chapter 1 introduction 1.1 depression...
TRANSCRIPT
1
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 DEPRESSION – AYURVEDA
Vishada is one of the Vatananatmaja Vikaras and it is further said that Vishada is
the main factor that increases the range of all the diseases“Vishado
Rogavardhanaanaam Shreshthah”[1]. Dalhana commented “Asiddhi Bhayat
Vividheshu Karyasu Sado Apravrutihi” i.e a condition originated from apprehension
of failure, resulting in incapability of mind and body to function properly with
significant reduction in activity. Symptomatic representation of the state of Vishada
is explained in Shrimad Bhagvad Geeta. Depression is a state of low mood and
aversion to activity that can affect a person’s thoughts, behaviour, feelings and
physical well-being. It may include feeling of sadness, anxiety, emptiness,
hopelessness, worthlessness, guilty, irritability or restlessness [2]. The symptoms of
Vishada which are found in various references in Indian science when compared to
depression almost appear similar, so we can correlate Vishada with depression.
According to contemporary science depression is a serious mental health concern that
will touch most people‘s life directly or indirectly.
Charaka Samhita mentions “Vishada” as one of the Nanatmaja Vata Vikara and
it is further said that, Vishada is the main factor that increases the range of all the
diseases. Sushruta has mentioned it under the Mano Vikaras. Further he mentioned
that Vishada is common among Tamasika Manasa Prakruti.Whereas Vagbhata has
stated that person with predominant Tamasa Guna are more prone to suffer from
Vishada commenting on Anumanagamya Bhavas in Charaka Samhita says “Bhayam
Vishadena ” i.e. understanding the feeling of fear in a person by seeing his depressed
state or behaviour [3].
2
1.2 DEPRESSION – AN OVERVIEW
Depression, sometimes referred as unipolar depression, is a heterogeneous
syndrome rather than a single disease and has been characterized as a collection of
“physiological, neuroendocrine, behavioural and psychological symptoms” [4]. It is
a common mental disorder characterized by sadness, loss of interest in activities and
by decreased energy and is differentiated from normal mood changes that are part of
life by the extent of its severity, the symptoms and the duration of the disorder.
Moreover, depression often comes with symptoms of anxiety. These problems can
become chronic or recurrent and lead to substantial impairments in an individual’s
ability to take care of his or her everyday responsibilities. [5]. Affected individuals
differ remarkably regarding the profile of clinical features, severity and course of
illness as well as their response to treatment and reintegration efforts.
Depression is a group of brain disorders with varied origins, complex genetics
and obscure neurobiology. It is a chronic and potentially debilitating form of
psychiartric disorders. Any form of stressful life event is considered as the very initial
sign of depression, thereby depression is often thought as stress related disorder [6].
Depressive illness can cause loss of productivity, enjoyment and intimacy of
individual. [7].
Majority of depressed patients have sleep disturbances, including reduced amount
of slow wave sleep (SWS), increased rapid eye movement (REM) sleep amount and
shortened REM sleep latency [8]. Although depression is a very different
phenomenon, it also shares many connections with sleep and they both influenced by
biological and environmental factors. Each phenomenon can also influence the other,
such as the sleep symptoms listed by the DSM-V criteria under depression. DSM- V
criteria plays great importance in diagnosis of depression.
1.3 EPIDEMIOLOGY
According to the World Health Organization (WHO) depression affects 121
million people worldwide. It is one of the top 10 causes of morbidity and mortality.
The high prevalence of suicide in depressed patients (up to 15%) coupled with
complications arising from stress and its effects on the cardiovascular system have
suggested that it will be the second leading cause of death by the year 2020 [9]. It
would fourth rank among all the medical illnesses in terms of its disabling impact on
3
the world population. Depression can lead to suicide and is responsible for 850,000
deaths every year 7.15% of the population of most developed countries suffers with
depression. 80% of depressed people are not currently having any treatment. The
prevalence of depression is reported as 7.5 percent in Australia, 8 percent in Canada
and 5.4-8.9 percent in the United States [10, 11]. In India prevalence of all psychiatric
disorder is 65.4 per 1000 population out of which, total 51% i.e. 31.2 per 1000
population is affected by depressive illness [12].
Depression is common in people in their 20s, 30s and 40s although depression
can occur at any age. People who were born in the later part of the 20th century
seemed to have higher rates of depression and suicide than those of the previous
generation, in part, because of high substance abuse and the rising demands in the
standards of living. At least one in ten outpatients have depression but most of the
cases are unrecognized or inappropriately treated. Every year, 5.8% males and 9.5%
females experience episodes of depression worldwide. This imposes a large
economic burden on the society, it decreases the productivity and the functional
decline and it increases the mortality [13].
The one-year prevalence rate is about 5% and recurrence rates up to 85% have
been reported. Epidemiological studies suggest that, patients with lifetime history of
depression have greater risk of developing cardiac problems and these are not merely
the effects of associated life style and substance use co-morbidity [14, 15].
1.4 ETIOLOGY
Depression has multifactorial aetiology arising from environmental,
psychological, genetic and biological factors. As outlined below in Fig. 1, research
over the past decade has clarified that depression is associated with neurotransmitter
imbalances, Hypothalamic- Pituitary- Adrenal (HPA) axis disturbances, dysregulated
inflammatory pathways, increased oxidative and nitrosative damage,
neuroprogression and mitochondrial disturbances [16].
4
Figure 1.1 Multiple pathways associated with Depression
1.4.1 Neurotransmitters in depression
The main focus of neurotransmitter research has been driven by the ‘monoamine
hypothesis’ of depression, which states that a deficit of monoamine neurotransmitters;
mainly serotonin, norepinephrine and dopamine, underlies depression [17].
