business succession planning - ebook · • succession planning means that the company is easily...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Andere Keys to...
BusinessSuccessionPlanning
HelpDeskTool-KitsforBusinessProfessionals
CopyrightNotice
Copyright©2017byAndereCorporation.
Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,distributed,ortransmittedinanyformorbyanymeans,includingphotocopying,recording,orotherelectronicormechanicalmethods,withoutthepriorwrittenpermissionofthepublisher,exceptinthecaseofbriefquotationsembodiedincriticalreviewsandcertainothernon-commercialusespermittedbycopyrightlaw.Permissionrequestsshouldbesubmittedtothepublisherinwritingattheaddressebelow:
3
CONTENTS
Preface 5
1 SuccessionPlanningVs.ReplacementPlanning
7
2 PreparingforthePlanningProcess 13
3 InitiatingProcess 19
4 TheSWOTAnalysis 27
5 DevelopingtheSuccessionPlan 33
6 ExecutingthePlan 39
7 GainingSupport 45
8 ManagingtheChange 50
9 OvercomingRoadblocks 57
10 ReachingtheEnd 62
Highexpectationsarethekeytoeverything.
SamWalton
5
Preface
Thelossofvaluableleadershipcancrippleacompany.Businesssuccessionplanningisessentiallypreparingsuccessorstotakeonvitalleadershiproleswhentheneedarises.
Whetheritispreparingsomeonetotakeoverasthesoleproprietorofasmallbusinessorapositionofleadershipinacorporation,businesssuccessionplanningisessentialtothelong-termsurvivalofacompany.Thisbookwillteachyouthedifferencebetweensuccessionplanningandmerereplacementplanningandhowtopreparepeopletotakeontheresponsibilitiesofleadershipsothatthecompanythrivesinthetransition.
Changeisthelawoflife.Andthosewholookonlytothepastorpresentarecertaintomissthefuture.
JohnF.Kennedy
7
ChapterOne:SuccessionPlanningVs.ReplacementPlanning
Successionplanningandreplacementplanningaretwodifferentthings.Replacementplanningisfocusedonidentifyingimmediateunderstudies,whilesuccessionplanningisfocusedondevelopingtalenttomoveforward.
WhatisBusinessSuccessionPlanning?
Successfulsuccessionplanningisrelatedtoleadershipdevelopment.Itdevelopsapooloftalentsothattherearenumerousqualifiedcandidatesthroughouttheorganizationtofillvacanciesinleadership.Successionplanningusedtoconcentrateondevelopingleadershipatthetoplevel,butnowitisbuildingastrongtalentbase,whichhelpstoincreaseemployeeloyaltyandensurethelongevityofthecompany.Thisstrategyrequiresrecruitingqualifiedtalent,creatingatalentpool,andinstillingloyalty.
Benefitsofsuccessionplanning:
• Decreasedturnover
• Increasedemployeesatisfaction
• Improvedcommitmenttocompanygoals
• Enhancedimageoftheorganization
Whatdoessuccessionplanningrequire?
• Identifythelong-termgoalsandobjectivesofthebusiness:Thelong-termgoalsdirectlyrelatetosuccessionplanning.Isthecompany’sgoaltogrowormaintainitscurrentposition?Willitexpandintootherfields?Allofthesequestionsneedtobeaddressedbeforecreatingasuccessionplan.
• Understandthedevelopmentalneedsofthecompanyandidentifyemployeeswhofittheseneeds:Theresponsibilitiesofemployeeschangeovertime.Somepositionsmaybeeliminatedinthefuturewhileotherswillbeadded.
• Recognizetrendsintheworkforceandengageemployeestobuildloyalty:Understandingworkforcetrendswillhelpyoupredicttheneedsofyourorganization.Forexample,areyourkeyemployeesnearingretirement?Haveyouinvestedintalentedemployeestotakeonadditionalroles?
9
WhatIsReplacementPlanning?
Replacementplanningworksundertheassumptionthatthestructureoftheorganizationwillnotchange.Thisiseasiertoapplyinsmallfamilybusinessesthatdonothaveanygoalstoexpandorgrowinthefuture.Therearetypicallytwoorthree“replacements”identifiedintheorganizationchart.Eachbackupislistedwithhisorherabilitytoreplaceanexistingleader.Theemployeesarenotnecessarilydevelopedtounderstandthenewworkingenvironmentorsmoothlytransitionintohisorhernewresponsibilities.
DifferencesBetween
Manyexecutivesbelievethattheyareengaginginsuccessionplanning,butinrealitytheyarestillusingreplacementplanning.
TheMainDifferences:
• Replacementplanningfocusesonfindingsuitablereplacementsonlyfortopexecutives.
• Successionplanningmeansthatthecompanyiseasilyabletofillvacanciesthroughoutthebusinessbecauseemployeesarebeingempoweredanddeveloped.
• Thereisashortlistofcandidatesinreplacementplanning.
• Successionplanningbuildsalargetalentpool.
Successionplanningtakesalittlemoretimeandeffortfromthoseinleadership,butityieldsahighreturnonsuchaninvestment.
DecidingWhatYouNeed
Thereareseveraldifferentfactorsthatindicatewhenacompanyneedstoimplementorre-evaluatesuccessionplanning.
• Turnoverbecomescritical:Thenumberofhigh-potentialworkersleavingishigherthanaverageworkersleaving.(Thiscanhappeninanyeconomy.)
• Employeesfeelundervalued:Whenamajorityofyouremployeesfeelthatthereisnoroomforadvancementorthatyouchoosetoomanyoutsidehires,thereisasuccession-planningproblem.
