ch05 discussion blue

Upload: clairecharm27

Post on 10-Apr-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    1/56

    2004 by South-Western/Thomson Learning 1

    Business-Level StrategyBusiness-Level Strategy

    Robert E. Hoskisson

    Michael A. Hitt

    R. Duane Ireland

    Chapter 5Chapter 5

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    2/56

    2

    Chapter 2Chapter 2

    Strategic LeadershipStrategic Leadership

    Chapter 4Chapter 4

    The InternalThe Internal

    OrganizationOrganization

    Chapter 6Chapter 6

    Competitive Rivalry andCompetitive Rivalry and

    Competitive DynamicsCompetitive Dynamics

    Chapter 9Chapter 9

    International StrategyInternational Strategy

    Chapter 1Chapter 1

    Introduction toIntroduction to

    Strategic ManagementStrategic Management

    Chapter 3Chapter 3

    The ExternalThe External

    EnvironmentEnvironment

    Chapter 5Chapter 5

    Business-LevelBusiness-Level

    StrategyStrategy

    Chapter 8Chapter 8Acquisition andAcquisition and

    Restructuring StrategiesRestructuring Strategies

    Chapter 11Chapter 11

    Corporate GovernanceCorporate Governance

    Strategic IntentStrategic Intent

    Strategic MissionStrategic Mission

    Chapter 7Chapter 7

    Corporate-Level StrategyCorporate-Level Strategy

    Chapter 10Chapter 10

    Cooperative StrategyCooperative Strategy

    Chapter 12Chapter 12

    Strategic EntrepreneurshipStrategic Entrepreneurship

    Strategic

    Analysis

    Strategic

    Thinking

    Creating

    Competitive

    Advantage

    Monitoring

    And Creating

    EntrepreneurialOpportunities

    The Strategic Management ProcessThe Strategic Management Process

    Chapter 5Chapter 5

    Business-LevelBusiness-Level

    StrategyStrategy

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    3/56

    3

    Discussion QuestionsDiscussion Questions

    1. What role does the organizationsconcern for customers play in shapingits strategy?

    2. What is business level strategy? Whatare some types of business levelstrategy?

    3. What type of customers are necessary

    to pursue a cost leadership strategy?How is a cost leadership strategydeveloped?

    Click

    Here

    ClickHere

    Click

    Here More discussion questions

    Click

    Here

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    4/56

    4

    Discussion Questions (cont.)Discussion Questions (cont.)

    4. How does establishing the cost leadershipposition deal with the five competitive forces?What are the risks of pursuing costleadership?

    5. What type of customers are necessary topursue a differentiation strategy? How is adifferentiation strategy developed?

    6. How does establishing differentiation help a

    firm fend off threats from the five forces?What are the risks of pursuing differentiation?

    Click

    Here

    Click

    Here

    Click

    Here

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    5/56

    5

    Discussion Questions (cont.)Discussion Questions (cont.)

    7. When should a focus strategy beimplemented? What are the risksof a focus strategy?

    8. What is the integrated low-costdifferentiation strategy? What arethe arguments as to why it is

    increasing in importance? Whatare the risks associated with theintegrated strategy?

    Click

    Here

    Click

    Here

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    6/56

    6

    Discussion Question 1Discussion Question 1

    What role does the organizationsconcern for customers play inshaping its strategy?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    7/56

    7

    Managing Relationships WithManaging Relationships With

    CustomersCustomersCustomer relationships are strengthened byCustomer relationships are strengthened by

    offering them superior valueoffering them superior value

    help customers to develop a new competitivehelp customers to develop a new competitive

    advantageadvantage

    enhance the value of existing competitiveenhance the value of existing competitive

    advantagesadvantages

    Successful companies chart newSuccessful companies chart newcompetitive space in order to serve newcompetitive space in order to serve new

    customers as they simultaneously try tocustomers as they simultaneously try to

    find new ways to better server existingfind new ways to better server existing

    customerscustomers

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    8/56

    8

    Managing Relationships WithManaging Relationships With

    CustomersCustomers Establish a competitive advantage alongEstablish a competitive advantage along

    these dimensions:these dimensions:

    ReachReach

    the firms access and connection to customersthe firms access and connection to customers

