chapter5 analysis
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
1/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
(1) Gravity Analysis No load applied Only load due to gravity is applied. Boundary conditions are shown by blue colour in below figure.
Fig. 1 Boundary condition
Fig. 2 Equivalent (von-Mises) Stress
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
2/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig.3 Total deformation
Result achieved:
(i) Total deformation: 0.023588mm(ii) Von-mises stress: 4.44 MPa
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
3/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
(2)Modal Analysis (No loading condition)Modal Analysis is done to find natural frequency of the system.
Same boundary condition applied as above. Total 10 natural frequencies are found out.
Fig.4 Boundary condition for Modal analysis
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
4/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig.5 Meshing
Highly fine meshing is done with 15mm element size. Meshing is done with quadrilateral
element for better result. Total nodes generated are 771299 representing 187 bodies active
components. Total elements created are 116174.
Fig.6 First Mode (132.06 Hz)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
5/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig.7 Second Mode (136.97 Hz)
Fig. 8 Third Mode (141.22 Hz)
Result of Modal analysis:
Total 10 natural frequencies are found as below:
` Mode Frequency[Hz]
1 1 132.06
2 2 136.97
3 3 141.22
4 4 148.06
5 5 159.86
6 6 171.35
7 7 176.09
8 8 181.58
9 9 182.18
10 10 183.67
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
6/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
(A)CONDITION AT INSTANT WHEN MATERIAL JUST FALLS ON DECK
(1)MATERIAL IS STORED IN A CHAMBER ABOVE DECK AREA, NO HOPPERIS PROVIDED.
As the material is falling from height of 2 m, we are neglecting hopper effect. So we are
considering direct impact due to material falling. Material is stored at 2 m height. Potential
energy is stored at the height, as lump falls down the Potential energy is converted in to Kinetic
Energy, so we can find the value of falling velocity by formula,
V=
V= Impact velocity
V0= Initial velocity at 2m level (In our case it is assumed to be zero)
g= Gravitational acceleration (9.81 m/)
The impact velocity find is 6.465 m/
Explicit Dynamics is one of the modules of ANSYS, which is used to find deflection of
object due to impact loads. Lump is assumed cubical shape. Here the maximum lump size taken
as 300*300*300 , the total lump are assumed as cover the total plate. Bulk density is takenas 800 kg/. The explicit dynamics analysis is carried out as below to find effect of impactforce.
EXPLICIT DYNAMICS
Explicit dynamics is used to found impact stress and deflection of falling object. The material
falling is of 300mm*300mm*300mm cube of coal. Material falling velocity is 6.465 m/.Boundary conditions are given to feeder. This is shown below.
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
7/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig. 9 Boundary condition for explicit dynamics
Yellow coloured objects in above figure are coal lump which are impacting on VGF deck area.
Boundary conditions are shown by blue colour in above figure.
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
8/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig. 10 Directional deformation
Result of directional deformation is 0.27647mm, due to 300*300*300 lump size.
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
9/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig. 11 Von Mises stress
Von-Mises stress is found: 240.39 MPa due to 300*300*300 lump size.
(2)MATERIAL IS STORED IN HOPPER JUST ABOVE THE DECK PLATE AREAOF FEEDER.
In this condition material is taken falling from hopper just above the deck. By different
configuration of hopper different analysis is carried out. The hoper may conical shaped outlet
or wedge shape outlet. It is then differentiate by inner lining material, the material may be
mild steel or stainless steel. It may further differentiate by surcharge shape, it may be conical
or triangular. Based on it different cases are been taken to analyzed with different hopper
configuration.
http://win%28%27paper27gg.htm%27%29/http://win%28%27paper27gg.htm%27%29/ -
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
10/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 1: HOPPER OUTLET IS WEDGE SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH M.S
MATERIAL, CONICAL MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
i.
Bin
Opening Dimension (B) 2.5 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 3.90 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 35
Parallel section of bin mild steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Loads act on feeder are two types. Initial Load on feeder and flow load. Initial loads are at when
hopper is fully empty, in this time the loads acts on a feeder are higher, while flow loads are less
compare to initial loads. So, for safe design we will analyze for initial load because it is higher.
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
11/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Solution
i. Static Surcharge Factor qiAssuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material
is taken as 1.
=
= 0.333 m (1)
R =
= 0.975 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)
= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 0.975 m.
= tan = tan 30 = 0.577
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found, =14.13 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from wedge shaped outlet, so material flow will be plane flow
and for plane flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 0.