1.4.1.1 Serotonin
Several studies have demonstrated that, serotonergic dysfunction plays the major
role in the pathogenesis of depression. Tryptophan, a precursor of serotonin, was found
to be low in depressed patients and tryptophan depletion has been known to cause
relapse in patients with a history of depression. Genetic variants of tryptophan
hydroxylase, a rate-limiting enzyme in the synthesis of serotonin, were also found to
be associated with suicidal behaviour [18, 19, 20]. Furthermore, previous studies
focusing on serotonin metabolism have suggested that metabolism decreased in
depressed patients when a low level of 5-Hydroxy indoleacetic acid (5-HIAA), the
major metabolite of serotonin, was found in the cerebrospinal fluid. Serotonin receptors
have also been found to relate to depression. Positron emission tomography (PET) has
demonstrated the reduction of 5-HT1A receptor binding in patients with depression,
both pre-synaptically in the raphe nuclei and post- synaptically in several cortical
5
regions [21, 22]. Moreover, some researches have shown that, long-term antidepressant
treatment leads to the down regulation of the 5-HT2A receptor and up regulation of the
5-HT1A receptor. In terms of the serotonin transporter (5- HTT), single photon
emission computed tomography (SPECT) studies found reduced serotonin transporter
binding sites in depressed patients [23, 24]. This decreased reuptake of serotonin is
believed to be a compensatory mechanism to counteract transmission deficits in some
serotonergic systems. In addition, gene-environment interaction studies have suggested
that, subjects exposed to environmental stress are more likely to develop depression if
they have at least one allele of a ‘low-efficiency’ version of the serotonin transporter
[25].
1.4.1.2 Norepinephrine
Norepinephrine is also believed to play a major role in the pathophysiology of
depression. Previous research has demonstrated a correlation between the down
regulation of postsynaptic β-adrenergic receptors and clinical antidepressant responses,
as well as the clinical effectiveness of antidepressants with noradrenergic effects (e.g.
Desipramine, Venlafaxine, Duloxetine). Moreover, an increased density of α 2 -
adrenergic receptors has also been reported in depressed patients and suicide victims.
This up regulation may be due to a relative deficiency of norepinephrine in the synaptic
clefts. Finally, the reduction of urinary excretion of the metabolite 3-Methoxy-4-
hydroxy phenyl glycol (MHPG) was found in patients with depression. Although some
subgroups of patients manifested elevated circulating levels of norepinephrine and its
metabolites [26, 27].
1.4.1.3 Dopamine
Previous studies have suggested that, dopamine activity may be reduced in
depression. Medications and diseases that reduces dopamine concentrations (e.g.
reserpine, parkinsonism) were found to be associated with depressive symptoms. In
contrast, drugs that increase dopamine concentrations (e.g. tyrosine, amphetamine,
bupropion) have shown antidepressant efficacy [28].
1.4.2 HPA Disturbances
1.4.2.1 Physiology of stress response and HPA axis
In response to stressful stimuli the periventricular hypothalamus secretes
corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) into the hypothalamo–pituitary portal
6
circulation, which triggers the release of adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), which
then stimulates the release of cortisol from the adrenal cortex. CRH initiates events that
release glucocorticoids from the adrenal cortex and as a result of the great number of
effects exerted by glucocorticoids, several mechanisms have evolved to control HPA
axis activation and integrate the stress response. Physiological and behavioural
components of the stress response are multiple and complex and as such may be
mediated by several mechanisms [29, 30, 31].
1.4.2.2 Depression and HPA axis activity
Over activity of the HPA axis within individuals with major depressive disorder
has been documented since late 1950s. The past few decades have brought about
numerous indications of impaired activity of various components of the HPA axis and
are evidenced by the following: elevated total and free cortisol concentrations in urine,
plasma and cerebrospinal fluid. Both elevated levels and blunted awakening cortisol;
elevated concentration of cerebrospinal fluid. Increased activity of the HPA axis may
be partly related to reduce feedback inhibition by endogenous glucocorticoids that
serve as potent negative regulators of HPA axis activity, in particular the synthesis and
release of CRH in the paraventricular nucleus [32]. Evidence from dexamethasone
suppression tests (DST and DEX/CRH) suggests that glucocorticoid-mediated
feedback inhibition is impaired in depression in that HPA axis activity is not suppressed
by pharmacological stimulation of glucocorticoid receptors (GR). It has been suggested
that, because individuals with depression exhibit impaired HPA axis negative feedback
through elevated levels of cortisol, that the number or function of GR are reduced in
patients with antidepressant treatment increases glucocorticoid signal in the brain by
increasing GR expression and function, eventually leading to increased negative
feedback on the HPA axis [33].
1.4.2.3 Depressive symptom remission and HPA axis
It has been proposed that, hypercortisolemia in depression should be considered
a state marker and not a trait marker as it has been shown to normalize in patients with
symptom improvement [34]. Evidence suggests that, compared to individuals with
residual symptoms, those who remit have a more pronounced normalization of an
initially dysregulated HPA axis, although inconsistencies have been found [35]. A
potential link between alterations of the limbic-HPA system and the serotonergic
hypothesis of depression has been suggested and treatments targeting these
7
components may be beneficial. Investigations have found that, improved HPA system
regulation as measured by DEX/CRH test, was associated with treatment response after
5 weeks and a higher remission rate at the end of hospitalization. Change in HPA
system regulation as assessed by repeated DEX/CRH tests may be a potential
biomarker that predicts relapse and clinical outcome [36].
1.4.3 Oxidative & Nitrosative stress
Decreased antioxidant status and elevated oxidative and nitrosative stress are
found in patients with depression [37]. This is evidenced by reduced plasma
concentrations of important antioxidants such as vitamin C, vitamin E, and coenzyme
Q10 and by reduced antioxidant enzyme activity such as glutathione peroxidase. These
deficiencies in antioxidant defence impair protection against reactive oxygen species
(ROS), leading to damage to fatty acids, proteins and DNA. Depression is also
associated with increased levels of lipid peroxidation, comprising elevations in
malondialdehyde and increased oxidative damage to DNA, characterised by increased
levels of 8-Hydroxy-2-deoxyguanosine. Increased plasma levels of peroxides and
xanthine oxidase also associated with depression. The efficacy of antioxidant therapies
for depression is unknown, although N-acetylcysteine, a powerful antioxidant, was
found to be useful for depressive episodes in bipolar disorder and zinc, which serves
as a strong antioxidant, also has antidepressant activity [38, 39].
