case 3:17-cv-01825-jd document 106 filed 06/10/20 page 1 of 19 · 2020-06-12 · [proposed] final...

[PROPOSED] FINAL ORDER CERTIFYING SETTLEMENT CLASS AND GRANTING FINAL APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT AND FINAL JUDGMENT Case No. 17-cv-01825-JD

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION

GREGORY COFFENG, MARK GLASER and JORDAN WILSON, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC., Defendant.

Case No. 17-cv-01825-JD

[PROPOSED] FINAL ORDER AND JUDGMENT CERTIFYING SETTLEMENT CLASS AND GRANTING FINAL APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT

JUDGE: Hon. James Donato CRTRM: 11, 19th Floor

Case 3:17-cv-01825-JD Document 106 Filed 06/10/20 of 19


- 1 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Having considered the Joint Motion for Final Approval (the “Motion”, Dkt. No. 84) of the

Class Settlement (“Settlement”) between the Class Representatives, Plaintiffs Gregory Coffeng,

Mark Glaser, and Jordan Wilson (collectively, “Plaintiffs” or “Class Representatives”) and

Defendant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. (“VWGoA” or “Defendant”); the supporting Joint

Declaration of Gary S. Graifman and Thomas P. Sobran (“Joint Declaration”) (Dkt. No. 86) and

exhibits annexed thereto including the Second Amended Settlement Agreement (“Settlement

Agreement”); the Declaration (Dkt. No. 84 Att. 1) and Supplemental Declaration (Dkt. No. 93 Att.

2) of Cameron R. Azari and exhibits annexed thereto; the objections to the Settlement (Dkt. Nos.

89, 90, 91 and 101); the Brief in Further Support of Final Approval on behalf of Defendant (Dkt.

No. 92); the Reply in Support of Motion for Final Approval (Dkt. No. 93) and exhibits thereto; and

the Court, having held a fairness hearing on May 14, 2020 and having carefully considered all of

the submissions and arguments with respect to the Motion; and having provisionally certified, by

the Court’s prior Preliminary Approval Order dated August 29, 2019 (Dkt. 82) (the “Preliminary

Approval Order”), a Settlement Class pursuant to Rules 23(a) and 23(b)(3) of the Federal Rules of

Civil Procedure and directed the dissemination of Class Notice pursuant to the approved Notice

Plan; and the Court being fully advised in the premises, the Court finds and orders as follows:

1. Certification of the Class. The Court finds that, for purposes of Settlement, the

applicable prerequisites for class action treatment under FED. R. CIV. P 23(a) and 23(b)(3) are

satisfied, to wit: The Class or Settlement Class as defined in Paragraph I (Q) of the Settlement

Agreement and also defined below, consisting of approximately 1,765,180 Settlement Class

Members, is so numerous that joinder of all members is not practicable, questions of law and fact

are common to the Settlement Class, the claims of the Settlement Class Representatives are typical

of the claims of the Settlement Class, the Settlement Class Representatives will fairly and adequately

protect the interests of the Settlement Class, questions of law and fact common to the members of

the Settlement Class predominate over any questions affecting only individual members, and a class

action is superior to other available methods for fairly and efficiently adjudicating this controversy.

2. Notice of the Class Action Settlement. The Court finds that, as demonstrated by

the Declaration and Supplemental Declaration of Cameron Azari, and counsel’s submissions, Notice



- 2 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

to the Settlement Class was timely and properly effectuated in accordance with FED. R. CIV. P.

23(e) and the approved Notice Plan set forth in the Court’s Preliminary Approval Order. The Court

finds that said Notice constitutes the best notice practicable under the circumstances, and satisfies

all requirements of Rule 23(e) and due process.

3. CAFA Notice. In accordance with the requirements of the Class Action Fairness

Act of 2005, 28 U.S.C. § 1715 (“CAFA”), the Claims Administrator caused to be mailed a copy of

the proposed class action settlement and all other documents required by law to the Attorney General

of the United States and the Attorneys General in each of the jurisdictions where class members

reside, thereby satisfying the requirements of CAFA. None of the Attorneys General filed objections

to the Settlement.

4. Defined Terms of the Settlement Agreement. Unless otherwise defined herein,

the terms used in this Order that are defined in the Settlement Agreement shall have the same

meaning as set forth in the Settlement Agreement.

5. The Settlement is Fair, Reasonable and Adequate. The Court finds that the

Settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate and in all respects satisfies the requirements for a class

settlement under Rule 23. The Settlement provides substantial benefits to the Class such as:

(A) an extended warranty for (i) repair or replacement of a failed primary engine water

pump of a Settlement Class Vehicle, free of charge, by an authorized Volkswagen or Audi

dealer (depending on the brand of Settlement Class Vehicle), after December 6, 2019 (the

“Notice Date”) and during a period of 10 years or 100,000 miles (whichever occurs first)

from the In-service Date of the Settlement Class Vehicle, subject to all terms, conditions,

requirements and limitations set forth in Sections I(M) and II(A) of the Settlement

Agreement, and (ii) a percentage of the cost of repair or replacement, by an authorized

Volkswagen or Audi dealer, of a failed or damaged engine of a Settlement Class Vehicle that

was caused by a primary engine water pump failure, during said period of 10 years or 100,000

miles (whichever occurs first) from the vehicle’s In-Service Date, based on the percentages

set forth in Table 1 at Section II(A) of the Settlement Agreement as applicable to the



