case 2:11-cv-02686-jwl document 82 filed …...2017/03/06 · phone," "business class...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS
SPRINT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY L.P.,
Plaintiff,
v. Case No. 2:11-cv-02686-JWL
TIME WARNER CABLE INC., TIME WARNER CABLE LLC, TIME WARNER ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY, L.P., TIME WARNER ENTERTAINMENT-DVANCE/NEWHOUSE PARTNERSHIP, TWC COMMUNICATIONS, LLC, TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (KANSAS), LLC,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants.
SPRINT'S SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Plaintiff Sprint Communications Company L.P. complains as follows against
defendants Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment
Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC
Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC.
PARTIES
1. Plaintiff Sprint Communications Company L.P. ("Sprint") is a Limited
Partnership organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal
place of business at 6200 Sprint Parkway, Overland Park, Kansas 66251.
2. On information and belief, defendant Time Warner Cable Inc. is a Corporation
organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal place of
business at 600 Columbus Circle, New York, New York 10023.
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � ! � " " �# �� � � $ % � � � $ � � � & � $ � � � � �� � � $ % � � � $ � � � & � $ � � � �� � � $ % � � � $ � $ � � $ � � � � � � $ � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ % � � � $ �$ � � $ � � � � � � $ � � ' ( ) � � � $ * � $ % + � � � $� � � � � $ � � + � � � � % � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � $ % � � � $ � � � & � $� � , � � � � � � � �� $ � ) � � $ � - . � � � � � / � � � � �( 0 " 0 1 � ! 2 �
/////////////////� � 2 0 � 3 � 4 5 6 6 ' 7 # ' 8 4 9 : 9 ' ; % �; � � � � � � � � ( $ � � � ( $ (
� < � � � = � � � � � � � > � � � � � � > < ? � � � �� � � � ! � " " � @ A � ! � 3 B B C � 7 � ! � 3 2 � 3 B @ � D � � � � 7 3 B @ � � � 2 � 2 " 3 � � 3 E 2 � F � � 2 !1 0 " 0 1 � ! 2 � � B 0 % � A 0 A � � G � 0 � 7 � � � � B 0 % � A 0 A � � G � 0 � � � � � � B 0 % � A 0 A $ ! 0 A ! � � B 0 !� 3 B @ � D � � � � � � � � B 0 % � A 0 A $ ! 0 A ! � � B 0 ! ' � 1 # � 7 0 * � 0 E H 3 C 2 0 � � A ! 0 A 2 H � @ � � % �� 3 B B C � 7 � ! � 3 2 � � � � � � 1 � � B 0 % � A 0 A � � G � 0 � " 3 A B � ! � 3 � 0 A # � 7 0 2 - . � 2 � 2 / � � � � �< � � � � �6 � � � � � ! � " " � @ A � ! � 3 B B C � 7 � ! � 3 2 � 3 B @ � D � � � � - I � @ A � ! J / � 2 � � � B � ! 0 1� � A ! 0 A 2 H � @ 3 A F � � K 0 1 � 1 0 L � 2 ! � F C 1 0 A ! H 0 � � E 2 3 " ! H 0 � ! � ! 0 3 " ( 0 � � E � A 0 � E � ! H � ! 2 @ A � 7 � @ � �@ � � 7 0 3 " G C 2 � 0 2 2 � ! 9 4 8 8 � @ A � ! � � A M E � D � � # 0 A � � 1 � � A M � . � 2 � 2 9 9 4 N 6 �4 � � � " 3 A B � ! � 3 � 1 G 0 � � 0 " � 1 0 " 0 1 � ! � � B 0 % � A 0 A � � G � 0 � 7 � � 2 � � 3 A @ 3 A � ! � 3 3 A F � � K 0 1 � 1 0 L � 2 ! � F C 1 0 A ! H 0 � � E 2 3 " ! H 0 � ! � ! 0 3 " ( 0 � � E � A 0 � E � ! H � ! 2 @ A � 7 � @ � � @ � � 7 0 3 "G C 2 � 0 2 2 � ! 9 8 8 � 3 � C B G C 2 � � A 7 � 0 � � 0 E � 3 A M � � 0 E � 3 A M 6 8 8 4 O �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 2 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 1 of 33
3. On information and belief, defendant Time Warner Cable LLC is a Limited
Liability Company organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its
principal place of business at 600 Columbus Circle, New York, New York 10023.
4. On information and belief, defendant Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P.
is a Limited Partnership registered to do business in the state of Kansas and organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal place of business at 600
Columbus Circle, New York, New York 10023 in care of Time Warner Cable Inc.
5. On information and belief, defendant Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership is a partnership registered to do business in the State of Kansas
and organized under the laws of the State of New York with its principal place of business at 600
Columbus Circle, New York, New York 10023 in care of Time Warner Cable Inc.
6. On information and belief, defendant TWC Communications, LLC is a Limited
Liability Company registered to do business in the State of Kansas and organized and existing
under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal place of business at 600 Columbus
Circle, New York, New York 10023 in care of Time Warner Cable Inc.
7. On information and belief, defendant Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC is a Limited Liability Company registered to do business in the State of Kansas
and organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal place of
business at 600 Columbus Circle, New York, New York 10023 in care of Time Warner Cable Inc.
8. On information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc. is the direct or indirect parent
of each of Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC. Time Warner Cable Inc. owns and operates cable
2 P
Q R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` \ ^ V ^ T \ Z T [ a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ d d c U e Z d U Y U [ ^ \d U Z ] U _ U [ f c W Y g Z T f W X h Z T U i ^ \ Z T \ ^ j U e [ U T h k T \ ^ X [ l ^ _ Z m e W V [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V o ^ _ Z m Z X ^ ` m U [ l U [ eg X U T p U g Z _ g _ Z p ^ W V ] k e U T ^ e e Z [ q r r c W _ k Y ] k e c U X p _ ^ ` s ^ m t W X u ` s ^ m t W X u v r r P Q Rw R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` \ ^ V ^ T \ Z T [ a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X x T [ ^ X [ Z U T Y ^ T [ c W Y g Z T f ` d R y RU e Z d U Y U [ ^ \ y Z X [ T ^ X e l U g X ^ h U e [ ^ X ^ \ [ W \ W ] k e U T ^ e e U T [ l ^ e [ Z [ ^ W V z Z T e Z e Z T \ W X h Z T U i ^ \ Z T \^ j U e [ U T h k T \ ^ X [ l ^ _ Z m e W V [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V o ^ _ Z m Z X ^ ` m U [ l U [ e g X U T p U g Z _ g _ Z p ^ W V ] k e U T ^ e e Z [ q r rc W _ k Y ] k e c U X p _ ^ ` s ^ m t W X u ` s ^ m t W X u v r r P Q U T p Z X ^ W V a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p R| R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` \ ^ V ^ T \ Z T [ a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X x T [ ^ X [ Z U T Y ^ T [ }~ \ � Z T p ^ � s ^ m l W k e ^ y Z X [ T ^ X e l U g U e Z g Z X [ T ^ X e l U g X ^ h U e [ ^ X ^ \ [ W \ W ] k e U T ^ e e U T [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V z Z T e Z eZ T \ W X h Z T U i ^ \ k T \ ^ X [ l ^ _ Z m e W V [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V s ^ m t W X u m U [ l U [ e g X U T p U g Z _ g _ Z p ^ W V ] k e U T ^ e e Z [ q r rc W _ k Y ] k e c U X p _ ^ ` s ^ m t W X u ` s ^ m t W X u v r r P Q U T p Z X ^ W V a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p Rq R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` \ ^ V ^ T \ Z T [ a b c c W Y Y k T U p Z [ U W T e ` d d c U e Z d U Y U [ ^ \d U Z ] U _ U [ f c W Y g Z T f X ^ h U e [ ^ X ^ \ [ W \ W ] k e U T ^ e e U T [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V z Z T e Z e Z T \ W X h Z T U i ^ \ Z T \ ^ j U e [ U T hk T \ ^ X [ l ^ _ Z m e W V [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V o ^ _ Z m Z X ^ ` m U [ l U [ e g X U T p U g Z _ g _ Z p ^ W V ] k e U T ^ e e Z [ q r r c W _ k Y ] k ec U X p _ ^ ` s ^ m t W X u ` s ^ m t W X u v r r P Q U T p Z X ^ W V a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p R� R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` \ ^ V ^ T \ Z T [ a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T V W X Y Z [ U W T n ^ X � U p ^ e� z Z T e Z e � ` d d c U e Z d U Y U [ ^ \ d U Z ] U _ U [ f c W Y g Z T f X ^ h U e [ ^ X ^ \ [ W \ W ] k e U T ^ e e U T [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V z Z T e Z eZ T \ W X h Z T U i ^ \ Z T \ ^ j U e [ U T h k T \ ^ X [ l ^ _ Z m e W V [ l ^ n [ Z [ ^ W V o ^ _ Z m Z X ^ ` m U [ l U [ e g X U T p U g Z _ g _ Z p ^ W V] k e U T ^ e e Z [ q r r c W _ k Y ] k e c U X p _ ^ ` s ^ m t W X u ` s ^ m t W X u v r r P Q U T p Z X ^ W V a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p R� R S T U T V W X Y Z [ U W T Z T \ ] ^ _ U ^ V ` a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p R U e [ l ^ \ U X ^ p [ W X U T \ U X ^ p [ g Z X ^ T [W V ^ Z p l W V a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ d d c ` a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X x T [ ^ X [ Z U T Y ^ T [ c W Y g Z T f ` d R y R ` a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ Xx T [ ^ X [ Z U T Y ^ T [ } ~ \ � Z T p ^ � s ^ m l W k e ^ y Z X [ T ^ X e l U g ` a b c c W Y Y k T U p Z [ U W T e ` d d c ` Z T \ a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ Xc Z ] _ ^ { T V W X Y Z [ U W T n ^ X � U p ^ e � z Z T e Z e � ` d d c R a U Y ^ b Z X T ^ X c Z ] _ ^ { T p R W m T e Z T \ W g ^ X Z [ ^ e p Z ] _ ^
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 3 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 2 of 33
systems throughout the United States and in the State of Kansas through one or more of its
subsidiaries, affiliates, partners, or other related parties, including but not limited to Time Warner
Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC.
9. On information and belief, defendants Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC, and/or one or more of their affiliates, provide or participate
in providing broadband or packet-based telephony products or services, including "Digital Home
Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and other related telephony services.
JURISDICTION
10. This is an action for patent infringement under the United States Patent Laws, 35
U.S.C. § 271, et. seq. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action under 28 U.S.C.
§§ 1331 and 1338.
11. On information and belief, defendants Time Warner Cable Inc. and Time Warner
Cable, LLC conduct business in this Judicial District and have committed acts of patent
infringement in this Judicial District including, inter alia, importing, making, using, offering for
sale, or selling infringing products or services in this Judicial District, including "Digital Home
Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and other related telephony services.
12. On information and belief, defendants Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P.,
Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and
Time Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC are registered to do business in this
Judicial District, conduct business in this Judicial District, and have committed acts of patent
3 �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¡ ¤ ¡ � � � � � � � � � � �£ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥ ¦ � § � � � � ¨ © � ª � � � � � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � « � � � � � � ¬ � ¢ ¢ � ¡ ¡ ® � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¡ ¤ ¡ � � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥¦ � § � � � � ¨ © � ª � � � � � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � « � � � � � � ¬ � ¢ ¢ � � � � � ¨ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¯ � � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ° ± � � � � � � ² � � �¤ � � � � � ³ ° ´ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ � � � � � ³ ° ´ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ µ � ³ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � ¡¶ · ¸ ¹ º » ¹ ¼ ½ ¹ ¾ ¿À Á ¡ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ � � � � � ¢ � ª � � � Â� ¡ � ¡ � ¡ Ã Ä Å À � Æ Ç È É Æ Ê È � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ë � � � � � � � � � Ë � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ä Ì � ¡ � ¡ � ¡Ã à À � � À � � � À � � Ì ¡À À ¡ ® � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Í � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Í � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Î Ï Ç Æ Ð Ñ Ò Î Ñ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¯ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � Í � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ° ± � � � � � � ² � � �¤ � � � � � ³ ° ´ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ � � � � � ³ ° ´ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ µ � ³ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � ¡À Ä ¡ ® � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¡ ¤ ¡ �� � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥ ¦ � § � � � � ¨ © � ª � � � � � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � « � � � � � � ¬ � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Í � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Í � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 4 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 3 of 33
infringement in this Judicial District including, inter alia, importing, making, using, offering for
sale, or selling infringing products or services in this Judicial District, including "Digital Home
Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and other related telephony services.
VENUE
13. Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391 and 1400(b).
JOINDER
14. Joinder of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner
Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership,
TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC is
proper under 35 U.S.C. § 299. The allegations of patent infringement contained herein arise out
of the same series of transactions or occurrences relating to the making, using, offering for sale,
or selling within the United States, or importing into the United States, of the same accused
products or services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class
PRI," and other related telephony services.
15. Common questions of fact relating to Time Warner's infringement will arise in
this action. For example, common questions of fact regarding the design, development, and
operation of Time Warner's telephone network architecture will arise in this action, as well as
common questions of fact concerning Time Warner's infringement of the patents-in-suit.
Likewise, common questions of fact exist as to profits and revenues derived by Time Warner
Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), as well as Sprint's damages for the same. On information
and belief, common questions of fact will also likely exist with regard to one or more of Time
Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time
4 Ó
Ô Õ Ö × Ô Õ Ø Ù Ú Ù Õ Û Ô Õ Û Ü Ô Ý Þ ß à Ô á Ô â ã ä Ô Ý Û × Ô á Û Ô Õ á ã ß à Ô Õ Ø å æ ç è é ê ë ì æ ë å Ô Ú í î × Û Ô Õ Ø å Ú â ï Ô Õ Ø å ß Ý Ô Õ Ø å î Ö Ö Ù × Ô Õ Ø Ö î ×Ý â ã Ù å î × Ý Ù ã ã Ô Õ Ø Ô Õ Ö × Ô Õ Ø Ô Õ Ø í × î à ß á Û Ý î × Ý Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý Ô Õ Û Ü Ô Ý Þ ß à Ô á Ô â ã ä Ô Ý Û × Ô á Û å Ô Õ á ã ß à Ô Õ Ø ñ ä Ô Ø Ô Û â ã ò î Ú Ùó Ü î Õ Ù å ô ñ õ ß Ý Ô Õ Ù Ý Ý ö ã â Ý Ý ó Ü î Õ Ù å ô ñ õ ß Ý Ô Õ Ù Ý Ý ö ã â Ý Ý ó ÷ ø å ô â Õ à î Û Ü Ù × × Ù ã â Û Ù à Û Ù ã Ù í Ü î Õ ù Ý Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý úû ü ý þ üÿ � ú � Ù Õ ß Ù Ô Ý í × î í Ù × Ô Õ Û Ü Ô Ý ö î ß × Û í ß × Ý ß â Õ Û Û î � � � ú � ú ö ú � � ÿ � � ÿ â Õ à ÿ Ó � � � ú� � ý � ü �ÿ Ó ú Þ î Ô Õ à Ù × î Ö � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù ø Õ á ú å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù � � ö å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù ×� Õ Û Ù × Û â Ô Õ Ú Ù Õ Û ö î Ú í â Õ ù å � ú ó ú å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Õ Û Ù × Û â Ô Õ Ú Ù Õ Û � � à ð â Õ á Ù � � Ù � Ü î ß Ý Ù ó â × Û Õ Ù × Ý Ü Ô í å� � ö ö î Ú Ú ß Õ Ô á â Û Ô î Õ Ý å � � ö å â Õ à � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù ø Õ Ö î × Ú â Û Ô î Õ � Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý � â Õ Ý â Ý � å � � ö Ô Ýí × î í Ù × ß Õ à Ù × � � � ú � ú ö ú � � � � ú � Ü Ù â ã ã Ù Ø â Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö í â Û Ù Õ Û Ô Õ Ö × Ô Õ Ø Ù Ú Ù Õ Û á î Õ Û â Ô Õ Ù à Ü Ù × Ù Ô Õ â × Ô Ý Ù î ß Ûî Ö Û Ü Ù Ý â Ú Ù Ý Ù × Ô Ù Ý î Ö Û × â Õ Ý â á Û Ô î Õ Ý î × î á á ß × × Ù Õ á Ù Ý × Ù ã â Û Ô Õ Ø Û î Û Ü Ù Ú â ï Ô Õ Ø å ß Ý Ô Õ Ø å î Ö Ö Ù × Ô Õ Ø Ö î × Ý â ã Ù åî × Ý Ù ã ã Ô Õ Ø � Ô Û Ü Ô Õ Û Ü Ù � Õ Ô Û Ù à � Û â Û Ù Ý å î × Ô Ú í î × Û Ô Õ Ø Ô Õ Û î Û Ü Ù � Õ Ô Û Ù à � Û â Û Ù Ý å î Ö Û Ü Ù Ý â Ú Ù â á á ß Ý Ù àí × î à ß á Û Ý î × Ý Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý å Ô Õ á ã ß à Ô Õ Ø ñ ä Ô Ø Ô Û â ã ò î Ú Ù ó Ü î Õ Ù å ô ñ õ ß Ý Ô Õ Ù Ý Ý ö ã â Ý Ý ó Ü î Õ Ù å ô ñ õ ß Ý Ô Õ Ù Ý Ý ö ã â Ý Ýó ÷ ø å ô â Õ à î Û Ü Ù × × Ù ã â Û Ù à Û Ù ã Ù í Ü î Õ ù Ý Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý úÿ � ú ö î Ú Ú î Õ � ß Ù Ý Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö Ö â á Û × Ù ã â Û Ô Õ Ø Û î � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Ý Ô Õ Ö × Ô Õ Ø Ù Ú Ù Õ Û � Ô ã ã â × Ô Ý Ù Ô ÕÛ Ü Ô Ý â á Û Ô î Õ ú � î × Ù � â Ú í ã Ù å á î Ú Ú î Õ � ß Ù Ý Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö Ö â á Û × Ù Ø â × à Ô Õ Ø Û Ü Ù à Ù Ý Ô Ø Õ å à Ù ð Ù ã î í Ú Ù Õ Û å â Õ àî í Ù × â Û Ô î Õ î Ö � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Ý Û Ù ã Ù í Ü î Õ Ù Õ Ù Û � î × ï â × á Ü Ô Û Ù á Û ß × Ù � Ô ã ã â × Ô Ý Ù Ô Õ Û Ü Ô Ý â á Û Ô î Õ å â Ý � Ù ã ã â Ýá î Ú Ú î Õ � ß Ù Ý Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö Ö â á Û á î Õ á Ù × Õ Ô Õ Ø � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Ý Ô Õ Ö × Ô Õ Ø Ù Ú Ù Õ Û î Ö Û Ü Ù í â Û Ù Õ Û Ý � Ô Õ � Ý ß Ô Û ú� Ô ï Ù � Ô Ý Ù å á î Ú Ú î Õ � ß Ù Ý Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö Ö â á Û Ù � Ô Ý Û â Ý Û î í × î Ö Ô Û Ý â Õ à × Ù ð Ù Õ ß Ù Ý à Ù × Ô ð Ù à ù � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù ×ö â ã Ù ø Õ á ú å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù � � ö å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Õ Û Ù × Û â Ô Õ Ú Ù Õ Û ö î Ú í â Õ ù å � ú ó ú å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù ×� Õ Û Ù × Û â Ô Õ Ú Ù Õ Û � � à ð â Õ á Ù � � Ù � Ü î ß Ý Ù ó â × Û Õ Ù × Ý Ü Ô í å � � ö ö î Ú Ú ß Õ Ô á â Û Ô î Õ Ý å � � ö å â Õ à � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù ×ö â ã Ù ø Õ Ö î × Ú â Û Ô î Õ � Ù × ð Ô á Ù Ý � â Õ Ý â Ý � å â Ý � Ù ã ã â Ý � í × Ô Õ Û � Ý à â Ú â Ø Ù Ý Ö î × Û Ü Ù Ý â Ú Ù ú Õ Ô Õ Ö î × Ú â Û Ô î Õâ Õ à Ù ã Ô Ù Ö å á î Ú Ú î Õ � ß Ù Ý Û Ô î Õ Ý î Ö Ö â á Û � Ô ã ã â ã Ý î ã Ô ï Ù ã ù Ù � Ô Ý Û � Ô Û Ü × Ù Ø â × à Û î î Õ Ù î × Ú î × Ù î Ö � Ô Ú Ù� â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù ø Õ á ú å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × ö â ã Ù � � ö å � Ô Ú Ù � â × Õ Ù × � Õ Û Ù × Û â Ô Õ Ú Ù Õ Û ö î Ú í â Õ ù å � ú ó ú å � Ô Ú Ù
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 5 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 4 of 33
Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time
Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC's defenses in this litigation, if any.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Sprint's Voice-over-Packet ("VoP") Technology
16. In 1993, Sprint's leading technology specialists and engineers were attempting to
solve a very important problem affecting Sprint's ability to expand its network to support its
rapidly growing customer base. At that time, virtually all voice traffic was carried over the Public
Switched Telephone Network ("PSTN"), which utilized highly complex, extremely expensive
switches and other well-established components to route this traffic. One solution to Sprint's
problem—a solution that Sprint had used in the past—was to simply purchase additional
switches from the legacy manufacturers and install those in its network. Adding switches,
however, was extremely expensive and time consuming because Sprint's entire network of
switches would have to be reprogrammed for each switch addition or upgrade. In addition, voice
traffic on the PSTN was transported using inherently inefficient synchronous circuit-switching. A
circuit was reserved for the entire length of a call on the PSTN, which wasted significant
bandwidth during periods of time when no conversation was occurring. But legacy circuit-based
systems had long been widely used to carry voice communications, and there were no viable
alternatives in the marketplace available to Sprint or other carriers at the time.
