,20093 41 94804

8:554790/90294:90907 90 .422884307840705708039 ,9, 9080884384190

.4:3.,3/,,70-4/41/00,9089035708039,9,.0/439,;094/0,39

48.47:8 - 90280;08 8 90 070 8:70 9,9 90 2507, .4:50 4:/ 03/4780 ,3

/0.843 90 944 9 47 94:9 90 .4228843078 90 .4:/ 24;0 9 34 10,7 41

.43806:03.0%075,340;07944/,24.97,41902,3,8140/-48.47:84

701:80/ 94 434:7 90 8:2243808 807;0/ 43 2 3 90 03/ 98 5,79 20093 5,880/ ,

7084:943 /05483 48.47:8 349 43 ,3 .,70 41 0708 -:9 43 8 701:8, 94 708543/

1,;4:7,-9490,8802-8.,%0,.9439,03-905,79.4:3.,/94-0,..0590/-

9070894190/00,9080907347:33


13/27

,8 903 48.47:8 ,4345890 47 , 0709. 41 ,3 /08.75943 9 8 97:0 9,9 ,9

,.0/438,/;078,708970/94.42-3029:9.08,3/ 9:82,024:994-0,

0709.-:9901,.989,948.47:8147089,0/90011479%00;/03.00,;0890701470

.0,7 9 8 349 1470708 9,948.47:8,8 /05480/ -:9 -0.,:80 0 ,/ -003 90 .01

5708/30..08,89.4;0790.4:3.41.5,/34,99039439490%420410438590

4190!09730.,2.90,:947,/,/;,3.0/39%4,/29984-;4:81,.9,8109-

#420 94-0 /0.,90 9,8 90701470 30.088,7 147!45004 ,3/ 8 0,908 94 ,88079 9,9

48.47:8,/ 25480/43,.4:3.8,7-97,7/0.8438 :7907 9,8 390 3907089841

#420998.,241:3;078,:78/.94394/07,/00,3/7,.,99,9920,8,8

54071:390:7.,8#420980113492470

$420,.9894-0#0202-070/

48.47:8,8.43/0230/,24893 90 8,20,,808947:8,/-003/430,,9

94/0.,/080,707%4:80;07,4181703/8.44507,90/9905,793540714798

9:73410;039890//349800294,;0470/9470389,902849,9147,.0/4308944/

.43/0230/:981703/88:..00/0/380039499,990.4:3.8/01394341901,9,8

84/7,3:5 9,9 90 .4:/ 390757091 30,993 90 17,204741907 97,/943 %8

050/394.0305,798,3830307,94,..059,.0/43,3/,;4/,859390:7.41

#42,32570 :9 9 // 349 -73 90 574-02 94 ,3 03/ $97.9394.0308 8, 3 90

/01394341,.0/43,8419415,9.47.//3491,.09088:086:,709,898

548943..,2094-0,/4590/-90:7.41!078, 390 ,9907,141909.039:7

9801

82,7/0;0452039,55030/43900,3/7308/0,80.438/07,-080.94341

9028,390430507843,4190%4204104904305489,88,3/4305748454341907

97,/943%0,/4594341908090728398,//50,80902%0.4:/9,090394

3,9:7084190/013943,8,3,1172,9434190/3,2..4393:,3.041903,9:708,190790

:343%:890,..0590/,.0/43:99070070897.90,3/7308414:3/9/11.:9

94,/4598:.,548943


14/27

%0394.0300,/078470/4:9,9072344.,,/:8920393,..059390/01394341

,.0/43%0/0139434190.4:3.,11720/9,908:8789,84305489,88,3/430

574845432,/03433943,9:70819080970057,808901789,/-003700.90/-90

394.03084:97931,.99,9,89054392,/0,,389902-900,3/7308:9

9080.43/,3/97/57,8087057080390/907548943,,43%038890/1:79079,90,.