- 3 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Settlement Class Vehicle, and subject to all terms, conditions, requirements and limitations

set forth in Sections I(M) and II(A) of the Settlement Agreement; and

(B) reimbursement of (i) out-of-pocket expenses that were paid by a Settlement Class

member to repair or replace a failed primary engine water pump of a Settlement Class Vehicle

prior to December 26, 2019 and within 10 years or 100,000 miles (whichever occurred first)

from the Settlement Class Vehicle’s In-Service Date, at (a) 100% reimbursement of the paid

out-of-pocket expense if the repair or replacement was performed within 8 years or 80,000

miles (whichever occurred first) from the Settlement Class Vehicle’s In-Service Date, subject

to a maximum reimbursement of $950 if the repair or replacement was performed by an

independent service center, or (b) 70% reimbursement of the paid out-of-pocket expense if

the repair or replacement was performed from 8 years and one day or 80,001 miles (whichever

occurred first) up to 10 years or 100,000 miles (whichever occurred first) from said vehicle’s

In-Service Date, subject to a maximum reimbursement of $665 if the repair or replacement

was performed by an independent service center, subject to all terms, conditions,

requirements and limitations set forth in Sections I(M), II(B) and II(C) of the Settlement

Agreement, and (ii) reimbursement of a percentage of the out-of-pocket expenses that were

paid by a Settlement Class Member for repair or replacement of a failed or damaged engine

of a Settlement Class Vehicle that was directly caused by a primary engine water pump failure

that was performed prior to December 26, 2019 and within 10 years or 100,000 miles

(whichever occurred first) from the vehicle’s In-Service Date, based on the percentages set

forth in Table 1 at Section II(C) of the Settlement Agreement, subject to a maximum

reimbursement of $4,000 if the repair or replacement was performed by an independent

service center, and subject to all terms, conditions, requirements and limitations set forth in

Sections I(M), II (B) and (C) of the Settlement Agreement.

6. The Court finds that the Settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate, and in all

respects satisfied FED. R. CIV. P. 23, especially considering the facts and circumstances of this

case, the claims and defenses asserted, and the risks of non-recovery or reduced recovery, non-class

certification and potential delays of recovery associated with the continued litigation of these claims.



- 4 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

There are approximately 1,765,180 Settlement Class Members for approximately 874,781

Settlement Class Vehicles.

7. The Court also finds that the Settlement was entered as a result of extensive arm’s-

length negotiations of disputed claims among experienced counsel, and that there was no collusion.

The Settlement was entered into with a sufficient understanding by counsel of the strengths and

weaknesses of their respective cases, and of the potential risks versus benefits of continued

litigation, including but not limited to the ability to establish and/or extent of establishing liability,

damages, class certification, and maintenance of class certification through trial and potential

appeals. These factors have been explained to the Court’s satisfaction in the parties’ submissions.

8. As set forth in the Settlement Agreement, the Court finds that the Settlement does

not and shall not constitute any admission, acknowledgement or evidence of any wrongdoing or

liability on the part of Defendant or any Released Party, or of the merit of any claim or allegation

that was or could have been asserted in this Litigation.

9. Of the 1,765,180 Settlement Class Members, only four (4) objections were received

and only 302 Settlement Class Members submitted timely and valid requests for exclusion from the

Settlement. The Court finds that this demonstrates an extremely favorable reaction of the Class to

the Settlement, which further supports the finding herein that the Settlement is fair, reasonable and

adequate.

10. The Court has reviewed the parties’ submissions and hereby approves and accepts

the settlements and withdrawals of the objections of Marla S. Hyde (Dkt. No.89) and Karen King

(Dkt. No.90). These objections are hereby deemed withdrawn. The Court further these objections

to be without merit in any event.

11. The Court, having carefully considered the objections of Cynthia Middlebrooks (Dkt.

No. 91) and Cindy Bascoe (Dkt. No. 101), including all related submissions and arguments, finds

that these objections lack merit. These objections are hereby overruled.

12. The Court has considered the following requests for exclusion and finds them to be

invalid for failure to provide one or more of the required information set forth in the Preliminary

Approval Order and explained in the Class Notice: Jacquieline Haines, Patricia Young, James



- 5 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Bergstrom and Martha Vega (failure to provide VIN of their vehicles, as required), Judith Smith,

Virginia Wiepking, Robert Wiepking and Rober Willard (failure to provide their phone numbers, as

required), Veronica Gray and Marilyn Claus (failure to provide multiple required information

including the models, model years and VINs of their vehicles).

13. The Court appreciates the fact that because any reimbursement pursuant to the

Settlement was contingent upon the issuance of a final approval order, the process of reviewing the

Settlement Class Member reimbursement claims for completeness and/or validity has only now

begun. However, the Court is aware and satisfied that, as of the date of the final fairness hearing,

approximately 27,140 reimbursement claims have been received by the Claims Administrator.

14. The Parties and Settlement Class Members have irrevocably submitted to the

exclusive jurisdiction of this Court for any suit, action, proceeding or dispute arising out of

Settlement.

15. It is in the best interests of the Parties and the Settlement Class Members and

consistent with principles of judicial economy that any dispute between any Settlement Class

Member (including any dispute as to whether any person is a Settlement Class Member) and any

Released Party which in any way relates to the applicability, scope and/or interpretation of the

Settlement Agreement or this Final Order and Judgment, should be presented exclusively to this

Court for resolution by this Court.

