case study of nirma vs surf
DESCRIPTION
the classic war between nirma and surfTRANSCRIPT
•Aishwarya Lahiri, Bikash Jyoti Borah, Divya Sarin, Joy Chakravarty, Anubhav Khandelwal, Harsha Jagasia, Daniel Fernandes, Ananya Mohanty
One of the oldest players Result of merger between William
Hesketh Lever- England, Margarine Unie- Netherlands and Lever Brothers- India
Total size of HLL’s detergent business: Rs. 2000 crores (nearly 40% of the 5000 crores market)
Three key brands- Surf, Rin and Wheel, and smaller brands like Sunlight and 501, and Rin ALA
Started with door to door delivery- reached up to 200kgs a day
Was sold in poly bags, as compared to surf ‘s significantly expensive cartons
Positioned as a cheaper alternative to Surf and as a superior product compared to inferior washing soaps
Became a symbol of a low priced, good quality detergent
sales grew at a rate of 49% Aimed at the unorganized laundry soap
market in the urban and rural areas launched Nirma detergent bar, to counter
Rin, selling at one third of the price of Rin.
Course of action
1. Aggressive advertising
• Creating a jingle that connects to the market
• A new fresh advertising campaign
• Concentrating on cost
• Guerilla advertising
• IMC
• New agency: new ideas, new creative
2. Decreasing price of existing product
Nirma consumers received “acceptable” quality in lieu of low price
HLL COULD possibly follow this way.
Launch a new cost competitive product as compared to Nirma
This is what HLL did
They launched “Wheel”
Tap markets which were unexplored by Nirma
Nirma was popular in Gujarat in 1980s
Was gaining on markets as yet unexplored by Surf (middle to lower classes, rural)
Surf could have adopted various measures like price decrease to appeal to rural markets
3. New Promotion tactics along with advertising
Some amount extra with pack
Free items (buckets etc)
Produce sachets
Stick sachets in magazines and newspapers
1. Cost Reduction: decided to sell Surf in polybags as against its previous expensive cartons
2. Revamped its advertising Earlier, Surf’s campaign ads were
always used to establish ‘Surf washes whiter’.
In 1985, HLL created a character called Lalitaji, potrayed by TV artist Kavitha Chowdhary. Lalithaji represented a smart housewife who knew that good value always comes at a price.
3. Launch of Sunlight
Then launched a white detergent powder called Sunlight in 1985
priced to match Nirma
targeted the eastern and southern markets where Nirma was not very strong
4. Launch of Wheel R&D department of HLL was given the
responsibilty of producing a low-cost detergent, which gave better performance, at the same time, without any side-effects like ones caused by high soda-ash content in Nirma.
1986: developed a NSD(non-soap detergent): Wheel
launched as a detergent bar too to counter Swastik’s Super 777
5. Easy access to raw materials carefully selected the locations for
new plants in Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Punjab and Pondicherry
HLL supplied the raw materials, the contractors hired their own labour and produced the detergent.
provided HLL with greater flexibility to start new units faster, thus gaining concessions and significant cost savings.
6. Packaging in 30 grams plastic sachets
Wheel Detergents powder was packed in 30-gram plastic sachets, instead of usual one-kg packs. It was priced at Rs. 5.50 as against Nirma’s Rs. 5.25.
7. Advertising strategy
campaigns emphasized that Wheel provided “extra power, extra lather and was safe on hands and clothes.”
aimed at creating dissonance in the minds of Nirma buyers about the safety aspects and the benefits of switching over to Wheel.