    RichnessRichness

    the depth and detail of the two-way flow ofthe depth and detail of the two-way flow of

    information between the firm and customersinformation between the firm and customers

    AffiliationAffiliation

    facilitating useful interactions with customersfacilitating useful interactions with customers

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    9/56

    9

    The Central Role of CustomersThe Central Role of Customers

    In selecting a business-levelIn selecting a business-level

    strategy, the firm determinesstrategy, the firm determines

    1.1. whowho it will serveit will serve2.2. whatwhat needs those target customersneeds those target customers

    have that it will satisfyhave that it will satisfy

    3.3. howhow those needs will be satisfiedthose needs will be satisfied

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    10/56

    10

    CustomersCustomers

    Basis for Customer SegmentationBasis for Customer Segmentation

    ConsumerConsumer

    MarketsMarkets

    IndustrialIndustrial

    MarketsMarkets

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    11/56

    11

    Market Segmentation:Market Segmentation: Consumer MarketsConsumer Markets

    Demographic factorsDemographic factors

    ConsumerConsumer

    MarketsMarkets

    Socioeconomic factorsSocioeconomic factors

    GeographicGeographic

    factorsfactorsPsychological factorsPsychological factors

    Consumption patternsConsumption patterns

    Perceptual factorsPerceptual factors

    Dem.

    Soc.

    Geo.Psy.

    Con.

    Per.

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    12/56

    12

    Market Segmentation:Market Segmentation: Industrial MarketsIndustrial Markets

    IndustrialIndustrial

    MarketsMarkets

    End-use segmentsEnd-use segments

    Product segmentsProduct segments

    Geographic segmentsGeographic segments

    Common buying factorCommon buying factor

    segmentssegments

    Customer size segmentsCustomer size segments

    End

    Pro.

    Geo.

    Buy.

    Size

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    13/56

    13

    Discussion Question 2Discussion Question 2

    What is business level strategy?What are some types of businesslevel strategy?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    14/56

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    15/56

    15

    Business-Level StrategyBusiness-Level Strategy

    Business-level strategyBusiness-level strategy: an integrated and: an integrated and

    coordinated set of commitments and actionscoordinated set of commitments and actions

    the firm uses to gain a competitivethe firm uses to gain a competitive

    advantage by exploiting core competenciesadvantage by exploiting core competencies

    in specific product marketsin specific product markets

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    16/56

    16

    Key Issues of Business-LevelKey Issues of Business-Level

    StrategyStrategyWhat good or service to offer customersWhat good or service to offer customers

    How to manufacture or create the good orHow to manufacture or create the good or

    serviceservice

    How to distribute the good or service inHow to distribute the good or service in

    the marketplacethe marketplace

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    17/56

    17

    Types of Business-Level StrategiesTypes of Business-Level Strategies

    Business-level strategies are intended toBusiness-level strategies are intended to

    create differences between the firmscreate differences between the firms

    position relative to those of its rivalsposition relative to those of its rivals

    To position itself, the firm must decideTo position itself, the firm must decide

    whether it intends to perform activitieswhether it intends to perform activities

    differently or to perform different activitiesdifferently or to perform different activities

    as compared to its rivalsas compared to its rivals

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    18/56

    18

    Five Generic StrategiesFive Generic Strategies

    Competitive AdvantageCompetitive Advantage

    Compe

    tit i

    veS

    co

    pe

    Compe

    tit i

    veS

    co

    pe

    CostCost UniquenessUniqueness

    Bro

    ad

    Broad

    targe

    t

    tar

    ge

    t

    Narrow

    Narrow

    targe

    t

    targe

    t

    CostCost

    LeadershipLeadership

    DifferentiationDifferentiation

    Focused CostFocused Cost

    LeadershipLeadership

    FocusedFocused

    DifferentiationDifferentiation

    Integrated CostIntegrated Cost

    Leadership/Leadership/

    DifferentiationDifferentiation

    Click

    Here

    Return to

    Discussion

    Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    19/56

    19

    Discussion Question 3Discussion Question 3

    What type of customers are

    necessary to pursue a costleadership strategy? How is a cost

    leadership strategy developed?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    20/56