4190943,9:70819,894-070,,3/1:3.94332:89,;0985489,88398-,8890

394.0308,/2,/04:99,908:8789,8943,9:708,3/945489,808:390/3430

57484543

0,;08003,95489,8820,399,83,47/,33/;/:,90/ 4:8,90,-897,.9

,3/.4224370,92,/0.43.70903,5,79.:,7%03/;/:,94341904:8,8,33,7/

574.088%4:,8.43.07384/98.42509039009073,70,297010703.094.70,9:708

9 ,55038, 90 920 3 90 .,80 41 0;07 5,79.:,7 -03 3 5489,880907 9 -0

/;3047.70,90/8/1107039,90/1742,3490739857484543%4-08:70905489,88,3/

90574845434940907849,90;075,79.:,7,8983,7/70,93985489,88,3/8

70.430/3985,79.:,79-20,38419857484543

98390708939434909,990%4204104050/90394.030894 800905488-941

989072344.,,/:892039%0/4.973,099074190!450,/2,/09700025,80830

9,908:8789,8430507843, %8,9347/ //349,;0 90 8:-909 250/ 3 90

700907285489,88,3/574845439//34931,.920,3,39324709,390 57484543

41907008%:890430 507843,4190%420.4:/-0,..059,-09490394.0308%4

,890/4.:203938890/43903943,9:7089,9.70,90/34574-02147902%7009094

3,9:7084190%4200708:.9,90,.4190250714720/,9,705745079493.422:343

9904907%8025,888,9810/90394.030897010703.094907388903.04390

945489,808

%700!489438390,89

44390.4:3.41,.0/4390390,89,/970097,/94380,.39075709390

5078434108:878939843,%0070


15/27

%00,3/730

%0394.030,3/

%0,.0/43,3

-701 708:20 410,. 41 902 8 ;03-049, ;094 800390 /110703.0 ,3/

,7002039-09003902

%00,3/730!48943

%00,3/7308/0,..059890,55,/4.,3,1172,94370,7/34/,84304:8,,3/

97005489,808380990789408947:87410,3/7,388984390,:94794190

.030700/9,94/90$4348:390/990,9073908,204:8,47-03.,20

/4317420,;03,3/-0.,203.,73,90,3/2,/02,30808:878943.0;0/390

'73842-,3/-473174207084/3.,73,90,3/90249074-74:9214:798

%04944808:8789,89:8,3:3-7403.4393:994/90$43,3/974:29

90-0880/%7393-0.4232,34/,8349.,30/9490:2,3347,890:2,3

.0-0.,2097,3810770/9490/;30-:90702,33,9009073,84/90$43

:390/94280190:2,3370,9,3/1:30880.,:804198:34308:87898,:39

4393:994/,3/:3941903.,73,90109080,709094770/:.-0,1172,9438

417

3800394.43807;09080025,808702540/,3:2-074157,808

, 08:878981742943,9:7080/:458043 %01742834920,39943/.,900.:8;090-014704190:343-:994903/;8-941903,9:7089,9.,20394

90:3433490747/808:87898.425480/4190943,9:708414/0,/,3/

2,344/..4393:032770/:.-,3/3/;8-

- %0:34341903,9:70885489,9..7280105,30/,83,7/ ,3/70,


16/27

. 3.43806:03.04198:343,9047/8,3//00/870.47/0/,-4:9789390485080700570884389,9.,20147917429089,9041:343

/ 08:87898,943.01:4/,3/1:2,3%0/;30,3/90:2,3070:390/,990 ;0724203903 904 $579 .,20:543 90'73 ,3/ 9054074190

489 4;078,/40/ 07 %0 789 3 42 4/ ,3/ 2,3 ,70 9:8 :390/

3/;8-,8.,770/30742--90'730,84/3.,73,909442,7

,;0-79,3/80,8%0494484304-4704/84/0,8908,20-03

,8414/90,907,3/4/904$579,3/,82,30,8908,20-03,8,3

2,34394:983

0%04305489,888903.,73,905489,88414/90843.8.4254890

808,800,982,/04:90708025,80/24701:-$0;07:841394.

1 %4 05,3 98 89,90417898:397 14:3/, .43;0303957,80 430 3.,73,903,9:70414/9047/ ,8 , 0,. 17429,3,8:89070,9 0944 9 4;07,3/

