budget, finance and audit committee€¦ · budget, finance and audit committee . city of dallas,...
TRANSCRIPT
Budget, Finance and Audit Committee
City of Dallas, Park and Recreation Department
April 2, 2012
Cotton Bowl
Proposed 2013 Improvements and Financing
2 2 2
Briefing Information
Economic Impact History of the Cotton Bowl Existing Football Games Proposed Work Renovation Schedule Certificates of Obligation Certificates of Obligation – Schedule of Events
2
3 3 3
Economic Impact
AT&T Red River Rivalry (Texas and OU)* Prior to 16,000 seat expansion in 2008: Gross impact on local spending: $30.2M
Spending retained in Dallas County: $18.0M
Estimated impact after 2008 expansion: Gross impact on local spending: $33.8M
Spending retained in Dallas County: $20.2M *Data is from the report, “Economic Estimates for College Football During the 2007 State Fair of Texas”, dated Oct. 2007 by Dr. Patrick Rishe, Director, Sportsimpacts. Economic Impact was based on “non-local” spending (i.e. from visitors outside of Dallas County)
3
4 4 4
State Fair Classic (Grambling and Prairie View)* Gross impact on local spending: $6.0M Spending retained in Dallas County: $3.6M
The City of Dallas Office of Economic Development was able to interpolate City of Dallas’ gross general fund fiscal impacts for the two events evaluated in the study: The State Fair Classic would generate approximately
$100,000 in gross general fund revenue for the City The Red River Rivalry would generate approximately
$500,000 in gross general fund revenue for the City
*Data is from the report, “Economic Estimates for College Football During the 2007 State Fair of Texas”, dated Oct. 2007 by Dr. Patrick Rishe, Director, Sportsimpacts
Economic Impact
5 5
2012 TicketCity Bowl** Gross Economic Impact $9.60M
Economic Impact based on the City of Dallas and surrounding 4-county region
Economic Impact
**Data is from the report, “Economic Impact and Market Research Analysis of the 2012 TicketCity Bowl”, dated Feb. 2012 by Dr. Patrick Rishe, Director, Sportsimpacts
6 6 6
“Fair Park Football Stadium” was constructed in 1921 with 15,000 seats
In 1929, the Texas-OU game was established as an annual event at the stadium and became one of the greatest rivalries in American sports
6
History
7 7 7
In 1930, during the height of the Great Depression, the original facility was replaced with a 46,200-seat stadium
7
8 8 8
In 1936, the stadium was incorporated into the general layout of the Texas Centennial Exposition and officially renamed the “Cotton Bowl”
8
9 9 9
In the first Cotton Bowl game, held on January 1, 1937, the TCU Horned Frogs defeated the Marquette Golden Avalanche, 16-6
9
10 10 10
History
The stadium at Fair Park has had a long history of modifications to accommodate various sports events College Football
NFL and AFL Football
International Soccer
10
11 11 11
The upper decks were added in 1948 and 1949 when the Cotton Bowl served as home to the SMU Mustangs
Seating capacity increased to 72,000
11
12 12 12
In 1952, the Cotton Bowl was home to Dallas’ first NFL team, the Dallas Texans
In 1960, the stadium served as the home field to two professional football teams: Dallas Cowboys (NFL)
Dallas Texans (AFL – Kansas City Chiefs)
In 1968, the stadium was renovated when the bleachers were replaced by chair-back seats, reducing the capacity to 68,250 from 72,000
12
13 13 13
In 1993, the City of Dallas renovated the Cotton Bowl for World Cup soccer Restrooms and concessions expansion, minor press
box renovation New natural turf field (considered one of the top five
soccer pitches in the world) Movable bleachers increased football seating capacity
to 72,000 The 1994 World Cup was held in 9 U. S. cities The stadium hosted six international soccer games during the 1994 World Cup
13
14 14 14
In 2004, the State Fair of Texas (SFT) added bleacher seating in each end zone, increasing the stadium’s capacity by 4,000 seats to 76,000
