by doug rozendaal - velocity, inc

10
www.kitplanes.com BY DOUG ROZENDAAL 8 KITPLANES August 2010

Upload: others

Post on 11-Feb-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

www.kitplanes.com

By Doug RozenDaal

8 KITPLANES August 2010

Page 2: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

All aircraft are defined by their mis-sion. People hauling. Utility. Speed. Maneuverability and aerobatic prow-ess. Sex appeal. No sense denying it: We choose aircraft kits and make the com-mitment to build them based on an ever-shifting set of needs and desires—often not the same thing.

What if the mission objective is to fly a four-place airplane in the flight levels with turbine speed and piston efficiency on a high-performance, single-engine acquisition budget? Most experienced pilots and aircraft owners would say, “Yeah, right.” Or perhaps, “You’re dreaming.” Just as there’s no free lunch, aircraft that are capable of continent-crossing speeds at the altitudes where certain kinds of weather cease to be an issue are unlikely to be available without a generous bank balance.

Efficiency as a Key ComponentBurt Rutan recognized the lost work of the main wing lifting the downforce of the tail and designed a family of canard airplanes that included the Long-EZ. Rutan’s quest for efficiency most likely came from looking at the Wright broth-ers, who were severely horsepower lim-ited. In time, the Long-EZ morphed into a wide-body design with side-by-side, three- to four-place seating called the Velocity, thank you very much, Danny Maher. Maher started selling kits in 1985, and today nearly 700 kits have been sold and 500 aircraft are flying. Through it all, these canard designs managed to make speed and efficiency their calling cards, offsetting their basic unsuitability for really rough, short airstrips.

Duane Swing built a Velocity in 1989 and designed several modifica-tions including retractable landing gear. Finally, Swing bought the company in 1992. For a company to flourish and grow it needs a steady stream of new and better products. To fill that need, in 1997 Swing designed a larger version of the kit called the Velocity XL. The

original design, the SE, was intended for 160 to 220 horsepower. The XL was intended for naturally aspirated six-cyl-inder engines up to the 310 hp Conti-nental IO-550.

Engine MattersWhen Ronald Stevens was looking for a replacement for his Cirrus SR-22, he came to Velocity. He wanted a comfort-able, capable, cross-country airplane that would be much faster than his Cir-rus. There had been one previous TSIO-550-powered Velocity, but Stevens wanted to use an engine from Perfor-mance Engines in La Verne, California, and add air-conditioning to the mix, and he was willing to fund the develop-ment costs to do it.

The engine is a ported and polished version of the TSIO-550-E with forged high-compression pistons and other tweaks that help safely raise maximum rpm to 2800. Performance Engines claims the modifications in total yield 400 horsepower—that’s a 50-hp bump over the most stout version of the TSIO-550 as available from Continental. Well, this should be interesting.

Horsepower joins with aerodynamic efficiency for superlative performance in the Velocity. Composite construc-tion allows the airplane to have a sleek skin for low parasite drag while retain-ing a comfortable cabin that would be

KITPLANES August 2010 9 Photos: Richard VanderMeulen

Gull-wing doors and the newly introduced sidestick option provide easy access to the spacious and comfortable front seats. The sill is low enough that clambering in proves easy.

The NACA duct on the nose routes fresh air through an oil heat exchanger to pro-vide windshield defrost. Additional heat comes from a conventional heat muff on the exhaust cross-over pipe.

Page 3: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

nearly impossible to design or build using aluminum. The combination of the gull-wing doors and the newly designed optional sidestick provide easy access to the front seats; rear seat access is tougher. (Neither your grandmother, nor your girlfriend in a dress will want to climb in back.) But anyone who is agile will have no problem and find the rear seats comfortable with acceptable legroom, even for a 6-foot-3, 220-pound aviation writer. The low-cabin appear-ance of the airplane, due to its shal-low side windows and high beltline, is largely an optical illusion; the place for people inside is notably large.