1.4.4 Neuroprogression
Neurogenesis and neuronal plasticity are compromised in depression, with
subsequent neuro degeneration [40]. This results in stress-induced alterations to the
number and shape of neurons and glia in brain regions of depressed patients and
decreased proliferation of neural stem cells. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF)
is the most abundant and widely distributed neurotrophin in the central nervous system,
involved in neuronal survival, growth and proliferation. BDNF levels are low in people
with depression. However, BDNF levels increase with chronic administration of
several classes of antidepressants, including monoamine oxidase inhibitors, SSRIs,
tricyclic agents and SNRIs. Early life and chronic stress, which is often typical in
patients with depression, also has detrimental effects on BDNF [41, 42].
8
1.4.5 Mitochondrial disturbances
Mitochondria are intracellular organelles that generate most of the cell‘s supply
of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and are also involved in a range of other processes
such as signalling, cellular differentiation, cell death and the control of the cell cycle
and cell growth. High concentrations of mitochondria are found in the brain which
increases its vulnerability to reduction in aerobic metabolism [43]. Depression is
associated with mitochondrial dysfunction or disease with evidence of deletions of
mitochondrial DNA and lower activities of respiratory chain enzymes and ATP
production. Depressed patients presenting with somatic complaints also have low ATP
production rates in biopsied muscles. In addition, rates of depression increased in
patients with mitochondrial disorders [44].
1.4.6 Immuno-inflammation
Increased inflammation in depression has been confirmed in three recent meta
analyses. Elevated levels of C-reactive protein (CRP), interleukin-1 (IL-1) and
interleukin-6 (IL-6) were reported in a meta-analysis on depression in clinic and
community samples, levels of tumour necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) and IL-6 were
significantly higher in depressed patients than control and blood levels of soluble
interleukin-2 receptors, TNF-α and IL-6 were higher in a meta-analysis on patients with
depressive disorder than controls [45]. Depression is also characterised by a Th-1-like
cell-mediated response, with evidence of increased production of interferon-γ (IFN-γ),
increased IFN-γ/IL-4 ratios and increased neopterin levels. In addition, anti-depressant
medications have anti-inflammatory effects. An elevated immuno-inflammatory
response in depression is further supported by investigations into kynurenine pathway
metabolites or TRYCATS (tryptophan catabolites along the IDO pathway) [46].
TRYCATS are produced by the breakdown of tryptophan, involving the enzyme
indoleamine- 2, 3-dioxygenase (IDO). IDO is expressed in multiple cell types including
macrophages, dendritic cells, astrocytes and microglia and is strongly activated by the
pro-inflammatory cytokine IFN-γ and to a lesser extent TNF-α, IL-1 and IL-6. These
TRYCATS have both neurotoxic and neuro- protective qualities. Preliminary research
has demonstrated a relationship between depression and low levels of the
neuroprotective TRYCAT, kynurenicacid (KYNA) and high levels of the excitotoxic
TRYCAT, quinolinicacid (QUIN) [47].
9
1.5 NEUROPHARMACOLOGY OF SLEEP
1.5.1 Definition of sleep
Sleep is not one homogeneous state, but rather a progression through various
states with extremely unique characteristics. On the basis of behavioural and
physiological criteria divided into rapid eye movement sleep (REM) and non-rapid
eye movement sleep, (NREMS). REM sleep derives its name from the frequent bursts
of eye movement activity that occur. It is also referred to as paradoxical sleep because
the electroencephalogram (EEG) during REM sleep is similar to that of waking. In
infants, the equivalent of REM sleep is called active sleep because of prominent phasic
muscle twitches. NREM sleep, or orthodox sleep, is characterized by decreased
activation of the EEG; in infants it is called quiet sleep because of the relative lack of
motor activity.
1.5.1.1 Stages of Sleep
Within REM and NREM sleep, there are further classifications called stages. For
clinical and research applications, sleep is typically scored in epochs of 30 seconds
with stages of sleep defined by the visual scoring of three parameters: EEG,
electrooculogram (EOG) and electromyogram (EMG) recorded beneath the chin.
During wakefulness, the EEG shows a low voltage fast activity or activated pattern.
Voluntary eye movements and eye blinks are obvious. The EMG has a high tonic
activity with additional phasic activity related to voluntary movements. When the eyes
are closed in preparation for sleep, alpha activity (8-13 cycles per second [cps])
becomes prominent, particularly in occipital regions.
1.5.1.2 NREM Sleep
NREM sleep, which usually precedes REM sleep, is subdivided into
progressively deeper stages of sleep: N1 stage, N2 and stage N3 (deep or delta-wave
sleep). Sleep usually entered through a transitional state, N1 sleep, characterized by
loss of alpha activity and the appearance of a low voltage mixed frequency EEG
pattern with prominent theta activity (3-7 cps) and occasional vertex sharp waves may
also appear. Eye movements become slow and rolling, and skeletal muscle tone
relaxes. Subjectively, N1 may not be perceived as sleep although there is a decreased
awareness of sensory stimuli, particularly visual, and mental activity.Motor activity
may persist for a number of seconds during N1. Occasionally individuals experience
sudden muscle contractions, sometimes accompanied by a sense of falling and/or
10
dreamlike imagery; these hypnic (hypnosis = mental state like sleep) jerks are
generally benign and may be exacerbated by sleep deprivation.