    20

    Cost Leadership StrategyCost Leadership Strategy

    An integrated set of actions designed toAn integrated set of actions designed to

    produce or deliver goods or services at theproduce or deliver goods or services at the

    lowest costlowest cost,, relative to competitorsrelative to competitors withwith

    features that are acceptable to customersfeatures that are acceptable to customers

    relatively standardized productsrelatively standardized products

    features acceptable to many customersfeatures acceptable to many customers

    lowest competitive pricelowest competitive price

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    21/56

    21

    Cost Leadership StrategyCost Leadership Strategy

    Cost saving actions required by this strategy:Cost saving actions required by this strategy:

    building efficient scale facilities

    tightly controlling production costs and

    overhead

    minimizing costs of sales, R&D and service

    building efficient manufacturing facilities

    monitoring costs of activities provided byoutsiders

    simplifying production processes

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    22/56

    22

    How to Obtain a Cost AdvantageHow to Obtain a Cost Advantage

    Cost DriversCost Drivers Value ChainValue Chain

    Determine andDetermine and

    controlcontrolReconfigure, ifReconfigure, if

    neededneeded

    Alter production process Alter production process

    Change in automation Change in automation

    New distribution channelNew distribution channel

    Direct sales in place ofindirect sales

    Direct sales in place ofindirect sales

    New advertising mediaNew advertising media

    New raw materialNew raw material

    Backward integration Backward integration

    Forward integration Forward integration

    Change locationrelative to suppliers or

    buyers

    Change locationrelative to suppliers or

    buyers

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    23/56

    23

    q Product featuresq Performanceq Mix & variety of

    productsq Service levelsq Small vs. large buyersq Process technologyq Wage levelsq Product featuresq Hiring, training,

    motivation

    Factors That Drive CostsFactors That Drive Costs

    q Economies of scaleq Asset utilizationq Capacity utilization

    pattern Seasonal, cyclical

    q Interrelationshipsq Order processing

    and distributionq Value chain linkages

    Marketing & sales Logistics &

    operations

    Service

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    24/56

    24

    Questions Leading to Lower CostsQuestions Leading to Lower Costs

    1.1. How can an activity be performedHow can an activity be performed

    differently or even eliminated?differently or even eliminated?

    2.2. How can a group of linked value activitiesHow can a group of linked value activities

    be regrouped or reordered?be regrouped or reordered?

    3.3. How might coalitions with other firmsHow might coalitions with other firms

    lower or eliminate costs?lower or eliminate costs?

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    25/56

    25

    Discussion Question 4Discussion Question 4

    How does establishing the costleadership position deal with thefive competitive forces? What arethe risks of pursuing costleadership?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    26/56

    26

    Cost Leadership Strategy and theCost Leadership Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of Competition

    Rivalry Among CompetingRivalry Among Competing

    FirmsFirms

    Can use cost leadershipCan use cost leadership

    strategy to advantage since:strategy to advantage since:q competitors avoid pricecompetitors avoid price

    wars with cost leaders,wars with cost leaders,

    creating higher profits forcreating higher profits forthe entire industrythe entire industry

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    27/56

    27

    Cost Leadership Strategy and theCost Leadership Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of Competition

    Bargaining Power ofBargaining Power of

    BuyersBuyers

    Can mitigate buyers power by:Can mitigate buyers power by:q driving prices far belowdriving prices far below

    competitors, causing themcompetitors, causing them

    to exit and shifting powerto exit and shifting power

    with buyers back to thewith buyers back to thefirmfirm

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    28/56

    28

    Cost Leadership Strategy and theCost Leadership Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of Competition

    Bargaining Power ofBargaining Power of

    SuppliersSuppliers

    Can mitigate suppliers powerCan mitigate suppliers power

    by:by:q being able to absorb costbeing able to absorb cost

    increases due to low costincreases due to low cost

    positionpositionq being able to make very largebeing able to make very large

    purchases, reducing chancepurchases, reducing chance

    of supplier using powerof supplier using power

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    29/56

    29

    Cost Leadership Strategy and theCost Leadership Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionRivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

    Threat of New EntrantsThreat of New Entrants

    Can frighten off new entrantsCan frighten off new entrants

    due to:due to:q their need to enter on a largetheir need to enter on a large

    scale in order to be costscale in order to be cost

    competitivecompetitiveq the time it takes to movethe time it takes to move

    down the learning curvedown the learning curve

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    30/56

    30

    Cost Leadership Strategy and theCost Leadership Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of Competition

