changing human behavior is one of the most difficult tasks of water conservation 1
TRANSCRIPT
WHAT’S REQUIRED TO CHANGE BEHAVIOR AND ATTITUDE
Changing Human Behavior is One of the Most Difficult Tasks of Water Conservation
1
Presented by:
Ida Roberts
The Water Conservation School
7205 Somersworth Drive
Orlando, Florida 32835-6162
For more information, visit:
www.waterconservationschool.com
It can be and must be done because water is a finite resource with the gap between demand and supply increasing rapidly
To defer exorbitant costs of the monumental engineering alternative water supply projects, called the traditional “hard path (engineering mentality).” Costs +2-3x original projections, trending upwards
Conservation is the least expensive way to find new water. Compare conservation costs with the cost of the next unit of supply, called the new “soft path (nonstructural component).” Costs of conservation trending downward
Saving water saves energy costs, a large part of utility & individual expense
Population growth, growing regulatory tightening of supplies and less water availability due to climate change are factors.
Why We Must Change
Discharge to the Ocean
5 inches/year
StormwaterRunoff
Evapotranspirationplus Evaporation45 inches/year
Rainfall59 inches/year
Evaporation
Groundwater Recharge Volume - 9 inches/year
Max Speed – 14 inches/year
Groundwater pumping25 inches/year
Aquifer Net Loss = 16 inches per year
Fork In The RoadWe have reached a fork in the road on which path to take,
“hard path” or “soft path”:
Hard Path: Building more facilities at tremendous costs. The consequences:
1. Diminished natural world2. Higher economic costs3. Concentrated decision making
Soft Path: Changing the way people think of water and changing their behavior towards it.
The consequences:1. More productive use of water2. Transparent and open decision making3. An acceptance of the true value of water
Challenge: Changing Behavior
Behaviors can be changed Behaviors are learned Intervention needed for changes. Interventions has to be in the form of
leadership Most will not change on their own
6
What Leadership Does Change Require From You
Your leadership. How? Change Yourself. Make the transition from hard path
thinking to soft path thinking The ability to communicate is the corner stone of
leadership New management skills: “soft path” customer relations Training, public education, on-going feedback (informative
billing) and reminders Interact closely with your water users Greater direct participation by water users Effectively engage community groups in water
management Get neighbors to work together to capture conservation low
cost opportunities
What People Want
People don’t want to specifically “use” water What they actually want is to drink and
bathe, swim, produce goods and services, grow food and otherwise meet human needs
Overcome Myths and Barriers
Change of notion of a “perceived abundance of water” Overcome:
– “One person can’t make much of a difference,” – “Why should I comply when a lot of other people aren’t,”and – “This won’t affect me.”
Results of Negative Consequences
Negative consequences sometimes change behavior temporarily, but they do not change attitude. Must be combined with powerful positive reinforcement to succeed
Negatives can also engender the “no law against it” and “beat the system” noncompliance mentality
Positive Reinforcement Is The Key
Only positive reinforcement strategies produce long-term attitudinal change required for the permanent behavioral change required
Techniques to develop attitudinal change
Some Positives to Overcoming Barriers
People will resist appearing “wasteful” Identify a specific second use for the water Ask for specific solutions from customers – public
participation is critical Compare economic issues to the “cost of the next
unit of supply” and not the current cost of water Encourage news coverage of water conservation
issues. Despite their emotional resistance to the news media, people believe what they read in the press and see on television.
Overcome Specific Existing Barriers
Make it as hassle free for the customers as possible. Perceived hassles limit participation in water conservation, i.e.,
– Number one reason for resisting change to irrigation practices – fear of irrigation controller. Customers are afraid of it. They don’t know how to set it
– Print some very simple instructions, i.e., set day of the week and time, select days to irrigate, set time to start, decide time for each zone.
– People resist toilet rebates because of the footprint. Do they fit in the exact location? Or will it require redoing the bathroom floor. Also, how to dispose of old toilet
Give away or sell low flow showerheads ($5) & faucet aerators ($1) Emphasize the specially-engineered and independent testing
Washing machine resistance from utilities because people take them with them when they move
Few Studies on Water Use Behavioral Changes
Extrapolation can be used by studies done to change behavior involving greenhouse gases, recycling (33 % participation in 1972, 80 % in 1990), energy consumption
Get customers attention by offering incentives, both simply emotional (make themselves feel better) and financial
14
What Research Teaches Us
Knowledge alone does not produce behavior change, participation and incentives do
An intrinsic satisfaction from “doing the right thing” is achieved
The simpler, less hassles for the customers, the better
Rewards: Cash rebates or rebates on their bill are the best to show the savings
Utilize All The Tools
People respond differently to various tools Mailings, door-to-door solicitations, telephone
calls, presentations Emphasize benefits, why should care, specific
behaviors to change, tailored information, reminder labels at point of contact with water
Provide feedback, on bills, self generated, consumption monitors, provided by others, tailored
Goal setting Provide implementation plans
Verbal commitments Social support Social comparisons Focus groups Modeling Rewards and incentives Disincentives for unwanted behaviors
Utilize All The Tools
Challenge: Changing Behavior Behavior changes take time. Most permanent changes are
accomplished incrementally and a result of repetition
Long-term commitment is required
Permanent change is brought on by positive encouragement and rewards
18
How to Change Behavior Repetition Repetition Repetition Repetition Repetition Repetition Repetition
19
Specific Messages Beyond the Obvious
There is no relationship between the price of a water saving device and its effectiveness
Encourage full cost and volume pricing to move away from the culture of “cheap water” which encourages wastefulness
The Hundredth-Monkey The hundredth-monkey effect is a phenomenon in which a
learned behavior spreads rapidly from one group of monkeys to all related monkeys once a critical mass of acceptance is reached
When only a limited number of individuals know a 'new way', it remains the conscious property of those individuals
Each time another individual manifests this new awareness, the field is strengthened
Once a critical mass is reached (an exact number will vary), the awareness rapidly becomes common social change
You never know if you are talking to the hundredth monkey
21