challenges and outcomes of piloting the social tenure domain model (stdm) in the eastern caribbean...

15
CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo, Cyprian Selebalo, Danilo Antonio, Jamal Browne

Upload: kayley-courage

Post on 14-Dec-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN

Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo, Cyprian Selebalo, Danilo Antonio, Jamal Browne

Page 2: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

TENURE SITUATION IN THE OECS

Two main types of informal tenures:

1. Squatting/illegal occupation of land2. Family land – customary tenure

Page 3: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

PILOTING METHODOLOGY

Pilots selected – Saint Lucia; Saint Vincent

Two areas in each country selected to

capture informal (squatting) and customary

(family) lands.

Study areas chosen based on annecdotal

data and sampling done in a geographical

cluster-census type methodology.

Page 4: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

FAMILY LAND – SAINT LUCIA - PRASLIN

Page 5: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

PRASLIN FAMILY LANDPETER JULIEN’s

Land

10 Direct Descendants – Land Formally administrated

3 Legally appointed adminstrators

5-7th Generation Heirs of Peter

JulienFrancis Family

All Dead

Sale? Inheritance?

Page 6: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

PRASLIN – TYPICAL HOUSING UNITS

Page 7: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

PRASLIN – SUBDIVIDED FAMILY LAND

Page 8: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

SAINT VINCENT FAMILY LAND - LAYOU

Page 9: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

THE PECULIAR CASE OF LAYOU

Land owned by the Government and Private

individuals.

Current occupiers are heirs of squatters.

Heirs practice family land governance.

Some occupiers gained “permission” to

occupy from a local government official.

Page 10: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

SAINT VINCENT FAMILY LAND – LA CROIX

Page 11: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

LA CROIX - ACCESSHouses are built on steeply sloping land by which access is by foot on a series of make-shift stair cases or on terraced land.

Vehicular access is not facilitated.

Page 12: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,

LA CROIX – DIAMOND FAMILYThe Matriarchs

Dorris Diamond – Age 75

Cristina Diamond – Age 79

Photo Unavailable

Page 13: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,
Page 14: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,
Page 15: CHALLENGES AND OUTCOMES OF PILOTING THE SOCIAL TENURE DOMAIN MODEL (STDM) IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN Charisse Griffith-Charles, Asad Mohammed, Sunil Lalloo,