2,/09.0397,3839075709,9434190/4.9730

%0394.030!48943

394.0309044,38,84,..0590/ 90,55,/4.,3,1172,943 .43.07334/,8430

4:8, ,3/ 9700 5489,808 30 41 90 5489,808 4/ 90 $43 944 :543 2801 ,

/85038,943 147 90 8,;,943 41 90 :2,3 7,.0 0 974: 42 98 8,;3 47 ,8

,..42580/-4/808:8789

4/90$438,309073,5078435489,8832801.425090,3/-043/,29,9438

3.:/3948041920,3/85,.03908970394198025,8890394.030838890/9,9

90.,20/434190.030700/,834920,3994-09,033,907,8038098310/43

904907,3/4/80.4342394.0309044,38070.0,79,94//408349-0.420

-0.,:80 - 3,9:70 4/ 97,38.03/8 90 .43/943 41 , -0.423 3 98 .4330.943 90

394.030 0548943 41 9047/841 43 9047/ -0.,20 108 84:/ -03490/

%08047/8902,39,30/84:/-0390757090/4399,914483,20,3//09


17/27

,243:81:417,.0,3/97:998-0.,:80418/03,243:81:417,.0,3/

97:99,90.4310889,94/9047/-0.,20108324/8/03,243:88349

-,2934128010.:8;0,3/4.,39390.43130841,58.,17,20%0

394.03084:/ ,/2943904907,3/9,94/8 3/03-0430/ 9480.4342

,3/90,11720/9,94/7,80890:2,394847,3/18998,:9479%8,8

,55030/308:8789

3 08:8 789 9070 ,8 , :36:0 ,3/ :37050,9,-0 /;30 0.4342 4/ 90 $43

702,334/:3.,30,-089,-80/990:2,3.,83,9:70998 5489,88

,.43:3.9438:3,50,,990;0724203903904$579.,20:54390'73,3/

90540741904894;078,/40/07989031,399:814720/4290'73

.43.0;0/ ,3/ 42 80 .,770/ 3 07 42- ,3/ -74:9 1479 %0 :2,3 9,9 ,8

3/;/:,90/998;071472,943703941:3088,3/90'7324907-74:921479

3/:0.4:780%031,39,83/00/789,3/9024907,8 789494484304,;0

-79 94 789 $3.0 90 31,39 ,84/ .43430/ 9 2,3 90 24907 .4:/ -0 .,0/

%0494484304,;0-79944/,8, 847941.43.0884394900,3/73081907

-03 -473 90 :2,3 .4393:0/ 94 -0:2,3 3 98 :34394/:3/0743 , 3472,

050703.083,9:7,940;072,34394:98308:8789,83/00/1:4/,3/1:

2,3 94 3,9:708 9 907 70850.9;0 5489,808 :390/ 47 .43430/ ,9 90 0;0 41 90

574845430,8907014704305078435748454334290943,9:708414/0,/,3/

2,344/,8 3/;/:,90/ 70,908 5489,808 ,70 770/:.- ,3/3/;8- :390/ 0,8

349 94 5078438 247, :390/ ,8 90 394.030 548943 ,8 -003 54797,0/ - 907

4554303980,83/;8-430349,9900;0415489,88-:9,99,94157484543

.,701:44,990548943841900,3/7308,3/90394.0308849,990

/4349,;0908,2097,/943390:80419072344:9104-043/98/110703.094

90 /0,8 .43807;0/ -9020 8, 70,0 9,9 90 ,700 3 , 088039,54398%070 8

40;07,3 25479,39025,8807090797,/9438/4349.43;070%8,87010703.0 94

90 39075709,943 41 90 9072 5489,88 %0 394.0308 89, 070 9 90 ,55,/4.,3

97,/9437410,3/7,574-,-,3/$0;07:841394.;07/01390039-043/90

,55,/4.,38 398 70,7/ %005708843 5489,9.:343 ,808, 8003, 242039


18/27

,834905,30/-$0;07:82070439089703941,990801,9078,/.43807;0/9

7010703.09490/4.97304190%739

%0,.0/43,3!48943431.9390,89-09003

94804,..059,3/94804700.9,.0/43

3/8.:883,.0/430,;0440/39490,48.47:8410,3/7,,8/05480/

-90.4:3.44398,.94390.4:3.,/4590/,/01394341901,90.:/3,

3:2-074154894384390430,3/,3/.43807;3,1172,94389,984:/-0.4310880/4390

4907 %0 1,.9 9,9 3 701:83 94 ,.340/0 90 .4:3. ,3/ 98 /4.973, 1472:,9438

48.47:8,3/948041440/80,/070349:9418,3.94339054894380.:/0/

-,.0/438.0,7034:98,/2990/0;03-907.79.8,9903,890790,.3

;8,;890574,.0/43,397,/943

44390.4:3.984554303981,.0/9,4890549.,,92485070,/9404

147,5074/41,-4:994/0.,/08%0390549.,.2,90.,30/39071,;4:7,3/90

.,204:994.,03090.4:3.,3/5,79.:,790%4204104%044.,9088:090

7,80/,/7010703.094904305489,8841 90.4:3.8/0139439 98 3 943,9:708

%0,7:0/ 3 8:-89,3.09,9,3,9:70 9,03 3 ,3,-897,.9 803804:/349 089-9801

:3088 9 8:-8890/ 3, .43.7090 5,79.:,7 %0701470 90 94 3,9:708 41 90 ,.0/43,3/013943 2:89 -0 94 5078438.08947:8,8 -00;0/ 94 ,;0 9,:9 ,3/ . 90

.4:3.41,/.43/0230/

%0178994/0.,/0841909.039:7,78905074/0390948/08.,80/390

,.0/43,3 8/0 9070 ,8 903 43 90 7,22,7,3 4 ,8 ,907 2,/0 -845 41

,08,70,-9,9-4/,3/439049078/09070,8$0;07:84-0.,20!,97,7.41394.

3 08/08 9070070 4907843 -49 8/08 %0 ,.0/43,3 -4/ ,/ 0439:841

,39:24 1440/:5 90 90,.341907,22,7,3 98900548943410439:8

9,9.,2094-0,/4590/,890411.,90,.3-90,.0/43,3:7.97,/943

$0;07:8 ,3/ 90 7,22,7,3 43174390/ 0,. 4907 %0 /0-,90 -09003 902 .,3 -0

-74:94:94390-,8841,325479,394741901472073.47547,93,,703:2-0741


19/27

5,88,081742,970,9804190,9907%088:043.90.,770/4390/85:90,8;07

2:.90/:5990:804190728

%07,22,7,3-0,789308894901,.99,9-892090,.0/43,38/0390,89

,/-0:39424;0,,1742,.0/438,390,3/73047039,94394,5489433.

