chick-fil-a manager retention issues

12
Jennifer Burnham Matthew Hoffmaster Matthew Martin Hannah Simmons Amanda Simula It’s a Great Day at Chick- fil-A!

Upload: mattyboync

Post on 07-Nov-2014

1.623 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

We looked at manager retention rates at this Chick-fil-A location. We focused on culture, mainly attraction-selection-attrition model and socialization, in order to determine the effects of job satisfaction on turnover.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Jennifer BurnhamMatthew Hoffmaster

Matthew MartinHannah SimmonsAmanda Simula

It’s a Great Day at Chick-fil-A!

Page 2: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Mooresville Chick-fil-A• Worked with the operating partner, Darin

Wiggins

• Turnover issues with new managers• The last three Assistant Managers left the franchise

within a year of their hire date

• Methodology• Email• Topics• Surveys• Interviews• Analysis

Page 3: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

CultureBased on biblical principles

Closed on Sundays

Culture very family-based

Dedicated to philanthropies

Page 4: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

ASA• Employees Are drawn in by the culture

• Hired based on their propensity to fit in well with the company

• If new managers do not feel accepted or like the culture, there will probably be attrition

~• Cannot hire a good manager who engages

in behavior such as moonlighting at a strip club because it would upset the corporation

Page 5: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

CultureCurrent managers all love the culture

Those managers believe the feelings are shared

Not everyone is as good of a “fit” as it may seem to managers:

All front-line employees said that they “fit well” but either:

did not like the culture “much”did not like the culture “at all”

Possibly, managers that left did not fit with the culture as much as they or management expected

Page 6: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

CultureOrganizational culture should fit mission, values, and goals

Self proclaimed “Keys to Success:”

Customer serviceProduct qualityFranchisee relationsEmployee relationsPhilanthropies

Page 7: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

CultureDiscrepancy between corporate beliefs and employee beliefs:

Team-members placed low significance on franchisee relations and employee relations

Employee relations ranked MUCH HIGHER in Mooresville store than the other store. (more on this later)

Page 8: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Socialization• Ongoing process of internalizing

organization’s culture

• No formal rituals practiced when new management came on board

• Team members felt that formal introduction of new management was important• Build respect for new management • Feel more accepted and comfortable in new position

Page 9: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

CultureMooresville Store:

More family members who work thereMore friends at workPlace more emphasis on prior experienceBelieve “employee relations” more important than other location

Mooresville store could have a more developed culture leading to barriers to change, and lack of acceptance of new managers

Page 10: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Is the Cultural Pressure Too Much?

“We are watched very closely by Chick-fil-A... It's very weird.”

Personal questions often asked during interviews:

Marital statusNumber of dependentsInvolvement in community, civic, social, church, and professional organizations

Family members of prospective operators are often interviewed

Page 11: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Job Satisfaction• Idea that high performers having a

reduced probability of turnover as job attitudes elevated

• Current managers have a high level of job satisfaction

• Excited by the values of Chick-fil-A• Specifically Christian virtues and family values

• Front line employees think highly of management’s performance

• Clear that job satisfaction would have a tremendous affect on retention

Page 12: Chick-fil-A Manager Retention Issues

Conclusions• Maintain a policy of seeking out managers that

hold the same family values and Christian virtues

• Promote from within as much as possible

• Essential to have some previous restaurant experience, preferably another Chick-fil-A location

• Current managers be a part of the interviewing process

• Formal introduction policy be established