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND ADJUDGED THAT:

The Court certifies, for the purpose of this Settlement, a Settlement Class consisting of the

following:

All persons or entities who purchased or leased a Settlement Class Vehicle defined as certain 2008 through 2014 model and model year VW and Audi vehicles, as more particularly designated by Vehicle Identification Number (“VIN”) listed on Exhibit 4 of the Settlement Agreement, imported and distributed by Defendant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. for sale or lease in the United States and Puerto Rico (hereinafter “the Settlement Class”). Excluded from the Settlement Class are (a) anyone claiming personal injury, property damage (other than to the Settlement Class Vehicle itself) and/or subrogation; (b) all Judges who have presided over this matter and their spouses; (c) all current employees, officers, directors, agents and representatives of Defendant, and their family members;



- 6 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

(d) any affiliate, parent or subsidiary of Defendant and any entity in which Defendant has a controlling interest; (e) anyone acting as a used car dealer; (f) anyone who purchased a Settlement Class Vehicle for the purpose of commercial resale; (g) anyone who purchased a Settlement Class Vehicle with salvaged title and/or any insurance company who acquired a Settlement Class Vehicle as a result of a total loss; (h) any insurer of a Settlement Class Vehicle; (i) issuers of extended vehicle warranties and service contracts; (j) any Settlement Class Member who, prior to the date of the Settlement Agreement, settled with and released Defendant or any Released Parties from any Released Claims, and (k) any Settlement Class Member that filed a timely and proper Request for Exclusion from the Settlement Class, as listed in Exhibit A.

16. The Settlement Agreement submitted by the Parties is, in all respects, finally

approved pursuant to FED. R. CIV. P. Rule 23(e) as fair, reasonable, adequate, and in the best

interests of the Settlement Class.

17. The settlements and withdrawals of the objections of Marla S. Hyde and Karen King

are hereby approved and accepted, and those objections are hereby deemed withdrawn. The Court

further finds these objections to be without merit.

18. The Objections of Cindy Bascoe (Dkt. 101) and Cynthia Middlebrooks (Dkt. 91)

have been duly considered and are hereby overruled.

19. The Court excludes from the Settlement and Release, on the basis of their timely and

valid requests for exclusion, the 302 Settlement Class Members who are listed on Exhibit A annexed

hereto. Any other requests for exclusion are hereby rejected as untimely or as otherwise failing to

provide information required by this Court.

20. The Parties are directed to perform all obligations under the Settlement Agreement

in accordance with its terms.

21. The Parties and each person or entity within the definition of the Settlement Class

are hereby bound in all respects by the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement, including

but not limited to the release of claims contained therein, except for those identified in Exhibit A

annexed hereto, who have duly and timely excluded themselves from the Settlement.

22. The Action is hereby dismissed, with prejudice and without costs.

23. This Final Approval Order and Judgment has been entered without any admission by

any Party as to the merits of any allegation in this Action and shall not constitute a finding of either



- 7 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

fact or law as to the merits of any claim or defense that was or could have been asserted in the

Action. Nothing in this Final Approval Order and Judgment, the Settlement Agreement, the

proceedings, or any documents, filings or statements related thereto, is or shall be deemed or

construed to be an admission, or evidence, of any liability or wrongdoing on the part of the

Defendant, or of any allegation or claim asserted in this action, all of which are expressly denied by

Defendant.

24. The Released Claims, as set forth in the Settlement Agreement, are hereby fully and

finally deemed released, discharged, compromised, settled and dismissed with prejudice against

Defendant and all Released Parties.

25. Members of the Settlement Class and their successors and assigns are hereby

permanently barred and enjoined from asserting, commencing, prosecuting, maintaining or

continuing to prosecute or maintain, either directly or indirectly, any Released Claim against any of

the Released Parties in any forum, whether judicial, administrative or otherwise, with the exception

of any Settlement Class Members who have duly and timely excluded themselves from the

Settlement, as listed for purposes of identification on Exhibit A annexed hereto.

26. The Court appoints Plaintiffs Gregory Coffeng, Mark Glaser and Jordan Wilson as

representatives of the Settlement Class, and approves a service award of two thousand five hundred

dollars ($2,500.00) to each of the said Plaintiffs as a reasonable payment for his efforts, expenses

and risk in bringing this action, which shall be paid by Defendant as provided in the Settlement

Agreement.

27. The law firms of Kantrowitz Goldhamer & Graifman, P.C., Stull, Stull and Brody,

and Thomas B. Sobran, P.C., previously appointed as Interim Class Counsel for the Settlement Class

in the Preliminary Approval Order (Dkt. No. 82), are hereby confirmed and appointed as Class

Counsel for the Settlement Class.

28. Based upon Class Counsel’s submissions and arguments, including Class Counsel’s

lodestar, costs and expenses, and Settlement value estimate, the Court hereby approves Class

Counsel’s request for an award of reasonable attorney fees, costs and expenses in the collective

combined total amount of two million four hundred thousand dollars ($2,400,000.00), consisting of



- 8 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

$40,754.66 for all costs and expenses and $2,359,245.34 for all attorney fees (collectively, the “fee

and expense award”), which amounts shall be paid by Defendant in the manner set forth in the

Settlement Agreement. The Court finds said fee and expense award to be reasonable and consistent

with applicable law.