15 15 15
2006 Capital Bonds and the State Fair provided funding for renovation and expansion Improvements were performed by the Design-Build
delivery method Design-Build process was also used for the Giants of the Savanna Exhibit at the Dallas Zoo
15
Recent Improvements
16 16 16
Phase 1: January 15 – September 15, 2007 Replacement of flip seats with new bench seats
Concrete repairs and waterproofing in entire lower bowl area
Video scoreboard– second largest board in Texas
New sound system
16
Recent Improvements
17 17 17
Phase 2: January 15 –September 15, 2008 Addition of 16,000 new seats – 9th largest stadium in USA
Addition of new rest rooms and concessions
17
Recent Improvements
18 18 18
Locker room renovation and expansion
Addition of new media and conference center
18
Recent Improvements
19
Fair Park Events Event Attendance Projections Ticket City Bowl 45,000 Mardi Gras Texas Style 20,000 Irish Festival 73,000 Summer Adventure (Scheduled to open May 3, 2013) 350,000 Earth Day Dallas 75,000 Cotton Bowl Spectacular (Scheduled to open June 1, 2015) 200,000 Univision Cinco de Mayo 50,000 City Arts Festival 35,000 Soccer United Marketing 50,000 Fair Park Fourth 40,000 Mayor’s Back to School 25,000 State Fair 3,000,000 Diwali Mela 50,000 Holiday Lights (Scheduled to Open December 1, 2014) 150,000 White Rock Marathon 100,000+
20 20 20
TX-OU Current Contract expires in 2015
Grambling-Prairie View A&M Ticket City Bowl International soccer High school football Commercial filming Concerts and other events Diwali Mela Festival of Lights
20
Diverse Events at the Cotton Bowl
21 21 21
Jan 2 TicketCity Bowl Game Feb 13-14 Gatorade Commercial Film Shoot May 6 Dog Bowl May 26 International Soccer Double-Header June 9 Univision H2O Concert June 22 National Olympic Day & National Park &
Recreation Month Kickoff Jul 4 Fair Park Fourth Aug 1 DISD Teacher Rally (T) Aug 11 BvB Charity Football Aug 24 Garland HS vs. Plano East HS Aug 25 High School Football (2 games) Oct 6 Grambling v. Prairie View Oct 13 Texas vs. OU Nov 3 Diwali Mela Festival Nov 24 Pop Warner National Football Championships
2012 Cotton Bowl Events
22 22 22
Jan 1 Ticket City Bowl Game Feb 4 XLV Party (moved to Coliseum after tent
collapsed) Feb 5 XLV Party (moved to Coliseum after tent collapsed) April 17 Dog Bowl Jun 3 El Salvador National Soccer Practice Jul 4 Fair Park Fourth July 24 Club Deportivo Allianza de El Salvador vs. Club
Deportivo Aguila de El Salvador Aug 26 Colleyville Heritage High School vs. Duncanville Aug 27 Grapevine High School vs. Midlothian
Aug 27 Sherman vs. The Colony Oct 1 Grambling v Prairie View Oct 8 Texas vs. OU Nov 4 Diwali Mela Festival Nov 26 Pop Warner National Football Championships
2011 Cotton Bowl Events
23 23 23
The Cotton Bowl has a long history of college games:
Red River Rivalry, since 1929 State Fair Classic, since 1984
For the college games played during the State Fair, Fair Park provides an unmatched aura and experience with rides, food, games, shows and exhibits
Attraction and Mystique of the Cotton Bowl
24 24 24
According to the “Bleacher Report,” the Texas-OU game is the number one college football rivalry in the country
Fair Park, a 277-acre National Historic Landmark, provides an unparalleled setting for sports events
Attraction and Mystique of the Cotton Bowl
25
Contribution of Cotton Bowl to City
Prestige and community pride of hosting major events
Publicity / media value from hosting major events, including national and international TV broadcasts
Promoting entertainment options for local residents Visitors / alumni enjoy being in Dallas and do more
business in Dallas in the future Maintaining public facilities requires continuous
investment to prevent more expensive “catch-up” costs later
26 26
Amenities will make the stadium more marketable in an ever-growing market of venues
The Cotton Bowl is Dallas’ largest public event facility contributing to our citizens quality of life