After a few minutes of N1, sleep usually progresses to N2, which is heralded by the
appearance of sleep spindles (12-14 cps) and K-complexes (high amplitude negative
sharp waves followed by positive slow waves) in the EEG. N2 and subsequent stages
of NREM and REM sleep are all subjectively perceived as sleep. Particularly at the
beginning of the night, N2 is generally followed by a period comprised of N3. Slow
waves (< 2 cps in humans) appear during these stages, which are subdivided according
to the proportion of delta waves in the epoch; N3 requires a minimum of 20% and not
more than 50% of the epoch time occupied by slow waves. N3 is also referred to as
slow wave sleep (SWS), delta sleep, or deep sleep, since arousal threshold increases
incrementally from N1 through 4. Eye movements cease during N2-3, and EMG
activity decreases further.
1.5.1.3 REM sleep (or) N-R sleep
REM sleep is not subdivided into stages, but is rather described in terms of tonic
(Persistent) and phasic (episodic) components. Tonic aspects of N-R sleep include the
activated EEG similar to that of N1, which may exhibit increased activity in the theta
band (3-7 cps), and a generalized atonia of skeletal muscles except for the extra ocular
muscles and the diaphragm. Phasic features of N-R include irregular bursts of rapid
eye movements and muscle twitches. Normal sleep patterns vary from species to
species. As already discussed, humans go through five stages in approximately ninety
minute cycles throughout the night. Mice, however, spend far more time asleep, and
when they do sleep, the majority of it is NREM sleep. One strongly correlated aspect
of sleep is body and brain size and the average cycle time in NREM sleep- the smaller
the animal, the shorter the cycle [48].
1.5.2 Physiology of Sleep
Human and animal sleep depends on two major factors: a circadian regulator,
defining the diurnal rhythm and a homeostatic regulator defining the relationship
between wake time and sleep time.
11
Figure 1.2 Sleep stages in Human sleep with Duration in each stage.
1.5.2.1 Homeostatic Regulation of Sleep
Sleep is understood to be restorative, but precisely what is being restored is
uncertain. As a homeostatic process, sleep allows the body to return to equilibrium
when it is disturbed. For instance, sleep deprivation tends to be followed by extra
compensatory sleep to make up for the loss, albeit not on a minute-to-minute basis. The
homeostatic component, named Process S (sleep), is believed to derive from a substrate
or protein that registers a homeostatic “need to sleep” during periods of extended
wakefulness that is subsequently relieved during sleep. As NREM sleep appears to take
precedence over REM sleep following acute sleep loss, it is probable that the
homeostatic mechanisms for the two sleep states differ. The underlying mechanisms
remain unclear. However, studies have shown that adenosine acting in the basal
forebrain is a key mediator of homeostatic control. Increased adenosine release
accompanies the accumulation of the need to sleep, suggesting that the nucleoside,
adenosine, may be involved in the homeostatic control of sleep expression [49]. During
periods of wakefulness, glycogen, the body’s principal store of energy, is exhausted.
As glycogen is broken down into adenosine, extracellular levels of adenosine begin to
accumulate in the basal forebrain, leading to the replenishment of glycogen levels with
recovered sleep. Experimental models showed that, the injection of adenosine or an
12
adenosine A1 receptor agonist into the rat basal forebrain or the cat VLPO,
respectively, promoted sleep by inhibiting multiple wake-promoting regions of the
brain or exciting sleep-promoting cell groups. Adenosine also may excite VLPO
neurons by disinhibiting GABAergic inputs. Therefore, by inhibiting the basal
forebrain arousal system and triggering the VLPO nucleus, adenosine may act as
homeostatic regulator of the sleep need. Recent evidence has shown that the sleep
promoting effects of adenosine are further enhanced through its action at the A1
receptor, which triggers an intracellular cascade leading to increased adenosine A1
receptor production. Other mediators of homeostatic drive may be identified in the
future [50].
1.5.2.2 Circadian Sleep Regulation
A second component of the sleep-wake regulatory mechanism, involves circadian
influences. The SCN, which directs the circadian program, has been called the brain’s
“master clock”. Circadian timing, in which neurons fire in a 24-hour cycle, is organized
in a hierarchy of tissue-specific structures located throughout the body. These tissue-
specific rhythms are coordinated by the SCN based on light input from the outside
world during daytime and by melatonin secretion during the dark cycle [51]. Damage
to the SCN eliminates the circadian rhythms of many behaviours, including sleep. In
particular, lesions of the retinohypothalamic tract (RHT) of the SCN, which processes
light input, cause animals to exhibit free-running behaviours, demonstrating that the
SCN is necessary for synchronization of circadian rhythms to the solar day.
Many physiological processes have a diurnal pattern and are governed by 24 hour
clock, including body temperature, endocrine and autonomic functions, sleep,
cognitive processes and alertness. The diurnal pattern has a key role in assisting an
organism to adapt to environmental circumstances. Many core psychological functions
in healthy individuals such as mood, alertness and cognitive performances follow a
diurnal pattern, being best in the morning and declining throughout the course of the
day to an evening nadir. There is similarly a diurnal pattern to the stress response,
which may be of particular relevance to stress related disorders such as depression. The
circadian clock has a genetic foundation. A range of genes, including the so-called
‘clock’ genes, regulate the length of the circadian period. Variants of this gene
determine a person’s diurnal preference, i.e. being a ‘night owl’ or a ‘morning lark’,
and these genes are further implicated in the pathophysiology of mood disorders [52].
13
1.5.3 Sleep Changes as Biomarker for Depression
The relationship between sleep and depression is bidirectional, where sleep
disturbances are one of the core features of depressive illness. While
Polysomnographic (PSG) studies in adults with depression have demonstrated
significant differences on several sleep parameters. These studies have traditionally
examined sleep macro- architecture, which describes the latencies and durations of
sleep stages. Disturbances in duration of PSG parameters, such as total sleep time
(TST), sleep efficiency (SE), non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep (N1–3) and
rapid eye movement(REM) sleep as well as the frequency of REMs( REM density)
[53].
Numerous studies undertaken in depressive patients have suggested that a
common comorbidity of depression is a dysregulation of the circadian timing system.
In nearly 80% of depressed patients have profound disturbances in sleep architecture
have been documented. Depressed patients often complain of difficulties in falling
asleep, frequent nocturnal awakenings and early morning wakefulness.