90 84:9 94 054:3/ ,.0/43 93 ,3 0,3/730 80993 :9 41 98 .43.073 90

7,22,7,32,/04:99,99057,808:80/-73,20901742943,9:708,3/90430

3.,73,903,9:70414/ 9047/.,.0/43 ,/ 3 1,.9 3470/070794/4,3/

,..059,-0-:99490284:/-0,//0/903943,9:70841,.0/43%:89070070903

9700 57,808 9 90 9072 3,9:70 588 3 700 ,..059,-0 94 90 574,.0/43,3

97,/9433 90,89849,9490 84:/-09,03,8 902489 092,906:08943 %0

7,22,7,3/0130/909072.9,831.,39/110703.0$0;07:8,84,..0590/%0

90723,9:7058820,38090790.42243,83,34:8,47,5,79.:,7,83,5489,88

3490747/85887010770/3.079,3.4390989490.4224370,9-03/905,79.:,7841

, .,88 ,3/ 3 .079,3 49078 9 54390/ 94 90 5,79.:,7 9801 $4 1,7 907,22,7,3 ,3/

$0;07:8,700/

870,7/890:804190907239057,808900703493,7002039%07,22,7,3

2,39,30/ 9,9 3 90 1742 94 3,9:708 ,3/ 90 3 94 3,9:708 3,9:70 7010770/ 94 90

.422433,204:8,,3/3904303.,73,903,9:70954390/9490430507843414/

90$43 %820,389,9 147907,22,7,3 3 08:87894/0,/ 90.42243 70,9

-03/9097005078438,3/2,344/90.4224370,9-03/,:2,3-038.,2094

,:343,3/ 9,9 90.4393:0/ 3 2 :9904303.,73,903,9:70 ,11720/9,908:8

789,84/90$4338 3.,73,9089,90 %07,22,7,38025,88070 8 9,9 3 90

3.,73,943 4/ 90 $43 :390/ 94 8 5489,88 90 .42243 70,9 :3/073 , :2,3

-0383,//9439490/;303,9:70.0,809073,3.42243990,907,3/90

4$579%0303:90;3.0/07083/00/702,7,-0 %07,22,7,3.43807;0/90

39079414/90$433903.,73,943-:997010703.09490:2,302,39,30/43

9,99,8,3:5489,9484794:9,5489,8880,;00,730/079081742904

1,90789,9084:/,117278994-0.438:-89,39,990,907,3/.438:-89,39,9

:80.4310889,908943,9:7083,203944:8,8


20/27

%07,22,7,3,84-;4:870.0;0/83857,9431742!,943.34943410/4847/0,

%0/0,41.,5,79.:,793089339047/8,.45890703,47/419843

,5,791742,5,79.:,7-0380.4:/90701470/7,,8,75/1107039,943-090034:8,

,3/5489,88,3/2,04:995,79.:,77010703.094902,344/9,990898-9801,5,79

1742,:2,3-038,3/9,94/90$43:390/99428013903.,73,94308,;0/

280140;0717421,3394908,20,342,97010703.0944/0,/-,/299390

1472:,414303.,73,903,9:70414/9047/9,33,9:7039080380415489,88%0

6:08943.,3,:2,394:9,5489,88.420394-03,3/;0370,9390.43.7090

47/41920,3/85,.0,8,8947.,1:70,55,7039/408349-4907907,22,7,398

.0,7 9,9 0/408 349,39 94 4-043/90 9072344., 97,/943 41 90 ,55,/4.,38 3

/8.:883903.,73,94380,;080039890289,0.90394.0309044,38

,84,/.422990/97010703.0949090725489,88

$0;07:8 14:3/907,22,7,38 /01038041 90 3 943,9:708 9474: :3.43;3.3

,3/,:0/,998433900.9:,-,.74:3/,82470789490,39,3!,943.$0;07:8

,8480083904:8,90.42243,3/,/2989,99870,-:90/4083497,399,9904:8,

089838:.80,89403,-090 4:8,414/,3/904:8,412,394.420940907,990

0;04190.42243 :8,414/38898$0;07:83.:/08904%739,3/412,34/8

93 9 , :2,3 -038 94: 0 .,3 .43.0;0 3 4:7 23/8 , 4., /1107039,943

-090034:8,,3/5489,88%48,9,9904:8,414/,3/90 4:8,412,3,70:390/3

789 ,8 907014703420,33 4798 70,843 90 :343 41 90 3,9:708 3 78994:

