chapter - v enzymatic activities chapter -...
TRANSCRIPT
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
99
Chapter - V
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
100
Acetylcholinesterase (AChE)
Cholinesterases (ChEs) are a ubiquitous class of serine hydrolases which
physiologically remove acetylcholine from the synaptic cleft. ChEs are widely distributed
among vertebrate and invertebrate animals (Bocquene et al., 1997). Acetylcholinesterase is an
enzyme that regulates the amount of neurotransmitter acetylcholine at neuron junctions. It is a
serine protease that hydrolyzes the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. AChE is found mainly at
neuromuscular junctions and cholinergic brain synapses, where its activity serves to terminate
synaptic transmission. It belongs to carboxylesterase family of enzymes.
AChE has very high catalytic activity - each molecule of AChE degrades about 25000
molecules of acetylcholine (ACh) per second, approaching the limit allowed by diffusion of
the substrate (Quinn, 1987; Taylor and Radic, 1994). The active site of AChE comprises 2
subsites - the anionic site and the esteratic subsite. The structure and mechanism of action of
AChE have been elucidated from the crystal structure of the enzyme (Sussman et al., 1991;
1993).
During neurotransmission, ACh is released from the nerve into the synaptic cleft and
binds to ACh receptors on the post-synaptic membrane, relaying the signal from the nerve.
AChE, also located on the post-synaptic membrane, terminates the signal transmission by
hydrolyzing ACh. The liberated choline is taken up again by the pre-synaptic nerve and ACh
is synthetized by combining with acetyl-CoA through the action of cholineacetyltransferase
(Whittaker, 1990; Purves et al., 2008; Ohanka, 2012).
AChE is found in many types of conducting tissue: nerve and muscle, central and
peripheral tissues, motor and sensory fibers, and cholinergic and noncholinergic fibers. The
activity of AChE is higher in motor neurons than in sensory neurons (Massoulie et al., 1993;
Chacho and Cerf, 1960; Koelle, 1954). Acetylcholinesterase exists in multiple molecular
forms, which possess similar catalytic properties, but differ in their oligomeric assembly and
mode of attachment to the cell surface. The major form of acetylcholinesterase found in brain,
muscle, and other tissues, known as is the hydrophilic species, which forms disulfide-linked
oligomers with collagenous, or lipid-containing structural subunits.
For a cholinergic neuron to receive another impulse, ACh must be released from the
ACh receptor. This occurs only when the concentration of ACh in the synaptic cleft is very
low. Inhibition of AChE leads to accumulation of ACh in the synaptic cleft and results in
impeded neurotransmission. Irreversible inhibitors of AChE may lead to muscular paralysis,
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
101
convulsions and bronchial constriction.
Organophosphorus (OPs) insecticides are known to inhibit acetylcholinesterase, which
plays an important role in neurotransmission at cholinergic synapses by rapid hydrolysis of
neurotransmitter acetylcholine to choline and acetate (Soreq and Zakut, 1993). These inhibit
the action of the cholinesterase by phosphorylating or carbamylating the active centre of the
enzymes. The most important toxic property of organophosphorus pesticide compounds is
inhibiting their target enzyme acetyl cholinesterase activity (O' Brein, 1967; Corbeit, 1974).
Most of the organophosphate compounds are similar with the ester part of acetylocholine and
they react with esterase part of AchE after entering into the exposed animal. The conversion
of acetylcholine into acetic acid and choline catalyzed by AchE is considered to be the key
reaction in synaptic transmission (Bachelard, 1976).
Acetylcholinesterase activity is one of the most frequently used indicators to verify
organophosphate effects (Chuiko, 2000; Aguiar et al., 2004). The inhibition of AChE for
pestcides can affect locomotion and equilibrium in exposed fishes and may impair feeding,
escape, and reproductive behavior (Saglio and Trijasse, 1998; Bretaud et al., 2000). The
inhibitory effects organophosphorus pesticides on cholinesterases are generally considered as
the basis for the biological activity of fishes. Hence AchE estimation in fishes has proved
valuable in detecting the pollution of fresh water and marine waters.
The inhibition of cholinesterase activity serves as a reliable biomarker both of
exposure and of effect of organophosphates (Coppage and Braidech, 1976; Fulton and Key,
2001; Chambers et al., 2002; Vioque-Fernandez et al., 2009). It is well accepted that 20% or
greater inhibition of AChE in birds, fishes and invertebrates indicates exposure to
organophosphate insecticides (Mayer and Ellersiek, 1986).
The inhibitory effects of organophosphorus insecticides are dependent on their
binding capacity to the enzyme active site and by their rate of phosphroylation in relation to
behavior and age (Dutta et al., 1995). Organophosphorus pesticides are converted in vivo to
the corresponding active phosphate ester or oxon (P=O), which is a potent
acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. Studies using animal liver have shown that cytochrome P450
(CYP) enzymes mediate the oxidative desulphuration of the OP parathion to the active
metabolite paraoxon (Neal, 1967). Organophosphorus compounds generally are lipophilic and
therefore cross the blood-brain barrier in most cases (Vale, 1998). Tomokuni et aI., (1985)
observed the accumulation of diazinon in the brain of rats and mice after single interperitoneal
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
102
injection. They also found that brain AChE activity was inhibited markedly after injection.
Inhibition of AChE that is responsible for the degradation of acetylcholine will result
in excessive stimulation of cholinergic nerves. This will result in tremors, convulsion and
finally the death of the aquatic organism (Baxter and Barker, 1998). Several factors seem to
be involved in affecting the AChE activity caused by OPs such as length to time and exposure
concentrations (Uncer et aI., 2006). Inhibition of AChE, impairs cholinergic nerve impulses
and may result in death of organisms (Salles et al., 2006).
Inhibition of AChE was accompanied by an increase in acetylcholine levels
(Brzezinski and Ludwicki, 1973). This condition can lead to increase of catecholamines which
can affect the activity of enzymes involved in glycogenolysis and glycogen synthesis.
Continuous stress may affect the synthesis site of AChE or decrease the levels of excess
AChE. Mortality of fish may be due to inhibition of other enzymes, especially those taking
part in carbohydrate and protein metabolisms. The inhibitory effect on AChE activity
indicates that insecticides might interfere in vital processes like energy metabolism of nerve
cells (Ansari et al., 1987). Consequently, inhibition of AChE leads to paralysis and death.