29. The Court further directs that of the aforesaid fee and expense award, the

$2,359,245.34 attributed to the Class Counsel’s collective attorney fees Counsel shall be paid as

follows: (i) seventy-five percent (75%), or $1,769,434, shall be paid pursuant to the terms of the

Settlement Agreement, and (ii) the remaining twenty-five percent (25%), or $589,811.34, shall be

paid within ten (10) business days after Class Counsel’s submission, to the Court, of the post-

distribution accounting required under the Northern District Procedural Guidance for Class Action

Settlements. Said payments are to be made to the Class Counsel designee set forth in the Settlement

Agreement, and shall constitute satisfaction in full of any and all obligations of Defendant with

respect to the payment of attorney fees, costs and expenses in connection with this action and

controversy.

30. The Court also confirms the approval of Epiq Class Action & Claims Solutions, Inc.

as Claims Administrator to effectuate the duties and responsibilities set forth in the Settlement

Agreement.

31. Without affecting the finality of this judgment, the Court’s retained jurisdiction of

this Settlement also includes the administration and consummation of the Settlement. In addition,

without affecting the finality of this judgment, the Court retains exclusive jurisdiction of, and the

Parties and all Settlement Class Members are hereby deemed to have submitted to the exclusive

jurisdiction of this Court for, any suit, action, proceeding or dispute arising out of or relating to this

Order and Judgment, the Settlement Agreement, or the Applicability of the Settlement Agreement.

///

///

///



- 9 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

32. The Court finds that no just reason exists for delay in entering this Final Order and

Judgment. Accordingly, the Clerk is hereby directed to enter final judgment.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

Dated: __________________ ___________________________________________ Honorable James Donato United States District Judge

Respectfully submitted by:

Patrice L. Bishop Stull, Stull & Brody 8383 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 800 Beverly Hills, CA 90211 Tel: (323) 456-8638 Fax: (323) 456-8601 Email: [email protected] Local Counsel for Plaintiff Gregory Coffeng Gary S. Graifman Jay I. Brody Kantrowitz, Goldhamer & Graifman, P.C. 747 Chestnut Ridge Road Chestnut Ridge, NY 10977 Tel: (845) 356-2570 Fax: (845) 356-4335 Email: [email protected] Thomas P. Sobran Thomas P. Sobran, P.C. 7 Evergreen Lane Hingham, MA 02043 Tel: (781) 741-6075 Fax: (781) 741-6074 Email: [email protected] Counsel for Plaintiffs Gregory Coffeng, Mark Glaser, and Jordan Wilson

Michael B. Gallub Herzfeld & Rubin, P.C. 125 Broad Street New York, NY 10004 Tel: (212) 471-8536 Email: [email protected]

June 10, 2020



- 10 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Craig L. Winterman Herzfeld & Rubin LLP 10866 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 800 Los Angeles CA 90024 Tel: (310) 553-0451 Fax: (310) 553-0648 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Defendant, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.


EX

HIB

IT A


Source Date Submitted First Name Last Name Make Model Year Redacted VIN Status

1 Paper Opt Out 12/6/2019 David Rousseau Audi A4 2011 ************02563 Complete2 Paper Opt Out 12/8/2019 Pamela Massey Audi A5 2013 ************10036 Complete3 Paper Opt Out 12/9/2019 Sandra Miller Volkswagen CC 2011 ************07103 Complete4 Paper Opt Out 12/9/2019 Carol Walsh Audi A4 2011 ************51530 Complete5 Paper Opt Out 12/10/2019 Kathleen Booth Volkswagen CC 2010 ************11831 Complete6 Paper Opt Out 12/10/2019 Michael Sterner Volkswagen CC 2010 ************04825 Complete7 Paper Opt Out 12/11/2019 Kimberly Rogers Audi A5 2013 ************09497 Complete8 Paper Opt Out 12/14/2019 Ann Faitz Volkswagen EOS 2009 ************23397 Complete9 Paper Opt Out 12/17/2019 Thelma Cruz Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************52331 Complete

10 Paper Opt Out 12/19/2019 Sadmir Halilovich Volkswagen CC 2010 ************29400 Complete11 Paper Opt Out 12/23/2019 Jacob Earley Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************99658 Complete12 Paper Opt Out 12/27/2019 Andrew Terranova Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************25570 Complete13 Paper Opt Out 1/8/2020 Susan French Audi A4 2013 ************09216 Complete14 Paper Opt Out 1/13/2020 Elaine Leong Volkswagen Passat 2010 ************66491 Complete15 Paper Opt Out 1/27/2020 Henry Kluck Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************00431 Complete16 Paper Opt Out 2/6/2020 Leah Bartlett Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************45929 Complete17 Paper Opt Out 2/10/2020 Robert Foutz Volkswagen GTI 2009 ************03103 Complete18 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Adolfo Gonzalez Volkswagen CC 2014 ************39075 Complete19 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Alexandra Wright Volkswagen Jetta 2014 ************43689 Complete20 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Alma Arredondo Volkswagen Jetta 2012 ************16936 Complete21 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Araceli Salvador Volkswagen Jetta 2014 ************14257 Complete22 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Camoron Wright Volkswagen CC 2010 ************19248 Complete23 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 DeJuan Oliver Volkswagen CC 2010 ************12890 Complete24 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Eric De Los Santos Volkswagen CC 2011 ************30753 Complete25 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Jamie Cortez Volkswagen Jetta 2013 ************01401 Complete26 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Jason Wolf Volkswagen Jetta 2009 ************50974 Complete27 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Mary Shade Volkswagen Jetta 2013 ************08995 Complete28 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Monica Gonzalez De Garcia Volkswagen CC 2014 ************39075 Complete29 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Nobert Brown Volkswagen CC 2012 ************06523 Complete30 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Olga Barajas Volkswagen Jetta 2013 ************01401 Complete31 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Timothy Bui Volkswagen CC 2010 ************25711 Complete32 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Timothy Painter Volkswagen Jetta 2011 ************11664 Complete33 Paper Opt Out 2/13/2020 Vicki Brown Volkswagen CC 2012 ************06523 Complete34 Web Opt Out 01/01/2020 Stephen Gross Audi A4 2014 ************12050 Complete35 Web Opt Out 01/02/2020 Joshua Wilson Volkswagen GTi 2013 ************06479 Complete36 Web Opt Out 01/02/2020 Vivian Ellis Volkswagen CC 2009 ************43455 Complete37 Web Opt Out 01/07/2020 Joseph Kidd Audi A5 2012 ************27575 Complete38 Web Opt Out 01/11/2020 shan yao Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************83089 Complete39 Web Opt Out 01/12/2020 Fuijae Lee Volkswagen CC 2010 ************63089 Complete40 Web Opt Out 01/22/2020 Christopher Gorski Audi a5 2010 ************53120 Complete