• Therearenoreplacementsforkeytalent:Shouldavaluedmemberofstaffsuddenlyleave,thereisnooneabletotakehisorherplace.
• Managersnoticethattherearenotmanycandidatesforpromotion:Employeeswhoarenotdevelopedforleadershipwillneverbepromoted.
• Thetimetofillmetricishighorunknown:Thetimetofillmetricistheaveragelengthoftimethatittakestofillaposition.Ahighnumbermeansthatthecompanyneedstofocusonsuccessionplanning.
• Theretentionriskanalysisishigh:Ariskanalysisusesdifferentfactorstodeterminethepotentialnumberofemployeeswhowillleave.Thesewillfactorinretirementandothertrends.
11
PracticalIllustration
Jacobhadtoplanforthescenariothattheremaybeavacancywithinthecompany.First,heinspectedtheactualrequirementsofthecompany.Afterseeingrecordbreakingsalesandprofit,itwassafetoassumetheyshouldexpand.Thiscalledforhisplantobeoneofsuccessionratherthanreplacement.Giventhecurrenttalentbasehehadtoworkwith,heknewthatthereweremanyemployeeswhorequiredonlyalittletraininginordertobecomethenextsuccessfulleadersofthecompanyontheoccasionofavacancy.
Agoalwithoutaplanisjustawish.
AntoinedeSaint-Exupery
13
ChapterTwo:PreparingforthePlanningProcess
Implementinganynewprocessrequiresplanning.Likeanyotherbusinessplan,successionplanningrequirestakingahardlookatthebusinesstoidentifyitsneedsandopportunities.Deviseparameterswithinlegalandoperationalparameters.Createaplanthatfitswiththecompany’slong-termgoalsandevaluatetheplanasneeded.
HowtoSetParametersforthePlanningProcess
Beforecreatingasuccessionplan,itisessentialtosettheparametersfortheprocess.Theparametersincludeguidelines,rolesofemployees,anddifferentapproachestoimplementingtheplan.
CommonParametersinclude:
• Recognizelegalobligations:Considermethodsthatincreasediversityandprotecttherightsofindividuals.
• Identifyguidelines:Guidelinesforpoliciesandprocedures,actionplans,andidentifyingtargetgroupsareessentialtosuccess.
• Detectkeyroles:Thesearerolespeopletakeonthataredifficulttoreplace.
• Determinemethodsforhiringandretainingemployees:Thisisparticularlyimportantinkeypositions.
• Forecastfutureneeds:Remembertobeawareofchangestokeyrequirementsinthefuture.
• Createactionplans:Developthenecessarystepsforindividualactionplans.
Theparametersforeachcompanywillvaryslightly,butthelistaboveisausefulstartingpoint.
15
ShouldYouEstablishaCommittee?
Thesizeoftheorganizationwilldeterminetheeffectivenessofacommittee.Smallsoleproprietorshipsmayfindittoocomplicated,butorganizationswithmorethan20employeescouldbenefitfromacommittee.
Theresponsibilitiesofacommittee:
• Identifyimportantsuccessionplanningissues.
• Outlinethesuccessionplanningprocess.
• Managetheplanningprocess.
• WorkwithHRandotherteams.
• Developspecificstrategies.
• Evaluateprogressandmakenecessaryadjustments.
Onceyouhavelaidouttheparametersforthesuccessionplan,establishyourcommittee.Creatingacommitteeis,inaway,atypeofsuccessionplanningbecauseitgivesyourvaluableemployeesroomtogrowanddevelop.
HowtoGatherOperationalData
Preparingforthebusinessplanprocessrequiresdata.Gatheringsomedataiseasy,whileotherthingsarealittletricky.Financescanassessproductivity,sales,cost,andlabor.However,thingssuchastrainingandoperationaldatademandabitmorework.
Waystogatherdata:
• QuestionnairesandSurveys:Peoplearemorelikelytoansweranonymousquestionnaireshonestly.
• FinancialReports:Keepingatabonfinancialreportswillshowyoutheeffectivenessofnewpolicies.
• Meetingswithdifferentdepartments:Havedifferentdepartmentsmeettodiscussneedsandopportunities.Createcross-functionalteamsifnecessary.
• Conductat-riskmetrics:Determineemployeetrends.
17
PracticalIllustration
Kerrywantedtobeabletomakeplansforthechancethattheremaybeavacancyinthepapercompany'sleadershippositions.Thecompanywasratherlarge,sotheyfounditimportanttogathertogetheracommitteetohelpdecideupontheissues.Thoseissuesincludedthingslikelegalobligations,guidelines,keyrolesthatmightbedifficulttoreplaceandmethodsforhiringandretainingemployees.Inordertogetabetter,moreinformedviewandassessmentofthecurrentsituation,thecommitteehadquestionnairesandstatisticreportsonthecompanymadetogiveabetterview,andthisledtoabettersuccessionplanoverall.
Effectiveleadershelpotherstounderstandthenecessityofchangeandtoacceptacommonvisionofthedesiredoutcome.
JohnKotter
19
ChapterThree:InitiatingProcess
Theinitiationprocessisessentialtothesuccessofbusinesssuccessionplanning.Atthisstage,thegoalsandobjectivesareset.Thefirststepofthisprocessistocreateamissionstatementandavisionstatement.Corevaluesofthecompanyneedtobeincorporatedintoanyprocess,includingasuccessionplan.Themissionstatementandvisionstatementwillguidethesuccessionplan,andsteerpeoplewhochoosetobecomementorsintherightdirection.
DevelopaMissionStatement
ConsideringthattheCenterforCreativeLeadershipestimates66percentofoutsidehiresinseniormanagementpositionsmeetwithfailurewithin18months,providingsmoothtransitionsshouldbeanimportantpartofanymissionstatement.
