caltrans 2021 disparity study - california

CALTRANS2021 DISPARITY STUDY

1

David DeLuzDeputy DirectorCaltrans Office of Civil RightsKeith Herron, MBA PEChief Data Analysis & Supportive Services/Outreach BranchCaltrans Office of Civil Rights

Kevin WilliamsManaging Director

BBC Research & Consulting

For technical support, contact Lori Large in the Zoom chat or at [email protected]

AGENDA

• BBC Disparity Study Presentation

• Q&A with BBC

• Public Comment

• Exit survey

2

Agenda:

1) Overview

2) Disparity study presentation

3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey


NOTICES

• Please be aware that this webinar is being recorded, however, certain portions such as the public comment period will not be included if the recording is used for future outreach. Please contact [email protected] for more information.

• Caltrans ensures that no person in the state of California is excluded from participation in, denied the benefits of, or otherwise subjected to discrimination in Caltrans programs, policies, procedures, activities, and services on the grounds of race, color, national origin, sex, age, or disability.

• For more information on Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 at Caltrans please visit: https://dot.ca.gov/programs/civil-rights/title-vi

3For technical support, contact Lori Large in the Zoom chat or at [email protected]

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

mailto:[email protected]

https://dot.ca.gov/programs/civil-rights/title-vi

LOGISTICS AND EXPECTATIONS

• Please stay muted the entire meeting

• During the Q&A sessions, please use the “Raise Hand” feature and stay muted until you are called on by the presenter

• Please mute yourself once you have asked your question

• To ask a question outside of Q&A time, message it directly to Wittney Skigen (BBC) in the Zoom chat

• Please include your email address; if we cannot get to your question during the Q&A session, we will follow up with you

• If you are having technical difficulties, contact Lori Large in the Zoom chat or at [email protected]. Her contact info will be on every slide

4

Agenda:

1) Public Outreach Overview

2) Logistics andexpectations

3) Annual budgeting

4) Q&A with Keith Herron


6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey


LOGISTICS AND EXPECTATIONS

5

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

DISTRICT SMALL BUSINESS LIAISONS

District Counties Contact

1 Del Norte, Lake, Mendocino, Humboldt Aaron Morgan(707) [email protected]

2Siskiyou, Modoc, Trinity, Shasta, Lassen, Tehama, Plumas

Patricia Silva(530) 229-0561 [email protected]

3Glenn, Butte, Sierra, Colusa, Sutter, Yuba, Nevada, Placer, Yolo, Sacramento, El Dorado

Robynn [email protected]

4Sonoma, Napa, Solano, Marin, Contra Costa, Alameda, San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Clara

Jada Pugh(510) [email protected]

5Santa Cruz, San Benito, Monterey, San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara

Jessica Biro(805) [email protected]

6Fresno, Kings, Tulare, Madera, Western Kern County

Lorena Ramos(559) [email protected]


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

DISTRICT SMALL BUSINESS LIAISONS


District Counties Contact

7 Los Angeles, VenturaMaria [email protected]

8 San Bernardino, RiversidePaige Johnson(909) [email protected]

9 Mono, Inyo, Western Kern CountyJessica Klemencic(760) [email protected]

10Amador, San Joaquin, Calaveras, Alpine, Stanislaus, Tuolumne, Merced, Mariposa

Bob Adams(209) [email protected]

11 San Diego, ImperialMaria Ibarra(619) 688-3151 [email protected]

11 San Diego, ImperialMaecel Mathis(619) 220-7343 [email protected]

12 OrangeMirley Vargas(657) [email protected]

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

POLL

• A poll will now appear on your screen. Make sure to scroll all the way down and answer all questions.

8

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


•For general reference: •Northern region: north of Sacramento•Central region: between Bakersfield and Sacramento•Southern region: south of Bakersfield

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

2021 CALTRANS DISPARITY STUDYKEVIN WILLIAMS

MANAGING DIRECTOR, BBC RESEARCH AND CONSULTING


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

9

STUDY OBJECTIVES

10

Contract

policies

M/WBE

participation

OCR

programs

Market

conditionsDo M/WBEs

face barriers in

Caltrans

contracting?

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

STUDY ELEMENTS

11

Utilization analysis

Project management

Community engagement

Legal framework and analysis

Review of contracting and programs

Availability analysis

Disparity analysis

Analysis of marketplace barriers

Recommendations

Reports and presentations

Data assessment and collection

Relevant contracts/ market area

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

STUDY TEAM

12

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Oceanside, CA

Action

Research

Anecdotal Expert

Costa Mesa, CA

GCAP

Services

ProgramExpert

Atlanta, GA

Holland &

Knight

Legal Expert

BBC Research

& Consulting

Denver, CO

Luster

National

Mill Valley, CA

Outreach Expert

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT

13

Informational

efforts

Engagement

efforts

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

UTILIZATION ANALYSIS

14

Primary lines

of work

Race and

genderStudy

period

Prime and

subcontracts

M/WBE Participation

All relevant

industries

Survey

dataCaltrans

data

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

AVAILABILITY ANALYSIS

15

Vendor roleLines of work

CapacityYear est.

Interest

Race and

gender

Custom

Census

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

AVAILABILITY ANALYSIS

16

Representative

database

Business

population

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

CONTRACT MATCHING

17

. . .

Firm 1(Minority)

Electrical workSubcontractor2001$5 million

Civil engineeringPrime contractor1964$30 million

Electrical workPrime/sub2010$2 million

1990$1 million

SubcontractorElectrical work

Firm 2(Woman)

1997$7 million

SubcontractorElectrical work

Firm 3(Majority)

Firm 4(Woman)

Firm 1,000(Majority)

✓

✓

✓

• Electrical work

• Subcontract

• 2017 award

• $1.2 million

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

DISPARITY ANALYSIS

18

M/WBE

participation DISPARITY

INDEX=M/WBE

availability

.80 = substantial underutilization

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

2016 DISPARITY STUDYSTATE CONTRACTS

19

70

65

31

72

153

73

61

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Minority/Woman

White woman

Black American

Asian Pacific American

Subcontinent Asian…

Hispanic American

Native American

Subcontinent AsianAmerican

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

TIMELINE

20

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Final

report

Data collection

and analysesBegin Public

OutreachDraft

results

Project

Initiation

Draft

report

Month

Mar Apr May JunJul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

QUESTIONS?

21

Kevin WilliamsManaging DirectorBBC Research & [email protected]

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey


PUBLIC COMMENT

22

Agenda:



3) Annual budgeting



6) Q&A with BBC

7) Public comment

8) Exit survey


● Experiences with discrimination

● Barriers to success

● Payment issues

● Private or public sector work

● Prime contractor or subcontractor work

● Working with Caltrans and local agencies

Testimony on experiences in the California marketplace:

Study Email: [email protected] Research & Consulting: [email protected]

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

THANK YOU!!


https://www.research.net/r/M8YTVGY

This will be emailed out to attendees after the meeting.

Please fill our exit survey.

Thank you for attending our last meeting!

Please send any written feedback or testimony to BBC via email until May.

Study Email: [email protected]

BBC Research & Consulting: [email protected]

Agenda:

1) Overview


3) Q&A with BBC

4) Public comment

5) Exit survey

https://www.research.net/r/M8YTVGY

caltrans 2021 disparity study - california

Documents