christ web viewinventory (stai), and the rosenberg self-esteem scale (rses). ... read each item...
TRANSCRIPT
1Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Effects of Art Therapy on Individuals Who are Homeless
By Christina Meskil
Western Washington University; Human Services Department
HSP 385 – Applied Research Methods
2Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Abstract
This research proposal seeks to answer the question “What is the effect of art therapy on
individuals who are homeless?” There will be a brief overview of some of the psychological
implications of homelessness as well as an overview of the purposes of art therapy. This proposal
contains a summary of similar studies done to test the effectiveness of art therapy programs with
various populations, as well as a proposal for a new study to be conducted specifically with
homeless individuals in the United States.
Introduction
The United States is one of the wealthiest nations in the world with a gross domestic
product of over 15 trillion dollars according to the World Bank (2013), and yet, according to the
National Alliance to End Homelessness, there are over 633,782 people experiencing
homelessness in America (2013). Experiences of poverty and homelessness can have profound
impacts on people’s sense of sense of identity and self-esteem. It is presented that employment
quality of life, mental health, status, social networks, and personal identity; this can be attributed
to our society’s tendency to define people by their occupation (Williams & Stickley, 2011).
Researchers Williams and Stickley conducted a series of interviews with people
experiencing homelessness. Common themes in these interviews were expressed feelings of
rejection and stigma. Participants reported that homeless makes them feel lost and like they do
not know who they are anymore. They shared that they had frequently experienced harassment
from the general public. One man, John, describes this harassment “...people take offence as you
look dirty and just decide to beat you up because you are homeless which happens quite often
3Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
now...” This rejection consequently leads to a negative perception of self and experiences of
stigmatization (2011).
According to the American Art Therapy Association, art therapy is a therapeutic process
in which a professional utilizes art to engage clients in a creative process that helps them explore
their feelings, foster self-awareness, manage behavior and addictions, develop social skills,
reduce anxiety and improve self-esteem (2013).
This paper is proposing a study to be done around the benefits of conducting art therapy
programs within the homeless population. This proposed study is important because it may
create a way for people experiencing homelessness to recover from their feelings of negative
self-perception and stigmatization.
Review of Literature
What we see from the large body of research done thus far in the area of art therapy is
that art therapy among vulnerable populations has a significant positive impact on mood,
attitude, and self-esteem (Thomas et al., 2011). We see this in populations such as the elderly
(Kim, 2013) and troubled youth (Kelly, 2010). What is missing, and indeed what this proposal is
recommending be explored further, is how art therapy can be implemented in homeless adult
populations. We do find one study done in which the focus of an art therapy program is the
homeless adult population; however, the study itself has limitations which will be discussed at
length (Thomas et al.).
Australian psychotherapist and art therapy expert Jo Kelly put forth an article discussing
the efficacy and importance art therapy. “Art therapy is a modality of psychotherapy that uses the
visual creative process for healing,” says Kelly (2010, pg. 255). Kelly also put forth that art is a
4Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
particularly useful asset when looking at populations with no or limited language capabilities to
describe their experiences. As we have grown in our understanding of the brain, we learn that
images themselves greatly influence our thoughts, feelings, and wellbeing (Hass-Cohen & Carr,
2008). Of art therapy, Kelly says this:
The uniqueness of art therapy as a modality can be seen by its ability to move between
interior and exterior worlds, between the pictorial and verbal. As an experiential activity,
the sensory nature of working with art materials can provoke behavioral changes and
prompt stimulation of memory. The art becomes the evidence of the experience. It can be
reflected upon, destroyed, remarked upon, retained and reviewed. (pg. 257)
Through this, Kelly explains the inherent value in art therapy, and good cause to consider
pursuing further research.