Panel Full o’ PixelsA spacious instrument panel is unclut-tered by two Garmin G900X screens and the three standby instruments. The last Velocity we tested had a then-leading-edge Grand Rapids suite, but

the two big-screen Garmins give the Velocity a true “big airplane” appear-ance from the pilot’s seat. An overhead panel has engine starting and light-ing controls. It would be a problem for

those visually impaired by “short arms syndrome,” but for a myopic, advanc-ing in years pilot accustomed to peering over the top of the spectacles, it worked perfectly. Luxurious glove leather covers

10 KITPLANES August 2010 www.kitplanes.com

Velocity continued

Garmin’s G900X suite is new to the Velocity. Also of note are the PS Engineering DVD entertainment system (with three screens total), TruTrak Sorcerer autopilot and air-conditioning controls at the top of the center console.

Stick ‘em up! The panel has ample space for the Garmin G900X and the standby steam gauges with luxury automobile styling and ergonomics.

Page 4: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

seats generously padded with closed-cell polyurethane foam. It sat as comfort-ably as it looked.

The fit and finish of the airplane on the outside is smooth and sleek. Many canard airplanes have a spartan exterior appearance, but Stevens has incorpo-rated contemporary graphics appropri-ate to the modern lines of the airplane. Not only did it look good inside and out, it looked fast.

Fast is a good thing when flying airplanes, but not a good thing when moving them on the ground. Photo flights almost always occur in the early morning or late evening when the light is low. When I saw where the airplane was parked in the display area on the grounds, I was convinced that we would never get it to a taxiway to fly in the morning light. But the patient Velocity crew worked carefully and efficiently to snake the airplane out, and in what seemed like only a few minutes, we were on a taxiway ready for start.

KITPLANES August 2010 11

Velocity tXl-5Kit price with quickbuild options ................................ $56,500Estimated completed price ..................... $200,000 - $250,000Estimated build time.............................................. 1800 hoursNumber flying (at press time) ...............................................16Powerplant .........................Continental TSIO-550, 310-400 hpPropeller ................................ MT four -blade, constant-speedPowerplant options............................ Continental IO-520/550

AirfrAmeWingspan ......................................................................... 31 ft Wing loading ........................................................ 20.0 lb/sq ftFuel capacity....................................................................93 galMaximum gross weight ................................................2900 lbTypical empty weight ....................................................1750 lbTypical useful load ......................................................... 1150 lbFull-fuel payload .............................................................606 lbSeating capacity ......................................................................5Cabin width ....................................................................47.5 inBaggage capacity ............................................................100 lb

PerformAnceCruise speed ........................................... 288 mph (250 kt) TAS 25,000 ft @ 75% of max-continuous, 24.5 gphMaximum rate of climb ............................................. 1600 fpmLanding speed (canard a/c don’t “stall”) ....86 mph (75 kt) IASMinimum speed .......................................... 75 mph (65 kt) IASTakeoff distance ............................................................ 1300 ftLanding distance ........................................................... 1500 ft

Specifications are manufacturer’s estimates and are based on the configuration of the demonstrator aircraft. As they say, your mileage may vary.

READY,

STABLEWILLING

®

208.337.5111

Page 5: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

12 KITPLANES August 2010 www.kitplanes.com

Continental BreakfastStarting the Velocity is textbook Con-tinental. After a little fuel boost, bump the starter and the big six in the back of the airplane comes to life. With the doors open there is no prop blast, and the exhaust noise is directed behind you. The gull-wing door, pulled down, shut with the feeling of a car door, and moving the latch forward to lock it gave the feeling of a pressurized airplane. With the door closed the cabin was eerily quiet. Demo pilot John Abraham reached down to turn on the climate-control system and selected 68°. Within moments a cool breeze was flowing from the overhead vents.

The airplane taxis like any other cast-ering nosewheel airplane. It is annoying to drag a brake, but differential braking works fine. The rudders are small and ineffective at taxi speed. The airplane did not show much tendency to weath-ervane, but the winds were light. At the end of the runway the runup was standard with one exception: There is no trim indicator. The trim system is a spring cartridge, and the elevator tab on the canard is in plain view of the pilot. Abraham told me to trim the elevator trailing edge down, one finger width for solo, two with passengers, and add a fin-ger for full fuel.