    Threat of SubstituteThreat of Substitute

    ProductsProducts

    Cost leader is well positionedCost leader is well positioned

    to:to:q make investments to bemake investments to be

    first to create substitutesfirst to create substitutesq

    buy patents developed bybuy patents developed bypotential substitutespotential substitutesq lower prices in order tolower prices in order to

    maintain value positionmaintain value position

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    31/56

    31

    Structure for Cost LeadershipStructure for Cost Leadership

    StrategyStrategy

    Office of the PresidentOffice of the President

    Centralized StaffCentralized Staff

    MarketingMarketing PersonnelPersonnel

    EngineeringEngineering OperationsOperations AccountingAccounting

    Operations is main functionOperations is main function Process engineering isProcess engineering is

    emphasized over R&Demphasized over R&D

    Large centralized staffLarge centralized staff

    Formalized proceduresFormalized procedures Structure is mechanical, jobStructure is mechanical, job

    roles highly structuredroles highly structured

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    32/56

    32

    Risks of Cost Leadership StrategyRisks of Cost Leadership Strategy

    Processes used by the cost leader to produceProcesses used by the cost leader to produceand distribute its good or service couldand distribute its good or service couldbecome obsolete because of competitorsbecome obsolete because of competitors

    innovationsinnovations Too much focus by the cost leader on costToo much focus by the cost leader on cost

    reductions may occur at the expense of tryingreductions may occur at the expense of tryingto understand customers perceptions ofto understand customers perceptions ofcompetitive levels of differentiationcompetitive levels of differentiation

    Competitors may learn how to successfullyCompetitors may learn how to successfullyimitate the cost leaders strategyimitate the cost leaders strategy

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    33/56

    33

    Discussion Question 5Discussion Question 5

    What type of customers are

    necessary to pursue a differentiationstrategy? How is a differentiation

    strategy developed?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    34/56

    34

    Differentiation StrategyDifferentiation Strategy

    An integrated set of actions designed by aAn integrated set of actions designed by a

    firm to produce or deliver goods or servicesfirm to produce or deliver goods or services

    (at an acceptable cost) that customers(at an acceptable cost) that customers

    perceive as being different in ways that areperceive as being different in ways that areimportant to themimportant to them

    price for product can exceed what the firmsprice for product can exceed what the firms

    target customers are willing to paytarget customers are willing to pay

    nonstandardized productsnonstandardized products

    customers value differentiated features morecustomers value differentiated features more

    than they value low costthan they value low cost

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    35/56

    35

    Differentiation StrategyDifferentiation Strategy

    Value provided byValue provided by unique features andunique features and

    value characteristicsvalue characteristics

    Command premium priceCommand premium price

    High customer serviceHigh customer service

    Superior qualitySuperior quality

    Prestige or exclusivityPrestige or exclusivity

    Rapid innovationRapid innovation

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    36/56

    36

    Differentiation StrategyDifferentiation Strategy

    Differentiation actions required by this strategy:Differentiation actions required by this strategy:

    developing new systems and processesdeveloping new systems and processes

    shaping perceptions through advertisingshaping perceptions through advertising

    quality focusquality focus

    capability in R&Dcapability in R&D

    maximize human resource contributionsmaximize human resource contributions

    through low turnover and high motivationthrough low turnover and high motivation

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    37/56

    37

    How to Obtain a DifferentiationHow to Obtain a Differentiation

    AdvantageAdvantage

    Cost DriversCost Drivers Value ChainValue Chain

    Control ifControl if

    neededneededReconfigure toReconfigure to

    maximizemaximize

    customer perceptions of uniquenesscustomer perceptions of uniquenesscustomer perceptions of uniquenesscustomer perceptions of uniqueness

    customer reluctance to switch to non-unique productcustomer reluctance to switch to non-unique productcustomer reluctance to switch to non-unique productcustomer reluctance to switch to non-unique product

    Raise performance of product or serviceRaise performance of product or service

    Lower buyers costsLower buyers costs

    Create sustainability through:Create sustainability through:

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    38/56

    38

    Factors That Drive DifferentiationFactors That Drive Differentiation

    Unique product featuresUnique product featuresUnique product performanceUnique product performance Exceptional servicesExceptional servicesNew technologiesNew technologiesQuality of inputsQuality of inputs Exceptional skill or experienceExceptional skill or experience