Kim (2013) collected data from aging Korean-Americans to examine some of the benefits
of art therapy. Many older adults consider the end stages of life to be ones of hopelessness,
dependence, waiting for death, losing family members, sickness, and boredom (Hooyman &
Kiyak, 2002), and Kim undertook a study to see how the use of art therapy could mitigate some
of these end of life negative thoughts. The study utilized a pre-test post-test design and the data
was collected from 50 Korean-Americans from two adult day health care programs (ADHCP),
one in New Jersey and the other in New York. Participants were selected using a mini mental
status exam (MMSE). Clients who scored at least a 25 out of 30 (indicating high cognitive
functioning), and who had not participated in art therapy before were invited to participate in the
study. Participants were randomly sorted into either the intervention group or the control group.
Both groups were given three tests before and after the intervention received their art therapy
intervention: the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS), the State-Trait Anxiety
5Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Inventory (STAI), and the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES). This methodology for testing
the efficacy of an art therapy program and its impact on participants seems effective and may be
valuable to duplicate in further research. The outcomes of this particular study showed that aging
Korean-Americans who participated in art therapy showed higher self esteem, reduced anxiety,
reduced negative emotions, and promotes better quality of life (Kim).
While the proposed study will focus largely on homeless adults, the “Hunger and
Homelessness Survey” put out by the United States Conference of Mayors shows that
approximately a quarter of the homeless population consists of families. The YWCA did a study
of a homeless youths’ art program. The authors echo Kelly (2010) in advocating art as an ideal
mode of expression for those with limited ability to express themselves. Results show that
children in the art program experience belonging, success and creativity (Shepard & Booth,
2009).
In the Australian study of art therapy and the homeless population (Thomas, et. al, 2011)
we see what potential this topic has for being fruitful. Thomas, Gray, McGinty and Ebringer
conducted a small scale art therapy study within a homeless population. The majority of research
done was qualitative. Unfortunately, this particular study has some short comings. The
population size of this study is very small, and there are no pre or post study interviews. The lack
of pre or post study interviews is significant because it calls into question whether change had
begun prior to the art therapy, and if the change was sustained once the test was complete. The
small scale of the study is inadequate to draw reliable conclusions from. The study does yield,
however, some structure for how future research might be conducted. Thomas, Gray, McGinty
and Ebringer report that three major themes emerged from their study, these themes being the
beginning of engagement and participation stage, benefits to clients, and recognition from the
6Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
community. As we look to future research, these areas are ones to pay special attention to.
Finally, this study also shows some of the potential outcomes for clients in art therapy programs.
Some of the outcomes seen in this Australian study show that clients experienced the benefits of
self-discovery, decision making, diversion from alcohol and other addictions, and relief from
mental health issues. This should provide cause as well as home when it comes to future
research.
Art therapy is a proven successful technique for elevating self-esteem, reducing anxiety,
reducing negative emotions, and promoting better quality of life (Kim, 2013). It also promotes
belonging, success, creativity, (Shepard & Booth, 2009) and gives a voice to the voiceless
(Kelly, 2010). In homeless adults, art therapy has the potential to develop self-discovery,
decision making, diversion from alcohol and other addictions, and relief from mental health
issues (Thomas, et. al, 2011). Further research is needed to explore this topic in depth.
Methods
Research Design
Researcher will utilize a longitudinal trend design for this study. This will allow for the
observation of how art therapy affects individuals who are homeless over time. We will do this
by administering the same test twice to our participants over a 6 week period. The tests
administered to participants will give quantitative results (Marlow, 2011) representing affect
(Watson & Clark, 1999), anxiety (Speilberger, Gorsuch, Lushene, Vagg & Jacobs, 1983), and
self-esteem (Blascovich & Tomaka, 1993). This method was modeled after a similar study done
to gauge the effectiveness of art therapy programs among other populations (Kim, 2013).
Participants
7Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
To answer the question “What is the effect of art therapy on individuals who are
homeless?” our team will compile a list of every homeless drop-in center and day health center
in the United States. From this list we will randomly select 100 centers to participate in the
study. Fifty of these centers will be given the opportunity to participate in the art therapy session;
this will be called the therapy group. The other 50 centers will not participate in art therapy
sessions, but will be observed and referred to as the control group.