Complete Opt Outs

Coffeng v Volkswagen Settlement - CA4161Opt Out Report - Report Date: 3/13/2020



41 Web Opt Out 01/26/2020 Michael Stark Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************02084 Complete42 Web Opt Out 01/26/2020 Ernesto Cancel Volkswagen GTI 2010 ************24785 Complete43 Web Opt Out 01/29/2020 Sandra Dold Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************09556 Complete44 Web Opt Out 01/30/2020 David DePaola Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************25255 Complete45 Web Opt Out 02/02/2020 Yvonne Cottrell Volkswagen CC 2010 ************31706 Complete46 Web Opt Out 02/03/2020 Junqi Qian Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************10407 Complete47 Web Opt Out 02/04/2020 Jennifer Damron Audi A3 2009 ************00991 Complete48 Web Opt Out 02/06/2020 Carol Jackimowicz Volkswagen CC Sport 2013 ************69990 Complete49 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Nahid Ghasemi Volkswagen CC 2013 ************57186 Complete50 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Edwin Cho Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************33771 Complete51 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Robert Ragasa Volkswagen Jetta 2013 ************32705 Complete52 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Isaac Rojas Volkswagen CC 2012 ************04357 Complete53 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Paul Solby Volkswagen CC 2010 ************21731 Complete54 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Michael Nassar Volkswagen CC 2012 ************35525 Complete55 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Lindsey Macklin Volkswagen CC 2010 ************59608 Complete56 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Lakeisha Macklin Volkswagen CC 2010 ************59608 Complete57 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Gregory Buri Volkswagen GTI 2010 ************89412 Complete58 Web Opt Out 02/07/2020 Gilberto Floresta Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************13344 Complete59 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Mansour Jafari Volkswagen CC 2012 ************11655 Complete60 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Milad Jafari Volkswagen CC 2012 ************11655 Complete61 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Luciano Franco Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************12038 Complete62 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Derick Hockaday Volkswagen CC 2010 ************46716 Complete63 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Wendy Gavia Delgado Volkswagen CC 2010 ************25256 Complete64 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Katherine Miller Volkswagen CC 2014 ************15363 Complete65 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Marie Zanderson Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************39129 Complete66 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Christopher Grapsas Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************28876 Complete67 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Thuy Chung Volkswagen EOS 2012 ************01571 Complete68 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Magdalena Campuzano Volkswagen CC 2010 ************58040 Complete69 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Eloy Campuzano Volkswagen CC 2010 ************58040 Complete70 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Scott Rubin Volkswagen Passat 2010 ************91522 Complete71 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Roseanne Rubin Volkswagen Passat 2010 ************91522 Complete72 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Jorge Villasenor Volkswagen CC 2012 ************21852 Complete73 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 George Villasenor Volkswagen CC 2012 ************21852 Complete74 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Damon Sweatt Volkswagen CC 2013 ************20916 Complete75 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Robbin Bocchini Volkswagen Passat 2009 ************35898 Complete76 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Vincent Bocchini Volkswagen Passat 2009 ************35898 Complete77 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Aisha Martinez Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************42187 Complete78 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Julio Aguilar Linares Volkswagen CC 2012 ************04045 Complete79 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Carmen Summerson-Aguilar Volkswagen CC 2012 ************04045 Complete80 Web Opt Out 02/11/2020 Daria Saraczyn Audi A5 2014 ************13458 Complete81 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Susan Hlawatsch Volkswagen Tiquan 2011 ************35238 Complete82 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Karina Pascual Volkswagen Tiguan SE 2013 ************80026 Complete83 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Aubrey Parrott Volkswagen Passat 2010 ************55429 Complete84 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 David Parrott Volkswagen Passat 2013 ************55429 Complete85 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Lindsey Kucich Volkswagen EOS 2012 ************02947 Complete



86 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Matthew Cinquanta Volkswagen CC 2011 ************29285 Complete87 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Raul Vargas Volkswagen CC 2009 ************37707 Complete88 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Enedino Noyloa Volkswagen GTI 2011 ************48962 Complete89 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Eulonda Craig Volkswagen CC 2010 ************59956 Complete90 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Sidara Lay Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************49707 Complete91 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Brittney Smith Volkswagen CC 2010 ************57923 Complete92 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Naomi Washington Volkswagen CC 2010 ************57923 Complete93 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Cheryl Earhart Volkswagen CC 2012 ************12579 Complete94 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Taylor Burr Volkswagen Passat 2009 ************30846 Complete95 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Ericw Wallace Audi A4 2012 ************02448 Complete96 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Darryl Edwards Audi A4 2013 ************09938 Complete97 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Wenjing Xu Audi Q5 2012 ************42674 Complete98 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Carrie Bryden Audi A3 2012 ************26433 Complete99 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Fred Furman Audi A3 2013 ************29218 Complete