= hopper half angle= 35tan = 0.70
m=0
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 0.861
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
12/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is wedge shaped, so m=0, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 42.257 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 16653 Pa.
Fig 12 Von-Mises stress (Case 1)
Fig 13 Total deformation (Case 1)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
13/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Results found for Case 1:
Total Deformation: 0.1076 mm
Von- Mises stress: 15.83 MPa
CASE 2: HOPPER OUTLET IS WEDGE SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH S.S
MATERIAL, CONICAL MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
ii. BinOpening Dimension (B) 2.5 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 3.90 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 35
Parallel section of bin stainless steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
14/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Solution
ii. Static Surcharge Factor qiAssuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material
is taken as 1.
=
= 0.333 m (1)
R =
= 0.975 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)
= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 0.975 m.
= tan = tan 18 = 0.3249
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found, =15.78 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from wedge shaped outlet, so material flow will be plane flow
and for plane flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 0.
= hopper half angle= 35tan = 0.70
m=0
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 1.377
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
15/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is wedge shaped, so m=0, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 67.55 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 26620 Pa.
Fig 14 Boundary condition (Case 2)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
16/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 15 Total Deformation (Case 2)
Fig 16 Von-Mises stress
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
17/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 3: HOPPER OUTLET IS WEDGE SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH M.S
MATERIAL, TRIANGULAR SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
iii. BinOpening Dimension (B) 2.5 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 3.90 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 35
Parallel section of bin mild steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
iii. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
18/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of triangular shape, for triangular shape
material is taken as 0.
=
= 0.5 m (1)
R =
= 1.95 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 0.975 m.
= tan = tan 30 = 0.577
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 13.97 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from wedge shaped outlet, so material flow will be plane flow
and for plane flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 0.
= hopper half angle= 35tan = 0.70
m=0
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 0.856
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
19/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is wedge shaped, so m=0, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 41.98 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 16543 Pa.
Fig 17 Boundary conditions (Case 3)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
20/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 18 Total Deformation (Case 3)
Fig 19 Von Mises stress (Case 4)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
21/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 4: HOPPER OUTLET IS WEDGE SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH S.S
MATERIAL, TRIANGULAR MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
iv. BinOpening Dimension (B) 2.5 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 3.90 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 35
Parallel section of bin stainless steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
iv. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
22/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material is taken as 1.
=
= 0.5 m (1)
R =
= 1.95 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 1.95 m.
= tan = tan 18 = 0.3249
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 18.15 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from wedge shaped outlet, so material flow will be plane flow
and for plane flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 0.
= hopper half angle= 35tan = 0.70
m=0
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 1.474
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
23/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is wedge shaped, so m=0, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 72.29 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 28488 Pa.
Fig 20 Boundary Condition (Case 4)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
24/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 21 Total Deformation (Case 4)
Fig 22 Von Mises stress (Case 4)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
25/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 5: HOPPER OUTLET IS CONICAL SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH M.S
MATERIAL, CONICAL MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
v. BinOpening Dimension (B) 1 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 2.0 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 25
Parallel section of bin mild steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
v. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
26/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material is taken as 1.
=
= 0.333 m (1)
R =
= 0.5 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 0.5 m.
= tan = tan 30 = 0.577
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 11.28 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from conical shaped outlet, so material flow will be axial flow
and for axial flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 1.
= hopper half angle= 25tan = 0.466
m=1
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 1.4065
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
27/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is conical shaped, so m=1, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 11.038 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 14054 Pa.
Only single hopper above the deck area:
Fig 23 Boundary Condition (Case 5)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
28/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 24 Total Deformation (Case 5)
Fig 25 Von-Mises stress (Case 5)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
29/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Two hoppers above the deck area:
Fig 26 Boundary condition (Two Hopper)
Fig 27 Total Deformation (Two Hopper)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
30/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 28 Von Mises stress (Two hopper)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
31/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 6: HOPPER OUTLET IS CONICAL SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH S.S
MATERIAL, CONICAL MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
vi. BinOpening Dimension (B) 1.0 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 2.0 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 25
Parallel section of bin stainless steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
vi. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
32/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material is taken as 1.
=
= 0.333 m (1)
R =
= 0.5 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 0.5 m.
= tan = tan 18 = 0.3249
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 13.79 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from conical shaped outlet, so material flow will be axial flow
and for axial flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 1.