3,9:70.,320,309074:8,475489,882:89-0,9900;04190,99079,8147389,3.0

4/9047/4-0.,203.,73,90-:39394280190:2,3479010803/40/9

,3390039,3/7,943,84:3054:3/39057,801742943,9:7080/:458043

$0;07:8 8,8 9,9 08:8789,8 14720/41 90430 5489,88 419047/ ,3/430 108

03/40/ 9 23/ ,3/ 70,843 9,9 0 8 90 430 3.,73,90 3,9:70 ,3/ 5489,88 41 90

47/

%,9 8 39075709,943 41 90 /4.9730 ,8 .79.0/ - 5078438 -0433 94 90 574

,.0/43,397,/94383490/-$0;07:8,99033.43108839,97898174294


21/27

3,9:708,704:8,39,908174294 57484543$0;07:8,38078190:2,3,8

,11720/94,;0-00314720/-9801,5,791742:34394/90$439,9:2,34:/-0

,3 3/0503/039 5489,88 9 9843 57484543 %02,344/41789 ,8349 14720/

3/0503/0394190:34394/90$43%0:2,3.,20394-0339042-41,7

.,7108$0;07:8433:34394/90$430147090:34390108//349089-:9

,990;07242039030,8.43.0;0/990108.,2094-03:34394/9047/

,3/ 70.0;0/ 90 -0333 41 08903.0 %0 :343 ,3/ 90 .423 394 -03 41 90 108

,55030/,943.094:9,3920,5-09003902%0./147389,3.0//34970.0;0

90-03334108903.0-980139042-4190'73%047/48-0147090,08

.70,90/ 90 108 03/40/923/,3/70,843 3:34392801,3/ 9:8 9 .,20 394

-03

%0831.,3.0419890,.341$0;07:884:/-0850.,3490/0.,380007090

.43.073419044,384190394.030$.44.0,7209-$0;07:84.4393:08990

0,3/73097,/943%0/110703.0-09003$0;07:8,3/,3394.0309044,30,-,

,3,,998543989,99014720789,3/8-905489,9.:343-:990,9907-0389:.