Above: A plenum chamber reduces cooling drag and increases cooling effectiveness. Ensuring that this highly tuned six-cylinder powerplant remains under thermal control is not the work of a moment. Below: A four-blade MT pusher propeller allows for a smaller diameter, resulting in lower tip speeds that increase efficiency, more ground clearance and reduced noise.

The main landing gear is a beefy built-up composite structure and, when retracted, is almost entirely concealed by simple gear doors.

Page 6: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

KITPLANES August 2010 13

Gear Up, Let’s GoAn electric hydraulic pump in the nose compartment raised the gear, and the speed and climb rate continued to accel-erate. We flew the short distance from Lakeland, Florida, to Plant City to meet up with the photo platform and photog-rapher Richard VanderMeulen.

This was my first flight in a canard airplane. I was interested to learn how they handled and flew. My instincts told me that the airplane might be pitchy and light, but the powerful trim sys-tem and fairly heavy control pressures make the airplane stay where you put it in pitch and roll. The airplane was yaw stable, and the rudders did little until about half deflection, then responded as normally. The sidestick option might reduce the control movement and hence the leverage contributing to the control forces. Rolling left was especially heavy due to the geometry of how your arm interfaces with the stick.

Many of the canard airplanes of the Rutan legacy have belly-mounted speed brakes. This one did not. Slowing to the 120-KIAS gear speed required some forethought but was not a particular challenge. The gear extended without noticeable effect on the trim, and Abra-ham recommended a final approach speed of 85 to 90 KIAS. Speed control

The TSIO-550 has a wastegate con-troller that manages manifold pressure and allows for full throttle on takeoff. It spooled up smoothly without over-boosting. The initial acceleration was brisk. The small rudders require a signif-icant deflection to maintain directional control, and my first takeoff wandered a bit off center. At about 70 knots indi-cated (KIAS), the nose got light and a small tug on the outboard stick got us in the air. (I have not flown the previous center-stick arrangement, but the new sidestick setup allows for a single set of central engine controls and the possi-bility of an instructor in the right seat catching your mistakes without having to literally fight over the stick.)

The aileron control forces felt heavy on the ground, and they were also heavy in the air. Again, a spring cartridge pro-vides aileron trim, and there is no indi-cator other than stick position. As the airplane left the ground, it was slightly out of roll trim and responded accord-ingly. The heavy roll forces require a firm push on the stick, but while firm, it must be finessed to prevent over-cor-rection. It’s a curious quirk that the aile-rons require considerable force but are very effective in the initial few degrees of control movement. Once the trim was centered, the roll was not an issue.

What’s in the Box

The Velocity comes in a variety of con-figurations, priced by the factory minus engine, avionics, paint and interior. A basic kit includes all the major airframe components, including many pre-formed composite parts. The fuselage shell is premolded, split horizontally. In the basic kit, the foam wing and canard cores are pre cut; the main and auxiliary spars are preformed.

According to the company, 80% of the kits sold go out in the full quickbuild format. The FastBuild wings, canard and tipsails are finished through primer, including installation of inter-nal radio antennas. That option adds $13,000 to the base kit. (The price listed in the specifications table includes the major quickbuild components.)

A FastBuild fuselage option ($9000) includes pre-installed bulkheads, firewall, conduit ducts, nosegear, maingear, axles, tires and tubes, and windshield. The fuselage halves are permanently joined, glassed and finished through primer.

—Marc Cook

Page 7: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

It is not the airplane’s strong suit. It is a challenging airplane to fly precisely in proximity to another airplane. It wasn’t scary, but there was some turbulence and it was hard work.

After the photos I got another shot at a landing, and while it was better, I wasn’t satisfied. We left the photo plane behind, swapped seats, and departed to climb up into the flight levels. Abraham knew the control pressures and posi-tions, and his takeoff lacked the bobble in roll that had plagued me both times.

The Velocity XL is a purpose-built airplane. It is intended to be a high-altitude, cross-country cruiser. With

airframe meant the only way to slow down was with the brakes. They were effective, and we cleared the runway. I did not have canard flying figured out, but I would get another chance.