WhatisaMissionStatement?
Amissionstatementisaconcisesentenceorparagraphthatexplainsthecompany’sgoalorpurpose.Forexample,Disney’smissionstatementis,“Tomakepeoplehappy.”Missionstatementsdefinethecompanytoemployeesandconsumers.Shortermissionstatementsareactuallymoredifficulttowrite.Somecompaniesusebulletstohighlightimportantinformation.
HowtoWriteaMissionStatement
Eventhoughitisbrief,missionstatementstaketimetoperfect.Thefirststepistobrainstormwithemployeesanddiscoverwhateveryonedesiresforthecompany.Trytoincludethefollowingstatementswithinyourmissionstatement.
• StatementofPurpose:Thisexploresthepurposeinspirationofthecompany.
• StatementofStrategy:Thestatementexplainshowthebusinessstrategyconnectswithemployeesandcustomers.
• StatementofValue:Thislinksthestrategiesoftheorganizationwiththevaluesofemployeesandconsumers.
• StatementofBehavioralStandards:Employeebehaviorislinkedtothecompany’svaluesinthisstatement.
• StatementofCharacter:Thecultureofthecompanyisoutlinedinthisstatement.
21
DevelopaVisionStatement
Visionstatementsaresimilartomissionstatements.Missionstatementsarecenteredonthecurrentsituationandstrategies,whilevisionstatementsconcentrateonthefutureofthecompany.Whatdoesitlooklikewhenthecompanygoalsareachieved?Visionstatementsareoftenusedtoguidemissionstatements.Theyinspirepeoplebasedoncommonvalues.Visionstatementsmaybecreatedforacompany,aproject,orindividuals.
Writingavisionstatement:
• Determinethevaluesofthecompany:Askpeoplehowtheyfeelaboutthefutureoftheorganizationanditsvalues.
• Discoverfuturegoals:Findoutwhatvisionpeoplehaveofthecompanyinthefuture.Attempttocreatespecificfuturegoals.
• Writeandrewrite:Visionstatementsshouldbeabletochange.Onceavisionstatementisdrafted,itcanandshouldbealteredasthemarketchangesandthecompanydevelops.
Visionstatementsfocusonthevaluesoftheorganizationandinspirepeopletoworktogethertowardacommongoal.
ChoosingtoBeaMentor
DeanTerriScanduraoftheUniversityofMiami,reportsthat71percentofFortune500companieshavestrongmentoringprograms.Mentoringisthebestwaytocreatesmoothemployeetransitionsbytransferringknowledgebetweenpeople.Sincetalentpoolsarebroad,anyoneinthecompanycanbecomeamentorandtransferhisorherpassionandvision.Choosingtobecomeamentorhasmanybenefitsforboththementorandprotégé.
Benefitsofbecomingamentor:
• Createnewcontacts:Mentoringanotheremployeewillexposethementortoanewcircleofpeopleanddifferentpointsofview.
• Developleadershipskills:Mentoringteachesusefulleadershipskillsonaninformallevel.
• Learnnewskills:Mentorscanlearnnewandusefulskillsfromtheirprotégés.
23
Whoshouldbeamentor?
Successfulmentorshavecertainqualitiesincommon:
• Goodlistener:Mentorsmustbeeffectivecommunicatorswhoareabletoactivelylistentotheirprotégés.
• Sensitivityandempathy:Mentorsshouldbegenuinelyinterestedinthedevelopmentalneedsoftheirprotégésandfindthemosteffectivemethodsofmeetingtheseneeds.
• Committedandconfidential:Mentoringrelationshipsareeffectivewhentrustisestablished.Mentorsmustbecommittedtotherelationshipandkeeptheconfidenceoftheirprotégés.
Mentorsneedtocarefullychoosetheirprotégés.Donotwastetimedevelopingsomeonewhoisnotcommittedtothetask.Characteristicsofsuccessfulprotégés:
• Committedtodevelop:Learningnewskillstakestimeandeffort;theunmotivatedwillbecomeeasilydiscouraged.
• Abletoacceptfeedback:Peoplewhocannotacceptconstructivecriticismwillnotdevelopeasily.
• Eagertotakeonnewchallenges:Partoflearninganddevelopingistakingonnewandexcitingprojects.
Mentoringprogramswillvarybybusinessanddepartment,butallmentoringprogramsbringtogetherqualifiedmentorswithprotégéstocontinuethegrowthanddevelopmentofessentialskills.Togethermentorsandprotégéssetgoalsandworktowardthosegoals.
25
PracticalIllustration
Garyrealizedsomethingsaboutthepapercompanythatwerelacking.Hecalledtogetherameetingtodiscussthem.Herevealedthattheyhadnomissionstatement,novisionstatement,notevenamentoringprogram.Alloftheemployeeswereaskedabouttheirviewofthecompany,andhowtheysawthecustomersviewtobe.Theyusedthatinformationtocarefullycraftatopnotchmissionstatement.Theirplansforexpansioninthefuturewereincludedintheirvisionsstatement.Theyusedtheinformationlaidoutintheirsuccessionplananddeterminedthatamentoringprogramwouldbejustthethingtodeveloptheleadershipqualitiesthatmaybecalleduponifthereareanyvacancies.
Buildyourweaknessesuntiltheybecomeyourstrongpoints.