= hopper half angle= 25tan = 0.466
m=1
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 2.1988
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
33/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is conical shaped, so m=1, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 17.25 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 21963 Pa.
Fig 29 Boundary condition (Case 6)
Fig 30 Total Deformation (Case 6)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
34/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 31 Von-Mises stress (Case 6)
Two hoppers above deck:
Fig 32 Boundary Conditions (Two hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
35/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 33 Total Deformation (Two hoppers)
Fig 34 Von Mises stress (Two hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
36/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 7: HOPPER OUTLET IS CONICAL SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH M.S
MATERIAL, TRIANGULAR SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
vii. BinOpening Dimension (B) 1.0 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 2.0 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 25
Parallel section of bin mild steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
vii. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
37/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of triangular shape, for triangular shape
material is taken as 0.
=
= 0.5 m (1)
R =
= 1.0 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 1.0 m.
= tan = tan 30 = 0.577
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 15.04 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from conical shaped outlet, so material flow will be axial flow
and for axial flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 1.
= hopper half angle= 25tan = 0.466
m=1
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 1.5947
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
38/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is conical shaped, so m=1, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 12.51 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 15928 Pa.
Fig 35 Boundary Condition (Case 7)
Fig 36 Total Deformation (Case 7)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
39/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 37 Von Mises stress (Case 7)
Two hopper outlet:
Fig 38 Boundary Condition (Two hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
40/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 39 Total Deformation (Two hoppers)
Fig 40 Von Mises stress (Two hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
41/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
CASE 8: HOPPER OUTLET IS TRIANGULAR SHAPED; HOPPER IS INLINED WITH
S.S MATERIAL, TRIANGULAR MATERIAL SURCHARGE AT TOP OF HOPPER:
viii. BinOpening Dimension (B) 1.0 m
Height H 2.0 m
Width D 2.0 m
Surcharge Hs 1.0 m
Height of hopper Hh 1.0 m
Half angle 25
Parallel section of bin stainless steel
Hopper section Lined with stainless steel type 304-2B
Length of opening L 1 m
ii. Bulk Solid Type = coal
Effective angle of
internal friction = 50
Angle of friction between
coal and mild steel = 30
Angle of friction between
coal and stainless
steel n = 18
Bulk density = 0.80 t/m
Solution
viii. Static Surcharge Factor qi
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
42/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Assuming material surcharge on top of the bin is of conical shape, for conical shape material is taken as 1.
=
= 0.5 m (1)
R =
= 1.0 m (2)
=
[1-
] +
(3)= 0.4 (for incompressible material this value is taken o.4, coal is incompressible)
= *g = 0.8*9.81= 7.848 ton/
R= 1.0 m.
= tan = tan 18 = 0.3249
H = 2 m.
Put the all above values in equation (3)
We found,
= 16.84 KPa.
Initial non dimensional surcharge factor ,
= *
[
+
- 1] (4)
In this case material is coming out from conical shaped outlet, so material flow will be axial flow
and for axial flow the value ofm in above equation is taken as 1.
= hopper half angle= 25tan = 0.466
m=1
by putting all values in equation (4) we get, = 1.6851
Initial load acting on feeder for this case is found by,
W= * * * (5)
m= 0 (for wedge shape outlet)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
43/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
m=1 (for axial flow or conical outlet)
In this case outlet is conical shaped, so m=1, put all values in equation (5)
We get load on hopper outlet in this case,
W= 13.22 KN
This force will applied on all four deck plates, so it will converted into pressure to apply on deck
plate in ANSYS 14 workbench.
Pressure, P = 16832 Pa.
Fig 41 Boundary Condition (Case 8)
Fig 42 Total Deformation (Case 8)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
44/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 43 Von Mises stress (Case 8)
Fig 44 Boundary Condition (Two hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
45/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 45 Total Deformation (Two Hoppers)
Fig 46 Von Mises stress (Two Hoppers)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
46/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
(B)CONDITION WHEN MATERIAL STARTS SCREENINGIn this situation three conditions are taken:
(1)If the material falls are over sized with 300*300*300 lump size(2)If the material falls are over sized with 100*100*100
lump size
(3) If the material falls average sized with 30*30*30 lump size(1)If the material falls are over sized with 300*300*300 lump size:
At the instant when material is start screening.
Here it is assumed that all lumps are of 300*300*300 size. The conveying is done byvibratory motion, lump are move in parabolic curve to move ahead. Here the amplitude of this
curve not high, so material will not create impact on deck as well as screen. Therefore, It is
assumed that material is moving with sliding motion. So, at any instant the load is equal to
material retained at on particular deck. So direct material load is acting on deck and screen by
W=mg.