17. One of Sprint's talented technologists, Joe Christie, observed that data
communications between computers were handled differently. Computers communicated with
each other using "packets" of data. Packet communications, unlike the synchronous
communications of the PSTN, could occur "asynchronously" where the sending and receiving
points could send and receive out of synch with each other. This created an opportunity to realize
substantial efficiencies by transmitting voice data packets only when there is voice data to send
5 !
" # $ % & $ ' % ( & $ ( # ) % * & % ( + , - . # % / & 0 1 & 2 3 4 5 6 & 7 # $ ( % & $ 6 3 ) 8 9 : " ; ; 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( ) 4 % 6 9 < < ; 9 # % - : ) * &" # $ % & $ ; # = > & ? % @ 4 $ * # ( ) 4 % A & $ . ) / & 6 B C # % 6 # 6 D 9 < < ; E 6 - & @ & % 6 & 6 ) % ( 3 ) 6 > ) ( ) F # ( ) 4 % 9 ) @ # % G HI J K L M J N O J K P Q R S M T UV W X Y Z [ \ ] ^ _ Y ` a b _ c a X b d e ` f a [ g h ^ _ d i j L a ` k Z _ l _ m no p H ? % o q q r 9 A 8 $ ) % ( E 6 > & # - ) % F ( & / 3 % 4 > 4 F G 6 8 & / ) # > ) 6 ( 6 # % - & % F ) % & & $ 6 2 & $ & # ( ( & * 8 ( ) % F ( 46 4 > . & # . & $ G ) * 8 4 $ ( # % ( 8 $ 4 = > & * # @ @ & / ( ) % F A 8 $ ) % ( E 6 # = ) > ) ( G ( 4 & s 8 # % - ) ( 6 % & ( 2 4 $ t ( 4 6 5 8 8 4 $ ( ) ( 6$ # 8 ) - > G F $ 4 2 ) % F / 5 6 ( 4 * & $ = # 6 & H , ( ( 3 # ( ( ) * & 9 . ) $ ( 5 # > > G # > > . 4 ) / & ( $ # @ @ ) / 2 # 6 / # $ $ ) & - 4 . & $ ( 3 & 7 5 = > ) /A 2 ) ( / 3 & - : & > & 8 3 4 % & 1 & ( 2 4 $ t B u 7 A : 1 v D 9 2 3 ) / 3 5 ( ) > ) w & - 3 ) F 3 > G / 4 * 8 > & s 9 & s ( $ & * & > G & s 8 & % 6 ) . &6 2 ) ( / 3 & 6 # % - 4 ( 3 & $ 2 & > > + & 6 ( # = > ) 6 3 & - / 4 * 8 4 % & % ( 6 ( 4 $ 4 5 ( & ( 3 ) 6 ( $ # @ @ ) / H x % & 6 4 > 5 ( ) 4 % ( 4 A 8 $ ) % ( E 68 $ 4 = > & * y # 6 4 > 5 ( ) 4 % ( 3 # ( A 8 $ ) % ( 3 # - 5 6 & - ) % ( 3 & 8 # 6 ( y 2 # 6 ( 4 6 ) * 8 > G 8 5 $ / 3 # 6 & # - - ) ( ) 4 % # >6 2 ) ( / 3 & 6 @ $ 4 * ( 3 & > & F # / G * # % 5 @ # / ( 5 $ & $ 6 # % - ) % 6 ( # > > ( 3 4 6 & ) % ) ( 6 % & ( 2 4 $ t H , - - ) % F 6 2 ) ( / 3 & 6 93 4 2 & . & $ 9 2 # 6 & s ( $ & * & > G & s 8 & % 6 ) . & # % - ( ) * & / 4 % 6 5 * ) % F = & / # 5 6 & A 8 $ ) % ( E 6 & % ( ) $ & % & ( 2 4 $ t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z 5 ( > & F # / G / ) $ / 5 ) ( + = # 6 & -6 G 6 ( & * 6 3 # - > 4 % F = & & % 2 ) - & > G 5 6 & - ( 4 / # $ $ G . 4 ) / & / 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( ) 4 % 6 9 # % - ( 3 & $ & 2 & $ & % 4 . ) # = > &# > ( & $ % # ( ) . & 6 ) % ( 3 & * # $ t & ( 8 > # / & # . # ) > # = > & ( 4 A 8 $ ) % ( 4 $ 4 ( 3 & $ / # $ $ ) & $ 6 # ( ( 3 & ( ) * & Ho { H x % & 4 @ A 8 $ ) % ( E 6 ( # > & % ( & - ( & / 3 % 4 > 4 F ) 6 ( 6 9 | 4 & ; 3 $ ) 6 ( ) & 9 4 = 6 & $ . & - ( 3 # ( - # ( #/ 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( ) 4 % 6 = & ( 2 & & % / 4 * 8 5 ( & $ 6 2 & $ & 3 # % - > & - - ) @ @ & $ & % ( > G H ; 4 * 8 5 ( & $ 6 / 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( & - 2 ) ( 3& # / 3 4 ( 3 & $ 5 6 ) % F u 8 # / t & ( 6 v 4 @ - # ( # H 7 # / t & ( / 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( ) 4 % 6 9 5 % > ) t & ( 3 & 6 G % / 3 $ 4 % 4 5 6/ 4 * * 5 % ) / # ( ) 4 % 6 4 @ ( 3 & 7 A : 1 9 / 4 5 > - 4 / / 5 $ u # 6 G % / 3 $ 4 % 4 5 6 > G v 2 3 & $ & ( 3 & 6 & % - ) % F # % - $ & / & ) . ) % F8 4 ) % ( 6 / 4 5 > - 6 & % - # % - $ & / & ) . & 4 5 ( 4 @ 6 G % / 3 2 ) ( 3 & # / 3 4 ( 3 & $ H : 3 ) 6 / $ & # ( & - # % 4 8 8 4 $ ( 5 % ) ( G ( 4 $ & # > ) w &6 5 = 6 ( # % ( ) # > & @ @ ) / ) & % / ) & 6 = G ( $ # % 6 * ) ( ( ) % F . 4 ) / & - # ( # 8 # / t & ( 6 4 % > G 2 3 & % ( 3 & $ & ) 6 . 4 ) / & - # ( # ( 4 6 & % -
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 6 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 5 of 33
and refraining from wasting valuable bandwidth during periods of silence. In addition, unlike the
complex and expensive switches used in the PSTN, data packets could be routed using fairly
inexpensive components that could be made available from a number of competing vendors.
Unfortunately, the two systems were not compatible with each other. Interfacing a circuit-
switched system with a packet-based system in a geographically expansive telecommunications
environment was not a reality, at least not before Joe Christie.
1 8 . Joe Christie was an expert in two dissimilar technologies: packet-based networks
and SS7 signaling (which was used by the PSTN to set up voice calls). Mr. Christie proposed a
solution that would ultimately revolutionize the telecommunications industry. He devised a way
to leverage the efficiencies of packet-based networks to make telephone calls to and from the
PSTN. To do so, Mr. Christie invented a series of architectures, components, and processes that
would allow the PSTN to "talk" to packet-based networks to set up and route telephone calls
across these disparate networks in a seamless and transparent manner. These calls were highly
efficient and substantially decreased the need for telephone companies to rely on expensive
legacy PSTN equipment.
19. Mr. Christie's Voice-over-Packet ("VoP") technology reduced or eliminated the
need of service providers to rely on conventional switches and switch-to-switch call processing.
Instead, Mr. Christie conceived of centralizing network control by using a call processor to
orchestrate calls over his new packet-based system. The call processor acted like the brains of the
network, determining where a call needed to go and then enabling routing to its destination. This
call processor extracted the intelligence of expensive and complicated legacy switches and
placed this intelligence on functionally separate computer platforms. By extracting call control
from the switch manufacturers, Mr. Christie allowed a host of competitors to provide processing
6 }
~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � ~ � � ~ � ~ � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � �~ � � � � £ � � � � ~ � � � � ¤ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � ¥ � ¦ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~� � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ �� � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � ¦ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ �� � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � © � ~ � � ª � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � �~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � ~ � � � � � � � « � � � � � � � � ¬ � ¦ � � � � � � � � � � � ® � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � ¤ © ® � � ª ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � ~ � � ¦ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � § � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � �� ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � ~ � �� � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ¯ � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ¦ � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 7 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 6 of 33
equipment and to get into the business of telephony. This innovation would eventually increase
competition, drive down the costs of telephony, and greatly improve efficiency.
20. When Mr. Christie presented his innovations to Sprint executives and Sprint
technical management, they recognized the importance of his innovations. Mr. Christie's
inventions had the potential to render obsolete major components within the PSTN and to break
the grip that switch manufacturers held on carriers and service providers. Mr. Christie's
innovations could dramatically alter the way telephone calls were made and change the
landscape of the relative strength and leverage of the players in the industry. They represented a
sea change in telephony, and Mr. Christie's colleagues at Sprint, including upper-level
executives, realized it. Sprint promptly assigned a patent agent to shadow Mr. Christie to learn as
much as possible about the various aspects of his new systems and to seek patent protection.
Sprint also assigned a team of some of Sprint's most talented engineers to work with Mr. Christie
and to help develop concepts into tangible platforms. Due to the highly sensitive nature of the
project, the team was sequestered in a Kansas City facility and instructed to maintain the project
in the strictest of confidence. Few people in Sprint knew of this project at the time.
21. Joe Christie died unexpectedly in his home in February of 1996. Mr. Christie did
not live to see his innovations deployed into a commercial platform. But Mr. Christie's
revolutionary inventions have an enduring legacy. Mr. Christie's inventions and the related
innovations made by people working with Mr. Christie have resulted in a VoP patent portfolio of
over 120 issued United States Patents. Unfortunately, many companies in the industry, including
Time Warner, have realized the great value in this technology and have misappropriated it
without Sprint's permission. It is because of this unauthorized use that Sprint has taken efforts to
enforce this patent portfolio against others in the industry in the past and is now enforcing its
7 °
± ² ³ ´ µ ¶ ± · ¸ ¹ · º ¸ » ¼ ± ¸ ´ · ¸ » ¸ ½ ± ¾ ³ ¿ ´ · ± ¿ ¿ » À ¸ ± Á ± µ ½ » · Â Ã Ä ½ ´ ¿ ´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · Æ » ³ Á º ± Å ± · ¸ ³ ¹ Á Á  ´ · Ç È ± ¹ ¿ ±Ç » ¶ µ ± ¸ ´ ¸ ´ » · É º È ´ Å ± º » Æ · ¸ ½ ± Ç » ¿ ¸ ¿ » À ¸ ± Á ± µ ½ » · Â É ¹ · º ¼ È ± ¹ ¸ Á  ´ ¶ µ È » Å ± ± À À ´ Ç ´ ± · Ç Â ÃÊ Ë Ã Ì ½ ± · Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± µ È ± ¿ ± · ¸ ± º ½ ´ ¿ ´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · ¿ ¸ » Ï µ È ´ · ¸ ± Ð ± Ç ³ ¸ ´ Å ± ¿ ¹ · º Ï µ È ´ · ¸¸ ± Ç ½ · ´ Ç ¹ Á ¶ ¹ · ¹ ¼ ± ¶ ± · ¸ É ¸ ½ ± Â È ± Ç » ¼ · ´ Ñ ± º ¸ ½ ± ´ ¶ µ » È ¸ ¹ · Ç ± » À ½ ´ ¿ ´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · ¿ Ã Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± Ò ¿´ · Å ± · ¸ ´ » · ¿ ½ ¹ º ¸ ½ ± µ » ¸ ± · ¸ ´ ¹ Á ¸ » È ± · º ± È » ¾ ¿ » Á ± ¸ ± ¶ ¹ Ó » È Ç » ¶ µ » · ± · ¸ ¿ Æ ´ ¸ ½ ´ · ¸ ½ ± Ô Ï Ä Õ ¹ · º ¸ » ¾ È ± ¹ Ö¸ ½ ± ¼ È ´ µ ¸ ½ ¹ ¸ ¿ Æ ´ ¸ Ç ½ ¶ ¹ · ³ À ¹ Ç ¸ ³ È ± È ¿ ½ ± Á º » · Ç ¹ È È ´ ± È ¿ ¹ · º ¿ ± È Å ´ Ç ± µ È » Å ´ º ± È ¿ Ã Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± Ò ¿´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · ¿ Ç » ³ Á º º È ¹ ¶ ¹ ¸ ´ Ç ¹ Á Á  ¹ Á ¸ ± È ¸ ½ ± Æ ¹  ¸ ± Á ± µ ½ » · ± Ç ¹ Á Á ¿ Æ ± È ± ¶ ¹ º ± ¹ · º Ç ½ ¹ · ¼ ± ¸ ½ ±Á ¹ · º ¿ Ç ¹ µ ± » À ¸ ½ ± È ± Á ¹ ¸ ´ Å ± ¿ ¸ È ± · ¼ ¸ ½ ¹ · º Á ± Å ± È ¹ ¼ ± » À ¸ ½ ± µ Á ¹  ± È ¿ ´ · ¸ ½ ± ´ · º ³ ¿ ¸ È Â Ã Ä ½ ± Â È ± µ È ± ¿ ± · ¸ ± º ¹¿ ± ¹ Ç ½ ¹ · ¼ ± ´ · ¸ ± Á ± µ ½ » · Â É ¹ · º Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± Ò ¿ Ç » Á Á ± ¹ ¼ ³ ± ¿ ¹ ¸ Ï µ È ´ · ¸ É ´ · Ç Á ³ º ´ · ¼ ³ µ µ ± È × Á ± Å ± Á± Ð ± Ç ³ ¸ ´ Å ± ¿ É È ± ¹ Á ´ Ñ ± º ´ ¸ Ã Ï µ È ´ · ¸ µ È » ¶ µ ¸ Á  ¹ ¿ ¿ ´ ¼ · ± º ¹ µ ¹ ¸ ± · ¸ ¹ ¼ ± · ¸ ¸ » ¿ ½ ¹ º » Æ Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± ¸ » Á ± ¹ È · ¹ ¿¶ ³ Ç ½ ¹ ¿ µ » ¿ ¿ ´ ¾ Á ± ¹ ¾ » ³ ¸ ¸ ½ ± Å ¹ È ´ » ³ ¿ ¹ ¿ µ ± Ç ¸ ¿ » À ½ ´ ¿ · ± Æ ¿  ¿ ¸ ± ¶ ¿ ¹ · º ¸ » ¿ ± ± Ö µ ¹ ¸ ± · ¸ µ È » ¸ ± Ç ¸ ´ » · ÃÏ µ È ´ · ¸ ¹ Á ¿ » ¹ ¿ ¿ ´ ¼ · ± º ¹ ¸ ± ¹ ¶ » À ¿ » ¶ ± » À Ï µ È ´ · ¸ Ò ¿ ¶ » ¿ ¸ ¸ ¹ Á ± · ¸ ± º ± · ¼ ´ · ± ± È ¿ ¸ » Æ » È Ö Æ ´ ¸ ½ Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ±¹ · º ¸ » ½ ± Á µ º ± Å ± Á » µ Ç » · Ç ± µ ¸ ¿ ´ · ¸ » ¸ ¹ · ¼ ´ ¾ Á ± µ Á ¹ ¸ À » È ¶ ¿ Ã Ø ³ ± ¸ » ¸ ½ ± ½ ´ ¼ ½ Á  ¿ ± · ¿ ´ ¸ ´ Å ± · ¹ ¸ ³ È ± » À ¸ ½ ±µ È » Ó ± Ç ¸ É ¸ ½ ± ¸ ± ¹ ¶ Æ ¹ ¿ ¿ ± ² ³ ± ¿ ¸ ± È ± º ´ · ¹ Ù ¹ · ¿ ¹ ¿ Î ´ ¸  À ¹ Ç ´ Á ´ ¸  ¹ · º ´ · ¿ ¸ È ³ Ç ¸ ± º ¸ » ¶ ¹ ´ · ¸ ¹ ´ · ¸ ½ ± µ È » Ó ± Ç ¸´ · ¸ ½ ± ¿ ¸ È ´ Ç ¸ ± ¿ ¸ » À Ç » · À ´ º ± · Ç ± Ã Ú ± Æ µ ± » µ Á ± ´ · Ï µ È ´ · ¸ Ö · ± Æ » À ¸ ½ ´ ¿ µ È » Ó ± Ç ¸ ¹ ¸ ¸ ½ ± ¸ ´ ¶ ± ÃÊ Û Ã Ü » ± Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± º ´ ± º ³ · ± Ð µ ± Ç ¸ ± º Á  ´ · ½ ´ ¿ ½ » ¶ ± ´ · Ú ± ¾ È ³ ¹ È Â » À Û Ý Ý Þ Ã Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± º ´ º· » ¸ Á ´ Å ± ¸ » ¿ ± ± ½ ´ ¿ ´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · ¿ º ± µ Á »  ± º ´ · ¸ » ¹ Ç » ¶ ¶ ± È Ç ´ ¹ Á µ Á ¹ ¸ À » È ¶ Ã ß ³ ¸ Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± Ò ¿È ± Å » Á ³ ¸ ´ » · ¹ È Â ´ · Å ± · ¸ ´ » · ¿ ½ ¹ Å ± ¹ · ± · º ³ È ´ · ¼ Á ± ¼ ¹ Ç Â Ã Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± Ò ¿ ´ · Å ± · ¸ ´ » · ¿ ¹ · º ¸ ½ ± È ± Á ¹ ¸ ± º´ · · » Å ¹ ¸ ´ » · ¿ ¶ ¹ º ± ¾  µ ± » µ Á ± Æ » È Ö ´ · ¼ Æ ´ ¸ ½ Í È Ã Î ½ È ´ ¿ ¸ ´ ± ½ ¹ Å ± È ± ¿ ³ Á ¸ ± º ´ · ¹ à » Ô µ ¹ ¸ ± · ¸ µ » È ¸ À » Á ´ » » À» Å ± È Û Ê Ë ´ ¿ ¿ ³ ± º á · ´ ¸ ± º Ï ¸ ¹ ¸ ± ¿ Ô ¹ ¸ ± · ¸ ¿ Ã á · À » È ¸ ³ · ¹ ¸ ± Á Â É ¶ ¹ · Â Ç » ¶ µ ¹ · ´ ± ¿ ´ · ¸ ½ ± ´ · º ³ ¿ ¸ È Â É ´ · Ç Á ³ º ´ · ¼Ä ´ ¶ ± Ì ¹ È · ± È É ½ ¹ Å ± È ± ¹ Á ´ Ñ ± º ¸ ½ ± ¼ È ± ¹ ¸ Å ¹ Á ³ ± ´ · ¸ ½ ´ ¿ ¸ ± Ç ½ · » Á » ¼  ¹ · º ½ ¹ Å ± ¶ ´ ¿ ¹ µ µ È » µ È ´ ¹ ¸ ± º ´ ¸Æ ´ ¸ ½ » ³ ¸ Ï µ È ´ · ¸ Ò ¿ µ ± È ¶ ´ ¿ ¿ ´ » · à ⠸ ´ ¿ ¾ ± Ç ¹ ³ ¿ ± » À ¸ ½ ´ ¿ ³ · ¹ ³ ¸ ½ » È ´ Ñ ± º ³ ¿ ± ¸ ½ ¹ ¸ Ï µ È ´ · ¸ ½ ¹ ¿ ¸ ¹ Ö ± · ± À À » È ¸ ¿ ¸ »± · À » È Ç ± ¸ ½ ´ ¿ µ ¹ ¸ ± · ¸ µ » È ¸ À » Á ´ » ¹ ¼ ¹ ´ · ¿ ¸ » ¸ ½ ± È ¿ ´ · ¸ ½ ± ´ · º ³ ¿ ¸ È Â ´ · ¸ ½ ± µ ¹ ¿ ¸ ¹ · º ´ ¿ · » Æ ± · À » È Ç ´ · ¼ ´ ¸ ¿
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 8 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 7 of 33
patents in this case.
Sprint's Enforcement Efforts and Licenses
22. In 2007, in the matter styled Sprint Communications Co. L.P. v. Vonage Holdings
Corp. et al., Case No. 05-2433-JWL (D. Kan.), a Kansas jury found that Vonage Holdings Corp.
and Vonage America, Inc. ("Vonage") had infringed six patents contained in this portfolio,
including patents that are at issue in this case, found that the six patents were valid, assessed a
five percent (5 %) reasonable royalty, and awarded Sprint $69.5 million in damages. Following
the verdict, Vonage entered a settlement agreement with Sprint whereby Vonage paid Sprint $80
million for a license to Sprint's VoP portfolio. Previously, in that same matter, tglo.com, Inc.
(formerly known as VoiceGlo Holdings, Inc) and Theglobe.com Inc. ("VoiceGlo") had entered a
settlement agreement in which VoiceGlo licensed Sprint's VoP patents.