KnuteRockne
27
ChapterFour:TheSWOTAnalysis
SWOTstandsforStrengths,Weaknesses,Opportunities,andThreats.SWOTanalyseshavebeenusedsincethe1960’stocreatebusinessstrategiesbasedontheinformationfromtheanalysis.Strengthsandweaknessesareinternalfactors,andopportunitiesandthreatsareexternalfactors.ConductingaSWOTanalysisisanimportantsteptotakebeforecreatinganybusinessplan.ASWOTanalysisshouldbemeasuredagainstcompetitors,andusedtodeterminewhatneedstobeinvolvedinasuccessionplan.
IdentifyingStrengths
Thestrengthsofanorganizationareanyinternalcharacteristicsthatprovideacompetitiveadvantage.Strengthsthatarenoteasilyimitatedormatchedbycompetitorsareknownascorecompetencies.Thestrengthsofanybusinessordepartmentwillvary.
TypicalCompanyStrengths
• Customerloyalty
• Products
• Customerservice
• Financialgains
• Employeeloyalty
• Researchanddevelopment
IdentifyingWeaknesses
Weaknessesarealsointernalcharacteristicsofacompany.Theyshowadvantagesthatcompetitorshaveoveryou.Weaknessesaffectthereputationofthecompanyaswellasitsfinancialhealth.Asinternalcharacteristics,ofanorganization,itispossibletoaddressweaknesses.Itisessentialtoidentifyweaknessesintheorganizationandfindwaystoturnthemintostrengths.
TypicalWeaknesses:
• Inefficientcustomerservice
• Poorfinances
• Lowqualityproductsorservices
• Highemployeeturnover
• Disloyalcustomers
• Badrelationshipswithvendors
29
IdentifyingOpportunities
Opportunitiesarenotinternal.Externalfactorsaccountfortheopportunitiesthatanycompanyhas.Whileopportunitiesarenotunderthecontroloftheorganization,theseenvironmentalfactorsneedtobeevaluatedandactedonquickly.Rememberthattheopportunitiesthatyourcompanyhaveareopportunitiesforyourcompetitorsaswell.
TypicalOpportunities:
• Growingmarkets
• Advancementintechnology
• Economicstability
• Demographicchanges
• Mergers
IdentifyingThreats
Threatsareexternalfactorsthatinfluenceyourcompany.Theycankeepyoufromreachingyourgoalsandneedtobeaddressedinthecompany’sstrategicplan.Negativeenvironmentalfactorsneedtobeaddressedsothattheirimpactisminimized.
TypicalThreats
• Pricewars
• Buyersmarkets
• Newcompetitors
• Demographicchanges
• Advancementintechnology(makesyourproductobsolete)
31
PracticalIllustration
JennyneededtoperformaSWOTanalysisonapaperdistributioncompany.Thismeantthatsheneededtolistthestrengths,weaknesses,opportunities,andthreatsthatmayaffectthecompanyasawhole.Someofthestrengthsweretheloyalcustomerstheyhadthatcamebacktimeandtimeagain.Someweaknessesincludedthefactthattheyhadapoorrelationshipwiththeirvendors.Theyhadopportunitiesintheformofadvancingtechnologiesthattranslatedintoincreasedprofits,andtheywerethreatenedbytheriseincompetition.Havingallofthisinformationopenandavailablehelpedmakethecompanymoreself-aware,andthusbetterabletoplanforthefuture.
Hewhofailstoplan,planstofail.
Proverb
33
ChapterFive:DevelopingtheSuccessionPlan
Onceyouhaveagraspofyourbusinessandknowthedirectionyouwanttotake,itistimetodevelopasuccessionplan.Todothisdetermineyourpriorities,usetheprioritiestosetgoalsandobjectives,anddevelopastrategytoachievethesegoals.Whenthisprocessiscompletebegindraftingthesuccessionplanthatfitsyourneeds.
PrioritizeWhattheSuccessionPlanWillAddress
Theprioritiesofeachcompanywillbeunique.Doyouneedtofocusontrainingpeopleforexecutivemanagementpositions?Whatarethestrengthsyouwishtoachieve?UsetheSWOTanalysistohelpguideyou.
CommonBusinessPriorities:
• Profitincrease
• Customerservice
• Employeeloyalty
• Inventorycontrol
• Customerloyalty
Clearlydefiningthecompany’sprioritieswilldecidewhattypeofknowledgetransferwillbecoveredinthesuccessionplan.
SetGoalsandObjectives
Successforanyplanrequiresspecificgoalsandobjectives.Goalsandobjectivesgivemotivationandasenseofdirection.ThegoalsandobjectivesofanybusinessstrategyneedtobeSMART:
• Specific:Goalsshouldhavespecificinstructions.Forexample,aspecificgoalwouldbeinstructingmentorstomeetwithprotégésonceaweek.
• Measurable:Itshouldbeclearwhengoalsandobjectivesaremet.Forexample,reducingturnoverby10percentisameasurablegoal,ratherthansimplyreducingturnover.
• Attainable:Impossiblegoalsarenotmotivating.Makesurethatgoalsarereasonableandattainablesuchasimprovingsalesbyareasonablepercentage.
• Relevant:Goalsneedtoberelevanttoemployeesandtheirfunctions.Askingsomeoneinproductiontoimprovecustomerserviceinnotveryrelevant.
• Timely:Goalsneedspecifictimeframes.Forexample,askthatturnoverdropfivepercentinsixmonths.
35
DevelopaStrategyforAchievingGoals
SMARTgoalscannotbeachievedwithouttakingstrategicaction.Thegoalsneedtobedividedintoindividualactions.Aftersettinggoals,itisimportanttowritedownalistofstepstoachievethegoals.Brainstormafewdifferentideasthencritiquethemfortheireffectiveness.Besuretoseekoutfeedbackfromthoseinvolved.
Example:
Goal:Toimproveemployeeloyaltyanddecreaseturnovertwopercentin60days.