Both epidemiological and electroencephalographic studies implicate sleep
disturbance in the pathogenesis of depression. PSG studies in depressed patients show
a reduction in the absolute number of delta waves during the first NREM sleep period
and a general decrease in delta activity throughout the night. Additionally, an
alteration in the temporal distribution of REM sleep with impairment of the timing of
the REM/NREM sleep cycle was documented. It has been suggested that, patients
with decreased REMOL prior to treatment are prone to develop subsequent episodes
of depression and experiencing rapid relapses after remission. The presence of sleep
abnormalities in the first degree relatives of depressed patients (even those who never
experienced the illness) suggests that these sleep changes can be viewed as “markers”
of depression. The decrease in slow wave activity during the first NREM period and
the increase of REM sleep occur more frequently in early depression although the
significance of this is not clear[54].
Functional neuroimaging studies using positron emission tomography have
indicated that MDD patients have higher rates of brain glucose metabolism during the
first NREM sleep period as compared to non-depressed controls, a change associated
with decreased slow wave activity. Despite this associational evidence, whether sleep
14
disturbance has a causal role on depression is still not completely resolved. However,
the clinical management of depression should entail an awareness of the reciprocal
relationship between insomnia and the depressive episodes. It has been suggested that
the existence of abnormalities in the timing of REM/NREM sleep cycle [55, 56].
1.6 Role of Melatonergic system in Sleep regulation and Depression
Melatonin or N-acetyl-5-methoxytryptamine, is a hormone principally produced
and released by the pineal gland. It is a major neurohormone influencing the activity
of SCN neurons. The effect of melatonin is exerted via two distinct melatonin
receptors, MT1 and MT2 [57] . Melatonin inhibits (via MT1 receptors) as well as
phase-shifts (via MT2 receptors) the electrical activity of SCN neurons. In transgenic
mice lacking MT1 receptors, melatonin does not elicit acute inhibitory responses but
can still shift the phase of circadian rhythmicity in SCN firing rate. Therefore, MT2
receptors in the SCN are considered responsible for the phase-shifting and entrainment
effects of melatonin. The firing rate of the SCN decreases in the transition from NREM
to REM sleep, as shown by the simultaneous recording of electroencephalographic
activity and SCN electrical activity in male Wistar rats [58, 59]. These observations,
however require further confirmation in primates, since the relative amount of REM
sleep in rodents is quite limited. The role of the SCN in the regulation of sleep was
first studied in squirrel monkeys. In this primate species SCN lesions, on the one hand,
resulted in the loss of consolidated sleep/wake periods and, on the other hand, caused
a prolonged sleep compared to animals with an intact SCN. The evidence supported
the conclusion that the circadian signal arising from the SCN promotes wakefulness
during the day and facilitates consolidation of sleep during the subjective night.
Indeed, the mechanisms by which the SCN regulates sleep appear to be complex. The
primary projections from the SCN involve hypothalamic and extrahypothalamic
structures (e.g., the basal forebrain or midline thalamic nuclei) that are involved in the
regulation of sleep/wake cycle, autonomic regulation, psychomotor performance and
melatonin secretion. The main purpose of the SCN output system is to integrate
environmental cues with the circadian system, thus conferring maximum flexibility to
the response. Hence, the neural pathways from the SCN, which promote wakefulness
are complemented by those involved in SCN promotion of sleep. The sleep-promoting
action of the SCN also depends upon melatonin whose circadian secretion is regulated
15
by the SCN. Signals from the SCN have been shown to influence physiology and
behaviour including melatonin synthesis, temperature and sleep [60].
Figure 1.3 Synthesis of Melatonin.
1.6.1 Melatonin: biosynthesis, metabolism and mechanism of action
Melatonin was isolated in 1958 by Lerner and his associates, and its chemical
nature was identified as N-acetyl-5-methoxytryptamine. Axelrod (1974) demonstrated
that the pinealocytes have the necessary enzymatic components for the biosynthesis
of melatonin. The sequence of events for the biosynthesis of melatonin is as follows:
Tryptophan is taken up from the circulation and is converted into serotonin.
Serotonin is converted into N-acetylserotonin by the enzyme arylalkylamine N
acetyltransferase(AA NAT);
N-acetylserotonin is converted to melatonin by the enzyme hydroxy-indole-O-
methyltransferase.
Melatonin has both lipophilic and hydrophilic properties. Once formed it is
released into capillaries and can reach all tissues of the body within a very short
16
period [61]. In the circulation, melatonin is partially bound to albumin and can also
bind to hemoglobin. The secretion of melatonin occurs mainly during the night, with
maximum plasma levels normally found between 02:00 and 03:00 AM [62]. An
episodic secretion of melatonin during the night has also been noted. The half-life of
melatonin after intravenous infusion is about 30 min. However, a recent study
indicated that melatonin exhibits a bi-exponential decay with a first distribution half-
life of 2 min and a second metabolic half-life of 20 min [63]. A positron emission
tomography (PET) study indicated that melatonin enters the brain from the circulation;
brain radioactivity was high within 6–8 min after the injection of 11C melatonin. In
the liver, melatonin is first hydroxylated and then conjugated with sulfate and
glucuronide. In human urine, 6-sulfatoxymelatonin (aMT6 s) has been identified as
the main metabolite. In the brain, melatonin is metabolized into kynurenine
derivatives.
It is of interest that the well-documented antioxidant properties of melatonin are
shared by some of its metabolites including cyclic 3-hydroxymelatonin, N1-acetyl-
N2-formyl-5-methoxykynuramine and, with a highest potency, N1-acetyl- 5-
methoxykynuramine [64, 65]. Although melatonin synthesis occurs in a number of
tissues (i.e. the retina, skin and gut), circulating melatonin is almost totally derived
from the pineal gland as indicated by its disappearance after pineal removal. Since
there is no storage of melatonin in the pineal gland, and since the circulating melatonin
is degraded rapidly by the liver, plasma (or saliva) levels of melatonin as well as
urinary levels of aMT6 s reflect appropriately the pineal biosynthetic activity.