100 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Kristen Bowers Audi Q5 2014 ************18280 Complete101 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Erik Brazil Audi A5 2013 ************03543 Complete102 Web Opt Out 02/13/2020 Natalie Jaeger Audi Q5 2012 ************14188 Complete103 Web Opt Out 02/14/2020 Aisha Martinez Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************42187 Complete104 Web Opt Out 02/14/2020 Charles Rascher Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************00862 Complete105 Web Opt Out 02/14/2020 Donald McCaffree Volkswagen GTI 2009 ************45480 Complete106 Web Opt Out 02/14/2020 Martha Marshman Volkswagen CC 2013 ************09250 Complete107 Web Opt Out 02/14/2020 Matha Ayon Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************05184 Complete108 Web Opt Out 12/03/2019 Keon Jones Audi A4 2011 ************23485 Complete109 Web Opt Out 12/03/2019 ginamarie best Volkswagen Eos 2014 ************02146 Complete110 Web Opt Out 12/03/2019 Shahram Movahedi Volkswagen CC 2011 ************13415 Complete111 Web Opt Out 12/04/2019 David Merritt Audi Q5 2012 ************29060 Complete112 Web Opt Out 12/04/2019 Anthony Tiburzi Audi A6 2014 ************39161 Complete113 Web Opt Out 12/04/2019 Anthony Tiburzi Audi Q5 2014 ************35966 Complete114 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Iris Huang Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************16241 Complete115 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Larz Conwell Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************12183 Complete116 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Keith Bartlett Volkswagen Jetta 2009 ************05687 Complete117 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Keith Bartlett Volkswagen Eos 2014 ************00461 Complete118 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Gabriel Ventura Volkswagen gti 2013 ************96689 Complete119 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Aidan Hahn Audi Q5 2011 ************77979 Complete120 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Darrell Clarke Audi A4 2010 ************17932 Complete121 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 david cheyne Audi tt 2013 ************07729 Complete122 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Amy Hurd Audi A3 2012 ************05836 Complete123 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Jarius Cotton Audi A4 2010 ************45078 Complete124 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Brittany Karen Volkswagen Passat 2008 ************99989 Complete125 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Renee Martin Volkswagen Eos 2014 ************06321 Complete126 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Trevor Warkentin Audi A4 2011 ************15054 Complete127 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Luan Huynh Audi A6 2014 ************04502 Complete128 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Steven Pilcher Audi A4 Quattro 2011 ************44213 Complete129 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Amjad Pervaiz Volkswagen Jetta 2014 ************87384 Complete130 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Amit Mehta Audi A5 2013 ************56412 Complete



131 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Christina Dakin Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************05970 Complete132 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Christopher Antolino Audi Q5 2014 ************04523 Complete133 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Kevin Kenard Volkswagen CC 2009 ************34158 Complete134 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Neil Gordon Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************47448 Complete135 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 ANTOINETTE BOYD Volkswagen EOS 2009 ************17251 Complete136 Web Opt Out 12/05/2019 Charles Rider Audi A4 2013 ************83285 Complete137 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Kevin Donohoe Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************20413 Complete138 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Kim Jun Tuerto Volkswagen cc sports Lux 2011 ************28001 Complete139 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Mihai Enache Volkswagen CC 2013 ************13562 Complete140 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Camilo Hoyos Nino Volkswagen Jetta GLI 2014 ************46226 Complete141 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Tommie Ginn Audi CFFP 2013 ************43208 Complete142 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Dawn Schulz-Tan Audi Q5 2012 ************71730 Complete143 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Randie Kimmey Volkswagen Beetle 2013 ************30833 Complete144 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Chris Bargar Volkswagen Beetle 2013 ************01368 Complete145 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Michelle Stringer Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************23262 Complete146 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Megan Voissem Audi Allroad 2013 ************43551 Complete147 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Sheila May Volkswagen Passat 2009 ************53876 Complete148 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Barbara Holland Volkswagen TIGUAN 2013 ************51742 Complete149 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 zixu wang Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************02652 Complete150 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 David Cruise Audi A4 2014 ************26614 Complete151 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 jason meyers Audi a3 2009 ************41175 Complete152 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Joao Pinho Volkswagen GTI 2010 ************81346 Complete153 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Ann Trudgeon Volkswagen CC 2013 ************24124 Complete154 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Raju Nivarthi Audi Q5 2014 ************35754 Complete155 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Ann Trudgeon Volkswagen CC 2013 ************59328 Complete156 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 ANTONIO RIVERA JR Volkswagen CC 2012 ************13570 Complete157 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Timothy Hermesch Volkswagen CC R- Lineq 2014 ************06075 Complete158 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Ivan Lalic Audi A4 2011 ************10517 Complete159 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 pasquale Perrelli Audi s5 2008 ************08192 Complete160 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Christopher Gonzalez Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************38020 Complete161 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 shadi etemad Audi A4 2013 ************97391 Complete162 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Jose Gutierrez Molina Audi A4 2009 ************51196 Complete163 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Debra Nunes Audi A4 Wagon 2011 ************32798 Complete164 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Tracy Parsons Audi A5 2014 ************04577 Complete165 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Thomas Knott Audi A4 2011 ************42578 Complete166 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 sergio aguilera Audi aq5 2012 ************34341 Complete167 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 Martha Ostria Audi A4 2011 ************47522 Complete168 Web Opt Out 12/06/2019 carl brewer Audi A5 2011 ************00925 Complete169 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Hoang Nguyen Volkswagen GTI 2011 ************31517 Complete170 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Anthony Brozena Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************04286 Complete171 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 manish mathema Volkswagen cc 2012 ************10558 Complete172 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 fonzella Willis Volkswagen passat 2009 ************09870 Complete173 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Joanne Dellangelo Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************73540 Complete174 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Warren Eng Volkswagen GTI 2009 ************12400 Complete175 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Kwang YOON Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************36104 Complete