23. In 2008, Sprint again sued to enforce patents from its VOP portfolio in additional
lawsuits against companies engaging in the unauthorized use of Sprint's VoP technology: Sprint
Communications Co. L.P. v. Paetec Holding Corp. et al., Case No. 08-cv-2044-JWL/GLR (D.
Kan.), Sprint Communications Co. L.P. v. Broadvox Holdings, LLC et al., Case No. 08-cv-2045-
JWL/DJW (D. Kan.); Sprint Communications Co. L.P. v. Big River Telephone Co., LLC, Case
No. 08-cv-2046-JWL/DJW (D. Kan.), and Sprint Communications Co. L.P. v. Nuvox, Inc. et al.,
Case No. 08-cv-2047-JWL/JPO (D. Kan.). By late 2009, Sprint had entered settlement
agreements resolving these lawsuits and, as a result, a number of additional companies licensed
patents from Sprint's VoP portfolio.
24. During this same time frame, Sprint continued to derive substantial revenues from
providing numerous cable companies, including Time Warner Cable, with a network backbone to
carry voice traffic to support those companies' digital home telephone offerings, which use
packet networks coupled with the PSTN.
8 ã
ä å æ ç è æ é ê è æ ë ê é ì å é ç í î ï ð ñ ò ó ô õ ö ò ÷ ø ð ù ú û ú ò ó ö ÷ ÷ ø ð ó õ ü ò ý þ ñ ù ú ò õ ú õÿ ÿ í � è ÿ � � � � ê è æ ë ç � å æ æ ç � é æ � � ç � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � å é ç ! " í � # $ ÿ % & & $ ' ( ) * + í , å è í - � å , å è é å é . / � � 0 " / è � æ ë å æ 1 " è å 2 ç 3 " � � ê è 2 é " � ä íå è � 1 " è å 2 ç 4 � ç � ê ì å � � è ì í * 5 1 " è å 2 ç 6 - ë å � ê è 0 � ê è 2 ç � é ê 7 ä å æ ç è æ é ì " è æ å ê è ç � ê è æ ë ê é ä " � æ 0 " � ê " �ê è ì � / � ê è 2 ä å æ ç è æ é æ ë å æ å � ç å æ ê é é / ç ê è æ ë ê é ì å é ç � 0 " / è � æ ë å æ æ ë ç é ê 7 ä å æ ç è æ é 8 ç � ç 9 å � ê � � å é é ç é é ç � å0 ê 9 ç ä ç � ì ç è æ * # : - � ç å é " è å ; � ç � " � å � æ � � å è � å 8 å � � ç � < ä � ê è æ = > ? í # � ê � � ê " è ê è � å � å 2 ç é í @ " � � " 8 ê è 2æ ë ç 9 ç � � ê ì æ � 1 " è å 2 ç ç è æ ç � ç � å é ç æ æ � ç � ç è æ å 2 � ç ç � ç è æ 8 ê æ ë < ä � ê è æ 8 ë ç � ç ; � 1 " è å 2 ç ä å ê � < ä � ê è æ = ã �� ê � � ê " è 0 " � å � ê ì ç è é ç æ " < ä � ê è æ A é 1 " B ä " � æ 0 " � ê " í B � ç 9 ê " / é � � � ê è æ ë å æ é å � ç � å æ æ ç � � æ 2 � " í ì " � � � è ì í* 0 " � � ç � � � C è " 8 è å é 1 " ê ì ç D � " 3 " � � ê è 2 é � � è ì - å è � E ë ç 2 � " ; ç í ì " � � è ì í * 5 1 " ê ì ç D � " 6 - ë å � ç è æ ç � ç � åé ç æ æ � ç � ç è æ å 2 � ç ç � ç è æ ê è 8 ë ê ì ë 1 " ê ì ç D � " � ê ì ç è é ç � < ä � ê è æ A é 1 " B ä å æ ç è æ é íÿ & í � è ÿ � � ã � < ä � ê è æ å 2 å ê è é / ç � æ " ç è 0 " � ì ç ä å æ ç è æ é 0 � " � ê æ é 1 F B ä " � æ 0 " � ê " ê è å � � ê æ ê " è å �� å 8 é / ê æ é å 2 å ê è é æ ì " � ä å è ê ç é ç è 2 å 2 ê è 2 ê è æ ë ç / è å / æ ë " � ê G ç � / é ç " 0 < ä � ê è æ A é 1 " B æ ç ì ë è " � " 2 � H � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � å é ç ! " í � ã $ ì 9 $ ÿ � % % $ ' ( ) I D ) J * + í, å è í - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � K � � � � � � L � � � � � � � M � � � � � � � � � å é ç ! " í � ã $ ì 9 $ ÿ � % # $' ( ) I + ' ( * + í , å è í - N � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � K � � O � � � � P � � � Q � � � � � M � � � � å é ç! " í � ã $ ì 9 $ ÿ � % > $ ' ( ) I + ' ( * + í , å è í - � å è � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � R � � � L M S � � � � � � � � å é ç ! " í � ã $ ì 9 $ ÿ � % � $ ' ( ) I ' B F * + í , å è í - í T � � å æ ç ÿ � � ? � < ä � ê è æ ë å � ç è æ ç � ç � é ç æ æ � ç � ç è æå 2 � ç ç � ç è æ é � ç é " � 9 ê è 2 æ ë ç é ç � å 8 é / ê æ é å è � � å é å � ç é / � æ � å è / � ; ç � " 0 å � � ê æ ê " è å � ì " � ä å è ê ç é � ê ì ç è é ç �ä å æ ç è æ é 0 � " � < ä � ê è æ A é 1 " B ä " � æ 0 " � ê " íÿ % í + / � ê è 2 æ ë ê é é å � ç æ ê � ç 0 � å � ç � < ä � ê è æ ì " è æ ê è / ç � æ " � ç � ê 9 ç é / ; é æ å è æ ê å � � ç 9 ç è / ç é 0 � " �ä � " 9 ê � ê è 2 è / � ç � " / é ì å ; � ç ì " � ä å è ê ç é � ê è ì � / � ê è 2 E ê � ç ( å � è ç � å ; � ç � 8 ê æ ë å è ç æ 8 " � C ; å ì C ; " è ç æ "ì å � � � 9 " ê ì ç æ � å 0 0 ê ì æ " é / ä ä " � æ æ ë " é ç ì " � ä å è ê ç é A � ê 2 ê æ å � ë " � ç æ ç � ç ä ë " è ç " 0 0 ç � ê è 2 é � 8 ë ê ì ë / é çä å ì C ç æ è ç æ 8 " � C é ì " / ä � ç � 8 ê æ ë æ ë ç B < E ! í
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 9 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 8 of 33
The Patents-In-Suit
25. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,343,084 ("the '084 Patent") entitled "Broadband Telecommunications
System," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael Christie on January 29,
2002. A copy of the '084 Patent was attached as Exhibit A to Sprint's Original Complaint and is
incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. A.)
26. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,633,561 ("the '3,561 Patent") entitled "Method, System and
Apparatus for Telecommunications Control," which duly and legally issued in the name of
Joseph Michael Christie on October 14, 2003. A copy of the '3,561 Patent was attached as
Exhibit B to Sprint's Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No.
1 at Ex. B.)
27. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,463,052 ("the '052 Patent") entitled "Method, System and Apparatus
for Telecommunications Control," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael
Christie on October 8, 2002. A copy of the '052 Patent was attached as Exhibit C to Sprint's
Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. C.)
28. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,452,932 ("the '932 Patent") entitled "Method, System and Apparatus
for Telecommunications Control," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael
Christie on September 17, 2002. A copy of the '932 Patent was attached as Exhibit D to Sprint's
Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. D.)
29. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,473,429 ("the '429 Patent") entitled "Broadband Telecommunications
9 U
V W X Y Z [ X \ [ ] ^ _ \ ^ ` a b [c d e f g h i j k i l l m n o i j k i p k q r s t j r o u v h p p i w j x r j k s l h g g o i w q k y k i k g r y h j z i j k r o r p k i j h j z k s{ j i k r z m k h k r p f h k r j k | s e } y ~ � ~ y � � � � � k q r � � � � f h k r j k � � r j k i k g r z � � o s h z u h j z � r g r � s x x � j i � h k i s j pm v p k r x y � t q i � q z � g v h j z g r w h g g v i p p � r z i j k q r j h x r s l � s p r n q � i � q h r g � q o i p k i r s j � h j � h o v c U yc � � c e � � s n v s l k q r � � � � f h k r j k t h p h k k h � q r z h p � � q i u i k � k s m n o i j k � p � o i w i j h g � s x n g h i j k h j z i pi j � s o n s o h k r z u v o r l r o r j � r q r o r i j e � � � � � s � e | s e � h k � � e � e �c } e f g h i j k i l l m n o i j k i p k q r s t j r o u v h p p i w j x r j k s l h g g o i w q k y k i k g r y h j z i j k r o r p k i j h j z k s{ j i k r z m k h k r p f h k r j k | s e } y } ~ ~ y d } � � � k q r � ~ y d } � f h k r j k � � r j k i k g r z � � r k q s z y m v p k r x h j z� n n h o h k � p l s o � r g r � s x x � j i � h k i s j p � s j k o s g y � t q i � q z � g v h j z g r w h g g v i p p � r z i j k q r j h x r s l� s p r n q � i � q h r g � q o i p k i r s j � � k s u r o � � y c � � ~ e � � s n v s l k q r � ~ y d } � f h k r j k t h p h k k h � q r z h p� � q i u i k � k s m n o i j k � p � o i w i j h g � s x n g h i j k h j z i p i j � s o n s o h k r z u v o r l r o r j � r q r o r i j e � � � � � s � e | s e� h k � � e � e �c � e f g h i j k i l l m n o i j k i p k q r s t j r o u v h p p i w j x r j k s l h g g o i w q k y k i k g r y h j z i j k r o r p k i j h j z k s{ j i k r z m k h k r p f h k r j k | s e } y � } ~ y � d c � � k q r � � d c f h k r j k � � r j k i k g r z � � r k q s z y m v p k r x h j z � n n h o h k � pl s o � r g r � s x x � j i � h k i s j p � s j k o s g y � t q i � q z � g v h j z g r w h g g v i p p � r z i j k q r j h x r s l � s p r n q � i � q h r g� q o i p k i r s j � � k s u r o � y c � � c e � � s n v s l k q r � � d c f h k r j k t h p h k k h � q r z h p � � q i u i k � k s m n o i j k � p� o i w i j h g � s x n g h i j k h j z i p i j � s o n s o h k r z u v o r l r o r j � r q r o r i j e � � � � � s � e | s e � h k � � e � e �c � e f g h i j k i l l m n o i j k i p k q r s t j r o u v h p p i w j x r j k s l h g g o i w q k y k i k g r y h j z i j k r o r p k i j h j z k s{ j i k r z m k h k r p f h k r j k | s e } y � d c y U ~ c � � k q r � U ~ c f h k r j k � � r j k i k g r z � � r k q s z y m v p k r x h j z � n n h o h k � pl s o � r g r � s x x � j i � h k i s j p � s j k o s g y � t q i � q z � g v h j z g r w h g g v i p p � r z i j k q r j h x r s l � s p r n q � i � q h r g� q o i p k i r s j m r n k r x u r o � � y c � � c e � � s n v s l k q r � U ~ c f h k r j k t h p h k k h � q r z h p � � q i u i k � k s m n o i j k � p� o i w i j h g � s x n g h i j k h j z i p i j � s o n s o h k r z u v o r l r o r j � r q r o r i j e � � � � � s � e | s e � h k � � e � e �c U e f g h i j k i l l m n o i j k i p k q r s t j r o u v h p p i w j x r j k s l h g g o i w q k y k i k g r y h j z i j k r o r p k i j h j z k s{ j i k r z m k h k r p f h k r j k | s e } y � � ~ y � c U � � k q r � � c U f h k r j k � � r j k i k g r z � � o s h z u h j z � r g r � s x x � j i � h k i s j p
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 10 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 9 of 33
System," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael Christie on October 29,
2002. A copy of the '429 Patent was attached as Exhibit E to Sprint's Original Complaint and is
incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. E.)
30. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,298,064 ("the '064 Patent") entitled "Broadband Telecommunications
System," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael Christie on October 2,
2001. A copy of the '064 Patent was attached as Exhibit F to Sprint's Original Complaint and is
incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. F.)
31. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,262,992 ("the '992 Patent") entitled "System and Method for
Transporting a Call in a Telecommunication Network," which duly and legally issued in the
names of Tracy Lee Nelson, William Lyle Wiley, and Albert Daniel DuRee on July 17, 2001. A
copy of the '992 Patent was attached as Exhibit G to Sprint's Original Complaint and is
incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. G.)
32. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,330,224 ("the '224 Patent") entitled "System and Method for
Providing Enhanced Services for a Telecommunication Call," which duly and legally issued in
the names of Joseph Michael Christie, Joseph S. Christie, and Tracy Lee Nelson on December
11, 2001. A copy of the '224 Patent was attached as Exhibit H to Sprint's Original Complaint and
is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. H.)
33. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,563,918 ("the '918 Patent") entitled "Telecommunications System
Architecture for Connecting a Call," which duly and legally issued in the names of Tracy Lee
10 � �
� � � � � � ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ £ ¦ § ¨ � © ª ¦ ¨ � « © ¨ ¨ � ¤ � � § � ¦ ¤ ª � £ � ª © � � ¬ ® ¬ � � ¯ £ ° ¤ ¥ £ © � ¨ ± £ ² ¤ � � ¤ � ¬ ª ³ ¥ � ¬ ´ � ² µ ¶ µ � � µ · ¸ ¥ ¬ ¯ � ¬ � £ � ¹ º µ ¶ » © � � ª � ¢ © � © � � © ¥ £ � ¦ © � ¼ ½ £ ¤ ´ ¤ � ¼ � ¬ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¾ � ³ ² ¤ « ¤ ª © ¨ ± ¬ � ¯ ¨ © ¤ ª � © ª ¦ ¤ �¤ ª ¥ ¬ ² ¯ ¬ ² © � � ¦ ´ � ² � � ² � ª ¥ � £ � ² � ¤ ª · ¿ À Á Á  ¬ ¥ · à ¬ · � © � ¼ ½ · ¼ · ÄÅ � · » ¨ © ¤ ª � ¤ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¤ � � £ � ¬ ¢ ª � ² ´ � © � � ¤ « ª � � ª � ¬ © ¨ ¨ ² ¤ « £ � � ¤ � ¨ � © ª ¦ ¤ ª � � ² � � � ¤ ª © ª ¦ � ¬Æ ª ¤ � � ¦ � � © � � � » © � � ª � à ¬ · Ç µ ¶ È � Ç º ¿ É � £ � ¹ � Ç º » © � � ª � ¡ Ä � ª � ¤ � ¨ � ¦ É Ê ² ¬ © ¦ ´ © ª ¦ Ë � ¨ � ¥ ¬ � � § ª ¤ ¥ © � ¤ ¬ ª �� � � � � � ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ £ ¦ § ¨ � © ª ¦ ¨ � « © ¨ ¨ � ¤ � � § � ¦ ¤ ª � £ � ª © � � ¬ ® ¬ � � ¯ £ ° ¤ ¥ £ © � ¨ ± £ ² ¤ � � ¤ � ¬ ª ³ ¥ � ¬ ´ � ² µ µ � � � · ¸ ¥ ¬ ¯ � ¬ � £ � ¹ � Ç º » © � � ª � ¢ © � © � � © ¥ £ � ¦ © � ¼ ½ £ ¤ ´ ¤ � Ì � ¬ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¾ � ³ ² ¤ « ¤ ª © ¨ ± ¬ � ¯ ¨ © ¤ ª � © ª ¦ ¤ �¤ ª ¥ ¬ ² ¯ ¬ ² © � � ¦ ´ � ² � � ² � ª ¥ � £ � ² � ¤ ª · ¿ À Á Á  ¬ ¥ · à ¬ · � © � ¼ ½ · Ì · ÄÅ � · » ¨ © ¤ ª � ¤ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¤ � � £ � ¬ ¢ ª � ² ´ � © � � ¤ « ª � � ª � ¬ © ¨ ¨ ² ¤ « £ � � ¤ � ¨ � © ª ¦ ¤ ª � � ² � � � ¤ ª © ª ¦ � ¬Æ ª ¤ � � ¦ � � © � � � » © � � ª � à ¬ · Ç µ Ç µ ¶ ¶ µ ¿ É � £ � ¹ ¶ ¶ µ » © � � ª � ¡ Ä � ª � ¤ � ¨ � ¦ É � � � � � � © ª ¦ ° � � £ ¬ ¦ ¬ ²Ë ² © ª � ¯ ¬ ² � ¤ ª « © ± © ¨ ¨ ¤ ª © Ë � ¨ � ¥ ¬ � � § ª ¤ ¥ © � ¤ ¬ ª à � � ¢ ¬ ² Í ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ £ ¦ § ¨ � © ª ¦ ¨ � « © ¨ ¨ � ¤ � � § � ¦ ¤ ª � £ �ª © � � � ¬ Ë ² © ¥ � Î � � à � ¨ � ¬ ª Ï ¤ ¨ ¨ ¤ © � Î � ¨ � Ï ¤ ¨ � � © ª ¦ ¸ ¨ ´ � ² �  © ª ¤ � ¨  § Ð � � ¬ ª ® § ¨ � � Ñ µ � � � · ¸¥ ¬ ¯ � ¬ � £ � ¹ ¶ ¶ µ » © � � ª � ¢ © � © � � © ¥ £ � ¦ © � ¼ ½ £ ¤ ´ ¤ � Ò � ¬ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¾ � ³ ² ¤ « ¤ ª © ¨ ± ¬ � ¯ ¨ © ¤ ª � © ª ¦ ¤ �¤ ª ¥ ¬ ² ¯ ¬ ² © � � ¦ ´ � ² � � ² � ª ¥ � £ � ² � ¤ ª · ¿ À Á Á  ¬ ¥ · à ¬ · � © � ¼ ½ · Ò · ÄÅ µ · » ¨ © ¤ ª � ¤ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¤ � � £ � ¬ ¢ ª � ² ´ � © � � ¤ « ª � � ª � ¬ © ¨ ¨ ² ¤ « £ � � ¤ � ¨ � © ª ¦ ¤ ª � � ² � � � ¤ ª © ª ¦ � ¬Æ ª ¤ � � ¦ � � © � � � » © � � ª � à ¬ · Ç Å Å � µ µ º ¿ É � £ � ¹ µ µ º » © � � ª � ¡ Ä � ª � ¤ � ¨ � ¦ É � � � � � � © ª ¦ ° � � £ ¬ ¦ ¬ ²» ² ¬ Ó ¤ ¦ ¤ ª « ¼ ª £ © ª ¥ � ¦ � � ² Ó ¤ ¥ � � ¬ ² © Ë � ¨ � ¥ ¬ � � § ª ¤ ¥ © � ¤ ¬ ª ± © ¨ ¨ ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ £ ¦ § ¨ � © ª ¦ ¨ � « © ¨ ¨ � ¤ � � § � ¦ ¤ ª� £ � ª © � � � ¬ ® ¬ � � ¯ £ ° ¤ ¥ £ © � ¨ ± £ ² ¤ � � ¤ � ® ¬ � � ¯ £ � · ± £ ² ¤ � � ¤ � © ª ¦ Ë ² © ¥ � Î � � à � ¨ � ¬ ª ¬ ª  � ¥ � � ´ � ²� � µ � � � · ¸ ¥ ¬ ¯ � ¬ � £ � ¹ µ µ º » © � � ª � ¢ © � © � � © ¥ £ � ¦ © � ¼ ½ £ ¤ ´ ¤ � Ô � ¬ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¾ � ³ ² ¤ « ¤ ª © ¨ ± ¬ � ¯ ¨ © ¤ ª � © ª ¦¤ � ¤ ª ¥ ¬ ² ¯ ¬ ² © � � ¦ ´ � ² � � ² � ª ¥ � £ � ² � ¤ ª · ¿ À Á Á  ¬ ¥ · à ¬ · � © � ¼ ½ · Ô · ÄÅ Å · » ¨ © ¤ ª � ¤ � ¯ ² ¤ ª � ¤ � � £ � ¬ ¢ ª � ² ´ � © � � ¤ « ª � � ª � ¬ © ¨ ¨ ² ¤ « £ � � ¤ � ¨ � © ª ¦ ¤ ª � � ² � � � ¤ ª © ª ¦ � ¬Æ ª ¤ � � ¦ � � © � � � » © � � ª � à ¬ · Ç Õ Ç Å ¶ � È ¿ É � £ � ¹ ¶ � È » © � � ª � ¡ Ä � ª � ¤ � ¨ � ¦ É Ë � ¨ � ¥ ¬ � � § ª ¤ ¥ © � ¤ ¬ ª � � � � � � �¸ ² ¥ £ ¤ � � ¥ � § ² � ¬ ² ± ¬ ª ª � ¥ � ¤ ª « © ± © ¨ ¨ ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ £ ¦ § ¨ � © ª ¦ ¨ � « © ¨ ¨ � ¤ � � § � ¦ ¤ ª � £ � ª © � � � ¬ Ë ² © ¥ � Î � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 11 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 10 of 33
Nelson, William Lyle Wiley, Royal Dean Howell, Michael Joseph Gardner, and Albert Daniel
DuRee on May 13, 2003. A copy of the '918 Patent was attached as Exhibit Ito Sprint's Original
Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. I.)
34. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,639,912 ("the '912 Patent") entitled "Number Portability in a
Communications System," which duly and legally issued in the names of Joseph Michael
Christie, Joseph S. Christie, Jean M. Christie, Michael Joseph Gardner, Albert Daniel DuRee,
William Lyle Wiley, and Tracy Lee Nelson on October 28, 2003. A copy of the '912 Patent was
attached as Exhibit J to Sprint's Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See
Doc. No. 1 at Ex. J.)
35. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 6,697,340 ("the '340 Patent") entitled "System and Method for
Providing Enhanced Services for a Telecommunication Call," which duly and legally issued in
the names of Joseph Michael Christie, Joseph S. Christie, Jean M. Christie, and Tracy Lee
Nelson on February 24, 2004. A copy of the '340 Patent was attached as Exhibit K to Sprint's
Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. K.)
36. Plaintiff Sprint is the owner by assignment of all right, title, and interest in and to
United States Patent No. 7,286,561 ("the '6,561 Patent") entitled "Method System and Apparatus
for Telecommunications Control," which duly and legally issued in the name of Joseph Michael
Christie on October 23, 2007. A copy of the '6,561 Patent was attached as Exhibit L to Sprint's
Original Complaint and is incorporated by reference herein. (See Doc. No. 1 at Ex. L.)
37. The patents identified in paragraphs 25-36 and attached at Exhibits A—L to the
Original Complaint (Doc. No. 1) are herein collectively referred to as "Sprint's Patents." Sprint's
11 Ö Ö
× Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Ý Þ ß Ù Ù ß à á â ã Ù Ø Þ ß Ù Ø ã Ý ä Û ã à Ù å Ø à Ü æ Û ç Ø Ù Ù Ý è ß é ê à Ø Ù ë Û Ú Ø ì ê í à î ï Ü Ø î Ý à Ü ï ð Ù ñ Ø î ò å à Ü ß Ø Ùå ó ä Ø Ø Û Ü è à ã Ö ô Ý õ ö ö ô ÷ ð é Û ì ã Û ø ò ê Ø ù ú Ö û ü à ò Ø Ü ò ç à Ú à ò ò à é ê Ø ï à Ú ý þ ê ß ñ ß ò ÿ ò Û � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú � î ß � ß Ü à Ù� Û á ì Ù à ß Ü ò à Ü ï ß Ú ß Ü é Û î ì Û î à ò Ø ï ñ ã î Ø ø Ø î Ø Ü é Ø ê Ø î Ø ß Ü ÷ � � � � å Û é ÷ × Û ÷ Ö à ò ý þ ÷ ÿ ÷ �ô ÷ ü Ù à ß Ü ò ß ø ø � ì î ß Ü ò ß Ú ò ê Ø Û ç Ü Ø î ñ ã à Ú Ú ß � Ü á Ø Ü ò Û ø à Ù Ù î ß � ê ò Ý ò ß ò Ù Ø Ý à Ü ï ß Ü ò Ø î Ø Ú ò ß Ü à Ü ï ò Û Ü ß ò Ø ï � ò à ò Ø Ú ü à ò Ø Ü ò × Û ÷ � Ý � ô ú Ý ú Ö õ � � ò ê Ø ù ú Ö õ ü à ò Ø Ü ò � Ø Ü ò ß ò Ù Ø ï � × ó á ñ Ø î ü Û î ò à ñ ß Ù ß ò ã ß Ü à� Û á á ó Ü ß é à ò ß Û Ü Ú � ã Ú ò Ø á Ý ç ê ß é ê ï ó Ù ã à Ü ï Ù Ø � à Ù Ù ã ß Ú Ú ó Ø ï ß Ü ò ê Ø Ü à á Ø Ú Û ø ë Û Ú Ø ì ê è ß é ê à Ø Ù� ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý ë Û Ú Ø ì ê � ÷ � ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý ë Ø à Ü è ÷ � ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý è ß é ê à Ø Ù ë Û Ú Ø ì ê í à î ï Ü Ø î Ý ð Ù ñ Ø î ò å à Ü ß Ø Ù å ó ä Ø Ø ÝÞ ß Ù Ù ß à á â ã Ù Ø Þ ß Ù Ø ã Ý à Ü ï � î à é ã â Ø Ø × Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Û Ü � é ò Û ñ Ø î õ û Ý õ ö ö ô ÷ ð é Û ì ã Û ø ò ê Ø ù ú Ö õ ü à ò Ø Ü ò ç à Úà ò ò à é ê Ø ï à Ú ý þ ê ß ñ ß ò ë ò Û � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú � î ß � ß Ü à Ù � Û á ì Ù à ß Ü ò à Ü ï ß Ú ß Ü é Û î ì Û î à ò Ø ï ñ ã î Ø ø Ø î Ø Ü é Ø ê Ø î Ø ß Ü ÷ � � � �å Û é ÷ × Û ÷ Ö à ò ý þ ÷ ë ÷ �ô � ÷ ü Ù à ß Ü ò ß ø ø � ì î ß Ü ò ß Ú ò ê Ø Û ç Ü Ø î ñ ã à Ú Ú ß � Ü á Ø Ü ò Û ø à Ù Ù î ß � ê ò Ý ò ß ò Ù Ø Ý à Ü ï ß Ü ò Ø î Ø Ú ò ß Ü à Ü ï ò Û Ü ß ò Ø ï � ò à ò Ø Ú ü à ò Ø Ü ò × Û ÷ � Ý � ú � Ý ô ö � � ò ê Ø ù ô ö ü à ò Ø Ü ò � Ø Ü ò ß ò Ù Ø ï � � ã Ú ò Ø á à Ü ï è Ø ò ê Û ï ø Û îü î Û � ß ï ß Ü � ý Ü ê à Ü é Ø ï � Ø î � ß é Ø Ú ø Û î à � Ø Ù Ø é Û á á ó Ü ß é à ò ß Û Ü � à Ù Ù Ý ç ê ß é ê ï ó Ù ã à Ü ï Ù Ø � à Ù Ù ã ß Ú Ú ó Ø ï ß Üò ê Ø Ü à á Ø Ú Û ø ë Û Ú Ø ì ê è ß é ê à Ø Ù � ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý ë Û Ú Ø ì ê � ÷ � ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý ë Ø à Ü è ÷ � ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Ý à Ü ï � î à é ã â Ø Ø× Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Û Ü � Ø ñ î ó à î ã õ Ý õ ö ö ÷ ð é Û ì ã Û ø ò ê Ø ù ô ö ü à ò Ø Ü ò ç à Ú à ò ò à é ê Ø ï à Ú ý þ ê ß ñ ß ò � ò Û � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú� î ß � ß Ü à Ù � Û á ì Ù à ß Ü ò à Ü ï ß Ú ß Ü é Û î ì Û î à ò Ø ï ñ ã î Ø ø Ø î Ø Ü é Ø ê Ø î Ø ß Ü ÷ � � � � å Û é ÷ × Û ÷ Ö à ò ý þ ÷ � ÷ �ô � ÷ ü Ù à ß Ü ò ß ø ø � ì î ß Ü ò ß Ú ò ê Ø Û ç Ü Ø î ñ ã à Ú Ú ß � Ü á Ø Ü ò Û ø à Ù Ù î ß � ê ò Ý ò ß ò Ù Ø Ý à Ü ï ß Ü ò Ø î Ø Ú ò ß Ü à Ü ï ò Û Ü ß ò Ø ï � ò à ò Ø Ú ü à ò Ø Ü ò × Û ÷ � Ý õ û � Ý � � Ö � � ò ê Ø ù � Ý � � Ö ü à ò Ø Ü ò � Ø Ü ò ß ò Ù Ø ï � è Ø ò ê Û ï � ã Ú ò Ø á à Ü ï ð ì ì à î à ò ó Úø Û î � Ø Ù Ø é Û á á ó Ü ß é à ò ß Û Ü Ú � Û Ü ò î Û Ù Ý ç ê ß é ê ï ó Ù ã à Ü ï Ù Ø � à Ù Ù ã ß Ú Ú ó Ø ï ß Ü ò ê Ø Ü à á Ø Û ø ë Û Ú Ø ì ê è ß é ê à Ø Ù� ê î ß Ú ò ß Ø Û Ü � é ò Û ñ Ø î õ ô Ý õ ö ö � ÷ ð é Û ì ã Û ø ò ê Ø ù � Ý � � Ö ü à ò Ø Ü ò ç à Ú à ò ò à é ê Ø ï à Ú ý þ ê ß ñ ß ò â ò Û � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú� î ß � ß Ü à Ù � Û á ì Ù à ß Ü ò à Ü ï ß Ú ß Ü é Û î ì Û î à ò Ø ï ñ ã î Ø ø Ø î Ø Ü é Ø ê Ø î Ø ß Ü ÷ � � � � å Û é ÷ × Û ÷ Ö à ò ý þ ÷ â ÷ �ô � ÷ � ê Ø ì à ò Ø Ü ò Ú ß ï Ø Ü ò ß ø ß Ø ï ß Ü ì à î à � î à ì ê Ú õ � � ô � à Ü ï à ò ò à é ê Ø ï à ò ý þ ê ß ñ ß ò Ú ð � â ò Û ò ê Ø� î ß � ß Ü à Ù � Û á ì Ù à ß Ü ò � å Û é ÷ × Û ÷ Ö � à î Ø ê Ø î Ø ß Ü é Û Ù Ù Ø é ò ß � Ø Ù ã î Ø ø Ø î î Ø ï ò Û à Ú � � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú ü à ò Ø Ü ò Ú ÷ � ì î ß Ü ò � Ú
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 12 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 11 of 33
Patents are a part of Sprint's revolutionary VoP patent portfolio.
Time Warner
38. Upon information and belief, Time Warner—including Time Warner Cable Inc.,
Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC—is the second largest cable operator in the United
States, providing cable television, broadband Internet, and telephone service to both residential
and commercial customers.
39. Upon information and belief, Time Warner—including Time Warner Cable Inc.,
Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC—has made, used, offered to sell, or sold, and
continues to make, use, offer to sell, and/or sell broadband and/or packet-based telephony
products or services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class
PRI," and other related telephony services, without Sprint's permission.
40. Upon information and belief, within this Judicial District, Time Warner, without
Sprint's permission, has made, used, offered to sell, and/or sold, and continues to make, use,
offer to sell, and/or sell broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or services, including
"Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and other related
telephony services, that infringe Sprint's Patents.
41. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had actual knowledge of, should
have known of, and/or has been willfully blind to, U.S. Patent Nos. 6,633,561, 6,463,052,
6,452,932, 6,473,429, and 6,298,064 (the "Known Patents") since at least July 2007.
42. Time Warner's knowledge of at least some of the Sprint Patents notwithstanding,
12 � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � � " � � # � � � $ � % & � " � � � � ' ( � � � � � � � � � � � � � % " � )* + , - . / 0 1 - 02 3 ) 4 � � � " � � � 5 � � " � � � � 6 7 � % " � 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � ; " � < % & 6 " � = 9 " 5 � : � � � � � > � 7 % � ? � < ) 89 " 5 � : � � � � � > � 7 % � @ @ > 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � A � � � � � � " � 5 � � � > � 5 � � � ' 8 @ ) � ) 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � �A � � � � � � " � 5 � � � B C 6 $ � � < � D E � F G � & � � � � � � � � � � G " � 8 9 : > > � 5 5 & � " < � � " � � � 8 @ @ > 8 � � 6 9 " 5 � : � � � � �> � 7 % � ? � � � 5 � � " � � ! � � $ " < � � H I � � � � � J 8 @ @ > ; " � � G � � � < � � 6 % � � = � � � < � 7 % � � � � � � � � � " � � G � 4 � " � � 6! � � � � � 8 � � � $ " 6 " � = < � 7 % � � � % � $ " � " � � 8 7 � � � 6 7 � � 6 ? � � � � � � � 8 � � 6 � � % � � G � � � � � � $ " < � � � 7 � � G � � � " 6 � � � " � %� � 6 < � 5 5 � � < " � % < & � � � 5 � � � )2 K ) 4 � � � " � � � 5 � � " � � � � 6 7 � % " � 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � ; " � < % & 6 " � = 9 " 5 � : � � � � � > � 7 % � ? � < ) 89 " 5 � : � � � � � > � 7 % � @ @ > 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � A � � � � � � " � 5 � � � > � 5 � � � ' 8 @ ) � ) 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � �A � � � � � � " � 5 � � � B C 6 $ � � < � D E � F G � & � � � � � � � � � � G " � 8 9 : > > � 5 5 & � " < � � " � � � 8 @ @ > 8 � � 6 9 " 5 � : � � � � �> � 7 % � ? � � � 5 � � " � � ! � � $ " < � � H I � � � � � J 8 @ @ > ; G � � 5 � 6 � 8 & � � 6 8 � � � � 6 � � � � % % 8 � � � � % 6 8 � � 6< � � � " � & � � � � 5 � L � 8 & � � 8 � � � � � � � % % 8 � � 6 D � � � � % % 7 � � � 6 7 � � 6 � � 6 D � � � � < L � � B 7 � � � 6 � � % � � G � � '� � � 6 & < � � � � � � � $ " < � � 8 " � < % & 6 " � = M N " = " � � % O � 5 � � G � � � 8 P M Q & � " � � � � > % � � � � G � � � 8 P M Q & � " � � � � > % � � �� R ? 8 P � � 6 � � G � � � � % � � � 6 � � % � � G � � ' � � � $ " < � � 8 F " � G � & � ! � � " � � # � � � � 5 " � � " � � )S T ) 4 � � � " � � � 5 � � " � � � � 6 7 � % " � 8 F " � G " � � G " � U & 6 " < " � % N " � � � " < � 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � 8 F " � G � & �! � � " � � # � � � � 5 " � � " � � 8 G � � 5 � 6 � 8 & � � 6 8 � � � � 6 � � � � % % 8 � � 6 D � � � � % 6 8 � � 6 < � � � " � & � � � � 5 � L � 8 & � � 8� � � � � � � % % 8 � � 6 D � � � � % % 7 � � � 6 7 � � 6 � � 6 D � � � � < L � � B 7 � � � 6 � � % � � G � � ' � � � 6 & < � � � � � � � $ " < � � 8 " � < % & 6 " � =M N " = " � � % O � 5 � � G � � � 8 P M Q & � " � � � � > % � � � � G � � � 8 P M Q & � " � � � � > % � � � � R ? 8 P � � 6 � � G � � � � % � � � 6� � % � � G � � ' � � � $ " < � � 8 � G � � " � � " � = � ! � � " � � # � � � � � � � � )S � ) 4 � � � " � � � 5 � � " � � � � 6 7 � % " � 8 9 " 5 � : � � � � � G � � G � 6 � < � & � % L � � F % � 6 = � � 8 � G � & % 6G � $ � L � � F � � 8 � � 6 D � � G � � 7 � � � F " % % & % % ' 7 % " � 6 � � 8 4 ) ! ) � � � � � � E � � ) V 8 V 2 2 8 W V � 8 V 8 S V 2 8 T W � 8V 8 S W � 8 K 2 � 8 V 8 S X 2 8 S � K 8 � � 6 V 8 � K 3 8 T V S H � G � M Y Z [ \ Z ] ^ _ ` Z _ a b c a d Z e ` ^ _ f ` ^ a _ g h f i j k k X lm j l n d o ` p ^ q Z ` q r a s Z [ \ f ` t u ` [ v ^ _ f ` ^ a _ a [ o ` [ v _ w ` x y q d Z _ ] ^ _ ` Z _ a Z [ _ \ d _ w a _ ^ Z t d Z u z
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 13 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 12 of 33
Time Warner continued to make, use, sell, and/or offer for sale its products and services that
infringe Sprint's intellectual property, all despite an objectively high likelihood that Defendants'
actions constituted infringement of one or more valid patents. Upon information and belief,
Time Warner either knew or should have known of such infringement of Sprint's intellectual
property rights.
COUNT 1: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '084 Patent
43. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-42 above.
44. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '084 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '084 Patent. These broadband and/or packed-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of receiving and do receive telephone calls
originating from a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '084 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
45. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '084 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
13 { |
} ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � �~ � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � �} ~ � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ ¡ ¦ ¡ § ¨ © § ª ¦ « ¦ ¡§ ¬ ® ¯ ¬ ° ± ² ± ¬ ³ ´ ³ µ ± ¶ · ¸ ¹ ¤ º ³ ± ¬ ³» | � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ �� � � � � � � � � � { ¼ » ½ � � � � � �» » � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¿ � � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � À À ¾ �} ~ � � � � � � � � Á � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ¾ � � � � � � � À �  � � } ~ � � � � � � � � Á � � � � � � ~ � � � � � Ã Ä � � � � � � � Å � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � } � ¾ ¾ � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � À À ¾ � � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¿ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � �Æ Ç � � � � � È � À À ¾ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � ~ � � � � � É Ê Ë »  � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � �� � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � à � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � Ì � ~ � ~ � � � Í � � �  � � � � � Î Ì Ï � � ~ � � � � ¾ � � � �  � � � � � Î Ì Ï � � ~ � � � � ¾ � � � �  Р¿ � Î � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � É Ê Ë »  � � � � � � } � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ã� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � ~ � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � à � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ñ � � � � � � � � �  � } Å � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � �~ � � � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � { � � � � � É Ê Ë »  � � � � � � � � � � | Ò � � � � ¾ � Ó ½ Ô { Æ � È �» Ò � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¿ � � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � À À ¾ �} ~ � � � � � � � � Á � � � � � � ~ � � � � � ¾ � � � � � � � À �  � � } ~ � � � � � � � � Á � � � � � � ~ � � � � � Ã Ä � � � � � � � Å � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � } � ¾ ¾ � � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � À À ¾ � � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¿ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � � �Æ Ç � � � � � È � À À ¾ � ~ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � É Ê Ë »  � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � ~ � � � ~ � � � � � ~ � � � � � � ~ � ~ �� � � � � � � � ½ Ê { { � � � � � � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � ~ � � � � � � � � ~ � � � } ~ � � � � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¿ � � � � } ~ � � � � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 14 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 13 of 33
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '084 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
46. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '084 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
47. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '084 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief
COUNT 2: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '3,561 Patent
48. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-47 above.
49. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '3,561 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
14 Õ Ö
× Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Ü × Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å × æ à ç Ø ã è Ý Ü é ê é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å ëì í î Ø ã ï Û ð ñ Û ò ó æ ô õ Û ê Ø â å ã Û â õ ó ß ç Ý Þ á × × æ à à ô ã ß ï Ø å ß æ ã õ Ý Ü Ü × Ý Ø ã í Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Ûö ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã ø Û â î ß ï Û õ ù ú Ø ã õ Ø õ û Ý Ü Ü × í ß í ã æ å ó Ø î Û ï æ ã õ å â ô ï å ß î Û ü ã æ ò Ú Û í ý Û æ â Ø ã è æ å ó Û âü ã æ ò Ú Û í ý Û æ â Ø ò Ø â Û ã Û õ õ æ ÷ å ó Û þ ÿ � Ö ê Ø å Û ã å Ù Û ÷ æ â Û å ó ß õ õ ô ß å ò Ø õ ÷ ß Ú Û í ß ã � Û ï Û à Ù Û â � ÿ Õ Õ éÖ � é � ç æ ã ß ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã Ø ã í Ù Û Ú ß Û ÷ Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û ö ã ï é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Ü × ÝÞ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å × æ à ç Ø ã è Ý Ü é ê é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å ë ì í î Ø ã ï Û ð ñ Û ò ó æ ô õ Ûê Ø â å ã Û â õ ó ß ç Ý Þ á × × æ à à ô ã ß ï Ø å ß æ ã õ Ý Ü Ü × Ý Ø ã í Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û ö ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã ø Û â î ß ï Û õù ú Ø ã õ Ø õ û Ý Ü Ü × � õ ß ã ÷ â ß ã ý Û à Û ã å æ ÷ å ó Û þ ÿ � Ö ê Ø å Û ã å ò ß Ú Ú ï æ ã å ß ã ô Û ô ã Ú Û õ õ Û ã � æ ß ã Û í Ù è å ó ß õ × æ ô â å éÖ � é ì õ Ø í ß â Û ï å Ø ã í ç â æ � ß à Ø å Û ï æ ã õ Û ô Û ã ï Û æ ÷ Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û ö ã ï é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â× Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Ü × Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å × æ à ç Ø ã è Ý Ü é ê é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å ëì í î Ø ã ï Û ð ñ Û ò ó æ ô õ Û ê Ø â å ã Û â õ ó ß ç Ý Þ á × × æ à à ô ã ß ï Ø å ß æ ã õ Ý Ü Ü × Ý Ø ã í Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Ûö ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã ø Û â î ß ï Û õ ù ú Ø ã õ Ø õ û Ý Ü Ü × � õ ß ã ÷ â ß ã ý Û à Û ã å æ ÷ å ó Û þ ÿ � Ö ê Ø å Û ã å Ý ø ç â ß ã å ó Ø õ õ ô ÷ ÷ Û â Û í Ø ã íò ß Ú Ú ï æ ã å ß ã ô Û å æ õ ô ÷ ÷ Û â ß â â Û ç Ø â Ø Ù Ú Û ß ã � ô â è Ø ã í í Ø à Ø ý Û õ ß ã Ø ã Ø à æ ô ã å ã æ å è Û å í Û å Û â à ß ã Û í ÷ æ â ò ó ß ï óø ç â ß ã å ß õ Û ã å ß å Ú Û í å æ â Û Ú ß Û ÷ é � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � ! � " � # $ % & ' ( � ) � � Ö � é ø ç â ß ã å â Û Ø Ú Ú Û ý Û õ Ø ã í ß ã ï æ â ç æ â Ø å Û õ Ù è â Û ÷ Û â Û ã ï Û å ó Û Ø Ú Ú Û ý Ø å ß æ ã õ õ Û å ÷ æ â å ó ß ãç Ø â Ø ý â Ø ç ó õ Õ * Ö � Ø Ù æ î Û éÖ + é � ç æ ã ß ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã Ø ã í Ù Û Ú ß Û ÷ Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û ö ã ï é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û Ü Ü × ÝÞ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å × æ à ç Ø ã è Ý Ü é ê é Ý Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â ä ã å Û â å Ø ß ã à Û ã å ë ì í î Ø ã ï Û ð ñ Û ò ó æ ô õ Ûê Ø â å ã Û â õ ó ß ç Ý Þ á × × æ à à ô ã ß ï Ø å ß æ ã õ Ý Ü Ü × Ý Ø ã í Þ ß à Û á Ø â ã Û â × Ø Ù Ú Û ö ã ÷ æ â à Ø å ß æ ã ø Û â î ß ï Û õù ú Ø ã õ Ø õ û Ý Ü Ü × ó Ø î Û Ù Û Û ã Ý Ø ã í ï ô â â Û ã å Ú è Ø â Û Ý í ß â Û ï å Ú è ß ã ÷ â ß ã ý ß ã ý å ó Û þ , Ý - � Õ ê Ø å Û ã å Ù è à Ø ü ß ã ý Ýô õ ß ã ý Ý õ Û Ú Ú ß ã ý Ý Ø ã í æ ÷ ÷ Û â ß ã ý ÷ æ â õ Ø Ú Û Ù â æ Ø í Ù Ø ã í Ø ã í ð æ â ç Ø ï ü Û å ë Ù Ø õ Û í å Û Ú Û ç ó æ ã è ç â æ í ô ï å õ æ âõ Û â î ß ï Û õ Ý ß ã ï Ú ô í ß ã ý . � ß ý ß å Ø Ú / æ à Û ê ó æ ã Û Ý 0 . 1 ô õ ß ã Û õ õ × Ú Ø õ õ ê ó æ ã Û Ý 0 . 1 ô õ ß ã Û õ õ × Ú Ø õ õ ê 2 ö Ý 0 Ø ã í
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 15 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 14 of 33
other related telephony services, that infringe the '3,561 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of placing and do place telephone calls that
terminate on a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '3,561 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
50. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had, or should have had, actual
knowledge of the '3,561 Patent since at least July 2007.