Instrument
The art therapy will be offered to the therapy group every day for six weeks. Participation
will be voluntary. Participants will be able to withdraw or join or rejoin at any point in the
process, however observers will make note of how many sessions each individual participated in.
Prior to the therapy group receiving treatment, both the therapy and the control group will
be asked to take 3 tests: the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule extended form (PANAS-X),
the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), and the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES). The
PANAS-X (Appendix A) presents participants with 60 words describing feelings or emotions
and asks them to score each word on a scale of 1-5 of how often they have felt the feeling or
emotion in the past week. The data is observed by comparing how participant ranked positive
emotions versus negative emotions (Watson & Clark, 1999). The STAI (Appendix B) measures
levels of depression and anxiety asking participants to rate 40 statements on a scale of 1-4 in
terms of how often that statement applies to them (1 being almost never, 4 being almost always).
Some examples of these statements would be “I am worried” and “I worry too much about
something that doesn’t really matter” (Speilberger, Gorsuch, Lushene, Vagg & Jacobs, 1983).
Finally, the RSES (Appendix C) assesses self-esteem using a ten item scale. 5 of the items are
8Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
positive statements, 5 are negative and participants are asked to rate them on a 1-4 scale of
strongly agree to strongly disagree (Blascovich & Tomaka, 1993).
Data Collection
All participants, both in the control group and the therapy group will be given an
informed consent form (Appendix D) which will be explained to them before they are given the
choice to sign and participate or not. These 3 tests will be administered to both the therapy group
and the control group prior to art therapy course, and then again after the therapy group has
undergone the therapy. There will be no names included on the tests, and completed tests will be
stored in a secure location.
Data Analysis
Tests will be gathered by researchers and coded according to which group (control or
therapy) the individual is in, and whether the test was taken before or after the art therapy
treatment had been conducted. The PANAS-X will be evaluated using Appendix E to compare
the affect of the therapy group and the control group before and after the art therapy treatment
(Watson & Clark, 1999). The STAI will use Appendix F to compare levels of anxiety of the
therapy group and the control group before and after the art therapy treatment (Speilberger,
Gorsuch, Lushene, Vagg & Jacobs, 1983). Finally, the RSES will use Appendix G to compare
the levels of self-esteem of the therapy group and the control group before and after the art
therapy treatment (Blascovich & Tomaka, 1993).
Feasibility
9Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
In this proposed study, limitations may arise as we cannot ethically and do not desire to
force any one to participate against their will; We will also not be able to obtain understanding of
why individuals chose not to participate or if that group of non-participants would have had a
different experience with the art therapy treatment.
Because this proposed study would be conducted by individuals who are hoping to
promote art therapy in the homeless population, there is already a bias toward the subject matter
of this study. In order to obtain accurate, unbiased data it will be important for the researchers
who are collecting data and conducting interviews to avoid using language that will prompt the
participants to affirm art therapy or discouraging them from speaking freely against art therapy.
Another prospective limitation may be that researchers may be unaware of while
conducting this study, is that some participants may be struggling with mental illness. National
Coalition for the Homeless (2009) states that, 20 to 25% of the homeless population in the
United States suffers from some form of severe mental illness. This needs to be a consideration
when administering informed consent and discerning whether participants are able to give
informed consent. It is also important to tread carefully when it comes to the subject matter of
the art therapy and whenever possible to minimize risk by avoiding possibly inflammatory
topics.
This research may be used by a variety of different organizations seeking alternative
methods for providing support and reprieve for individuals dealing with homelessness.
10Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
References
American Art Therapy Association. (July, 2013). What is art therapy?. Retrieved from
http://www.americanarttherapyassociation.org/upload/whatisarttherapy.pdf
Blascovich, J., & Tomaka, J. (1993). Measures of personality and social psychological attitudes.
(3rd ed., pp. 115-160). Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research.
Hass-Cohen, N., & Carr, R. (2008). Art therapy and clinical neuroscience. London: Jessica
Kingsley.
Hooyman, N. R., & Kiyak, H. I. (2002). Social gerontology: A multidisciplinary perspective.