Actions:
• Increasetraining
• Matchmentorsandprotégés
• Evaluatingjobdescriptionsandpayscales
• Setclearexpectations
• Communicateconsistently
DraftthePlan
OnceeverythingfromtheSWOTanalysis,goals,andstrategiesisconsidered,theinformationisusedtodrafttheplan.Theplandeterminesspecificstepstakenonaroutinebasistoachievebusinessgoalsandalsothetimelineforreachingthosegoals.Plansmustbereevaluatedfromtimetotimetomeasuretheireffectiveness.Itisimportanttobeflexibleandmonitortheplancarefully.
PlanIncludes:
• Goal/Objective
• Action/Activity
• Dates
• Status
37
PracticalIllustration
Erinneededtogatherthecompany'scommitteetogetherforameeting.Shewantedtomakeitagoaltomakeandincreaseincustomerloyalty.Afterabriefdiscussion,theyrealizedtheyneededatimeframeandanactionableplan,sotheydevelopedamorespecificgoal.Intheend,theywantedtoincreasecustomerloyaltybyfivepercentwithinthenextyear.Theydeterminedthatthebestwaytodothatistodevelopandemployeerewardsprogram,whichistheonethingthatgivesthecompetitionanupperhand.Afterlookingatthecosteffectivenessofsomeoptionsforthatplan,theyfoundtheonethatbestfitandwereabletoputitintoaction.Theywereabletoreachtheirgoalduetoproperplanning.
Staycommittedtoyourdecisions,butstayflexibleinyourapproach.
TomRobbins
39
ChapterSix:ExecutingthePlan
Executingasuccessfulsuccessionplanrequiresassigningtherolesandresponsibilitiesoftheplanaswellasmonitoringtheprogressoftheplan.Doingsowillhelpguidethesuccessionplaninthefuture.Overtime,thewayinwhichthesuccessionplanisapproachedwillchange.Foranyplantohavelong-termsuccess,itmustbeflexible.
AssignResponsibilityandAuthority
Beforeasuccessionplancanbeexecuted,theresponsibilitiesofthoseinvolvedneedtobeestablished.ThisrequiresidentifyingthepositionsthatwillbedirectlyaffectedandrequiresthesupportofHRandtheseniorleadershipteam.Acommitteeorasmallteamofemployeesmaybechosentooverseetheprocess.Itisimportantthattheskillsofthoseinchargematchthejobdescriptionandthatthegroundrulesareclearlyestablished.
IdentifyingProjectLeaders:
• Personalvaluesalignwithcompanyvalues
• Haveahistoryoffollowingthroughwithprojects
• Havetheappropriatequalifications
• Communicatewell
Thegoalsandobjectivesofeachplanwilldeterminewhattolookforinprojectleaders.Onceleadersarechosen,itisimportanttoestablishaclearchainofcommandandprovidetheteamwithnecessarymaterials,support,andguidance.
EstablishaMonitoringSystem
Onceaplanisimplemented,itneedstobemonitoredtodetermineitseffectiveness.Thecommitteeorgroupoverseeingthesuccessionplanningprocessisresponsibleformonitoringandevaluatingthesystem.Thisshouldbedonecontinuously.Theplanshouldbejudgedbasedonthegoalsandobjectivesoftheplan.Aformalevaluationistypicallydoneevery30days.
Whattoevaluate:
• Howwellwerethegoalsandobjectivesachieved?
• Weretheyachievedinthetimeframeestablished?
• Whatisthefeedbackfromemployees?
• Whatisthefeedbackfromtheleadershipteam?
• Whatarethefinancialgainsorlossesfromthecurrentplan?
Evaluatingthesystemwillprovideusefulinformationandshowthoseinleadershippositionshowandwhenthesystemshouldbealtered.
41
IdentifyingPaths
Thecriticalpathsofaprojectdeterminetheorderofeachactivityinthesuccessionplan.Italsoshowsthetimeandresourcesnecessarytocompleteaproject.Itissimilartoarecipe.
BasicPathAnalysis(BakingCookies):
Activity Precededby Time
Measureingredients C 3minutes
Mixingredients A 2minutes
Preheatoven Nothing 1minute
Preparecookiesheet A,B 5minutes
Cooktime B,C,E 20minutes
Apathanalysiswillhelpdeterminewhatchangesneedtooccurinasuccessionplaninordertomakeitmoreeffective.
ChoosingYourFinalApproach
Withthebackgroundandsystemsestablished,itistimetochoosethefinalapproachforthesuccessionplan.Thismeansputtingitalltogether.Thefinalapproachshouldincludeeverythingfromthemissionandvisionstatementstopathsandstrategies.Whenalloftheinformationistogether,therewillbenocontradictionsandthecoursewillbeclear.
WhatisintheFinalPlan?
• MissionStatement
• VisionStatement
• Overview
• SWOT
• Strategy
• LeadershipTeam
• Recommendations
• Conclusions
43
PracticalIllustration
KevincalledtogetherameetingoftheHRdepartmentatthepaperdistributionfactorytohelpoverseetheexecutionofanewlyconceivedsuccessionplan.Theywouldhelpevaluatetheplananditsoveralleffectivenessasitprogressedovertime.Thiswastomakesurethatitcouldbechangedwhereappropriate,soitwasfoundedontheprincipleofflexibility.Onetheyhadgatheredtogetheralloftheassortedprecursorsfortheplansuchasthemissionstatementforthecompany,theleadershipteam,andthewholestrategythatwouldbeputintoeffect,theywerereadytosuccessfullyexecutethesuccessionplan.
Noonecanwhistleasymphony.