176 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Borhan Ai Audi A4 2013 ************09997 Complete177 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Rajendra Vemulapalli Audi A4 2009 ************68245 Complete178 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Tim Larson Audi Q5 2012 ************76180 Complete179 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Gretchen Matos Serrano Audi Q5 2013 ************88004 Complete180 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Xochitl Morales Audi Q5 2012 ************71860 Complete181 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Kathleen Rentschler Audi a4 2012 ************08980 Complete182 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 Mary Doten Audi Q5 2014 ************25005 Complete183 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 John Pelliccio Audi A5 Cabriolet 2013 ************14548 Complete184 Web Opt Out 12/07/2019 David Fiedler Audi A5 2013 ************65698 Complete185 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Andrei Matytsin Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************39033 Complete186 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Rodolfo Gallardo Volkswagen CC 2011 ************03045 Complete187 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Brett Doran Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************13368 Complete188 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 LINDA STERN Volkswagen Tiguan 2009 ************28423 Complete189 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 ALAN STERN Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************48008 Complete190 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Angela Messler Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************01499 Complete191 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Mary Pillmear Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************05171 Complete192 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 MATTHEW MILLARD Volkswagen Beetle 2013 ************46452 Complete193 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Thomas Vinh Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************21260 Complete194 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Ed Brydle Audi A4 2009 ************66592 Complete195 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Nathaniel Minami Audi A4` 2012 ************13465 Complete196 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 Keith Larrabee Audi Q5 2013 ************02142 Complete197 Web Opt Out 12/08/2019 ADAM GOMEZ Audi TT 2012 ************07501 Complete198 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Chris Bensey Volkswagen Tiguan 2009 ************01648 Complete199 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Zhongyue Sun Volkswagen CC 2013 ************08042 Complete200 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 mellody salinas Volkswagen beetle 2012 ************50591 Complete201 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Uriel Sanchez Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************03928 Complete202 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Jean Holznagel Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************29108 Complete203 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Robert Dalton Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************20420 Complete204 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Michael O'Shea Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************65400 Complete205 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 john Burrow Volkswagen gti 2014 ************04089 Complete206 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Lori Ribenstein Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************25985 Complete207 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 yaquelin castro Volkswagen jetta 2014 ************27099 Complete208 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 ANDRIJA GRBESIC Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************08810 Complete209 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Hank Pace Audi A5 2013 ************31804 Complete210 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Sarah Pleasant Volkswagen CC 2010 ************53843 Complete211 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Charles Nguti-Anye Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************25361 Complete212 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Kirk Hood Audi A4 2010 ************67380 Complete213 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Nadine Lee Audi A5 2013 ************43747 Complete214 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Sheldon Irons Audi A3 2010 ************15689 Complete215 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Tanya Balser Audi A5 2014 ************05771 Complete216 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Tracey McCormack Audi Audi 2010 ************13729 Complete217 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Robert Stamm Audi A4 2013 ************81728 Complete218 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Daniel Mnookin Audi Q5 2013 ************22690 Complete219 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Delvin Almon Audi Audi 2012 ************96508 Complete220 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Carmine Rullo Audi q5 2014 ************10521 Complete