Many organophosphates are potent neurotoxins, functioning by inhibiting the action of
AChE in nerve cells. Significant AChE inhibition following organophosphate exposure has
been shown to occur in a number of vertebrate and invertebrate species at concentrations well
below the LC50 value (Day and Scott, 1990; Booth et al., 2001; De Mel and Pathiratne, 2005).
Studies done on the inhibitory effects of organophosphorus compounds on an array of fish
species have produced varied results. Dembele et al. (2000) found that 0.36 ppb of
chlorpyrifos inhibited brain AChE activity in the common carp, Cyprinus carpio by 85%,
while Boone and Chambers (1997) found that 50% inhibition in brain AChE activity in the
mosquitofish, Gambusia affinis, required a 50-fold greater concentration.
Several investigators (Day and Scott, 1990; Boone and Chambers; 1997; Mileson et
al,. 1998; Pan and Dutta, 1998; Chuiko, 1999; Dembele et al., 2000; Booth et al., 2001; Erwin
et al., 2003; De Mel and Pathiratne, 2005; Kristen et al., 2005; Rao; 2006; Venkateswara,
2006; Elif and Demet , 2007; Khalid et al., 2008; Pavlov et al., 2008; Vineet et al., 2008)
reported the inhibition of AChE following organophosphate pesticides exposure in a different
fish species.
The activity of cholinesterases differs from one fish species to another. Chciko et al.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
103
(2000) observed acetylcholine esterase, butyrylcholinesterase activities in brain and plasma of
fresh water teleosts and reported that brain acetycholinesterase activity varied among fish
species approximately 15-fold ranging from 138 to 2011 µ mol/g/ hr. All cyprinids had higher
brain AChE activity than other fish families.
Individual variation in the enzyme inhibition activity of OP pesticides was also noted.
Varo et al. (2003) have demonstrated an age-dependent correlation in AChE inhibition in
European sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax exposed to the OP pesticide dichlorvos in his study.
Another important factor in intraspecies variability is the general health of the organism, and
the extent of exposure to other stressors.
The inhibition of AChE activity is regarded as a significant parameter in assessing the
complex toxicogenic effects of pesticides (Bradbury et al., 1986). Great deal of work has been
turned out on these lines with reference to AChE inhibition by organophosphate pesticides,
but no attempt has been made on Cyprinus carpio with reference to acute and chronic toxicity
of phorate. Hence an attempt is made to study the AChE activity in economically important
edible fish Cyprinus carpio on exposure to acute and chronic toxicity of phorate.
RESULTS
The data on the levels of AChE activity in the organs such as gills, liver, muscle,
kidney and brain of the fish cyprinus carpio at 1 and 4 days on exposure to acute toxicity of
phorate and 1, 7, 15 and 30 days on exposure to chronic toxicity of phorate, besides controls,
are presented in the Table-9 and Figure-8. For comparison, the differences obtained in relation
to controls of each organ at the above said exposure periods in acute and chronic toxicity
study of phorate, were converted as percentages of the corresponding controls and those
percent values are also presented in the same table and was plotted a graph of percent changes
against exposure periods in Figure-8.
From the data presented in the Table-9 and Figure-8 it is seen that, relative to controls,
the levels of of AChE activity in all the organs of the fish exposed to phorate gradually
decreased at 1 and 4 days of exposure in acute toxicity in the order of 1>4 and the differences
in the activity between controls and experimental were also found to be statistically significant
(P<0.05). In the fish exposed to chronic toxicity of phorate relative to controls the levels of
AChE activity elevated at day 1 in all the organs. The levels of AChE activity gradually
decreased from day 7 to day 15 followed by an increase at day 30 on exposure to chronic
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
104
toxicity of phorate in all the organs of the fish in the order of 1>7>15<30. The values were
found to be statistically significant (P<0.05). However, based on the percent values obtained
(Table-9 and Figure-8) the decrease in AChE activity was found to be predominantly more in
the organs of the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate.
DISCUSSION
Acetylcholinesterase (AChE, EC 3.1.1.7) activity is routinely used as a biomarker of
the exposure to certain groups of contaminants, such as organophosphate insecticides (Grue et
al., 1997). Low concentrations of the compounds can inhibit AChE, which leads to an
accumulation of acetylcholine at central cholinergic synapses and neuromuscular junctions
(Sancho et al., 1997; Varo et al., 2003). The inhibition of the acetylcholinesterase by
pesticides can affect locomotion and equilibrium of exposed organisms (Saglio and Trijasse,
1998; Bretaud et al., 2000).
The AChE activity is vital to normal behaviour and muscular function in animals and
represents a prime target on which some toxicants can exert a detrimental effect. Inhibition of
the AChE activity results in a build up of acetylcholine causing prolonged excitatory
postsynaptic potential. This results in repeated, uncontrolled firing of neurons leading to
hyperstimulation of the nerve or muscle fibres, which leads paralysis, and eventual death.
Neurological and behavioral activities of animals can be extremely sensitive to
environmental contamination (Doving, 1991; Scherer, 1992; Silbergeld, 1993; Costa, 1996).
Organophosphate pesticides are competitive inhibitors of acetylecholineesterase (AChE), the
key enzyme in the transmission of nerve impulse. AChE is readily phosphorylated by the
organophosphate pesticides at the active site serine (Aldrige and Reiner, 1972; Taylor, 1990).
organophosphates causes inhibition of AChE and accumulation of acetylecholine at the
synapse (Loskowsky and Dettbam, 1975) which leads to over stimulating the post synaptic
cells (Pope et al., 1995). It is well accepted that 20% or greater inhibition of AChE in birds,
fishes and invertebrates indicates exposure to organophosphate insecticides (Mayer and
Ellersiek, 1986).
In the present investigation the data on AChE activity revealed a decrease in the
enzyme activity in both the nervous (brain) and non-nervous (gill, liver, muscle and kidney)
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio exposed to acute and chronic toxicity of phorate except at
day 1 in chronic toxicity exposure (Table-9 and Figure-8).