9 90 ,55,/4.,3 39075709,943 41 5489,88 ,/298 43 90 574845. :343 1 98

/;0703.0.4:/-07430/4:99094203.4:/,70024709,309074190299004

,.0/43,3 97,/943 3 90 ,89 41 . 43 90 7,22,7,3 ,8 430 41 90 0,705430398

%0 5489,88 ,/298 $0;07:8 5,79.5,908 3 90 4:8, -:9 43 98 ,..4:39 90 147207

.,3349-0 /03910/990 ,990747;.0;078, 0,84,.340/089,90789 8

,11720/94-04305489,88,3/9843010803/40/923/,3/84:9,94/9047/

:390/94280190:2,37,.0,8,40,3/,:2,3-0383/;/:,,;090-03019

/:0942-7,.0

%090723,9:70588 39057,80 1742943,9:7080/:458043 543984390

430,3/944/90$43,3/4390490794905,79.:,710803/40/923/,3/70,843

.90147207:390/942801%4:901472078,5489,88,3/,5748454338

43 79 ,3/ 09073, 4/ 90 ,9907 -0.,20 5489,9. 43 3 98 :3439 90 147207


22/27

%070147090,99078349, 5489,883090789,57484543,3/08:878984/90$43

383.,73,9089,90

0900343907,22,7,3,3/$0;07:841394.9070,24345890,8.079,3

9014720734990,9907-0.,:809,804,11720/41789,84794109070,:2,39

.0890/4339023/41909044,3%,92,-09070,843574,.0/43,3

8947,3830307,,;05,880/2-,3/90:7.419,997,/94334708231,;4:7

41,34907:23,70439:841,39:24.,20941,205488-3909790841909

.039:7 $0;07:8 41 394. ,/ 94 0,;0 394. 3 43 ,..4:39 41 549., /81,;4:7

$3.0 903 9 8 /0,9 3 9 90 0.05943 41 ,-4:9 94 0,78 03 0 ,8 3

4389,39345090!,97,7. ,/ 94 ;03 80.:843 3&550759 %4:33430418

7938 90 3,20 41 0439:8 ,550,78 90 ,9907 ,8 , 701:9,943 41 $0;07:8 40;07 90

6:08943,89441,70439:870,:3/078944/8455430398,244943074290543941

;04124/0738947,3830307,0439:857454:3/0/,9047,-,3/43390,3:5489,948

2,344/4190920898.,20/9,935,.04190 ,3:5489,94894:9,5489,88

0439:8 411070/ ,3,3:5489,948 2,344/ %0 9047 8 343 ,8 035489,8,. 90

,3930,89,..0598,898411.,90,.3

%07,22,7,3839075709,9438944/3300/41.4770.94394:0,8:33949,0

9 1742 $0;07:8 0439:8 8 .70/90/ 94 ,;0 411070/ 9 94 90 8,981,.943 41 90 ,3930

794/497,/943,3/4341,2,8.:88,3.910/9%070;80/0/9434189474190

789,3 :7. - 8943,077908 ,-4:9 0439:8 0 ;00/ 90 :2,3 3,9:70

30907,8,;398435489,88.0397041-03347,8-03,-897,.9,3/2507843,-:9

,8:390/99047/,3:5489,948,8988:-0.9,3/30;070890/,8,303993/0503/039

412%070;8078349094907.70/99,9$0;07:8,/14708,/40/0439:8%0

.4:/31,.9,;08,/2470,/9070,/$0;07:824704-0.9;0,3/94:990730790/

570:/.0 3 1,;4:741,.0/43 %097:941902,9907 8 9,9,.0/43/;/0/0439:8

1742$0;07:8,89,8/430990:7./4390.039:7080;03944:79208

0 ,;0 349 ,38070/ 90.7:., 6:08943 4 8 90430 5489,88 ,3/ 5748454341

789470439:89890430 5489,88,3/57484543414/90$43474/9047/


23/27

:9902,344/41789,8349,-897,.9,3/2507843, 9 8 .43.7090,3/507843,3 90

5078435489,88,3/57484543414/90$43%0507843,70,94190:2,38349

3/0503/039-:983,3/9905078434190$43

$0;07:847490,-4:9 94/0.,/08-014700439:82,39,30/ 90548943.0

,;0 8:22,70/ ,70,/ 0 ,/ 2,39,30/ 9,9 90 430 5489,88 41 08:8 789 8

.42548903,209009073,.425090,3/:3.70,90/5489,88414/90$43:390/9

90 .70,90/ 5489,88 41 90 :2,3 %0 :2,3 40;07 8 349 3/0503/039 -:9 9 98

.43.70903088,3/507843,89,9:8983/;8-:390/990507843414/90$430.,3

800 9:8 9,9 $0;07:8 ,/ ,70,/ 470/ 4:9 90 548943 . 0439:8 ,/4590/ :83

90.3.,907283843,

%070 8 , 6:08943 070 .423 1742 90394.030 8/0 3 1,.9,-,,3, 41 90

!078,3:7. 7,80/ 9 ,907 %0 5489,88 41 4/ 90$43 8 09073, 50710.9 ,3/ 10/

94:9,/2993,//94384903.,34/90$4370.0;0394:34390:2,3,990

0;04190 5489,88 %0 6:08943 8 349 ,8/11.:9 1742 , 9044., 5439 41 ;0 ,8

,-,,/2,30/4:79,,-4:94/2508/0,8.4:7,3:,08349,/06:,9094

05,330,970,943147389,3.08349,5:707,943,.43.059789,39044/408

349 20,3 - 9 9,9 4/4 ,.8 50710.943 -738 90 47/ 394 -03 94 2,0 :5 90

/01.03. 32 0 .431088 43 90 4907,3/ 9,9 90 09073, 50710.94/.70,90/ 90

47/,8,305708843414;0.083908,20,370/025943,84904/41

4;09,08901,032,3394:3439280138;075489,88

,9903,-4:9905748454341789 909700 97,/9438.431088 9,908:8789

,84305748454347900,3/7308 5489,88,3/574845434940907,894,850.9841

507843903,7/,3/904:9,7/849,9,850.,970,920398349411070/-902

%0708,13,5439./0807;084:7,9903943305,3390 5489,9.:3437

,3/$0;07:8/434989,0.:8;0990,55,/4.,339075709,943419090725489,88

47 7 ,8 0 ,;0 8003 9 20,39 9,9 90 :343,8 3,7/ ,3/ 70, 5489,88 8 ,3

3/;/:,90/4:8,,3/3/;/:,9438,33,7/574.088398-,88$0;07:8.4:/,1172


24/27

9,90;0794:9.789039079,30/0;0747/.08540,3/0;07/00/.

050714720/.,201479174290:34341903,9:7083903.,73,94390:2,3,99,30/98

089 543997:253 4;07 , 90259,9438 ,3/0053 94 90 50710.943 70,9;0 94 0;07

89,0 3 10 #0,7/3 9047/8,3/ /00/841789 , /893.943 8 5488-0 94-0/7,3

-09003 94809,9,70/;30,3/94809,9,70:2,383139,9 3 70,908,943.0

4/,3/2,3:93290,700570884384190:343

43.:843

%09.039:7.4:3.8.,:80/90430:7.94-0/;/0/3949700-4/08742

90 .431.9 -09003 9044,38 ,3/ :7. 0,/078 41 90 0,3/730 ,3/ 90394.030

$.448,/85990:7.390,8939494.,25800,.41902,8897:394

,3 90 :5507 ,3/ 3 90 .431.9 94 4907 147.08 .,20 43 90 8.030 #420 ,3/

4389,393450,3/,1907,.0/439,890809480089,9/423,90/90:7.