(6th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
Kelly, J. (2010). What is art therapy and how do we know it works? An Australian perspective
on the need for more research. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 5(5),
255-259.
Kim, S. (2013). A randomized, controlled study of the effects of art therapy on older Korean-
Americans’ healthy aging. Arts in Psychotherapy, 40(1), 158-164. doi:
10.1016/j.aip.2012.11.00
Marlow, C. R. (2011). Research methods for generalist social work. (5th ed., p. 154). Belmont,
CA: Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning.
National Coalition for the Homeless, (2009). Mental illness and homelessness. Retrieved from
website: http://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/Mental_Illness.pdf
Rosenberg, M. (1965). Society and the adolescent self-image. Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press.
11Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Shepard, J., & Booth, D. (2009). Heart to heart art: Empowering homeless children and
youth. Reclaiming Children & Youth, 18(1), 12-15.
Speilberger, C. D. (1977). State-trait anxiety inventory for adults. Redwood City, CA: Mind
Garden. Retrieved from: www.mindgarden.com/products/staisad.htm
Speilberger, C. D., Gorsuch, R. L., Lushene, R., Vagg, P. R., & Jacobs, G. A. (1983). Manual for
the state-trait anxiety inventory. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.
The National Alliance to End Homelessness, (2013). The state of homelessness in America 2013.
Retrieved from website: http://www.endhomelessness.org/library/entry/the-state-of-
homelessness-2013
The United States Conference of Mayors, (2011). Hunger and homelessness survey. Retrieved
from website: http://usmayors.org/pressreleases/uploads/2011-hhreport.pdf
The World Bank, (2013). Gdp. Retrieved from website:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD
Thomas, Y., Gray, M., McGinty, S., & Ebringer, S. (2011). Homeless adults engagement in art:
First steps towards identity, recovery and social inclusion. Australian Occupational
Therapy Journal, 58(6), 429-436. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1630.2011.00977.
Watson, D., & Clark, L. A. (1999). Manual for the positive and negative affect schedule:
Expanded form. University of Illinois, Retrieved from
http://www2.psychology.uiowa.edu/faculty/clark/panas-x.pdf
12Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Williams, S., & Stickley, T. (2011). Stories from the streets: People’s experiences of
homelessness. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 18(5), 432-439. doi:
10.1111/j.1365-2850.2010.01676.x
13Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix A
PANAS-X
This scale consists of a number of words and phrases that describe different feelings and emotions. Read each item and then mark the appropriate answer in the space next to that word. Indicate to what extent you have felt this way during the past few weeks. Use the following scale to record your answers:
1-very slightly or not at all; 2-a little; 3-moderately; 4-quite a bit; 5-extremely
______ cheerful ______ sad ______ active ______ angry at self
______ disgusted ______ calm ______ guilty ______ enthusiastic
______ attentive ______ afraid ______ joyful ______ downhearted
______ bashful ______ tired ______ nervous ______ sheepish
______ sluggish ______ amazed ______ lonely ______ distressed
______ daring ______ shaky ______ sleepy ______ blameworthy
______ surprised ______ happy ______ excited ______ determined
______ strong ______ timid ______ hostile ______ frightened
______ scornful ______ alone ______ proud ______ astonished
______ relaxed ______ alert ______ jittery ______ interested
______ irritable ______ upset ______ lively ______ loathing
______ delighted ______ angry ______ ashamed ______ confident
______ inspired ______ bold ______ at ease ______ energetic
______ fearless ______ blue ______ scared ______ concentrating
______ disgusted ______ shy ______ drowsy ______ dissatisfied with self with self
(Watson & Clark, 1999)
14Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix B
15Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
(Speilberger, 1977)
16Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix C
Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale
Instructions: Below is a list of statements dealing with your general feelings about yourself. If you strongly agree, circle SA. If you agree with the statement, circle A. If you disagree, circle D. If you strongly disagree, circle SD.