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
105
The decrease in AchE activity was also observed earlier when treated with Roger and
Dimecron in fresh water mussel, L. Marginalis (Vijayaendrababu and Vasudev, 1984). Similar
observations were made in fresh water crab, O.Senex senex by Fenitrothion (Bhagyalakshmi
and Ramamurthi, 1980); in snails exposed to different organophosphorus compounds
(Ramana Rao and Ramurthi, 1979; Singh and Agarwal, 1982) and in fishes ( Anuradha,1993;
Singh and Singh, 2005).
Pan and Dutta (1998) studied the inhibition of brain acetylcholinesterase activity of
juvenile largemouth bass, Pterus salmoides by sublethal concentrations of diazinon and
reported that juvenile brain acetylcholinesterase activities were significantly inhibited by
sublethal doses of diazinon. Erwin et al. (2003) studied the effects of chronic exposure of
parathion on acetylcholine esterase inhibition and increased food consumption rate in the
zebra fish, Danio rerio and reported that inhibition rate was significant above 0.9 µ g/l after
144 days and above 4.3 µg/l after 250 days of exposure.
Kristen et al. (2005) studied the effects of diazinon exposure in hybrid striped bass on
biochemical and behavioural aspects and reported that the sublethal exposure to diazinon, an
organophosphate pesticide, may lead to feeding behavior abnormalities in hybrid striped bass
through inhibition of brain acetylcholine esterase activity. Venkateswara (2006) studied
sublethal effects of profenofos on locomotive behaviour and gill architecture of the mosquito
fish, Gambusia affinis and reported that the sublethal concentration of profenofos altered
locomotive behaviour such as distance traveled and swimming speed in fish due to inhibition
in the activity of acetylcholine esterase and caused for the deformities in the primary and
secondary lamella of gill.
Khalid et al. (2008) studied the ethological response and haematological and
biochemical profiles of carp, cyprinus carpio exposed to trichlorfos, and reported a significant
reduction in the acetylcholinesterase activity in the brain tissue of the fish exposed to
tricholorfos. Pavlov et al. (2008) studied the effect of DDVP, an organophosphorus
insecticide on feeding behaviour and brain acetyl cholinesterase activity in bream, Abramis
brama (L.) and reported that DDVP exposure resulted in the inhibition of brain
acetylcholinesterase activity. Vineet et al. (2008) studied the behaviour and respiratory
dysfunction as an index of malathion toxicity in the fresh water fish, Labeo rohita (Hamilton)
and reported that the carp in toxic media exhibited irregular, erratic and darting, swimming
movements, hyper excitability, and loss of equilibrium and sinking to the bottom which might
be due to inactivation of AChE activity.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
106
In the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate in the present study the suppression in
AChE activity has increased in all the organs with the increase in exposure period. Jaqueline
et al., (2008) also reported a decrease in AChE activity in the brain and muscle of fingerlings
of the common carp (Cyprinus carpio), grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) and bighead
carp (Aristichthys nobilis) on exposure to lethal concentration (LC50) of diafuran.
The organophosphate pesticides inhibit the cholinesterase activity in almost all animal
tissues (O’ Brein, 1969; Goodman et al., 1979). The AChE activity differs from one species to
the other in fishes. Chuiko (1999) worked on comparative study of acetylcholinesterase and
butyrylcholinesterase in brain and serum of several fresh water fish by DDVP, an
organophosphorus pesticide-reported that brain acetylcholinesterase activity varied among
fish species approximately 10-fold, ranging from 192.6 to 1353.2µ mol/g/h respectively in
perch and white fish. All cyprinids had higher brain acetycholinesterase activity than those
other fish families. Serum acetycholinesterase activity was 100-fold lower than in brain.
Duration of exposure, type of organophosphate, as well as species of fish has an effect on the
extent of AChE activity.
It was well documented that highly purified phosphorothionates (P=S form) are not
direct inhibitors of cholinesterase but when they are metabolized to their corresponding
oxygen analogues (P=O form) become highly potent inhibitors (March et al., 1956 and
Murphy et al., 1968). The susceptibility of animals to poisoining by organophosphorus
insecticides will be dependent upon the rate at which the analogues are made available to
inhibit cholinesterase at critical site in nerve tissue or organs innervated by cholinergic nerves.
In the fish exposed to chronic toxicity of phorate in the present investigation, relative
to controls the levels of AChE activity elevated at day 1 in all the organs. The levels of of
AChE activity gradually decreased at day 7 and at day 15 followed by an increase at day 30 in
all the organs of the fish. Similar results obtained by Sailabala (1988) in major carp, Catla
catla on exposure to an organophosphate insecticide malathion and Prasada Charyulu (1993)
in common carp cyprinus carpio on exposure to Phosphamidan with regarding to AChE
activity.
The AChE activity suddenly activated during 24 hours of exposure. The enhancement
in the activity of AChE might be due to the pesticide stress. But at later periods of exposure
like 7th
day and 15th
day the AChE activity was reduced, with maximal reduction at 15th
day
exposure period of phorate. The inhibition of AChE activity will result in the accumulation of
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
107
acetylcholine (Ach) at different periods of exposure. Heath (1961) and O’ Brein (1967)
reported that OP insecticides react with AChE to form phosphorylated enzyme. This
phosphorylated enzyme inhibits AChE activity for several weeks (Coppage and Duke, 1971)
and such inhibition is observed here in the present study.
However at day 30 the inhibitory activity was increased and came nearer to normal
level. Thus, the fish Cyprinus carpio fairly recovered from the inhibitory activity in the tissues
of fish. The concomitant recovery in AChE activity at day 30 might be due to active
metabolism of phorate which is being removed from the site of action and thus enabling the
enzyme to resume unhindered hydrolysis of Ach. Similar reports were also observed by
Coppage and Duke (1972) in fish brain exposed to malathion.
Maximum decrease in AChE activity in the brain of cyprinus carpio on exposure to
phorate toxicity may indicate disruption in the integratory activity of central nervous system.
The reports of Coppage, (1972) revealed that death occurs in fishes when AChE activity falls
below a critical level and according to Coppage et al., (1975) inhibition of brain AChE to the
level of 70 to 80% is critical to fishes. In the present study this critical situation was observed
in the fish at 4 days of exposure to acute toxicity of phorate. Probably the inhibition of
respiratory centre of the brain, and the inhibitory nature of pesticide may be responsible for
the decrease in this enzyme activity.