0900390949.039:7.4:3.89070,8430831.,39/110703.008947:842

90 .4:3. 41 .43/0230/ .4:/ -0 ,/;0780 :/0/,8 2:. 147 86:089433 41 ,3

:36:,10/,8.7594341 %049448 94,7 ,8 147 90 ,1172,943 41 94 3,9:7089 907

70850.9;0 5489,8089 7010703.0 94 4:7 47/ ,90;07 -0 907 :891.,943 1742 90

394.030 5439 41 ;0 9080 .4:/ 349 .,77 .43;.943 94 2,3 4:98/0 90 394.030

.7.0839003/90394.0308/0,/942,0.42243.,:80990,.0/43,38/0

,3/8,;090280;081742949,,33,943390#42,32570

%00,3/7308/043904907,3/,/,;9,9948:89,3980139025700;03

,,3890970204//8,3/90549.,1,;4:7.94-9,30/1474;0790391;00,781742

050/ 9 94 89703903 9801 98 9044 .4:/ -0 287057080390/ 43 90 74:3/ 41 ,

.42-3,94341909457,8081742943,9:708,3/4303.,73,903,9:70414/9047/19001742 8 9,03,870107739490-01470,3/9043094 90,19074190:34390

.79.82 8 3/00/ ;,/ :9 9,9 8 349 ,9 90 20,39 - 90 57,808 84 9,9 90

28:3/0789,3/3,834-,88370,9


25/27

9 8 3/00/ 8,98139,92:.47 8 -03/43034:792089405 90:7.0894

70,. :3/0789,3/3,243902 , 90$579 414/:/0 902 94 90 4, 41:39 3

,7002039990/;305,3

%4 , .079,3 09039 98 ,8 -003 /430 $00 ' $,2:0 %0 4:3. 41 ,.0/43 #0

0,230/8947.,,3/%044.,$:7;0 3/,3%044.,-7,7$,/7,849055,3/

0 ,;0 34 7010703.0 94 90 :80 41 98 9072 3 90 5402.,7938 ,,389 90 -4/ 9,9

700.90/90.4:3.413,3.0399208;034341,2,8.:8/40834902549090723

90 9 .039:7 ..47/3 94,3.0397907890 .79.841,.0/43070 7010770/94- 90

8:554790784190.4:3.,8 /,7342034/893:807847343.431472898:93,24/07397,38,94341,9.039:747-0439:841,39:203990/,38994804,117241

:7 47/ 08:8 789 430 4254890 ,9:70 90 ,93 97,38,947 :808 90 47/8 4397,

434589,8$00!'1%0092,.4198.433.,3-06:089430/1742

,3:89.543941;0,80

7,/7990397000990789408947:841.9097/,/90;0,3,902,84789,9020398

706:73.43/023,94308/080,/79903;4:20841/4.973,88:08%097/09907,8

700.90/-394.03081,9,.0/43,..0590/90439080.43/09907,3/90472:,741#0:34341$00'$,2:045.9551

$00 -/ 55 ,3930 ,:9478 ,70 .0,7 743 3 907 ,880882039 41

,.0/43%4:,909700809-,.8417,70.0,717429023:90841,.0/43,80

,;0902357399097948419039023,3:3.43;3.3, 7,3829,:99,99070,843.00390$43,83492539,990$434-0.,20

3.,73,903789,8,.70,9:70%07007043;071050450390:7.44:/,..059907,390,.3

390

7/.039:7907007094/01390,99025989405,3901,9324/073920890,;0

.42094-07010770/94,84/,82,3/3,282090741902.4:/13/,..059,3.0390:7.4/,8247$,-0,382//349800,3507843,/893.943-09003903,208-:9440/:543902,85439394908,205078433/110703924/08%0700/,/4590/-904:3.41.0,,11720/9,990$43,841908,204:8,08803.047-03990,907

9,83903/0/940.:/07,3828:22,7-:9907,38070.0;0732,34:99,99

,11720/434/,82 98,7:203990.,770/9902,,70-4/41.43807;,9;0:7.203390,89

2507474389,3930 050/90:7.32,3,8,3/,800314798 5747088,3/:39

998,2323/0.43;030/904:3.41.0,20093,9005038081479174290

2507,970,8:7:99030,87,/:,8,0/949078/0-907,3800/0/30,8390710485

%0,55,/4.,38070 9700 :7.2034 ,.6:70/ 1,20 1742 90 841 90

9 .039:7

%0070,841,08,70,8-7490770474188,,3/9071703/704741,,3:8

%00,3/730548943 8.0,77010.90/3903.,73,943419047/-9,3,8:84

7490 9 ,8 , 4:3 2,3 41 09003 0,78 $00 90 970,980 3 %0 .030 ,3/ !489.030,907880.43/80708'4'

%0$7,3 8:80/07090394.030 8/0,3/349 14790394.030$7,39.90

3/,3$7,3:7..,203.439,.91742 %0089073548943,889,90/3,/4.:20395705,70/-!4500441#420,3/80399490,89

,998920%8,890%42008947:80570880/8,981,.9434;079


26/27

98901,.99,990%420//3494394909072344.,8:-909084190,89!07,5890

,:947,8349.43;078,3999020990/4.:203938890/4390:39417898507843

.,8900,3/730025,88,80 $00'$,2:045.95580,;03490/,-4;051,.0/43//

349,..059508:8-043/,990394.0308/0,/,/2990/3 4790894741:9.08800'$,2:0 45.9551%0.4:3.23:908.9,43.47:20.:203.47:255198-003.014797010770/94,884,9,9 90 4/243,8349, 9044., 05079,3/- 9,9 90 834/// 349 70,089,-8,