Allows the Cotton Bowl to remain viable as a prime destination for sports
and entertainment Retention and attraction of annual and touring events
Why Renovations Are Needed
27 27
Allows the Cotton Bowl to compete for international events: World Cup bid – 2018 and 2022
Future Olympics
Bi-annual CONCACAF (Gold Cup Soccer)
Longevity may translate to larger economic impact of events in the future
Why Renovations Are needed
28 28 28
Proposed improvements will: Address functional and aesthetic insufficiencies Add amenities that are now expected in college
stadiums Club seats Festive concourses Updated concessions Updated press box for coaches Athletic directors and the press
28
Proposed Renovations
29 29 29
New, historically contextual facade around each end zone to screen 2008 expansion Landmark Commission required that the Park and
Recreation Department return to them within 2 years with a plan and schedule for the addition of a facade as a condition of their approval of the 2008 Improvements
29
Proposed Renovations
30 30 30
Renovation of existing east and west concourses to address: Patchwork concrete floor Temporary concessions Exposed piping and conduits Poor lighting and visibility
30
31 31 31
Improvements to east and west concessions
31
32 32 32
Club seating under Press Box Level 5 overhang Finish out area at Levels 3 and 4 of the Press Box
32
Existing Press Box Level 4
33 33 33
Renovations to the existing Press Box, including broadcast TV cabling improvements
New elevator to Press Box to address capacity Conference required improvements Associated code improvements
33
34 34 34
Initiate RFQ/RFP Process for Design-Build firm March 2012
Select Design-Build firm April 2012 Park Board/Council approval
of Design-Build contract – design phase May 2012
Park Board /Council approval of GMP for construction December 2012
34
35 35 35
Renovation Schedule
Begin construction January 2013 Complete construction September 2013
35
36
Certificates of Obligation
37 37 37
Certificates of Obligation
Issuance of $25.5 million (maximum amount) in Certificates of Obligation (CO’s) is proposed for Cotton Bowl improvements
State law requires the publication of 2 notices and a 30 day waiting period between the first notice and the sale date
37
38 38 38
Certificates of Obligation Sale Overview
The Co-Financial Advisors have recommended a competitive sale due to favorable market conditions
Estimated issuance costs of $145,840 will be paid from CO proceeds (schedule attached)
Structure Ten year term
Level payments
Non-callable
38
39 39 39
Schedule of Events
April 2 Budget, Finance & Audit Committee Briefing
April 4 City Council briefing
April 11 City Council approval of plans to prepare for issuance of CO’s, including publication of the Notice of Intent
May 16 City Council approval of the parameters ordinance authorizing the sale of the CO’s
June 6 Receive and accept bids for the sale of the CO’s
June 26 Receive proceeds
39
40 40 40 40
41
42 42 42
Appendix
Sources and Uses – Certificates of Obligation Proceeds
Debt Service Schedule – Certificates of Obligation Proceeds
Bond Summary Statistics – Certificates of Obligation Proceeds
Estimated Issuance Costs
42
43 43 43
Source and Use of Funds
43
44 44 44
Debt Service Schedule
44
45
Bond Summary Statistics
46 46 46
Certificates of Obligation Estimated Cost of Issuance
46
Co-Bond CounselBracewell & GiulianiWest & Associates
Co-Financial AdvisorsFirst Southwest CompanyEstrada Hinojosa
Official Statement Typing Fee
Official Statement Printing Fee
Rating AgenciesMoody's Investors ServiceStandard & Poor's AuditorGrant Thorton
Dallas Morning News
Filing FeeAttorney General Office
Grand Total
*Total M/WBE Participation as % of Total Issuance Costs:
$26,775 18.36%20,825 14.28%
19,170 13.14%12,780 8.76%
1,500 1.03%
10,000 6.86%
21,000 14.40%15,640 10.72%
7,650 5.25%
1,000 0.69%
9,500 6.51%
$145,840 100.00%
23.04%