The rate of inhibition of AChE activity in the organs of animals exposed to pollutants
can be correlated to the concentration of pollutant and length of exposure (Coppage, 1972). It
was reported that, in general, inhibition of brain AChE activity is directly proportional to the
concentration of the pollutant (Coppage, 1971; Coppage, 1972; Coppage and Duke, 1972;
Macek et al., 1972). In the present study, suppression in AChE activity is more in the organs
of the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate than to chronic toxicity. Further within acute
toxicity, the suppression in the enzyme activity is more at 4 days of exposure than at 1 day and
it may be due to the availability of more pesticide for enzyme inhibition. This ultimately leads
to the suppression in nervous activity, osmo and ion regulatory activity as well as cellular
enzyme metabolic activity.
Thus the results obtained in the present study shows that the pesticide phorate is
interfering with the nervous system of the fish Cyprinus carpio by inhibiting the enzyme
acetylcholinesterase.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
108
Table-9
Acetylcholinesterase activity (µ moles of Ach hydrolysed /mg protein/hr) in different organs
of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic toxicity of
phorate. The values below the mean are percent changes over the respective control.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
109
ORGAN
EXPOSURE PERIOD IN DAYS
ACUTE TOXICITY CHRONIC TOXICITY
CONTROL 1 4 CONTROL 1 7 15 30
GILL
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
328.760c
0.490
168.430b
0.397
-48.76
85.556a
0.490
-73.97
328.760d
0.490
386.775e
0.249
+17.64
265.407c
0.216
-19.27
220.532a
0.353
-32.92
257.221b
0.401
-21.76
LIVER
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
152.083c
0.610
91.468b
0.434
-39.85
46.055a
0.275
-69.71
152.083d
0.610
188.461e
0.296
+23.92
116.206b
0.165
-23.59
88.968a
0.289
-41.50
122.548c
0.194
-19.42
MUSCLE
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
706.148c
0.517
359.803b
0.324
-49.04
118.081a
0.508
-83.27
706.148d
0.517
846.530e
0.415
+19.88
583.560c
0.102
-17.36
513.440a
0.310
-27.29
561.175b
0.050
-20.53
KIDNEY
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
204.950c
0.469
123.750b
0.531
-39.61
68.106a
0.590
-66.76
204.950d
0.469
236.122e
0.328
+15.21
175.929c
0.244
-14.16
133.094a
0.205
-35.06
156.130b
0.247
-23.82
BRAIN
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
1080.418c
1.246
408.850b
0.526
-62.15
117.435a
0.451
-89.13
1080.418d
1.246
1398.060e
0.295
+29.40
807.720b
0.356
-25.24
567.651a
0.279
-47.46
928.403c
0.465
-14.07
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations. Values with different superscripts
with in the column are significantly different from each other at P<0.05 according to Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test (DMR) test.
Figure-8
Acetylcholinesterase activity (µ moles of Ach hydrolysed /mg protein/hr) in different organs
of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic toxicity of
phorate.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
110
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
111
Succinate dehydrogenase (SDH), Malate dehydrogenase (MDH) and Lactateate
dehydrogenase (LDH)
Enzymes are protein catalysts that accelerate the rates of biochemical reactions and
regulate metabolic pathways. The study of the various factors that influence the rate of
enzyme-catalyzed reactions is referred to as enzyme kinetics. Much of the pioneering work on
enzyme kinetics was done in the early 1900's by German biochemists Leonor Michaelis and
Maude L. Menten, who formulated a theory to explain the major events in enzyme catalysis.
The Michaelis-Menten theory assumes that the enzyme (E) and substrate (S) combine
reversibly to form an enzyme-substrate (ES) complex. The ES complex then breaks apart to
form free enzyme and the product (P).
Glycolysis is the metabolic pathway that converts glucose into pyruvate. The free
energy released in this process is used to form the high energy compounds of ATP and
NADH. It occurs, with variations, in nearly all organisms, both aerobic and anaerobic. It
occurs in the cytosol of the cell. The most common type of glycolysis is the Embden-
Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP pathway), which was first discovered by Gustav Embden, Otto
Meyerhof, and Jakub Karol Parnas. The citric acid cycle also known as the tricarboxylic acid
cycle (TCA cycle), is a series of chemical reactions used by all aerobic organisms to generate
energy through the oxidization of acetate derived from carbohydrates, fats and proteins into
carbon dioxide. In eukaryotic cells, the citric acid cycle occurs in the matrix of the
mitochondrion. The components and reactions of the citric acid cycle were established in the
1930s by the Nobel laureates Albert Szent-Gyorgyi and Hans Adolf Krebs.
The mitochondria contain the biochemical machinery for aerobic cellular respiration,
the process by which sugars, fatty acids, and amino acids are broken down to carbon dioxide
and water, with some of their chemical energy captured as adenosine triphosphate (ATP). A
key series of reactions in cell respiration is the Krebs (citric acid) cycle, a complex pathway
involving some enzymes and numerous metabolic intermediates. One of the best studied
enzymes in the Krebs cycle is succinate dehydrogenase (SDH).
Succinate dehydrogenase(SDH), a flevin linked enzyme of TCA cycle , catalyses the
reversible oxidation of succinate to fumerate and serves as a link between electron transport
and oxidative phosphorylation (Singer et al., 1973). It is the only enzyme that participates in
both the citric acid cycle and the electron transport chain. Since the activity of SDH in
mitochondria is greater than the other enzymes of TCA cycle, an insight into the alterations of
this enzyme activity may be taken as index to assess the function of TCA cycle in different
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
112
organs of the fresh water animals (Madanamohan Das and Venkatachari, 1984). SDH is
unique among the Krebs cycle enzymes in that it is tightly bound to the inner mitochondrial
membrane. Any alterations in its activity indicate changes in the structure and function of
mitochondria.
Malate dehydrogenase (MDH) is an enzyme present in the mitochondrial matrix and
cytosol catalyses the inter-conversion of malate-pyruvate as well as oxaloacetate-pyruvate.
MDH is found in all eukaryotic cells as two isozymes, mitochondrial (m-MDH) and
cytoplasmic (soluble, s-MDH). MDH belongs to the NAD-dependent dehydrogenases, which
are one of the largest and best-studied families of nucleotide-binding proteins, over 100
different members have already been identified.