Ittakesawholeorchestratoplayit.
H.E.Luccock
45
ChapterSeven:GainingSupport
Asuccessfulbusinesssuccessionplanrequiresthesupportofalltheemployeesinvolved.Peoplenaturallyresistchange,evenbeneficialchange.Itisimportanttocloselymonitoranynewplansandimmediatelyaddressanyandallemployeeconcerns.Thisistheonlywaytodevelopthesupportthatisnecessaryforasuccessionplantoreachitsfullpotential.
GatheringData
Gatheringdataonceasuccessionplanisinplaceissimilartogatheringdatabeforecreatingorchangingasuccessionplan.Infact,datashouldbegatheredonaregularbasis.Atthisstage,itisimportanttofacilitateopenandhonestcommunicationsothatemployeesfeelfreetosharetheirconcernswiththoseinleadershippositions.
Techniques
• Meetings:Largemeetingsarenotveryeffective,butsmallerintimatemeetingswillprovidemoreinsight.
• Surveys:Employeesurveysareusefulateverystageoftheprocess.Mostpeoplearemorecomfortablewithanonymoussurveys.
• Metrics:Differentkeymetricswillshowtheeffectivenessofthesuccessionplan.
AddressingConcernsandIssues
Leavingconcernsandissuesunaddressedwillleadtogreaterproblemsovertime.Evenissuesthatdonotseemimportantneedtobeaddressedimmediately.Communicationisthekeytoaddressingemployeeconcerns.Practiceactivelisteningtounderstandwhatemployeesaretryingtosaybeforechoosingtheappropriatemethodtoaddresstheissue.
ActiveListening
• Payattention:Givethespeakeryourundividedattentionandmakesurethatyourbodylanguageandcommentsshowthatyouarelistening.
• Repeat:Paraphrasewhatissaidtoavoidanymiscommunication.
• Donotinterrupt:Allowthespeakertofinish,andavoidemotionalresponses.
• Respond:Respondhonestlyandrespectfully.Speaktothesituationandtrytofindamutuallyequitablesolution.
47
EvaluatingandAdapting
Gainingsupportforasuccessionplanmeansadaptingitaccordingtoongoingevaluationsofitsprogress.Theabilitytoremainadaptableisessentialtosuccess.Monitoringsystemsshouldalreadybeinplacetodeterminetheeffectivenessofthesuccessionplan.Evaluatingthesuccessoftheplanandtheemployeebuyincanbedoneusingvarioustechniques.
Evaluating:
• Self-reviews:Employeescanevaluatetheirdevelopmentanddemonstratetheeffectivenessofthesuccessionplan.
• Managerreviewsofemployees:Leaderscanreviewtheeffectivenessoftheprogramandemployeebuyin.
• Datagathered:Thedatawillgiveanideaofhowwellthesuccessionplanisworking.
Oncetheevaluationsarecomplete,considerdifferentwaystoadaptthestrategiestofittheneeds.Forexample,addapersonalactionplanorprovidementorswithleadershiptraining.
PracticalIllustration
Jamesknewthatinorderforthenewsuccessionplantobesuccessfulandreachitsfullpotential,itwouldneedthefullsupportoftheemployeesatthepaperdistributioncompany.Inordertogarnertogetherthissupport,Jamesmadeitapointtoregularlysurveyandcollectdatafromtheemployees.Ifsomethingwasgoingwrong,itwouldbeaddressedimmediately.Thisbuilttrustwithinthecompanythatnotonlyweretheirvoicesheard,butthatthecompanywasactiveinthedevelopmentofthenewplan.Overallevaluationswerecarriedoutconcerningtheplanafterithadbeenineffectforsometime.Thiscombinedtheself-viewofemployees,themanager’sreviewsoftheemployeesandthedatathathadbeengathereduptothatpointtodetermineifanysignificantchangeswereneeded.Intheend,theplanwassuccessfulduetoitsabilitytoadapt.
49
Ifyoudon’tcreatechange,changewillcreateyou.
Anonymous
ChapterEight:ManagingtheChange
Changeisnevereasy.Implementingoralteringasuccessionplanneedstobedonestrategicallyinordertotransitionsmoothly.Changesthatarenotexplainedormonitoredaremorelikelytofail.Achangemanagementplanandcommunicationplanwillworkwiththesuccessionplanoranyotherplantoencouragethegrowthanddevelopmentofemployeesandthebusiness.
DevelopingaChangeManagementPlan
Achangemanagementplanisabletoclearlylinkthechangeswiththeorganizationalgoalsandcommunicatethepurposeforthechanges.Thiswillhelplowerresistancetothechangestakingplace.Peoplewhounderstandtheprocessaremorelikelytoacceptandmoveforwardwithit.
ThePlan
• Sharegoals:Explainhowthechangeisessentialforachievinglong-termsuccessandreachingthecompany’sgoals.
• Communicate:Shareabouttheunderlyingissuesandrespectdifferentpointsofview.
• Involvepeopleintheprocess:Encourageemployeestotakeownershipinthechangemanagementplan.
• Developstructureandschedules:Explaineachperson’sroles,responsibilities,andexpectationsclearly.
51
DevelopingaCommunicationPlan
Becausecommunicationissoimportantinmanagingchange,itneedstobeapriority.Developingacommunicationplanwillhelpfacilitatethechange.Acommunicationplanoutlinesdifferentcommunicationresponsibilitiesincludingtheaudience,projecttopic,date,deliverymechanism,issues,presenter/communicator,source,andresult.