221 Web Opt Out 12/09/2019 Alan Huang Audi Q5 2011 ************05409 Complete222 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Tara Helm Volkswagen Jetta 2013 ************98657 Complete223 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Catrice Ostine Volkswagen CC 2010 ************64538 Complete224 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Inocenta Rafael Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************06089 Complete225 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Kurt Bachmann Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************52393 Complete226 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Robert Pierre Volkswagen CC 2010 ************11331 Complete227 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Henry Mark Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************17614 Complete228 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 lafayette ross Volkswagen CC 2013 ************23240 Complete229 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 robin armsted-ross Volkswagen Passat 2010 ************67749 Complete230 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Elise Cozzi Volkswagen GTI 2012 ************20445 Complete231 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Mary Schuetz Volkswagen Bettle Turbo Convertible 2013 ************12945 Complete232 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Robin Finke Volkswagen Tiguan 2010 ************01649 Complete233 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Christian Briel Audi A3 2012 ************24184 Complete234 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Susan Davis Audi Q5 2012 ************28321 Complete235 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Shinika Phillips Audi A4 2014 ************77955 Complete236 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 CARLOS CONTRERASTORRES JR Audi A6 2013 ************99026 Complete237 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 ASHWIN KATUKURI Audi a4 2012 ************09296 Complete238 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 kehan li Audi A5 2014 ************42020 Complete239 Web Opt Out 12/10/2019 Amanda Murphy Audi A4 2014 ************16764 Complete240 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 Alondra Montero Volkswagen EOS 2009 ************21866 Complete241 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 Benjamin Ives Volkswagen Passat 2014 ************62527 Complete242 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 John Carr Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************95722 Complete243 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 GEDIAN WANG Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************02353 Complete244 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 CHRISTINE COLLINS Volkswagen EOS 2012 ************14762 Complete245 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 Jose Rojo Audi A4 2011 ************52280 Complete246 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 Lauren Shapiro Audi A5 2011 ************26194 Complete247 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 David Browne Audi Q5 2011 ************87752 Complete248 Web Opt Out 12/11/2019 Aaron Waksmundzki Audi A4 2013 ************47361 Complete249 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Margarete Kampa Volkswagen CC 2010 ************32026 Complete250 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Regina Henderson Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************19780 Complete251 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Bethany Mazur Volkswagen tiguan 2011 ************31475 Complete252 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Bethany Mazur Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************00452 Complete253 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Mark Beifuss Volkswagen Jetta-GLI 2009 ************41787 Complete254 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Quinae Austin Audi A4 2.0 2010 ************14275 Complete255 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Deborah DiMarco Audi A4 2009 ************31742 Complete256 Web Opt Out 12/12/2019 Travis Giese Audi A6 2014 ************90604 Complete257 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 James Lippard Jr Volkswagen EOS 2012 ************08689 Complete258 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 braulio rodriguez Volkswagen gti 2012 ************08008 Complete259 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 Jean Mozetich Volkswagen Jetta GLI 2014 ************53875 Complete260 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 William Gonzalez Volkswagen EOS 2014 ************07228 Complete261 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 Alexis Sowers Audi Q5 2013 ************88295 Complete262 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 Bridget Warne Audi A4 2014 ************05950 Complete263 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 Hsing Jao Audi Q5 2012 ************80297 Complete264 Web Opt Out 12/13/2019 Alison Egan Audi Q5 2014 ************13056 Complete265 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 Scarlett Abrell Volkswagen EOS 2012 ************04882 Complete



266 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 Ryan Malin Volkswagen Jetta GLI 2013 ************29824 Complete267 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 Terry Hardee Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************63801 Complete268 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 Markus Cleverley Audi Allroad 2014 ************69475 Complete269 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 Suchi Ma Audi Q5 2014 ************55662 Complete270 Web Opt Out 12/14/2019 zuleika santiago Audi a4 2010 ************36460 Complete271 Web Opt Out 12/15/2019 Daviary Rodriguez Volkswagen cc 2014 ************38507 Complete272 Web Opt Out 12/15/2019 Darren Chan Volkswagen Tiguan 2012 ************89691 Complete273 Web Opt Out 12/15/2019 Frank Rodgers Audi A4 2013 ************46308 Complete274 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 Ester Cordero Volkswagen Tiguan 2011 ************02156 Complete275 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 Kimberly King Volkswagen GTI 2009 ************05891 Complete276 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 Nakita Hunter Volkswagen CC 2010 ************60236 Complete277 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 John Scribner Volkswagen Passat 2008 ************69054 Complete278 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 Juan Prieto Audi A4 2013 ************35116 Complete279 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 Rodger Couser Audi Allroad 2013 ************78029 Complete280 Web Opt Out 12/16/2019 John Joyce Audi A4 2013 ************83186 Complete281 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Melanie Romero Volkswagen CC 2012 ************14143 Complete282 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Evan Firsick Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************25122 Complete283 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Lucas Rodriguez Volkswagen CC Sport 2014 ************17236 Complete284 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Evan Sheftel Volkswagen Tiguan 2013 ************89005 Complete285 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 KIRAN RUDRAMUNI Volkswagen EOS 2010 ************16269 Complete286 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Jonathon McAlexander Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************52367 Complete287 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 james Greene Audi Q5 2012 ************13375 Complete288 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Yolanda Costantini Audi Q5 2014 ************79482 Complete289 Web Opt Out 12/17/2019 Antonio Arguelles Audi All Road 2013 ************77280 Complete290 Web Opt Out 12/20/2019 Ji Hyun Volkswagen GTI 2013 ************37801 Complete291 Web Opt Out 12/21/2019 Javier Endara Volkswagen tiguan 2013 ************30297 Complete292 Web Opt Out 12/23/2019 Wenjing Xu Audi Q5 2012 ************42674 Complete293 Web Opt Out 12/23/2019 Keith Tipping Audi A4 2009 ************35498 Complete294 Web Opt Out 12/23/2019 Ermal Isufaj Audi A4 2010 ************46888 Complete295 Web Opt Out 12/23/2019 Marilee Pearson Audi Q5 2014 ************55854 Complete296 Web Opt Out 12/25/2019 Jesse stewart Audi A4 2009 ************13464 Complete297 Web Opt Out 12/27/2019 Jennifer Nosratian Volkswagen Tiguan 2014 ************70169 Complete298 Web Opt Out 12/27/2019 Debra Yerkes Volkswagen Jetta 2008 ************58833 Complete299 Web Opt Out 12/28/2019 NICOLA GERBINO Volkswagen TIGUAN 2010 ************00683 Complete300 Web Opt Out 12/28/2019 Leroy San Agustin Audi A4 2011 ************27087 Complete301 Web Opt Out 12/29/2019 Philip King Audi A4 2014 ************41314 Complete302 Web Opt Out 12/30/2019 Theresa Lee Volkswagen JETTA 2013 ************88461 Complete


case 3:17-cv-01825-jd document 106 filed 06/10/20 page 1 of 19 · 2020-06-12 · [proposed] final...

Documents