Malate dehydrogenase (MDH) catalyzes the interconversion of L-malate and
oxaloacetate using nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) as a coenzyme. The TCA cycle
is completed when the oxidation of L-Malic acid to oxaloacetic acid is accomplished by the
enzyme malate dehydrogenase. MDH is also involved in gluconeogenesis, the synthesis of
glucose from smaller molecules. Pyruvate in the mitochondria is acted upon by pyruvate
carboxylase to form oxaloacetate, a citric acid cycle intermediate. In order to get the
oxaloacetate out of the mitochondria, malate dehydrogenase reduces it to malate, and it then
traverses the inner mitochondrial membrane. Once in the cytosol, the malate is oxidized back
to oxaloacetate by cytosolic malate dehydrogenase. Finally, phosphoenolpyruvate
carboxykinase converts oxaloacetate to phosphoenolpyruvate.
Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) is an enzyme present in a wide variety of organisms,
including animals. The glycolytic enzymes in the cell breakdown glucose resulting in the
formation of pyruvate. Further oxidation of pyruvate depends on the availability of oxygen. If
the availability of oxygen is less, the anaerobic condition leads to the conversion of pyruvate
to lactate. This reaction is catalysed by the enzyme lactateate dehydrogenase (LDH). It is the
key enzyme located at the vital point between glycolysis and TCA cycle. Because of its
strategic location and its relation to cori cycle, it is likely that any fluctuation in the cellular
environment alters the activity of this enzyme. LDH is considered to be the most important
enzyme of the glycolytic pathway in animals including fishes.
Reports available on the effects of pesticides on different freshwater animals indicating
noticeable changes in the activities of SDH (Bergen, 1971; Koundinya and Ramamurthi,
1978; Siva Prasada Rao and Ramana Rao, 1979; Bhagyalakshmi et al., 1982; Guruprasad Rao
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
113
and Nanda Kumar, 1982; Satya Prasad, 1983; Swami et al., 1983; Sambasiva Rao et al., 1984;
Suneetha, 2012); MDH (Thakore et al., 1981; Kabeer Ahmed et al., 1983; Srinivas, 1993;
Mishra and Shukla, 2003; Suneetha, 2012); LDH (Harold Philip, 1984; Naidu, 1985; Prasad et
al., 1987; Ghosh,1989; Ravinder, 1989, David, 1995, Muralimohan, 2000; Hymavathi, 2001;
Suneetha, 2012); SDH and MDH (Srinivas Moorthy et al., 1986); SDH and LDH (Sastry and
Siddiqui, 1982); MDH and LDH (Tripathi and Shukla, 1990) and SDH, MDH and LDH
(Suneetha, 2012) .
Pesticides alter the mitochondrial structure and decrease the SDH activity in the organs
of many animals (Siva Prasada Rao and Ramana Rao, 1979; Bhagyalakshmi et al., 1982;
Swami et al., 1983). It has been reported that there was an increase in LDH activity
accompanied with the decrease in SDH in the organs of the freshwater animals exposed to
pesticide toxicity (Koundinya and Ramamurthi, 1978; Bhagyalakshmi et al., 1982). Sastry and
Siddiqui (1982) reported increase in LDH activity of liver and brain and decreases in succinic
dehydrogenase (SDH) activity of liver and brain of Channa punctatus exposed to sublethal
concnentrations of sevin.
Mishra and Shukla, (2003) reported that endosulfan treatment reduced the activity of
cytoplasmic malate dehydrogenase (cMDH) and mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase
(mMDH) in the muscle of the fish. Suneetha, (2012) observed a decrease in the SDH and
MDH activities in the brain, gill, kidney, liver and muscle of the freshwater fish Labeo rohita
after exposing to lethal and sublethal concentrations of two pesticides, endosulfan and
fenvalerate for 24 hrs and 15 days.
RESULTS
The data on the activities of succinate dehydrogenase (SDH), malate dehydrogenase
(MDH) and lactateate dehydrogenase (LDH) in the organs such as gills, liver, muscle, kidney
and brain of the fish cyprinus carpio at 1 and 4 days on exposure to acute toxicity of phorate
and 1, 7, 15 and 30 days on exposure to chronic toxicity of phorate, besides controls, are
presented in the Tables 10, 11 and 12. For comparison, the differences obtained in relation to
the controls of each parameter in each organ of the fish at the above said exposure periods in
acute and chronic toxicity study of phorate, were converted as percentages of the
corresponding controls and those percent values are also presented in the same tables and was
plotted a graph of percent changes against exposure periods in figures 9, 10 and 11.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
114
Activity of Succinate dehydrogenase
From the data presented in the Table-10 and Figure-9 relative to controls, the activity
of SDH in all the organs of the fish exposed to phorate decreased at 1 and 4 days of exposure
in acute toxicity in the order of 1>4 and the differences in the activity between controls and
experimental were also found to be statistically significant (P<0.05). The decrease was more
at day 4 than at day 1 in all the organs of the fish. Suppression of this enzyme progressed from
day 1 to day 4 in all the organs of the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate. In the fish
exposed to chronic toxicity of phorate, in the activity of SDH from day 1 to day 7 there was
increase in the decrement but from day 7 to day 30 it was regressed in all the organs of the
fish in the order of 1>7<15<30.
Activity of Malate dehydrogenase
From the data presented in the Table-11 and Figure-10 relative to controls, the activity
of MDH in all the organs of the fish exposed to phorate decreased at 1 and 4 days of exposure
in acute toxicity in the order of 1>4 and the differences in the activity between controls and
experimental were also found to be statistically significant (P<0.05). The decrease was more
at day 4 than at day 1 in all the organs of the fish. Suppression of this enzyme progressed from
day 1 to day 4 in all the organs of the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate. In the fish
exposed to chronic toxicity of phorate, in the activity of SDH from day 1 to day 7 there was
increase in the decrement but from day 7 to day 30 it was regressed in all the organs of the
fish in the order of 1>7<15<30. All the values were found to be statistically significant
(P<0.05).