Example
Topic Method Date Presenter Audience
Morale Meeting 10-10
TeamLead ManagementTeam
Sales ConferenceCall
10-12
VPofSales AllSalesEmployees
Evaluation PowerPoint 10-11
CommitteeLead
PlanCommittee
ImplementingthePlans
Developingachangemanagementandcommunicationplaniseasierthanimplementingthem.Fortunately,mostbusinessplanshaveasimilarimplementationprocess.Changemanagementandcommunicationplanshaveclearstepsthathelptomakethetransitionseasierforemployersandemployees.
Steps
• Definethechangeprocess:Theprocessincludesrolesandresponsibilities,procedures,tools,andperformancemeasurements.
• Determinewhatisneeded:Considerandprovidethenecessaryresourcerequirementsandscheduletheimplementation.
• Monitor:Monitorthechangemanagementandcommunicationprocessaccordingtotheperformancemeasurements.
• Evaluateandmodify:Evaluatetheeffectivenessofthechangesandalterthemasneeded
53
ProvidingConstructiveCriticism
Beingcriticizedisneverfun.Peopleinpositionsofauthority,however,needtoeffectivelydeliverconstructivecriticism.Feedbackthatisnotdeliveredwellcancausedireresults.Thereareseveralbasiccharacteristicsofconstructivecriticism.
ConstructiveCriticism
• Bespecific:Focusonspecificactions,anddonotbringinpersonalperceptions.
• Addresscontrollableprofessionalissues:Donotbringuppersonalshortcomingsorissuesthattherecipientcannotchange.
• Providecriticismearly:Donotallowproblemstocontinuewithoutaddressingthem.Thisreinforcestheideathatthebehaviorisacceptable.
• Involvetherecipient:Providepeoplewithopportunitiestoaskforfeedback,andinvolvethemintheactionplan.
• Berespectful:Considertheneedsoftherecipientandmakesurethatthetoneandmannerofdeliveryishelpfulandnotcondemning.
EncouragingGrowthandDevelopment
Employeedevelopmentneedstobenurturedandencouraged.Peopleneedtobechallenged,buttheyalsoneedtoknowthattheyareappreciatedforallofthehardworkthattheydo.Companiesthatinvestintheiremployeesarestatisticallymoresuccessfulthancompaniesthatdonot.Encouraginggrowthanddevelopmentisfundamentaltothesuccessofanybusinesssuccessionplan.
Waystoencouragedevelopment:
• Challengeemployees:Givepeopletheopportunitytotakeonnewrolesandresponsibilities.
• Recognizegrowth:Acknowledgetheprogressthatyouremployeesmake.
• Rewarddevelopment:Rewardpeoplefortakingonnewprojectswithraises,educationreimbursement,andlateralpromotions.
• Promoteinternally:Promotefromwithinwheneverpossible.
55
PracticalIllustration
Terryneededtohandlethenewtransitionwellsothatitwouldbeasmoothone.Communicationwiththeemployeeswashismainconcern,andsohedevelopedasetplan.Regularmeetingsensuredthateveryonewasclearonthechangesthatweretakingplaceandtheprogressoftheirdevelopment.Feedbackwasgiventothoseneededit.Althoughsomewascriticism,italsowenthandinhandwiththeprogressofthecompanybyencouraginggrowthandchallengingemployeestotakeonnewrolesandresponsibilities,whilealsotakingthetimetorewardtheirdevelopment.Thetransitionwasmademuchsmootherbythisapproachandwentoffwithoutahitch.
Decisionanddeterminationaretheengineerandfiremanofour
traintoopportunityandsuccess.
BurtLawlor
57
ChapterNine:OvercomingRoadblocks
Roadblocksaccompanyeveryplan.Itiseasytobecomediscouragedwhenplansbegintounravel,however,minorproblemsaretobeexpectedandnoreasontogiveuponaplanofaction.Successionplansarejustasvulnerabletoroadblocksasanyotherbusinessplan,butanticipatingcommonobstacles,re-evaluatinggoals,andstayingfocusedwillhelpthesuccessionplansucceed.
CommonObstacles
Theobstaclesthatsuccessionplansusuallyfaceareuniquetoeachsituation.Thereare,however,severaldifferentcommonobstaclesthatsuccessionplansface.
Obstacles:
• Lackofsupportfromseniormanagement:AneffectivesuccessionplanrequiresmorethanemployeebuyinandHRoversight.Seniormanagementneedstobecommittedtotheplan’ssuccess.
• Leadersarenotflexible:Plansneedtobealteredforindividualcircumstances.Whenpeopletrytogoforwardwithaplanthatdoesnotmakesense,theplanwillfail.
• Theplanisviewedasoptional:Acompanythathasalargetalentpoolmaybecomecomplacentaboutsuccessionplanning.
• Goalscannotbeachieved:Tryingtodotoomuchtoofastwillleadtofrustrationandfailure.
Onceobstaclesareidentified,alternativestotheobstaclesneedtobechosen.Constantevaluationandre-evaluationofgoalswillhelpovercomeobstacles.
Re-EvaluatingGoals
Businessdynamicschangeandgoalsneedtobere-evaluatedperiodically.Ifgoalsareconsistentlynotachieved,oddsarethattheyaretooaggressive.Re-evaluategoalsaccordingtoSMARTgoalguidelines.Formalevaluationsthatarescheduledareagoodtimetore-evaluateandaltergoals.
Signsthatgoalsneedtobere-evaluated:
• Goalsarenotachieved:Occasionallyfallingshortofreachingagoalistobeexpected,butwhengoalsareconsistentlymissedthegoalsareprobablynotachievable.
• Thecostsofgoalsoutweighthebenefits:Ifemployeesneedtoworkovertimetoachievegoals,thegoalsareprobablynotworthit.