Melatonin levels are higher at night than during the day in all animal species studied,
regardless of being diurnal, nocturnal or crepuscular. The circadian pattern of pineal
AANAT, and consequently of melatonin production and secretion, is abolished by
lesions of the SCN. Environmental 24 h light/dark (L/D) cycle acts thus as the
pervasive and pre-eminent Zeitgeber that regulates melatonin synthesis [66]. The
circadian activity of the SCN is synchronized to the L/D cycle mainly by light that is
perceived by the retina. The signal generated in the retina is transmitted to the SCN
through a monosynaptic retinohypothalamic tract that originates from the ganglion
cell layer in the retina and uses glutamate as a neurotransmitter.
17
Recently, it has been found that a sub-group of retinal ganglion cells containing
melanopsin and that innervate the SCN are involved in the photic transmission of light
signals to the SCN. Animal studies demonstrate that the neural pathway connecting
the SCN with the pineal gland starts by a gamma-aminobutyric acid GABA-ergic
projection from the SCN to the paraventricular nucleus (PVN). In addition, the SCN
connects through the subparaventricular zone to the dorsomedial nucleus of the
hypothalamus, which is crucial for producing circadian rhythms of sleep and waking,
locomotor activity, feeding and corticosteroid production [67]. Indeed, physiological
and immunohistochemical studies have revealed that GABA is the principal
transmitter in SCN cells. To control pineal function, efferent fibers from the PVN go
through the medial forebrain bundle and reticular formation and make synaptic
connection with the cells of the intermedio-lateral columns of the cervical spinal cord,
from where preganglionic sympathetic fibers arise and project to the superior cervical
ganglia (SCG).
The postganglionic sympathetic fibers from SCG reach the pineal gland and
release norepinephrine (NE). Activation of pineal beta-adrenergic receptors results in
elevation of cyclic AMP and increases in the synthesis and activity of pineal AA NAT.
Alpha1-adrenergic receptors are also detectable in the pineal gland and potentiate
β-adrenergic receptor activity through the increase of Ca2C activity and the activation
of protein kinase. Beta-adrenergic blockers have been shown to suppress the nocturnal
synthesis and secretion of melatonin in humans, suggesting a similar regulation of
pineal melatonin production [68]. During the light phase, the SCN electrical activity
is high, and under these conditions NE release is inhibited. During the scotophase, the
SCN activity is inhibited and NE release in the pineal is augmented [69]. Exposure to
light (that stimulates the SCN) during the dark phase inhibits NE release in the pineal
gland. Melatonin secretion is suppressed by light intensities ranging from outdoor
levels to, under certain circumstances, those seen indoors. Light-induced suppression
of pineal melatonin synthesis and secretion in humans has a peak sensitivity to short
wavelength light (446–477 nm) [70]. Melatonin is thus produced and released from
the pineal gland during the time of electrical ‘quiescence’ of the SCN occurring in
darkness and is therefore been referred to as the ‘hormone of darkness’. Pineal
melatonin production was shown to be independent of sleep or sleep deprivation.
18
Melatonin production exhibits considerable inter-individual differences with more
than 10-fold variability in nocturnal melatonin concentrations among individuals. A
genetic cause of this variability is suggested by the lower variability found in siblings
as compared to the general population [71]. Melatonin sleep promoting effects
involves interaction with specific receptors in the cell membrane. Melatonin may also
interact with nuclear hormone receptors, with a number of intracellular proteins such
as calmodulin, dihydronicotinamide riboside:quinone reductase 2 and tubulin-
associated proteins and is a potent antioxidant acting as a free radical scavenger as
well as via induction of antioxidant enzymes [72]. With the exception of membrane
receptors, the relevance of any of these interactions to the sleep promoting effects of
the hormone is unknown. The sleep promoting and circadian effects of melatonin have
been attributed to the two subtypes of human melatonin receptors (MT1 and MT2).
MT1 mRNA is mostly expressed in the SCN while MT2 mRNA is distributed in the
SCN and other areas of the CNS, as well as in the periphery. It is believed that at the
SCN MT1 receptors are related to amplitude of SCN circadian rhythmicity, while
MT2 receptors are involved in entrainment of circadian rhythms [73].
1.6.2 Melatonin and Sleep
Melatonin has been implicated in a number of physiological functions like
regulation of circadian rhythms, sleep and body temperature, sexual maturation,
immune function, antioxidant mechanisms, regulation of mood, cardiovascular
functions, etc [74]. Among these various functions, the soporific and sleep/wake
rhythm regulating functions of melatonin have gained wide scientific attention
resulting in numerous studies undertaken in animals and in human subjects. The
finding that melatonin is secreted primarily during night time, the close relationship
between nocturnal increase of endogenous melatonin, and the timing of human sleep
and the sleep-promoting effects of exogenous melatonin prompted many investigators
to suggest melatonin is involved in the physiological regulation of sleep. The onset of
night time melatonin secretion occurs approximately 2 h before individual’s habitual
bed time and has been shown to correlate well with the onset of evening sleepiness.
Suppression of melatonin production by procedures like treatment with β-blockers has
been shown to correlate with insomnia. Conversely, increasing plasma melatonin
concentrations by suppressing melatonin metabolizing enzymes in the liver resulted
19
in increased sleepiness [75]. The period of wakefulness immediately prior the
‘opening of the sleep gate’ is referred to as the wake-maintenance zone or ‘forbidden
zone’ for sleep. During this time the sleep propensity is lowest and the activity of SCN
neurons is high [76]. The transition phase from wakefulness/arousal to high sleep
propensity coincides with the nocturnal rise in endogenous melatonin. In several
studies, a temporal relationship between the nocturnal increase of endogenous
melatonin and opening of the sleep gate was found in most subjects. Upon
administration of melatonin in the afternoon, the sleep gate was advanced by 1–2 h,
while exposure to 2 h of evening bright light between 08:00 and 10:00 PM delayed
the next day rise in nocturnal melatonin and the opening of sleep gate. It was therefore
proposed that melatonin promotes sleep by inhibiting the circadian wakefulness
generating mechanism. This effect is presumably mediated by MT1 receptors at the
SCN level. Melatonin appears to promote sleep by inhibiting the firing of SCN
neurons. This effect is most probably linked to the activation of GABAergic
mechanisms in the SCN, as shown by a number of studies. It therefore appears that
melatonin has a pivotal role in the circadian sleep timing mechanism through its
activity on the SCN. However, there are melatonin receptors in additional human brain
areas, e.g. hippocampus [77].