51. Upon information and belief, despite such knowledge of the '3,561 Patent, Time
Warner acted in reckless disregard of Sprint's known patent rights and an objectively high
likelihood that its products and services (see, e.g., Paragraph 49) infringed Sprint's valid and
enforceable '3,561 Patent. As such, and upon information and belief, Time Warner's
infringement of the '3,561 Patent has been and is willful.
52. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '3,561 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
53. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '3,561 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 3: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '052 Patent
54. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
15 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 9 8 : ; 6 8 < 6 8 : 8 = 7 5 > ? @ 8 9 A B C 8 @ D 6 7 ; 6 B > E 9 B > F 8 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 K L 7 8 @ 8 M 9 5 ; < M ; > < ; > < N 5 9 = ; C O 8 6 PM ; @ 8 < 6 8 : 8 = 7 5 > ? = 9 5 < Q C 6 @ ; > < N 5 9 @ 8 9 A B C 8 @ ; 9 8 C ; = ; M : 8 5 E = : ; C B > F ; > < < 5 = : ; C 8 6 8 : 8 = 7 5 > 8 C ; : : @ 6 7 ; 66 8 9 R B > ; 6 8 5 > ; > 5 > P = ; C O 8 6 > 8 6 S 5 9 O D @ Q C 7 ; @ D E 5 9 8 T ; R = : 8 D 6 7 8 J U L V D B > ; R ; > > 8 9 6 7 ; 6 < B 9 8 C 6 : ?B > E 9 B > F 8 @ ; 6 : 8 ; @ 6 C : ; B R 3 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 Q > < 8 9 H 4 W K U K X K Y Z [ 3 \ ; ] K4 ^ K W = 5 > B > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > ; > < M 8 : B 8 E D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 7 ; @ 7 ; < D 5 9 @ 7 5 Q : < 7 ; A 8 7 ; < D ; C 6 Q ; :O > 5 S : 8 < F 8 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 @ B > C 8 ; 6 : 8 ; @ 6 ` Q : ? Z ^ ^ [ K4 3 K W = 5 > B > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > ; > < M 8 : B 8 E D < 8 @ = B 6 8 @ Q C 7 O > 5 S : 8 < F 8 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 D L B R 8_ ; 9 > 8 9 ; C 6 8 < B > 9 8 C O : 8 @ @ < B @ 9 8 F ; 9 < 5 E U = 9 B > 6 a @ O > 5 S > = ; 6 8 > 6 9 B F 7 6 @ ; > < ; > 5 M b 8 C 6 B A 8 : ? 7 B F 7: B O 8 : B 7 5 5 < 6 7 ; 6 B 6 @ = 9 5 < Q C 6 @ ; > < @ 8 9 A B C 8 @ \ c d d e d f g K D J ; 9 ; F 9 ; = 7 h i ] B > E 9 B > F 8 < U = 9 B > 6 a @ A ; : B < ; > <8 > E 5 9 C 8 ; M : 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 K j @ @ Q C 7 D ; > < Q = 5 > B > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > ; > < M 8 : B 8 E D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 a @B > E 9 B > F 8 R 8 > 6 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 7 ; @ M 8 8 > ; > < B @ S B : : E Q : K4 Z K W = 5 > B > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > ; > < M 8 : B 8 E D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 X ; M : 8 k > C K D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 X ; M : 8 l l X DL B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 m > 6 8 9 6 ; B > R 8 > 6 X 5 R = ; > ? D l K J K D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 m > 6 8 9 6 ; B > R 8 > 6 P j < A ; > C 8 N V 8 S 7 5 Q @ 8J ; 9 6 > 8 9 @ 7 B = D L _ X X 5 R R Q > B C ; 6 B 5 > @ D l l X D ; > < L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 X ; M : 8 k > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > U 8 9 A B C 8 @\ n ; > @ ; @ ] D l l X a @ B > E 9 B > F 8 R 8 > 6 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 S B : : C 5 > 6 B > Q 8 Q > : 8 @ @ 8 > b 5 B > 8 < M ? 6 7 B @ X 5 Q 9 6 K4 H K j @ ; < B 9 8 C 6 ; > < = 9 5 T B R ; 6 8 C 5 > @ 8 o Q 8 > C 8 5 E L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 X ; M : 8 k > C K D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9X ; M : 8 l l X D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 m > 6 8 9 6 ; B > R 8 > 6 X 5 R = ; > ? D l K J K D L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 m > 6 8 9 6 ; B > R 8 > 6 Pj < A ; > C 8 N V 8 S 7 5 Q @ 8 J ; 9 6 > 8 9 @ 7 B = D L _ X X 5 R R Q > B C ; 6 B 5 > @ D l l X D ; > < L B R 8 _ ; 9 > 8 9 X ; M : 8k > E 5 9 R ; 6 B 5 > U 8 9 A B C 8 @ \ n ; > @ ; @ ] D l l X a @ B > E 9 B > F 8 R 8 > 6 5 E 6 7 8 G H D 4 I 3 J ; 6 8 > 6 D U = 9 B > 6 7 ; @ @ Q E E 8 9 8 < ; > <S B : : C 5 > 6 B > Q 8 6 5 @ Q E E 8 9 B 9 9 8 = ; 9 ; M : 8 B > b Q 9 ? ; > < < ; R ; F 8 @ B > ; > ; R 5 Q > 6 > 5 6 ? 8 6 < 8 6 8 9 R B > 8 < E 5 9 S 7 B C 7U = 9 B > 6 B @ 8 > 6 B 6 : 8 < 6 5 9 8 : B 8 E K p q r s t u v w x t y s t z s { | z s } y ~ y s tz � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � w � � � � �4 h K U = 9 B > 6 9 8 ; : : 8 F 8 @ ; > < B > C 5 9 = 5 9 ; 6 8 @ M ? 9 8 E 8 9 8 > C 8 6 7 8 ; : : 8 F ; 6 B 5 > @ @ 8 6 E 5 9 6 7 B >
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 16 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 15 of 33
paragraphs 1-53 above.
55. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '052 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '052 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of receiving and do receive telephone calls
originating from a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '052 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
56. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had, or should have had, actual
knowledge of the '052 Patent since at least July 2007.
57. Upon information and belief, despite such knowledge of the '052 Patent, Time
Warner acted in reckless disregard of Sprint's known patent rights and an objectively high
likelihood that its products and services (see, e.g., Paragraph 55) infringed Sprint's valid and
enforceable '052 Patent. As such, and upon information and belief, Time Warner's infringement
of the '052 Patent has been and is willful.
58. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '052 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
59. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
16 � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � � � ¤ � � ¥ � ¡ ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ª � « � ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ¬ ¬ © ¦§ ¢ � ¨ � � � � � � £ � � £ � � ¢ � � £ © � ¢ � � � ® ¦ ¬ � ¯ � ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � � £ � � £ � � ¢ � � £ ° ± ¤ � � � « � ² ³ � ´ � � µ � �¯ � � £ � � � � � � ¦ § ¨ © © � ¢ ¢ µ � « � £ � � � ¦ ¬ ¬ © ¦ � � ¤ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ª � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � ¶ � � � « � �· ¸ � � � � � ¹ ¦ ¬ ¬ © � � � � � � � � ¦ � � ¤ « µ � � � � £ ¥ ® � � � ¦ ¤ � � « £ ¥ ® � ¡ � � � � � £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ � ® ¢ � ½ � � ¦µ � � � ¦ � � ¥ ¥ � � ¦ � � ¤ � ¡ ¡ � � � � ¡ � � � � ¥ � � � � � ¤ � � � ¤ � � ¤ ² � � � � « ½ � £ ° � � � � ¤ £ � ¥ � � � � � ® � � � ¤ µ « £ � � �� � � � « � � ¦ � « ¥ µ ¤ � � ¾ ¿ � £ � ¥ À � ¢ � ¯ � � � � ¦ Á ¾  µ � � � � � © ¥ � � � ¯ � � � � ¦ Á ¾  µ � � � � � © ¥ � � � ¯ à ª ¦ Á � � ¤� £ � � � � � ¥ � £ � ¤ £ � ¥ � � � � � ® � � � � « � � ¦ £ � � £ � ¡ � � � � £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ � § � � � � � � � � ¤ � � � ¤ � � ¤ ² � � � � « ½ � £ °� � � � ¤ £ � ¥ � � � � � ® � � � ¤ µ « £ � � � ¤ ² � � � � � � « � � � � � « � � � � ¥ � � ¡ � � « � � � � � � ¤ ¤ � � � « � � � £ � ¥ � � � � � � « � ¥ ¥ �� � � � � £ � � ¡ � � ¢ � � � � ° � � « ½ � £ � � £ ´ � � ½ ¦ � µ « � � � ¦ ¡ � � � Ä � ¢ � ¥ � ¦ £ � � ¯ ¶ § ³ ¦ � � ¢ � � � � � £ � � £ ¤ � � « £ ¥ ® � ¡ � � � � � � £ ¥ � � � £ « ¥ � ¢ � � ¡ £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ µ � ¤ � � � � � � ¶ � © � Å ¼ Æ � · � ¹ �� � � � � � � � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � � � ¤ � � ¥ � ¡ ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � � � � � � ¤ ¦ � � � � � µ ¥ ¤ � � � � � � ¤ ¦ � « £ µ � ¥½ � � ´ ¥ � ¤ � � � ¡ £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ � � « � � £ ¥ � � � £ Ç µ ¥ ® ¼ » » Æ �� Æ � � � � � � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � � � ¤ � � ¥ � ¡ ¦ ¤ � � � £ � � µ « � ½ � � ´ ¥ � ¤ � � � ¡ £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ ¦ § ¢ �¨ � � � � � � « £ � ¤ � � � « ½ ¥ � � � ¤ � � � � � � ¤ � ¡ ¶ � � � £ È � ½ � � ´ � � � £ � � £ � � � £ � � � ¤ � � � � É � « £ � � ¥ ® � � �¥ ½ � ¥ � � � ¤ £ � � £ £ � � � � ¤ µ « £ � � � ¤ � � � � « � � · Ê Ë Ë Ì Ë Í Î � ¦ ¯ � � � � � � � � � � ¹ � ¡ � � � � ¤ ¶ � � � £ È � � � ¥ ¤ � � ¤� � ¡ � � « � � � ¥ � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ � ± � � µ « � ¦ � � ¤ µ � � � � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � � � ¤ � � ¥ � ¡ ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � È � � ¡ � � � � ¢ � � £� ¡ £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ � � � � � � � � � ¤ � ´ ¥ ¥ ¡ µ ¥ �� Ï � � � � � � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � � � ¤ � � ¥ � ¡ ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ª � « � ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ¬ ¬ © ¦§ ¢ � ¨ � � � � � � £ � � £ � � ¢ � � £ © � ¢ � � � ® ¦ ¬ � ¯ � ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � � £ � � £ � � ¢ � � £ ° ± ¤ � � � « � ² ³ � ´ � � µ � �¯ � � £ � � � � � � ¦ § ¨ © © � ¢ ¢ µ � « � £ � � � ¦ ¬ ¬ © ¦ � � ¤ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ª � ¡ � � ¢ � £ � � ¶ � � � « � �· ¸ � � � � � ¹ ¦ ¬ ¬ © È � � ¡ � � � � ¢ � � £ � ¡ £ � � º » � ¼ ¯ � £ � � £ ´ ¥ ¥ « � � £ � µ � µ � ¥ � � � � � É � � � ¤ � ® £ � � © � µ � £ �� Ð � ± � � ¤ � � « £ � � ¤ � � � Ä ¢ � £ � « � � � � Ñ µ � � « � � ¡ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � � © � � ¥ � ª � « � ¦ § ¢ � ¨ � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 17 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 16 of 33
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '052 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief
COUNT 4: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '932 Patent
60. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-59 above.
61. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '932 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '932 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of placing and do place telephone calls that
terminate on a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '932 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
62. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had, or should have had, actual
knowledge of the '932 Patent since at least July 2007.
63. Upon information and belief, despite such knowledge of the '932 Patent, Time
Warner acted in reckless disregard of Sprint's known patent rights and an objectively high
likelihood that its products and services (see, e.g., Paragraph 61) infringed Sprint's valid and
17 Ò Ó
Ô Õ Ö × Ø Ù Ù Ô Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß á à â Ø ß â Õ Ü à Ý Ø à â Ô ã Ý ä Õ à å Ú Ù æ ç æ Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß á à â Ø ß â Õ Ü à Ý Ø à â èé ê ë Õ à ì Ø í î Ø ï ð ã ñ ò Ø ç Õ ß â à Ø ß ò ð Ü ä Ú Û Þ Ô Ô ã Ý Ý ñ à Ü ì Õ â Ü ã à ò Ú Ù Ù Ô Ú Õ à ê Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß Ô Õ Ö × Øó à ô ã ß Ý Õ â Ü ã à õ Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø ò ö ÷ Õ à ò Õ ò ø Ú Ù Ù Ô ù ò Ü à ô ß Ü à ú Ø Ý Ø à â ã ô â ð Ø û ü ý þ ç Õ â Ø à â Ú õ ä ß Ü à â ð Õ ò ò ñ ô ô Ø ß Ø ê Õ à êï Ü × × ì ã à â Ü à ñ Ø â ã ò ñ ô ô Ø ß Ü ß ß Ø ä Õ ß Õ Ö × Ø Ü à ÿ ñ ß å Õ à ê ê Õ Ý Õ ú Ø ò Ü à Õ à Õ Ý ã ñ à â à ã â å Ø â ê Ø â Ø ß Ý Ü à Ø ê ô ã ß ï ð Ü ì ðõ ä ß Ü à â Ü ò Ø à â Ü â × Ø ê â ã ß Ø × Ü Ø ô æ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� ü æ õ ä ß Ü à â ß Ø Õ × × Ø ú Ø ò Õ à ê Ü à ì ã ß ä ã ß Õ â Ø ò Ö å ß Ø ô Ø ß Ø à ì Ø â ð Ø Õ × × Ø ú Õ â Ü ã à ò ò Ø â ô ã ß â ð Ü àä Õ ß Õ ú ß Õ ä ð ò Ò � ý Õ Ö ã ë Ø æ� Ò æ ! ä ã à Ü à ô ã ß Ý Õ â Ü ã à Õ à ê Ö Ø × Ü Ø ô Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß Ô Õ Ö × Ø ó à ì æ Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß Ô Õ Ö × Ø Ù Ù Ô ÚÛ Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß á à â Ø ß â Õ Ü à Ý Ø à â Ô ã Ý ä Õ à å Ú Ù æ ç æ Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß á à â Ø ß â Õ Ü à Ý Ø à â è é ê ë Õ à ì Ø í î Ø ï ð ã ñ ò Øç Õ ß â à Ø ß ò ð Ü ä Ú Û Þ Ô Ô ã Ý Ý ñ à Ü ì Õ â Ü ã à ò Ú Ù Ù Ô Ú Õ à ê Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß Ô Õ Ö × Ø ó à ô ã ß Ý Õ â Ü ã à õ Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø òö ÷ Õ à ò Õ ò ø Ú Ù Ù Ô ð Õ ë Ø Ö Ø Ø à Ú Õ à ê ì ñ ß ß Ø à â × å Õ ß Ø Ú ê Ü ß Ø ì â × å Ü à ô ß Ü à ú Ü à ú â ð Ø û " þ ç Õ â Ø à â Ö å Ý Õ # Ü à ú Úñ ò Ü à ú Ú ò Ø × × Ü à ú Ú Õ à ê ã ô ô Ø ß Ü à ú ô ã ß ò Õ × Ø Ö ß ã Õ ê Ö Õ à ê Õ à ê í ã ß ä Õ ì # Ø â è Ö Õ ò Ø ê â Ø × Ø ä ð ã à å ä ß ã ê ñ ì â ò ã ßò Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø ò Ú Ü à ì × ñ ê Ü à ú $ % Ü ú Ü â Õ × & ã Ý Ø ç ð ã à Ø Ú ' $ ( ñ ò Ü à Ø ò ò Ô × Õ ò ò ç ð ã à Ø Ú ' $ ( ñ ò Ü à Ø ò ò Ô × Õ ò ò ç ) ó Ú ' Õ à êã â ð Ø ß ß Ø × Õ â Ø ê â Ø × Ø ä ð ã à å ò Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø ò Ú â ð Õ â Ü à ô ß Ü à ú Ø â ð Ø û " þ ç Õ â Ø à â æ Û ð Ø ò Ø Ö ß ã Õ ê Ö Õ à ê Õ à ê í ã ß ä Õ ì # Ø â èÖ Õ ò Ø ê â Ø × Ø ä ð ã à å ä ß ã ê ñ ì â ò Õ à ê í ã ß ò Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø ò Õ ß Ø ì Õ ä Õ Ö × Ø ã ô ä × Õ ì Ü à ú Õ à ê ê ã ä × Õ ì Ø â Ø × Ø ä ð ã à Ø ì Õ × × ò â ð Õ ââ Ø ß Ý Ü à Õ â Ø ã à Õ à ã à è ä Õ ì # Ø â à Ø â ï ã ß # Ú ò ñ ì ð Õ ò Ú ô ã ß Ø * Õ Ý ä × Ø Ú â ð Ø ç õ Û î Ú Ü à Õ Ý Õ à à Ø ß â ð Õ â ê Ü ß Ø ì â × åÜ à ô ß Ü à ú Ø ò Õ â × Ø Õ ò â ì × Õ Ü Ý Ò ã ô â ð Ø û " þ ç Õ â Ø à â ñ à ê Ø ß " ý ! æ õ æ Ô æ + þ Ó Ò ö Õ ø æ� þ æ ! ä ã à Ü à ô ã ß Ý Õ â Ü ã à Õ à ê Ö Ø × Ü Ø ô Ú Û Ü Ý Ø Þ Õ ß à Ø ß ð Õ ò ð Õ ê Ú ã ß ò ð ã ñ × ê ð Õ ë Ø ð Õ ê Ú Õ ì â ñ Õ ×# à ã ï × Ø ê ú Ø ã ô â ð Ø û " þ ç Õ â Ø à â ò Ü à ì Ø Õ â × Ø Õ ò â , ñ × å þ ü ü Ó æ� " æ ! ä ã à Ü à ô ã ß Ý Õ â Ü ã à Õ à ê Ö Ø × Ü Ø ô Ú ê Ø ò ä Ü â Ø ò ñ ì ð # à ã ï × Ø ê ú Ø ã ô â ð Ø û " þ ç Õ â Ø à â Ú Û Ü Ý ØÞ Õ ß à Ø ß Õ ì â Ø ê Ü à ß Ø ì # × Ø ò ò ê Ü ò ß Ø ú Õ ß ê ã ô õ ä ß Ü à â ù ò # à ã ï à ä Õ â Ø à â ß Ü ú ð â ò Õ à ê Õ à ã Ö ÿ Ø ì â Ü ë Ø × å ð Ü ú ð× Ü # Ø × Ü ð ã ã ê â ð Õ â Ü â ò ä ß ã ê ñ ì â ò Õ à ê ò Ø ß ë Ü ì Ø ò ö - . . / . 0 1 æ Ú ç Õ ß Õ ú ß Õ ä ð � Ò ø Ü à ô ß Ü à ú Ø ê õ ä ß Ü à â ù ò ë Õ × Ü ê Õ à ê
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 18 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 17 of 33
enforceable '932 Patent. As such, and upon information and belief, Time Warner's infringement
of the '932 Patent has been and is willful.
64. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '932 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
65. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '932 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 5: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '429 Patent
66. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-65 above.
67. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '429 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '429 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of receiving and do receive telephone calls
18 2 3
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` : 5 E : E a H W W U O E K 5 6 8 K 5 P 4 L 4 5 B 7 6 B G 4 = > ? @ A : B 4 5 B Q K < < 9 7 5 B K 5 F 4 F 5 < 4 E E 4 5 b 7 K 5 4 I ; Y B G K E U 7 F 8 B CR c C D E : I K 8 4 9 B : 5 I J 8 7 d K L : B 4 9 7 5 E 4 e F 4 5 9 4 7 6 M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 U : ; < 4 V 5 9 C H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8U : ; < 4 W W U H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 X 5 B 4 8 B : K 5 L 4 5 B U 7 L J : 5 Y H W C A C H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 X 5 B 4 8 B : K 5 L 4 5 B ZD I [ : 5 9 4 \ ] 4 Q G 7 F E 4 A : 8 B 5 4 8 E G K J H M N U U 7 L L F 5 K 9 : B K 7 5 E H W W U H : 5 I M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 U : ; < 4V 5 6 7 8 L : B K 7 5 ^ 4 8 [ K 9 4 E _ ` : 5 E : E a H W W U O E K 5 6 8 K 5 P 4 L 4 5 B 7 6 B G 4 = > ? @ A : B 4 5 B H ^ J 8 K 5 B G : E E F 6 6 4 8 4 I : 5 IQ K < < 9 7 5 B K 5 F 4 B 7 E F 6 6 4 8 K 8 8 4 J : 8 : ; < 4 K 5 b F 8 Y : 5 I I : L : P 4 E K 5 : 5 : L 7 F 5 B 5 7 B Y 4 B I 4 B 4 8 L K 5 4 I 6 7 8 Q G K 9 G^ J 8 K 5 B K E 4 5 B K B < 4 I B 7 8 4 < K 4 6 C f g h i j k l m n j o i j p i q r p i s o t o i jp u v w x u y z { z u | } v | ~ z � � � � m � | z u |R R C ^ J 8 K 5 B 8 4 : < < 4 P 4 E : 5 I K 5 9 7 8 J 7 8 : B 4 E ; Y 8 4 6 4 8 4 5 9 4 B G 4 : < < 4 P : B K 7 5 E E 4 B 6 7 8 B G K 5J : 8 : P 8 : J G E 2 � R c : ; 7 [ 4 CR � C T J 7 5 K 5 6 7 8 L : B K 7 5 : 5 I ; 4 < K 4 6 H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 U : ; < 4 V 5 9 C H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 U : ; < 4 W W U HM K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 X 5 B 4 8 B : K 5 L 4 5 B U 7 L J : 5 Y H W C A C H M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 X 5 B 4 8 B : K 5 L 4 5 B Z D I [ : 5 9 4 \ ] 4 Q G 7 F E 4A : 8 B 5 4 8 E G K J H M N U U 7 L L F 5 K 9 : B K 7 5 E H W W U H : 5 I M K L 4 N : 8 5 4 8 U : ; < 4 V 5 6 7 8 L : B K 7 5 ^ 4 8 [ K 9 4 E_ ` : 5 E : E a H W W U G : [ 4 ; 4 4 5 H : 5 I 9 F 8 8 4 5 B < Y : 8 4 H I K 8 4 9 B < Y K 5 6 8 K 5 P K 5 P B G 4 = S @ > A : B 4 5 B ; Y L : � K 5 P HF E K 5 P H E 4 < < K 5 P H : 5 I 7 6 6 4 8 K 5 P 6 7 8 E : < 4 ; 8 7 : I ; : 5 I : 5 I \ 7 8 J : 9 � 4 B Z ; : E 4 I B 4 < 4 J G 7 5 Y J 8 7 I F 9 B E 7 8E 4 8 [ K 9 4 E H K 5 9 < F I K 5 P � � K P K B : < � 7 L 4 A G 7 5 4 H � � � F E K 5 4 E E U < : E E A G 7 5 4 H � � � F E K 5 4 E E U < : E E A � V H � : 5 I7 B G 4 8 8 4 < : B 4 I B 4 < 4 J G 7 5 Y E 4 8 [ K 9 4 E H B G : B K 5 6 8 K 5 P 4 B G 4 = S @ > A : B 4 5 B C M G 4 E 4 ; 8 7 : I ; : 5 I : 5 I \ 7 8 J : 9 � 4 B Z; : E 4 I B 4 < 4 J G 7 5 Y J 8 7 I F 9 B E : 5 I \ 7 8 E 4 8 [ K 9 4 E : 8 4 9 : J : ; < 4 7 6 8 4 9 4 K [ K 5 P : 5 I I 7 8 4 9 4 K [ 4 B 4 < 4 J G 7 5 4 9 : < < E
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 19 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 18 of 33
originating from a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '429 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
68. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had, or should have had, actual
knowledge of the '429 Patent since at least July 2007.
69. Upon information and belief, despite such knowledge of the '429 Patent, Time
Warner acted in reckless disregard of Sprint's known patent rights and an objectively high
likelihood that its products and services (see, e.g., Paragraph 67) infringed Sprint's valid and
enforceable '429 Patent. As such, and upon information and belief, Time Warner's infringement
of the '429 Patent has been and is willful.
70. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '429 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
71. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '429 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 6: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '064 Patent
72. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-71 above.
73. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
19 � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � ¢ � � � £ � � � ¡ � ¤ ¥ ¦ § � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � ¨ � � � � � £ ©� � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � £ � � � � � � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � � ¨ � � ® ¯ ° ¥ ° ± ° ² ¬ ³ � ´ � µ °¶ · ° ¯ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ ¸ � £ � � � � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ¡ � � ¡ � ¨ � � � � ¡ � £ ¨ ¡ � º � ¡ � ¨ � � � � � £� � � � £ � ¨ � � � � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � £ � � � � » £ © ¬ ¼ ¼ ³ °¶ � ° ¯ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ ¸ � £ � � � � ¨ � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � £ � ¨ � � � � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � � ¦ � � �¹ � � � � � � � � � ¨ � � � � � � £ � � � ¨ � � � � � � � ¨ � � ¥ � � � � � ½ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � � � ¨ � � � ¸ ¾ � � � � º � £ © ¡ � � ¡£ � � � £ � ¡ � � ¨ � ¡ � � � � � � � � ¨ � � � � � ¨ � � � º � � � � ´ ¿ À À Á À  à ° � ¤ � � � � � � � ¡ ¶ ³ µ � � � � � � � � ¨ ¥ � � � � � ½ � º � £ � ¨ � � ¨� � � � � � � � ¸ £ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � ° Ä � � � ¡ � � � ¨ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ ¸ � £ � � � � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ½ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � ¡ � � ¸ � � � � � ¨ � � � � £ £ � £ °³ ¼ ° ¯ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ ¸ � £ � � � � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Å � � ° � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Æ Æ ± �¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � Ç � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � � � � © � Æ ° ¤ ° � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � Ç � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ä ¨ º � � � � È § � � ¡ � � �¤ � � � � � � � ¡ � � � ¦ ¹ ± ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � Æ Æ ± � � � ¨ ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Å � � � � � � � � � � ¥ � � º � � � �´ É � � � � � µ � Æ Æ ± ½ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � � � £ £ � � � � � � � � £ � � � � � ¾ � � � � ¨ ¸ © � ¡ � � ± � � � °³ � ° Ä � � ¨ � � � � � � � ¨ � � � ¢ � � � � � � � � � � Ê � � � � � � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Å � � ° � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � �± � ¸ £ � Æ Æ ± � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � Ç � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � � � � © � Æ ° ¤ ° � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � Ç � � � � � � � � � � � � �Ä ¨ º � � � � È § � � ¡ � � � ¤ � � � � � � � ¡ � � � ¦ ¹ ± ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � Æ Æ ± � � � ¨ ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ �Å � � � � � � � � � � ¥ � � º � � � � ´ É � � � � � µ � Æ Æ ± ½ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � ª « ¬ � ¤ � � � � � � ¥ � � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � ¨ � � ¨� � £ £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¸ £ � � � ¾ � © � � ¨ ¨ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � © � � ¨ � � � � � � � � ¨ � � � � ¡ � � ¡¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � £ � ¨ � � � � £ � � � ° Ë Ì Í Î Ï Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ï Ô Î Ï Õ Î Ö × Õ Î Ø Ô Ù Ô Î ÏÕ Ú Û Ü Ý Ú Þ ß à ß Ú á â Û á ã ß ä å Ð æ Ò ç á ß Ú á³ ¬ ° ¥ � � � � � � � � £ £ � � � � � � ¨ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¸ © � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � £ £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � �� � � � � � � � ¡ � � è ³ � � ¸ � º � °³ ° ¯ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¨ ¸ � £ � � � � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Å � � ° � ¦ � � � ¹ � � � � � ± � ¸ £ � Æ Æ ± �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 20 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 19 of 33
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '064 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '064 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of placing and do place telephone calls that
terminate on a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '064 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
74. Upon information and belief, Time Warner has had, or should have had, actual
knowledge of the '064 Patent since at least July 2007.
75. Upon information and belief, despite such knowledge of the '064 Patent, Time
Warner acted in reckless disregard of Sprint's known patent rights and an objectively high
likelihood that its products and services (see, e.g., Paragraph 73) infringed Sprint's valid and
enforceable '064 Patent. As such, and upon information and belief, Time Warner's infringement
of the '064 Patent has been and is willful.
76. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '064 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
77. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
20 é ê
ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô õ ö í ÷ ð ò ø ù ú û ü û ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô ý þ ÿ � ð ò � î � � î � � ö � � îü ð ñ ô ò î ñ � � ì ÷ ù ë ï õ õ ö í í � ò ì � ð ô ì ö ò � ù ú ú õ ù ð ò ÿ ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò � î ñ � ì � î � � ð ò � ð � � ù ú ú õ � ð � î � î î ò ù ð ò ÿ � � ñ ñ î ò ô ø ð ñ î ù ÿ ì ñ î � ô ø ì ò � ñ ì ò � ì ò � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô � ø í ð � ì ò � ù� � ì ò � ù � î ì ò � ù ð ò ÿ ö � � î ñ ì ò � � ö ñ � ð î � ñ ö ð ÿ � ð ò ÿ ð ò ÿ � ö ñ ÷ ð � � î ô ý � ð � î ÿ ô î î ÷ � ö ò ø ÷ ñ ö ÿ � � ô � ö ñ� î ñ � ì � î � ù ì ò � � ÿ ì ò � � � ì � ì ô ð � ö í î ü � ö ò î ù � � � � � ì ò î � � õ ð � � ü � ö ò î ù � � � � � ì ò î � � õ ð � � ü � ù � ð ò ÿö ô � î ñ ñ î ð ô î ÿ ô î î ÷ � ö ò ø � î ñ � ì � î � ù ô � ð ô ì ò � ñ ì ò � î ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô û ë � î � î � ñ ö ð ÿ � ð ò ÿ ð ò ÿ � ö ñ ÷ ð � � î ô ý� ð � î ÿ ô î î ÷ � ö ò ø ÷ ñ ö ÿ � � ô � ð ò ÿ � ö ñ � î ñ � ì � î � ð ñ î � ð ÷ ð � î ö � ÷ ð � ì ò � ð ò ÿ ÿ ö ÷ ð � î ô î î ÷ � ö ò î � ð � ô � ð ôô î ñ í ì ò ð ô î ö ò ð ò ö ò ý ÷ ð � � î ô ò î ô � ö ñ � ù � � � � ð � ù � ö ñ î � ð í ÷ î ù ô � î ü � ë � ù ì ò ð í ð ò ò î ñ ô � ð ô ÿ ì ñ î � ô øì ò � ñ ì ò � î � ð ô î ð � ô � ð ì í � ö � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô � ò ÿ î ñ � � � û � û õ û é ! � ð � û! � û � ÷ ö ò ì ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò ð ò ÿ � î ì î � ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ � ð � � ð ÿ ù ö ñ � � ö � ÿ � ð � î � ð ÿ ù ð � ô � ð � ò ö � î ÿ � î ö � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô � ì ò � î ð ô î ð � ô " � ø é ê ê ! û! � û � ÷ ö ò ì ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò ð ò ÿ � î ì î � ù ÿ î � ÷ ì ô î � � � � � ò ö � î ÿ � î ö � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô ù ë ì í îï ð ñ ò î ñ ð � ô î ÿ ì ò ñ î � � î � � ÿ ì � ñ î � ð ñ ÿ ö � � ÷ ñ ì ò ô # � � ò ö � ò ÷ ð ô î ò ô ñ ì � � ô � ð ò ÿ ð ò ö � $ î � ô ì � î ø � ì � � ì � î ì � ö ö ÿ ô � ð ô ì ô � ÷ ñ ö ÿ � � ô � ð ò ÿ � î ñ � ì � î � % & & ' & ( ) û ù ü ð ñ ð � ñ ð ÷ � ! � � ì ò � ñ ì ò � î ÿ � ÷ ñ ì ò ô # � � ð ì ÿ ð ò ÿî ò � ö ñ � î ð � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô û þ � � � � � ù ð ò ÿ � ÷ ö ò ì ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò ð ò ÿ � î ì î � ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ # � ì ò � ñ ì ò � î í î ò ôö � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô � ð � � î î ò ð ò ÿ ì � � ì � � û! � û � ÷ ö ò ì ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò ð ò ÿ � î ì î � ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î ò � û ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î ú ú õ ùë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô õ ö í ÷ ð ò ø ù ú û ü û ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô ý þ ÿ � ð ò � î � � î � � ö � � îü ð ñ ô ò î ñ � � ì ÷ ù ë ï õ õ ö í í � ò ì � ð ô ì ö ò � ù ú ú õ ù ð ò ÿ ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î ò � ö ñ í ð ô ì ö ò � î ñ � ì � î � � ð ò � ð � � ù ú ú õ # � ì ò � ñ ì ò � î í î ò ô ö � ô � î � ê � � ü ð ô î ò ô � ì � ö ò ô ì ò � î � ò î � � î ò $ ö ì ò î ÿ � ø ô � ì � õ ö � ñ ô û! ! û þ � ð ÿ ì ñ î � ô ð ò ÿ ÷ ñ ö � ì í ð ô î � ö ò � î * � î ò � î ö � ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î ò � û ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñõ ð � î ú ú õ ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô õ ö í ÷ ð ò ø ù ú û ü û ù ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ ó ò ô î ñ ô ð ì ò í î ò ô ýþ ÿ � ð ò � î � � î � � ö � � î ü ð ñ ô ò î ñ � � ì ÷ ù ë ï õ õ ö í í � ò ì � ð ô ì ö ò � ù ú ú õ ù ð ò ÿ ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò î ñ õ ð � î
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 21 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 20 of 33
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '064 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief
COUNT 7: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '992 Patent
78. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-77 above.
79. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '992 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '992 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of monitoring and do monitor user
communications during a call to detect a call trigger in a manner that directly infringes at least
claim 1 of the '992 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
80. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '992 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
21 + ,
- . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 6 7 1 8 5 9 7 : ; < 3 . : 3 : = > ? ? @ A : 5 . / 1 5 . B 7 2 7 . 4 0 / 4 C 7 D E F G H 3 4 7 . 4 > 6 I 1 5 . 4 C 3 : : J / / 7 1 7 K 3 . KL 5 M M 9 0 . 4 5 . J 7 4 0 : J / / 7 1 5 1 1 7 I 3 1 3 N M 7 5 . O J 1 P 3 . K K 3 2 3 B 7 : 5 . 3 . 3 2 0 J . 4 . 0 4 P 7 4 K 7 4 7 1 2 5 . 7 K / 0 1 L C 5 9 C6 I 1 5 . 4 5 : 7 . 4 5 4 M 7 K 4 0 1 7 M 5 7 / Q R S T U V W X Y Z V [ U V \ U ] ^ \ U _ [ ` [ U V\ a b c d a e f g f a h i b h j f k l l m Y n h f a ho p Q 6 I 1 5 . 4 1 7 3 M M 7 B 7 : 3 . K 5 . 9 0 1 I 0 1 3 4 7 : N P 1 7 / 7 1 7 . 9 7 4 C 7 3 M M 7 B 3 4 5 0 . : : 7 4 / 0 1 4 C 5 .I 3 1 3 B 1 3 I C : , q o o 3 N 0 8 7 Qo r Q s I 0 . 5 . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 3 . K N 7 M 5 7 / > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 - . 9 Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 ? ? @ >t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 @ 0 2 I 3 . P > ? Q H Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 w x K 8 3 . 9 7 y z 7 L C 0 J : 7H 3 1 4 . 7 1 : C 5 I > t u @ @ 0 2 2 J . 5 9 3 4 5 0 . : > ? ? @ > 3 . K t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 - . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 6 7 1 8 5 9 7 :; < 3 . : 3 : = > ? ? @ C 3 8 7 N 7 7 . > 3 . K 9 J 1 1 7 . 4 M P 3 1 7 > K 5 1 7 9 4 M P 5 . / 1 5 . B 5 . B 4 C 7 D r r + H 3 4 7 . 4 N P 2 3 { 5 . B >J : 5 . B > : 7 M M 5 . B > 3 . K 0 / / 7 1 5 . B / 0 1 : 3 M 7 N 1 0 3 K N 3 . K 3 . K y 0 1 I 3 9 { 7 4 w N 3 : 7 K 4 7 M 7 I C 0 . P I 1 0 K J 9 4 : 0 1: 7 1 8 5 9 7 : > 5 . 9 M J K 5 . B | } 5 B 5 4 3 M ~ 0 2 7 H C 0 . 7 > � | � J : 5 . 7 : : @ M 3 : : H C 0 . 7 > � | � J : 5 . 7 : : @ M 3 : : H � - > � 3 . K0 4 C 7 1 1 7 M 3 4 7 K 4 7 M 7 I C 0 . P : 7 1 8 5 9 7 : > 4 C 3 4 5 . / 1 5 . B 7 4 C 7 D r r + H 3 4 7 . 4 Q t C 7 : 7 N 1 0 3 K N 3 . K 3 . K y 0 1 I 3 9 { 7 4 wN 3 : 7 K 4 7 M 7 I C 0 . P I 1 0 K J 9 4 : 3 . K y 0 1 : 7 1 8 5 9 7 : 3 1 7 9 3 I 3 N M 7 0 / 2 0 . 5 4 0 1 5 . B 3 . K K 0 2 0 . 5 4 0 1 J : 7 19 0 2 2 J . 5 9 3 4 5 0 . : K J 1 5 . B 3 9 3 M M 4 0 K 7 4 7 9 4 3 9 3 M M 4 1 5 B B 7 1 5 . 3 2 3 . . 7 1 4 C 3 4 K 5 1 7 9 4 M P 5 . / 1 5 . B 7 : 3 4 M 7 3 : 49 M 3 5 2 , 0 / 4 C 7 D r r + H 3 4 7 . 4 J . K 7 1 � � s Q 6 Q @ Q � + o , ; 3 = Qp E Q s I 0 . 5 . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 3 . K N 7 M 5 7 / > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 - . 9 Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 ? ? @ >t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 @ 0 2 I 3 . P > ? Q H Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 w x K 8 3 . 9 7 y z 7 L C 0 J : 7H 3 1 4 . 7 1 : C 5 I > t u @ @ 0 2 2 J . 5 9 3 4 5 0 . : > ? ? @ > 3 . K t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 - . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 6 7 1 8 5 9 7 :; < 3 . : 3 : = > ? ? @ K 5 K . 0 4 C 3 8 7 3 9 4 J 3 M { . 0 L M 7 K B 7 0 / 4 C 7 D r r + H 3 4 7 . 4 J . 4 5 M 6 I 1 5 . 4 / 5 M 7 K 4 C 5 : M 3 L : J 5 4 5 .} 7 9 7 2 N 7 1 + E , , Q s I 0 . / J 1 4 C 7 1 5 . / 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 . 3 . K N 7 M 5 7 / > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7 - . 9 Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1@ 3 N M 7 ? ? @ > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 @ 0 2 I 3 . P > ? Q H Q > t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 v . 4 7 1 4 3 5 . 2 7 . 4 wx K 8 3 . 9 7 y z 7 L C 0 J : 7 H 3 1 4 . 7 1 : C 5 I > t u @ @ 0 2 2 J . 5 9 3 4 5 0 . : > ? ? @ > 3 . K t 5 2 7 u 3 1 . 7 1 @ 3 N M 7
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 22 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 21 of 33
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '992 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
81. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '992 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
82. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '992 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief
COUNT 8: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '224 Patent
83. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-82 above.
84. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '224 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '224 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of providing and do provide enhanced
22 � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ ¢ � � £ � � � � � ¤ � � � � � � � ¡ ¢ � � £ � � � � ¡ � � � � � � � � ¥ � � � ¦ § § ¨ © � � � � � ª � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ � � ¥ � ¢ � � � � « � � � � ª � � ¨ ¬ ®¯ ® ° ± � � � � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � ª � ¢ � � ¥ � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � ´ � � ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � � � � �² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � ¤ � � ® © ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¶ · � � � � � � ¸ ¹ � ¡ � � � � �© � � � � � � � � � ± � ² ³ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � ´ � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � º � � � ¥ � � � £ � � � � � � ¥ � � � ¦ § § ¨ © � � � � � ¡ � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � ¢ � � � � � » � � � � � ª ¤ � � � � � � � � � ®¯ ¨ ® · � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � ¼ � � � � � � � � � � ½ � � � � � � ¥ ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � ´ � � ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � �� � ª ¢ � � � � � ² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � ¤ � � ® © ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¶· � � � � � � ¸ ¹ � ¡ � � � � � © � � � � � � � � � ± � ² ³ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ �´ � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � º � � � ¥ � � � £ � � � � � � ¥ � � � ¦ § § ¨ © � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � ¥ ¥ � � � � � � �¡ � ¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥ ¥ � � � � � � ± � � � ª ¢ � � � » � � ¤ � � � � � � � £ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥ � � ¡ � � � �� ± � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ � � � � � � ¢ � � ¥ ® ¾ ¿ À Á Â Ã Ä Å Æ Â Ç Á Â È Á É Ê È Á Ë Ç Ì Ç Á ÂÈ Í Î Ï Ð Í Ñ Ò Ó Ò Í Ô Õ Î Ô Ö Ò × Ø Ø Ù Å Ú Ô Ò Í Ô¯ Û ® � ± � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � £ � � � � � � � � � � ± � � � � � � ª ¤ � � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¢ � £ � � � � � � � � � ¥ � � � � � �± � � � £ � � ± � � Ü ¯ ¨ � ª � � � ®¯ Ý ® ° ± � � � � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � ª � ¢ � � ¥ � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � ´ � � ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � � � � �² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � � ¤ � � ® © ® � ² � � � ³ � � � � � µ � � � � � � � � � � � � ¶ · � � � � � � ¸ ¹ � ¡ � � � � �© � � � � � � � � � ± � ² ³ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ² � � � ³ � � � � � � � ª ¢ � ´ � ¥ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ª � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¤ � � � � � � � � � � ¢ ¤ � � ¥ � � � £ � � £ � � � ¦ ¨ ¨ Ý © � � � � � ª ¤ � � � � £ �� � � � £ � � � ¢ ¢ � � £ � � � � � ¥ ¥ � � � � £ ¥ � � � � ¢ � ª � � � � ª � � � � � � ¸ � � ± � � � � ¶ ª � � � � � � ¢ � ± � � � ¤ ± � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � ¢ � � � � £ Þ « � £ � � � ¢ ß � � � © � � � � � à Þ á � � � � � � � � ¢ � � � © � � � � � à Þ á � � � � � � � � ¢ � � � © â ´ � à � � �� � � � � � � ¢ � � � � � � ¢ � ± � � � ¤ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¥ � � � £ � � � � ¦ ¨ ¨ Ý © � � � � � ® ² � � � � ª � � � � ª � � � � � � ¸ � � ± � � � � ¶ª � � � � � � ¢ � ± � � � ¤ ± � � � � � � � � � � ¸ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ± � ª ¢ � � ¥ ± � � � � � � � £ � � � � � ± � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 23 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 22 of 33
services in a manner that directly infringes at least claim 1 of the '224 Patent under 35 U.S.C. §
271(a).
85. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '224 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '992 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
86. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '224 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
87. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '224 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 9: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '918 Patent
88. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
23 ã ä
å æ ç è é ê æ å é ë ì í ì ë ë æ ç î ï ì î ð é ç æ ê î ñ ò é ë ó ç é ë ô æ å ì î ñ æ ì å î ê ñ ì é í õ ö ó î ï æ ÷ ã ã ø ù ì î æ ë î ú ë ð æ ç ä û ü ý þ ý ÿ ý �ã � õ � ì � ý � û ý ü � ö ë é ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë ì ë ð � æ ñ é æ ó � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ê ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ � � ÿ �� é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î ÿ ö í � ì ë ò � � ý ù ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î � ð è ì ë ê æ � � æ � ï ö ú å æù ì ç î ë æ ç å ï é � � � ÿ ÿ ö í í ú ë é ê ì î é ö ë å � � � ÿ � ì ë ð � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë þ æ ç è é ê æ å� � ì ë å ì å � � � � ÿ ð é ð ë ö î ï ì è æ ì ê î ú ì ñ � ë ö � ñ æ ð ô æ ö ó î ï æ ÷ ã ã ø ù ì î æ ë î ú ë î é ñ þ � ç é ë î ó é ñ æ ð î ï é å ñ ì � å ú é î é ë� æ ê æ í � æ ç ã � õ õ ý ü � ö ë ó ú ç î ï æ ç é ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë ì ë ð � æ ñ é æ ó � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ê ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ çÿ ì � ñ æ � � ÿ � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î ÿ ö í � ì ë ò � � ý ù ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î � ð è ì ë ê æ � � æ � ï ö ú å æ ù ì ç î ë æ ç å ï é � � � ÿ ÿ ö í í ú ë é ê ì î é ö ë å � � � ÿ � ì ë ð � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë þ æ ç è é ê æ å � � ì ë å ì å � � � � ÿ ð é ð ë ö î ï ì è æ ê ö ë å î ç ú ê î é è æ � ë ö � ñ æ ð ô æ ö ç ì ë ò ö î ï æ ç� ë ö � ñ æ ð ô æ ö ç ì � ì ç æ ë æ å å ö ó î ï æ ÷ � � ã ù ì î æ ë î � æ ó ö ç æ î ï é å å ú é î � ì å ó é ñ æ ð é ë � æ ê æ í � æ ç ã � õ õ ý� � ý ü � ö ë é ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë ì ë ð � æ ñ é æ ó � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ê ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ � � ÿ �� é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î ÿ ö í � ì ë ò � � ý ù ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î � ð è ì ë ê æ � � æ � ï ö ú å æù ì ç î ë æ ç å ï é � � � ÿ ÿ ö í í ú ë é ê ì î é ö ë å � � � ÿ � ì ë ð � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë þ æ ç è é ê æ å� � ì ë å ì å � � � � ÿ � å é ë ó ç é ë ô æ í æ ë î ö ó î ï æ ÷ ã ã ø ù ì î æ ë î � é ñ ñ ê ö ë î é ë ú æ ú ë ñ æ å å æ ë � ö é ë æ ð � ò î ï é å ÿ ö ú ç î ý� � ý � å ì ð é ç æ ê î ì ë ð � ç ö � é í ì î æ ê ö ë å æ � ú æ ë ê æ ö ó � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ê ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ çÿ ì � ñ æ � � ÿ � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î ÿ ö í � ì ë ò � � ý ù ý � � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç � ë î æ ç î ì é ë í æ ë î � ð è ì ë ê æ � � æ � ï ö ú å æ ù ì ç î ë æ ç å ï é � � � ÿ ÿ ö í í ú ë é ê ì î é ö ë å � � � ÿ � ì ë ð � é í æ ì ç ë æ ç ÿ ì � ñ æ ë ó ö ç í ì î é ö ë þ æ ç è é ê æ å � � ì ë å ì å � � � � ÿ � å é ë ó ç é ë ô æ í æ ë î ö ó î ï æ ÷ ã ã ø ù ì î æ ë î � þ � ç é ë î ï ì å å ú ó ó æ ç æ ð ì ë ð� é ñ ñ ê ö ë î é ë ú æ î ö å ú ó ó æ ç é ç ç æ � ì ç ì � ñ æ é ë � ú ç ò ì ë ð ð ì í ì ô æ å é ë ì ë ì í ö ú ë î ë ö î ò æ î ð æ î æ ç í é ë æ ð ó ö ç � ï é ê ïþ � ç é ë î é å æ ë î é î ñ æ ð î ö ç æ ñ é æ ó ý � � � � ! " # $ % � & � ' ( & � ) % * % � & + , - . + / 0 1 0 + 2 3 , 2 4 0 5 ! 6 7 # 8 2 0 + 2� � ý þ � ç é ë î ç æ ì ñ ñ æ ô æ å ì ë ð é ë ê ö ç � ö ç ì î æ å � ò ç æ ó æ ç æ ë ê æ î ï æ ì ñ ñ æ ô ì î é ö ë å å æ î ó ö ç î ï é ë
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 24 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 23 of 33
paragraphs 1-87 above.
89. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '918 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '918 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of employing and do employ control
system data tables filled with call routing data in a manner that directly infringes at least claim 11
of the '918 under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
90. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '918 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '918 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
91. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
24 9 :
; < = < > = < ; ? @ A B C D < E F G H IC J I K ; F L M L N F = O < P M F L < L Q E H R M H N S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L X I S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H Y Y V ST M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P V F O ; < L [ S Y I \ I S T M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P ] ^ Q G < L X H _ ` H a ? F b @ H\ < = P L H = @ ? M ; S T U V V F O O b L M X < P M F L @ S Y Y V S < L Q T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L N F = O < P M F L c H = G M X H @d e < L @ < @ f S Y Y V ? < G H E H H L S < L Q X b = = H L P R [ < = H S Q M = H X P R [ M L N = M L > M L > P ? H g J A C \ < P H L P E [ O < h M L > Sb @ M L > S @ H R R M L > S < L Q F N N H = M L > N F = @ < R H E = F < Q E < L Q < L Q _ F = ; < X h H P ] E < @ H Q P H R H ; ? F L [ ; = F Q b X P @ F =@ H = G M X H @ S M L X R b Q M L > i j M > M P < R k F O H \ ? F L H S l i m b @ M L H @ @ V R < @ @ \ ? F L H S l i m b @ M L H @ @ V R < @ @ \ n W S l < L QF P ? H = = H R < P H Q P H R H ; ? F L [ @ H = G M X H @ S P ? < P M L N = M L > H P ? H g J A C \ < P H L P I T ? H @ H E = F < Q E < L Q < L Q _ F = ; < X h H P ]E < @ H Q P H R H ; ? F L [ ; = F Q b X P @ < L Q _ F = @ H = G M X H @ < = H X < ; < E R H F N H O ; R F [ M L > < L Q Q F H O ; R F [ X F L P = F R@ [ @ P H O Q < P < P < E R H @ N M R R H Q a M P ? X < R R = F b P M L > Q < P < M L < O < L L H = P ? < P Q M = H X P R [ M L N = M L > H @ < P R H < @ P X R < M O A AF N P ? H g J A C b L Q H = o p K I c I V I q 9 D A d < f IJ r I K ; F L M L N F = O < P M F L < L Q E H R M H N S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L X I S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H Y Y V ST M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P V F O ; < L [ S Y I \ I S T M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P ] ^ Q G < L X H _ ` H a ? F b @ H\ < = P L H = @ ? M ; S T U V V F O O b L M X < P M F L @ S Y Y V S < L Q T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L N F = O < P M F L c H = G M X H @d e < L @ < @ f S Y Y V Q M Q L F P ? < G H < X P b < R h L F a R H Q > H F N P ? H g J A C \ < P H L P b L P M R c ; = M L P N M R H Q P ? M @ R < a @ b M P M Lj H X H O E H = 9 r A A I K ; F L N b = P ? H = M L N F = O < P M F L < L Q E H R M H N S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L X I S T M O H U < = L H =V < E R H Y Y V S T M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P V F O ; < L [ S Y I \ I S T M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P ]^ Q G < L X H _ ` H a ? F b @ H \ < = P L H = @ ? M ; S T U V V F O O b L M X < P M F L @ S Y Y V S < L Q T M O H U < = L H = V < E R HW L N F = O < P M F L c H = G M X H @ d e < L @ < @ f S Y Y V Q M Q L F P ? < G H X F L @ P = b X P M G H h L F a R H Q > H F = < L [ F P ? H =h L F a R H Q > H F = < a < = H L H @ @ F N P ? H g J A C \ < P H L P E H N F = H P ? M @ @ b M P a < @ N M R H Q M L j H X H O E H = 9 r A A IJ A I K ; F L M L N F = O < P M F L < L Q E H R M H N S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L X I S T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H Y Y V ST M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P V F O ; < L [ S Y I \ I S T M O H U < = L H = Z L P H = P < M L O H L P ] ^ Q G < L X H _ ` H a ? F b @ H\ < = P L H = @ ? M ; S T U V V F O O b L M X < P M F L @ S Y Y V S < L Q T M O H U < = L H = V < E R H W L N F = O < P M F L c H = G M X H @
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 25 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 24 of 33
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '918 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
92. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '918 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 10: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '912 Patent
93. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-92 above.
94. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '912 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '912 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of placing or receiving and do place or
receive telephone calls to or from a ported telephone number in a manner that directly infringes
at least claim 1 of the '912 under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
95. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
25 s t
u v w x y w y z { | | } ~ y � x � � � x � � � � x � � � � � � � � � � � w � � x � � � � � � � x � � x � � � x � � y y � x � � � x � � � � � � � y } � � � � �� s � � y w � � � � � � w x � � � � � � � w � � � � x y � � � � x � � � � � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � � x � � { � � � � � w � x � �} w � � � | | } { � � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � } � � � w x � { | � � � { � � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � �� � � w x � � ¡ � � � � � y � � w � � x � � y � � � { � � } } � � � � x � � w � � � x y { | | } { w x � � � � � � w � x � � } w � � �� x � � � � w � � � x ¢ � � � � � � y u v w x y w y z { | | } ~ y � x � � � x � � � � x � � � � � � � � � � � w � � x � { ¢ � � � x � � w y y � � � � � � � w x �� � � � � � x � � x � � � � y � � � � � � � � � � w � w � � � � x � � � � w x � � w � w � � y � x w x w � � � x � x � � � � � � � � � � � � x � � � � � � � � � �¢ � � � x � � y � x � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � £ ¤ ¥ ¦ § ¨ © ª « ¬ § ¦ § ® ¦ ¯ ° ® ¦ ± ² ¦ §® ³ ´ µ ¶ ³ · ¸ ¹ ¸ ³ º » ´ º ¼ ¸ ½ ¾ ¨ ¿ « À º ¸ ³ º� Á � ¢ � � � x � � � w � � � � � y w x � � x � � � � � � w � � y � � � � � � � � x � � � � � w � � � � w � � � x y y � � � � � � � � x� w � w � � w � � y �  � s w � � � � �� à � Ä � � x � x � � � � w � � � x w x � � � � � � � { � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � � x � � { � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � | | } {� � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � } � � � w x � { | � � � { � � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � � � � � w x � � ¡ � � � � � y �� w � � x � � y � � � { � � } } � � � � x � � w � � � x y { | | } { w x � � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � � x � � � � w � � � x ¢ � � � � � � yu v w x y w y z { | | } � w � � � � � x { w x � � � � � � x � � � w � � { � � � � � � � � � x � � � x � � x � � � � � � � s � w � � x � � � � w Å � x � {� y � x � { y � � � � x � { w x � � � � � � � x � � � � y w � � � � � w � � w x � w x � � � � w � Å � � � � w y � � � � � � � � � x � � � � � � � � y � �y � � � � � � y { � x � � � � � x � Æ Ç � � � � w � È � � � � � � x � { É Æ Ê � y � x � y y } � w y y � � � x � { É Æ Ê � y � x � y y } � w y y � Ë � { É w x �� � � � � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � x � y � � � � � � y { � � w � � x � � � x � � � � � � � � s � w � � x � � � � � y � � � � w � � w x � w x � � � � w � Å � � �� w y � � � � � � � � � x � � � � � � � � y w x � � � y � � � � � � y w � � � w � w � � � � � � � w � � x � � � � � � � � � � x � w x � � � � � w � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � x � � w � � y � � � � � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � � � � x � x � � � � � � x w � w x x � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � x � � � x � � yw � � � w y � � � w � � � � � � � � � � � s � x � � � Á t Ä � ¢ � } � Ì s Í � u w z �� t � Ä � � x � x � � � � w � � � x w x � � � � � � � { � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � � x � � { � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � | | } {� � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � } � � � w x � { | � � � { � � � � � w � x � � � x � � � � w � x � � x � � � � � w x � � ¡ � � � � � y �� w � � x � � y � � � { � � } } � � � � x � � w � � � x y { | | } { w x � � � � � � w � x � � } w � � � � x � � � � w � � � x ¢ � � � � � � y
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 26 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 25 of 33
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '912 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '912 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
96. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '912 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
97. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '912 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 11: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '340 Patent
98. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-97 above.
99. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '340 Patent by making,
26 Î Ï
Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ò Ô Õ Ö × × Ø Ù Ú Ù Ó Û Ü Ý Ò Þ ß Ò à Ü á Ò â ã Ó Û ä â ß Ù å ß Û æ Ü Ý ß ç è é Î ê Ò Ü ß Ó Ü á Ó Ü Ú â ë ì í Ú Ó Ü æ Ú â ß Ù Ü Ý Ú Ô â Ò ä Ô á Ú Ü Ú Óî ß à ß ï ð ß í Î ñ é é ò ó ì Û Ó æ á í Ü Ý ß í Ú Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ò Ó Ù ð ß â Ú ß æ Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó à ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß íØ Ò ð â ß × × Ø Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü Ø Û ï ì Ò Ó ø Ö × ò ê ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü ùú Ù Þ Ò Ó à ß û ü ß ä Ý Û á Ô ß ê Ò í Ü Ó ß í Ô Ý Ú ì Ö ô õ Ø Ø Û ï ï á Ó Ú à Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ô Ö × × Ø Ö Ò Ó Ù ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ßö Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó ë ß í Þ Ú à ß Ô Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ò Ô Õ Ö × × Ø Ù Ú Ù Ó Û Ü Ý Ò Þ ß à Û Ó Ô Ü í á à Ü Ú Þ ß ã Ó Û ä â ß Ù å ß Û í Ò Ó ø Û Ü Ý ß íã Ó Û ä â ß Ù å ß Û í Ò ä Ò í ß Ó ß Ô Ô Û æ Ü Ý ß ç è é Î ê Ò Ü ß Ó Ü ð ß æ Û í ß Ü Ý Ú Ô Ô á Ú Ü ä Ò Ô æ Ú â ß Ù Ú Ó î ß à ß ï ð ß í Î ñ é é òè Ï ò ó ì Û Ó Ú Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ò Ó Ù ð ß â Ú ß æ Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó à ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß × × Ø Öô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü Ø Û ï ì Ò Ó ø Ö × ò ê ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü ù ú Ù Þ Ò Ó à ß û ü ß ä Ý Û á Ô ßê Ò í Ü Ó ß í Ô Ý Ú ì Ö ô õ Ø Ø Û ï ï á Ó Ú à Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ô Ö × × Ø Ö Ò Ó Ù ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó ë ß í Þ Ú à ß ÔÐ Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ò Ô Õ Ö × × Ø ý Ô Ú Ó æ í Ú Ó å ß ï ß Ó Ü Û æ Ü Ý ß ç è é Î ê Ò Ü ß Ó Ü ä Ú â â à Û Ó Ü Ú Ó á ß á Ó â ß Ô Ô ß Ó þ Û Ú Ó ß Ù ð ø Ü Ý Ú Ô Ø Û á í Ü òè ÿ ò ú Ô Ò Ù Ú í ß à Ü Ò Ó Ù ì í Û � Ú ï Ò Ü ß à Û Ó Ô ß � á ß Ó à ß Û æ ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó à ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß íØ Ò ð â ß × × Ø Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü Ø Û ï ì Ò Ó ø Ö × ò ê ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü ùú Ù Þ Ò Ó à ß û ü ß ä Ý Û á Ô ß ê Ò í Ü Ó ß í Ô Ý Ú ì Ö ô õ Ø Ø Û ï ï á Ó Ú à Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ô Ö × × Ø Ö Ò Ó Ù ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ßö Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó ë ß í Þ Ú à ß Ô Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ò Ô Õ Ö × × Ø ý Ô Ú Ó æ í Ú Ó å ß ï ß Ó Ü Û æ Ü Ý ß ç è é Î ê Ò Ü ß Ó Ü Ö ë ì í Ú Ó Ü Ý Ò Ô Ô á æ æ ß í ß Ù Ò Ó Ùä Ú â â à Û Ó Ü Ú Ó á ß Ü Û Ô á æ æ ß í Ú í í ß ì Ò í Ò ð â ß Ú Ó þ á í ø Ò Ó Ù Ù Ò ï Ò å ß Ô Ú Ó Ò Ó Ò ï Û á Ó Ü Ó Û Ü ø ß Ü Ù ß Ü ß í ï Ú Ó ß Ù æ Û í ä Ý Ú à Ýë ì í Ú Ó Ü Ú Ô ß Ó Ü Ú Ü â ß Ù Ü Û í ß â Ú ß æ ò � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �è ò ë ì í Ú Ó Ü í ß Ò â â ß å ß Ô Ò Ó Ù Ú Ó à Û í ì Û í Ò Ü ß Ô ð ø í ß æ ß í ß Ó à ß Ü Ý ß Ò â â ß å Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ô Ô ß Ü æ Û í Ü Ý Ú Óì Ò í Ò å í Ò ì Ý Ô é ! è ÿ Ò ð Û Þ ß òè è ò ó ì Û Ó Ú Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ò Ó Ù ð ß â Ú ß æ Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó à ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß × × Ø Öô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü Ø Û ï ì Ò Ó ø Ö × ò ê ò Ö ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í ÷ Ó Ü ß í Ü Ò Ú Ó ï ß Ó Ü ù ú Ù Þ Ò Ó à ß û ü ß ä Ý Û á Ô ßê Ò í Ü Ó ß í Ô Ý Ú ì Ö ô õ Ø Ø Û ï ï á Ó Ú à Ò Ü Ú Û Ó Ô Ö × × Ø Ö Ò Ó Ù ô Ú ï ß õ Ò í Ó ß í Ø Ò ð â ß ö Ó æ Û í ï Ò Ü Ú Û Ó ë ß í Þ Ú à ß ÔÐ Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ò Ô Õ Ö × × Ø Ý Ò Þ ß ð ß ß Ó Ö Ò Ó Ù à á í í ß Ó Ü â ø Ò í ß Ö Ù Ú í ß à Ü â ø Ú Ó æ í Ú Ó å Ú Ó å Ü Ý ß ç " # ñ ê Ò Ü ß Ó Ü ð ø ï Ò ã Ú Ó å Ö
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 27 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 26 of 33
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '340 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of providing and do provide enhanced
services in a manner that directly infringes at least claim 11 of the '340 Patent under 35 U.S.C. §
271(a).
100. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '340 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit in
December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
knowledge or awareness of the '340 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
101. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '340 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
102. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '340 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
27 $ %
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
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 28 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 27 of 33
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
COUNT 12: PATENT INFRINGEMENT Infringement of the '6,561 Patent
103. Sprint realleges and incorporates by reference the allegations set forth in
paragraphs 1-102 above.
104. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC have been, and currently are, directly infringing the '6,561 Patent by making,
using, selling, and offering for sale broadband and/or packet-based telephony products or
services, including "Digital Home Phone," "Business Class Phone," "Business Class PRI," and
other related telephony services, that infringe the '6,561 Patent. These broadband and/or packet-
based telephony products and/or services are capable of receiving and do receive telephone calls
originating from a non-packet network, such as, for example, the PSTN, in a manner that directly
infringes at least claim 1 of the '6,561 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a).
105. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC did not have actual knowledge of the '6,561 Patent until Sprint filed this lawsuit
in December 2011. Upon further information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC did not have constructive knowledge or any other
28 _ `
a b c c d e f g b f h i g e j h k k i l b l l i m n l n o c i b f p h l q n f r r n s n t i j b f n f n s e h f g f e g q i g r i g i l s b f i r k e l a u b d uv m l b f g b j i f g b g c i r g e l i c b i k w x y z { | } ~ � � � | � { | � { � � � { � � � � { |� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � } � � � � � �� � � � v m l b f g l i n c c i t i j n f r b f d e l m e l n g i j o q l i k i l i f d i g u i n c c i t n g b e f j j i g k e l g u b fm n l n t l n m u j � � � � _ n o e � i �� � � � � m e f b f k e l s n g b e f n f r o i c b i k � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i £ f d � � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i ¤ ¤ ¢ � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g ¢ e s m n f q � ¤ � ¦ � � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g § ¨ r � n f d i © ª i a u e h j i¦ n l g f i l j u b m � ¡ ¢ ¢ e s s h f b d n g b e f j � ¤ ¤ ¢ � n f r b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i £ f k e l s n g b e f v i l � b d i j« ¬ n f j n j � ¤ ¤ ¢ u n � i o i i f � n f r d h l l i f g c q n l i � r b l i d g c q b f k l b f t b f t g u i ® ¯ � ° ¯ � ¦ n g i f g o q s n ± b f t �h j b f t � j i c c b f t � n f r e k k i l b f t k e l j n c i o l e n r o n f r n f r © e l m n d ± i g § o n j i r g i c i m u e f q m l e r h d g j e lj i l � b d i j � b f d c h r b f t ² ³ b t b g n c ´ e s i ¦ u e f i � µ ² ¶ h j b f i j j ¢ c n j j ¦ u e f i � µ ² ¶ h j b f i j j ¢ c n j j ¦ · £ � µ n f re g u i l l i c n g i r g i c i m u e f q j i l � b d i j � g u n g b f k l b f t i g u i ® ¯ � ° ¯ � ¦ n g i f g � u i j i o l e n r o n f r n f r © e l m n d ± i g §o n j i r g i c i m u e f q m l e r h d g j n f r © e l j i l � b d i j n l i d n m n o c i e k l i d i b � b f t n f r r e l i d i b � i g i c i m u e f i d n c c je l b t b f n g b f t k l e s n f e f § m n d ± i g f i g a e l ± � j h d u n j � k e l i ¸ n s m c i � g u i ¦ v ª � b f n s n f f i l g u n g r b l i d g c qb f k l b f t i j n g c i n j g d c n b s � e k g u i ® ¯ � ° ¯ � ¦ n g i f g h f r i l � ° � � v � ¢ � ¹ _ º � « n �� � ° � � m e f b f k e l s n g b e f n f r o i c b i k � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i £ f d � � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i ¤ ¤ ¢ � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g ¢ e s m n f q � ¤ � ¦ � � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g § ¨ r � n f d i © ª i a u e h j i¦ n l g f i l j u b m � ¡ ¢ ¢ e s s h f b d n g b e f j � ¤ ¤ ¢ � n f r b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i £ f k e l s n g b e f v i l � b d i j« ¬ n f j n j � ¤ ¤ ¢ r b r f e g u n � i n d g h n c ± f e a c i r t i e k g u i ® ¯ � ° ¯ � ¦ n g i f g h f g b c v m l b f g k b c i r g u b j c n a j h b gb f ³ i d i s o i l _ � � � � � m e f k h l g u i l b f k e l s n g b e f n f r o i c b i k � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i £ f d � � b s i ¡ n l f i l¢ n o c i ¤ ¤ ¢ � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g ¢ e s m n f q � ¤ � ¦ � � b s i ¡ n l f i l ¥ f g i l g n b f s i f g §¨ r � n f d i © ª i a u e h j i ¦ n l g f i l j u b m � ¡ ¢ ¢ e s s h f b d n g b e f j � ¤ ¤ ¢ � n f r b s i ¡ n l f i l ¢ n o c i£ f k e l s n g b e f v i l � b d i j « ¬ n f j n j � ¤ ¤ ¢ r b r f e g u n � i d e f j g l h d g b � i ± f e a c i r t i e l n f q e g u i l
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 29 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 28 of 33
knowledge or awareness of the '6,561 Patent before this suit was filed in December 2011.
106. Upon information and belief, Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC,
Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '6,561 Patent will continue unless enjoined by this Court.
107. As a direct and proximate consequence of Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner
Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's infringement of the '6,561 Patent, Sprint has suffered and
will continue to suffer irreparable injury and damages in an amount not yet determined for which
Sprint is entitled to relief.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
Wherefore, Sprint requests entry of judgment in its favor and against Time Warner
as follows:
A. Judgment that Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner
Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership,
TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC have
directly infringed one or more claims of Sprint's Patents;
B. Judgment that Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner
Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership,
TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC's
direct infringement has been, and will continue to be, willful, including that Time Warner Cable
Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner
29 » ¼
½ ¾ ¿ À Á Â Ã Ä Â ¿ Å Æ À Æ Å Â ¾ Â Ç Ç ¿ È É Ê Â Ë Ì Í Î Ì Ï Ð Æ É Â ¾ É Ñ Â È ¿ Å Â É Ê Ò Ç Ç Ó Ò É À Æ Ç È Ò Á Â Ã Ò ¾ Ô Â Õ Â Ö Ñ Â Å » × Ï Ï ØÏ × Ì Ø Ù Ú ¿ ¾ Ò ¾ È ¿ Å Ö Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ Æ ¾ Ã Ñ Â Á Ò Â È Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ Õ Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â ß ß Ý ÍÛ Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É Ý ¿ Ö Ú Æ ¾ á Í ß Ø Ð Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É â ã Ã ä Æ ¾ Õ Â å æ Â À Ê ¿ Ó Ç ÂÐ Æ Å É ¾ Â Å Ç Ê Ò Ú Í Û Ü Ý Ý ¿ Ö Ö Ó ¾ Ò Õ Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ Ç Í ß ß Ý Í Æ ¾ Ã Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ È ¿ Å Ö Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ ç Â Å ä Ò Õ Â Çè é Æ ¾ Ç Æ Ç ê Í ß ß Ý ë Ç Ò ¾ È Å Ò ¾ Ä Â Ö Â ¾ É ¿ È É Ê Â Ë Ì Í Î Ì Ï Ð Æ É Â ¾ É À Ò Á Á Õ ¿ ¾ É Ò ¾ Ó Â Ó ¾ Á Â Ç Ç Â ¾ ì ¿ Ò ¾ Â Ã Ñ á É Ê Ò Ç Ý ¿ Ó Å É ØÏ × í Ø ã Ç Æ Ã Ò Å Â Õ É Æ ¾ Ã Ú Å ¿ î Ò Ö Æ É Â Õ ¿ ¾ Ç Â ï Ó Â ¾ Õ Â ¿ È Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ Õ Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â ÅÝ Æ Ñ Á Â ß ß Ý Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É Ý ¿ Ö Ú Æ ¾ á Í ß Ø Ð Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É âã Ã ä Æ ¾ Õ Â å æ Â À Ê ¿ Ó Ç Â Ð Æ Å É ¾ Â Å Ç Ê Ò Ú Í Û Ü Ý Ý ¿ Ö Ö Ó ¾ Ò Õ Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ Ç Í ß ß Ý Í Æ ¾ Ã Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á ÂÞ ¾ È ¿ Å Ö Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ ç Â Å ä Ò Õ Â Ç è é Æ ¾ Ç Æ Ç ê Í ß ß Ý ë Ç Ò ¾ È Å Ò ¾ Ä Â Ö Â ¾ É ¿ È É Ê Â Ë Ì Í Î Ì Ï Ð Æ É Â ¾ É Í ç Ú Å Ò ¾ É Ê Æ Ç Ç Ó È È Â Å Â Ã Æ ¾ ÃÀ Ò Á Á Õ ¿ ¾ É Ò ¾ Ó Â É ¿ Ç Ó È È Â Å Ò Å Å Â Ú Æ Å Æ Ñ Á Â Ò ¾ ì Ó Å á Æ ¾ Ã Ã Æ Ö Æ Ä Â Ç Ò ¾ Æ ¾ Æ Ö ¿ Ó ¾ É ¾ ¿ É á Â É Ã Â É Â Å Ö Ò ¾ Â Ã È ¿ Å À Ê Ò Õ Êç Ú Å Ò ¾ É Ò Ç Â ¾ É Ò É Á Â Ã É ¿ Å Â Á Ò Â È ð ñ ò ó ô õ ò ö ÷ ò ò õ ø ù õ öÜ Ê Â Å Â È ¿ Å Â Í ç Ú Å Ò ¾ É Å Â ï Ó Â Ç É Ç Â ¾ É Å á ¿ È ì Ó Ã Ä Ö Â ¾ É Ò ¾ Ò É Ç È Æ ä ¿ Å Æ ¾ Ã Æ Ä Æ Ò ¾ Ç É Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â ÅÆ Ç È ¿ Á Á ¿ À Ç úã Ø û Ó Ã Ä Ö Â ¾ É É Ê Æ É Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ Õ Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â ß ß Ý Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Åà ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É Ý ¿ Ö Ú Æ ¾ á Í ß Ø Ð Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É â ã Ã ä Æ ¾ Õ Â å æ Â À Ê ¿ Ó Ç Â Ð Æ Å É ¾ Â Å Ç Ê Ò Ú ÍÛ Ü Ý Ý ¿ Ö Ö Ó ¾ Ò Õ Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ Ç Í ß ß Ý Í Æ ¾ Ã Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ È ¿ Å Ö Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ ç Â Å ä Ò Õ Â Ç è é Æ ¾ Ç Æ Ç ê Í ß ß Ý Ê Æ ä ÂÃ Ò Å Â Õ É Á á Ò ¾ È Å Ò ¾ Ä Â Ã ¿ ¾ Â ¿ Å Ö ¿ Å Â Õ Á Æ Ò Ö Ç ¿ È ç Ú Å Ò ¾ É ë Ç Ð Æ É Â ¾ É Ç üý Ø û Ó Ã Ä Ö Â ¾ É É Ê Æ É Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ Õ Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â ß ß Ý Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Åà ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É Ý ¿ Ö Ú Æ ¾ á Í ß Ø Ð Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É â ã Ã ä Æ ¾ Õ Â å æ Â À Ê ¿ Ó Ç Â Ð Æ Å É ¾ Â Å Ç Ê Ò Ú ÍÛ Ü Ý Ý ¿ Ö Ö Ó ¾ Ò Õ Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ Ç Í ß ß Ý Í Æ ¾ Ã Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â Þ ¾ È ¿ Å Ö Æ É Ò ¿ ¾ ç Â Å ä Ò Õ Â Ç è é Æ ¾ Ç Æ Ç ê Í ß ß Ý ë ÇÃ Ò Å Â Õ É Ò ¾ È Å Ò ¾ Ä Â Ö Â ¾ É Ê Æ Ç Ñ Â Â ¾ Í Æ ¾ Ã À Ò Á Á Õ ¿ ¾ É Ò ¾ Ó Â É ¿ Ñ Â Í À Ò Á Á È Ó Á Í Ò ¾ Õ Á Ó Ã Ò ¾ Ä É Ê Æ É Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á ÂÞ ¾ Õ Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å Ý Æ Ñ Á Â ß ß Ý Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å à ¾ É Â Å É Æ Ò ¾ Ö Â ¾ É Ý ¿ Ö Ú Æ ¾ á Í ß Ø Ð Ø Í Û Ò Ö Â Ü Æ Å ¾ Â Å
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 30 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 29 of 33
Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner
Cable Information Services (Kansas), LLC have been and continue to be willfully infringing one
or more claims of at least the '932 Patent, the '3,561 Patent, the '429 Patent, the '064 Patent, and
the '052 Patent;
C. An Order finding that Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable LLC, Time
Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse
Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable Information Services
(Kansas), LLC's actions make this case exceptional under 35 U.S.C. § 285;
D. An award of damages to compensate Sprint for Time Warner Cable Inc., Time
Warner Cable LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's direct infringement, including damages pursuant to 35
U.S.C. § 284, as well as prejudgment and post-judgment interest;
E. An Order permanently enjoining Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable
LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC, and their respective officers, agents, servants, employees,
attorneys, and those persons in active concert or participation with a Defendant who receive
actual notice of the order by personal service or otherwise, from any further acts of
infringements, including including sales, offers for sale, and uses of their infringing products
and/or services and any other infringement of Sprint's Patents, whether direct or indirect; and
F. An award of treble damages for Time Warner Cable Inc., Time Warner Cable
30 þ ÿ
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � � � � � " � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � $ � � $ � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � % & þ ' � � � � � � � � � � % þ � ( ) * � � � � � � � � � � % + ' & � � � � � � � � � � % ÿ ) + � � � � � � � � � � � � % ÿ ( ' � � � � � � ,� - � . � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � - � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � � � � � " � � � � / � � � � � � � � � � 0 � � � � � � � � � � 1 � � � � � � � � � � � � � þ ( 2 - � - � - 3 ' 4 ( ,5 - � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � - � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � - � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � � � � � " � � � � / � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � þ (2 - � - � - 3 ' 4 + � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 � $ � � � � � � � � � � � 6 � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � ,� - � . � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � 6 � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � - � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � � � � � " � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � � �� � � � � � � # � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 5 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � $ � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � / � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � , � � 7 - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � $ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 31 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 30 of 33
LLC, Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Time Warner Entertainment-
Advance/Newhouse Partnership, TWC Communications, LLC, and Time Warner Cable
Information Services (Kansas), LLC's willful infringement pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 284; and
G. An award of costs and expenses in this action, including an award of Sprint's
reasonable attorneys' fees pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 285; and
H. For such other and further relief as the Court may deem just, proper, and equitable
under the circumstances.
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Sprint respectfully demands a trial by jury on all claims and issues so triable.
DESIGNATION OF PLACE OF TRIAL
Sprint hereby designates Kansas City, Kansas as place of trial pursuant to Local
Rule 40.2.
Respectfully Submitted,
SHOOK, HARDY & BACON L.L.P.
/s/ Aaron Hankel Aaron Hankel (Admitted to D. Kansas) B. Trent Webb ( KS Bar No. 15965) Ryan Dykal (Admitted pro hac vice) Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP 2555 Grand Boulevard Kansas City, Missouri 64108-2613 816-474-6550 Telephone 816-421-5547 Facsimile
Robert Reckers (pro hac vice) Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP JPMorgan Chase Tower 600 Travis Street Suite 1600
31 8 9
: : ; < = > ? @ A B C D @ C E D F @ C F B > D ? @ D F ; G ? H B D I < : J K J < = > ? @ A B C D @ C E D F @ C F B > D ? @ D F LM N O B D P @ Q R @ S T G U V @ K B C F D @ C V T > H < = A ; ; G ? ? U D > P B F > G D V < : : ; < B D N = > ? @ A B C D @ C ; B W X @Y D Z G C ? B F > G D [ @ C O > P @ V \ ] B D V B V ^ < : : ; _ V S > X X Z U X > D Z C > D ` @ ? @ D F H U C V U B D F F G 8 a b J [ J ; J c d e f g B D Nh J M D B S B C N G Z P G V F V B D N @ i H @ D V @ V > D F T > V B P F > G D < > D P X U N > D ` B D B S B C N G Z [ H C > D F _ VC @ B V G D B W X @ B F F G C D @ I V _ Z @ @ V H U C V U B D F F G 8 a b J [ J ; J c d e a g B D Nj J k G C V U P T G F T @ C B D N Z U C F T @ C C @ X > @ Z B V F T @ ; G U C F ? B I N @ @ ? l U V F < H C G H @ C < B D N @ m U > F B W X @U D N @ C F T @ P > C P U ? V F B D P @ V J n o p q r n s t u v w u x y u z q {[ H C > D F C @ V H @ P F Z U X X I N @ ? B D N V B F C > B X W I l U C I G D B X X P X B > ? V B D N > V V U @ V V G F C > B W X @ Jn o | z } r q y z t r t s ~ { q � o t s y u z q {[ H C > D F T @ C @ W I N @ V > ` D B F @ V ] B D V B V ; > F I < ] B D V B V B V H X B P @ G Z F C > B X H U C V U B D F F G : G P B X� U X @ f � J d J � @ V H @ P F Z U X X I [ U W ? > F F @ N <[ j � � ] < j M � � � � � M ; � R : J : J K JQ V Q M B C G D j B D � @ XM B C G D j B D � @ X \ M N ? > F F @ N F G � J ] B D V B V ^� J = C @ D F A @ W W \ ] [ � B C R G J 9 a � � a ^� I B D � I � B X \ M N ? > F F @ N � � � � � � � � � � ^| � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ ¡ ¢£ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¥ ¦ § ¨ © ª « ¬ ® ¯ § ¦ ©° § ¨ ± § ± ² ³ ´ µ ¶ · ³ ± ± « ¬ ¦ ³ � ¸ ¹ º » ¼ £ � ¹ ½» ¹ � ¼ ¸ ¾ ¸ ¼ � ¤ ¤ º ¿ ® ® À Á « ¨ ®» ¹ � ¼ ¸ £ ¹ ¼ ¤ ¤ ¸ ¾  § à ± ³ Ä ³ ®Å « Æ ® ¦ ´ Å ® à � ® ¦ ± Ç À ¦ « Á § à ¯ ³ à ® ÈÉ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ¡ ¡ ¢Ê Ë · « ¦ Ì § ¨ ² Á § ± ® ¿ « Í ® ¦� º º ¿ ¦ § ¯ ³ ± Î ´ ¦ ® ® ´Î ¬ ³ ´ ® ¹ � º º
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 32 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 31 of 33
Dated: December 16, 2013
Houston, Texas 77002-2992 T: 713.227.8008 F: 713.227.9508
Attorneys For Plaintiff Sprint Communications Company L.P.
32 Ï Ð
Ñ Ò Ó Ô Õ Ò Ö × Ø Ù Ú Û Ô Ü Ü Ý Ý Ð Þ Ð ß ß ÐØ à Ü á Ï â Ð Ð Ü â ã Ý Ý ãä à Ü á Ï â Ð Ð Ü â ß å Ý ãæ ç ç è é ê ë ì í î è é ï ð ñ ò ê ç ò ó ó ô õ é ò ê çö è ÷ ÷ ø ê ò ù ñ ç ò è ê í ö è ÷ õ ñ ê ì ú û ï ûCase 2:11-cv-02686-JWL-JPO Document 69-1 Filed 10/24/13 Page 33 of 33
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 32 of 33
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on the 16th
day of December, 2013, I electronically filed the foregoing with
the Clerk of the Court by using the CM/ECF System which will send a notice of electronic filing
to all attorneys linked to this case.
S /s/ Aaron E. Hankel
Aaron E. Hankel
Case 2:11-cv-02686-JWL Document 82 Filed 12/16/13 Page 33 of 33