Case 1: It is assumed that all lumps are oversized and screening is not done. The material that
falling on deck , leaves in same quantity without screening. So the load act will be same for all
plates.
Load on each row of plates*= width of total 4 plate x length of plate x height of material lump x
density
= 5974.29 N ( This the load acting on each row of plate)
*= each row contains four plates
The total load is converted in to pressure and applied on each plate. The results found are as
below.
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
47/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 47 Boundary condition
Fig. 48 Total Deformation
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
48/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 49 Von-Mises Stress
Fig 50 First natural frequency (119.34 Hz)
Fig 51 Second natural frequency (126.56 Hz)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
49/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Result found:
(1)Total deformation: 0.041mm(2)Von Mises Stress: 7.6384MPa(3)1st mode: 119.34 Hz(4)2nd mode: 126.56 Hz(5)3rd mode: 128.08 Hz
Case 2: It is assumed that material falling are having some large size lump and some that
can be screened:
Some assumptions made for screening:
(1)First row of screen, screens the material is 35% of total material(2)Second row of screen, screens the material is 25% of total material(3)Third row of screen, screens the material is 20% of total material(4)Fourth row of screen, screen the material is 10% of total material(5)Rest of 10% material passed through last plate, which is oversized.
As above assumption, the pressure on each row of plate is found out:
(1)For first row: 2365 Pa(2)For second row: 1536 Pa(3)For third row: 945 Pa(4)
For forth row: 472 Pa(5)For last plate: 1454 Pa
Fig 50 Boundary and Loading Conditions
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
50/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 53 Total Deformation
Fig 54 Von Mises stress
Fig 55 First modal frequency (119.34 Hz)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
51/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 56 Second Modal frequency (126.56 Hz)
Result found:
(1)Total Deformation: 0.040mm(2)Von Mises stress: 7.099 MPa(3)1st mode: 119.34 Hz(4)2nd mode: 126.56 Hz(5)3rd mode: 128.08 Hz
(2)If the material falls are over sized with 100*100*100 lump size:Case 1: It is assumed that all lumps are oversized and screening is not done. The material that
falling on deck , leaves in same quantity without screening. So the load act will be same for all
plates.
Load on each row of plates*= width of total 4 plate x length of plate x height of material lump x
density
Load= 1991.43 N
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
52/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 57 Loading and Boundary conditions
Fig 58 Total deformation
Fig 59 Von Mises stress
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
53/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 60 First Modal frequency (126.56 Hz)
Fig 61 Second Modal frequency (128.09 Hz)
Result found:
(1)Total Deformation: 0.028 mm(2)Von Mises stress: 5.5096 MPa(3)1st mode: 119.34 Hz(4)2nd mode: 126.56 Hz(5)3rd mode: 128.09 Hz
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
54/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Case 2: It is assumed that material falling are having some large size lump and some that
can be screened:
Same assumptions made for screening as above case:
(1)For first row: 788 Pa
(2)For second row: 512 Pa(3)For third row: 315 Pa(4)For forth row: 157 Pa(5)For last plate: 484 Pa
Fig 62 Boundary and loading conditions
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
55/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 63 Total deformation
Fig 64 Von Mises stress
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
56/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 65 First Modal frequency (119.34 Hz)
Fig 66 Second Modal frequency (126.56 Hz)
Result found:
(1)Total Deformation: 0.0279 mm(2)Von Mises stress: 5.329 MPa(3)1st mode: 119.34 Hz(4)2nd mode: 126.56 Hz(5)3rd mode: 128.09 Hz
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
57/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
(6)If the material falls average sized with 30*30*30 lump sizeHere the average material size 30*30*30 , the material screening percentages are as above.
Fig 67 Loading and boundary conditions
Fig 68 Total deformation
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
58/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Fig 69 Von Mises stress
Fig 70 First Modal frequency (119.34 Hz)
Fig 71 Second Modal frequency (126.56 Hz)
-
7/31/2019 CHAPTER5 Analysis
59/59
ANALYSIS OF VIBRATING-GRIZZLY FEEDER
Result found:
(1)Total Deformation: 0.0237 mm(2)Von Mises stress: 4.7108 MPa(3)1st mode: 119.34 Hz(4)2nd mode: 126.56 Hz(5)3rd mode: 128.09 Hz