Activity of Lactate dehydrogenase
From the data presented in the Table-12 and Figure-11 relative to controls, an increase
was observed in the activity of LDH in all the organs of the fish exposed to both acute and
chronic toxicity of phorate. The LDH activity in the liver of both controls and experimental
fish is higher than in the other organs of the fish. The percent increase was also more in liver
when compared to the other organs of the fish exposed to both acute and chronic toxicity of
phorate. In the fish exposed to acute toxicity of phorate, in the activity of LDH, the increase
was more at day 4 than at day 1 in all the organs of the fish in the order of 1<4. In the fish
exposed to chronic toxicity of phorate, there was a gradual increase in the activity of LDH
from day 1 to day 7 but from the day 15 to day 30 a decrease in the increment was observed in
the order of 1<7>15>30.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
115
DISCUSSION
The edible freshwater fishes constitute one of the major sources of nutritious food for
humans. Fish are largely being used for the assessment of the quality of aquatic environment
and as such can serve as bioindicators of environmental pollution. Among the aquatic species,
the fish are the major targets of toxicants contamination.
Analysis of biochemical parameters could help to identify the level of toxicity to target
organs as well as the general health status of animals. It may also provide an early warning
signal in stressed organism (Folmar, 1993). These parameters are the indicators of the
response of the animal to the environmental effects and can also serve as markers for toxicant
exposure and effect in fish. The biochemical parameters in fish are valid for
physiopathological evaluation and sensitive for detecting potential adverse effects and
relatively early events of pollutant, like pesticide damage (Almeida et al., 2002; Matos et al.,
2007; Osman et al., 2010).
Enzymes are biochemical macromolecules which control metabolic processes of
organisms, thus a slight variation in enzyme activity would affect the organisms (Roy, 2002).
Enzymatic activities also provide quick screening methods for assessing the health of fish and
can be used to determine the incipient lethal concentration of a toxicant. Therefore, by
estimating enzyme activities in an organism, it can be easily identify a disturbance in
metabolism. The studies related to the activities of enzymes in the presence of pollutants like
pesticides in water became a routine practice in clinical medicine to diagnose certain diseases
and the extent of tissue or organ damage (Racicool et al., 1975).
Stress is an energy demanding process and the animal mobilizes energy substrates to
cope with stress metabolically (Vijayan et al., 1997). Changes in the activities of the enzymes
like, succinate dehydrogenase, malate dehydrogenase and lactate dehydrogenase are sensitive
to environmental pollutants like pesticides (Devi, 2003).
In the present investigation the oxidative enzymes like succinate dehydrogenase
(SDH) and malate dehydrogenase (MDH) showed a reduction and elevation in non-oxidative
enzyme like LDH in their activity in all the osmoregulatory (gill and kidney) and non-
osmoregulatory (liver, muscle and brain) tissues of the fish Cyprinus carpio, which indicates
the suppression of oxidative metabolism in the fish exposed to acute and chronic toxicity of
phorate (Akhilender Naidu et al., 1984). The decrease in the MDH activity is in line with the
decreased SDH activity indicating suppressed oxidative metabolism. As SDH and MDH are
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
116
the oxidative enzymes involved in Kreb’s cycle, any disturbance in these enzyme activities
will affect the Kreb’s cycle. Since this cycle represents a central oxidative pathway for
carbohydrates, fats and amino acids, if there is any disturbance in this cycle the whole
metabolism is likely to be affected
In support of present investigation, several reports are available on a decrease in the
activity of SDH and MDH and increase in the LDH activity after exposingto different
pesticides. It has been reported earlier by several investigators that pesticides alter the
mitochondrial structure and decrease the SDH activity in the organs of many animals (Bergen,
1971; Koundinya and Ramamurthi, 1978; Siva Prasada Rao and Ramana Rao, 1979;
Bhagyalakshmi et al., 1982; Guruprasad Rao and Nanda Kumar, 1982; Swami et al., 1983).
Suneetha, (2012) observed a decrease in the SDH activity in the brain, gill, kidney,
liver and muscle of the freshwater fish Labeo rohita after exposing to lethal and sublethal
concentrations of two pesticides, endosulfan and fenvalerate for 24 hrs and 15 days. Khemani
et al., (1989) reported a significant inhibition in the SDH activity in the tissues of rat treated
with dieldrin and suggested that one of the reasons for the observed inhibition of SDH activity
could be diminished availability of the soluble cofactors within the subcellular structures.
Several reports are available on the decrease in SDH activity with the increase in LDH
activity accompanied in the organs of the freshwater animals exposed to pesticide toxicity
(Koundinya and Ramamurthi, 1978; Siva Prasad Rao and Ramana Rao, 1979; Dayananda
Reddy, 1980; Bhagyalakshmi et al., 1982).
Sastry and Siddiqui (1982) reported increases in LDH activity of liver and brain and
decreases in succinic dehydrogenase (SDH) activity of liver and brain of Channa punctatus
exposed to sublethal concnentrations of sevin. Ghosh (1987) reported that there was an
increased activity of lactic dehydrogenase (LDH) in brain, liver and muscle and decreased
activity in kidney and intestine of Clarias batrachus when exposed to sublethal concentrations
of Tara 909, Suquin and Croton 36.
Decrease in the MDH activity was also reported by several investigators. A decrease in
the activity of MDH was observed by Thakore et al., (1981) in the liver of BHC treated mice.
The MDH activity in the tissues of the fish Tilapia mossambica was decreased on exposure to
malathion (Kabeer Ahmed et al., 1983). Srinivas, (1993) studied the impact of endosulfan on
carbohydrate metabolism in the fresh water fish Clarias batrachus and reported decreased
MDH activity. Mishra and Shukla, (2003) studied endosulfan effects on muscle malate
dehydrogenase of the freshwater catfish Clarias batrachus and reported that endosulfan
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
117
treatment reduced the activity of cytoplasmic malate dehydrogenase (cMDH) and
mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase (mMDH) in the muscle of the fish. Suneetha, (2012) also
observed a decrease in the MDH activity in the brain, gill, kidney, liver and muscle of the
freshwater fish Labeo rohita after exposing to lethal and sublethal concentrations of two
pesticides, endosulfan and fenvalerate for 24 hrs and 15 days.
It is known that SDH and MDH acts as indictors of aerobic respiration, their inhibition
and with subsequent elevation of LDH indicates the prevalence of anaerobic conditions
imposed by the stress factor of phorate toxicity. As SDH and MDH are the key enzymes in
TCA cycle, it is logical to assume that with the inhibition of SDH and MDH and elevation of
LDH activities, the metabolic pathway might have turned to anaerobic to meet the increased
energy demands during the phorate exerted toxic stress.