    Detailed informationDetailed information Extensive personal relationships withExtensive personal relationships with

    buyers and suppliersbuyers and suppliers

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    39/56

    39

    Differentiation Strategy and theDifferentiation Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionRivalry Among CompetingRivalry Among Competing

    FirmsFirms

    Can defend againstCan defend against

    competition because:competition because:q brand loyalty tobrand loyalty to

    differentiated productdifferentiated product

    offsets price competitionoffsets price competition

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    40/56

    40

    Discussion Question 6Discussion Question 6

    How does establishing differentiation

    help a firm fend off threats from thefive forces? What are the risks of

    pursuing differentiation?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    41/56

    41

    Differentiation Strategy and theDifferentiation Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionBargaining Power of BuyersBargaining Power of Buyers

    Can mitigate buyer powerCan mitigate buyer power

    because:because:

    q well differentiated productswell differentiated productsreduce customer sensitivityreduce customer sensitivity

    to price increasesto price increases

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    42/56

    42

    Differentiation Strategy and theDifferentiation Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionBargaining Power ofBargaining Power of

    SuppliersSuppliers

    Can mitigate suppliers powerCan mitigate suppliers power

    by:by:q absorbing price increasesabsorbing price increases

    due to higher marginsdue to higher marginsq

    passing along higherpassing along higher

    supplier prices becausesupplier prices because

    buyers are loyal tobuyers are loyal to

    differentiated branddifferentiated brand

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    43/56

    43

    Differentiation Strategy and theDifferentiation Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionThreat of New EntrantsThreat of New Entrants

    Can defend against newCan defend against new

    entrants because:entrants because:

    q new products must surpassnew products must surpassproven products or,proven products or,

    q new products must be atnew products must be at

    least equal to performanceleast equal to performance

    of proven products, butof proven products, but

    offered at lower pricesoffered at lower prices

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    44/56

    44

    Differentiation Strategy and theDifferentiation Strategy and the

    Five Forces of CompetitionFive Forces of CompetitionThreat of SubstituteThreat of Substitute

    ProductsProducts

    Well positioned relative toWell positioned relative to

    substitutes because:substitutes because:q brand loyalty to abrand loyalty to a

    differentiated product tendsdifferentiated product tends

    to reduce customers testingto reduce customers testing

    of new products orof new products or

    switching brandsswitching brands

    RivalryAmong

    RivalryAmong

    CompetingFirms

    CompetingFirms

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    Bargainin

    gPow

    er

    ofB

    uyers

    ofB

    uyers

    Bargaining PowerBargaining Power

    of Suppliersof Suppliers

    Threato

    fNew

    Threato

    fNew

    Entrants

    Entrants

    Thre

    atof

    Thre

    atof

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Subs

    titut

    ePro

    ducts

    Five Forces ofFive Forces ofCompetitionCompetition

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    45/56

    45

    OperationsOperations HumanHumanResourcesResources

    Structure for DifferentiationStructure for Differentiation

    StrategyStrategyPresident andPresident and

    Limited StaffLimited Staff

    MarketingMarketing

    New ProductNew ProductR&DR&D

    Marketing is the main function for tracking new product ideasMarketing is the main function for tracking new product ideas New product R&D is emphasizedNew product R&D is emphasized Most functions are decentralizedMost functions are decentralized Formalization is limited to foster change and promote new ideasFormalization is limited to foster change and promote new ideas

    Overall structure is organic; job roles are less structuredOverall structure is organic; job roles are less structured

    R&DR&D

    FinanceFinanceMarketingMarketing

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    46/56

    46

    Major Risks of DifferentiationMajor Risks of Differentiation

    StrategyStrategy

    Customers may decide that the priceCustomers may decide that the price

    differential between the differentiateddifferential between the differentiated

    product and the cost leaders product isproduct and the cost leaders product is

    too largetoo largeMeans of differentiation may cease toMeans of differentiation may cease to

    provide value for which customers areprovide value for which customers are

    willing to paywilling to pay

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    47/56

    47

    Major Risks of DifferentiationMajor Risks of Differentiation

    StrategyStrategy

    Experience may narrow customersExperience may narrow customers

    perceptions of the value of differentiatedperceptions of the value of differentiated

    features of the firms productsfeatures of the firms products

    Makers of counterfeit goods may attemptMakers of counterfeit goods may attempt

    to replicate differentiated features of theto replicate differentiated features of the

    firms productsfirms products

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    48/56

    48

    Discussion Question 7Discussion Question 7

    When should a focus strategy be

    implemented? What are the risksof a focus strategy?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    49/56