Slot into a Learning ExperienceI have opined on these pages before that flying in formation is an excellent way to really learn how to precisely control an airplane. Joined up with an A-36 Bonanza, we orbited for the photos that share the pages with this text. Most Velocity pilots will seldom find them-selves in close formation with other airplanes. Probably that’s a good thing:

was straightforward, but it requires pre-cise movement of the stick.

I was told the drill was to fly it on like a wheel-landing in a taildragger. Had it actually been a taildragger, there would have been an incredible bounce, because I failed to sufficiently arrest the descent rate prior to impact and the mains arrived firmly—followed immediately by the impact of the nosewheel. The composite maingear legs and aluminum nosegear strut took it in stride without any tendency to bounce, and we rolled down the runway. The combination residual thrust of the four-blade MT composite propeller and the slippery

Engine controls are located where the pilot’s hand naturally rests.

14 KITPLANES August 2010 www.kitplanes.com

The rear seat can be configured spaciously for two passengers, or cozy for three. Leg-room is comfortable for most, and adequate for even the tallest passengers.

Page 8: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

KITPLANES August 2010 15

the two of us and full tanks, we weighed in at just less than 3000 pounds—well below the airplane’s 3350-pound maximum gross weight, set above the factory’s max of 2900 pounds by the builder. The initial climb was done at 35.5 inches of manifold pressure (MP) and 2700 rpm, burning 40 gallons per hour to yield a climb rate of 1700 fpm at 145 KIAS. That heady rate of climb continued up to 15,000 feet, where we commanded the TruTrak Sorcerer auto-pilot to maintain 160 KIAS for cooling. This dropped the climb rate to 800 fpm, but passing FL180 the G900 was show-ing 216 KTAS—in the climb.

At FL210 we leveled off and reduced power to 31 inches/2550 rpm, leaned to 26 gph on the rich side of peak, and waited for the airplane to stabilize.

Rocket Wrangling

In 2008, Rocket Racing League purchased Velocity Aircraft as a way of ensuring its supply of airframes for the rocket-powered racing endeavor. In the time since, RRL has, according to Velocity representatives, kept its hands off, allowing the Sebastian, Florida, company to continue its efforts in the kit business.

Two demonstration aircraft flew this year at the Tulsa Air and Space Museum airshow in late April, but progress has been slower than expected. Velocity stands ready to build the six airframes anticipated to be part of the racing league, but had not, at press time, received the order to start them.

—M.C.

AIRCRAFT TOOLSUPPLY COMPANY

Toll Free: 1-800-248-0638

www.aircraft-tool.com

AIRCRAFT ENGINE STAND KITOur new engine stand requires ABSOLUTELY NO WELDING. We ship it to you in a compact 11”x11”x36” box (which makes shipping costs downright reasonable), with everything you need to get going. All you need to supply are a couple of 1/2” wrenches and a little elbow grease.

p/n 65530C

Works with all Continental and Lycoming engines.

*Shown how you will receive your Engine Stand Kit.

kitplaneAugust2010.indd 1 5/5/2010 11:12:55 AM

Page 9: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

www.kitplanes.com

Come Back, JoneeeGetting to altitude in the Velocity is easy. Getting down requires some planning. Selecting a 190 KIAS airspeed hold in the autopilot and reducing the power slowly to 17 inches yielded a 1500-fpm descent—you would, of course, want to make that reduction from cruise power as gradual as you can manage. Caution would be warranted when hand flying, because the smooth contour of the fuse-lage and the tight-fitting doors belied the fact that we were flying near the 200 KIAS redline. That, and you’re eating airspace rapidly.

The Florida heat was kicking up some turbulence as we descended, and at the high indicated airspeed the canard was flexing in the bumps. Probably no more than the tail of a conventional airplane, but the tail is not in your field of view—if it was, we might fly slower in turbu-lence. Abraham said the canard could withstand in excess of 25,000 pounds of weight, far beyond anything we were experiencing in the chop.