• Thegoalsarecausingstress:Whengoalscauseunnecessarystress,productivitywillsufferovertime.
59
• Employeefeedbackshowsthegoalsareachievable:Donotunderestimateemployeefeedback.Ifmostemployeesfeelthatgoalsarenotachievabletheyprobablyaren’t.
FocusingonProgress
Plansareneverperfect.Focusingonminorsetbackswilllowermoraleandcreateasenseoffailure.Ifgoalsareconsistentlyre-evaluatedandadjusted,itwillbeeasytomeasureprogress.Focusingonprogresswillbuildmoraleandshowsuccessionplanningsuccessandfailure.Creatingprogressreportswillhelpmonitortheprogressofthesuccessionplan.Theyaresimilartoevaluations,buttheyconcentrateontheprogressoftheplansbeingimplemented.
ProgressReportsInclude:
• Risks:ASWOTanalysiswillshowtherisks.
• Metrics:Usedatagatheredtocreatemetrics.
• Projectscompleted:Theseareimplementedprojectsrelatedtotheplan.
• Projectscontinuing:Theseareprojectsstillbeingimplemented.
• Projectsbeginning:Theseprojectsarestillintheplanningstage.
Progressreportscanbewrittenoutusingthesameformatasanyotherbusinessreport.
PracticalIllustration
Jimmywasfacedwithaplethoraofproblemswhentryingtoimplementanewplanatthepaperdistributioncompany.Thingslikealackofsupportfromuppermanagement,leadersthatweren'tasflexibleashehadhoped,andevensomeofthegoalswerenotbeingachieved.Hefoundthatbyre-evaluatingthegoalsthatwereoriginallyset,theywereabletodivertresourcestomorevaluablecauseswithinthecompanyandovercometheproblemsthatwerefaced.Evenwhenfacingthefailuretomeetcertaingoals,theyfocusedontheprogressmadebythecompanyunderthenewplanandalltheprojectsthatwerecompleted.
61
Successissimple.
Dowhat’sright,therightway,attherighttime.
ArnoldH.Glasgow
ChapterTen:ReachingtheEnd
Successionplanningrequirestimeandeffort.Itisaninvestmentinemployeesandaninvestmentinthelifeofthecompany.Nomatterwhatconditionthebusinessisin,successionplanningcanleadtolong-termsuccess.Success,however,isbasedonthecircumstancesandgoalsofeachcompany.
HowtoKnowWhenYou’veAchievedSuccess
Successisdifferentforeachcompanyandforeachplan.Thegoalsandobjectivesofthesuccessionplanwillhelpdeterminethesuccessofitsimplementation.WhengoalsarecreatedaccordingtotheguidelinesofSMARTgoalsandaremonitored,re-evaluated,andadjusted,attainingthemwillbepossible.
IndicatorsofSuccess:
• Goalsareachieved:Goalsareanimportantindicatorofsuccess.Whenprogressismadetowardsachievingdifferentgoals,itisclearthataplanisonitswaytosuccess.
• Growthdemandsgoalplanstobeadjustedorexpanded:Changesinthecompanyrequirechangesinthebasicgoalsandobjectives.Sometimesthesuccessofaprojectrequirestheplantobeexpanded.
• Successionplanningbecomespartofthecompany’sculture:Successionplanningrequiresthesupportofemployeesateverylevel.Whenitisembracedinthecompanyculture,thereislittleresistancetotheplan,andgoalsbecomeeasiertoachieve.
63
Transitioning
Transitioningintoaviablesuccessionplanisnotalwayssimple.Peopleresistchange,butimplementingachangemanagementprogramwillhelpmakethetransitioneasieroneveryone.Carefullyresearchwhatisneededandplanoutthedetailsoftheplan.Createanunderstandablescheduleforthetransitionandmaintainaclearchainofresponsibilityandcommunication.
Remembertoprovideopenlinesofcommunicationduringanytransitiontoalleviateanyemployeeconcernsandpreventcostlymiscommunications.Thesuccessionplanisparticularlyvulnerableduringthetransitionphase.Asmoothtransitionwillfacilitateanychangewithintheorganization,andimprovethechancesforlong-termsuccess.
WrappingitAllUp
Theimpactthatsuccessionplanninghasontheoverallsuccessofthebusinesscannotbeoverstated.ApplyingthelessonsfromthisChapterwillhelpinstillaviablesuccessionplan.Thismeansputtingeverythingtogether.Thedifferenttopicstieintoeachothernaturally,andgatheringdatawillhelpcompletemorethanoneaspectofthesuccessionplan.RefertotheChaptersasneededduringthecompany’stransition.
PracticalIllustration
Billhadimplementedaplanatthepaperdistributioncompanythatwasnearingtheendofitsrun.Therewerebumpsintheroad,buttheplanwasflexibleandsoweretheappointedleadersinvolved.Thetransitioncommitteehaddonetheirjobwell,andcontinuedtheirevaluationsanddatacollectiontotheend,makingminoradjustmentalltheway.Thegoalsoftheplanhadbeenachievedandthegrowthdemandshadbeenexpandedinsomeareas.Billandtherestofthecompanywerepleasedwiththeresults,andwerereadytoimplementthenextplan.
65
Successisajourney,notadestination
BenSweetland
ClosingThoughts
• AlbertEinstein:Wecan’tsolveproblemsbyusingthesamekindofthinkingweusedwhenwecreatedthem.
• AbrahamLincoln:Agoalproperlysetishalf-wayreached.
• DavidRockefeller:Successinbusinessrequirestraininganddisciplineandhardwork.Butifyou'renotfrightenedbythesethings,theopportunitiesarejustasgreattodayastheyeverwere.