The decrease in SDH and MDH activity also indicates the impairment of oxidative
metabolism in the mitochondria as a consequence of hypoxic conditions under pesticide
exposure, most probably by disrupting the oxygen binding capacity of the respiratory pigment.
The decrease in SDH and MDH activity may be due to the disorganization of mitochondria
affecting enzymes of TCA cycle. The decrease in these enzyme activities might be probably
due to mitochondrial damage and decreased state of respiration (Shomessubra Bag et al.,
1999). The fall in these enzyme activities might be related to the close contact of pesticide
with cell organelle and their subsequent disorganization accompanied by increased
histopathology of gill area and shifting of the aerobic to anaerobic metabolism as reported in
other teleosts (Ramalingam and Reddy, 1982; Shaffi, 1995). Any alteration in the respiratory
area decrease the oxygen absorption capacity of the gill due to its close contact with polluted
water (Hughes and Morgan, 1973; Singh and Sing, 1979). It may also be one of the reasons
for the diminished activity of SDH and MDH.
Nagarathnamma, (1982) and Srinivasulu Reddy and Ramana Rao, (1986) reported that
disruption in gill lamellae caused by the organophosphate pesticides adversely affected the
absorption of oxygen from the surrounding medium in fish and prawn respectively. Decrease
in SDH and MDH activity may be due to damage in the mitochondrial structural integrity in
the organs of the fish (Bergen, 1971; Satya Prasad, 1983). The decrease in the activity of
MDH may suggests the lower level of functioning of TCA cycle due to inadequate supply of
substrate or decreased oxygen uptake at the tissue level during phorate toxicity stress. Another
probable reason for the low level of MDH activity may be the reduced SDH activity which
inturn lowers fumarate-malate conversions.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
118
The pesticide induced suppression in the activity of SDH and MDH in all the organs of
the fish can be correlated to the binding of pesticide to the active sites of the oxidative
enzymes and/or impairment in mitochondrial organization (Viarengo, 1985; Hodson, 1988). In
the present study such impairment might have gradually increased with the increase in the
period of exposure in chronic toxicity study upto day 7 due to slow accumulation of pesticide
in the tissues of the fish. Decrease in the activity of SDH and MDH stimulated the fish to
switch over from aerobic to anaerobic glycolysis. Hence an increase in the activity of LDH
was observed. This indicates the fish might have relied more on anaerobic glycolysis in
meeting the energy requirements, as the energetically more efficient oxidative metabolism is
suppressed.
The decreased activities of SDH and MDH observed in the tissues of the fish may be
attributed to the hypoxic conditions or to the inadequate substrate availability or to the
decreased oxygen absorption potential of the tissues. Thus fish have relied more on anaerobic
glycolysis in meeting the increased energy demands during the phorate exerted toxic stress,
thus the elevation of LDH activity was in the tissues of the fish.
May be due to the domination of detoxification over accumulation, the fish slowly
regained the oxidative metabolic activity by activating the SDH and MDH from day 15 to day
30. The suppression in the activities of SDH and MDH and the elevation in the LDH activity
was decreased slowly at day 15 and day 30 in the tissues of the fish on exposure to chronic
toxicity of phorate. The fish might have relied both on energetically more efficient oxidative
metabolism and less efficient anaerobic glycolysis during this period of exposure as more
energy is required either for detoxification or for the degradation of pesticide. So on prolonged
exposure to chronic toxicity of phorate the fish could develop resistance to phorate and could
adapt slowly to the new enivironment (Vijayaram et al., 1989).
More suppression in SDH and MDH activities and subsequent elevation in the activity
of LDH in the liver might be greater interference of pesticide with the activities of oxidative
metabolic enzymes in liver as the liver is important centre for metabolism, inter conversion
and detoxification as it plays a vital role during toxic stress in fishes. There is the possibility
of greater interference of the pesticide in the gill with the activities of oxidative metabolic
enzymes. This is the reason for the greater suppression in SDH and MDH activities with the
elevation in the activity of LDH in the gill. Further, the suppression of SDH and MDH
activities and elevation of LDH activity identified in the muscle, as glycolysis and glycolytic
enzymes are dominant in muscle. The decrease in oxidative metabolism with the suppression
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
119
of SDH and MDH activities and accumulation of lactate with the elevation of LDH activity in
the muscle of the fish exposed to toxic stress could be one of the reasons for inactive state of
the fish. Stimulation of oxidative metabolism and glycolytic activity in this organ of fish on
prolonged exposure to phorate toxicity indicates the elevation in the muscular activity of this
organ, by which the fish is made possible to adapt to the toxic stress. Kidney is being one of
the important organs of the osmoregulation, suppression of oxidative metabolism leads to a
great set-back in its osmo and ion regulatory function. The suppression of SDH and MDH
activities in the kidney indicates less availability of energy to perform its energetically
expensive oxidative metabolism.
On prolonged exposure the decrease in the suppression of SDH and MDH activities
and also in the elevation of LDH activity in the fish exposed to phorate toxicity might be due
to the gradual restoration of its normal metabolic activities, gradual recovery of the oxidative
metabolic activity, the fish gained tolerance to the sublethal stress of phorate and the increase
in oxidative and glycolytic cycles. This indicate the active role of the fish in controlling and
coordinating the metabolic disturbances occurred during phorate toxic stress on prolonged
exposure. It could be due to the activation of detoxification, degradation and pesticide
eliminating pathways.
Thus on overall assessment the results of this study show that the fish Cyprinus carpio
were stressed after being exposed to acute and chronic toxicity of phorate. The pesticide
phorate altered the activity of the carbohydrate metabolic enzymes significantly thus result in
the instable physiological state of the fish. Therefore, lethal and sublethal concentrations of
phorate have some deleterious effect on the basic activities of enzymes of carbohydrate
metabolism in the gill, liver, muscle, kidney and brain of the experimental fish, Cyprinus
carpio. On comparison, in the activities of enzymes, the suppression in SDH and MDH
activities and the elevation in LDH activity is more in the tissues of the fish exposed to acute
toxicity of phorate due to more pesticidal stress.