1. On the whole, I am satisfied with myself. SA A D SD
2.* At times, I think I am no good at all. SA A D SD
3. I feel that I have a number of good qualities. SA A D SD
4. I am able to do things as well as most other people. SA A D SD
5.* I feel I do not have much to be proud of. SA A D SD
6.* I certainly feel useless at times. SA A D SD
7. I feel that I’m a person of worth, at least on an equal plane with others. SA A D SD
8.* I wish I could have more respect for myself. SA A D SD
9.* All in all, I am inclined to feel that I am a failure. SA A D SD
10. I take a positive attitude toward myself. SA A D SD
(Rosenberg, 1965)
17Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix D
Effects of Art Therapy on Homeless AdultConsent Form
Principal Investigator:Christina MeskilStudent, Human Services Dept.Western Washington University(253) 279-9269
Description:I am interested in the effect of art therapy within the homeless adult population. In this study you will be placed in one of two groups, one of which participate in daily art therapy sessions for six weeks, the other will not. Regardless of which group you are in, once before and once after the six week period we will give you a series of psychological
Confidentiality:Your name will not be attached to your test results or interview responses. Your name and any other identifiers will be kept in a locked file that is only accessible to me or my research associates. Any information from this study that is published will not identify you by name.
Benefits:This study may provide you with an opportunity to participate in a potentially beneficial experience with art therapy. Results of this study may benefit other homeless adults by providing information to social workers, case managers, and other professionals in the field about how to create programing and treatment that is effective for homeless adults.
Risk:Participating in the art therapy sessions and discussion of feelings may make you feel sad or uncomfortable. However, there are no other known risks to you.
Contact People: If you have any questions you may contact the principal investigator at the phone number listed above. If you have any question about your rights as a research subject, please contact the Office of the Vice Provost for Research at Western Washington University at (360-650-2884).
Voluntary Nature of Participation:Your participation in this study is voluntary. If you don’t wish to participate, or would like to end your participation in this study, there will be no penalty or loss of benefits to which you are otherwise entitled. In other words, you are free to make your own choice about being in this study or not, and may quit at any time without penalty.
Signature:Your signature on this consent form indicates that you fully understand the above study, what’s being asked of you in this study, and that you are signing this voluntarily. If you have any questions about this study, please feel free to ask them now or at any time throughout the study.
Signature_________________________ Date___________
A copy of this consent form is available for you to keep.
(Marlow, 2011)
18Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix E
Evaluating the PANAS-X
General Dimension Scales
Negative Affect (10) afraid, scared, nervous, jittery, irritable, hostile, guilty, ashamed, upset, distressed
Positive Affect (10) active, alert, attentive, determined, enthusiastic, excited, inspired, interested, proud, strong
Basic Negative Emotion Scales
Fear (6) afraid, scared, frightened, nervous, jittery, shaky
Hostility (6) angry, hostile, irritable, scornful, disgusted, loathing
Guilt (6) guilty, ashamed, blameworthy, angry at self, disgusted with self, dissatisfied with self
Sadness (5) sad, blue, downhearted, alone, lonely
Basic Positive Emotion Scales
Joviality (8) happy, joyful, delighted, cheerful, excited, enthusiastic, lively, energetic
Self-Assurance (6) proud, strong, confident, bold, daring, fearless
Attentiveness (4) alert, attentive, concentrating, determined
Other Affective States
Shyness (4) shy, bashful, sheepish, timid
Fatigue (4) sleepy, tired, sluggish, drowsy
Serenity (3) calm, relaxed, at ease
Surprise (3) amazed, surprised, astonished
(Watson & Clark, 1999)
19Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix FEvaluating the STAI
(Speilberger, 1977)
20Running Head: ART THERAPY AND HOMELESSNESS
Appendix G
Scoring the RSES
Scoring: SA=3, A=2, D=1, SD=0. Items with an asterisk are reverse scored, that is, SA=0, A=1,
D=2, SD=3. Sum the scores for the 10 items. The higher the score, the higher the self esteem.
(Rosenberg, 1965)