Once below 10,000 feet, we canceled our IFR flight plan and sampled some air work. Steep turns required signifi-cant nose-up trim or significant force, but were manageable. Power-off stalls were exactly like Rutan told us years ago. The canard is mounted with 3° more incidence than the main wing. Pull the stick full aft and at about 67 KIAS the canard stalls first, the nose settles, the airspeed increases, the nose comes up again, and the whole affair repeats itself. Add some power and the only difference is that instead of settling, the airplane does a stair-step climb. The rudders and ailerons are totally effective throughout. It is that simple.

That’s How You Do ItWith Abraham flying we entered the pattern for a “demo” landing. I watched as he flew it right onto the runway with a slight flare, touched down smoothly, and then held the nose off until the canard gave up its lift and the nose settled to the pavement. He proved what I knew: For the earlier landings, the problem was with the pilot, not the plane. And to be fair, it was not a prob-

for a given IAS, TAS will increase 2% of IAS for every 1000-foot increase in alti-tude. That means if the same power is available, for every flight level increase, the TAS will increase by 3.3 knots. The engine has plenty of manifold pressure available to produce cruise power at that altitude. Had the time and temperatures permitted, the airplane would have exceeded 250 KTAS at FL250.

Slippery airplanes seem to just go faster and faster, easing up to the ultimate cruise velocity over a longer period than slower, draggier ships. After a few min-utes at FL210, the indicated airspeed settled on 167 knots, which the G900X computed to be 238 knots true (KTAS).

The secret to operating piston engines in the flight levels is cooling. Doing so successfully requires a well-designed cowling system for a stressed turbo-charged engine. At 26 gph, the engine was operating well rich of peak and using fuel to keep the CHTs below the yellow arc of 420° F. Abraham said the owner had not explored climbing and cruising on the lean side of peak EGT or TIT (turbine-inlet temperature). The plane was adequately instrumented for lean-of-peak operations, and several TSIO-550 operators successfully use LOP to keep their engines cool. This might be an option to improve efficiency and operate at higher altitudes.

Let there be no mistake: 238 knots in a homebuilt at FL210 is an impres-sive feat. An old rule of thumb says that

Velocity continued

A fixed position trimtab, affectionately called the sparrow strainer, provides pitch feedback and increases pitch stability.

Page 10: By Doug RozenDaal - Velocity, Inc

KITPLANES August 2010 17

lem, simply a matter of learning to fly a different aircraft.

So what does it cost? The company lit-erature shows a budget breakdown that includes almost everything but air in the tires, except labor as part of a builder-assistance program. Total: $318,000. That’s a Garmin G900X-equipped, five-seat, mid-200-knot airplane. It’s fair to ask how Stevens did relative to his old Cirrus SR-22. The Cirrus is much slower and more expensive, he said.

The Velocity turbo was designed to be efficient and fly fast. Handling char-acteristics were further down the prior-ity list. Nothing about the handling is spooky—quite the opposite, actually; the airplane has forgiving handling. It just lacks the pleasant control forces and harmony that draw some pilots to an air-plane. Other pilots like to rotate, estab-lish a climb, engage the autopilot and be on their way. Like so many things, it boils down to personal preference and mission suitability. If your mission is to go fast in the flight levels in an uncon-ventional aircraft that is, as these things go, pretty affordable given the speed, the Velocity is your answer. J

For more information, call 772/589-1860 or visit www.velocityaircraft.com. Find a direct link at www.kitplanes.com.

DOUG ROZENDAALDoug’s pilot certificate requires two cards and includes ratings in busi-ness jets, WW-II bombers, transports and fighters, as well as seaplanes, glid-ers and the coveted “All Makes and Models of Single and Multi Engine Piston Powered” endorse-ment. He holds a low alti-tude aerobatic waiver and flies airshows in the P-51, T-6, Rocket, and RVs.

TruTrak EFIS GP - $2200 add EMS - $600 plus probes l add Autopilot - $1000 per axis

Introducing...the TruTrak EFIS GPIntroducing...the TruTrak EFIS GPOur EFIS GP offers many of the great features of

the EFIS SG at an unbeatable value!

Toll Free: 866-TRUTRAK • FAX: 479-751-3397 • www.trutrakap.comTruTrak Flight Systems 1500 S Old Missouri Rd Springdale, AR 72764

4.625 x 4.750.indd 2 5/6/10 10:19 AM