.,70410708,,3892%070147090;041#0307,:091440/-0$00'$,2:045.95/0807;08,9903943 :9.08,8 31,.92,/0,8.,504,9-845543039894;0399071:743900,3/7308/0.0/0103/0/

$0.43/.4:3.41508:83/05480/,3:2-07412034142%04/4709417:8,3/

-,841/088,070;79:,.43/0230/-90.4:3.41901190.:203.,.4:3.4190

,.0/43,38/0,3/70,7/34907834938343 $0.43/.4:3.41508:83/05480/,3:2-07412034142%04/4709417:8,3/

-,841/088,070;79:,.43/0230/-90.4:3.41901190.:203.,.4:3.4190

,.0/43,38/0,3/70,7/34907834938343 4790/;843,190790.4:3.41800-04551

%08023:908,;0-0035:-80/324/07392083:7450-24709,3430#42,3,94.

0/9473985,507900/94341/:,7/$.,79.9,43.47:20.:203.47:2 ,907/07:90748:80/

$00#'$0078%04:3.41,.0/43$!'$,2:045.95800,84

3'$,2:045.9551

$005,83490/-'$,2:0 45.953

%883490/-51,3/'$,2:0 45.953

%0.4228843078:/0/9,91;02033.:/348.47:80707085438-014790/0.843841

$00'$,2:045.955 $005,3/'$,2:045.9534908

03 8:22430/ - 90 5,79 .4:3. 48.47:8 2,/0 98 5439 94: 9 8 0907

28:3/078944/47 3903943,287057080390/-574,.0/43,38947,38 30307, $00

'$,2:045.9551%0;07/.94190,8802-8;0331$007010703.03'$,2:045.9

5%070070.425,3989,9,9,.0/43147.0,800790/43:33/00,90894097,.9907

83,9:708$00'$,2:045.953845 98981,.99,9#'$00782880/$003,-4;0

9,.0/43981,.9,8,.340/0/-3,94:8414389,393450$00'$,2:0 45

.95$00,-4;05

$00'$,2:045.955%04/4709417:8,3394.0300,/0742,/08

,/:892039749094 43 41,0, 104394.030 9,9,.0/43:80/5489,88390803804157484543070,84$0078/4083498009088:0$00$0078 45.953

324/07392080890738.4,78,;08439,99057,804303.,73,903,9:70,/

473,-003.430/905543,7,38.44347/0794-:/439907904741,97:3.,90/

2,344/ 3 789 9 8 , 1,.9 40;07 9,9 309077 347 ,3 9044,3 41 90 :7.97,/9439,91440/2,/4590/9,9025,88


27/27

0,3/7308,84,/2990/9,94/.,3349-04.,0/383.,73,943419049,3,8:8

,/2,/09854397,3/49078,84,..0590/9 %,990394.030838890/43,920,5-09003901472,943419002-74,3/90:34341

90 3,9:708 3 8:55479 41 907 943,9:70 1472:, ,8 ,3 0,3/730 ,..:8,943 .394.0308/01390700.90/

%0494488,30,3/73090727010.9390289.,897,3/39079044.,933:99044.,900,3/7308//3498,,39324709,3,990394.0308,11720/$00

'$,2:045.95511:07 /8.:884341 900,3/730.79.82 4190394.03090,.38 3.:/0/ 3'

$,2:0 45 .9 55 1 %0 ,.0/43,3 /013943 8 ;03 - % 3/0 %0

0.:203.,4.:2039841 90,909:0349/43/4347,8:22,7,3/

.4220398800'$,2:045.9557,22,7,3394809208,8,90,.07

73,79903370098-44348:7;;08433,3,3.039$7,.97,38,9439,8

-003 5:-80/ 3 24/073 9208 3 90 $7,. 9 , 703/073 394 , :7450,3 ,3:,0 -475:8 $.75947:2789,347:2 7039,:2 $00 -07 4397, 25:27,22,9.:2 0/

48050-43'4$.7594708$7%42:84:;,3%0349083985,507,701742

90$7,.;07843.890473,9,90,;034 80,;03490/,70,/,.0/43,11720/9,908:8789,84305489,88,3/430

574845432,/0343 3943,9:708 %0.79.8 1443900,3/730 97,/943 9,:9

9,9789,81742943,9:7085489,9.:3434305489,88,3/43057484543,3/430

3.,73,903,9:70414/9047/ 4397,7,2$7,.5%0.438:-89,39,20,38,;3908,20-03

4397,7,245.95

4397,7,245.9 5

-/551

-/5

$00900/9435

,-,,3,-07&3430$'4$.75494708$7$7,.

4250/ 1742 90 44#% %% 88,8 3434:741 '

$,2:0/7:7,480,3,470

christological controversy and the division of the church - father v.c. samuel

Documents