1.7 Neopterin – Biomarker for Depression
Important reciprocal relationships exist between the hypothalamo-pituitary-
adrenal cortical HPA axis and humoral and cellular components of the immune
system. The production of HPA axis-activating cytokines in febrile illness and organ
transplantation and the immunosuppressive effect of pharmacological doses of gluco-
corticoids are well known [78].Specific cytokines activate specific levels of the HPA
axis; e.g. the stimulation of CRH secretion by interleukin IL-1 and IL-6 and
stimulation of ACTH secretion by IL-2 and IL-6. HPA axis hyperactivity is the most
prominent neuroendocrine abnormality in depression, occurring in 30-50% of
patients. Though considerable work has been done attempting to clarify immune
changes as biological markers of depression, the results have not been consistent.
Neopterin is a reliable, easy-to-measure and well-established soluble marker of
immune activation [79]. Neopterin, a biopterin precursor, is released by macrophages
and reflects activation of the cell-mediated immune system (T-lymphocytes). It is a
product of GTP hydrolysis by cyclo-hydrolase, which is stimulated by interferon-γ
20
(IFN- γ). IFN- γ is secreted by activated T-lymphocytes; therefore, elevated plasma
neopterin is considered to represent activation of T-lymphocytes, although it is
secreted primarily by myeloid cells. Elevated neopterin thus reflects putative
activation of the inflammatory cytokine network, including IL-1, IL-6 and tumor
necrosis factor TNF, which in turn act on the central nervous system. Plasma neopterin
often is elevated in states of activated cell-mediated immunity, such as autoimmune
illness, organ transplantation and viral infections including the human
immunodeficiency virus HIV. It also is elevated in patients with anorexia nervosa,
another psychiatric illness in which HPA axis activation occurs [80].
Neopterin (10, 20, 30-D-erythro-trihydroxypropylpterin) was first isolated from
human urine in 1965. Chemically neopterin represents an unconjugated pteridine
which is synthesized from guanosine triphosphate (GTP) through the GTP
cyclohydrolase I pathway. Thereby, GTP is converted to 7,8-dihydroneopterin
triphosphate by GTP cyclohydrolase I (GCH-I) as the first and rate-limiting step of
the pathway leading to the formation of 5,6,7,8-tetrahydrobiopterin GTP
cyclohydrolase I can be induced by IFN-γ in various cells and species. However unlike
most other cells, human monocyte-derived macrophages and dendritic cells do not
express the subsequent enzymes of the pathway such as 6- pyruvoyl-tetrahydropterin
synthase, which also is relatively insensitive to IFN-γ. As a consequence, following
dephosphorylation of 7, 8-dihydroneopterin triphosphate and oxidation leads to
formation of neopterin [81].
1.8 Depression and Cognitive Changes
Depression unquestionably may affect the ability to think, concentrate, make
decision, formulate ideas, reason, and remember. Other cognitive symptoms of
depression are represented by negative self-evaluation, worthlessness, thoughts of
death, suicidal ideation, ruminative thinking over minor past failings, delusions (50%
of patients tend to focus on fixed ideas of guilt and sinfulness, poverty, somatic
concerns, and feelings of persecution), and hallucinations [82]. Cognitive
dysfunctions are generally assessed by a neuropsychological examination including
an interview of the patient's background and present situation, a behavioural
observation, and the administration of a battery of neuropsychological tests. In an
attempt some researchers employed the P300 event-related electroencephalographic
21
potential for cognitive processes [83]. The P300 component of the Event-Related
Potential (ERP) is a positive deflection which occurs when a subject detects an
informative task-relevant stimulus. Real-time recording of ongoing brain activity can
be used to investigate changes in ERPs related to the completion of a specific cognitive
task. ERPs have millisecond temporal resolution, and can therefore be used to monitor
the neural processes engaged in cognitive functions and capture rapid changes in
cerebral activity.
The ERP task most frequently used to elicit the P300 wave is the oddball task, in
which participants are confronted with a repetitive sequence of standard stimuli (e.g.,
a 1000 Hz sound that occurs 80% of the time) and a few deviant stimuli (e.g., a 2000
Hz sound that occurs 20% of the time). Participants must detect the deviant stimuli as
quickly as possible (typically by pressing a button or keeping count mentally).
Because the subjects must explicitly assess the situation, categorize the pertinent
stimuli, and make a decision, the P300 wave is thought to represent real-time
processing of working memory and voluntary attention as well as a decisional
‘‘response-related stage’’ that indexes memory updating and/or cognitive closure
mechanisms. More precisely P300 amplitude is related to stimulus probability,
stimulus significance, task difficulty, motivation, vigilance and also handedness.
The P300 latency is mainly influenced by the task complexity and is only weakly
influenced by response selection processes. Moreover, P300 latency could be heritable
[84]. The P300 wave can provide a highly useful means for monitoring the efficiency
of cognitive processing. Indeed, many studies have shown the relevance of the P300
as a biological marker for pathophysiological mechanisms. There is general agreement
that a reduction in the P300 amplitude is: (1) a state marker (i.e., a biological marker
that is altered during the disease but stabilizes after clinical remission) of depression
(2) a trait marker (i.e., a biological parameter that is altered during and after the
disease) of schizophrenia, and (3) a vulnerability marker (i.e., a biological variable
that is altered before the emergence of the disease) for alcoholism. These markers, if
present, could be used to aid diagnosis, predict prognosis, or choose the most
appropriate treatment for the psychiatric disorder.