    49

    Focused Business-LevelFocused Business-Level

    StrategiesStrategiesA focus strategy must exploit a narrowA focus strategy must exploit a narrowtargets differences from the balance oftargets differences from the balance of

    the industry by:the industry by:

    isolating a particular buyer groupisolating a particular buyer group

    isolating a unique segment of a productisolating a unique segment of a product

    lineline

    concentrating on a particularconcentrating on a particulargeographic marketgeographic market

    finding their nichefinding their niche

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    50/56

    50

    Factors That May Drive FocusedFactors That May Drive Focused

    StrategiesStrategies Large firms may overlook small nichesLarge firms may overlook small niches

    Firm may lack resources to compete in theFirm may lack resources to compete in the

    broader marketbroader market

    May be able to serve a narrow marketMay be able to serve a narrow market

    segment more effectively than can largersegment more effectively than can larger

    industry-wide competitorsindustry-wide competitors

    Focus may allow the firm to directFocus may allow the firm to directresources to certain value chain activitiesresources to certain value chain activities

    to build competitive advantageto build competitive advantage

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    51/56

    51

    Major Risks of Focused StrategiesMajor Risks of Focused Strategies

    Firm may be outfocused by competitorsFirm may be outfocused by competitors

    Large competitor may set its sights onLarge competitor may set its sights on

    your niche marketyour niche market

    Preferences of niche market may changePreferences of niche market may change

    to match those of broad marketto match those of broad market

    Click

    Here Return to Discussion Questions

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    52/56

    52

    Discussion Question 8Discussion Question 8

    What is the integrated low-costdifferentiation strategy? What are

    the arguments as to why it isincreasing in importance? Whatare the risks associated with theintegrated strategy?

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    53/56

    53

    Advantages of Integrated StrategyAdvantages of Integrated Strategy

    A firm that successfully uses anA firm that successfully uses an

    integrated cost leadership/differentiationintegrated cost leadership/differentiation

    strategy should be in a better position to:strategy should be in a better position to:

    adapt quickly to environmental changesadapt quickly to environmental changes

    learn new skills and technologies morelearn new skills and technologies more

    quicklyquickly

    effectively leverage its coreeffectively leverage its corecompetencies while competing againstcompetencies while competing against

    its rivalsits rivals

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    54/56

    54

    Benefits of Integrated StrategyBenefits of Integrated Strategy

    Successful firms using this strategy haveSuccessful firms using this strategy have

    above-average returnsabove-average returns

    Firm offers two types of values toFirm offers two types of values to

    customerscustomers

    some differentiated features (but lesssome differentiated features (but less

    than a true differentiated firm)than a true differentiated firm)

    relatively low cost (but now as low asrelatively low cost (but now as low asthe cost leaders price)the cost leaders price)

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    55/56

    55

    Using the Functional StructureUsing the Functional Structure

    The integrated form of the functional

    structure

    must have decision-making patterns that are

    partially centralized and partially decentralized will have semi-specialized jobs and rules and

    procedures that call for some formal and some

    informal job behavior

    Strategic flexibility is obtained via flexible manufacturing systems

    information networks

    total quality management systems

  • 8/8/2019 Ch05 Discussion Blue

    56/56

    56

    Major Risks of Integrated StrategyMajor Risks of Integrated Strategy

    An integrated cost/differentiation businessAn integrated cost/differentiation business

    level strategy often involves compromiseslevel strategy often involves compromises

    (neither the lowest cost nor the most(neither the lowest cost nor the most

    differentiated firm)differentiated firm) The firm may become stuck in theThe firm may become stuck in the

    middle lacking the strong commitmentmiddle lacking the strong commitment

    and expertise that accompanies firmsand expertise that accompanies firms

    following either a cost leadership or afollowing either a cost leadership or a

    differentiated strategydifferentiated strategy