canadian health spending: managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

25
NUFFIELD TRUST/CHSRF MASTERCLASS CANADIAN HEALTH SPENDING: MANAGING IN A DOWNTURN (1990-1999) May 17, 2011 – London, England Terrence Sullivan Professor, Dept of Health Policy Management and Evaluation Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto

Upload: cfhi-fcass

Post on 05-Dec-2014

1.197 views

Category:

Health & Medicine


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Canadian Masterclass on Managing a Health System through an Economic Downturn (Terrence Sullivan)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

NUFFIELD TRUST/CHSRF MASTERCLASSCANADIAN HEALTH SPENDING: MANAGING IN A DOWNTURN (1990-1999)May 17, 2011 – London, England

Terrence SullivanProfessor, Dept of Health Policy Management and Evaluation

Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto

Page 2: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

CURRENT PICTURE SASKATCHEWAN ONTARIO U.K.

Combined Life expectancy at birth (‘97)

79.5 81 79.7

Population (2011) 1M 13.2M 60.5M

Current Debt (2011) • 20 million surplus

• Net Debt: 7% of provincial GDP

• $16.7B deficit• Net Debt: 37.6%

of Provincial GDP

• £ 163B deficit• Net Debt: 59% of

GDP

Per Capita GDP (2009) C$45,718 C$43,847 US$32,798

2

Page 3: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

SourcesFigure 1: Canadian Institute for Health Information; United

Kingdom Office for National StatisticsFigure 2/3: OECD Health Data 2010. 3

Page 4: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

• Recession hits North America hard (Black Friday/Gulf War/Oil Shocks)

• Significant growth in debt burden by federal/provincial governments

• Multiple Premier’s Commissions on Health Reform• Experimentation with regionalization emerges in English

Canada• Significant contraction caused decline in public confidence but

no evidence of any adverse health outcomes• Significant National Reform Commission Efforts followed in

early 2000

Important Context for Canada (1990-2000)

4

Page 5: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Source: Public Accounts and 2000 budgets.

Total health expenditure per capita, US$ PPP

5

Page 6: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Federal and provincial-territorial surplus/deficit(-)Public Accounts basis

Source: Public Accounts and 2000 budgets.

6

Page 7: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Source: Public Accounts and 2000 budgets.

Federal and provincial-territorial net debtPublic Accounts basis

7

Page 8: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

8

Page 9: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

9

Page 10: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Provincial/Territorial Government RevenuesConstant Dollar Indices (1993 = 100), Canada, 1993 to 2009

federal revenue as a proportion in the current document

Change in Federal Transfers

Source: NHEX Database, CIHI.

10

Page 11: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

ONTARIO & SASKATCHEWANCASES

11

Page 12: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

12

Page 13: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

13

Page 14: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Per Capita Physician Spending 1981-2010

14

Page 15: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Hospital beds per 1,000 population

Source: OECD Health Data 2010.

15

Page 16: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Evolution of Assessments of the Quality of the Health Care System“Thinking broadly about Canada's health-care system and the quality of medical services it provides, how would you describe it overall? Would you say it is excellent, very good, good, only fair, poor or very poor?”

Source: Department of Finance.

16

Page 17: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

QUESTIONS?

17

Page 18: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

18

Page 19: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Source: Department of Finance.

Net Debt-to-GDP Ratio

19

Page 20: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Source: 2000 Federal Budget

20

Page 21: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

21

Page 22: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

The provinces and territories recorded an aggregate surplus in 1999-2000

Federal and provincial-territorial budgetary balancePublic Accounts basis

Source: Public Accounts and 2000 budgets.

22

Page 23: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Federal and provincial-territorial surplus/deficit(-)Public Accounts basisSource: Public Accounts and 2000 budgets.

23

Page 24: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Provincial-territorial revenues and program spendingNational Accounts basis

Source: National Income and Expenditure Accounts.

24

Page 25: Canadian health spending: Managing in a downturn (1990-1999)

Interprovincial comparison of taxpayer-supported debt as a percentage of GDP

Source: Moody’s Investors Service Inc.

25