It may be concluded that the phorate induced alterations in the activities of
carbohydrate metabolic enzymes caused significant metabolic effect on the physiological
consequences. The physiological conditions are directly related to the bioavailability of the
pesticide. The alteration in these enzyme activities can be taken as good markers or indicators
of the pesticide induced stress. These biochemical parameters offer a rapid and sensitive
means of monitoring towards the impact of pesticides on aquatic biota and ultimately whole of
the ecosystem.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
120
Table-10
Succinate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate. The values below the mean are percent changes over the respective
control.
ORGAN
EXPOSURE PERIOD IN DAYS
ACUTE TOXICITY CHRONIC TOXICITY
CONTROL 1 4 CONTROL 1 7 15 30
GILL
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.174c
0.0074
0.124b
0.0091
-28.27
0.083a
0.0044
-51.91
0.174d
0.0074
0.096a
0.0013
-44.82
0.092a
0.0016
-47.12
0.122b
0.0018
-29.88
0.155c
0.0029
-10.80
LIVER
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.579c
0.0065
0.295b
0.0034
-48.97
0.173a
0.0030
-70.00
0.579e
0.0065
0.248b
0.0025
-57.16
0.216a
0.0013
-62.57
0.312c
0.0021
-46.12
0.403d
0.0047
-30.31
MUSCLE
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.152c
0.0047
0.095b
0.0026
-37.38
0.051a
0.0037
-66.36
0.152e
0.0047
0.098c
0.0016
-35.67
0.073a
0.0013
-51.53
0.091b
0.0017
-40.21
0.116d
0.0021
-23.78
KIDNEY
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.146c
0.0037
0.120b
0.0051
-17.67
0.073a
0.0032
-49.59
0.146e
0.0037
0.101b
0.0034
-30.82
0.094a
0.0015
-35.47
0.107c
0.0023
-26.57
0.127d
0.0017
-12.86
BRAIN
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.189c
0.0034
0.154b
0.0029
-18.60
0.115a
0.0038
-38.79
0.189e
0.0034
0.137c
0.0013
-27.48
0.108a
0.0011
-42.70
0.128b
0.0021
-31.84
0.152d
0.0024
-19.66
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations. Values with different superscripts
with in the column are significantly different from each other at P<0.05 according to Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test (DMR) test.
Table-11
Malate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate. The values below the mean are percent changes over the respective
control.
ORGAN
EXPOSURE PERIOD IN DAYS
ACUTE TOXICITY CHRONIC TOXICITY
CONTROL 1 4 CONTROL 1 7 15 30
GILL
Mean
S.D. ±
0.253c
0.0029
0.178b
0.0031
0.157a
0.0032
0.253e
0.0029
0.205c
0.0013
0.181a
0.0021
0.198b
0.0016
0.225d
0.0037
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
121
% change -29.26 -37.78 -18.65 -28.18 -21.70 -10.88
LIVER
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.373c
0.0036
0.185b
0.0043
-49.76
0.145a
0.0050
-61.01
0.373e
0.0036
0.281c
0.0021
-18.03
0.188a
0.0018
-49.42
0.277b
0.0025
-25.56
0.315d
0.0043
-15.54
MUSCLE
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.128c
0.0041
0.113b
0.0025
-11.70
0.082a
0.0042
-35.85
0.128e
0.0041
0.114c
0.0029
-11.07
0.087a
0.0013
-31.51
0.095b
0.0018
-25.27
0.116d
0.036
-9.51
KIDNEY
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.165c
0.0051
0.128b
0.0037
-22.53
0.113a
0.0031
-31.50
0.165d
0.0051
0.133b
0.0015
-19.15
0.121a
0.0013
-26.70
0.148c
0.0021
-10.45
0.150c
0.0017
-9.06
BRAIN
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.193c
0.0032
0.140b
0.0053
-27.41
0.132a
0.0043
-31.29
0.193e
0.0032
0.152b
0.0016
-21.36
0.148a
0.0018
-23.27
0.162c
0.0036
-16.19
0.178d
0.0021
-7.81
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations. Values with different superscripts
with in the column are significantly different from each other at P<0.05 according to Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test (DMR) test.
Table-12
Lactate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate. The values below the mean are percent changes over the respective
control.
ORGAN
EXPOSURE PERIOD IN DAYS
ACUTE TOXICITY CHRONIC TOXICITY
CONTROL 1 4 CONTROL 1 7 15 30
GILL
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.183a
0.0026
0.234b
0.0069
+28.15
0.308c
0.0028
+68.61
0.183a
0.0026
0.219c
0.0029
+20.01
0.244e
0.0025
+33.54
0.229d
0.0034
+25.45
0.206b
0.0017
+12.99
LIVER
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.348a
0.0344
0.472b
0.0125
+35.91
0.604c
0.0042
+73.65
0.348a
0.0344
0.477d
0.0030
+37.20
0.521e
0.0026
+49.76
0.446c
0.0026
+28.40
0.424b
0.0017
21.95
MUSCLE
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.162a
0.0039
0.233b
0.0032
+44.05
0.263c
0.0062
+62.37
0.162a
0.0039
0.203c
0.0034
+25.44
0.223e
0.0028
+38.10
0.212d
0.0021
+31.19
0.193b
0.0020
+19.32
KIDNEY
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.121a
0.0027
0.153b
0.0060
+26.54
0.167c
0.0034
+38.55
0.121a
0.0027
0.140c
0.0021
+16.08
0.153e
0.0023
+26.81
0.146d
0.0017
+21.37
0.134b
0.0018
+11.55
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
122
BRAIN
Mean
S.D. ±
% change
0.212a
0.0063
0.277b
0.0079
+30.89
0.304c
0.0035
+43.54
0.212a
0.0063
0.250c
0.0028
+18.19
0.277e
0.0030
+30.94
0.259d
0.0016
+22.48
0.234b
0.0020
+10.84
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations. Values with different superscripts
with in the column are significantly different from each other at P<0.05 according to Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test (DMR) test.
Figure-9
Succinate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate.
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations.
Figure-10
Malate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
123
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations.
Figure-11
Lactate dehydrogenase activity (µ moles of formazone formed/mg protein/hr) in different
organs of the fish Cyprinus carpio at different periods of exposure to acute and chronic
toxicity of phorate.
CHAPTER - V ENZYMATIC ACTIVITIES
124
All the values are mean ± SD of six individual observations.