22
However, some results concerning the P300 component are controversial. For
instance, while a significant number of studies have found reduced P300 amplitudes
in patients with depression other studies have failed to replicate this finding. There are
similar contradictory results regarding P300 evoked in visual oddball tasks as well as
P300 latency. Indeed, several studies have reported that P300 latency is not altered in
depression, but rather reaction time is changed. One possible explanation for these
heterogeneous results is the clinical sub-types of the depressed patients included in
these studies. Many individuals with a history of depression use multiple medications,
have co-morbid psychiatric disorders, and have complicated family histories [85].
1.9 Alternative Therapy for Depression
Depressive disorders are very common in clinical practice, with approximately
11.3% of all adults afflicted during any one year [86]. The majority of patients suffer
from mild to moderate forms and are treated in primary care settings. Such patients
are often reluctant to take synthetic antidepressants in their appropriate doses due to
their anticipated side effects including inability to drive a car, dry mouth, constipation
and sexual dysfunction. As a therapeutic alternative, effective herbal drugs may offer
advantages in terms of safety and tolerability, possibly also improving patient
compliance [87, 88]. The advent of the first antidepressants- the Monoamine Oxidase
Inhibitors (MAOIs) and Tricyclic Antidepressants (TCAs) in the 1950s and 1960s
represented a dramatic leap forward in the clinical management of depression.
The subsequent development of the Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors
(SSRIs) and the Serotonin Norepinephrine Reuptake Inhibitor (SNRI) venlafaxine in
the past decade and a half has greatly enhanced the treatment of depression by offering
patients medications that are as effective as the older agents but are generally more
tolerable and safer in an overdose [89,90]. The introduction of atypical
antidepressants, such as bupropion, nefazadone, and mirtazapine, has added
substantially to the available pharmacopoeia for depression. Nonetheless, rates of
remission tend to be low and the risk of relapse and recurrence remains high. Thus,
there is a need for more effective and less toxic agents [91].
Depression is the most common condition among patients seeking treatment with
complementary and alternative therapies. Despite effective allopathic antidepressant
management plans, complete remission rate with allopathic pharmacotherapy remains
23
low [92].Some of the reasons for the use of CAM include the relatively lower
incidence of adverse effects, perceived effectiveness, and the desire for egalitarian
relationships with medical practitioners, a holistic approach to the individual's
problems and dissatisfaction with conventional healthcare [93]. However, despite this
upsurge in the number of CAM consultations, providers of conventional healthcare
have failed to address the issue. Given their frequent use, CAM approaches warrant
the same level of evaluation as conventional treatments. Service users, planners,
general practitioners and mental health professionals need to be informed about which
treatments are effective, which are not, and which ones have been adequately
evaluated [94].The last decade has witnessed a significant growth of interest in
Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) worldwide.
The 3 most widely used CAM approaches in depression are Relaxation, Exercise
and Herbal remedies [95]. Out of this, Herbal medicines are gaining growing interest
because of their cost-effective, eco-friendly attributes and true relief from disease
condition. Ayurveda usage is among the oldest Indian indigenous systems of medicine
with documented history of about 5000 years and 80% of the population still depends
upon Ayurveda for their health concerns [96]. Many plants have folklore claim in the
treatment of several dreadful diseases but they are not scientifically exploited and/or
improperly used. The use of traditional herbal medicines for the treatment of
depression is well documented. A number of plants have been identified in ancient
herbal texts from all over the world that were used to “settle the spirit,” “lift the mood,”
and “clear the mind”. Many of these herbs have been found to possess potent
chemicals which influence various organ systems that play a key role in mood,
anxiety, and mental function [97].
Recently, several herbal medicines showing promising antidepressant effects in
preclinical studies have been entered into clinical trials. It has been found that some
antidepressant herbal medicines combat depression via known
psychopharmacological actions such as inhibition of monoamine re-uptake (such as
serotonin, dopamine and noradrenaline), augmentation of binding and sensitization of
serotonin receptors, inhibition of monoamine oxidase, and modulation of neuro-
endocrine system. Other actions of the herbs may encompass GABAergic effects,
cytokine modulation (particularly in depressive disorders with a comorbid
inflammatory condition), as well as opioid and cannabinoid system effects. Moreover,
24
particular group of herbal preparations, termed as adaptogens, are thought to play a
primary role in the reactions of the body to repeated stress and adaptation mainly due
to their association with the HPA-axis that is a part of the stress system. Therefore,
these plant drugs deserve detailed studies in the light of modern medicine [98,99].
The present Polyherbal formulation was developed at the National Facility for
Tribal and Herbal Medicine, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, India in
collaboration with Interdisciplinary Institute of Indian System of Medicine (IIISM),
SRM University, Chennai, India. The formulation was European patented
(EP1569666B1) for the management of Neurological Disorders. It is a polyherbal
formulation made into tablet dosage form, from freeze dried hydro- alcoholic extracts
of Bacopa monnieri whole plant, Hippophae rhamnoides leaves and fruits and
Dioscorea bulbifera rhizome in collaboration through a Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) with a traditional health care practitioner, using high ethical
standards. The acute, short- term toxicity, pharmacological profile in animals as well
as clinical studies for the formulation showed good results with a very high therapeutic
index [(T.12016/25/2010-DCC (AYUSH)]. The polyherbal formulation exhibits
better therapeutic value on neurological disorder. It may also show positive benefits
on depression symptoms, sleep pattern and biomarkers. Existing knowledge also
advice that traditional herbal medicines are more effective and shows less toxic
effects. Hence the present study was aimed to evaluate the effect of polyherbal
formulation on Psychological parameters, Cognitive functioning, Sleep pattern,
Depression scores and its regulation of biomarkers in mild to moderate depressed
patients.