8/4/2019 CFS Ontario 2011 Election: Liberal Platform Factsheet

1/2

TAKE IT OVER!ELECTION DAY IS OCTOBER 6

Students in Ontario pay the highest tuition fees in Canada and have long advocated for more affordable post-secondaryeducation. Students have been working with each party to make education a central issue this election season.

Students should be proud of what weve accomplished together as the Ontario Liberal Party has decided to make one of ourcentral demands, up-front grants, the cornerstone of their campaign. This is a significant victory!

However, the announcement was mischaracterized in the press as soon as it went public, confusing Ontarians, journalistsand students alike. On the day of the announcement, Federation representatives spoke with several Liberal staff to clarifythe details. While the announcement is a victory, it is important to note that we have several concerns. The information belowshould clarify what the Liberals are promising in their platform.

THE ANNOUNCEMENT

On September 5, the Ontario Liberals released their election platform. Central to their promises was the announcement of a $430million investment into grants for most (but not all) college and undergraduate university students. What does this announcementmean? Here is an explanation to use when speaking to media who may contact you, to train your volunteers and to share with yourmembers. Keep in mind that the Liberal Party seems to want to fight this election out on education and if we work hard enough wecan probably pressure them to improve their promises.

THE FACTS:

A grant worth $1,600 for undergraduate and $730 for college students will be given to eligible students whose parentsmake less than $160,000 per year. This should make new grants available to more than 300,000 students.

Students who attend an institution that charges more than the average tuition fees will still receive $1,600. If a studentattends an institution that charges less than the average, they will receive $1,600.

Students who do not take a 100 per cent course load but who are still considered full-time as defined by the governmentshould still receive $1,600.

The grant will not be renewed for students who drop from clear standing (presumably as defined by each institution) or whomove from full-time to part-time status.

Grant eligibility should be automatic; students dont have to apply for the Ontario Student Assistance Program (OSAP) toreceive it. Its unclear as to how the government would determine students family income, though, in absence of an OSAPform.

Nothing about the Liberal announcement will affect OSAP eligibility or administration. Debt can still rise to $29,200 perstudent and Ontario Student Opportunity Grants will still be distributed.

The Liberals say that there will not be any changes announced during the campaign to reform or improve OSAP.

There will be no announcement made to improve graduate student education, research or funding. There was no moneypromised for research at all.

There was no announcement about hiring more faculty or reducing class sizes.

Satellite campuses were promised in Barrie (Laurentian), Milton (Laurier) and Brampton (a York, U of T, Ryersonsupercampus). These campuses will offer undergraduate teaching only.

LIBERAL POST-SECONDARY EDUCATIONPLATFORM FACTSHEET

8/4/2019 CFS Ontario 2011 Election: Liberal Platform Factsheet

2/2

IS THE PROMISED GRANT A TUITION FEE REDUCTION?

No. The Liberals have promised an up-front grant to students which will amount to $1,600 for undergraduate students and $730for college students. This grant will not stop tuition fees from rising and the Liberals have said they will not announce their planfor tuition fees until after theyre elected.

IS EVERYONE ELIGIBLE FOR THE GRANT?

No. The following is a list of students who will not be eligible for the grant:

Studentsinprofessionalprograms, who pay the highest fees, are not eligible for the program. In fact, their fee increaseswill be subsidizing the grants in part. Because the highest cost programs wont be included, the least accessible fields ofeducation will remain further out of reach for low- and middle-income students.

Students who fallfromclearstandingwill lose the grant.

Internationalstudents are not eligible for the grant.

Part-timestudentsare ineligible for the grant and students who move from full-time to part-time status will lose the grant.

Studentswhoseparentsmakeover$160,000annually will also be ineligible, even if their parents do not subsidize theireducation.

Graduatestudents are ineligible for the grant, even though they have less access to provincial student financial assistanceand pay higher fees.

I HEARD THE GRANT IS WORTH 30 PER CENT OF THE COST OF TUITION FEES. IS THIS TRUE?

No. The Liberals have excluded tuition fees from professional programs in their average calculation, which are higher thanother programs. The average undergraduate tuition fee is $6,300, according to Statistics Canada, but the Liberal Party saysit is $5,400. This is problematic because professional programs have the highest tuition fees, and excluding them from thecalculation skews the average to be lower, and denies students enrolled in them from needed financial aid. For example, if youwere a student in business administration at the University of Toronto, this grant would only comprise 13 per cent of your fees.This grant also does not cover ancillary fees.

DOES THIS GRANT MAKE EDUCATION MORE AFFORDABLE?

The best way to increase the accessibility of college and university is to reduce tuition fees. This grant will help many studentsafford the high cost of tuition fees, but it may also justify more tuition fee increases, and more student debt. Up-front grantslike this are good and students have long been calling for more grants, but real accessibility means reducing and eliminating allfinancial barriers.

WHATS THIS ABOUT SATELLITE CAMPUSES?

Existing satellite campuses in Ontario have been plagued by low educational quality and confusing governance structures wherelocal autonomy is trumped by decision makers in another region of the province. Students have been highly critical of any plansto expand undergraduate education while at the same time not hiring more professors or guaranteeing that all the coursesstudents require to finish their degrees will be available at all campuses. The Liberals are also promising that these campuses willbe undergraduate-only; there will be no graduate education or research opportunities. This could mean that students will havelower quality professors, as most professors try to work where they can teach and research together.

IS THIS THE BEST POLICY IN THE ELECTION?

This is going to be a hard promise for the other parties to beat. While it would have been best to target the up-front costs byreducing tuition fees, this is still a significant investment into up-front student grants. Check out the political party report cardwhen it is available and make sure you are communicating updates to your members. Things could change at any time.

THE LAST WORD

The Liberals have indicated that this is supposed to be the final platform policy but, as we have seen time and time again,updates, changes and clarifications are common when an election is underway. This document contains what has been madeclear so far, but stay tuned for possible updates and share anything you learn with the Ontario Executive.

CANADIAN FEDERATION OF STUDENTS - ONTARIO TAKE-IT-OVER.CA